Diskussion:Jonas Eriksson Sundahl

message: Jag har inte Anders Edestams bok men på webben stavas namnet vanligtvis Jonas Eriksson Sundahl. --Nordelch För Wikipedia - i tiden 12 september 2008 kl. 18.45 (CEST)

message: Svenskgeografi.se doesn't know a Gäserud in Värmland, but a Gäserud in Vestergötaland.
German WP tells that he was born in "Oden" in "Wärmelandsdal". Svenskgeografi.se knows a gård named Odenstad in Värmland.
217.239.30.22 22 november 2011 kl. 12.15 (CET) (Ulamm)
replies: text: Interesting. According to this tidskrift from Genealogiska föreningen there are two explanations to his background. Firstly one Anders Edestam, a Swede, who claims that Sundahls father Erik Olofsson Sund owned Gäserud in Dalsland, not Västergötland. It doesn't specify exactly where Jonas was born, it's just that he doesn't mention Oden or any other place.

text: The other one, a Karl Lohmeyer, a german says that he was born in Oden, Värmland, which could or could not be Odenstad. He also gives a completely different namn to his father (Olaf Erickson Sundahl) and claims that Jonas' mother belonged to the Hesselgren family, whereas Edestam mentions that his grandmother (mother's mother) had been remarried to a man called Hesselgren. This definitely needs more looking into, but from my point of view I would rather trust Edestam who would, one could presume, have had access to better sources and was more or less specialized in Dalsland history. /Diupwijk 22 november 2011 kl. 12.56 (CET)
replies: text: :In general, I'd agree that Edestam has better access and better understanding of the sources. My only problem is, that I coud not find a Gäserud in Värmland by Svenskgeografi.se.

text: :German WP used "Gjäserud" as part of the father's name ("von Gjäserud" as "af Gäserud"), but Edestam's knowledge of Swedish language ist better than Lohmeyer's, surely :) --91.55.125.60 23 november 2011 kl. 10.54 (CET) (Ulamm)
replies: text: ::No, Gäserud is definitely in Dalsland. One could only speculate why Lohmeyer claims that Värmland was his birthplace. Maybe Sundahl did live there for awhile, who knows? According to Edestam, he was raised by his mother's half brother - perhaps he lived in Värmland? Also, I don't know what he means with "Valley of Värmland". There are several larger valleys in Värmland, the largest one is Älvdalen which follows the Klarälv, but it is as far as I know always referred to as "The Valley", and Odenstad is not in Älvdalen (maybe something was lost in translation).

text: ::"Gjäserud" looks like an archaic spelling of "Gäserud", in case you didn't know.

text: ::It seems they have saved Edestams books and whatnot in Åmål library, close to my hometown. I could possibly go there and snoop around the next time I am visiting those parts of the country. /Diupwijk 23 november 2011 kl. 14.43 (CET)
thread_title:  Place of birth 

message: Hej, wikipedianer!
Jag har just ändrat 1 externa länkar på Jonas Eriksson Sundahl. Kontrollera gärna mina ändringar. Om du har några frågor, eller vill be boten ignorera vissa länkar eller hela artikeln, läs frågor och svar för mer information. Jag har gjort följande ändringar:
*Lade till arkiv https://web.archive.org/web/20071122162227/http://www.schloss-carlsberg.de/Inhalt/Oberamt/Tschifflik/tschifflik.html till http://www.schloss-carlsberg.de/Inhalt/Oberamt/Tschifflik/tschifflik.html
När ändringarna har blivit kontrollerade kan du använda verktygen nedan för att rapportera eventuella problem.
*Om du har hittat länkar som påstås vara döda men inte är det kan du rapportera det som falskt positivt.
*Om du har hittat fel i själva ändringen kan du rapportera en bugg.
*Om du har hittat fel med själva URL:en, som till exempel att den använder en otillförlitlig arkivtjänst, kan du ändra det med URL-verktyget.
Hälsningar.—InternetArchiveBot (Rapportera fel) 20 juli 2018 kl. 01.39 (CEST)
thread_title:  Externa länkar ändrade