user: ### NOW ANSWER:
Question: Which Debut year has a Player of noel carroll, and Games smaller than 12?
Columns: ['Debut year', 'Player', 'Games', 'Goals', 'Years at club']
Types: ['real', 'text', 'real', 'real', 'text']
Sample row: [1950.0, 'Alan Sorrell', 1.0, 0.0, '1950']
SQL:

assistant: SELECT MAX("Debut year") FROM "Table" WHERE "Player" = 'noel carroll' AND "Games" < 12.0;