Columns: Pick # | MLS team | Player | Position | Affiliation
37 | Vancouver Whitecaps FC | Bilal Duckett | Defender | University of Notre Dame | 38 | New York Red Bulls | Billy Cortes | Defender | University of Maryland | 39 | New England Revolution | Steven Perry | Forward | University of Notre Dame Indiana Invaders | 40 | Chivas USA | Jon Okafor | Midfielder | Brown University Central Jersey Spartans | 42 | New England Revolution | Ryan Kinne | Midfielder | Monmouth University Central Jersey Spartans | 43 | Toronto FC | Matt Gold | Defender | Ohio State University | 45 | Chicago Fire | Jason Herrick | Forward | University of Maryland | 46 | Sporting Kansas City | Konrad Warzycha | Midfielder | Ohio State University | 47 | Seattle Sounders FC | Alex Caskey | Midfielder | Davidson College Atlanta Blackhawks | 48 | Columbus Crew | Bernardo Anor | Midfielder | University of South Florida Bradenton Academics | 49 | Toronto FC | Joao Plata | Midfielder | LDU Quito | 50 | D.C. United | Joe Willis | Goalkeeper | University of Denver Real Colorado Foxes | 51 | Chicago Fire | Davis Paul | Forward | University of California, Berkeley | 52 | Real Salt Lake | Jarad Van Schaik | Midfielder | University of Portland | 53 | FC Dallas | Scott Gordon | Defender | Lynn University Baton Rouge Capitals