WITH : Patton Oswalt ( Paul Aufiero ) , Kevin Corrigan ( Sal ) , Michael Rapaport ( Philadelphia Phil ) , Marcia Jean Kurtz ( Theresa Aufiero ) , Matt Servitto ( Detective Velardi ) , Gino Cafarelli ( Jeff Aufiero ) , Serafina Fiore ( Gina Aufiero ) , Polly Humphreys ( Christine ) , Jonathan Hamm ( Quantrell Bishop ) and Scott Ferrall ( Sports Dogg ) .