Clinical trial NCT03705000: SLlt Stent II Lacrimal Stent for the Treatment of Nasolacrimal Duct Obstruction
Official title: Safety and Efficacy of the Slit Stent II Lacrimal Stent for the Treatment of Nasolacrimal Duct Obstruction
Study type: INTERVENTIONAL
Overall status: SUSPENDED
Phase: NA
Conditions: Epiphora
Dacryocystorhinostomy
Lead sponsor: University of Michigan
Sponsor class: OTHER
First posted: 2018-10-15
Enrollment: 50
Sex: ALL
Minimum age (years): 22
Standard ages: ADULT
OLDER_ADULT
Accepts healthy volunteers: no
Allocation: RANDOMIZED
Intervention model: PARALLEL
Primary purpose: TREATMENT

Brief summary: This project aims to test whether a newly designed lacrimal stent - the SlitStent - when placed into the lacrimal system in the standard fashion following a DCR surgery, will provide good symptomatic relief for epiphora and be well tolerated.

Epiphora, or severe tearing, is both a very common debilitating symptom and a potential cause of dangerous infections (i.e. dacryocystitis and orbital cellulitis). DCR+lacrimal stenting surgery is 80-95% successful at improving epiphora, and the longer the stent remains in place, the better the long-term outcome. However, lacrimal stents that provide adequate circumferential force to facilitate post-DCR healing also occupy space and prevent good tear drainage until removed. Yet patients want complete symptomatic improvement as soon as possible, even if it compromises long-term results.

This study aims to test a newly designed lacrimal stent that allows tears to drain through the lumen of the stent. The new stent is constructed by modifying a commercially available stent by placing openings along the side of the stent using a process developed by a University of Michigan engineer/collaborator. Following slit placement, the stent will be gas-sterilized for surgery. Patient who are scheduled for DCR+stenting surgery who provide informed consent will be randomized 2:1 to receive the investigational SlitStent or the standard commercially available stent. Following surgery, patients will be assessed both clinically, which is standard of care, and via a patient questionnaire.

Detailed description: This is a single center study that will be conducted at the University of Michigan (Ann Arbor, Michigan). Fifty (50) subjects will be enrolled and treated with either the experimental Slit Stent II or the control stent BIKA for DCR. Patients who are currently scheduled to undergo a DCR (dacryocystorhinostomy) as per standard of care will be offered participation in the study. Patients who elect to participate in the study will be consented and then randomized to the treatment or control arm.

A lacrimal stent is hollow silicone tubing with a non-traumatic tip. The tubing is securely attached into malleable stainless steel probes that are used to guide the silicone tubing through the lacrimal drainage apparatus. The device is used to maintain an open lacrimal path between the surface of the eye and the nasal passages, particularly during a healing process following injury or surgery.

The BIKA for DCR lacrimal stent is a bicanalicular intubation device used for intubation of the lacrimal drainage apparatus, especially in cases of dacryocystorhinostomy (conventional or laser). The silicone tube acts as a conformer during the healing process while facilitating drainage of tears through capillary action around the stent. In cases of canalicular lacerations, the silicone tube guides wound healing and prevents the onset of synechia.

The BIKA lacrimal stent consists of a single unit including a silicone tube (length: 280 mm, external diameter: 0.94 mm), and one steel probe at each end of the silicone tube (length: 53 mm, external diameter: 0.8 mm) with round tips.

The BIKA for DCR is a sterile, single-use device, and is an FDA cleared device.

The Slit Stent II (investigational) device is created by modifying an existing FDA cleared lacrimal stent (Bika, manufactured by FCI Opthalmics) by adding additional 3 mm and 35 mm long slits of equal depth.

The axial cutouts located on the stent allow drainage of tears from the ocular surface to the nasal/oropharynx cavities through the internal lumen of the stent.

All modifications to the stent are inspected under an optical microscope at a magnification of at least 5x to ensure they are free from cutting defects, which could impact the structural integrity of the Slit Stent II. To ensure that the Slit Stent II can withstand the forces experienced during implantation and removal, additional mechanical integrity tests were performed. Comparing the implantation forces to the maximum insertion and removal force, it was determined that the modified Slit Stent II will have excellent tensile strength - essentially identical to unmodified stent - to prevent mechanical failure in patient use. Each section was tested to determine the maximum elongation and force it can withstand before failure.

The study duration will be 6 months for all study patients.

The following examination schedule will be followed from screening through the postoperative visits:

* Screening (Day -60 to Day 0 Preoperatively)
* Device implantation operation
* Phone call Assessment at 1 day post op
* Phone call Assessment at 45 days post op (+/- 15 days)
* Day 5-14 postoperatively
* Day 30-120 postoperatively (with stent removal)
* 4-7 month final post-operative exam

Subjects will be randomly assigned to the experimental vs. control stents using a randomized block design with 1:1 allocation to treatment and control. Stents will be provided to the surgical team on the day of surgery by the Study Coordinator. Surgical team, recruitment staff, and scheduling staff will be masked to treatment assignment until day of surgery. All tests and measurements should be obtained in accordance with the procedures specified in this protocol. If it is not possible to perform a measurement or examination due to the individual eye's specific ocular pathology, the reason for not performing the test or measurement should be documented on the source documents.

The investigator may designate one or more surgeon sub-investigators at his/her investigative site. A surgeon sub-investigator may evaluate subjects for the study and perform the Slit Stent II lacrimal stent intubation. Surgeon sub-investigators will be listed on all applicable investigator regulatory documents (including the delegation of responsibilities log) and will complete all sponsor-required training for the study.

For the two post-op study visits, the Quality of Life (QOL) questionnaire (Glasgow Benefit Inventory (GBI)- see Appendix A) and the Patient Tearing Questionnaire (Munk Scale and Lac-Q questionnaire, see Appendix B) will be administered by an interviewer, and the interviewer will record the subject's responses directly onto the corresponding questionnaire CRFs or source documents and calculate the GBI score, Munk Score, and Lac-Q score.

Eligibility criteria: Inclusion Criteria:

1. Willingness and ability to comply with schedule for follow-up visits and postoperative evaluations.
2. Eligible for unilateral DCR surgery with stenting for treatment of epiphora secondary to nasolacrimal duct obstruction.Ability to instill post-operative eye drop
3. Signed written, informed consent.

Exclusion Criteria:

1. Subjects under legal guardianship or who, in the investigator's opinion, lack the mental capacity to provide written informed consent for study participation.
2. Subjects scheduled for bilateral DCR surgery
3. Subjects with known sensitivity to silicone
4. Subjects with a current condition that, in the investigator's opinion, would interfere with the treatment.
5. Inability to use eye drops
6. Subjects with a known sensitivity to required study medications (e.g. antibiotic drops) if an alternative medication is not available.

Primary outcomes:
measure: Safety, as measured by number of subjects with at least one Adverse Event
timeFrame: Surgery to final exit visit (Month 4-7)
Secondary outcomes:
measure: Glasgow Benefit Inventory (GBI) Questionnaire (Quality of Life)
timeFrame: 1-4 month post-operative follow-up visit
measure: Lac-Q score
timeFrame: 1-4 months post operative
Other outcomes:
Locations:
city: Ann Arbor
country: United States
facility: Kellogg Eye Center, 1000 Wall Street
state: Michigan
Study officials:
affiliation: University of Michigan Kellogg Eye Center
name: Thomas Gardner, MD, MS
role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR
References: