Columns: School | Nickname | Location | Colors | Tenure
Danville | Blue Devils | Danville | Blue, White | 1954-1962, 1963-1979, 1981-present | East Knox | Bulldogs | Howard | Purple, White | 1964-1979, 1981-2014 | Loudonville | Redbirds | Loudonville | Red, Gray | 2004–present | Lucas | Cubs | Lucas | Orange, Black | 2013–present | Mansfield Christian | Flames | Mansfield | Red, White | 2013–present