Clinical trial NCT04154462: Evaluation of the Use of Medical Scribes in VAMC Emergency Departments and Specialty Care Clinics
Official title: Evaluation of the Use of Medical Scribes on Provider Efficiency, Patient Satisfaction, and Wait Times in VAMC Emergency Departments and Specialty Care Clinics
Study type: INTERVENTIONAL
Overall status: COMPLETED
Phase: NA
Conditions: Medical Scribes
Keywords: workforce
medical records
documentation
efficiency
patient satisfaction
Lead sponsor: VA Boston Healthcare System
Sponsor class: FED
Collaborators: name: US Department of Veterans Affairs
First posted: 2019-11-06
Enrollment: 12
Sex: ALL
Standard ages: CHILD
ADULT
OLDER_ADULT
Accepts healthy volunteers: yes
Allocation: RANDOMIZED
Intervention model: PARALLEL
Intervention model description: A two-arm randomized field experiment is being used to assess the effect of medical scribes on productivity, wait times, and patient satisfaction. OVAC will work with participating VAMCs to identify providers to participate in the pilot. A varied provider pool will limit selection bias but must be balanced with recruitment and retention of providers. The goal is to keep the provider-scribe pairs consistent throughout the pilot.

Each VAMC site randomized to treatment will have two VA employee scribes and two contract scribes. Two medical scribes, ideally one employee and one contract, will be assigned to one physician, with two physicians and/or Licensed Independent Practitioners (LIP) participating at each facility. Scribes will work with others if the provider partner is not available during a scheduled shift. Power analyses have been conducted to determine the minimum effect size for each outcome with 80% power, which will be useful for putting the final results into context.
Primary purpose: HEALTH_SERVICES_RESEARCH

Brief summary: Background and study aims: Medical scribes are trained paraprofessionals that assist providers with documenting patient encounters. Prior evidence suggests that scribes may be effective in increasing provider productivity and satisfaction, and decreasing provider time spent on documentation without negatively affecting patient satisfaction. Section 507 of the MISSION Act of 2018 mandated a two-year pilot of medical scribes, which will begin in March 2020 in specialty clinics and emergency departments (EDs) of twelve VA Medical Centers (VAMCs) across the country. The aims of this study are to understand how the introduction of scribes and scribe training affect provider efficiency, patient and provider satisfaction, wait times, and daily patient volume in the VA context.

Who can participate? Urban and rural VAMCs willing to be assigned medical scribes for use in EDs or selected high wait time specialty clinics (cardiology, orthopedics).

What does the study involve? Four medical scribes will be assigned to each of the 12 VAMC sites randomized into treatment with the VA hiring half as new employees and contracting out for the remaining half. 30% of the scribes will be assigned to emergency departments and the other 70% will be assigned to specialty care. Remaining sites that expressed interest in the pilot but were not randomized treatment will be used as comparators. Provider productivity, patient volume, wait times, and patient satisfaction from the treated sites will be compared to baseline (pre-scribe) data as well as data from comparison sites.

What are the possible benefits and risks of participating? VAMCs where medical scribes are introduced may see gains in provider efficiency, reduced wait times, and increased patient satisfaction due to the shifting of administrative burdens associated with documenting patient encounters in electronic health records from providers to these trained professionals. The introduction of medical scribes could complicate patient encounters by making some patients and/or providers uncomfortable.

Where is the study run from? This study is being coordinated by the Partnered Evidence-based Policy Resource Center (PEPReC) at the VA Boston Healthcare System in collaboration with the VA Office of Veterans Access to Care (OVAC).

When is the study starting and how long is it expected to run for? March 2020 to February 2022

Who is funding the study? U.S. Veterans Health Administration


Eligibility criteria: Inclusion Criteria:

• Expression of interest by VAMC

Exclusion Criteria:

• Lack of appropriate site capabilities

The VA Office of Veterans Access to Care developed a list of 32 interested VAMCs based on email surveying, which were categorized based on location (urban, rural), desired scribe deployment (ED, specialty care), and underserved (based on high new patient specialty care wait times). 12 VAMCs were then randomly selected for the treatment, accounting for the requirements of the law, OVAC preferences, and site capabilities, with the remainder used as comparison sites.

Primary outcomes:
measure: Pay period work relative value-based provider efficiency
timeFrame: Approximately 42 months
measure: Pay period visit-based provider efficiency
timeFrame: Approximately 42 months
measure: Daily visit-based provider efficiency
timeFrame: Approximately 42 months
measure: Days to completed consult
timeFrame: Approximately 42 months
measure: Days to scheduled consult
timeFrame: Approximately 42 months
measure: Unique patient volume
timeFrame: Approximately 42 months
measure: Patient satisfaction
timeFrame: Approximately 42 months
Secondary outcomes:
Other outcomes:
Locations:
city: Tucson
country: United States
facility: Southern Arizona VA Health Care System
state: Arizona
city: Louisville
country: United States
facility: Robley Rex VA Medical Center
state: Kentucky
city: Augusta
country: United States
facility: Togus VA Medical Center
state: Maine
city: Helena
country: United States
facility: Fort Harrison VA Medical Center
state: Montana
city: Manchester
country: United States
facility: Manchester VA Medical Center
state: New Hampshire
city: East Orange
country: United States
facility: East Orange VA Medical Center
state: New Jersey
city: Fargo
country: United States
facility: Fargo VA Medical Center
state: North Dakota
city: Oklahoma City
country: United States
facility: Oklahoma City VA Medical Center
state: Oklahoma
city: San Antonio
country: United States
facility: Audie L. Murphy VA Hospital
state: Texas
city: Temple
country: United States
facility: Olin E. Teague Veterans' Medical Center
state: Texas
city: Hampton
country: United States
facility: Hampton VA Medical Center
state: Virginia
city: Clarksburg
country: United States
facility: Louis A. Johnson VA Medical Center
state: West Virginia
Study officials:
affiliation: Boston VA Healthcare System
name: Steven Pizer, PhD
role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR
References:
citation: Pearson, E., Frakt, A., & Pizer, S. (2018, December). Medical Scribes, Productivity, and Satisfaction. Partnered Evidence-based Policy Resource Center Policy Brief, 3(2).