with regret and , ultimately , finding redemption 
(ROOT (PP (PP (IN with) (NP (NN regret))) (CC and) (, ,) (ADVP (RB ultimately)) (, ,) (S (VP (VBG finding) (NP (NN redemption))))))
(ROOT (PP (PP (IN ) (NP (NN ))) (CC ) (, ) (ADVP (RB )) (, ) (S (VP (VBG ) (NP (NN ))))))