with pat storylines , precious circumstances and beautiful stars 
(ROOT (PP (IN with) (NP (NP (NN pat) (NNS storylines)) (, ,) (NP (JJ precious) (NNS circumstances)) (CC and) (NP (JJ beautiful) (NNS stars)))))
(ROOT (PP (IN ) (NP (NP (NN ) (NNS )) (, ) (NP (JJ ) (NNS )) (CC ) (NP (JJ ) (NNS )))))