title: Julien Temple
Vidhaata
Taal (film)
Samhita (film)
Kisna: The Warrior Poet
Kalicharan
Subhash Ghai
Karma (1986 film)
Yaadein (2001 film)
Apna Sapna Money Money
sentences: Julien Andrew Temple (born 26 November 1952) is an English film, documentary and music video director.
 He began his career with short films featuring the Sex Pistols, and has continued with various off-beat projects, including "The Great Rock 'n' Roll Swindle", "Absolute Beginners" and a documentary film about "Glastonbury".
Vidhaata is a 1982 Indian movie directed by Subhash Ghai and produced by Gulshan Rai's company Trimurti Films.
 It stars Dilip Kumar, Sanjay Dutt and Padmini Kolhapure in lead roles, and, Shammi Kapoor, Sanjeev Kumar, Amrish Puri, Madan Puri, Suresh Oberoi and Sarika in supporting roles.
 The film was remade in Kannada as "Pithamaha" starring Ravichandran, Rajesh, Udayakumar, Vijayalakshmi Singh and was also remade in Tamil as "Vamsa Vilakku" with Sivaji Ganesan and Prabhu.
Taal (English: "Rhythm") is a 1999 Indian musical romantic drama film co written, edited, produced and directed by Subhash Ghai.
 "Taal" was an official selection for the 2005 .
 Taal was screened retrospectively, during the 2014 International Film Festival of India in the "Celebrating Dance in Indian cinema" section.
Samhita: The Script (or simply Samhita) is a 2013 Indian Marathi film directed by duo Sumitra BhaveSunil Sukthankar and produced by Mukta Arts in association with Ashokk Movies.
 The film starts Devika Daftardar, Milind Soman, and Rajeshwari Sachdev in the lead roles along with Uttara Baokar and Jyoti Subhash reprising the supporting roles.
 The film had its theatrical release on 18 October 2013 and won several awards including two National Film Awards at the 60th National Film Awards; the Best Female Playback Singer for Arati Ankalikar-Tikekar and the Best Music Direction (Songs) for Shailendra Barve.
 The director-producer Subhash Ghai, the founder of Mukta Arts, was not initially part of the film and was approached when the director duo faced a financial problems.
Kisna: The Warrior Poet is an Indian Hindi film written, edited, produced and directed by Subhash Ghai and starring Vivek Oberoi (who plays the title role), Antonia Bernath, and Isha Sharvani.
 The musical film is set in the British India of the tumultuous 1940s when Indian nationalists fighting for the country's independence rose up as one, urging the British Raj to leave.
 It is a love story about two people who are torn between Karma (the noble deed) and Dharma (the duty).
 The film has two veteran composers, A. R. Rahman and Ismail Darbar; the lyrics were written by Javed Akhtar.
 This film also marks Amrish Puri's final performance.
 The film, however, did not perform well at the box office.
 The film was premiered in the Marché du Film section of the 2005 Cannes Film Festival.
Kalicharan is a 1976 Indian action drama film directed by Subhash Ghai and starring Shatrughan Sinha, Reena Roy, Ajit, Danny Denzongpa, Madan Puri and Premnath.
 The film became a box office hit.
 The film was the directorial debut of Subhash Ghai and was the breakthrough role for stars Shatrughan Sinha and Reena Roy.
 It was later remade into the Telugu film "Khaidi Kalidasu" (1977), Kannada film Kaalinga (1980) with Vishnuvardhan and the Tamil film "Sangili" (1982) with Prabhu and Sivaji Ganesan in the lead roles and in Malayalam "Pathamudayam" (1985) by Mohanlal.
Subhash Ghai (born 24 January 1945) is an Indian film director, producer and screenwriter, known for his works predominantly in Hindi cinema.
 His most notable works include "Kalicharan" (1976), "Karz" (1980), "Hero" (1983), "Meri Jung" (1985), "Karma" (1986), "Ram Lakhan" (1989), "Saudagar" (1991), "Khalnayak" (1993), "Pardes" (1997), "Taal" (1999), and Black & White (2008).
 In 1982, He started Mukta Arts Private Limited which, in 2000, became a public company, with Subhash Ghai as its executive chairman.
 In 2006, he received the National Film Award, for producing the social problem film "Iqbal", in the same year he founded the Whistling Woods International film and media institution in Mumbai.
 In 2015, He received the IIFA Award for outstanding contribution to Indian Cinema.
Karma (Hindi:कर्मा) is a 1986 Indian action film directed by Subhash Ghai and featuring an ensemble cast including Dilip Kumar, Nutan, Naseeruddin Shah, Jackie Shroff, Anil Kapoor, Poonam Dhillon, Sridevi and Anupam Kher.
 The film reunites Subhash Ghai and Dilip Kumar after the success of their last film together "Vidhaata" (1982).
 The film also marked the first time Dilip Kumar was paired with veteran actress Nutan.
 The film was a huge success at box office.
Yaadein (English: "Memories") is a 2001 Bollywood musical drama film written, directed, edited and produced by Subhash Ghai.
 The ensemble cast cross over film starring Hrithik Roshan, Kareena Kapoor, and Jackie Shroff in lead roles, was released worldwide on 27th July 2001 to negative reviews.
 Yaadein was a box office disappointment.
 The soundtrack and background score composed by Anu Malik received positive reviews, and remained a Chartbuster.
 Jackie Shroff received nomination for Best Performance in a Supporting Role, Male at the 47th Filmfare Awards.
Apna Sapna Money Money (English: "Money Is Our Dream") is an Indian Hindi comedy film released on 10 November 2006.
 Directed by Sangeeth Sivan, "Apna Sapna Money Money" is a tale of several characters who are in a mad race to be rich.
 The film, produced by Subhash Ghai, is a situational comedy starring a host of actors: Ritesh Deshmukh, Celina Jaitley, Koena Mitra, Jackie Shroff, Sunil Shetty, Shreyas Talpade, Bobby Darling, Riya Sen, Anupam Kher, Rajpal Yadav and Chunky Pandey.

Question: Question: Who is older, Julien Temple or Subhash Ghai? 

 Your answer will be verified with exact match score. To ensure correct verification, only provide the answer within the <answer> </answer> tags. Do not put any sentences or reasoning process within the <answer> </answer> tags. 

Supporting Information: Paragraph 0 

 Julien Andrew Temple (born 26 November 1952) is an English film, documentary and music video director.
 He began his career with short films featuring the Sex Pistols, and has continued with various off-beat projects, including "The Great Rock 'n' Roll Swindle", "Absolute Beginners" and a documentary film about "Glastonbury". 

--------------------------------

Paragraph 1 

 Vidhaata is a 1982 Indian movie directed by Subhash Ghai and produced by Gulshan Rai's company Trimurti Films.
 It stars Dilip Kumar, Sanjay Dutt and Padmini Kolhapure in lead roles, and, Shammi Kapoor, Sanjeev Kumar, Amrish Puri, Madan Puri, Suresh Oberoi and Sarika in supporting roles.
 The film was remade in Kannada as "Pithamaha" starring Ravichandran, Rajesh, Udayakumar, Vijayalakshmi Singh and was also remade in Tamil as "Vamsa Vilakku" with Sivaji Ganesan and Prabhu. 

--------------------------------

Paragraph 2 

 Taal (English: "Rhythm") is a 1999 Indian musical romantic drama film co written, edited, produced and directed by Subhash Ghai.
 "Taal" was an official selection for the 2005 .
 Taal was screened retrospectively, during the 2014 International Film Festival of India in the "Celebrating Dance in Indian cinema" section. 

--------------------------------

Paragraph 3 

 Kisna: The Warrior Poet is an Indian Hindi film written, edited, produced and directed by Subhash Ghai and starring Vivek Oberoi (who plays the title role), Antonia Bernath, and Isha Sharvani.
 The musical film is set in the British India of the tumultuous 1940s when Indian nationalists fighting for the country's independence rose up as one, urging the British Raj to leave.
 It is a love story about two people who are torn between Karma (the noble deed) and Dharma (the duty).
 The film has two veteran composers, A. R. Rahman and Ismail Darbar; the lyrics were written by Javed Akhtar.
 This film also marks Amrish Puri's final performance.
 The film, however, did not perform well at the box office.
 The film was premiered in the Marché du Film section of the 2005 Cannes Film Festival. 

--------------------------------

Paragraph 4 

 Kalicharan is a 1976 Indian action drama film directed by Subhash Ghai and starring Shatrughan Sinha, Reena Roy, Ajit, Danny Denzongpa, Madan Puri and Premnath.
 The film became a box office hit.
 The film was the directorial debut of Subhash Ghai and was the breakthrough role for stars Shatrughan Sinha and Reena Roy.
 It was later remade into the Telugu film "Khaidi Kalidasu" (1977), Kannada film Kaalinga (1980) with Vishnuvardhan and the Tamil film "Sangili" (1982) with Prabhu and Sivaji Ganesan in the lead roles and in Malayalam "Pathamudayam" (1985) by Mohanlal. 

--------------------------------

Paragraph 5 

 Subhash Ghai (born 24 January 1945) is an Indian film director, producer and screenwriter, known for his works predominantly in Hindi cinema.
 His most notable works include "Kalicharan" (1976), "Karz" (1980), "Hero" (1983), "Meri Jung" (1985), "Karma" (1986), "Ram Lakhan" (1989), "Saudagar" (1991), "Khalnayak" (1993), "Pardes" (1997), "Taal" (1999), and Black & White (2008).
 In 1982, He started Mukta Arts Private Limited which, in 2000, became a public company, with Subhash Ghai as its executive chairman.
 In 2006, he received the National Film Award, for producing the social problem film "Iqbal", in the same year he founded the Whistling Woods International film and media institution in Mumbai.
 In 2015, He received the IIFA Award for outstanding contribution to Indian Cinema. 

--------------------------------

Paragraph 6 

 Karma (Hindi:कर्मा) is a 1986 Indian action film directed by Subhash Ghai and featuring an ensemble cast including Dilip Kumar, Nutan, Naseeruddin Shah, Jackie Shroff, Anil Kapoor, Poonam Dhillon, Sridevi and Anupam Kher.
 The film reunites Subhash Ghai and Dilip Kumar after the success of their last film together "Vidhaata" (1982).
 The film also marked the first time Dilip Kumar was paired with veteran actress Nutan.
 The film was a huge success at box office. 

--------------------------------

Paragraph 7 

 Yaadein (English: "Memories") is a 2001 Bollywood musical drama film written, directed, edited and produced by Subhash Ghai.
 The ensemble cast cross over film starring Hrithik Roshan, Kareena Kapoor, and Jackie Shroff in lead roles, was released worldwide on 27th July 2001 to negative reviews.
 Yaadein was a box office disappointment.
 The soundtrack and background score composed by Anu Malik received positive reviews, and remained a Chartbuster.
 Jackie Shroff received nomination for Best Performance in a Supporting Role, Male at the 47th Filmfare Awards. 

--------------------------------

 


Answer: Subhash Ghai