The context of the following conversation is Jan wasn't so sure about Riley's idea at first, but Riley was able to convince Jan the idea is good.:
Riley says I told Jan about my idea earlier..
The friend responds What did she say?.
Riley responds She wasn't too sure about it..
The friend responds But it is a good plan, did you convince her otherwise?.
Riley responds I think I did, after I explained it to Jan, she thought it was a good idea..
The friend responds Jan is pretty reasonable, so I'm not that surprised. Congratulations!.