title: Cabinet Secretary for Justice
Kentucky Justice and Public Safety Cabinet
Cabinet Secretary (Philippines)
Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Constitution
Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work
Cabinet Secretary (Australian minister)
Malcolm Turnbull
Arthur Sinodinos
Chief Cabinet Secretary
Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport
sentences: The Cabinet Secretary for Justice, commonly referred to as the Justice Secretary, is a position in the Scottish Government Cabinet.
 The Cabinet Secretary has overall responsibility for law and order in Scotland.
 The Cabinet Secretary is assisted by the Minister for Community Safety and Legal Affairs.
The Kentucky Justice and Public Safety Cabinet (JPSC) is an agency of the U.S. Commonwealth of Kentucky that is responsible for providing law enforcement, criminal justice and correctional services to the citizens of Kentucky.
 The Cabinet is headed by a Cabinet Secretary appointed by the Governor of Kentucky, with the consent of the Kentucky State Senate.
 The Cabinet Secretary is a key member of the Governor's senior policy staff.
The Office of the Cabinet Secretary (Filipino: "Tanggapan ng Kalihim ng Gabinete" ) or simply Cabinet Secretary is a member of the Cabinet of the Philippines who provides support to the President, and who facilitates the exchange of information, as well as the discussion and resolution of issues among the other Cabinet members.
 He or she also acts as a coordinator and integrator of the initiatives of the President.
 The Office of the Cabinet Secretary was created through Executive Order No. 237, s. 1987.
The Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Constitution, commonly referred to as the Finance Secretary, is a member of the Cabinet in the Scottish Government.
 The Cabinet Secretary has Ministerial responsibility for the Scottish Government's Finance Directorates.
 The current Cabinet Secretary is Derek Mackay.
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work is a position in the Scottish Government Cabinet.
 The Cabinet Secretary has responsibilities for the Scottish economy, infrastructure, trade and investment, business, industry, employment, trade unions and energy.
 The Cabinet Secretary is assisted by the Minister for Business, Innovation and Energy and the Minister for Employability and Training.
The Cabinet Secretary was a former title conferred on an Australian minister responsible for assisting the Prime Minister to manage the day-to-day procedural and operational matters of the Cabinet and any Cabinet committees.
 As per all other ministers in the Westminster system, the Cabinet Secretary was a sitting member of Parliament, chosen by the Prime Minister and officially appointed by the Governor-General.
 The Cabinet Secretary was a portfolio minister of the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet and existed at various stages between 2007 and 2017, when the position was abolished.
Malcolm Bligh Turnbull (born 24 October 1954) is the 29th and current Prime Minister of Australia.
 He first served as parliamentary leader of the Liberal Party and as opposition leader from 2008 to 2009, and became parliamentary leader and Prime Minister after defeating Tony Abbott at the 2015 Liberal leadership spill.
 The Turnbull Government was re-elected at the 2016 federal election, but with only a one-seat majority.
Arthur Sinodinos {'1': ", '2': ", '3': ", '4': "} (born 25 February 1957 in Newcastle, New South Wales) is an Australian politician, the Liberal member of the Senate representing New South Wales since 2011, and the Minister for Industry, Innovation and Science in the Turnbull Government since January 2017.
 Sinodinos has previously served as the Cabinet Secretary between September 2015 and January 2017, briefly as the acting Minister for Health and Aged Care and Acting Minister for Sport during January 2017; and was the Assistant Treasurer in the Abbott Ministry during 2013 and 2014.
 He stepped aside from his ministerial duties during an investigation by the New South Wales Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC), although he still formally held the position until he officially resigned on 19 December 2014.
 Prior to his appointment to the Senate, he was a senior public servant and investment banker.
 He re-entered Cabinet as Cabinet Secretary on 21 September 2015 when he was appointed by Malcolm Turnbull.
The Chief Cabinet Secretary of Japan (内閣官房長官 , naikaku-kanbō-chōkan ) is a Minister of State who is responsible for directing the Cabinet Secretariat of Japan.
 The main function of the Chief Cabinet Secretary is to coordinate the policies of ministries and agencies in the executive branch.
 The Chief Cabinet Secretary serves as the government's press secretary, conducts policy research, prepares materials to be discussed at cabinet meetings, and, in time of national crisis, coordinates ministries and agencies of the executive branch.
 The Chief Cabinet Secretary is customarily nominated as the first in line to serve as temporary Acting Prime Minister in case the Prime Minister is unable to serve due to death or other grave reasons until a new Prime Minister is appointed.
 The Chief Cabinet Secretary's office is located on the fifth floor of the Prime Minister's official residence in Tokyo.
The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport, commonly referred to as the Health Secretary, is a cabinet position in the Scottish Government.
 The Cabinet Secretary is responsible for the Scottish Government Health and Social Care Directorates and NHS Scotland.
 The Cabinet Secretary is assisted by the Minister for Public Health and Sport and the Minister for Mental Health.

Question: Question: Who was born in 1954 and appointed Arthur Sinodinos as Cabinet Secretary? 

 Your answer will be verified with exact match score. To ensure correct verification, only provide the answer within the <answer> </answer> tags. Do not put any sentences or reasoning process within the <answer> </answer> tags. 

Supporting Information: Paragraph 0 

 The Cabinet Secretary for Justice, commonly referred to as the Justice Secretary, is a position in the Scottish Government Cabinet.
 The Cabinet Secretary has overall responsibility for law and order in Scotland.
 The Cabinet Secretary is assisted by the Minister for Community Safety and Legal Affairs. 

--------------------------------

Paragraph 1 

 The Kentucky Justice and Public Safety Cabinet (JPSC) is an agency of the U.S. Commonwealth of Kentucky that is responsible for providing law enforcement, criminal justice and correctional services to the citizens of Kentucky.
 The Cabinet is headed by a Cabinet Secretary appointed by the Governor of Kentucky, with the consent of the Kentucky State Senate.
 The Cabinet Secretary is a key member of the Governor's senior policy staff. 

--------------------------------

Paragraph 2 

 The Office of the Cabinet Secretary (Filipino: "Tanggapan ng Kalihim ng Gabinete" ) or simply Cabinet Secretary is a member of the Cabinet of the Philippines who provides support to the President, and who facilitates the exchange of information, as well as the discussion and resolution of issues among the other Cabinet members.
 He or she also acts as a coordinator and integrator of the initiatives of the President.
 The Office of the Cabinet Secretary was created through Executive Order No. 237, s. 1987. 

--------------------------------

Paragraph 3 

 The Cabinet Secretary was a former title conferred on an Australian minister responsible for assisting the Prime Minister to manage the day-to-day procedural and operational matters of the Cabinet and any Cabinet committees.
 As per all other ministers in the Westminster system, the Cabinet Secretary was a sitting member of Parliament, chosen by the Prime Minister and officially appointed by the Governor-General.
 The Cabinet Secretary was a portfolio minister of the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet and existed at various stages between 2007 and 2017, when the position was abolished. 

--------------------------------

Paragraph 4 

 Malcolm Bligh Turnbull (born 24 October 1954) is the 29th and current Prime Minister of Australia.
 He first served as parliamentary leader of the Liberal Party and as opposition leader from 2008 to 2009, and became parliamentary leader and Prime Minister after defeating Tony Abbott at the 2015 Liberal leadership spill.
 The Turnbull Government was re-elected at the 2016 federal election, but with only a one-seat majority. 

--------------------------------

Paragraph 5 

 Arthur Sinodinos {'1': ", '2': ", '3': ", '4': "} (born 25 February 1957 in Newcastle, New South Wales) is an Australian politician, the Liberal member of the Senate representing New South Wales since 2011, and the Minister for Industry, Innovation and Science in the Turnbull Government since January 2017.
 Sinodinos has previously served as the Cabinet Secretary between September 2015 and January 2017, briefly as the acting Minister for Health and Aged Care and Acting Minister for Sport during January 2017; and was the Assistant Treasurer in the Abbott Ministry during 2013 and 2014.
 He stepped aside from his ministerial duties during an investigation by the New South Wales Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC), although he still formally held the position until he officially resigned on 19 December 2014.
 Prior to his appointment to the Senate, he was a senior public servant and investment banker.
 He re-entered Cabinet as Cabinet Secretary on 21 September 2015 when he was appointed by Malcolm Turnbull. 

--------------------------------

Paragraph 6 

 The Chief Cabinet Secretary of Japan (内閣官房長官 , naikaku-kanbō-chōkan ) is a Minister of State who is responsible for directing the Cabinet Secretariat of Japan.
 The main function of the Chief Cabinet Secretary is to coordinate the policies of ministries and agencies in the executive branch.
 The Chief Cabinet Secretary serves as the government's press secretary, conducts policy research, prepares materials to be discussed at cabinet meetings, and, in time of national crisis, coordinates ministries and agencies of the executive branch.
 The Chief Cabinet Secretary is customarily nominated as the first in line to serve as temporary Acting Prime Minister in case the Prime Minister is unable to serve due to death or other grave reasons until a new Prime Minister is appointed.
 The Chief Cabinet Secretary's office is located on the fifth floor of the Prime Minister's official residence in Tokyo. 

--------------------------------

Paragraph 7 

 The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport, commonly referred to as the Health Secretary, is a cabinet position in the Scottish Government.
 The Cabinet Secretary is responsible for the Scottish Government Health and Social Care Directorates and NHS Scotland.
 The Cabinet Secretary is assisted by the Minister for Public Health and Sport and the Minister for Mental Health. 

--------------------------------

 


Answer: Malcolm Turnbull