-- Clean/Circuit/Subcircuit.lean

import Clean.Circuit.Basic

import Clean.Circuit.Theorems

variable {F : Type} [Field F]

namespace FlatOperation

open Circuit (ConstraintsHold.Completeness ConstraintsHold)

end FlatOperation

variable {α β: TypeMap} [ProvableType α] [ProvableType β]

section

open Circuit

open FlatOperation (constraintsHold_cons constraintsHold_append)

def FormalCircuit.toSubcircuit (circuit : FormalCircuit F β α)
    (n : ℕ) (input_var : Var β F) : Subcircuit F n :=
  let ops := circuit.main input_var |>.operations n
  have h_consistent : ops.SubcircuitsConsistent n := circuit.subcircuitsConsistent input_var n

  have imply_soundness : ∀ env : Environment F,
    let input := eval env input_var
    let output := eval env (circuit.output input_var n)
    ConstraintsHoldFlat env ops.toFlat → circuit.Assumptions input → circuit.Spec input output :=

def FormalAssertion.toSubcircuit (circuit : FormalAssertion F β)
    (n : ℕ) (input_var : Var β F) : Subcircuit F n :=
  let ops := circuit.main input_var |>.operations n
  have h_consistent : ops.SubcircuitsConsistent n := circuit.subcircuitsConsistent input_var n

  {
    ops := ops.toFlat,
    Soundness env := circuit.Assumptions (eval env input_var) → circuit.Spec (eval env input_var),
    Completeness env := circuit.Assumptions (eval env input_var) ∧ circuit.Spec (eval env input_var),
    UsesLocalWitnesses _ := True,
    localLength := circuit.localLength input_var

    imply_soundness := by admit /- proof elided -/

def GeneralFormalCircuit.toSubcircuit (circuit : GeneralFormalCircuit F β α)
    (n : ℕ) (input_var : Var β F) : Subcircuit F n :=
  let ops := circuit.main input_var |>.operations n
  have h_consistent : ops.SubcircuitsConsistent n := circuit.subcircuitsConsistent input_var n

  have imply_soundness : ∀ env : Environment F,
      let input := eval env input_var
      let output := eval env (circuit.output input_var n)
      ConstraintsHoldFlat env ops.toFlat → circuit.Spec input output :=

end

@[circuit_norm]
def subcircuit (circuit : FormalCircuit F β α) (b : Var β F) : Circuit F (Var α F) :=
  fun offset =>
    let a := circuit.output b offset
    let subcircuit := circuit.toSubcircuit offset b
    (a, [.subcircuit subcircuit])

namespace Circuit

variable {α β: TypeMap} [ProvableType α] [ProvableType β]

end Circuit

namespace ElaboratedCircuit

def ComputableWitnesses' (circuit : ElaboratedCircuit F β α) : Prop :=
  ∀ (n : ℕ) (input : Var β F),
    Environment.OnlyAccessedBelow n (eval · input) →
      (circuit.main input).ComputableWitnesses n

def ComputableWitnesses (circuit : ElaboratedCircuit F β α) : Prop :=
  ∀ (n : ℕ) (input : Var β F) env env',
  circuit.main input |>.operations n |>.forAllFlat n {
    witness n _ compute :=
      env.AgreesBelow n env' → eval env input = eval env' input → compute env = compute env' }

end ElaboratedCircuit

-- Repository definitions used:
content: syntax "infer_constant_length" : tactic

content: macro_rules
  | `(tactic|infer_constant_length) => `(tactic|(
    apply ConstantLength.fromConstantLength
    try simp only [circuit_norm]
    try intros
    try ac_rfl))

example :
  let add (x : Expression F) := do
    let y : Expression F ← witness fun _ => 1
    let z ← witness fun eval => eval (x + y)
    assertZero (x + y - z)
    pure z
  ConstantLength add := by admit /- proof elided -/

content: class ConstantLength (circuit : α → Circuit F β) where
  localLength : ℕ
  localLength_eq : ∀ (a : α) (n : ℕ), (circuit a).localLength n = localLength

content: class ElaboratedCircuit (F : Type) (Input Output : TypeMap) [Field F] [ProvableType Input] [ProvableType Output] where
  main : Var Input F → Circuit F (Var Output F)

   
  localLength : Var Input F → ℕ

   
  localLength_eq : ∀ input offset, (main input).localLength offset = localLength input
    := by admit /- proof elided -/

content: @[circuit_norm]
def localLength : Operation F → ℕ
  | .witness m _ => m
  | .assert _ => 0
  | .lookup _ => 0
  | .subcircuit s => s.localLength

content: @[circuit_norm]
def localLength : List (FlatOperation F) → ℕ
  | [] => 0
  | witness m _ :: ops => m + localLength ops
  | assert _ :: ops | lookup _ :: ops => localLength ops

content: inductive FlatOperation (F : Type) where
  | witness : (m : ℕ) → (Environment F → Vector F m) → FlatOperation F
  | assert : Expression F → FlatOperation F
  | lookup : Lookup F → FlatOperation F

content: @[circuit_norm]
def lookup {Row : TypeMap} [ProvableType Row] (table : Table F Row)  (entry : Row (Expression F)) : Circuit F Unit := fun _ =>
  ((), [.lookup { table := table.toRaw, entry := toElements entry }])

content: def Circuit (F : Type) [Field F] (α : Type) := ℕ → α × List (Operation F)

content: inductive Operation (F : Type) [Field F] where
  | witness : (m : ℕ) → (compute : Environment F → Vector F m) → Operation F
  | assert : Expression F → Operation F
  | lookup : Lookup F → Operation F
  | subcircuit : {n : ℕ} → Subcircuit F n → Operation F

content: structure Condition (F : Type) [Field F] where
  witness (offset : ℕ) : (m : ℕ) → (Environment F → Vector F m) → Prop := fun _ _ => True
  assert (offset : ℕ) (_ : Expression F) : Prop := True
  lookup (offset : ℕ) (_ : Lookup F) : Prop := True
  subcircuit (offset : ℕ) {m : ℕ} (_ : Subcircuit F m) : Prop := True

content: structure Subcircuit (F : Type) [Field F] (offset : ℕ) where
  ops : List (FlatOperation F)

  
  
  
  Soundness : Environment F → Prop
  Completeness : Environment F → Prop
  UsesLocalWitnesses : Environment F → Prop

  
  
  localLength : ℕ

  
  imply_soundness : ∀ env,
    ConstraintsHoldFlat env ops → Soundness env

  
  implied_by_completeness : ∀ env, env.ExtendsVector (localWitnesses env ops) offset →
    Completeness env → ConstraintsHoldFlat env ops

  
  imply_usesLocalWitnesses : ∀ env, env.ExtendsVector (localWitnesses env ops) offset →
    UsesLocalWitnesses env

  
  localLength_eq : localLength = FlatOperation.localLength ops

content: @[circuit_norm]
def localWitnesses (env : Environment F) : (l : List (FlatOperation F)) → Vector F (localLength l)
  | [] => #v[]
  | witness _ compute :: ops => compute env ++ localWitnesses env ops
  | assert _ :: ops | lookup _ :: ops => localWitnesses env ops

content: structure Environment (F : Type) where
  get : ℕ → F

content: def ConstraintsHoldFlat (eval : Environment F) : List (FlatOperation F) → Prop
  | [] => True
  | op :: ops => match op with
    | assert e => (eval e = 0) ∧ ConstraintsHoldFlat eval ops
    | lookup { table, entry } =>
      table.Contains (entry.map eval) ∧ ConstraintsHoldFlat eval ops
    | _ => ConstraintsHoldFlat eval ops

content: structure Lookup (F : Type) where
  table : RawTable F
  entry : Vector (Expression F) table.arity

content: structure RawTable (F : Type) where
  name : String
  arity : ℕ
  Contains : Vector F arity → Prop
  Soundness : Vector F arity → Prop
  Completeness : Vector F arity → Prop
  imply_soundness : ∀ row, Contains row → Soundness row
  implied_by_completeness : ∀ row, Completeness row → Contains row

content: structure StaticTable (F : Type) (Row : TypeMap) [ProvableType Row] where
  name : String
  length : ℕ
  row : Fin length → Row F
  
  
  
  index : Row F → ℕ
  Spec : Row F → Prop
  contains_iff : ∀ t, (∃ i, t = row i) ↔ Spec t

content: def Contains (table : StaticTable F Row) (row : Row F) :=
  ∃ i : Fin table.length, row = table.row i

content: instance ProvableType.fromStruct {α : TypeMap} [ProvableStruct α] : ProvableType α where
  size := combinedSize α
  toElements x :=
    toComponents x |> componentsToElements (components α) |>.cast combinedSize_eq.symm
  fromElements v :=
    v.cast combinedSize_eq |> componentsFromElements (components α) |> fromComponents
  fromElements_toElements x := by admit /- proof elided -/

content: @[reducible]
def TypeMap := Type → Type

content: inductive Expression (F : Type) where
  | var : Variable F -> Expression F
  | const : F -> Expression F
  | add : Expression F -> Expression F -> Expression F
  | mul : Expression F -> Expression F -> Expression F

content: structure Variable (F : Type) where
  index : ℕ

content: def const (x : α F) : Var α F :=
  let values : Vector F _ := toElements x
  fromVars (values.map .const)

content: @[reducible] def Var (M : TypeMap) (F : Type) := M (Expression F)

content: @[circuit_norm]
def fromVars (vars : Vector (Expression F) (size M)) := fromElements vars

content: class Witnessable (F : Type) [Field F] (value : outParam TypeMap) (var : TypeMap) [ProvableType value] where
  witness : ((Environment F) → value F) → Circuit F (var F)
  var_eq : var F = value (Expression F) := by admit /- proof elided -/

content: @[circuit_norm]
def Table.toRaw (table : Table F Row) : RawTable F where
  name := table.name
  arity := size Row
  Contains row := table.Contains (fromElements row)
  Soundness row := table.Soundness (fromElements row)
  Completeness row := table.Completeness (fromElements row)
  imply_soundness row := table.imply_soundness (fromElements row)
  implied_by_completeness row := table.implied_by_completeness (fromElements row)

content: structure Table (F : Type) (Row : TypeMap) [ProvableType Row] where
  name : String
   
  Contains : Row F → Prop

   
  Soundness : Row F → Prop
  Completeness : Row F → Prop

  imply_soundness : ∀ row, Contains row → Soundness row
  implied_by_completeness : ∀ row, Completeness row → Contains row

content: @[circuit_norm]
def localLength : Operations F → ℕ
  | [] => 0
  | .witness m _ :: ops => m + localLength ops
  | .assert _ :: ops => localLength ops
  | .lookup _ :: ops => localLength ops
  | .subcircuit s :: ops => s.localLength + localLength ops

content: @[reducible, circuit_norm]
def Operations (F : Type) [Field F] := List (Operation F)

content: structure FormalCircuit (F : Type) [Field F] (Input Output : TypeMap) [ProvableType Input] [ProvableType Output]
    extends elaborated : ElaboratedCircuit F Input Output where
  Assumptions (_ : Input F) : Prop := True
  Spec : Input F → Output F → Prop
  soundness : Soundness F elaborated Assumptions Spec
  completeness : Completeness F elaborated Assumptions

content: structure FormalAssertion (F : Type) (Input : TypeMap) [Field F] [ProvableType Input]
    extends elaborated : ElaboratedCircuit F Input unit where
  Assumptions : Input F → Prop
  Spec : Input F → Prop
  soundness : FormalAssertion.Soundness F elaborated Assumptions Spec
  completeness : FormalAssertion.Completeness F elaborated Assumptions Spec

  
  localLength _ := 0
  
  output _ _ := ()

content: structure GeneralFormalCircuit (F : Type) (Input Output : TypeMap) [Field F] [ProvableType Input] [ProvableType Output]
    extends elaborated : ElaboratedCircuit F Input Output where
  Assumptions : Input F → Prop 
  Spec : Input F → Output F → Prop 
  soundness : GeneralFormalCircuit.Soundness F elaborated Spec
  completeness : GeneralFormalCircuit.Completeness F elaborated Assumptions

content: @[circuit_norm]
def SubcircuitsConsistent (offset : ℕ) (ops : Operations F) := ops.forAll offset {
  subcircuit offset {n} _ := n = offset
}

 @[circuit_norm]
def forAll (offset : ℕ) (condition : Condition F) : Operations F → Prop
  | [] => True
  | .witness m c :: ops => condition.witness offset m c ∧ forAll (m + offset) condition ops
  | .assert e :: ops => condition.assert offset e ∧ forAll offset condition ops
  | .lookup l :: ops => condition.lookup offset l ∧ forAll offset condition ops
  | .subcircuit s :: ops => condition.subcircuit offset s ∧ forAll (s.localLength + offset) condition ops

content: def FlatOperation.forAll (offset : ℕ) (condition : Condition F) : List (FlatOperation F) → Prop
  | [] => True
  | .witness m c :: ops => condition.witness offset m c ∧ forAll (m + offset) condition ops
  | .assert e :: ops => condition.assert offset e ∧ forAll offset condition ops
  | .lookup l :: ops => condition.lookup offset l ∧ forAll offset condition ops

content: @[circuit_norm]
def FormalAssertion.Soundness (F : Type) [Field F] (circuit : ElaboratedCircuit F Input unit)
    (Assumptions : Input F → Prop) (Spec : Input F → Prop) :=
  
  ∀ offset : ℕ, ∀ env,
  
  ∀ input_var : Var Input F, ∀ input : Input F, eval env input_var = input →
  Assumptions input →
  
  ConstraintsHold.Soundness env (circuit.main input_var |>.operations offset) →
  
  Spec input

content: @[reducible, circuit_norm]
def operations (circuit : Circuit F α) (offset : ℕ) : Operations F :=
  (circuit offset).2

content: @[circuit_norm]
def ConstraintsHold.Soundness (eval : Environment F) : List (Operation F) → Prop
  | [] => True
  | .witness _ _ :: ops => ConstraintsHold.Soundness eval ops
  | .assert e :: ops => eval e = 0 ∧ ConstraintsHold.Soundness eval ops
  | .lookup { table, entry } :: ops =>
    table.Soundness (entry.map eval) ∧ ConstraintsHold.Soundness eval ops
  | .subcircuit s :: ops =>
    s.Soundness eval ∧ ConstraintsHold.Soundness eval ops

content: @[circuit_norm]
def Soundness (F : Type) [Field F] (circuit : ElaboratedCircuit F Input Output)
    (Assumptions : Input F → Prop) (Spec : Input F → Output F → Prop) :=
  
  ∀ offset : ℕ, ∀ env,
  
  ∀ input_var : Var Input F, ∀ input : Input F, eval env input_var = input →
  Assumptions input →
  
  ConstraintsHold.Soundness env (circuit.main input_var |>.operations offset) →
  
  let output := eval env (circuit.output input_var offset)
  Spec input output

content: @[reducible, circuit_norm]
def output (circuit : Circuit F α) (offset : ℕ) : α :=
  (circuit offset).1

content: @[explicit_provable_type]
def eval (env : Environment F) (x : Var α F) : α F :=
  let vars := toVars x
  let values := vars.map (Expression.eval env)
  fromElements values

content: @[circuit_norm]
def toVars (var : M (Expression F)) := toElements var

content: @[circuit_norm]
def eval (env : Environment F) : Expression F → F
  | var v => env.get v.index
  | const c => c
  | add x y => eval env x + eval env y
  | mul x y => eval env x * eval env y

content: @[circuit_norm]
def GeneralFormalCircuit.Soundness (F : Type) [Field F] (circuit : ElaboratedCircuit F Input Output) (Spec : Input F → Output F → Prop) :=
  
  ∀ offset : ℕ, ∀ env,
  
  ∀ input_var : Var Input F, ∀ input : Input F, eval env input_var = input →
  
  ConstraintsHold.Soundness env (circuit.main input_var |>.operations offset) →
  
  let output := eval env (circuit.output input_var offset)
  Spec input output

content: def map {m : ℕ} (xs : Vector α m) (body : α → Circuit F β)
    (_constant : ConstantLength body := by admit /- proof elided -/
    ) : Circuit F (Vector β m) :=
  xs.mapM body

content: def ConstantLength.fromConstantLength {circuit : α → Circuit F β} [Inhabited α]
    (h : ∀ (a : α) n, (circuit a).localLength n = (circuit default).localLength 0) : ConstantLength circuit where
  localLength := (circuit default).localLength 0
  localLength_eq a n := h a n

content: @[reducible]
def unit (_ : Type) := Unit

content: @[reducible, circuit_norm]
def localLength (circuit : Circuit F α) (offset := 0) : ℕ :=
  Operations.localLength (circuit offset).2

content: @[circuit_norm]
def FormalAssertion.Completeness (F : Type) [Field F] (circuit : ElaboratedCircuit F Input unit)
    (Assumptions : Input F → Prop) (Spec : Input F → Prop) :=
  
  ∀ offset, ∀ env, ∀ input_var : Var Input F,
  env.UsesLocalWitnessesCompleteness offset (circuit.main input_var |>.operations offset) →
  
  ∀ input : Input F, eval env input_var = input →
  Assumptions input → Spec input →
  
  ConstraintsHold.Completeness env (circuit.main input_var |>.operations offset)

content: @[circuit_norm]
def ConstraintsHold.Completeness (eval : Environment F) : List (Operation F) → Prop
  | [] => True
  | .witness _ _ :: ops => ConstraintsHold.Completeness eval ops
  | .assert e :: ops => eval e = 0 ∧ ConstraintsHold.Completeness eval ops
  | .lookup { table, entry } :: ops =>
    table.Completeness (entry.map eval) ∧ ConstraintsHold.Completeness eval ops
  | .subcircuit s :: ops =>
    s.Completeness eval ∧ ConstraintsHold.Completeness eval ops

content: @[circuit_norm]
def Completeness (F : Type) [Field F] (circuit : ElaboratedCircuit F Input Output)
    (Assumptions : Input F → Prop) :=
  
  ∀ offset : ℕ, ∀ env, ∀ input_var : Var Input F,
  env.UsesLocalWitnessesCompleteness offset (circuit.main input_var |>.operations offset) →
  
  ∀ input : Input F, eval env input_var = input →
  Assumptions input →
  
  ConstraintsHold.Completeness env (circuit.main input_var |>.operations offset)

content: @[circuit_norm]
def GeneralFormalCircuit.Completeness (F : Type) [Field F] (circuit : ElaboratedCircuit F Input Output) (Assumptions : Input F → Prop) :=
  
  ∀ offset : ℕ, ∀ env, ∀ input_var : Var Input F,
  env.UsesLocalWitnessesCompleteness offset (circuit.main input_var |>.operations offset) →
  
  ∀ input : Input F, eval env input_var = input →
  Assumptions input →
  
  ConstraintsHold.Completeness env (circuit.main input_var |>.operations offset)

content: def toFlat : Operations F → List (FlatOperation F)
  | [] => []
  | .witness m c :: ops => .witness m c :: toFlat ops
  | .assert e :: ops => .assert e :: toFlat ops
  | .lookup l :: ops => .lookup l :: toFlat ops
  | .subcircuit s :: ops => s.ops ++ toFlat ops

content: def Environment.UsesLocalWitnesses (env : Environment F) (offset : ℕ) (ops : Operations F) : Prop :=
  ops.forAllFlat offset { witness n _ compute := env.ExtendsVector (compute env) n }

content: @[circuit_norm]
def Environment.ExtendsVector (env : Environment F) (wit : Vector F n) (offset : ℕ) : Prop :=
  ∀ i : Fin n, env.get (offset + i.val) = wit[i.val]

content: def Operations.forAllFlat (n : ℕ) (condition : Condition F) (ops : Operations F) : Prop :=
  forAll n { condition with subcircuit n _ s := FlatOperation.forAll n condition s.ops } ops

content: def Circuit.ComputableWitnesses (circuit : Circuit F α) (n : ℕ) :=
  ∀ env env', (circuit.operations n).ComputableWitnesses n env env'

content: def Environment.OnlyAccessedBelow (n : ℕ) (f : Environment F → α) :=
  ∀ env env', env.AgreesBelow n env' → f env = f env'

content: def Operations.ComputableWitnesses (ops : Operations F) (n : ℕ) (env env' : Environment F) : Prop :=
  ops.forAllFlat n { witness n _ compute := env.AgreesBelow n env' → compute env = compute env' }

content: def Environment.AgreesBelow (n : ℕ) (env env' : Environment F) :=
  ∀ i < n, env.get i = env'.get i

content: def Condition.ignoreSubcircuit (condition : Condition F) : Condition F :=
  { condition with subcircuit _ _ _ := True }

content: def Condition.implies (c c': Condition F) : Condition F where
  witness n m compute := c.witness n m compute → c'.witness n m compute
  assert offset e := c.assert offset e → c'.assert offset e
  lookup offset l := c.lookup offset l → c'.lookup offset l
  subcircuit offset _ s := c.subcircuit offset s → c'.subcircuit offset s

content: def induct {motive : List (FlatOperation F) → Sort*}
  (empty : motive [])
  (witness : ∀ m c ops, motive ops → motive (.witness m c :: ops))
  (assert : ∀ e ops, motive ops → motive (.assert e :: ops))
  (lookup : ∀ l ops, motive ops → motive (.lookup l :: ops))
    (ops : List (FlatOperation F)) : motive ops :=
  match ops with
  | [] => empty
  | .witness m c :: ops => witness m c ops (induct empty witness assert lookup ops)
  | .assert e :: ops => assert e ops (induct empty witness assert lookup ops)
  | .lookup l :: ops => lookup l ops (induct empty witness assert lookup ops)

content: def Condition.applyFlat (condition : Condition F) (offset : ℕ) : FlatOperation F → Prop
  | .witness m c => condition.witness offset m c
  | .assert e => condition.assert offset e
  | .lookup l => condition.lookup offset l

content: def FlatOperation.singleLocalLength : FlatOperation F → ℕ
  | .witness m _ => m
  | .assert _ => 0
  | .lookup _ => 0

content: def induct {motive : Operations F → Sort*}
  (empty : motive [])
  (witness : ∀ m c ops, motive ops → motive (.witness m c :: ops))
  (assert : ∀ e ops, motive ops → motive (.assert e :: ops))
  (lookup : ∀ l ops, motive ops → motive (.lookup l :: ops))
  (subcircuit : ∀ {n} (s : Subcircuit F n) ops, motive ops → motive (.subcircuit s :: ops))
    (ops : Operations F) : motive ops :=
  match ops with
  | [] => empty
  | .witness m c :: ops => witness m c ops (induct empty witness assert lookup subcircuit ops)
  | .assert e :: ops => assert e ops (induct empty witness assert lookup subcircuit ops)
  | .lookup l :: ops => lookup l ops (induct empty witness assert lookup subcircuit ops)
  | .subcircuit s :: ops => subcircuit s ops (induct empty witness assert lookup subcircuit ops)

-- Repository lemmas used:
content: lemma Environment.agreesBelow_of_le {F} {n m : ℕ} {env env' : Environment F} :
    env.AgreesBelow n env' → m ≤ n → env.AgreesBelow m env'

content: theorem forAll_implies {c c' : Condition F} (n : ℕ) {ops : List (FlatOperation F)} :
    (forAll n (c.implies c').ignoreSubcircuit ops) → (forAll n c ops → forAll n c' ops)

content: theorem forAll_cons {condition : Condition F} {offset : ℕ} {op : FlatOperation F} {ops : List (FlatOperation F)} :
  forAll offset condition (op :: ops) ↔
    condition.applyFlat offset op ∧ forAll (op.singleLocalLength + offset) condition ops

content: theorem forAll_empty {condition : Condition F} {n : ℕ} : forAll n condition [] = True

content: lemma forAll_toFlat_iff (n : ℕ) (condition : Condition F) (ops : Operations F) :
    FlatOperation.forAll n condition ops.toFlat ↔ ops.forAllFlat n condition

content: lemma forAll_append {condition : Condition F} {ops ops' : List (FlatOperation F)} (n : ℕ) :
  forAll n condition (ops ++ ops') ↔
    forAll n condition ops ∧ forAll (localLength ops + n) condition ops'

content: lemma localLength_cons {F} {op : FlatOperation F} {ops : List (FlatOperation F)} :
    localLength (op :: ops) = op.singleLocalLength + localLength ops

-- Local definitions used:
content: def FormalCircuit.toSubcircuit (circuit : FormalCircuit F β α)
    (n : ℕ) (input_var : Var β F) : Subcircuit F n :=
  let ops := circuit.main input_var |>.operations n
  have h_consistent : ops.SubcircuitsConsistent n := circuit.subcircuitsConsistent input_var n

  have imply_soundness : ∀ env : Environment F,
    let input := eval env input_var
    let output := eval env (circuit.output input_var n)
    ConstraintsHoldFlat env ops.toFlat → circuit.Assumptions input → circuit.Spec input output :=

content: def FormalAssertion.toSubcircuit (circuit : FormalAssertion F β)
    (n : ℕ) (input_var : Var β F) : Subcircuit F n :=
  let ops := circuit.main input_var |>.operations n
  have h_consistent : ops.SubcircuitsConsistent n := circuit.subcircuitsConsistent input_var n

  {
    ops := ops.toFlat,
    Soundness env := circuit.Assumptions (eval env input_var) → circuit.Spec (eval env input_var),
    Completeness env := circuit.Assumptions (eval env input_var) ∧ circuit.Spec (eval env input_var),
    UsesLocalWitnesses _ := True,
    localLength := circuit.localLength input_var

    imply_soundness := by admit /- proof elided -/

content: def GeneralFormalCircuit.toSubcircuit (circuit : GeneralFormalCircuit F β α)
    (n : ℕ) (input_var : Var β F) : Subcircuit F n :=
  let ops := circuit.main input_var |>.operations n
  have h_consistent : ops.SubcircuitsConsistent n := circuit.subcircuitsConsistent input_var n

  have imply_soundness : ∀ env : Environment F,
      let input := eval env input_var
      let output := eval env (circuit.output input_var n)
      ConstraintsHoldFlat env ops.toFlat → circuit.Spec input output :=

content: @[circuit_norm]
def subcircuit (circuit : FormalCircuit F β α) (b : Var β F) : Circuit F (Var α F) :=
  fun offset =>
    let a := circuit.output b offset
    let subcircuit := circuit.toSubcircuit offset b
    (a, [.subcircuit subcircuit])

content: def ComputableWitnesses' (circuit : ElaboratedCircuit F β α) : Prop :=
  ∀ (n : ℕ) (input : Var β F),
    Environment.OnlyAccessedBelow n (eval · input) →
      (circuit.main input).ComputableWitnesses n

content: def ComputableWitnesses (circuit : ElaboratedCircuit F β α) : Prop :=
  ∀ (n : ℕ) (input : Var β F) env env',
  circuit.main input |>.operations n |>.forAllFlat n {
    witness n _ compute :=
      env.AgreesBelow n env' → eval env input = eval env' input → compute env = compute env' }

-- Local lemmas used:
content: lemma computableWitnesses_implies {circuit : ElaboratedCircuit F β α} :
    circuit.ComputableWitnesses → circuit.ComputableWitnesses'

content: theorem compose_computableWitnesses (circuit : ElaboratedCircuit F β α) (input : Var β F) (n : ℕ) :
  Environment.OnlyAccessedBelow n (eval · input) ∧ circuit.ComputableWitnesses →
    (circuit.main input).ComputableWitnesses n

-- Target theorem and proof:
theorem Circuit.subcircuit_computableWitnesses (circuit : FormalCircuit F β α) (input : Var β F) (n : ℕ) :
  Environment.OnlyAccessedBelow n (eval · input) ∧ circuit.ComputableWitnesses →
    (subcircuit circuit input).ComputableWitnesses n
:= by
  intro h env env'
  simp only [circuit_norm, FormalCircuit.toSubcircuit, Operations.ComputableWitnesses,
    Operations.forAllFlat, Operations.forAll_toFlat_iff]
  exact circuit.compose_computableWitnesses input n h env env'