"Of course not.  Anyone possessing the necessary rigorous training, mathematical skill, and knowledge of the stars could calculate a horoscope, knowing nothing more than the exact hour and place of birth of the subject.  You know that, dear.  You could learn to do it yourself... if you weren't so terribly busy.  But remember: the stars incline but they do not compel.  You enjoy free will.  If I am to make the extremely detailed and difficult analysis necessary to advise you in a crisis, I must know in what sector to look.  Are we most concerned with the influence of Venus?  Or possibly with Mars?  Or will the-"