Clinical trial NCT00680303: Spacing Lidcombe Program Clinic Visits
Official title: The Effect of Spacing of Lidcombe Program Clinic Visits
Study type: INTERVENTIONAL
Overall status: UNKNOWN
Phase: PHASE2
Conditions: Stuttering
Keywords: Early Stuttering
Lidcombe Program
Stuttering Treatment
Efficiency
Efficacy
Service Delivery
Models of intervention
Lead sponsor: University of Sydney
Sponsor class: OTHER
Collaborators: name: National Health and Medical Research Council, Australia
name: Newcastle University
First posted: 2008-05-20
Enrollment: 120
Sex: ALL
Minimum age (years): 3
Maximum age (years): 6
Standard ages: CHILD
Accepts healthy volunteers: yes
Allocation: RANDOMIZED
Intervention model: PARALLEL
Primary purpose: HEALTH_SERVICES_RESEARCH

Brief summary: The purpose of this study is to evaluate the efficiency of the Lidcombe Program for early stuttering by varying the time between clinic visits during the first stage of the program.

Detailed description: Stuttering is a communicative disorder that affects an estimated 5.19% of children. Although approximately 71.4% of children whose stuttering onset is in the preschool years exhibit spontaneous recovery within two years after first reported onset, there remain a significant number of children who require fluency intervention. Given the potential for negative long term social and communicative consequences due to persistent stuttering, there is a consensus among speech-language pathologists that stuttering should be treated early. However, the longer a child's stuttering persists, the less likely the child will spontaneously recover.

The Lidcombe Program is a behavioral therapy program for preschool children designed to treat stuttering at its early stages. The treatment approach involves the direct participation of parents, who are trained during parent and child weekly visits to a speech language pathologist. In the first stage of the program, the clinician demonstrates the therapy to the parent, observes the parent conduct therapy and provides feedback and goals for the following week until the next clinic visit. The clinician guides the parent to provide three types of verbal "reinforcement" contingencies for the child's stutter free speech. These include, acknowledgment, praise and request for self-evaluation, where the child is asked to recognize his or her stutter free speech. If unambiguous stuttering occurs, the parent provides two types of verbal "punishment" contingencies including acknowledgment of the stuttering and request for self-correction, where the child is asked to repeat the stuttered word again. These contingencies are administered by parents in everyday speaking conversations, in order to promote generalization of fluent speech. When the child's stuttering is reduced to near-zero levels, the child then enters the second stage of the program, where the number of clinic visits are gradually phased out from bi-monthly to monthly to every 2 months, and so on, as required by the child. The purpose of the stage 2 visits is for the speech language pathologist to evaluate the child's speech and to ensure that near-zero stuttering levels are maintained.

When the first stage of the Lidcombe program is followed as the program was originally designed, the median treatment time to achieve the criteria of near-zero levels of stuttering is 11 one-hour weekly clinic visits, with treatment times varying according to the severity of the stuttering. However, clinicians have been deviating from the standard weekly sessions for various reasons. For instance, some private practitioners are offering first stage treatment visits once every 2 weeks rather than weekly and other practitioners are offering treatment intensively, so that clients from remote areas can have access to the Lidcombe program. As yet, there are no data to confirm whether treatment using fortnightly or twice weekly clinic visits is as effective or efficient as the standard weekly visits. The aim of this project is to evaluate the following questions: (1) Does altering the spacing of LP clinic visits affect treatment efficiency? (2) Does altering the spacing of LP clinic visits affect treatment efficacy?

Eligibility criteria: Inclusion Criteria:

1. 3;0-5;11 years of age
2. Stuttering for longer than 6 months
3. Functional English spoken by parent and child
4. Stuttering over 2%SS in one Beyond Clinic measure
5. Diagnosis of stuttering

Exclusion Criteria:

1. Less than 2%SS
2. Previous treatment for stuttering in last 6 months
3. Parental report of ADHD or intellectual disability

Primary outcomes:
measure: 1. Number of clinic visits required to achieve Stage II (0-1%SS, Severity Rating=1) 2. Number of clinic days to achieve Stage II 3. Percent Syllables Stuttered (%SS) at entry to Stage II
timeFrame: Entry into Stage II
Secondary outcomes:
measure: Parent reported Severity Ratings (SR)
timeFrame: Pre-treatment, entry into Stage 2, 9 months post-randomization, 18 months post-randomization
Other outcomes:
Locations:
city: Newcastle
country: Australia
facility: University of Newcastle
state: New South Wales
city: Montreal
country: Canada
facility: The Montreal Fluency Centre
state: Quebec
Study officials:
affiliation: University of Sydney
name: Mark Onslow
role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR
References: