Clinical trial NCT06131723: UCLA Health Patient Health Tickler Email
Official title: UCLA Health Patient Health Tickler Email
Study type: INTERVENTIONAL
Overall status: ENROLLING_BY_INVITATION
Phase: NA
Conditions: Health Maintenance
Keywords: primary care
digital outreach
Lead sponsor: University of California, Los Angeles
Sponsor class: OTHER
First posted: 2023-11-14
Enrollment: 81000
Sex: ALL
Minimum age (years): 18
Standard ages: ADULT
OLDER_ADULT
Accepts healthy volunteers: no
Allocation: RANDOMIZED
Intervention model: PARALLEL
Intervention model description: Parallel-arm control trial
Primary purpose: HEALTH_SERVICES_RESEARCH

Brief summary: This is a prospective clinical trial evaluating how a behaviorally-informed outreach email notification impacts patient engagement with primary care. This trial is being implemented in conjunction with UCLA Health's larger quality improvement initiative (the My Action Plan Quality Improvement Initiative) in order to improve primary care preventive measure completion rates.

The main question it aims to answer is if sending an enhanced email notification (i.e., enhanced tickler email) to identified UCLA Health primary care patients increases their engagement with primary care.

Participants will be assigned to either a control (standard tickler email) or treatment (enhanced tickler email) condition, based on whether their birth date ends in an odd or even number. Researchers will compare control and treatment groups to see if and how they differ in pre-defined outcome measures.

Detailed description: Health maintenance measures have been shown to be critical in early detection, secondary prevention, and early management of numerous medical conditions--from diabetes to various cancers. The standardization of these health maintenance measures has resulted in major improvements in population health. Despite the importance of these primary care tests and screenings, many patients are overdue for these tests.

Given this healthcare gap, it is critical to investigate more effective strategies to communicate to patients about health maintenance measures they need to complete. This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of a behaviorally-informed outreach email message. The investigators intend to launch the study as a part of UCLA Health's My Action Plan initiative, a UCLA Health primary care outreach quality improvement initiative aimed at encouraging patients to complete their overdue health maintenance measures.

Specifically, the My Action Plan (MAP) initiative is an outreach effort targeting primary care patients at UCLA Health who have outstanding, clinically indicated primary care preventative care gaps (e.g., overdue colorectal cancer screening, outstanding diabetes tests). At the beginning of the month following their birth month, patients with at least one of these open care gaps receive a MAP Letter in the form of a patient portal message. The MAP Letter contains a personalized list of outstanding preventive care items and actionable steps to complete the items. When the MAP Letter is received in the patient portal, it triggers an email "tickler" that is sent to patients' personal email address to notify them of the patient portal message.

At the beginning of each month, patients who are due to receive a MAP Letter will be assigned to receive either the current standard email tickler used by UCLA Health (control tickler) or a behaviorally-informed email tickler (enhanced tickler), based on whether their birth date ends in an odd or even number. The control email will notify them that they have a new message posted in their MyChart patient portal account, and prompt them to sign in to read it. The behaviorally-informed email will directly notify them that they are due for an important medical exam and prompt them to sign in to their MyChart patient portal account to schedule their recommended appointment; this message will be signed by their primary care doctor's office. In each month, emails will go out to all eligible patients in both conditions at the same time.

Both email notifications will contain links to the patient's MyChart portal account. The control tickler will link patients to their MyChart patient portal home page (standard procedure for email ticklers), whereas the enhanced tickler will link patients directly to the MAP Letter.

The investigators plan to run this clinical trial for 18 months.

By studying whether patients review the MAP letter and whether or not the engagement translates into completing health maintenance measures, the proposed study will provide insightful information on how health systems could optimize electronic patient outreach.

Analysis Plan:

* The investigators will utilize patient-level ordinary least squares (OLS) estimation, with statistical inferences based on model-robust standard errors. The primary model term will be an indicator variable for arm assignment.
* The analysis will control for sex, age, race/ethnicity, indicators for screenings/tests that patients are due for (which are marked on their MAP letter), and whether patients have upcoming primary care appointments at the time of MAP outreach. Missing covariate values will be handled by including 'unknown' indicators, along with mean imputation for quantitative covariates.
* Our primary analyses will include patients who were contacted for the first time during our intervention period. For patients who reappear in the program between November 2024 and May 2025, we will explore the effect of the second exposure to the redesigned tickler email within this subsample. Retargeting may be influenced by participants' original assignment to the control or treatment condition. For example, patients originally assigned to the enhanced tickler email condition may be more likely to close their care gap during the first exposure, reducing the likelihood of being retargeted in the second year. To address this potential endogeneity, we will assess the balance between the control and treatment groups within the retargeted sample.
* Exploratory analyses will investigate heterogeneous treatment effects by patients' baseline motivation (i.e., the extent to which patients seem to have an intention to get the screenings/tests), which will be proxied by each patient's history of screenings/tests. Specifically, the investigators will calculate, among all the screenings/tests that are included in the My Action Plan Initiative and that a patient was due for in the past few years prior to the MAP outreach (the investigators aim for 10 years, but the exact time window is based on data availability), what percentage was completed by the patient (as far as UCLA Health could tell). A higher percentage indicates a higher baseline motivation to complete the screenings/tests patients are due for.
* The investigators will explore whether the difference between conditions is moderated by how frequently patients have seen their PCP in the past few years prior to the MAP outreach (the investigators target 3 years, but the exact time window is based on data availability).
* Additionally, the investigators will investigate whether the translation of engagement with the MAP Letter to actual appointment scheduling and screening/test completion (defined later in the secondary outcome section) depends on whether patients face structural barriers to get screenings/tests. The investigators will explore proxies including socioeconomic factors at the zipcode level (social vulnerability, income), insurance type, and distance from UCLA Health clinics (as a proxy for accessibility to healthcare).

Eligibility criteria: Inclusion Criteria:

1. Empaneled to UCLA Health DOM Primary Care
2. Has at least one overdue health maintenance measure that the My Action Plan initiative focuses on
3. Has an active MyChart status

Exclusion Criteria:

1. Under the age of 18
2. Deceased
3. In hospice
4. Has opted out of electronic communication (bulk messages, email, and/or text)
5. For the final analysis, the investigators will further exclude patients who have scheduled appointments for all screenings/tests or completed all screenings/tests prior to the date when they are supposed to receive the email notification, as well as patients who use proxies (e.g., family members who receive the email tickler on their behalf) given that all proxies are assigned to receive a standard tickler email.

Primary outcomes:
measure: MAP Letter opened
timeFrame: From email notification outreach until 9 a.m. the next day before an automatic text reminder is sent to every participant, and 7 days after getting the outreach email notification
Secondary outcomes:
measure: Signing in to their MyChart patient portal
timeFrame: From email notification outreach until 9 a.m. the next day before an automatic text reminder is sent to every participant, and 7 days after getting the outreach email notification
measure: Visiting the appointment scheduling page
timeFrame: From email notification outreach until 9 a.m. the next day before an automatic text reminder is sent to every participant, and 7 days after getting the outreach email notification
measure: Taking action for at least one overdue screening/test
timeFrame: From email notification outreach until 9 a.m. the next day before an automatic text reminder is sent to every participant, and 7 days after getting the outreach email notification
measure: Completing at least one screening/test
timeFrame: 6 months after getting the outreach email notification
Other outcomes:
Locations:
city: Los Angeles
country: United States
facility: UCLA Health Department of Medicine, Quality Office
state: California
Study officials:
References: