Clinical trial NCT04036864: Singing-voice Disorders and Aerodynamic Profiles in Dysodic Singers
Official title: Retrospective Study of Singing-voice Disorders and Aerodynamic Profiles in Dysodic Singers
Study type: OBSERVATIONAL
Overall status: UNKNOWN
Conditions: Dysodia
Keywords: Singers
Lead sponsor: University Hospital, Montpellier
Sponsor class: OTHER
Collaborators: name: GIPSA-lab, Grenoble, France
First posted: 2019-07-30
Enrollment: 100
Sex: ALL
Minimum age (years): 18
Standard ages: ADULT
OLDER_ADULT
Accepts healthy volunteers: no
Observational model: OTHER
Time perspective: RETROSPECTIVE
Sampling method: NON_PROBABILITY_SAMPLE
Study population: Patients who have consulted the phoniatrician (Dr Amy de la Bretèque) of the ENT department of the Gui de Chauliac hospital between January 2015 and June 2018.

Brief summary: Singers are over-represented in phoniatric consultation; they present increased risk of developing voice disorders. They represent a specific population among phoniatric patients (specific singing-voice complaints, increased sensitivity to voice). Singing-voice disorder is called dysodia in the same way as dysphonia, which refers to speaking-voice disorders. The diagnosis of dysodia is made after a laryngeal examination and a voice assessment to identify patient's speech and singing difficulties. Most studies on prevalence of voice disorders in singers come from the American continent. Very few descriptions of this population have been made in France.

Voice assessment of dysodic singers includes aerodynamic voice measurements. The use of aerodynamic measurements for the diagnosis of voice pathologies is now widely demonstrated. These parameters include measurements of estimated subglottal pressure (ESGP), phonation threshold pressure (PTP) (minimum pressure to initiate a sound) and oral airflow (OAF). They depend on the level of training of singers and the type of vocal dysfunction. Aerodynamic behaviours of dysodic singers have not yet been described, although they can help to better identify the singer's vocal difficulties and could be essential parameters for targeting more precisely rehabilitation exercises proposed in voice therapy.

This study aims to describe the characteristics of a French population of singers consulting in phoniatrics and their aerodynamic behaviours. Do the singers' aerodynamic parameters (pressure, flow) reflect the dysfunctions in singing voice? Based on results of the literature on speaking and singing non-pathological voice, the investigators hypothesize that during voice assessment, ESGP values will be increased and OAF ones will be decreased over the entire vocal range of the singer in case of voice pathology.

Detailed description: Singers are over-represented in phoniatric consultation; they present increased risk of developing voice disorders whether they are amateurs or professionals. They represent a specific population among phoniatric patients because of their increased sensitivity to the slightest voice change that makes them consult earlier than non-. In addition, their complaints are specific to singing voice. The most common lesion found in singers is vocal-fold nodule. It comes from a vocal straining characterized by the use of a pressed phonation mode, resulting in an increased subglottal pressure and a decreased flow rate.

Singing-voice disorder is called dysodia in the same way as dysphonia, which refers to speaking-voice disorders. Dysodia results in a variety of symptoms. Acoustic signs are the most numerous: tonal anomalies (lack of accuracy, reduction of vocal range); dynamic anomalies (problem to sing softly or loudly); timbre abnormalities (vibrato problems, strained voice, roughness, difficulties on attacks). Dysodia also results in respiratory disorders, physical signs, psychological consequences and damage to hedonistic properties (loss of comfort, vocal endurance, musicality). It can reach amateur or professional singers. For professional singers, voice is the main working tool. When they have dysodia, professional difficulties can be temporary or even lead to the loss of work. In addition, dysodia can lead to financial loss and well-documented anxiety. For amateur singers, dysodia hinders their musical practice, thus limiting the recognized benefits of choral singing on cohesion, social integration and personal development. The diagnosis of dysodia is made after a laryngeal examination and a vocal assessment to identify patient's speech difficulties.

Voice assessment includes subjective voice analyses but also instrumental analyses that include acoustic, electrophysiological and aerodynamic voice measurements. The interest of aerodynamic parameters for the diagnosis of vocal pathologies is now widely demonstrated. These parameters include measurements of estimated subglottal pressure (ESGP), phonation threshold pressure (PTP) (minimum pressure to initiate a sound) and oral air flow (OAF). They depend on the level of training of singers and the type of vocal dysfunction. These aerodynamic data are collected with devices such as the Assisted Voice Evaluation Device (EVA2©) used in the laryngeal department of the Gui de Chauliac University Hospital. These pressure and flow parameters are higher in opera singers than in non-singers. In clinical practice, the ESGP and PTP are higher during vocal straining in dysphonic patients. Concerning OAF, results remain controversial: increase with vocal effort in euphonics non-singers; decrease with intensity increase in euphonic non-singers. Aerodynamic behaviours of dysodic singers have not yet been described, although they can help to better identify the singer's vocal difficulties and could be essential parameters for targeting more precisely rehabilitation exercises proposed in voice therapy.

In addition, most studies on prevalence of vocal disorders in singers come from the American continent. Very few descriptions of this population have been made in France. The few that exist are quite old or involve limited samples. Moreover, to date, no study has explored the aerodynamic profiles (flow and pressure) of singers, although these profiles are considered to be relevant clinical indicators to describe the singer's vocal difficulties and thus precise more specific therapeutic objectives.

In this context, our project aims to fill these gaps by describing a French population of singers consulting in phoniatrics and describing their aerodynamic behaviours. Do the singers' aerodynamic parameters (pressure, flow) reflect the dysfunctions in singing voice? Based on results of the literature on speaking and singing non-pathological voice, the investigators hypothesize that during voice assessment, the values of ESGP and PTP will be increased and that those of OAF will be decreased over the entire range of the singer in case of vocal pathology

Eligibility criteria: Inclusion Criteria:

* have consulted Dr Amy de la Bretèque, phoniatrist, between January 2015 and June 2018
* be a singer (professional or amateur)
* be over 18 years old

Exclusion Criteria:

* under 18 years old

Primary outcomes:
measure: Aerodynamic data : estimated subglottal pressure
timeFrame: 1 day
measure: Aerodynamic data : phonation pressure threshold
timeFrame: 1 day
measure: Aerodynamic data : oral airflow rate
timeFrame: 1 day
Secondary outcomes:
measure: social and medical data : age
timeFrame: 1 day
measure: social and medical data : sex
timeFrame: 1 day
measure: social and medical data : occupation
timeFrame: 1 day
measure: social and medical data : singing style
timeFrame: 1 day
measure: social and medical data : level of training
timeFrame: 1 day
measure: social and medical data : voice complaint
timeFrame: 1 day
measure: social and medical data : phoniatric diagnosis
timeFrame: 1 day
measure: social and medical data : tobacco consumption
timeFrame: 1 day
measure: social and medical data : voice treatment
timeFrame: 1 day
Other outcomes:
Locations:
city: Montpellier
country: France
facility: Uh Montpellier
Study officials:
affiliation: UH MONTPELLIER
name: Marion BEAUD
role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR
References: