Clinical trial NCT05560490: FibroFix Cartilage P Knee Implant Study
Official title: Safety and Performance of FibroFix™ Cartilage P Implant and Drill Set for Articular Cartilage Repair Within the Knee Joint
Study type: INTERVENTIONAL
Overall status: TERMINATED
Phase: NA
Conditions: Osteoarthritis, Knee
Keywords: knee
cartilage repair
articular cartilage lesion
Cartilage implant
Lead sponsor: Orthox Limited
Sponsor class: INDUSTRY
Collaborators: name: Avania B.V.
First posted: 2022-09-29
Enrollment: 2
Sex: ALL
Minimum age (years): 18
Maximum age (years): 65
Standard ages: ADULT
OLDER_ADULT
Accepts healthy volunteers: no
Allocation: NA
Intervention model: SINGLE_GROUP
Intervention model description: multicentre, prospective, non-randomised, open-label, first-in-human
Primary purpose: TREATMENT

Brief summary: This is a multi-center first-in-human prospective clinical investigation to evaluate the safety and performance of the FibroFix™ Cartilage P Implant and Drill Set. The Implant is a medical device designed by Orthox Ltd. to repair a damaged area of cartilage within the knee joint.

The aim is to 75 participants over two Stages:

In STAGE I, up to a total of 6 subjects will be recruited and safety assessed after 6 months of follow-up.

In Stage II an additional 69 subjects. The subjects will be followed up for 2 years with MRI imaging, then a further 8 years with patient outcome questionnaires.

Detailed description: This is a multi-center, prospective, non-randomized, open-label clinical investigation. Safety oversight throughout will be provided by an independent data monitoring committee (DMC). The clinical investigation will be split into two stages.

Stage I of the clinical investigation will enroll a small cohort of subjects, up to a total of 6 (accounting for a 17% dropout rate) having been implanted with the FibroFix Cartilage P, to provide a minimum of 5 evaluable subjects. The initial safety of the FibroFix Cartilage P implant and the FibroFix Cartilage P Drill Set will be evaluated in these subjects across a maximum of 2 sites. Recruitment into the clinical investigation will then be paused.

Following the implantation of FibroFix Cartilage P in the initial cohort of subjects, the DMC will monitor all emerging safety issues against the stopping rules of the clinical investigation. Any treatment-emergent Serious Adverse Events (SAE) or other safety concerns during Stage I of the clinical investigation will immediately be referred, on a case-by-case basis, to the DMC for review against the stopping rules.

A formal review of safety against the stopping rules will be undertaken by the DMC at two-time points:

1. when all of the initial cohort of subjects complete 3 months post-surgery follow-up;
2. when all of the initial cohort of subjects complete 6 months post-surgery follow-up.

Each DMC review will be triggered by the last subject within the safety cohort completing the relevant 3-month and 6- month post-surgery follow-up activities, respectively.

The re-opening of recruitment will only be triggered by authorization from the DMC to proceed.

Stage II of the clinical investigation will evaluate the performance and safety of FibroFix Cartilage P and the FibroFix Cartilage P Drill Set in a wider group of subjects, a further 69 recruited from all participating clinical centers to provide 60 evaluable out of 75 recruited subjects who have been implanted with the FibroFix Cartilage P, allowing for 20% drop out rate.

Stage I (safety cohort) subjects will be analyzed with the Stage II subjects as an overall cohort unless amendments to the treatment protocol and/or medical device are required following the evaluation of the safety cohort.

Primary outcomes will be reported in an interim report following completion of the 1-year post-surgery follow-up. All subjects will be follow-up for a total of 2 years post-surgery after which a final clinical study report will be written.

All participants in this clinical investigation will receive a single appropriately sized FibroFix Cartilage P implant, surgically implanted using the corresponding FibroFix Cartilage P Drill Set.

If it is not possible to implant FibroFix Cartilage P during surgery because the lesion is too large or, if once debrided the area is too large for study implant, the standard of care will be implemented at the discretion of the surgeon, and any adverse events related to use of the FibroFix cartilage P Drill Set will be followed.

The objective of Stage I, the initial safety cohort, will be to demonstrate the safety of FibroFix Cartilage P implant in a small number of subjects at 3- and 6-month post-surgery follow-up, and FibroFix Cartilage P Drill Set intraoperatively.

The objective of Stage II, Full cohort, will be to demonstrate the performance and safety of FibroFix Cartilage P implant at 1-year post-surgery follow-up, and FibroFix Cartilage P Drill Set intraoperatively. Performance of FibroFix Cartilage P will be determined by change in the Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS) Pain and Function (Sport/Rec) scores from baseline at 1-year post-surgery follow-up.

The null hypothesis being tested is the mean improvement in KOOS pain score at 1-year post-surgery from baseline is less than or equal to 8 points versus the alternative hypothesis that the mean improvement is greater than 8 points.

Subject participation will last 2 years and will require several visits to the doctor's office. Screening:

Subjects who are potential candidates for the clinical investigation will be identified by clinical research team members at the clinical centers involved. During the Screening phase, the following assessments will be performed:

* Collection of informed consent;
* Eligibility checked with subject against inclusions and exclusion criteria; • Collection of demographic and medical history data;
* Magnetic Resonance imaging (MRI).

Pre-operative Assessment:

If the subject has consented to participate and meets the inclusion criteria but none of the exclusion criteria, the following baseline assessments will be conducted. The subject's following medical history and medication history will be reviewed as part of this baseline assessment: demographics, patient history, and physical (review of systems, allergies, vital signs, physical examination, MRI assessment available to provide diagnosis, and urine pregnancy test for female subjects), concomitant medications, and MRI will be reviewed and baseline questionnaires (KOOS, Lysholm Knee Score and Tegner Activity Scale, Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) Pain, EuroQol 5-Dimension 5-Level (EQ-5D-5L), and Kellgren and Lawrence system) will be completed.

Post-operative Assessment:

For the study, subjects have to visit the hospital 6 times over 2 years (at 2w, 6w, 3m, 6m, 1y, and 2y). During all the follow-up visits, concomitant medications and safety events will be reviewed and subjects have to complete the VAS Pain, Lysholm, and Tegner activity questionnaires. In addition, during all visits except the 2w visit, subjects have to complete the KOOS questionnaire. During the 6m, 1y, and 2y visits, patients also have to complete the EQ-5D. An MRI will be conducted at 3m, 6m, 1y, and 2y.

Participants will then be followed up for a further 8 years for Device related adverse events and the same patient outcome questionnaires.

Eligibility criteria: Inclusion Criteria:

1. Patient is able to provide written informed consent;
2. Age ≥18 years at time of enrolment;
3. Able to comply with the protocol-defined pre-operative procedures, the post-operative clinical and imaging evaluations and the recommended rehabilitation regimen as determined by the Investigator;
4. Has a joint surface lesion, ICRS Grade 3 or above, on femoral condyles;
5. Female subjects of child-bearing potential: a negative urine pregnancy test at time of enrolment.
6. Patient has been diagnosed by MRI or other imaging technique to confirm presence of cartilage lesion and the lesion remains symptomatic. Only patients for whom the decision to perform surgery has already been made will be invited to participate. Asymptomatic lesions will NOT be included;

   Intra-Operative Inclusion criterion:
7. Lesion area of less than of 26.6 mm height and less than 20.0 mm width in the index knee after debridement.

Exclusion Criteria:

1. Age \>65 years or \<18 years at time of enrolment;
2. Body Mass Index (BMI) \> 35;
3. Lesion area of more than 26.6 mm length and more than 20.0 mm width in the index knee after debridement;
4. Patient has multiple lesions to be treated;
5. Articular cartilage lesions in the tibia or patella, ICRS grades 3 and above;
6. KOOS Pain Subscale score at baseline that is \< 20 or \> 65. (Scale range: Maximum pain = 0, pain free = 100);
7. Patient has previously received the FibroFix™ Cartilage P implant;
8. Patient suffers from any medical condition that would hinder cartilage repair, such as additional unresolved comorbidities related to the index knee;

   1. Clinically significant untreated ligament instability of the same knee,
   2. Patient is post op from surgery on the same knee within 6 months which stipulates on-going rehabilitation,
   3. Untreated, symptomatic, unstable meniscal lesions on patients with residual meniscus volume of \<50% in the same compartment,
   4. Joint malalignment that in the opinion of the treating surgeon, requires osteotomy to correct,
   5. Any previous surgical cartilage treatment in the index knee within the previous 6 months,
   6. Evidence of osteonecrosis of the involved knee.
9. A known allergy to:

   1. General and/or regional anaesthetic,
   2. Silk or silk containing products, or
   3. Glycerol or products containing glycerol.
10. Demonstrating an active local or systemic infection;
11. Any condition, which in the judgment of the Investigator would preclude adequate evaluation of the FibroFix™ Cartilage P implant and clinical outcome;
12. A history of confirmed anaphylactoid reaction;
13. Has received local administration of any type of corticosteroid or systemic administration of antineoplastic, immunostimulating, or immunosuppressive agents within 180 days prior to the scheduled surgery;
14. Medical history that includes a confirmed diagnosis of rheumatoid or inflammatory arthritis, or relapsing polychondritis;
15. If female and of child-bearing potential: evidence of a positive pregnancy test or a stated intention to become pregnant in the next 6 months at time of enrolment;
16. Currently participating in another device or drug clinical investigation or has done so in the previous 3 months which would impact the results of the surgery in the opinion of the surgeon or be a barrier to participation.

Primary outcomes:
measure: Change in Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome score (KOOS) - year 1(Pain and Sport/Rec only)
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to 1 year after surgery
measure: Safety endpoint - year 1
timeFrame: up to year 1 after surgery
Secondary outcomes:
measure: Change in KOOS -week 6
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to week 6 after surgery
measure: Change in KOOS -month 3
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to month 3 after surgery
measure: Change in KOOS -month 6
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to month 6 after surgery
measure: Change in KOOS -year 1
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 1 after surgery
measure: Change in KOOS -year 2
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 2 after surgery
measure: Change in KOOS -year 3
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 3 after surgery
measure: Change in KOOS -year 4
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 4 after surgery
measure: Change in KOOS -year 5
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 5 after surgery
measure: Change in KOOS -year 6
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 6 after surgery
measure: Change in KOOS -year 7
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 7 after surgery
measure: Change in KOOS -year 8
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 8 after surgery
measure: Change in KOOS -year 9
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 9 after surgery
measure: Change in KOOS - year 10
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 10 after surgery
measure: Change in Lysholm knee score -week 2
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to week 2 after surgery
measure: Change in Lysholm knee score -week 6
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to week 6 after surgery
measure: Change in Lysholm knee score -month 3
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to month 3 after surgery
measure: Change in Lysholm knee score -month 6
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to month 6 after surgery
measure: Change in Lysholm knee score -year 1
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 1 after surgery
measure: Change in Lysholm knee score -year 2
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 2 after surgery
measure: Change in Tegner Activity Scale -week 2
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to week 2 after surgery
measure: Change in Tegner Activity Scale -week 6
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to week 6 after surgery
measure: Change in Tegner Activity Scale -month 3
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to month 3 after surgery
measure: Change in Tegner Activity Scale -month 6
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to month 6 after surgery
measure: Change in Tegner Activity Scale -year 1
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 1 after surgery
measure: Change in Tegner Activity Scale -year 2
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 2 after surgery
measure: Change in Visual Analogue Score (VAS) - week 2
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to week 2 after surgery
measure: Change in Visual Analogue Score (VAS) - week 6
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to week 6 after surgery
measure: Change in Visual Analogue Score (VAS) - month 3
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to month 3 after surgery
measure: Change in Visual Analogue Score (VAS) - month 6
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to month 6 after surgery
measure: Change in Visual Analogue Score (VAS) - year 1
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 1 after surgery
measure: Change in Visual Analogue Score (VAS) - year 2
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 2 after surgery
measure: Change in EQ-5D-5L -month 6
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to month 6 after surgery
measure: Change in EQ-5D-5L -year 1
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 1 after surgery
measure: Change in EQ-5D-5L -year 1
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 2 after surgery
measure: Magnetic Resonance Imaging -month 3
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to month 3 after surgery
measure: Magnetic Resonance Imaging -month 6
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to month 6 after surgery
measure: Magnetic Resonance Imaging -year 1
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 1 after surgery
measure: Magnetic Resonance Imaging -year 2
timeFrame: baseline (pre-surgery) to year 2 after surgery
measure: Usability Questionnaire - Surgeons and Theatre nurses
timeFrame: immediately post-surgery
measure: Usability Questionnaire - Processing staff
timeFrame: after processing of instruments
measure: Usability Questionnaire - Patients
timeFrame: pre-discharge from hospital
measure: Safety endpoint - month 3
timeFrame: up to month 3 after surgery
measure: Safety endpoint - month 6
timeFrame: up to month 6 after surgery
measure: Safety endpoint -year 2
timeFrame: up to year 2 after surgery
measure: Safety endpoint -year 3
timeFrame: up to year 3 after surgery
measure: Safety endpoint -year 4
timeFrame: up to year 4 after surgery
measure: Safety endpoint -year 5
timeFrame: up to year 5 after surgery
measure: Safety endpoint -year 6
timeFrame: up to year 6 after surgery
measure: Safety endpoint -year 7
timeFrame: up to year 7 after surgery
measure: Safety endpoint -year 8
timeFrame: up to year 8 after surgery
measure: Safety endpoint -year 9
timeFrame: up to year 9 after surgery
measure: Safety endpoint -year 10
timeFrame: up to year 10 after surgery
Other outcomes:
Locations:
city: Budapest
country: Hungary
facility: Menta Egészségközpont
city: Bristol
country: United Kingdom
facility: North Bristol NHS Trust
Study officials:
affiliation: North Bristol NHS HospitalsTrust
name: Michael Whitehouse
role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR
References: