Optimal Digital Weight Loss Treatment for Rural Individuals

Study Overview
=================
Brief Summary
-----------------
Over 130 million adults in the US experience overweight and obesity, and rural communities experience significantly higher rates of obesity and related chronic diseases. Although lifestyle interventions successfully produce clinically significant weight losses, the availability of weight management programs is limited in rural areas. Digital interventions offer an attractive alternative for delivering lifestyle programs to rural populations. However, in-person behavioral obesity treatment programs achieve better weight losses than digital programs, likely because in-person programs typically include personnel-intensive high touch treatment components. Some studies indicate that having a human behind the curtain of a digital program through emailed feedback or with the addition of online group sessions can significantly increase weight loss. Therefore, the aims of this study are to increase the public health impact of digital obesity treatment for rural populations by simultaneously investigating 3 high touch intervention components. The investigators will conduct a highly efficient experiment with participants residing in non-urban areas recruited online from across the United States. Participants (N=616; 22% racial/ethnic minority; 40% male) will be randomized to: (1) weekly facilitated synchronous group video sessions (yes vs. no); (2) type of self-monitoring feedback received (counselor-crafted vs. pre-scripted); and (3) individual coaching calls (yes vs. no). These components will be layered onto our 24-week evidence-based, interactive digital weight loss program delivered to groups of eligible individuals. Based on the results of the experiment, The investigators will identify an optimized program in which each component (or combination of components) contributes meaningfully (at least 1.5 kg greater weight loss at 6-months) to enhanced weight loss. The investigators will also exploratory analyses of weight trajectories 6-months post-treatment (i.e., at 12-months) to elucidate extended impact of the specific components on weight control. Ultimately, this research will set the stage for confirming the most promising digital behavioral weight loss intervention that can be used without geographic borders to reduce obesity rates among rural residents and provide the evidence needed to establish best practice policies for broadly effective digital approaches to weight control.

Official Title
-----------------
Addressing Rural Health Disparities by Optimizing High Touch Intervention Components in Digital Obesity Treatment

Conditions
-----------------
Overweight and Obesity

Intervention / Treatment
-----------------
* Behavioral: Core
* Behavioral: Facilitated Weekly Group Sessions
* Behavioral: Counselor Crafted Feedback
* Behavioral: Individual Coaching Calls
* Behavioral: Pre-Scripted Feedback


Participation Criteria
=================
Eligibility Criteria
-----------------
Inclusion Criteria: have a body mass index [BMI] > 25-55 kg/m2; home address in a zip code classified as non-urban in the USDA Rural-Urban Commuting Area [RUCA] codes of 4-10); have no physical limitations that prevent walking at a moderate pace for at least 10 minutes without stopping; be able to provide informed consent; have access to a smartphone and a computer or tablet with a video camera and stable access to the Internet (at home or work or some other stable source of access); complete all screening and baseline questionnaires and activities. Exclusion Criteria: only one member of a household may participate concurrently. currently participating in another weight loss program, taking a weight loss medication, have a history of bariatric surgery, or lost ≥ 10 pounds during the past 6-months; are pregnant, lactating, less than 6 months post-partum, or plan to become pregnant during the time frame of the investigation; report a medical condition that would affect the safety and/or efficacy of a weight management program involving diet and physical activity (e.g., uncontrolled heart condition, dementia, bulimia nervosa or binge eating disorder, or other significant psychiatric problems); or report conditions that in the judgment of the one of the Principal Investigators (MPIs) would render them unlikely to be able to independently follow the intervention protocol for 6 months, including conditions which might comprise their ability to engage independently with the intervention website materials, provide self-monitoring information on a smartphone app, attend Zoom video group or individual sessions at the available times (if randomized to receive these treatment components), and complete online questionnaires.

Ages Eligible for Study
-----------------
Minimum Age: 18 Years

Sexes Eligible for Study
-----------------
All

Accepts Healthy Volunteers
-----------------
Accepts Healthy Volunteers

Study Plan
=================
How is the study designed?
-----------------

Design Details

Primary Purpose: Treatment
Allocation: Randomized
Intervention Model: Factorial Assignment
Masking: Single


Arms and Interventions

| Participant Group/Arm | Intervention/Treatment |
| --- | --- |
| Experimental: Core+Facilitated Weekly Group Sessions+Counselor Crafted Feedback<br>Behavioral: Core The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Behavioral: Facilitated Weekly Group Sessions Participants will receive 24, 60-minute facilitated online video-conference-based weekly group sessions. Behavioral: Counselor Crafted Feedback Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages that are crafted by a trained professional based on their dietary, physical activity, and weight monitoring for the week as well as their completion of online modules, to construct an individualized feedback message. | Behavioral: Core<br>* The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Weekly tips and discussion board postings invite participants to apply skills introduced in the modules and prompt interaction and social support within the closed group which starts the program simultaneously.<br>Behavioral: Facilitated Weekly Group Sessions<br>* Participants will receive 24 facilitated online video-conference-based weekly group sessions. These groups will be 60 minutes long and will be facilitated by a trained professional, who reinforces the information and behavioral strategies introduced in the weekly modules, elicits the experiences of participants in applying behavioral skills to establish new diet and exercise habits, and guides problem solving. Group cohesion to offer social support is promoted.<br>Behavioral: Counselor Crafted Feedback<br>* Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages that are crafted by a trained professional based on their dietary, physical activity, and weight monitoring for the week as well as their completion of online modules, to construct an individualized feedback message. The emailed feedback will provide positive reinforcement for successful goal achievement, identify possible areas for improvement, and suggest possible strategies for identified challenges.<br>|
| Experimental: Core+Facilitated Weekly Group Sessions+Counselor Crafted Feedback+Individual Coaching Calls<br>Behavioral: Core The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Behavioral: Facilitated Weekly Group Sessions Participants will receive 24, 60-minute facilitated online video-conference-based weekly group sessions. Behavioral: Counselor Crafted Feedback Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages that are crafted by a trained professional based on their dietary, physical activity, and weight monitoring for the week as well as their completion of online modules, to construct an individualized feedback message. Behavioral: Individual Coaching Calls Participants will receive 3 30-minute online one-on-one coaching calls to focus on identifying and addressing challenges to successful behavior change and weight loss. | Behavioral: Core<br>* The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Weekly tips and discussion board postings invite participants to apply skills introduced in the modules and prompt interaction and social support within the closed group which starts the program simultaneously.<br>Behavioral: Facilitated Weekly Group Sessions<br>* Participants will receive 24 facilitated online video-conference-based weekly group sessions. These groups will be 60 minutes long and will be facilitated by a trained professional, who reinforces the information and behavioral strategies introduced in the weekly modules, elicits the experiences of participants in applying behavioral skills to establish new diet and exercise habits, and guides problem solving. Group cohesion to offer social support is promoted.<br>Behavioral: Counselor Crafted Feedback<br>* Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages that are crafted by a trained professional based on their dietary, physical activity, and weight monitoring for the week as well as their completion of online modules, to construct an individualized feedback message. The emailed feedback will provide positive reinforcement for successful goal achievement, identify possible areas for improvement, and suggest possible strategies for identified challenges.<br>Behavioral: Individual Coaching Calls<br>* Participants will receive 3 online one-on-one coaching calls to focus on identifying and addressing challenges to successful behavior change and weight loss. The first call will emphasize amplifying motivation and promoting early treatment engagement by establishing rapport, exploring personal reasons for weight loss and lifestyle change, and reinforcing and expanding change talk, and it will occur prior to starting the core program. Subsequent calls will use a motivational interviewing-informed approach to problem solve barriers to self-monitoring, particularly dietary self-monitoring because of the strong role it plays in promoting better weight loss and will occur during the first half of the program, reflecting the critical role of early engagement in the treatment program on long term weight loss success. Coaching calls will be of approximately 30 min duration and will follow a semi-structured interview format.<br>|
| Experimental: Core+Facilitated Weekly Group Sessions+Pre-Scripted Feedback<br>Behavioral: Core The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Behavioral: Facilitated Weekly Group Sessions Participants will receive 24, 60-minute facilitated online video-conference-based weekly group sessions. Behavioral: Pre-Scripted Feedback Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages constructed from a bank of pre-scripted messages that align with success, partial success, or absence of self-monitoring related to diet monitoring, physical activity, and self-weighing, as well as on weekly module engagement. | Behavioral: Core<br>* The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Weekly tips and discussion board postings invite participants to apply skills introduced in the modules and prompt interaction and social support within the closed group which starts the program simultaneously.<br>Behavioral: Facilitated Weekly Group Sessions<br>* Participants will receive 24 facilitated online video-conference-based weekly group sessions. These groups will be 60 minutes long and will be facilitated by a trained professional, who reinforces the information and behavioral strategies introduced in the weekly modules, elicits the experiences of participants in applying behavioral skills to establish new diet and exercise habits, and guides problem solving. Group cohesion to offer social support is promoted.<br>Behavioral: Pre-Scripted Feedback<br>* Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages constructed from a bank of pre-scripted messages that align with success, partial success, or absence of self-monitoring within each of the following domains: dietary monitoring, physical activity monitoring, and self-weighing, as well as on weekly module completion. Feedback is automatically generated based on decision algorithms and will be sent from program staff.<br>|
| Experimental: Core+Facilitated Weekly Group Sessions+Pre-Scripted Feedback+Individual Coaching Calls<br>Behavioral: Core The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Behavioral: Facilitated Weekly Group Sessions Participants will receive 24, 60-minute facilitated online video-conference-based weekly group sessions. Behavioral: Pre-Scripted Feedback Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages constructed from a bank of pre-scripted messages that align with success, partial success, or absence of self-monitoring related to diet monitoring, physical activity, and self-weighing, as well as on weekly module engagement. Behavioral: Individual Coaching Calls Participants will receive 3 30-minute online one-on-one coaching calls to focus on identifying and addressing challenges to successful behavior change and weight loss. | Behavioral: Core<br>* The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Weekly tips and discussion board postings invite participants to apply skills introduced in the modules and prompt interaction and social support within the closed group which starts the program simultaneously.<br>Behavioral: Facilitated Weekly Group Sessions<br>* Participants will receive 24 facilitated online video-conference-based weekly group sessions. These groups will be 60 minutes long and will be facilitated by a trained professional, who reinforces the information and behavioral strategies introduced in the weekly modules, elicits the experiences of participants in applying behavioral skills to establish new diet and exercise habits, and guides problem solving. Group cohesion to offer social support is promoted.<br>Behavioral: Individual Coaching Calls<br>* Participants will receive 3 online one-on-one coaching calls to focus on identifying and addressing challenges to successful behavior change and weight loss. The first call will emphasize amplifying motivation and promoting early treatment engagement by establishing rapport, exploring personal reasons for weight loss and lifestyle change, and reinforcing and expanding change talk, and it will occur prior to starting the core program. Subsequent calls will use a motivational interviewing-informed approach to problem solve barriers to self-monitoring, particularly dietary self-monitoring because of the strong role it plays in promoting better weight loss and will occur during the first half of the program, reflecting the critical role of early engagement in the treatment program on long term weight loss success. Coaching calls will be of approximately 30 min duration and will follow a semi-structured interview format.<br>Behavioral: Pre-Scripted Feedback<br>* Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages constructed from a bank of pre-scripted messages that align with success, partial success, or absence of self-monitoring within each of the following domains: dietary monitoring, physical activity monitoring, and self-weighing, as well as on weekly module completion. Feedback is automatically generated based on decision algorithms and will be sent from program staff.<br>|
| Experimental: Core+ Counselor Crafted Feedback+Individual Coaching Calls<br>Behavioral: Core The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Behavioral: Counselor Crafted Feedback Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages that are crafted by a trained professional based on their dietary, physical activity, and weight monitoring for the week as well as their completion of online modules, to construct an individualized feedback message. Behavioral: Individual Coaching Calls Participants will receive 3 30-minute online one-on-one coaching calls to focus on identifying and addressing challenges to successful behavior change and weight loss. | Behavioral: Core<br>* The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Weekly tips and discussion board postings invite participants to apply skills introduced in the modules and prompt interaction and social support within the closed group which starts the program simultaneously.<br>Behavioral: Counselor Crafted Feedback<br>* Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages that are crafted by a trained professional based on their dietary, physical activity, and weight monitoring for the week as well as their completion of online modules, to construct an individualized feedback message. The emailed feedback will provide positive reinforcement for successful goal achievement, identify possible areas for improvement, and suggest possible strategies for identified challenges.<br>Behavioral: Individual Coaching Calls<br>* Participants will receive 3 online one-on-one coaching calls to focus on identifying and addressing challenges to successful behavior change and weight loss. The first call will emphasize amplifying motivation and promoting early treatment engagement by establishing rapport, exploring personal reasons for weight loss and lifestyle change, and reinforcing and expanding change talk, and it will occur prior to starting the core program. Subsequent calls will use a motivational interviewing-informed approach to problem solve barriers to self-monitoring, particularly dietary self-monitoring because of the strong role it plays in promoting better weight loss and will occur during the first half of the program, reflecting the critical role of early engagement in the treatment program on long term weight loss success. Coaching calls will be of approximately 30 min duration and will follow a semi-structured interview format.<br>|
| Experimental: Core+ Counselor Crafted Feedback<br>Behavioral: Core The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Behavioral: Counselor Crafted Feedback Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages that are crafted by a trained professional based on their dietary, physical activity, and weight monitoring for the week as well as their completion of online modules, to construct an individualized feedback message. | Behavioral: Core<br>* The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Weekly tips and discussion board postings invite participants to apply skills introduced in the modules and prompt interaction and social support within the closed group which starts the program simultaneously.<br>Behavioral: Counselor Crafted Feedback<br>* Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages that are crafted by a trained professional based on their dietary, physical activity, and weight monitoring for the week as well as their completion of online modules, to construct an individualized feedback message. The emailed feedback will provide positive reinforcement for successful goal achievement, identify possible areas for improvement, and suggest possible strategies for identified challenges.<br>|
| Experimental: Core+Pre-Scripted Feedback+Individual Coaching Calls<br>Behavioral: Core The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Behavioral: Pre-Scripted Feedback Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages constructed from a bank of pre-scripted messages that align with success, partial success, or absence of self-monitoring related to diet monitoring, physical activity, and self-weighing, as well as on weekly module engagement. Behavioral: Individual Coaching Calls Participants will receive 3 30-minute online one-on-one coaching calls to focus on identifying and addressing challenges to successful behavior change and weight loss. | Behavioral: Core<br>* The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Weekly tips and discussion board postings invite participants to apply skills introduced in the modules and prompt interaction and social support within the closed group which starts the program simultaneously.<br>Behavioral: Individual Coaching Calls<br>* Participants will receive 3 online one-on-one coaching calls to focus on identifying and addressing challenges to successful behavior change and weight loss. The first call will emphasize amplifying motivation and promoting early treatment engagement by establishing rapport, exploring personal reasons for weight loss and lifestyle change, and reinforcing and expanding change talk, and it will occur prior to starting the core program. Subsequent calls will use a motivational interviewing-informed approach to problem solve barriers to self-monitoring, particularly dietary self-monitoring because of the strong role it plays in promoting better weight loss and will occur during the first half of the program, reflecting the critical role of early engagement in the treatment program on long term weight loss success. Coaching calls will be of approximately 30 min duration and will follow a semi-structured interview format.<br>Behavioral: Pre-Scripted Feedback<br>* Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages constructed from a bank of pre-scripted messages that align with success, partial success, or absence of self-monitoring within each of the following domains: dietary monitoring, physical activity monitoring, and self-weighing, as well as on weekly module completion. Feedback is automatically generated based on decision algorithms and will be sent from program staff.<br>|
| Experimental: Core+Pre-Scripted Feedback<br>Behavioral: Core The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Behavioral: Pre-Scripted Feedback Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages constructed from a bank of pre-scripted messages that align with success, partial success, or absence of self-monitoring related to diet monitoring, physical activity, and self-weighing, as well as on weekly module engagement. | Behavioral: Core<br>* The core intervention will include 24 online weekly behavioral modules, an online interactive discussion board, a physical activity tracker, an e-scale with recommendations for daily self-weighing, dietary self-monitoring via an app, as well as weekly calorie and physical activity goals. Weekly tips and discussion board postings invite participants to apply skills introduced in the modules and prompt interaction and social support within the closed group which starts the program simultaneously.<br>Behavioral: Pre-Scripted Feedback<br>* Participants will receive up to 24 weekly messages constructed from a bank of pre-scripted messages that align with success, partial success, or absence of self-monitoring within each of the following domains: dietary monitoring, physical activity monitoring, and self-weighing, as well as on weekly module completion. Feedback is automatically generated based on decision algorithms and will be sent from program staff.<br>|

What is the study measuring?
-----------------
Primary Outcome Measures

| Outcome Measure | Measure Description | Time Frame |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Change in weight at 6 months | The difference in weight between the randomization weight and the 6 month weight. Weight values will be obtained by an electronic scale provided to participants which transmits the data to the study server. | 6 months | 

Secondary Outcome Measures

| Outcome Measure | Measure Description | Time Frame |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Change in weight at 12 months | The difference in weight between the randomization weight and the 12 month weight. Weight values will be obtained by an electronic scale provided to participants which transmits the data to the study server. | 12 months | 

 Terms related to the study
=================
Keywords Provided by Centre Hospitalier Valida
-----------------
behavioral weight control, weight management, online weight loss program