Document:

EXHIBIT 10.23

 Exhibit 10.23 
 SPECIFIC TERMS IN THIS EXHIBIT HAVE BEEN REDACTED BECAUSE CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT FOR THOSE TERMS HAS BEEN REQUESTED. THE REDACTED MATERIAL HAS BEEN SEPARATELY FILED WITH THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE
COMMISSION, AND THE TERMS HAVE BEEN MARKED AT THE APPROPRIATE PLACE WITH THE WORD “[REDACTED]”. 
 AMENDED AND
RESTATED CRUDE OIL ACQUISITION AGREEMENT 
 between 

MORGAN STANLEY CAPITAL GROUP INC. 
 and 
 PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC 

Amended and Restated as of March 1, 2012 

 Table of Contents 

 

					
	 	  	Page	 
	 1. Definitions and Construction
	  	 	1	  
	 2. Effective Date and Term
	  	 	12	  
	 3. Conditions Precedent
	  	 	13	  
	 4. Daily Sales of Crude Oil
	  	 	13	  
	 5. Delivery Nominations and Reporting
	  	 	15	  
	 6. Certain Representations
	  	 	18	  
	 7. Warranties
	  	 	19	  
	 8. Pricing of Delivered Volumes
	  	 	19	  
	 9. Payment and Netting
	  	 	21	  
	 10. Additional MSCG Services
	  	 	23	  
	 11. Disposition of Crude Oil Upon Termination or Expiration
	  	 	23	  
	 12. Financial Information, Security and Requests for Further Assurances
	  	 	24	  
	 13. Refinery Turnaround, Maintenance and Closure
	  	 	29	  
	 14. Taxes
	  	 	29	  
	 15. Insurance
	  	 	30	  
	 16. Force Majeure
	  	 	31	  
	 17. Representations, Warranties and Covenants
	  	 	31	  
	 18. Termination Events, Default and Early Termination
	  	 	35	  
	 19. Indemnification and Claims
	  	 	42	  
	 20. Limitation on Damages
	  	 	43	  
	 21. Information and Inspection Rights
	  	 	44	  
	 22. Governance Committee
	  	 	44	  
	 23. Governing Law and Disputes
	  	 	45	  
	 24. Assignment
	  	 	46	  

  
 i 

 Table of Contents 

 

					
	 	  	Page	 
	 25. Notices
	  	 	46	  
	 26. Nature of the Transaction and Relationship of the Parties
	  	 	47	  
	 27. Confidentiality
	  	 	47	  
	 28. Miscellaneous
	  	 	48	  

 Schedules 

Schedule 1 – Pipelines 
 Schedule 2 –
Transfer Points and Pricing Dates 
 Schedule 3 – Form of Nomination and Forecast Report 

Schedule 4 – Form of Weekly Nomination 

Schedule 5 – Crude Oil Pricing Formulas 

Schedule 6 – Form of WTI Differential Report 

Schedule 7 – Estimated Transit Time and TVM Cost Calculation Methodology 
 Schedule 8 – Logistics Costs 
 Schedule 9 – Enbridge North Dakota Line Terms 

Schedule 10 – Hedge Adjustment Amount 

  
 ii 

 AMENDED AND RESTATED CRUDE OIL ACQUISITION AGREEMENT 

This Amended and Restated Crude Oil Acquisition Agreement was originally entered into between Toledo Refining Company LLC, a Delaware
limited liability company who has a place of business located at One Sylvan Way, 2nd Floor, Parsippany, NJ 07054-3887 (“TRC”) and Morgan Stanley Capital Group Inc., a Delaware corporation whose principal place of business is located at 2000 Westchester Avenue, Floor 01,
Purchase, New York 10577-2530 (“MSCG”) as of May 31, 2011 (such date, the “Effective Date” and such agreement, the “Original Agreement”) and is being amended and restated effective as of
12:00:01 a.m. Eastern Prevailing Time on March 1, 2012 (the “Assignment Date”) by MSCG and PBF Holding Company LLC, a Delaware limited liability company who has a place of business located at One Sylvan Way, 2nd Floor, Parsippany, New Jersey 07054-3887 (“PBF”)
(each of MSCG and PBF are referred to individually as a “Party” or collectively as the “Parties”). 

WHEREAS, TRC requested consent to the assignment of the Original Agreement from TRC to PBF and MSCG granted such consent pursuant to, and on the
terms set forth in, the assignment agreement among TRC, PBF and MSCG dated as of February 28, 2012 (the “Assignment”); 

WHEREAS, the Parties hereto wish to amend and restate the Original Agreement in its entirety as set forth herein; 

WHEREAS, the Parties hereto intend that, effective as of the Assumption Time on the Assignment Date, subject to the satisfaction or waiver of the
conditions precedent set forth in the Assignment, the Original Agreement shall be amended and restated as set forth herein; 
 WHEREAS,
PBF and MSCG each desire that, commencing on the Assignment Date, MSCG sell to PBF, and PBF purchase from MSCG, Crude Oil at Marysville, Michigan, Patoka, Illinois, Longview, Texas, Cushing, Oklahoma and St. James, Louisiana and certain other
locations agreed upon between the Parties (the “Delivery Locations”) for shipment to the Refinery (as defined below) or to such other locations as PBF elects, upon the terms and conditions contained herein. 

NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the premises and the respective promises, conditions, terms and agreements contained herein, and other good
and valuable consideration, the receipt and adequacy of which are hereby acknowledged, MSCG and PBF hereby agree as follows: 
  

	1.	DEFINITIONS AND CONSTRUCTION 

 

	1.1	Definitions. For purposes of this Agreement, including the foregoing recitals, the following terms shall have the meanings indicated below.

 “Acceptable Letter of Credit Issuer” means a major U.S. commercial bank or a U.S. branch of a
foreign bank which, at all times: (a) (i) satisfies all regulatory capital requirements applicable to it (including any individual regulatory capital requirements); (ii) is “well capitalized” within the meaning of
Section 38 of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act, as amended, or any successor statute, and any applicable regulations thereunder; (iii) has a senior unsecured credit rating of at least “A” (or its then current equivalent) by
Standard & Poor’s Ratings Service (or any successor rating agency thereto) and at least “A2” (or its then current equivalent) by Moody’s Investors Service, Inc. (or any successor rating agency thereto); and
(iv) meets the applicable criteria of the demanding Party for letter of credit issuers as in effect at such time, including credit, legal and risk management criteria; or (b) is otherwise acceptable to the demanding Party in its sole
discretion. 

  
 1 

 “Additional Termination Event” means any of the events or circumstances
specified as such in Section 18.3. 
 “Adjustment Amount” has the meaning specified in Section 8.2.5.

 “Affected Party” has the meaning specified in Section 18.3. 

“Affiliate” means, in relation to either Party, any entity controlled, directly or indirectly, by such Party, any entity
that controls, directly or indirectly, such Party, or any entity directly or indirectly under common control with such Party. For this purpose, “control” of any entity or Party means ownership of a majority of the issued shares, or voting
power or control in fact, of the entity or Party. For purposes of this Agreement, the term “Affiliate” does not include Morgan Stanley Derivative Products Inc. 
 “Agreement” or “this Agreement” means this Amended and Restated Crude Oil Acquisition Agreement and all Schedules hereto, which are incorporated herein, as may be
amended, modified or supplemented from time to time in accordance with the terms hereof. 
 “Ancillary Costs”
means all actual direct and indirect costs and expenses associated with or arising from the acquisition, storage, receipt, delivery, handling, loading, discharge, and movement of Crude Oil to the Delivery Locations, and all Taxes and charges imposed
by any Governmental Authority. For the avoidance of doubt, Ancillary Costs shall include all Logistics Impairment costs, expenses and losses. 
 “Applicable Law” means (i) any law, statute, regulation, code, ordinance, license, decision, order, writ, injunction, directive, judgment, policy, decree and any judicial or
administrative interpretations thereof, (ii) any agreement, concession or arrangement with any Governmental Authority or (iii) any license, permit or compliance requirement, including under any Environmental Law, in each case as may be
applicable to either Party or either Party’s performance under this Agreement. 
 “Assignment” has the
meaning specified in the preamble hereto. 
 “Assumption Time” has the meaning specified in the Assignment.

 “Bankrupt” means, with respect to a Party, any of its Guarantors, any of its direct or indirect parent
companies or any entity issuing a letter of credit on its behalf hereunder, as the case may be, that such Party (or any of its Guarantors, any of its direct or indirect parent companies or an entity providing a letter of credit on its behalf
hereunder): (i) is dissolved (other than pursuant to a consolidation, amalgamation or merger); (ii) becomes insolvent or is unable to pay its debts or fails or admits in writing its inability generally to pay its debts as they become due;
(iii) makes a general assignment, arrangement or composition with or for the benefit of its creditors; (iv) institutes or has instituted against it a proceeding seeking a judgment of insolvency or bankruptcy or any other relief under any
bankruptcy or insolvency law or other similar law affecting creditors’ rights, or a petition is presented for its winding-up or liquidation; (v) has a resolution passed for its winding-up, official management or liquidation, other than
pursuant to a consolidation, 

  
 2 

 
amalgamation or merger; (vi) seeks or becomes subject to the appointment of an administrator, provisional liquidator, conservator, receiver, trustee, custodian or other similar official for
all or substantially all of its assets; (vii) has a secured party take possession of all or substantially all of its assets, or has a distress, execution, attachment, sequestration or other legal process levied, enforced or sued on or against
all or substantially all of its assets; (viii) files an answer or other pleading admitting or failing to contest the allegations of a petition filed against it in any proceeding of the foregoing nature; (ix) causes or is subject to any
event with respect to it which, under Applicable Law, has an analogous effect to any of the events specified in clauses (i) to (viii) (inclusive); or (x) takes any action in furtherance of, or indicating its consent to, approval of,
or acquiescence in, any of the foregoing acts. 
 “Bankruptcy Code” means the United States Bankruptcy Code, 11
U.S.C. §§ 101 et. seq. 
 “Barrel” means 42 U.S. Gallons measured at a temperature of 60
degrees Fahrenheit and an absolute pressure of 29.921 inches of mercury. 
 “Base Interest Rate” means the
lesser of [REDACTED] and the maximum rate of interest permitted by Applicable Law. 
 “Breakage Costs” means,
without duplication, all out-of-pocket losses, damages and expenses reasonably and necessarily incurred by the Performing Party as a result of termination and liquidation of this Agreement, any Supply Contract (excluding any supply contracts
assigned from TRC to MSCG in February 2011) and any Specified Agreement, in each case including reasonable attorneys’ fees, court costs, collection costs, interest charges and other disbursements, and any costs incurred in a reasonable
commercial manner in obtaining, maintaining, replacing or liquidating commercially reasonable hedges or trading positions relating to (i) the volumes of Crude Oil for which MSCG has incurred forward purchase or sale obligations or forward price
risks in contemplation of fulfilling its objectives under this Agreement, or (ii) any Specified Agreement that is being terminated and liquidated. 
 “Business Day” means a day on which banks are open for general commercial business in New York, New York. 
 “Change of Control” means, as to PBF or either of its Guarantors, the occurrence of, or the taking of any corporate action to facilitate, any of the following: 

 

	 	(i)	the consolidation of PBF or either of its Guarantors with another person, the merger of PBF or either of its Guarantor into another person, the merger of another person
into PBF or either of its Guarantors, or any similar event pursuant to a transaction in which 50% or more of the voting shares of PBF or either of its Guarantors (other than sales of PBF Energy stock on a public exchange whereby no single party
acquires 50% or more of the stock) are changed into or exchanged for cash, securities or other property (other than any such transaction where the holders of the voting shares of PBF or either of its Guarantors immediately prior to such transaction
own, directly or indirectly, not less than a majority of the voting shares of the surviving or resulting person or persons immediately after such transaction); or 

  
 3 

	 	(ii)	the consummation of any transaction or series of related transactions (including any merger or consolidation) the result of which is that any person other than PBF or
either of its Guarantors becomes the beneficial owner directly or indirectly, of more than 50% of the voting shares of PBF or either of its Guarantors; 

 provided, however, that an initial public offering shall not constitute a Change of Control. 
 For purposes of this definition, any transfer of an equity interest in a person that was formed for the purpose of acquiring voting shares of a person shall be deemed to be a transfer of such portion of
such voting shares as corresponds to the portion of the equity of such person that has been so transferred. 
 “Change
of Law” means, on or after the Effective Date of this Agreement, any Applicable Law is adopted or changed or any court, tribunal or regulatory authority with competent jurisdiction changes its interpretation of any Applicable Law.

 “Commencement Date” means June 1, 2011. 

“Consumption Month” has the meaning specified in Section 8.2.1. 

“Counterparty” means any person from whom MSCG purchases Crude Oil for delivery to a Delivery Location and sale to PBF,
including any person that sells Crude Oil under a Supply Contract. 
 Credit Agreement” means (i) any present
or future material agreement or undertaking by TRC, PBF or PBF Energy for financing Refinery operations, (ii) any present or future material extension of credit, credit facility, guaranty, loan or indenture to or for TRC, PBF or PBF Energy,
(iii) any material obligation of TRC, PBF or PBF Energy (whether present or future, contingent or otherwise, as principal or surety or otherwise) in respect of borrowed money, or any guaranty of TRC’s, PBF’s or PBF Energy’s
obligations, with any bank, financial or lending institution, bond or note issuer, indenture trustee, guarantor, underwriter, Affiliate or any other person, including the Revolving Credit Agreement. 

“Credit Event Upon Merger” means a Party or any of its Guarantors consolidates or amalgamates with, merges with or into,
or transfers all or substantially all its assets to, another entity and, at the time of such consolidation, amalgamation, merger or transfer, (i) the resulting, surviving or transferee entity fails to assume all the obligations of such Party
under this Agreement or any Specified Agreement, either by operation of law or by an agreement satisfactory to the other Party or otherwise, or (ii) in the reasonable opinion of the other Party, the creditworthiness of the successor, surviving
or transferee entity, is materially weaker than the predecessor entity immediately prior to the consolidation, amalgamation, merger or transfer. 
 “Crude Oil” means crude oil, feedstock (excluding vacuum gas oils, also referred to as VGOs) and lube extracted feedstock (also referred to as LEF). 

“Daily Purchase Payment Amount” has the meaning specified in Section 8.1. 

“Daily Report of Refinery Volumes” has the meaning specified in Section 5.8. 

  
 4 

 “DCRC” means Delaware City Refining Company LLC. 

“DCRC Offtake Agreement” means the offtake agreement between MSCG and DCRC dated as of April 7, 2011 relating to
MSCG’s purchase from DCRC of refined petroleum products produced in DCRC’s Delaware City, Delaware refinery. 

“Default” means any of the events or circumstances specified as such in Section 18.2. 

“Default Interest Rate” means the lesser of (i) the Prime Rate as published under “Money Rates” in the
Wall Street Journal in effect at the close of the Business Day on which the payment was due plus [REDACTED]%, and (ii) the maximum rate of interest permitted by Applicable Law. 

“Defaulting Party” has the meaning specified in Section 18.4. 

“Delivered Volumes” has the meaning specified in Section 8.1. 

“Delivery Date” means any day on which Crude Oil is delivered by MSCG to PBF at a Delivery Location and purchased by PBF
at the Transfer Point. 
 “Delivery Month” has the meaning specified in Section 5.3. 

“Designated Executive” means the Chief Executive Officer, Chief Financial Officer, President, Secretary (or other senior
officer of a Party that is acceptable to the other Party) that is authorized to execute and deliver on such Party’s behalf the certificates required by Section 3. 
 “Early Termination Date” has the meaning specified in Section 18.4.4. 
 “Early Termination Fee” means the amount payable by one Party to the other Party in connection with the early termination of this Agreement in the amount specified in Section 18.5.

 “Effective Date” means, assuming the due execution of this Agreement by each Party’s authorized
representative, the date first written above, upon which this Agreement shall become binding upon and enforceable against the Parties. 
 “Enbridge North Dakota Line” means the gathering and transportation pipeline for Crude Oil from established receiving points in the areas of Montana and North Dakota to established
destination points in Minnesota, Montana and North Dakota for the onward movement to interstate destinations, which is owned and operated by Enbridge Energy Partners, L.P. 
 “Environmental Law” means any existing or past law, policy, judicial or administrative interpretation thereof or any legally binding requirement that governs or purports to govern the
protection of persons, natural resources or the environment (including the protection of ambient air, surface water, groundwater, land surface or subsurface strata, endangered species or wetlands), occupational health and safety and the manufacture,
processing, distribution, use, generation, handling, treatment, storage, disposal, transportation, release or management of solid waste, industrial waste or hazardous substances or materials. 

  
 5 

 “EPT” means Eastern Prevailing Time. 

“Event of Default” means any of the events or circumstances specified as such in Section 18.2. 

“Financial Officer” of any person shall mean the Chief Financial Officer, principal accounting officer, Treasurer or
Controller of such person. 
 “Force Majeure Event” means any cause or event reasonably beyond the control of a
Party, including fires, earthquakes, lightning, floods, explosions, storms, adverse weather, landslides and other acts of natural calamity or acts of God; navigational accidents or maritime peril; vessel damage or loss; strikes, grievances, actions
by or among workers or lock-outs, whether or not such labor difficulty could be settled by acceding to any demands of any such labor group of individuals; accidents at, closing of, or restrictions upon the use of mooring facilities, docks, ports,
pipelines, harbors, railroads or other navigational or transportation mechanisms; disruption or breakdown of or explosions or accidents to wells, storage plants, refineries, terminals, machinery or other facilities; acts of war, hostilities (whether
declared or undeclared), civil commotion, embargoes, blockades, terrorism, sabotage or acts of the public enemy; any act or omission of any Governmental Authority; good faith compliance with any order, request or directive of any Governmental
Authority; curtailment, interference, failure or cessation of supplies reasonably beyond the control of a Party; or any other cause reasonably beyond the control of a Party, whether similar or dissimilar to those above and whether foreseeable or
unforeseeable, which, by the exercise of due diligence, such Party could not have been able to avoid or overcome. 
 For
purposes of this Agreement, the failure of any Counterparty to perform its obligations to deliver Crude Oil to MSCG pursuant to any Supply Contract, whether as a result of a Force Majeure Event (as defined herein), breach of contract by such
Counterparty or any other reason beyond the reasonable control of MSCG or that cannot be mitigated by MSCG through reasonable commercial efforts, shall constitute a Force Majeure Event as to MSCG with respect to MSCG’s obligation to sell such
Crude Oil to PBF. 
 For purposes of this Agreement, the term “Force Majeure” expressly excludes: 

 

	 	(i)	a failure of performance of any person other than the Parties (except to the extent that such failure otherwise would constitute a Force Majeure Event but for this
exclusion); 

  

	 	(ii)	the loss of a Party’s market or any market conditions for any products produced at the Refinery or any market conditions that are unfavorable for either Party;

  

	 	(iii)	any failure by a Party to apply for, obtain or maintain any permit, license, approval or right of way necessary under Applicable Law for the performance of any
obligation under this Agreement; and 

  

	 	(iv)	a Party’s inability to economically perform its obligations under any transaction undertaken pursuant to this Agreement. 

“GAAP” shall mean generally accepted accounting principles in the United States applied on a consistent basis.

  
 6 

 “Governmental Authority” means any federal, state or local governmental
body, agency, instrumentality, authority or entity established or controlled by a government or subdivision thereof, including any legislative, administrative or judicial body or any person purporting to act therefor, port authority and any stock or
commodity exchange or similar self-regulatory body or supervisory authority having appropriate jurisdiction. 

“Guarantor” means, with respect to MSCG, Morgan Stanley, and with respect to PBF, each of PBF Energy and TRC.

 “Guaranty” means (i) the guaranty by MSCG’s Guarantor of MSCG’s prompt and complete payment
of obligations under this Agreement, and (ii) each of the guaranties by PBF’s Guarantors of PBF’s prompt and complete payment of obligations under this Agreement. 

“Independent Inspector” means a licensed person acceptable to both Parties that performs sampling, quality analysis and
quantity determinations of the Crude Oil purchased by a Party under this Agreement. 
 “Initial Nomination” has
the meaning specified in Section 5.3. 
 “Initial Term” has the meaning specified in Section 2.1.

 “Intercreditor Agreement” means the intercreditor agreement entered into as of March 1, 2012 among
MSCG, UBS AF, Stamford Branch as Revolving Agent and PBF. 
 “Letter of Credit Default” means the occurrence of
any of the following events as to any outstanding letter of credit: (i) the Acceptable Letter of Credit Issuer no longer meets any of the criteria of an “Acceptable Letter of Credit Issuer” as defined in this Agreement; (ii) the
Acceptable Letter of Credit Issuer fails to comply with or perform its obligations under such letter of credit; (iii) the Acceptable Letter of Credit Issuer disaffirms, disclaims, repudiates or rejects, in whole or in part, or challenges the
validity of, such letter of credit; (iv) the letter of credit expires or terminates, or fails or ceases to be in full force and effect at any time during any period when the demanding Party requires that the other Party maintain the letter of
credit; (v) the Party providing the letter of credit as Security fails to cause a renewal or replacement letter of credit to be delivered to the demanding Party at least 15 Business Days (or by such other date required by the demanding Party)
prior to the expiration of such letter of credit; or (vi) the Acceptable Letter of Credit Issuer becomes or is Bankrupt. 

“Liabilities” means any and all claims, demands, suits, losses, expenses (including reasonable attorneys’ fees),
damages, charges, fines, penalties, deficiencies, assessments, interest, fines, costs and expenses of any kind (including reasonable attorneys’ fees and other fees, court costs and other disbursements), causes of action and liabilities of every
type and character, including personal injury or death to any person or loss or damage to any personal or real property, any Liabilities directly or indirectly arising out of or related to any suit, proceeding, judgment, settlement or judicial or
administrative order and any Liabilities with respect to Environmental Laws. 
 “LIBOR” means, as of the date
of any determination, the London Interbank Offered Rate for one-month U.S. dollar deposits appearing on Page 3750 of the Telerate screen (or any successor page) at approximately 11:00 a.m. (London time). If such rate does not appear

  
 7 

 
on Page 3750 of the Telerate screen (or otherwise on such screen), LIBOR shall be determined by reference to such other comparable publicly available service for displaying eurodollar rates as
MSCG may select or, in the absence of such availability, by reference to the rate at which MSCG is offered one-month U.S. dollar deposits at or about 11:00 a.m. (London time) in any interbank eurodollar market where its eurodollar and foreign
currency and exchange operations are then being conducted. LIBOR shall be established on the first day on which a determination of the interest rate is to be made under this Agreement and shall be adjusted daily based on the one-month LIBOR quotes
made available through the foregoing sources. 
 “Lien” means any lien, security interest, pledge, mortgage,
claim, charge or other encumbrance of any nature whatsoever that secures any obligation of any person or any other agreement or arrangement having a similar effect. 
 “Logistics Impairment” has the meaning specified in Section 5.5. 
 “Material Adverse Change” means, (i) as to PBF or either of its Guarantors, any condition, circumstance, event, change or effect or combination thereof that individually or in the
aggregate has or reasonably could be expected to have or result in (A) a material adverse change in, or a material adverse effect upon, PBF’s or either of its Guarantors’ operations, business, properties, condition (financial or
otherwise) or prospects taken as a whole, for which MSCG has reasonable grounds for insecurity under this Agreement; (B) a material impairment of the ability of PBF to perform any of its obligations under any of the Transaction Documents or any
Specified Agreement or of either of its Guarantors to perform any of its obligations under its Guaranty, or (C) a material adverse effect upon the legality, validity, binding effect or enforceability against PBF of any of the Transaction
Documents or any Specified Agreement or against either of its Guarantors of its respective Guaranty, or upon any rights or remedies against such Party under any of the Transaction Documents, Specified Agreement or relevant Guaranty, as the case may
be, and (ii) as to MSCG, [REDACTED]. 
 “Monthly Amendment” has the meaning specified in Section 5.3.

 “MSCG Acquisition Report” has the meaning specified in Section 5.6. 

“MSCG In-Transit Volumes” means, from time to time, any Crude Oil that MSCG purchased from third parties and is
in-transit to a Delivery Location, wherever located, including while within a Pipeline, in storage tanks and including any line fill, tank bottoms and working inventories. 
 “Net Daily Payment Amount” has the meaning specified in Section 9.1. 
 “Nominated Volume” has the meaning specified in Section 5.3. 

  
 8 

 “Nomination and Forecast Report” (or “NFR”) has the
meaning specified in Section 5.3. 
 “Non-Performing Party” means either the Affected Party or the
Defaulting Party. 
 “NYMEX” means the New York Mercantile Exchange. 

“NYMEX Trading Day” means each day on which NYMEX is scheduled to be open for trading and on which it is actually open
for trading during the hours it is so scheduled to be open; provided that where used as the basis of a forward-looking determination, “NYMEX Trading Day” means each day on which NYMEX is scheduled to be open for trading. 

“Original Agreement” has the meaning specified in the preamble hereto. 

“Payment Amount Invoice” has the meaning specified in Section 9.1. 

“Payment Date” means, with respect to each Delivered Volume, the Business Day following the applicable Pricing Date.

 “PBF Energy” means PBF Energy Inc. 
 “Performing Party” has the meaning specified in Section 18.4. 
 “Pipelines” means, collectively, each of the pipelines listed in Schedule 1, as such schedule may be amended from time to time upon the agreement of the Parties, and
“Pipeline” means any one of these. 
 “Potential Event of Default” means any Event of Default,
which with notice or the passage of time, would constitute an Event of Default. 
 “PRC” means Paulsboro
Refining Company LLC, a subsidiary of PBF, and a limited liability company organized under the laws of the State of Delaware. 

“Price” means the price per barrel of Crude Oil determined in accordance with Schedule 5. 

“Pricing Date” means, with respect to the volume of Crude Oil delivered on a Delivery Date at a Delivery Location, the
day specified in Schedule 2, as such schedule may be amended from time to time upon the agreement of the Parties. 

“Quarterly Forward Price Report” has the meaning specified in Section 5.2. 

“Refinery” means the crude oil refinery owned and operated by TRC and located in Toledo, Ohio. 

“Refinery Volumes” has the meaning specified in Section 5.8. 

“Renewal Term” has the meaning specified in Section 2.2. 

“Representatives” means a Party’s or any of its Affiliates’ directors, officers, employees, auditors,
consultants, banks, financial advisors and legal advisors. 

  
 9 

 “Revolving Credit Agreement” means that certain Amended and Restated
Revolving Credit Agreement dated on or about May 31, 2011, among TRC, PBF, DCRC and PRC as borrowers, and the guarantors and lenders party thereto. 
 “Run-off Period” has the meaning specified in Section 11.1. 

“Security” has the meaning specified in Section 12.6.3. 

“Specified Agreement” means any agreement between the Parties to purchase, sell or exchange commodities, including any
spot or forward contract, future, option, swap, swap option, cap, floor or collar or other derivative transaction on or with respect to a commodity or any combination of these transactions. 

“Specified Indebtedness” means any obligation (whether present or future, contingent or otherwise, as principal or
surety or otherwise) of PBF or any Affiliate of PBF in respect of borrowed money. 
 “Sunoco” means Sunoco,
Inc. (R&M). 
 “Supply Contract” means a contract between MSCG and a Counterparty for the purchase of Crude
Oil by MSCG for the purpose of meeting MSCG’s delivery obligations to PBF under this Agreement, including any Crude Oil purchase contract assigned from TRC to MSCG. 
 “Taxes” means any and all U.S., Canadian and foreign federal, provincial, state and local taxes, import and export customs duties, imposts, duty fees and charges of every description,
including all excise, goods and services, severance, production, carbon, environmental, oil spill (including for avoidance of doubt the U.S. federal oil spill tax), gross receipts, commercial activity, and sales and use taxes, however designated,
paid or incurred with respect to the purchase, storage, exchange, use, transportation, resale, importation, importation, exportation or handling of the Crude Oil or measured by the price of the Crude Oil or the proceeds of sale under this Agreement,
including for any Tax, any interest, penalties or additions to tax attributable to any such Tax or for the failure to file any tax return or report; provided, however, that the term “Taxes” does not include: (i) any tax imposed on or
measured by net profits or net income unless such tax is imposed specifically on the sale of Crude Oil; (ii) any tax measured by capital value or net worth, whether denominated as franchise taxes, doing business taxes, capital stock taxes or
the like; and (iii) business license or franchise taxes or registration fees. 
 “Term” means the Initial
Term and any Renewal Term or Renewal Terms. 
 “Termination Amount” has the meaning specified in
Section 18.8. 
 “Termination Date” has the meaning specified in Section 11.1. 

“Termination Event” means an Event of Default or an Additional Termination Event. 

“Transaction Documents” means this Agreement, the Assignment, the Supply Contracts, any assignment contracts relating to
the Pipelines between MSCG and TRC, each Guaranty, the Intercreditor Agreement, the TRC Intercreditor Agreement and any confirmations or other writings or communications that document the sales of Crude Oil from MSCG to PBF. 

  
 10 

 “Transfer Points” means the locations specified in Schedule 2 hereto.

 “TRC Intercreditor Agreement” means the intercreditor agreement entered into as of May 31, 2011 among
MSCG, UBS AF, Stamford Branch as Revolving Agent and TRC. 
 “UCC” means the Uniform Commercial Code as in
effect from time to time in the State of New York. 
 “Unpaid Amounts” means any amounts owed by one Party to
another Party under this Agreement that have not been paid as of the date of determination. 
 “Weekly
Nomination” has the meaning specified in Section 5.4. 
 “Working Capital Rate” has the meaning
specified in Section 8.2.5.2. 
 “WTI” means light sweet U.S. domestic crude oil (West Texas Intermediate)
deliverable in satisfaction of futures contract delivery obligations under the rules of NYMEX. 
 “WTI Differential
Report” has the meaning specified in Section 8.2.1. 
 “WTI Hedge Volume” has the meaning
specified in Section 8.2.1. 
  

	1.2	Interpretation. Unless the context otherwise requires or except where specifically stated otherwise, in this Agreement: 

 

	 	1.2.1	words using the singular or plural number also include the plural or singular number, respectively; 

 

	 	1.2.2	references to any Party shall be construed as a reference to such Party’s successors in interest and permitted assigns; 

 

	 	1.2.3	references to a provision of Applicable Law or Applicable Laws generally are references to that provision or Applicable Laws generally, as may be amended, extended or
re-enacted from time to time; 

  

	 	1.2.4	references to “days,” “months” and “years” mean calendar days, months and years, respectively, and a
“day” consists of the 24-hour period commencing at 12:00:00 a.m. EPT and ending on 11:59:59 EPT on that day; 

  

	 	1.2.5	references to “dollars” or “$”mean U.S. dollars; 

 

	 	1.2.6	references to “Sections” and “Schedules” in this Agreement, or to a provision contained therein, shall be construed as references to
the Sections and Schedules of this Agreement, as may be amended, modified or supplemented from time to time in accordance with the terms hereof. References to any other agreement, or other document or to a provision contained in any of these, shall
be construed, at the particular time, as a reference to it as it may then have been amended, supplemented, modified, suspended, assigned or novated in accordance with its terms; 

  
 11 

	 	1.2.7	references to “assets” include present and future properties, revenues and rights of every description; 

 

	 	1.2.8	references herein to “consent” mean, unless otherwise specified, the prior written consent of the Party at issue, which shall not be unreasonably
withheld, delayed or conditioned; 

  

	 	1.2.9	the terms “hereof,” “herein,” “hereby,” “hereto” and similar words refer to this entire Agreement
and not any particular Section, subsection, Schedule or subdivision of this Agreement; 

  

	 	1.2.10	the words “include” or “including” shall be deemed to be followed by “without limitation” or “but not limited
to” whether or not they are followed by such phrases or words of like import; 

  

	 	1.2.11	the word “or” is meant to be inclusive and shall be interpreted as “and/or”; 

 

	 	1.2.12	references to a “judgment” include any order, injunction, determination, award or other judicial or arbitral measure in any jurisdiction;

  

	 	1.2.13	references to “obligations” shall be construed to mean a Party’s prompt and complete performance of its covenants and obligations required
pursuant to this Agreement; and 

  

	 	1.2.14	references to any “person” include any natural person, corporation, partnership, limited liability company, joint venture, trust or unincorporated
organization, estate, association, partnership, statutory body, joint stock company or any other private entity or organization, Governmental Authority, court or any other legal entity, whether acting in an individual, fiduciary or other capacity.

  

	1.3	If there is any ambiguity, inconsistency, discrepancy or conflict between this Agreement and any other Transaction Document, this Agreement shall prevail.

  

	1.4	Unless otherwise specified, in computing any period of time under this Agreement the day of the act, event or default from which such period begins to run shall be day
“zero” and not included. If the last day of the period so computed is not a Business Day then, unless this Agreement provides otherwise, the period shall run until the end of the next Business Day. 

 

	1.5	The provisions of this Agreement shall be construed in accordance with the natural meanings of its terms, and the contra proferentum rule shall not apply to the
construction or interpretation of this Agreement. 

  

	2.	EFFECTIVE DATE AND TERM 

 

	2.1	Initial Term. This Agreement shall be in effect on the Effective Date and shall continue in effect through the earlier of (i) second anniversary of the
“Commercial Operations Date” under the DCRC Offtake Agreement and (ii) June 30, 2013 (in either case, the “Initial Term”). 

  
 12 

	2.2	Renewal Term. From and after expiration of the Initial Term, this Agreement shall automatically renew for successive one-year terms (each such renewal period, a
“Renewal Term”). Absent an Event of Default or Additional Termination Event that results in an Early Termination Date, this Agreement shall terminate one year following written notice delivered no sooner than one year prior to
expiration of the Initial Term or at any time thereafter by one Party to the other Party; provided, however, that the Parties shall perform their obligations relating to termination pursuant to Section 11. 

 

	3.	CONDITIONS PRECEDENT 

  

	3.1	The obligations of the Parties under this amended and restated Agreement shall commence at the Assumption Time under the Assignment and shall be conditional upon the
satisfaction or waiver of the Conditions Precedent (as defined in the Assignment) in accordance with the terms of the Assignment. 

  

	4.	DAILY SALES OF CRUDE OIL 

 

	4.1	MSCG Crude Oil Sales. From and after the Assumption Time on the Assignment Date, upon the terms and conditions set forth herein, MSCG agrees to sell and deliver
to PBF, and PBF agrees to purchase and take delivery of, the Crude Oil requirements of PBF. MSCG shall sell the Crude Oil to PBF at the Delivery Locations in ratable deemed volumes as PBF may request pursuant to the nomination procedures set forth
in Section 5, subject to the provisions of Section 4.1.1. 

  

	 	4.1.1	Conditions to Sale Obligations. MSCG’s Crude Oil sale obligations are subject to: (i) the volume of Crude Oil requirements estimated by PBF, as set
forth in the relevant NFR, as may be modified by any subsequent NFR or Weekly Nomination from time to time and with allowance for variation as described in Section 5.5; (ii) available pipeline capacity on the relevant Pipelines used to
transport the Crude Oil to the Delivery Locations, provided that MSCG shall make commercially reasonable efforts to secure capacity as necessary to meet its delivery obligations hereunder; (iii) a Force Majeure Event (including delivery of the
Crude Oil by a Counterparty); (iv) PBF providing MSCG with any Security required hereunder; (v) the absence of a default under one or more Supply Contracts that collectively have a material adverse effect on MSCG’s ability to procure
Crude Oil for delivery and sale to PBF; and (vi) PBF’s performance of its obligations hereunder and under each of the other Transaction Documents. 

 

	4.2	 Pipeline Buy/Sell Transactions. If any of the Pipelines on which MSCG ships Crude Oil to the Delivery Locations refuses to recognize MSCG’s
title to the Crude Oil, the Parties shall enter into a buy/sell agreement under which MSCG will sell all volumes of Crude Oil that it desires to ship on such Pipeline to PBF as they pass the inlet flange of the Pipeline or its gathering system and
MSCG will purchase from PBF such volumes of Crude Oil as they pass the exit flange of such Pipeline or its gathering system. The Parties will mutually agree upon the price for such sales, provided that the price for each sale from MSCG to PBF will
equal the price for the corresponding sale from PBF to MSCG. If MSCG pays the transportation costs to the relevant Pipeline, the costs of shipping the relevant volumes on the Pipeline will be deducted from the price paid by MSCG for MSCG’s
purchase from PBF. Any amounts payable in connection with a Pipeline buy/sell agreement will be included on the next Payment Amount Invoice delivered after MSCG’s determination of such amount. TRC and MSCG previously

  
 13 

 
entered into a Pipeline buy/sell agreement on the Enbridge North Dakota Line at the prices and terms set forth in Schedule 9 hereto, and TRC has assigned this agreement to PBF under the terms of
the Assignment. 
  

	4.3	Exclusive Seller. PBF agrees that it shall procure all of the Refinery’s Crude Oil requirements, as well as any other Crude Oil Requirements of PBF, by
purchasing Crude Oil from MSCG and MSCG shall be its exclusive seller of Crude Oil to be processed in the Refinery or delivered to third parties during the Term of this Agreement. The Parties acknowledge and agree that TRC is solely a processor and
shall not purchase Crude Oil for processing in the Refinery. PBF agrees not to purchase Crude Oil from any person other than MSCG unless otherwise agreed in writing by MSCG or unless an Event of Default as described in Section 18.2.5 has
occurred with respect to MSCG, and in any case, non-exclusivity shall only apply to affected Crude Oil volumes. 

  

	4.4	MSCG Hedging Obligations. MSCG shall enter into hedge transactions to hedge the price risk incurred by PBF related to the mismatch between each Delivered Volume
priced on its respective Pricing Date and the actual volume consumed at the Refinery or sold to a third party as of such Pricing Date as set forth in the Daily Report of Refinery Volumes. The profits and losses on such hedging activities shall be
determined in accordance with Schedule 10 and shall be payable by one Party to the other Party pursuant to Section 8.3. 

  

	4.5	Title and Custody. 

  

	 	4.5.1	Transfer of Title. Title to Crude Oil purchased by PBF pursuant to the terms of this Agreement shall pass from MSCG to PBF as the Crude Oil passes the relevant
Transfer Point. 

  

	 	4.5.2	Ownership. MSCG shall own and have title to all of the Crude Oil in transit to the Transfer Locations until title to such Crude Oil passes from MSCG to PBF as
described in Section 4.5.1, or until MSCG otherwise disposes of such Crude Oil. PBF shall own and have title to all of the Crude Oil purchased from MSCG and in transit from the Transfer Locations and all Crude Oil at the Refinery, unless and
until PBF sells such Crude Oil to a third party. 

  

	4.6	Importation into the United States and Foreign Trade Zone. 

  

	 	4.6.1	PBF intends to cause TRC to continue to operate the Refinery as a subzone, FTZ Subzone 8H (the “Subzone”), under a valid grant of authority from the
Foreign Trade Zones Board, U.S. Customs and Border Protection Service (“Customs”) and the Toledo-Lucas County Port Authority. 

  

	 	4.6.2	For purposes of being able to sell jet fuel in privileged and non-privileged foreign status to Refinery customers, TRC is required to and from time to time will admit
foreign-origin Crude Oil into the Subzone. Accordingly, PBF may request that MSCG transport the Crude Oil in bond pursuant to Customs’ procedures from the point of importation at the U.S. port of entry into the United States to the Delivery
Location so as to preserve the foreign status of the Crude Oil. 

  

	 	4.6.2.1	 In such event, and provided that PBF or its designed representative provides MSCG with sufficient notice in writing, prior to the time of

  
 14 

	 	
importation, that foreign status is to be maintained as to a particular batch or shipment of Crude Oil, MSCG agrees to be responsible for and file all necessary Customs in-bond documentation (CBP
Form 7512) and secure in-bond movement under MSCG’s carrier bond. MSCG agrees to provide PBF with copies of the Forms 7512 filed with Customs promptly after the date of importation, which PBF will provide to TRC so that TRC is able to prepare
all necessary Customs documentation (including CBP Form 214) to admit the Crude Oil into the Subzone. 

  

	 	4.6.2.2	PBF shall cause TRC to prepare, maintain and file all necessary documentation in connection with operation of the Subzone and admission of foreign-status Crude Oil. PBF
shall cause TRC to maintain all records, inventories and accounts of operations within the Subzone in accordance with Applicable Law and the requirements of Customs and any other Governmental Authority. PBF agrees to provide MSCG with copies of the
Forms 214 filed with Customs promptly after the date of admission into the Subzone. 

  

	 	4.6.2.3	PBF shall indemnify and hold MSCG harmless from and against all Customs duties, penalties, fines and other expenses or damages that MSCG may incur resulting from
TRC’s failure to comply with Applicable Laws regarding entry of Crude Oil into the Subzone, including the failure to file accurate and timely Forms 214 that will extinguish MSCG’s liability for Customs duties under its in-bond
shipments. 

  

	5.	DELIVERY NOMINATIONS AND REPORTING 

 

	5.1	Coordination, Planning and Information Flow Procedures. The Parties intend that MSCG shall utilize its global crude oil and feedstock trading and marketing
capabilities to identify and present to PBF opportunities for the purchase from MSCG of U.S. domestic, Canadian and foreign Crude Oil. The Parties shall develop procedures for the exchange of information between PBF and MSCG throughout the Term to
facilitate sales to PBF and optimization of the Refinery operations. Such procedures will include meetings (whether in person or by telephone or video conference) on an as required basis and a monthly meeting in person between PBF personnel and MSCG
to, amongst other things, review the then current TRC maintenance activities, present information relating to Crude Oil slates available for delivery to the Delivery Locations, refinery run plans and related commercial matters including hedging,
sale and resale opportunities. Based on the planning and coordination activities described in this Section 5.1 and PBF’s nominations delivered in accordance with this Section 5, MSCG will use commercially reasonable efforts to locate
and select Crude Oil meeting PBF’s requirements, determine price estimates for such Crude Oil and negotiate, purchase and transport such Crude Oil to the Delivery Locations for sale to PBF. PBF will use commercially reasonable efforts to
cooperate with MSCG in the foregoing activities and to take delivery of the Crude Oil’s selected in accordance with the schedules agreed upon by the Parties. 

 

	5.2	 Quarterly Forward Price Report. On or prior to the last Business Day of each week, MSCG shall provide PBF with a report of MSCG’s estimated
forward prices for each relevant grade of Crude Oil for the following five calendar months and any other period requested (the “Quarterly Forward Price Report”). The information in the Quarterly

  
 15 

	 	
Forward Price Report is being provided for the Parties’ informational and planning purposes only; MSCG is not acting as a financial advisor or fiduciary or in any similar capacity and MSCG
is not giving PBF any assurance or guarantee as to the forward prices contained in the Quarterly Forward Price Report. 

  

	5.3	 Nomination and Forecast Report. Prior to the 20th of every month, the Parties shall consult regarding the Crude Oil available to MSCG for delivery to the Delivery
Locations and the amount of Crude Oil sales at the Delivery Locations required to meet the Refinery’s Crude Oil processing requirements and PBF’s sales to third parties for the following five calendar months, and PBF shall provide MSCG
with a report (the “Nomination and Forecast Report” or “NFR”), substantially in the form attached hereto in Schedule 3, that indicates PBF’s entire Crude Oil requirements for sale by MSCG and purchase by PBF
for the following five months (each such month, a “Delivery Month”). The NFR shall include any periods of TRC-scheduled Refinery maintenance and turnaround. 

 

	    	With respect to the fourth and fifth month following the month in which each NFR is delivered, the NFR shall be non-binding and indicative in nature and prepared solely
for the Parties’ planning purposes. 

  

	    	With respect to the third month following the month in which each NFR is delivered, the NFR shall specify the volumes of each grade of Crude Oil for delivery and
purchase by PBF on each day (for each day in such month, the “Nominated Volume”) at each Delivery Location during such third following month and shall constitute the initial formal nomination (the “Initial
Nomination”) for volumes to be delivered in such third following month. The Initial Nomination shall be binding, but shall be subject to amendment or adjustment as described in Section 5.5. 

 

	    	With respect to the first and second month following the month in which each NFR is delivered, the NFR shall update the previously delivered NFR containing the Initial
Nomination for the first following month and shall update the previously delivered NFR containing the Initial Nomination for the second following month, and in each case shall constitute an amendment (a “Monthly Amendment”) to the
respective Initial Nomination as further described in Section 5.5. 

  

	    	 By way of example, the NFR delivery prior to the 20th of February would (i) indicate estimated volumes of each grade of Crude Oil for delivery in June and July,
(ii) specify Nominated Volumes (by grade) for delivery each day in May (and shall constitute the Initial Nomination for May) and (iii) request adjustments to the Initial Nomination (which was delivered in January for April and in December
for March) for March and April. 

  

	    	PBF shall notify MSCG promptly upon becoming aware of any new circumstances that could require material changes to Nominated Volumes and MSCG shall notify PBF promptly
upon becoming aware of circumstances that could materially impact its ability to deliver Crude Oil during the period covered by the NFR. The Parties agree that the NFR shall be prepared in coordination between the Parties. 

 

	5.4	 Weekly Nomination. No later than 10:00 a.m. EPT on each Business Day, PBF shall provide to MSCG a report (the “Weekly
Nomination”), substantially in the form attached hereto in Schedule 4, specifying the best estimate of PBF’s Crude Oil 

  
 16 

	 	
requirements and specifying the Nominated Volumes of Crude Oil for delivery at each Delivery Location on each of the following seven calendar days. The Parties agree that the Weekly Nomination
shall be prepared in coordination between the Parties. The Parties acknowledge that PBF bears sole responsibility for the preparation, accuracy and correctness of the Weekly Nomination and notification of any changes to any Weekly Nomination that it
would like to request. 

  

	5.5	Agreement to Purchase Nominated Volumes. In the absence of notification from MSCG to PBF within one Business Day of MSCG’s receipt of any Initial
Nomination, and subject to the Parties mutual agreement to certain FOB Grade Differentials as described in Section 8.2.2, the Parties shall be deemed to have agreed to the sale by MSCG to PBF of the Nominated Volumes specified in such Initial
Nomination. 

  

	    	Each Monthly Amendment and each Weekly Nomination shall constitute an amendment to the Initial Nominations covering the same Delivery Dates. Unless MSCG notifies PBF
within one Business Day of its objection to any new information contained in any Monthly Amendment or Weekly Nomination, the Parties shall be deemed to have agreed to the sale by MSCG to PBF of the Nominated Volumes specified therein, subject to
pricing adjustments as set forth in Section 8.2.5.1. MSCG agrees to cooperate in the adjustment of previously agreed upon Nominated Volumes at the request of PBF to the extent the flexibility for a corresponding adjustment is allowed under the
terms of any relevant Supply Contracts or may be maintained in inventory or another commercially reasonable disposition or acquisition can be agreed upon. 

  

	    	Notwithstanding the above, the Parties acknowledge operational variability and agree that reasonable variations from the specified Nominated Volumes resulting from
ordinary course operational factors shall not constitute a breach of this Agreement; provided that PBF agrees to make a good faith effort to take delivery of Crude Oil in the volumes set forth in each NFR and Weekly Nomination in accordance with the
schedules set forth therein and MSCG agrees to exercise commercially reasonable efforts to accommodate such variations. 

  

	    	PBF agrees that MSCG shall have the right to substitute alternative grades of Crude Oil as long as such substitution would not have a negative economic impact on PBF,
provided that MSCG shall notify PBF in advance of any such contemplated substitution and subject to PBF’s reasonable consent to such substitutions. 

  

	    	PBF shall indemnify MSCG for any costs, expenses or other losses that MSCG incurs as a result of any amendment to an Initial Nomination requested by PBF or any other
adjustment to the Nominated Volumes (other than a substitution or other change to the Nominated Volumes requested by MSCG); provided that MSCG shall use commercially reasonable efforts to mitigate such costs, expenses or losses.

  

	    	 If, due to no fault of MSCG, MSCG is unable to, or it becomes impractical to, ship Crude Oil through a Pipeline or is unable to, or it becomes
impractical to, deliver Crude Oil to any Delivery Location because of a breakdown in or significant impairment of any logistical asset utilized in the storage and transportation of Crude Oil to such Delivery Location (each, a “Logistics
Impairment”), MSCG’s delivery obligations shall be excused to the extent affected by such Logistics Impairment and PBF shall indemnify MSCG for any losses, costs or expenses incurred as a result of such Logistics Impairment, including
for any market losses (e.g. the difference between the price at 

  
 17 

	 	
which MSCG sells any Crude Oil that it is impractical to deliver to a Delivery Location as a result of the Logistics Impairment and the Price of such Crude Oil hereunder). MSCG shall use
commercially reasonable efforts to mitigate costs, losses and expenses resulting from a Logistics Impairment. 

  

	5.6	MSCG Acquisition Report. On each Business Day, MSCG shall provide PBF with a report specifying the volumes, grades, Delivery Month and pricing information for
all Nominated Volumes for which the Parties have confirmed sales by mutually agreeing upon the price or the pricing formula, as applicable (the “MSCG Acquisition Report”). 

 

	5.7	Other Reports. Each Party shall provide the other Party with all daily tank gauging reports covering the Refinery tanks, any reports it receives from Pipelines
or any of the pipelines that PBF utilizes to ship Crude Oil from the Delivery Locations to the Refinery or other locations, and, if reasonably requested by the other Party, any other information related to the transactions covered by this Agreement.

  

	5.8	Daily Report of Refinery Volumes. On or prior to 11:00 a.m. EPT on each Business Day, PBF shall deliver to MSCG (for receipt on or prior to 11:00 a.m. EPT) a
report setting forth (i) the actual volumes of Crude Oil (the “Refinery Volumes”) delivered into and withdrawn out of each Refinery tank on the immediately prior days and total inventory levels in each Refinery tank, in each
case based on the best available information, including daily tank gauging reports and other relevant Refinery measurements, and (ii) all sales of Crude Oil to third parties (such report, the “Daily Report of Refinery
Volumes”). The Refinery Volumes shall be subject to subsequent adjustment as may be necessary to reflect any additional or more accurate measurement information. 

 

	6.	CERTAIN REPRESENTATIONS 

 

	6.1	The Parties intend that: 

  

	 	6.1.1	each purchase and sale of Crude Oil between them, whether or not further documented, shall constitute a “forward contract” under section 101(25) and a
“swap agreement” under section 101(53B) of the Bankruptcy Code, protected by, inter alia, section 556 and section 560 of the Bankruptcy Code, and that it will be treated as such under and in all proceedings related to any
bankruptcy, insolvency or similar law (regardless of the jurisdiction of application or competence of such law) or any regulation, ruling, order, directive or pronouncement made pursuant thereto; and 

 

	 	6.1.2	this Agreement and each transaction between the Parties hereunder constitutes a “master netting agreement” under section 101(38A) of the Bankruptcy
Code; and that the rights in Section 18 hereto include the rights referred to in section 561(a) of the Bankruptcy Code. 

  

	6.2	For purposes of Section 6.1, the Parties intend and agree that, in respect of a particular week during the Term, they shall be deemed to have entered into a
forward contract, swap agreement and eligible financial contract for the sale of Crude Oil by MSCG to PBF upon MSCG’s receipt of the Weekly Nomination for such calendar week. 

 

	6.3	 Single Agreement. This Agreement and all transactions hereunder form a single integrated agreement between the Parties. During the Term of this
Agreement, all 

  
 18 

	 	
transactions between MSCG and PBF as reflected in each NFR and Weekly Nomination are entered into in reliance on the fact that all such transactions and reports, together with this Agreement,
form a single agreement. 

  

	7.	WARRANTIES 

  

	7.1	Warranties of Title. 

MSCG represents and warrants to PBF, that, as of the date of delivery of Crude Oil sold hereunder, it has good and marketable title to the
Crude Oil sold and delivered pursuant to this Agreement, free and clear of any Liens, and that it has full right and authority to transfer such title and effect delivery of such Crude Oil. 

 

	7.2	Disclaimer of Warranties. EXCEPT FOR THE WARRANTY OF TITLE, THE PARTY SELLING CRUDE OIL HEREUNDER MAKES NO WARRANTY, CONDITION OR OTHER REPRESENTATION,
WRITTEN OR ORAL, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS OR SUITABILITY OF THE CRUDE OIL FOR ANY PARTICULAR PURPOSE OR OTHERWISE. 

  

	8.	PRICING OF DELIVERED VOLUMES 

 

	8.1	Pricing for Delivered Volumes. With respect to the volume of each grade of Crude Oil delivered by MSCG to PBF at the Delivery Locations and purchased by PBF on
each Delivery Date hereunder (for each such day, the “Delivered Volume”), PBF shall, on the relevant Payment Date, pay to MSCG the product of (i) the Delivered Volume and (ii) the Price for such grade determined in
accordance with Schedule 5 (the sum of such amount over all grades purchased on such Delivery Date, the “Daily Purchase Payment Amount”). The Daily Purchase Payment Amount shall be included on the Payment Amount Invoice delivered by
MSCG on the relevant Payment Date for such Delivery Date. 

  

	8.2	Pricing Differentials. 

  

	 	8.2.1	 WTI Differential Report. On the [REDACTED] day of the month two months prior to each month in which PBF intends to have TRC process Crude Oil
that it previously purchased from MSCG hereunder or sell such Crude Oil to third parties (each such month, a “Consumption Month”) (or the next Business Day if such [REDACTED] day is not a Business Day), MSCG shall prepare and
deliver to PBF a report substantially in the form of Schedule 6 (the “WTI Differential Report”). The WTI Differential Report will list the pro forma volume of [REDACTED] by contract month (the “WTI Hedge Volume”)
that would need to be purchased and sold to [REDACTED] (as described in Schedule 5 under component D of the Price formula) of [REDACTED] pricing from the [REDACTED] to the [REDACTED] for the Nominated Volumes that PBF will purchase in a Delivery
Month and later process or sell in such Consumption Month. MSCG shall prepare and deliver to PBF an updated WTI Differential Report following any agreed upon adjustment to a Nominated Volume. 

 

	 	8.2.2	 Setting WTI Differentials. The WTI Differential component of the Price (component D of the Price formula in Schedule 5) applicable to the
Nominated Volumes related to a particular Consumption Month will be established ratably 

  
 19 

 
(by WTI Hedge Volume), based on the applicable [REDACTED] effective on each [REDACTED] from (and including) the [REDACTED] of the second month preceding the Consumption Month (or the next
Business Day if applicable) to the [REDACTED] prior to the day on which the [REDACTED] expires during the month preceding the Consumption Month (the “Pricing Period”), [REDACTED] (applied only to the prices for [REDACTED] purchases)
(such pricing mechanism, the “Ratable Method”). 
  

	 	8.2.3	In lieu of the foregoing method for the determination of the WTI Differential, PBF may notify MSCG on or prior to the date of MSCG’s delivery of the WTI
Differential Report that it would like MSCG to establish fixed values for the WTI Differentials by mutual agreement. In such case, PBF shall notify MSCG on each [REDACTED] during the Pricing Period of the volume for which it wishes to establish WTI
Differential values on such day (such notification a “Fixed Value Request”), provided that if MSCG does not receive a Fixed Value Request on any [REDACTED], MSCG will not seek to establish WTI Differential values on such day. MSCG
shall make commercially reasonable efforts to fulfill each Fixed Value Request based on the then-current forward [REDACTED] for the applicable WTI Hedge Volume. The WTI Differential may be established in volumes of 100,000 Barrels up to the full
volumes listed in the Initial Nomination (as amended from time to time) relating to the Nominated Volumes that would be processed or sold during the Consumption Month. Upon establishing a WTI Differential for a particular volume to be processed or
sold in a Consumption Month pursuant to a Fixed Value Request, MSCG shall send a confirmation to PBF confirming the value of such WTI Differential, and PBF shall execute such confirmation and deliver a copy of the executed confirmation back to MSCG.
If, using commercially reasonable efforts, MSCG is unable to fulfill any Fixed Value Request with respect to a volume as of any [REDACTED] during the Pricing Period, then no WTI Differential will be set as to such volume on such day.

 MSCG shall price any portion of the [REDACTED] and otherwise in accordance with the Ratable Method; provided
that if greater than [REDACTED]% of the total WTI Hedge Volume remains unpriced as of the [REDACTED] prior to the [REDACTED] contract expiration, then MSCG will establish a WTI Differential as of the sixth [REDACTED] prior to the [REDACTED] contract
expiration with respect to any excess over [REDACTED]% of the total WTI Hedge Volume that remains unpriced. 
  

	 	8.2.4	Setting FOB Grade Differentials. The FOB Grade Differentials shall be determined using the methodology set forth in Schedule 5 (as component B of the Price
formula in Schedule 5). As described in Schedule 5, the FOB Grade Differential will be established either by a formula utilizing published prices or by mutual agreement based on then-current spot market conditions. If the Parties are unable to agree
upon an FOB Grade Differential for any volumes, then MSCG shall be deemed not to have entered into a commitment to sell, and PBF shall be deemed not to have entered into a commitment to purchase, such volumes. In this event, the Parties shall
cooperate in identifying alternative grades and volumes for sale, as outlined in Section 5.1. 

  
 20 

	 	8.2.5	Differential Adjustments. 

  

	 	8.2.5.1	Adjustments of Nominated Volumes. Following any adjustment to a Nominated Volume, MSCG shall determine, in consultation with PBF and in a commercially reasonable
manner, the difference between the WTI Differentials, FOB Grade Differentials and the Delivery Costs (components B, C and D of the Price formula in Schedule 5) that would have applied to the previously Nominated Volumes and the WTI Differentials,
FOB Grade Differentials and Delivery Costs that apply to the Nominated Volumes after any adjustments (including differences applicable to canceled or “unwound” Nominated Volumes) (the “Adjustment Amount”). MSCG shall make
a payment to PBF of any positive Adjustment Amount and PBF shall make a payment to MSCG of any negative Adjustment Amount. The Adjustment Amount shall be included on the next following Payment Amount Invoice. 

 

	 	8.2.5.2	Delivery Costs. The capital costs included in the calculation of Delivery Costs (component C of the Price formula in Schedule 5) will be calculated based on a
working capital rate (the “Working Capital Rate”) of [REDACTED]), which, as of each day, would be applied to the current market value of the MSCG In-Transit Volumes on such day and the total amount of MSCG accounts receivable owing
from PBF and associated with MSCG sales under this Agreement as of such day. Upon the occurrence of an MS CDS Event (as defined below), either Party may request on a reasonable basis an adjustment to the Working Capital Rate and the Parties shall
negotiate in good faith to determine the adjustment to the Working Capital Rate that shall apply; provided, that any request by MSCG for an increase in the Working Capital Rate after an MS CDS Event shall be effective, subject only to PBF’s
right of termination pursuant to Section 18.1.3. For purposes of the foregoing sentence, a “MS CDS Event” shall be deemed to have occurred following any calendar quarter in which the average of the daily settlement prices
(spreads) for Morgan Stanley’s five-year credit default swap on the trading platform operated by Markit Group Limited changes by more than [REDACTED] % from the previous calendar quarterly average. The price (spread) for such credit default
swap as of the Commencement Date was [REDACTED]. 

  

	8.3	Hedge Adjustment Amount. After the expiry of each front month NYMEX crude oil contract, MSCG shall determine the Hedge Adjustment Amount for such calendar month
in accordance with Schedule 10 in order to account for hedging losses and gains resulting from any mismatch between the day on which Delivered Volumes are priced hereunder and the day on which Delivered Volumes enter the Refinery processing units or
PBF delivers Delivered Volumes to third parties in a third party transaction. The Hedge Adjustment Amount shall be included in the next following Payment Amount Invoice after determination. From time to time the Parties may agree to adjust the hedge
to account for volumetric losses. 

  

	9.	PAYMENT AND NETTING 

 

	9.1	On each Payment Date, MSCG shall net the following amounts: 

  
 21 

	 	(i)	the Daily Purchase Payment Amount payable by PBF to MSCG on such day; 

  

	 	(ii)	the Hedge Adjustment Amount, if applicable; 

  

	 	(iii)	any adjustments to amounts paid by one Party to the other Party hereunder based upon additional information obtained after invoicing, including adjustments to the
prices or volumes used to determine any previously invoiced Daily Purchase Payment Amount, and including any Adjustment Amount as described in Section 8.2.5; 

 

	 	(iv)	any Ancillary Costs incurred prior to such day and not previously paid to MSCG or any adjustment to Ancillary Costs previously determined and invoiced;

  

	 	(v)	any outstanding interest that accrues pursuant to Section 9.4; and 

  

	 	(vi)	any other amounts due and payable as of such day under this Agreement or any other Transaction Document. 

(the aggregate net amount payable, the “Net Daily Payment Amount”). 

MSCG shall notify PBF of the Net Daily Payment Amount and the Party to whom such Net Daily Payment Amount is owed shall prepare and
deliver to the other Party an invoice in respect such amount by 11:00 a.m. EPT on such Payment Date (the “Payment Amount Invoice” for such day). The Party owing the Net Payment Amount shall pay such amount to the other Party on or
prior to 3:00 p.m. EPT on such day, subject to Section 9.3. 
  

	9.2	Payments. All payments to be made under this Agreement shall be made by wire transfer of same day funds in U.S. Dollars to such bank account at such bank as the
payee shall designate in writing to the payor from time to time. All payments shall be deemed received on the Business Day on which same day funds therefor are received by the payee. Payments received after any applicable time set forth in this
Agreement on any Business Day or on a day that is not a Business Day shall be deemed to have been received on the following Business Day. Except as otherwise expressly provided in this Agreement, all payments by PBF or MSCG shall be made in full
without discount, offset, withholding, counterclaim or deduction whatsoever for any claims which one Party may now have or hereafter acquire against the other Party, whether pursuant to the terms of this Agreement or otherwise except as expressly
provided herein. The Parties recognize and acknowledge that the exchange of certain information in a timely manner and subsequent payments based on the information are interrelated, and a reasonable delay in one aspect of the process will not
relieve the obligation of a Party to reasonably comply with any response to the information or payment. If payment would be due hereunder on a day that is not a Business Day, such payment shall be deemed instead to be due on the next Business Day
after such day. 

  

	9.3	 Disputed Invoices. If an invoiced Party, in good faith, disputes the accuracy of the amount invoiced, the invoiced Party shall pay such amount
as it in good faith believes to be correct and provide written notice stating the reasons why the remaining disputed amount is incorrect, along with supporting documentation. In the event the Parties are

  
 22 

 
unable to resolve such dispute, either Party may pursue any remedy available at law or in equity to enforce its rights hereunder. In the event that it is determined or agreed that the Party that
is disputing an invoice must or will pay the disputed amount, then such Party shall pay interest from and including the original payment due date until, but excluding, the date the disputed amount is received by the owed Party, at the Base Interest
Rate. 
  

	9.4	Interest on Late Payments. Interest shall accrue on late payments under this Agreement at the Default Interest Rate from and including the date that payment is
due until but excluding the date that payment is actually received by the Party to whom it is payable. 

  

	10.	ADDITIONAL MSCG SERVICES 

 

	10.1	Additional MSCG Risk Management Services. Throughout the Term, MSCG shall provide risk management services to PBF as requested by PBF, including (i) updates
on relevant commodities markets and price quotes for swaps and options, and (ii) providing swap or option products on the terms agreed upon between the Parties, such terms to include volumes, prices, tenors and settlement dates.

  

	11.	DISPOSITION OF CRUDE OIL UPON TERMINATION OR
EXPIRATION 

  

	11.1	Final Disposition. On the date of expiration or termination of this Agreement (the “Termination Date”), whether this Agreement terminates at the
end of its Term or on an Early Termination Date, subject to MSCG’s rights under Section 18.6, MSCG shall not enter any more Supply Contracts, but may, in its sole discretion, continue to sell to PBF the MSCG In-Transit Volumes as of the
Termination Date and any other volumes of Crude Oil that MSCG is obligated to purchase pursuant to the terms of any Supply Contracts outstanding as of the Termination Date, in each case in accordance with the terms hereof, such sales to occur over
the period of time necessary for MSCG to sell all such Crude Oil to PBF (the “Run-off Period”), and PBF’s obligation to purchase such Crude Oil under the terms of this Agreement shall survive termination.

  

	11.2	 Termination Payment Amount. On or prior to the later of (i) 30th day following the Termination Date and (ii) the tenth Business Day following the end of the Run-off Period, if
applicable (in either case, the “Final Settlement Date”), MSCG shall calculate a final accounting and true up of all amounts owed by PBF to MSCG or by MSCG to PBF under this Agreement and all other Transaction Documents (such
amount, the “Termination Payment Amount”). The Termination Payment Amount shall include payment of the price in respect of all Delivered Volumes that have not yet been paid. 

 

	11.3	For purposes of such calculation, the Payment Date for any such Delivered Volumes that would occur after the Final Settlement Date shall be accelerated and deemed to
occur on the Final Settlement Date. MSCG shall notify PBF of the Termination Payment Amount and the Party to whom such amount is payable shall prepare an invoice (the “Final Invoice”) and deliver it to the other Party by the fifth
Business Day following MSCG’s calculation and notification of such amount. The Party owing the Termination Payment Amount shall pay to the other Party the Termination Payment Amount on or prior to the fifth Business Day following receipt of the
Final Invoice. 

  

	11.4	Pipeline Shipping History. After termination of this Agreement and after the completion of any Run-off Period, MSCG shall assign to PBF or its designated
Affiliate all shipper history generated during the Term that is attributable to sales of Crude Oil under this Agreement, subject to any required consents by the Pipelines. 

  
 23 

	12.	FINANCIAL INFORMATION, SECURITY AND REQUESTS FOR
FURTHER ASSURANCES 

  

	12.1	Provision of Financial Information. 

  

	 	12.1.1	Each Party shall provide the other Party, to the extent not publicly available, (i) within 120 days following the end of each of its fiscal years (or such earlier
date on which it is required to file a Form 10-K under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (“Exchange Act”)), beginning with the fiscal year ending December 31, 2010, a copy of its or, if applicable, its
Guarantor’s audited consolidated financial statements for such fiscal year certified by independent certified public accountants; (ii) within 45 days after the end of its first three fiscal quarters of each fiscal year (or such earlier
date on which it is required to file a Form 10-Q under the Exchange Act), a copy of its or, if applicable, its Guarantor’s quarterly unaudited consolidated financial statements for such fiscal quarter; and (iii) with respect to PBF, within
30 days after the end of each of the first two months of each fiscal quarter, beginning with [April 30], 2012, the consolidated balance sheet of PBF as of the end of each such month and the related consolidated statements of income and cash flows of
PBF for such month and for the then elapsed portion of the fiscal year, accompanied by a certificate of a Financial Officer stating that such financial statements fairly present, in all material respects, the consolidated results of operations and
cash flows of PBF as of the date and for the periods specified in accordance with GAAP consistently applied, subject to normal year-end audit adjustments and the absence of footnotes. In all cases the financial statements delivered pursuant to this
Section 12.1.1 shall be for the most recent accounting period and prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles in the United States, consistently applied, or, at the election of PBF, in accordance with the accounting
principles provided by the International Financial Reporting Standards enacted by the International Accounting Standards Board. In the case of PBF, upon delivery to MSCG, the applicable report delivered by PBF to the Administrative Agent pursuant to
the terms of the Revolving Credit Agreement shall satisfy its related requirement under this Section 12.1.1. 

  

	 	12.1.2	Within 90 days after the beginning of each fiscal year, PBF shall provide to MSCG a budget for PBF in form reasonably satisfactory to MSCG, but to include balance
sheets, statements of income and sources and uses of cash, for (i) each month of such fiscal year prepared in detail and (ii) each fiscal year thereafter, through and including the fiscal year in which the Termination Date is scheduled to
occur at such time pursuant to the terms of Section 2, prepared in summary form, in each case, with appropriate presentation and discussion of the principal assumptions upon which such budgets are based, accompanied by the statement of a
Financial Officer of PBF to the effect that the budget of PBF is a reasonable estimate for the periods covered thereby and, promptly when available, any significant revisions of such budget. In the case of PBF, upon delivery to MSCG, the applicable
budget delivered by PBF to the Administrative Agent pursuant to the terms of the Revolving Credit Agreement shall satisfy its related requirement under this Section 12.1.2. 

  
 24 

	 	12.1.3	Upon reasonable notice, a Party also shall provide to the other Party any other information sufficient to enable it to ascertain such other Party’s or a
Guarantor’s current financial condition and for such Party to assure itself of the other Party’s ability to perform its obligations under this Agreement or a Guarantor’s ability to perform its obligations under its Guaranty.

  

	12.2	Guaranty. As security for the prompt payment and performance in full when due of MSCG’s obligations under this Agreement, MSCG shall cause its Guarantor to
deliver to PBF prior to the Assignment Date a Guaranty substantially in the form of the guaranty provided to TRC under the Original Agreement. As security for the prompt payment and performance in full when due of PBF’s obligations under this
Agreement, (i) PBF shall cause TRC to deliver to MSCG prior to the Assignment Date a Guaranty in form and substance similar to the prior PBF guaranty to MSCG and (ii) within five Business Days of a written request by MSCG, but not sooner
than the tenth Business Day following the listing of PBF Energy public stock on an exchange (i.e., NYSE), PBF shall cause PBF Energy to deliver to MSCG a Guaranty substantially in the same form as the guaranty provided by PBF under the Original
Agreement. 

  

	12.3	Security Interest in Crude Oil. 

  

	 	12.3.1	As security for all obligations of PBF to MSCG under the Transaction Documents, PBF hereby pledges to MSCG, as a secured party, and grants to MSCG a first priority
continuing security interest in, Lien on and right of set-off against all of PBF’s right, title and interest in the Crude Oil, wheresoever located and all proceeds thereof (except as set forth in the last sentence below, the
“Collateral”). PBF shall take such actions, at PBF’s expense, as MSCG may from time to time reasonably request to further evidence or perfect such security interest, Lien and right of set-off. Notwithstanding the above,
MSCG’s rights in the Collateral shall at all times be subject to the terms of the Intercreditor Agreement so long as such Intercreditor Agreement remains effective, and so long as such Intercreditor Agreement remains effective,
“Collateral” shall not include any assets that are not included in the definition of “MSCG Assets and Collateral” as defined in such Intercreditor Agreement. 

 

	 	12.3.2	PBF represents and warrants to MSCG that it has good title to the Collateral, free and clear of all Liens other than the security interest and Lien granted to MSCG
hereunder and that the Collateral shall at all times remain free and clear of all Liens other than the security interest and Lien granted to MSCG hereunder. This representation and warranty shall be a continuing representation and warranty for so
long as MSCG’s security interest in and Lien on the Collateral remain in effect. In connection with any sale by PBF of Collateral to a third party, the Parties agree to use commercially reasonable efforts to ensure that all payments in respect
of the purchase of the Collateral by a third party are paid directly to MSCG in an amount up to the amount owed to MSCG for the Collateral, consistent with the then applicable terms of the Intercreditor Agreement. If any such sale by PBF of
Collateral is in connection with the movement of Collateral to a refinery owned by PBF or a PBF Affiliate, or if the purchaser in any sale of Collateral is a PBF Affiliate, PBF shall pay to MSCG the purchase price in respect of the sale of such
Collateral from MSCG to PBF prior to PBF’s transfer of title to the third party or Affiliate purchaser, notwithstanding the Payment Date that would otherwise be applicable to PBF’s purchase from MSCG pursuant to the terms of Section 8
and Schedule 2. 

  
 25 

	 	12.3.3	PBF hereby irrevocably authorizes MSCG at any time and from time to time to file in any relevant jurisdiction any financing statements and amendments thereto that
contain the information required by Article 9 of the UCC of each applicable jurisdiction for the filing of any financing statement or amendment relating to the Collateral. 

 

	 	12.3.4	PBF shall keep and maintain, and shall cause TRC to keep and maintain, to the extent applicable, at its own cost and expense complete records of the movements of the
Collateral from the Delivery Locations to the Refinery and from the Refinery tanks to the processing units or from the Delivery Locations to the point of sale to a third party, in a manner consistent with prudent business practice, including all
pipeline reports and notifications (including pipeline nominations and revisions to nominations, daily pipeline schedule of oil flow, apportionment notices and disruption notices, notices and reports for physical batch swaps) and Refinery and
terminal reports, and all other documentation relating thereto. PBF shall, at PBF’s sole cost and expense, upon MSCG’s demand made at any time after the occurrence and during the continuance of any Event of Default by PBF or an Additional
Termination Event, deliver all tangible evidence of the location, volume and quality of the Collateral (by Tank or other location), including all reports from the Refinery, terminals or pipelines and books and records relating thereto to MSCG or to
its representatives (copies of which evidence and books and records may be retained by PBF) to the extent not already provided to MSCG pursuant to PBF’s reporting obligations under Section 5. Upon the occurrence and during the continuance
of any Event of Default by PBF or an Additional Termination Event, MSCG may transfer a full and complete copy of PBF’s books, records, reports, memoranda and all other writings relating to the Collateral to and for the use by any person that
has acquired or is contemplating acquisition of an interest in the Collateral or MSCG’s security interest therein, without the consent of PBF. 

  

	 	12.3.5	Upon the occurrence and during the continuance of any Event of Default by PBF or an Additional Termination Event, MSCG shall have all of the default rights and remedies
of a secured party under the UCC. PBF acknowledges and agrees that, to the extent notice of sale or other disposition of the Collateral or any part thereof shall be required by law, ten days’ prior notice to PBF of the time and place of any
public sale or of the time after which any private sale or other intended disposition is to take place shall be commercially reasonable notification of such matters. 

 

	 	12.3.6	Catastrophic Loss of Collateral. In connection with any catastrophic loss of Collateral (any loss other than a normal handling loss), at the election of MSCG in
its sole discretion, either (i) the Payment Date in respect of the purchase by PBF from MSCG of the volume of Crude Oil that constituted such Collateral shall be accelerated to the date of such loss or (ii) PBF shall immediately replace
the Collateral subject to the loss with additional Collateral or other Security having an equal or greater value. In the case of subclause (i), the pricing of the Crude Oil shall be based on the then current price for such volume determined in
accordance with Schedule 5. 

  
 26 

	12.4	Notification of Certain Events. Each Party shall notify the other Party in writing within two Business Days of learning of any of the following events:

  

	 	12.4.1	any Event of Default or Additional Termination Event, specifying the nature and extent thereof and the corrective action (if any) taken or proposed to be taken with
respect thereto; 

  

	 	12.4.2	in the case of PBF, TRC’s or PBF’s binding agreement to sell, lease, sublease, transfer or otherwise dispose of, or grant any person (including an Affiliate)
an option to acquire, in one transaction or a series of related transactions, all or a material portion of the Refinery assets; 

  

	 	12.4.3	it or any of its Guarantors consolidates or amalgamates with, merges with or into, or transfers all or substantially all of its assets to, another entity (including an
Affiliate); 

  

	 	12.4.4	in the case of PBF, any labor disturbances at the Refinery that could adversely impact the scheduled sales under an NFR; 

 

	 	12.4.5	any event that could reasonably be expected to have a Material Adverse Change as to it or any of its Guarantors, which may include the filing or commencement of, or any
threat or notice of intention of any person to file or commence, any action, suit, litigation or proceeding, whether at law or in equity by or before any Governmental Authority, against PBF or any Affiliate thereof, that could reasonably be expected
to result in a Material Adverse Change; 

  

	 	12.4.6	a final judicial or administrative judgment against it or any of its Guarantors that individually or in the aggregate is in excess of $10,000,000;

  

	 	12.4.7	in the case of PBF, any default by any party under any Credit Agreement, or any event which, with the giving of notice or lapse of time or both, would become an event
of default under any Credit Agreement, including any notice of acceleration, demand, termination, suspension or foreclosure issued by any secured party or person acting in a similar capacity; or 

 

	 	12.4.8	In the case of PBF, PBF’s entrance into a binding agreement that would result in a Change of Control with respect to PBF or the entry by any of PBF’s
Guarantors into a binding agreement that would result in a Change of Control with respect to such Guarantor, such notice to be provided no later than five Business Days following execution of such agreement. This Section 12.5.8 shall not apply
to any future public offering of stock of PBF or any of its Affiliates. 

  

	12.5	Security and Further Assurances. 

  

	 	12.5.1	Bilateral Further Assurances. Each Party may, in its reasonable discretion and upon notice to the other Party, require that such other Party provide it with
satisfactory security for or adequate assurance of (“Performance Assurance”) its or, if applicable, any of its Guarantor’s performance within a specified time period as appropriate, when (i) such demanding Party determines
that a Material Adverse Change has occurred as with respect to the other Party, or, if applicable, any of its Guarantors; and (ii) such other Party fails to comply with any material provision of this Section 12 or breaches any covenant set
forth in Section 17.4 in any material respect. 

  
 27 

	 	12.5.2	Variation Margin. MSCG may, in its reasonable discretion and upon notice to PBF, require that PBF provide it with satisfactory security (“Variation
Margin”) in an amount equal to MSCG’s estimate of its Exposure (as defined below) on any day on or prior to the third Business Day following such date of determination, subject to a minimum exposure to be mutually agreed between the
Parties from time to time. 

  

	 	12.5.2.1	MSCG shall calculate its “Exposure” by netting the following amounts: 

(i) the aggregate [REDACTED]; 
 (ii) the [REDACTED] on any relevant day; 
 (iii) the difference between
[REDACTED]; and 
 (iv) the [REDACTED]. 
  

	 	12.5.3	Base Margin. MSCG may, in its reasonable discretion and upon notice to PBF, require that PBF provide it with security for or adequate assurance of PBF’s and
its Guarantors’ performance of their obligations under the Transaction Documents (“Base Margin”, and together with Performance Assurance and Variation Margin, “Security”) in an amount to be mutually agreed
upon, which is intended to mitigate MSCG’s potential exposure and incurred costs upon the occurrence of an Event of Default, an Additional Termination Event in respect of PBF and any resulting early termination of this Agreement (in excess of
any amount covered by any Variation Margin posted by PBF at such time). 

  

	 	12.5.4	 Form and Delivery of Security. A Party shall provide Security to the other Party on or prior to the second Business Day following demand
therefor in the form of Collateral, cash or a letter of credit, or in any other document or mechanism acceptable to the demanding Party. The Security provided by a Party shall be for a duration and in an amount sufficient to cover a value up to the
other Party’s estimated financial exposure under this Agreement, including reasonable contingencies for the designated time period, which may be calculated in accordance with Sections 12.5.2 and 12.5.3. If Security is provided in the form of a
letter of credit, such letter of credit shall be issued by an Acceptable Letter of Credit Issuer and shall be in a form reasonably acceptable to the demanding Party in its sole discretion. All bank charges relating to any letter of credit and any

  
 28 

 
fees, commissions, costs and expenses incurred with respect to furnishing security are for the account of the Party providing the Security. [REDACTED]. 

 

	 	12.5.5	Each Party agrees, at any time and from time to time upon the request of the other Party, to execute, deliver and acknowledge, or cause to execute, deliver and
acknowledge, such further documents and instruments and do such other acts and things as such Party may reasonably request in order to fully effect the purposes of this Agreement. 

 

	13.	REFINERY TURNAROUND, MAINTENANCE AND CLOSURE

  

	 	13.1	Scheduled Maintenance. PBF shall provide to MSCG on an annual basis, at least 30 days prior to the beginning of each year during the Term, TRC’s anticipated
timing of scheduled maintenance or turnaround that may affect PBF’s Crude Oil requirements during the upcoming year, and shall update such schedule promptly following any change to the maintenance schedule. 

 

	 	13.2	Unscheduled Maintenance. PBF immediately shall notify MSCG orally (followed by prompt written notice) of any previously unscheduled downtime, maintenance or
turnaround and its expected duration. 

  

	14.	TAXES 

  

	14.1	PBF shall pay MSCG the amount of all Taxes paid or incurred by MSCG directly or indirectly with respect to the Crude Oil sold hereunder. MSCG shall provide PBF with
supporting documentation. To the extent not included in the purchase price, MSCG shall itemize separately any Taxes on the daily invoice. PBF hereby agrees to reimburse MSCG for any such Tax which MSCG may incur with respect to such Crude Oil,
whether determined during the duration of this Agreement or on audit after termination; provided, however, that PBF’s obligation to reimburse MSCG for Taxes shall survive termination of this Agreement for a period which equals the statute of
limitations applicable to the specific Tax in question. PBF shall pay MSCG for any Taxes arising from audit within two Business Days of receipt of MSCG’s invoice. MSCG shall notify PBF promptly upon being notified of the commencement of any
audit that may result in payments by PBF under this Section 14.1. 

  

	14.2	In the event that MSCG receives any refund of, or realizes the benefit of any credit with respect to Taxes that PBF previously had paid to MSCG, MSCG shall pay the
amount of such refund or credit to PBF, together with any interest thereon paid to MSCG by the Governmental Authority, but otherwise without interest thereon. If it is later determined that MSCG was not entitled to such refund, credit or interest,
then the portion thereof which is repaid, recaptured or disallowed will be treated as a Tax for which PBF shall reimburse and indemnify MSCG pursuant to this Section 14. 

 

	14.3	 Upon the reasonable request of PBF, PBF shall, at its sole expense, have the right to cause MSCG to contest the validity, applicability or amount of
any Tax for which MSCG is liable; provided, however, that MSCG shall not be required to take or consent to PBF taking any such action if, in MSCG’s sole discretion, such action could have a material adverse affect on MSCG. MSCG shall be
entitled to select counsel of its choice. MSCG 

  
 29 

 
shall not settle or compromise any claim or contest without PBF’s prior written consent, which shall not be unreasonably withheld; provided, however, that MSCG shall be entitled in its sole
discretion to settle or compromise any claims or contest of Tax liability if such settlement or compromise is made in connection with a closing agreement governing tax periods that cover both Tax liability hereunder and tax liabilities of MSCG that
are not related to this Agreement. 
  

	15.	INSURANCE 

  

	15.1	Insurance Required to be provided by MSCG. MSCG shall insure the Crude Oil under its cargo and casualty insurance policy. 

 

	15.2	Insurance Required to be provided by PBF and TRC. PBF shall procure, or provide through an Affiliate, and maintain in full force and effect throughout the Term
insurance coverage of the following types and amounts and with insurance companies rated not less than A- by A.M. Best, or otherwise reasonably acceptable to MSCG, in respect of PBF’s and TRC’s receipt, handling and storage of Crude Oil
under this Agreement: 

  

	 	15.2.1	Workers Compensation coverage in compliance with the Applicable Law; 

  

	 	15.2.2	automobile liability coverage in a minimum amount of $1,000,000; 

  

	 	15.2.3	casualty insurance coverage; and 

  

	 	15.2.4	comprehensive or commercial general liability coverage and umbrella excess liability coverage, which includes bodily injury, broad form property damage and contractual
liability coverages, in a minimum amount of $75,000,000, which includes losses for Crude Oil while in PBF’s or TRC’s care, custody and control, and “sudden and accidental pollution” liability coverages (excluding events
that result in acidic deposition). 

  

	15.3	Additional Insurance Requirements. 

  

	 	15.3.1	Each Party shall cause its insurance carriers to furnish insurance certificates to the other Party, in a form reasonably satisfactory to the other Party, evidencing the
existence of the coverages required pursuant to Sections 15.1 and 15.2. Each Party shall provide renewal certificates within 30 days of expiration of the previous policy under which coverage is maintained. 

 

	 	15.3.2	Each Party shall include an endorsement in the foregoing policies indicating that the underwriters agree to waive all rights of subrogation to the extent of such
Party’s obligations. Further, each Party shall name the other Party as an additional insured under the foregoing policies to the extent of the indemnities required under this Agreement. 

 

	 	15.3.3	The mere purchase and existence of insurance coverage shall not reduce or release either Party from any Liabilities incurred or assumed under this Agreement.

  

	 	15.3.4	In the event of a Crude Oil loss for which a Party must indemnify the other Party under this Agreement, the indemnifying Party’s insurance shall be the primary and
exclusive coverage for such loss, notwithstanding the existence of other valid and collectible insurance. 

  
 30 

	16.	FORCE MAJEURE 

 

	16.1	Neither Party shall be liable to the other Party if it is rendered unable by a Force Majeure Event to perform in whole or in part any obligation or condition of this
Agreement for so long as the Force Majeure Event exists and to the extent that performance is hindered by the Force Majeure Event; provided, however, that the Party unable to perform shall use any commercially reasonable efforts to avoid or remove
the Force Majeure Event, and in the case of PBF, where applicable, PBF shall cause TRC to use commercially reasonable efforts to avoid or remove the Force Majeure Event. During the period that performance by the affected Party of a part or whole of
its obligations has been suspended by reason of a Force Majeure Event, the other Party likewise may suspend the performance of all or a part of its obligations to the extent that such suspension is commercially reasonable, other than any payment or
indemnification obligations that arose prior to the Force Majeure Event. 

  

	16.2	The affected Party rendered unable to perform shall give written notice to the other Party within 24 hours after receiving notice of the occurrence of a Force Majeure
Event, including, to the extent feasible, the details and the expected duration of the Force Majeure Event and the volume of Crude Oil affected. Such Party also shall promptly notify the other when the Force Majeure Event has terminated.

  

	17.	REPRESENTATIONS, WARRANTIES AND COVENANTS

  

	17.1	Mutual Representations and Warranties. Each Party represents and warrants to the other Party as of the Effective Date, and shall be deemed to represent and
warrant as of the Commencement Date and as of the date of any purchase of Crude Oil hereunder, that: 

  

	 	17.1.1	it is (A) an “eligible commercial entity” and an “eligible contract participant” as defined in Sections 1a(11) and 1a(12) of the
U.S. Commodity Exchange Act, as amended, and (B) a “forward contract merchant” under section 101(26) and a “master netting agreement participant” under section 101(38B), for purposes of the Bankruptcy Code;

  

	 	17.1.2	it is duly organized and validly existing under the laws of the jurisdiction of its organization or incorporation and, if relevant under such laws, in good standing,
has the power to execute and deliver this Agreement and any other related documentation that it is required by this Agreement to deliver and to perform its obligations under this Agreement, and has taken all necessary action to authorize such
execution, delivery and performance; 

  

	 	17.1.3	such execution, delivery and performance do not violate or conflict with any Applicable Law in any material respect, any provision of its constitutional documents,
order or judgment of any court or Governmental Authority or, in any material respect, any of its assets or any contractual restriction binding on or affecting it or any of its assets; 

 

	 	17.1.4	 all governmental and other authorizations, approvals, consents, notices and filings that are required to have been obtained or submitted by it with
respect to 

  
 31 

	 	
this Agreement (including any internal authorizations, approvals and consents required by such Party under its organizational documents) have been obtained or submitted and are in full force and
effect, and all conditions of this Agreement have been obtained or submitted and are in full force and effect, and all conditions of any such authorizations, approvals, consents, notices and filings have been complied with, in all material respects;

  

	 	17.1.5	its obligations under this Agreement constitute its legal, valid and binding obligations, enforceable in accordance with their respective terms (subject to applicable
bankruptcy, reorganization, insolvency, moratorium or similar laws affecting creditors’ rights generally and subject, as to enforceability, to equitable principles of general application regardless of whether enforcement is sought in a
proceeding in equity or at law); 

  

	 	17.1.6	it is in good standing under the laws of each jurisdiction in which it is required to perform under this Agreement, and all governmental and other authorizations,
approvals, consents, notices, licenses and filings that are required to have been obtained or submitted by it in order to perform under this Agreement under the Applicable Laws of each relevant jurisdiction have been obtained or submitted and are in
full force and effect; 

  

	 	17.1.7	no Termination Event or Potential Event of Default has occurred and is continuing, and no such event or circumstance would occur as a result of its entering into or
performing its obligations under this Agreement; 

  

	 	17.1.8	there is not pending, nor to its knowledge threatened against it, any action, suit or proceeding at law or in equity or before any court, tribunal, Governmental
Authority, official or any arbitrator that is likely to affect the legality, validity or enforceability against it of this Agreement or its ability to perform its obligations under this Agreement; 

 

	 	17.1.9	it is not relying upon any representations of any other Party other than those expressly set forth in this Agreement; 

 

	 	17.1.10	it has entered into the Transaction Documents and will enter into any transaction thereunder as principal (and not as advisor, agent, broker or in any other capacity,
fiduciary or otherwise) and with a full understanding of the material terms and risks of the same, and has made its own independent decision to enter into the Transaction Documents and any transaction and as to whether the Transaction Documents and
any transaction are appropriate or suitable for it based upon its own judgment and upon advice from such advisers as it has deemed necessary and not in reliance upon any view expressed by any other Party; 

 

	 	17.1.11	it is capable of assessing the merits of and understanding (on its own behalf or through independent professional advice) the Transaction Documents and any transaction,
understands and accepts the terms, conditions and risks of the Transaction Documents and any transaction, and is capable of assuming, and assumes, the risks of the Transaction Documents and any transactions contemplated thereunder; and it is capable
of assuming those risks; 

  
 32 

	 	17.1.12	the other Party (i) is acting solely in the capacity of an arm’s-length contractual counterparty with respect to this Agreement, (ii) is not acting as a
financial advisor or fiduciary or in any similar capacity with respect to this Agreement and (iii) has not given to it any assurance or guarantee as to the expected performance or result of this Agreement; 

 

	 	17.1.13	it is not bound by any agreement that would preclude or hinder its execution, delivery, or performance of any of the Transaction Documents; 

 

	 	17.1.14	neither it nor any of its Affiliates has been contacted by or negotiated with any finder, broker or other intermediary in connection with the sale of Crude Oil
hereunder who is entitled to any compensation with respect thereto; and 

  

	 	17.1.15	none of its directors, officers, employees or agents or those of its Affiliates has received or will receive any commission, fee, rebate, gift or entertainment of
significant value in connection with any of the Transaction Documents. 

  

	17.2	Mutual Covenants. 

  

	 	17.2.1	Compliance with Applicable Laws. Each Party undertakes and covenants to the other Party that it shall comply in all material respects with all Applicable Laws,
including all Environmental Laws, to which it may be subject in connection with the performance of any obligation or exercise of any rights under any of the Transaction Documents or in connection with any transaction contemplated by or undertaken
pursuant to this Agreement, and PBF undertakes and covenants that it shall cause TRC to comply in all material respects with all Applicable Laws to which TRC may be subject in connection with PBF’s performance of any obligation or exercise by
MSCG of any rights under any of the Transaction Documents or in connection with any transaction contemplated by or undertaken pursuant to this Agreement. 

  

	 	17.2.2	Books and Records. All records or documents provided by any Party to the other Party shall, to the best knowledge of such Party, accurately and completely
reflect the facts or estimates about the activities and transactions to which they relate. Each Party shall promptly notify the other Party if at any time such Party has reason to believe that any records or documents previously provided to the
other Party no longer are accurate or complete. 

  

	 	17.2.3	Indemnity. In addition to any other remedies under this Agreement, a Party that fails to comply with the requirements of Section 17.2.1 or 17.2.2 shall
indemnify the other Party from and against any and all losses of whatever nature arising out of or connected with such non-compliance. 

  

	17.3	Additional PBF Representations and Warranties. PBF represents and warrants to MSCG as of the Effective Date, and shall be deemed to represent and warrant as of
the Commencement Date and as of the date of any purchase of Crude Oil hereunder, that: 

  

	 	17.3.1	 In the case of any action, inaction, consent, approval or other conduct that falls within the definition of “Bankrupt” with respect to
PBF, PBF intends that MSCG’s rights and entitlements to the following shall not be stayed, avoided or otherwise limited by the Bankruptcy Code, and PBF shall not oppose the exercise

  
 33 

	 	
of MSCG’s rights and entitlements to accelerate, close-out, liquidate, collect, net and set off rights and obligations under any of the Transaction Documents, including the rights set forth
in Section 18. 

  

	 	17.3.2	It acknowledges that MSCG from time to time during the Term will own all Crude Oil that MSCG purchased from third parties and is in-transit to the Transfer Points,
wherever located, including while within a Pipeline, until transfer of title to PBF or a third party, and further, will own all receivables and proceeds generated from the foregoing and has the right to sell, encumber and pledge such Crude Oil.

  

	17.4	Additional PBF Covenants. 

  

	 	17.4.1	PBF agrees that neither it nor TRC shall have any interest in or the right to dispose of, and shall not permit the creation of, or suffer to exist, any Lien with
respect to, any portion of the MSCG In-Transit Volumes. 

  

	 	17.4.2	PBF agrees that, during the Term hereof, neither it nor TRC shall enter into any Crude Oil arrangement for the purchase of Crude Oil to be shipped by PBF or TRC, as
applicable, to the Refinery or third parties or otherwise relating to the Refinery or PBF’s other operations utilizing the pipeline and storage facilities that are utilized by PBF in its purchase and shipment of Crude Oil to the Refinery under
this Agreement other than this Agreement. 

  

	 	17.4.3	PBF agrees, from time to time on MSCG’s request, to execute, deliver and acknowledge, or to cause any party to any Credit Agreement to execute, deliver and
acknowledge, such further documents and instruments and to take such other actions as MSCG may reasonably request in order to more fully effect the purposes of the transactions contemplated by and the provisions of this Agreement.

  

	 	17.4.4	PBF agrees that, during the Term hereof, any binding agreement entered into by it that would result in a Change of Control with respect to PBF or any of its Guarantors
will provide for a period no shorter than 60 days from the date of execution of such binding agreement to the date upon which the Change of Control becomes effective. 

 

	 	17.4.5	If the Parties mutually agree that it would be commercially reasonable for MSCG to sell any portion of the MSCG In-Transit Volumes to a third party or otherwise dispose
of any such MSCG In-Transit Volumes as a result of cessation of operations at the Refinery (due to a Force Majeure Event or otherwise) or for any other reason, PBF agrees that it will reimburse MSCG for all costs, losses and expenses incurred by
MSCG in connection therewith, and MSCG agrees that it will pay through to PBF any gains in connection therewith. Each Party shall act in a commercially reasonable manner in such determination. For the avoidance of doubt, such losses, costs and
expenses (or gains) would include MSCG’s market losses (or gains) related to the difference in the price at which MSCG is able to sell or otherwise dispose of Crude Oil and the Price that would have applied to such Crude Oil if sold to PBF
under this Agreement, and would include losses (or gains) incurred in connection with any related hedge transactions. MSCG shall use commercially reasonable efforts to mitigate costs, losses or expenses resulting from a cessation of Refinery
operations. 

  
 34 

	18.	TERMINATION EVENTS, DEFAULT AND EARLY
TERMINATION 

  

	18.1	Non-fault Based Early Termination Events. 

  

	 	18.1.1	Change of Law. 

 Each
Party shall make reasonable efforts to monitor proposed Changes of Law which may reasonably be expected to have an impact on such Party’s performance of its obligations under the Transaction Documents or its ability to hedge in a commercially
reasonable manner trading positions related to purchases and sales under this Agreement or in contemplation of fulfilling the objectives of this Agreement (“Hedging Activities”) and shall promptly notify the other Party upon
becoming aware of any such proposed Change of Law. Such notice shall identify the proposed Change of Law and set out, in reasonable detail, the effects the notifying Party anticipates such Change of Law would have upon the Transaction Documents (or
such Party’s performance thereunder) or its Hedging Activities if enacted. The Parties shall in good faith meet to discuss what, if any, measures can be taken by either Party (or both) to minimize or mitigate the effect of any such proposed
Change of Law. 
 If a Change of Law results or would result in a Party (the “Adversely Affected Party”)
incurring incremental damages, losses, costs, expenses, fees, fines, payments, Taxes, liabilities, penalties or other sanctions of a monetary nature (“Losses”) in excess of $3,000,000 per annum solely as a result of such
Party’s performance of its obligations under the Transaction Documents or as a result of its Hedging Activities, the Adversely Affected Party shall be entitled to request that the Parties meet for purposes of addressing such Change of Law by
providing written notice (a “Change of Law Notice”) to the other Party (the “Non-Affected Party”), provided always that the Adversely Affected Party shall use all reasonable efforts to minimize the effects of such
Change of Law or to mitigate the incremental Losses incurred by such Adversely Affected Party as a result of such Change of Law. 
 Within seven days of receipt of a Change of Law Notice, the Parties shall meet in good faith with a view to identifying any steps (“Consequential Steps”) that would alleviate the effects
of the relevant Change of Law on the Adversely Affected Party, which may constitute an agreement between the Parties to share the relevant incremental Losses incurred by the Adversely Affected Party or the amendment of any Transaction Document. In
identifying the Consequential Steps, the Parties shall, as far as is reasonably practicable, do so in a manner that preserves the balance of the commercial agreement (including economic benefits, risk allocation, costs and liabilities) existing
between the Parties under this Agreement as of the Effective Date. 
 In the event the Parties cannot reach agreement on the
Consequential Steps and on the implementation of the same within 30 days of receipt by the Non-Affected Party of the Change of Law Notice, the Adversely Affected Party may terminate this Agreement in accordance with Section 11, effective as of
the earlier of (i) the 

  
 35 

 
effective date of the Change of Law and (ii) six months following receipt by the Non-Affected Party of the Change of Law Notice and terminate all other Transaction Documents and all other
agreements that may then be outstanding between the Parties that relate specifically to this Agreement, each in accordance with its terms. 
  

	 	18.1.2	Change of Control. Upon the occurrence of a Change of Control with respect to PBF or any of its Guarantors, MSCG may, in its sole discretion, accelerate this
Agreement and designate a Termination Date, which shall be no earlier than the effective date of such Change of Control event, on which to terminate this Agreement in accordance with Section 11, and terminate all other Transaction Documents and
all other agreements that may then be outstanding between the Parties that relate specifically to this Agreement, each in accordance with its terms. 

  

	 	18.1.3	Increase in Working Capital Rate. 

 In the event the Parties cannot reach agreement on an adjustment to the Working Capital Rate upon a request by MSCG to increase the Working Capital Rate pursuant to Section 8.2.5.2 (“Increase
Request”) within 10 days of such Increase Request, if such adjustment would be reasonably likely to result in PBF incurring increased costs in connection with this Agreement in excess of $[REDACTED] per annum, PBF may terminate this
Agreement upon written notice to MSCG specifying a Termination Date no earlier than six months following PBF’s receipt of the Increase Request. In connection with such termination, the Parties shall terminate all other Transaction Documents and
all other agreements that may then be outstanding between the Parties that relate specifically to this Agreement, each in accordance with its terms. 
 For the period from and excluding the date of the Increase Request through the Termination Date, the Working Capital Rate shall be increased by MSCG to a rate that would not be reasonably likely to result
in PBF incurring increased costs in connection with this Agreement in excess of $[REDACTED] per annum. 
  

	18.2	Events of Default. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement, the occurrence of any of the following events or circumstances shall constitute a
“Default” or an “Event of Default”: 

  

	 	18.2.1	A Party or any of its Guarantors fails to make payment when due under this Agreement within two Business Days following receipt of a demand for payment by the other
Party. 

  

	 	18.2.2	A Party fails to (i) provide financial information as required by Section 12.1, or (ii) provide the other Party with Security as required by
Section 12.6, or such Security expires, terminates or no longer is in full force and effect, in each case within two Business Days following receipt of a demand therefor. 

 

	 	18.2.3	 A Party breaches any representation, warranty made or repeated or deemed to have been made or repeated by the Party in any material respect when made
or repeated or deemed to have been made or repeated under this Agreement, or any warranty or representation proves to have been incorrect or misleading in any 

  
 36 

	 	
material respect when made or repeated or deemed to have been made or repeated under this Agreement; provided, however, that if such breach is curable, such breach is not cured to the reasonable
satisfaction of the other Party (in its sole discretion) within ten Business Days from the date that such Party receives notice that corrective action is needed. 

 

	 	18.2.4	Other than a default more specifically described in this Section 18.2, a Party fails to perform any obligation or breaches a covenant required under this
Agreement, which, if capable of cure, is not cured to the reasonable satisfaction of the other Party (in its sole discretion) within five Business Days from the date that such Party receives written notice that corrective action is needed, provided
that no grace period will apply to any failure by PBF to notify MSCG of a Change of Control in accordance with Section 12.5.8. 

  

	 	18.2.5	There shall have occurred a default, event of default or other similar condition or event (however described) in respect of a Party or any of its Guarantors under any
Specified Agreement, which is not cured within the applicable time period, if any. Upon the occurrence of such event, the defaulting party (or in the case of a default by a Guarantor, the Party whose Guarantor defaulted) under the Specified
Agreement shall be deemed to be the Defaulting Party hereunder and the other Party shall be deemed to be the Performing Party. 

  

	 	18.2.6	A Party or any of a Party’s Guarantors or direct or indirect parent companies becomes or is Bankrupt. 

 

	 	18.2.7	Any of a Party’s Guarantors (i) fails to satisfy, perform or comply with any material obligation in accordance with its Guaranty if such failure continues
after any applicable grace or notice period, (ii) breaches any representation, covenant or warranty or any representation proves to have been incorrect or misleading in any material respect under its Guaranty, which is not cured to the other
Party’s reasonable satisfaction, in its sole discretion, within any applicable grace or notice period, or (iii) repudiates, disclaims, disaffirms or rejects, in whole or part, any obligation under its Guaranty, or challenges the validity
of its Guaranty. 

  

	 	18.2.8	Receipt of notice by the other Party of a consolidation, amalgamation, merger or transfer that would constitute a Credit Event Upon Merger or the occurrence of a Credit
Event Upon Merger with respect to a Party or any of its Guarantors. 

  

	 	18.2.9	There shall have occurred either (i) a default, event of default or other similar condition or event (however described) in respect of PBF or any of its Affiliates
under one or more agreements or instruments relating to Specified Indebtedness in an aggregate amount of not less than $10,000,000 that has resulted in such Specified Indebtedness becoming immediately due and payable under such agreements and
instruments before it would have otherwise been due and payable, including any notice of acceleration, demand, termination, suspension or foreclosure issued by any secured party or person acting in a similar capacity; or (ii) a default by PBF
or any of its Affiliates (individually or collectively) in making one or more payments on the due date thereof in an aggregate amount of not less than $10,000,000 under such agreements or instruments (after giving effect to any applicable notice
requirement or grace period). 

  
 37 

	 	18.2.10	Any claim is asserted or Lien (other than a Lien granted by MSCG) is placed on any portion of the Crude Oil owned by PBF or any portion of the MSCG In-Transit Volumes
due to an act or omission of PBF, TRC or any of PBF’s or TRC’s creditors or such Lien or claim is imminent. Upon the occurrence of such event, PBF shall be deemed to be a Defaulting Party hereunder and MSCG shall be deemed to be the
Performing Party. 

  

	 	18.2.11	Due to an act or omission of PBF, TRC or any of PBF’s or TRC’s creditors, MSCG’s first priority Lien in any portion of the Crude Oil owned by PBF or any
portion of the MSCG In-Transit Volumes shall cease to exist or shall lose its priority, or any action is taken to impair or negatively impact MSCG’s first priority Lien in any portion of the Crude Oil owned by PBF or any portion of the MSCG
In-Transit Volumes, including the assertion by any creditor that MSCG would not be entitled to an exclusive, first priority Lien in any of such Crude Oil, and, if it is reasonably likely to MSCG that such event is capable of cure within three
Business Days, such event shall not have been cured by the third Business Day following PBF’s receipt of notice that corrective action is needed. Upon the occurrence of such event, PBF shall be deemed to be a Defaulting Party hereunder and MSCG
shall be deemed to be the Performing Party. 

  

	 	18.2.12	There shall have occurred a default, event of default or other similar condition or event (however described) in respect of a Party under any Transaction Document.

  

	 	18.2.13	There shall have occurred a default under the Intercreditor Agreement in respect of any party thereto that is prejudicial to a Party’s rights hereunder, provided
that where such default under the Intercreditor Agreement occurs with respect to a party other than the Parties hereto, PBF shall be deemed to be the Defaulting Party hereunder and MSCG shall be deemed to be the Performing Party.

  

	 	18.2.14	The occurrence of a Letter of Credit Default in relation to any letter of credit provided by a Party hereunder. 

 

	 	18.2.15	There shall have occurred a default, event of default or other similar condition or event (howsoever described) in respect of a Party or a Party’s Affiliate under
the Products Offtake Agreement between PRC and MSCG dated as of December 14, 2010, the DCRC Offtake Agreement or any future refinery supply or offtake agreement between a PBF Affiliate and MSCG and such agreement is accelerated or there occurs
a default (howsoever described) with respect to a Party or a Party’s Affiliate thereunder substantially similar to one of the defaults described in Sections 18.2.1 (if such default is in an amount in excess of $1,000,000), 18.2.2 (sub-clause
(ii) only), 18.2.6, 18.2.7, 18.2.8 or 18.2.9. 

  

	18.3	Additional Termination Events. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement, the occurrence of any of the events or circumstances specified in Sections
18.3.1 through and including 18.3.4 shall constitute an “Additional Termination Event” and, in each instance, PBF shall be deemed to be the “Affected Party” and MSCG shall be deemed to be the Performing Party (as
defined in Section 18.4) for purposes of determining the rights and remedies available to the Performing Party under Sections 18.4 and 18.6. 

  
 38 

	 	18.3.1	The sale, lease, sublease, transfer, conveyance or other disposition by TRC, in one transaction or a series of related transactions, of all or a material portion of the
Refinery assets other than to an Affiliate. 

  

	 	18.3.2	Operations at the Refinery shall have ceased other than as a result of a Force Majeure Event for a period of at least 60 consecutive days. 

 

	 	18.3.3	There occurs an inability to inject Crude Oil into any Pipeline (in each case, other than as a result of a Force Majeure Event), in any material respect for a period of
at least 60 consecutive days and alternative arrangements cannot be mutually agreed to by the Parties. 

  

	 	18.3.4	A Force Majeure Event affecting the Refinery or a Pipeline has occurred and is continuing for a period of at least 60 consecutive days. 

 

	18.4	Remedies Generally. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement, any Guaranty or any Specified Agreement, upon the occurrence and continuance of an
Event of Default with respect to a Party or any of such Party’s Guarantors (such Party referred to as the “Defaulting Party”), or upon the occurrence and continuance of an Additional Termination Event with respect to the
Affected Party, the other Party (in each case, the “Performing Party”) may in its sole discretion, in addition to all other remedies available to it and without incurring any Liabilities (for any costs arising from delay or
otherwise) to the Affected Party or the Defaulting Party, as the case may be, do any or all of the following: 

  

	 	18.4.1	suspend its performance under this Agreement, including any Crude Oil sale, purchase, receipt, delivery or payment obligations, upon written notice to the Defaulting
Party or Affected Party; 

  

	 	18.4.2	accelerate the Payment Date with respect to all Delivered Volumes that have not yet been paid for; 

 

	 	18.4.3	declare all or any portion of the Defaulting Party’s or Affected Party’s obligations under this Agreement to be forthwith due and payable, all without
presentment, demand, protest or further notice of any kind, all of which are expressly waived by the Defaulting Party or Affected Party; 

  

	 	18.4.4	upon written notice to the Defaulting Party or the Affected Party, specify a date (the “Early Termination Date”) on which to terminate this Agreement
in accordance with Section 11, subject to MSCG’s rights under Section 18.6 if MSCG is the Performing Party; 

  

	 	18.4.5	terminate all other Transaction Documents and all other agreements that may then be outstanding between the Parties that relate specifically to this Agreement;

  

	 	18.4.6	close out any Specified Agreements pursuant to Section 18.7; 

  

	 	18.4.7	determine the Termination Amount due the Performing Party upon early termination as provided in Section 18.8; and 

  
 39 

	 	18.4.8	exercise any rights and remedies provided or available to the Performing Party under this Agreement or at law or equity. 

 

	18.5	Early Termination Fee. 

  

	 	18.5.1	In the event that this Agreement is terminated by MSCG pursuant to its rights under Section 18.1.2, PBF shall pay to MSCG an Early Termination Fee in an amount
equal to (i) if such termination occurs before the first anniversary of the Commencement Date, $[REDACTED], or (ii) if such termination occurs after the first anniversary of the Commencement Date, $[REDACTED]. 

 

	 	18.5.2	In the event that this Agreement is terminated by a Performing Party pursuant to its rights under Section 18.4.4 as a result of an Event of Default, the Defaulting
Party shall pay to the Performing Party an Early Termination Fee in an amount equal to (i) if the Event of Default occurs before the first anniversary of the Commencement Date, $[REDACTED] or (ii) if the Event of Default occurs after the
first anniversary of the Commencement Date, $[REDACTED]. 

  

	 	18.5.3	In the event that this Agreement is terminated by a Performing Party pursuant to its rights under Section 18.4.4 as a result of an Additional Termination Event,
the Affected Party shall pay to the Performing Party an Early Termination Fee in an amount equal to $[REDACTED]. 

  

	 	18.5.4	The Parties agree that the Early Termination Fee payable from one Party to the other Party pursuant to Section 18.5.1 represents a genuine pre-estimate of the loss
that MSCG will suffer as a result of the termination of this Agreement in the circumstances described in Section 18.5.1 and is payable in lieu of MSCG’s rights to claim damages resulting from such termination. 

 

	 	18.5.5	The Parties agree that the Early Termination Fee payable from the Defaulting Party or the Affected Party, as applicable, to the Performing Party pursuant to
Section 18.5.2 or 18.5.3 represents a genuine pre-estimate of the minimum loss that the Performing Party will suffer as a result of the termination of this Agreement in the circumstances described in Section 18.5.2 or 18.5.3, and that the
payment of the Early Termination Fee shall be in addition to the payment of any other amounts the Performing Party shall be entitled to in connection with termination pursuant to this Section 18. 

 

	18.6	Additional Remedies Available to MSCG if PBF Is the Defaulting Party or the Affected Party. If a Termination Event has occurred and is continuing and PBF is the
Non-Performing Party, MSCG may, in its sole discretion: (i) demand that PBFC purchase from MSCG all of the MSCG In-Transit Volumes, (ii) arrange for the alternate disposition of any of the MSCG In-Transit Volumes; and (iii) terminate
the assignment of any Supply Contracts or Pipeline agreements from TRC to MSCG resulting in their reversion to TRC where applicable. 

  

	18.7	 Export of Defaults to and Liquidation of Specified Agreements. The occurrence of an Early Termination Date shall constitute a material breach
and an event of default, howsoever described, under all Specified Agreements, and the Performing Party may, by giving a notice to the Non-Performing Party, designate an early termination date (which shall be no earlier than the Early Termination
Date) for all Specified Agreements and, 

  
 40 

 
upon such designation, terminate, liquidate, accelerate and otherwise close out all Specified Agreements that lawfully may be closed out and terminated or, to the extent that in the reasonable
opinion of the Performing Party certain of such Specified Agreements may not be liquidated and terminated under Applicable Law on such date, as soon thereafter as is reasonably practicable. In such event, the Performing Party shall calculate the
payments due upon early termination of such Specified Agreements in accordance with the terms set forth in such Specified Agreements, which shall be aggregated or netted to a single liquidated amount (the “Specified Agreement Close-Out
Amount”) and paid pursuant to the terms of such agreements, or if no payment date is specified, on the payment date specified in Section 18.9. In determining the Specified Agreement Close-Out Amount, the Performing Party may foreclose
upon and apply any collateral provided by or on behalf of the Non-Performing Party under this Agreement or any Specified Agreement. 
  

	18.8	Determination of the Termination Amount in the Event of Early Termination. The amount payable in respect of early termination shall comprise (without
duplication) all of the following amounts, which shall be aggregated or netted to a single liquidated amount (the “Termination Amount”) owing from one Party to the other Party: 

 

	 	18.8.1	if MSCG requires PBF to purchase the MSCG In-Transit Volumes pursuant to Section 18.6, the applicable Price of the MSCG In-Transit Volumes determined in accordance
with Schedule 5 as of the Early Termination Date; 

  

	 	18.8.2	the Specified Agreement Close-Out Amount as determined pursuant to Section 18.7; 

 

	 	18.8.3	the amount of any performance assurance, credit support or collateral provided by or on behalf of PBF under this Agreement or any Specified Agreement held by MSCG at
the Early Termination Date, which shall be applied as a credit to PBF; 

  

	 	18.8.4	Breakage Costs, including, for avoidance of doubt, the losses and costs (or gains) incurred (or realized) by the Performing Party, if MSCG is the Performing Party, in
terminating, transferring, or otherwise modifying any outstanding contracts with Customers (except supply contracts assigned by TRC to MSCG in February 2011); 

 

	 	18.8.5	all Unpaid Amounts, including any purchase price for Crude Oil that has not yet been paid as described in Section 18.4.2; 

 

	 	18.8.6	any other amounts or adjustments that are owed one Party by the other Party under this Agreement or any other Transaction Document; and 

 

	 	18.8.7	the applicable Early Termination Fee, if any, as provided in Section 18.5. 

 

	18.9	Payment of Termination Amount. The Performing Party shall notify the Non-Performing Party of the Termination Amount due from or due such Party. If the
Non-Performing Party owes the Termination Amount to the Performing Party, the Non-Performing Party shall pay the Termination Amount on the second Business Day after it receives the statement. If the Performing Party owes the Termination Amount to
the Non-Performing Party, the Performing Party shall pay the Termination Amount once it has reasonably determined all amounts owed by the Non-Performing Party to it under all Specified Agreements and pursuant to its rights of close-out and setoff
under Section 18.10. 

  
 41 

	18.10	Setoff Rights of Performing Party. If the Performing Party elects to designate an Early Termination Date under Section 18.4.4, the Performing Party shall be
entitled, at its option and in its discretion (and without prior notice to the Non-Performing Party), to setoff against the Termination Amount (whether such Termination Amount is payable to the Performing Party or to the Non-Performing Party) any
other amounts payable under any agreements between the Non-Performing Party and the Performing Party (whether or not matured or contingent and irrespective of the currency, place of payment or place of booking of the obligation, including amounts
payable under any guaranty provided by the Non-Performing Party). To the extent that the Termination Amount is so set off, the Termination Amount and other amounts will be discharged promptly and in all respects. The Performing Party will give
notice to the other Party of any set-off effected under this Section 18.10. 

  

	18.11	Non-Exclusive Remedies. The Performing Party’s rights under this Section 18 are in addition to, and not in limitation or exclusion of, any other rights
of setoff, recoupment, combination of accounts, Lien or other right which it may have, whether by agreement, operation of law or otherwise. No delay or failure on the part of a Performing Party to exercise any right or remedy shall constitute an
abandonment of such right or remedy and the Performing Party shall be entitled to exercise such right or remedy at any time after a Termination Event has occurred and is continuing. 

 

	18.12	Indemnification. The Non-Performing Party shall reimburse the Performing Party for its costs and expenses, including reasonable attorneys’ fees, incurred in
connection with the enforcement of, suing for or collecting any amounts payable by the Non-Performing Party. The Non-Performing Party shall indemnify and hold harmless the Performing Party for any damages, losses and expenses incurred by the
Performing Party as a result of any Termination Event. 

  

	19.	INDEMNIFICATION AND CLAIMS 

 

	19.1	To the fullest extent permitted by Applicable Law and except as specified otherwise elsewhere in this Agreement, PBF shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless MSCG, its
Affiliates, and their Representatives, agents and contractors for and against any Liabilities which is caused by PBF or its Representatives, agents or contractors in performing its obligations under this Agreement, or which is caused by acts or
omissions of TRC that are related to PBF’s performing its obligations under this Agreement, except in each case to the extent that such injury, disease, death, or damage to or loss of property was caused by the negligence or willful misconduct
on the part of MSCG, its Representatives, agents or contractors. 

  

	19.2	PBF agrees to indemnify MSCG for [REDACTED] except to the extent that such liability could have been mitigated by MSCG’s use of commercially reasonable efforts.

  
 42 

	19.3	To the fullest extent permitted by Applicable Law and except as specified otherwise elsewhere in this Agreement, MSCG shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless PBF, its
Affiliates, and their Representatives, agents and contractors for and against any Liabilities caused by MSCG or its Representatives, agents or contractors in performing its obligations under this Agreement, except to the extent that such injury,
disease, death, or damage to or loss of property was caused by the negligence or willful misconduct on the part of PBF, its Representatives, agents or contractors. 

 

	19.4	In addition to the indemnification obligations set forth in Sections 19.1 though 19.3 and elsewhere in this Agreement, each Party (referred to as the
“Indemnifying Party”) shall indemnify and hold the other Party (the “Indemnified Party”), its Affiliates, and their Representatives, agents and contractors, harmless from and against any and all Liabilities directly
or indirectly arising from (i) the Indemnifying Party’s breach of any of its obligations under or covenants made in this Agreement; (ii) the Indemnifying Party’s negligence or willful misconduct, and in the case of PBF,
TRC’s negligence or willful misconduct; (iii) the Indemnifying Party’s, or in the case of PBF, TRC’s, failure to comply with Applicable Law with respect to the sale, transportation, storage, handling or disposal of Crude Oil or
violation of any Environmental Law caused by the Indemnifying Party or its Representatives, agents or contractors, or in the case of PBF, caused by TRC, unless such violation liability results from the Indemnified Party’s negligence or willful
misconduct; or (iv) if any of the Indemnifying Party’s representations, covenants or warranties made herein proves to be materially incorrect or misleading when made. 

 

	19.5	The Parties’ obligations to defend, indemnify, and hold each other harmless under the terms of this Agreement shall not vest any rights in any third party (whether
a Governmental Authority or private entity), nor shall they be considered an admission of liability or responsibility for any purposes other than those enumerated in this Agreement. 

 

	19.6	Each Party agrees to notify the other Party as soon as practicable after receiving notice of any suit brought against it within the indemnities of this Agreement, shall
furnish to the other the complete details within its knowledge and shall render all reasonable assistance requested by the other in the defense. Each Party shall have the right but not the duty to participate, at its own expense, with counsel of its
own selection, in the defense and settlement thereof without relieving the other of any obligations hereunder. Notwithstanding the foregoing, an Indemnifying Party shall not be entitled to assume responsibility for and control of any judicial or
administrative proceeding if such proceeding involves a Termination Event by the Indemnifying Party under this Agreement which shall have occurred and be continuing. 

 

	20.	LIMITATION ON DAMAGES 

 

	20.1	Except for the Parties’ indemnification obligations set forth in this Agreement, or unless otherwise expressly provided in this Agreement, the Parties’
liability for damages is limited to direct, actual damages only and neither Party shall be liable for specific performance, lost profits or other business interruption damages, or special, consequential, incidental, punitive, exemplary or indirect
damages, in tort, contract or otherwise, of any kind, arising out of or in any way connected with the performance, the suspension of performance, the failure to perform, or the termination of this Agreement. Each Party acknowledges the duty to
mitigate damages hereunder. 

  
 43 

	21.	INFORMATION AND INSPECTION RIGHTS 

 

	21.1	Audit Rights. Upon request by either Party, the other Party shall provide the requesting Party with copies of all relevant documents and records in its
possession that reasonably relate to the calculation of any formula, invoice, statement or the amount of any payment under this Agreement, except for any documents or pricing information concerning any of MSCG’s proprietary activities that are
in the custody or control of MSCG or any other person (whether or not related to this Agreement) or MSCG’s hedging activity or trading positions with any person that may have been utilized in connection with any Supply Contracts. Upon request
by MSCG, PBF shall provide MSCG with copies of all relevant documents and records in TRC’s possession that reasonably relate to the calculation of any formula, invoice, statement or the amount of any payment under this Agreement.

  

	21.2	Right to Physical Inspection. From time to time during the Term, MSCG shall have the right, at its own cost and expense, to have an Independent Inspector conduct
surveys and inspections of any of the Tanks or facilities at the Refinery that are used to handle, store or transfer the Crude Oil from the Tanks to the Refinery process units, and to observe any Crude Oil transfer, handling, metering or related
activities; provided however that such surveys and inspections shall be made during normal working hours and upon reasonable notice and shall not disrupt the Refinery’s normal operations, and PBF shall cause TRC to provide MSCG with the
facility access necessary for MSCG to exercise such rights. Such surveys and inspections shall be in compliance with the Refinery’s prevailing rules and procedures, and the Party undertaking such survey or inspection shall be responsible for
its own personnel and representatives. If any dispute between the Parties has not been resolved as of the Early Termination Date or Termination Date, as applicable, MSCG’s inspection rights under this Section 21.2 shall continue for a
period that is the later of (i) the date on which all amounts due by one Party to the other Party as a result of termination or expiration of this Agreement are paid as provided in Section 18 and (ii) removal of or transfer of title
to the Crude Oil owned by MSCG or its consignees or assignees from the Refinery. 

  

	22.	GOVERNANCE COMMITTEE 

 

	22.1	Approved Representatives. The Parties shall each appoint by written notice to the other Party two senior individuals representing them (the “Approved
Representatives”) to be members of a governance committee (the “Governance Committee”) to administer, resolve and determine matters relating to the operation and administration of the Transaction Documents and to keep the
Parties apprised of all material aspects of and developments relating to the Transaction Documents. Each Approved Representative must be currently employed by the appointing Party at all times. Either Party may replace one or both of the individuals
serving as its Approved Representatives in its discretion from time to time upon written notice to the other Party. 

  

	22.2	Meetings of the Governance Committee. The quorum for decision making at a meeting of the Governance Committee shall be not less than one Approved Representative
appointed by each Party. Meetings of the Governance Committee shall be held quarterly or as required to resolve any matter or dispute or if so requested by either of the Parties. 

 

	22.3	 Decisions of the Governance Committee. If agreement is reached in writing, the Governance Committee shall have such written agreement reflected
in a mutually acceptable amendment to this Agreement; provided that revisions to the schedules to this 

  
 44 

 
Agreement may be made upon the mutual agreement of the Authorized Representatives in writing (including by an exchange of e-mails or electronic messages) without a formal amendment. The Parties
agree that the Governance Committee shall have due regard to the Parties’ goals and objectives that were the basis of entering into this Agreement when making any relevant decisions or making any agreement in respect of any matter referred to
it under the Transaction Documents. 
  

	22.4	Third Party Referee. Without prejudice to any provision of this Agreement that sets out a specific time frame for consideration of a matter by the Governance
Committee or for the Parties to have specific rights following the Governance Committee failing to agree on matters referred to it, in the event the Governance Committee cannot reach agreement within 30 Business Days on any matter before it, after
consulting in good faith and using all reasonable efforts to reach agreement, such matter or dispute shall be referred to an independent third party for resolution. The independent third party shall have an expertise in the subject matter and shall
be mutually agreed upon by the Parties. The third party’s determination shall be in the form of a written opinion, as is appropriate under the circumstances, to be delivered within 30 days of submission of the dispute to the firm or as soon
thereafter as the firm can reasonably render its decision, and shall confirm that it was rendered in accordance with this Section 22, including that it was arrived at with due regard to the contract objectives. The fees and expenses of such
third party for its services in resolving such dispute shall be borne equally by the Parties. With respect to any matters before the Governance Committee, the Parties agree that a Party shall not take action under Section 23 until the
procedures of this Section 22 have been completed; provided, however, that any applicable statute of limitations shall be tolled during such period and either Party may seek immediate injunctive relief if so required. 

 

	23.	GOVERNING LAW AND DISPUTES 

 

	23.1	Governing Law. This Agreement and all matters arising in connection therewith, including validity and enforcement, shall be governed by, interpreted and
construed in accordance with the laws of the State of New York, without giving effect to its conflicts of laws principles that would result in the application of a different law. Each Party hereby submits itself to the exclusive jurisdiction of any
federal court of competent jurisdiction situated in the Borough of Manhattan, State of New York or, if any federal court declines to exercise or does not have jurisdiction, in any New York state court in the Borough of Manhattan, State of New York
and to service of process by certified mail, delivered to the Party at its last designated address. 

  

	23.2	EACH PARTY HEREBY IRREVOCABLY WAIVES, TO THE
FULLEST EXTENT PERMITTED BY APPLICABLE LAW, ANY OBJECTION TO THE JURISDICTION
OF ANY SUCH COURT OR TO THE VENUE THEREIN OR ANY CLAIM
OF INCONVENIENT FORUM OF SUCH COURT. EACH PARTY WAIVES, TO THE
FULLEST EXTENT PERMITTED BY APPLICABLE LAW, ANY RIGHT IT MAY HAVE TO
A TRIAL BY JURY IN RESPECT OF ANY PROCEEDINGS RELATING TO THIS
AGREEMENT. EACH PARTY IRREVOCABLY AGREES TO DESIGNATE ANY PROCEEDING RELATING TO
THIS AGREEMENT BROUGHT IN THE COURTS OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
AS “COMMERCIAL” ON THE REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL INTERVENTION SEEKING ASSIGNMENT
TO THE COMMERCIAL DIVISION OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF
NEW YORK. 

  

	23.3	 Availability of Remedies. The Parties acknowledge and agree that damages may not be an adequate remedy for a breach of the provisions of this
Agreement. For this reason, 

  
 45 

 
among others, the Parties could be irreparably harmed if this Agreement is not deemed to be specifically enforceable or any other legal or equitable remedy or relief is deemed not to be
available, and the Parties hereby agree that, without prejudice to Section 18, this Agreement shall be specifically enforceable and that all other legal and equitable remedies and relief shall be available. 

 

	24.	ASSIGNMENT 

  

	24.1	This Agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of the Parties and their respective successors and permitted assigns. 

 

	24.2	A Party may not assign or otherwise transfer any of its rights or obligations or subcontract or delegate in whole or in part the performance of any of its obligations
under this Agreement to any person without the prior written consent of the other Party, except as set forth in Section 24.3; provided, that if a Party requests assignment or transfer of this Agreement to an Affiliate, consent shall not be
unreasonably withheld. If written consent is given for any assignment, the assignor shall remain jointly and severally liable with the assignee for the full performance of the assignor’s obligations under this Agreement, unless the Parties
otherwise agree in writing. 

  

	24.3	Either Party may assign its receivables under this Agreement to a third party without the consent of the other Party. 

 

	24.4	Any prohibited assignment in violation of this Section 24 shall be null and void ab initio and the non-assigning Party shall have the right, without
prejudice to any other rights or remedies it may have hereunder or otherwise, to terminate this Agreement effective immediately upon notice to the Party attempting such assignment. 

 

	25.	NOTICES 

  

	25.1	Notices in Writing. Any notice, demand or document that a Party is required or may desire to give hereunder, except to the extent specifically provided otherwise
herein, must be (i) in writing and (ii) given by personal delivery, overnight courier, facsimile, or U.S. mail registered or certified mail, return receipt requested, with the postage prepaid and properly addressed or communicated to such
Party at its address or facsimile number set forth in Section 25.2, or at such other address as either Party may have furnished to the other by notice given in accordance with this Section 25.1. Other than notices relating to a Potential
Event of Default, a Termination Event, termination of this Agreement, indemnification, assignment and disputes, notice may also be given by electronic mail at such e-mail address as is typically used for such type of matter in the conduct of the
recipient’s business. Any notice delivered or made by personal delivery, overnight courier, facsimile, or U.S. mail shall be deemed to be given on the date of actual delivery as shown by the receipt for personal delivery or overnight courier
delivery, the addresser’s machine confirmation for facsimile delivery, or the registry or certification receipt for registered or certified mail. 

  
 46 

	25.2	Addresses. 

 If to
PBF: 
 PBF Holding Company LLC 
 1 Sylvan Way, 2nd floor 
 Parsippany, NJ 07054-3887 

Attention: Executive Vice President, Commercial 
 With a copy to: 
 PBF Holding Company LLC 

1 Sylvan Way, 2nd floor 
 Parsippany, NJ 07054-3887 
 Attention: General Counsel 

If to MSCG: 
 Morgan Stanley Capital Group Inc. 
 2000 Westchester Avenue, Floor 01 

Purchase, New York 10577-2530 
 Attention: Randall O’Connor 
 Phone: 914-225-1466 

Facsimile: 914-225-9298 
 E-mail: randall.o’connor@morganstanley.com 
 With a copy to: 

Morgan Stanley Capital Group Inc. 
 2000 Westchester Avenue, Floor 01 
 Purchase, New York 10577-2530 

Attention: Kenneth Carlino 
 Phone: 914-225-1417 
 Facsimile: 914-225-9299 

E-mail: kenneth.carlino@morganstanley.com 
  

	26.	NATURE OF THE TRANSACTION AND RELATIONSHIP OF
THE PARTIES 

  

	26.1	Neither this Agreement nor any other Transaction Document or transaction under any of them, nor the performance by the Parties of their respective obligations under
this Agreement, any other Transaction Document or any transaction, shall constitute or create a joint venture, partnership or legal entity of any kind between the Parties. It is understood that each Party has complete charge of its employees and
agents in the performance of its duties hereunder, and nothing herein shall be construed to make a Party, or any employee or agent of such Party, an agent or employee of another Party. A Party shall not have any authority (unless expressly conferred
in writing under this Agreement or otherwise and not revoked) to bind another Party as its agent or otherwise. 

  

	27.	CONFIDENTIALITY 

 

	27.1	 This Agreement and all documents related to the foregoing and any information pertaining thereto made available by a Party or its Representatives to
the other Party or its Representatives, are confidential (collectively, “Confidential Information”). Each Party shall at a minimum use the same efforts and standard of care with respect to Confidential Information provided by the
other Party that it uses to preserve its own confidential 

  
 47 

 
information, and in no event less than reasonable efforts. Confidential Information shall not be discussed with or disclosed to any third party by any Party except for such information
(i) as may become generally available to the public through no breach of this Section 27.1 or any other agreement between the Parties, (ii) as may be required or appropriate in response to any summons, subpoena or otherwise in
connection with any litigation or to comply with any Applicable Law or accounting disclosure rule or standard or request by any supervisory or regulatory authority, (iii) as may be obtained from a non-confidential source that disclosed such
information in a manner that did not violate its obligations to the other Party or its credit support provider in making such disclosure, or (iv) as may be furnished to the disclosing Party’s Affiliates or to its Representatives, all of
whom are required to keep the information that is disclosed in confidence. This provision shall remain in effect for two years following the termination of this Agreement. 

 

	27.2	In the case of disclosure covered by clause (ii) of Section 27.1, and if the disclosing Party’s counsel advises that it is permissible to do so, the
disclosing Party shall notify the other Party in writing of any proceeding of which it is aware which may result in disclosure, and use reasonable efforts to prevent or limit such disclosure. The Parties may exercise all remedies available at law or
in equity to enforce or seek relief in connection with the confidentiality obligations contained in this Agreement. 

  

	28.	MISCELLANEOUS 

  

	28.1	Survival. Termination or expiration of this Agreement shall not affect any rights or obligations that may have accrued prior to termination, including any in
respect of antecedent breaches and, for the avoidance of doubt but subject to the terms of this Agreement, any rights or obligations under this Agreement or any of the other Transaction Documents in respect of transactions entered into up to and
including the date of termination or expiration of this Agreement, except as expressly provided herein. The obligations of each Party that expressly survive termination, are required to take effect on or give effect to termination or the
consequences of termination or which by their very nature must survive termination, shall continue in full force and effect notwithstanding termination of this Agreement. 

 

	28.2	Entire Agreement; Amendments. This Agreement constitutes the entire agreement of the Parties regarding the matters contemplated herein or related thereto, and no
representations or warranties shall be implied or provisions added hereto in the absence of a written agreement to such effect between the Parties after the Effective Date; provided, however, that nothing in this Agreement shall limit,
impair or contravene the Parties’ or their Affiliates’ rights as set forth in any Specified Agreement (whether entered into prior to, on or after the Effective Date) regarding the collection and determination of margin and collateral, the
exporting or importing of events of default, termination events, or the netting and setting off of amounts due. This Agreement may not be altered, amended, modified or otherwise changed in any respect except in writing duly executed by an authorized
representative of each Party and no representations or warranties shall be implied or terms added in the absence of a writing signed by both Parties. No promise, representation or inducement has been made by either Party that is not embodied in this
Agreement, and neither Party shall be bound by or liable for any alleged representation, promise or inducement not so set forth. 

  
 48 

	28.3	Severability. If at any time any court of competent jurisdiction declares any provision of this Agreement is or becomes illegal, invalid or unenforceable in any
respect under any Applicable Law of any jurisdiction, neither the legality, validity or enforceability of the remaining provisions nor the legality, validity or enforceability of such provision under the Applicable Law of any other jurisdiction
will, in any way, be affected or impaired. The Parties will negotiate in good faith with a view to reform this Agreement in order to give effect to the original intention of the Parties and produce as nearly as is practicable in all the
circumstances the appropriate balance of the commercial interests of the Parties. The failure to agree upon such provisions for any reason or no reason shall not be considered a breach of this Agreement. 

 

	28.4	Waiver and Cumulative Remedies. No failure to exercise, nor any delay in exercising, any right, power or remedy under this Agreement or provided by Applicable
Law shall operate as a waiver, nor shall any single or partial exercise of any right or remedy prevent any further or other exercise or the exercise of any other right or remedy. The rights and remedies provided in this Agreement are cumulative and
not exclusive of any rights or remedies (provided by Applicable Law or otherwise). Any waiver of any breach of this Agreement shall not be deemed to be a waiver of any subsequent breach. 

 

	28.5	Time Is of the Essence. Time shall be of the essence for this Agreement with respect to all aspects of each Party’s performance of its obligations under
this Agreement. 

  

	28.6	No Third-Party Beneficiaries. There are no third party beneficiaries to this Agreement and the provisions of this Agreement shall not impart any legal or
equitable right, remedy or claim enforceable by any person, firm or organization other than the Parties and their successors in interest and permitted assigns. 

 

	28.7	Announcements. At no time during the Term of this Agreement, and for a period of two years following its expiration or termination, shall any Party issue any
press announcement or public statement regarding this Agreement without the prior written consent of the other Party, which shall not be unreasonably withheld, delayed or conditioned, except as may be required by Applicable Law or to the extent
public disclosure is required under the circumstances described in any relevant confidentiality agreement entered into between the Parties. The issuing Party will: 

 

	 	28.7.1	use all reasonable efforts to notify the other Party of the content of such announcement at least three Business Days prior to such issue (unless otherwise required by
Applicable Law or to the extent public disclosure is required under the circumstances described in any relevant confidentiality agreement entered into by the Parties); and 

 

	 	28.7.2	take the other Party’s comments on the proposed announcement into account as is reasonable in the circumstances, provided such comments are received within two
Business Days of the notification. 

  

	28.8	Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed by the Parties in separate counterparts and all such counterparts shall together constitute one and the same
instrument. In the event that any signature is delivered by facsimile transmission, such signature shall create a valid and binding obligation of the Party executing (or on whose behalf the signature is executed) the same with the same force and
effect as if such facsimile signature page were an original thereof. 

  
 49 

 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, each Party hereto has caused this Agreement to be executed by its duly authorized
representative. 
  

			
	Executed by
	
	MORGAN STANLEY CAPITAL GROUP INC.
	
	/s/ Nancy King
		
	Name:	 	Nancy King
		
	Title:	 	Vice President
		
	Date:	 	2/29/12

  

			
	Executed by
	
	PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC
	
	/s/ Jeffrey Dill
		
	Name:	 	Jeffrey Dill
		
	Title:	 	Secretary
		
	Date:	 	2/28/12

  
 50 

 SCHEDULE 1 – PIPELINES 
 Canada Pipelines: 
  

	(1)	Peace Pipeline Limited 

	(2)	Pembina Pipeline – Northern Pipeline (formerly Federated), Drayton Valley Pipeline, Alberta Oil Sands Pipeline 

	(3)	Rainbow Pipeline Limited 

	(4)	Enbridge Pipeline – Mainline 

	(5)	Husky Mainline 

	(6)	Suncor Mainline 

	(7)	Keystone Pipeline 

 United States Pipelines:

  

	(8)	Belle Fourche Pipeline 

	(9)	Enbridge Pipeline (North Dakota) LLC 

	(10)	Enbridge Energy, Limited Partnership (Lakehead) 

	(11)	Enbridge Merchant Pipeline (Cushing) 

	(12)	Enterprise Product Partners LP (Midland) 

	(13)	Mesa Pipeline 

	(14)	Plains All American Pipeline (Basin and Cushing) 

	(15)	Sunoco Logistics Partners L.P. (Millenium, Nederland Terminal, Tulsa/Cushing) 

	(16)	West Texas Gulf Pipeline 

	(17)	BKPL – Sun Pipeline – Buckeye 

	(18)	EQO1 – Shell So. LA System 

	(19)	SGUF – Sun Pipeline Gulf Coast 

	(20)	SPCT – Sun Pipeline Central Texas 

	(21)	SPOK – Sun Pipeline Oklahoma 

	(22)	SWAY – Seaway Pipeline 

	(23)	WMO1 – Sun Pipeline Barnsdall 

	(24)	CHAP – Chi Cap 

	(25)	BUFF – Koch Gathering System 

	(26)	CHDS – Deep Sea Terminal 

	(27)	PENZ – Penzoil 

 SCHEDULE 2 – TRANSFER POINTS AND PRICING DATES 

 

					
	 Delivery Location
	  	 Transfer Point
	  	 Pricing Date*

			
		  	Pipeline: As the Crude Oil passes the downstream flange of the meter measuring receipt of Crude Oil upon intake.	  	 [REDACTED]

			
	Marysville, Michigan	  	Tank: As the Crude Oil passes the inlet flange of PBF’s storage tank to which the Crude Oil is being delivered.	  	
			
	Patoka, Illinois	  	As the Crude Oil passes the downstream flange of the Marathon Eastern Trunk pipeline meter measuring receipt of Crude Oil upon intake.	  	 [REDACTED]

			
	Cushing, Oklahoma	  	As the Crude Oil passes the downstream flange of the Ozark pipeline meter measuring receipt of Crude Oil upon intake.	  	 [REDACTED]

			
	Longview, Texas	  	As the Crude Oil passes the downstream flange of the pipeline meter measuring receipt of Crude Oil upon intake.	  	 [REDACTED]

			
	St. James, Louisiana	  	As the Crude Oil passes the downstream flange of the pipeline meter measuring receipt of Crude Oil upon intake.	  	 [REDACTED]

			
	 Mid-Valley Pipeline at

Clarkson, Kentucky
	  	As the Crude Oil passes the downstream flange of the pipeline meter measuring receipt of Crude Oil upon intake.	  	 [REDACTED]

			
	 Mid-Valley Pipeline at

Haynesville, Louisiana
	  	As the Crude Oil passes the downstream flange of the pipeline meter measuring receipt of Crude Oil upon intake.	  	 [REDACTED]

			
	Detroit, Michigan	  	As the Crude Oil passes the in-take flange of the relevant tank at the Buckeye Woodhaven terminal.	  	 [REDACTED]

  

	*	If the Pricing Date falls on a day that is not a Business Day, then the Pricing Date shall be the next following Business Day. 

 SCHEDULE 3 – FORM OF NOMINATION AND FORECAST REPORT 

Form of Nomination and Forecast Report 

All Dates and Volume Data are Included for Illustrative Purposes Only 

 

			
	 Date of Nomination:
	  	February 19, 2011
	 Delivery Month 1:
	  	March 2011
	 Delivery Month 2:
	  	April 2011
	 Delivery Month 3:
	  	May 2011
	 Delivery Month 4:
	  	Jun 2011
	 Delivery Month 5:
	  	July 2011
	 Form Author:
	  	PBF
	 Report Frequency:
	  	Prior to the 20th of every month
	 Scheduled Maintenance:
	  	[Insert dates/comments if any]

  

																					
	Delivery Month	  	1	 	 	2	 	 	3	 	 	4	 	 	5	 
	 Crude Oil Grade
	  	Volume (MBPD)	 
	 Domestic Sweet
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Syncrude
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Alberta Common Synthetic (ACS)
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Michigan Sweet
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 North Dakota Sweet
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Canadian Sweet
	  	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  
	 North Louisiana Sweet
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 LLS
	  	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  
	 Kentucky Sweet
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 West Texas Sour
	  	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  
	 LEF Composite
	  	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  
	 West Texas Intermediate
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Gulf Coast B
	  	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 Total
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		
	 Crude Oil Logistics
	  	Volume (MBPD)	 
	 West Texas Gulf Pipeline
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Mid Valley Pipeline
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Marysville Pipeline
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Ozark Pipeline
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Marathon Pipeline
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 

 SCHEDULE 4 – FORM OF WEEKLY NOMINATION 

Form of Weekly Nomination 
 All
Dates and Volume Data are Included for Illustrative Purposes Only 
  

					
	 Date of Nomination:
	  	February 17, 2011	  	
	 Form Author:
	  	PBF	  	
	 Report Frequency:
	  	On Each Business Day	  	
	 Scheduled Maintenance:
	  	[Insert dates/comments if any]	  	

  

																													
	Volume in Barrels	  	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 
	 	  	Tank #	 	 	Total Crude 
Oil
Requirement	 
	 Date
	  	405	 	 	408	 	 	409	 	 	410	 	 	412	 	 	413	 	 
	 18-Feb-11
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 19-Feb-11
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 20-Feb-11
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 21-Feb-11
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 22-Feb-11
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 23-Feb-11
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 24-Feb-11
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 Total
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 

 SCHEDULE 5 – CRUDE OIL PRICING FORMULAS 

The prices for MSCG’s sales of Nominated Volumes to PBF would be calculated as follows: 
 Price (in USD per barrel, for delivery to PBF at the Transfer Point) = A + B + C + D, where: 
  

	A  =	[REDACTED] 

  

	B  =	[REDACTED] 

  

	C  =	 [REDACTED] 

	D  =	[REDACTED] 

 General Provisions

 The Volumes listed above will be adjusted according to the crude oil selection and nomination provisions in Section 5 of the
Agreement. 

 SCHEDULE 6 – FORM OF WTI DIFFERENTIAL REPORT 

			
	WTI Differential Report	  	Illustrative Example

  

									
	Assumptions	  	 	 	 	 	  	 
	 Refinery Run Month
	  	 	Apr-11	  	 		  	
	 Injection Month
	  	 	Mar-11	  	 		  	
	 Spread Month
	  	 	Feb-11	  	 		  	
	 Refinery Run Rate
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	MBD	  	
	 Days in Run Month
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	Days	  	
	 Total Volume for Apr-11
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	MB	  	
	 Total Number of Spreads to Place in Spread Month
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	MB	  	

 Nymex WTI Profile 
  

																			
	 Injection Month Prompt Month
	 	 	Run Month	  	Prompt Month	  	 	 	 	 
	 Pricing Days
	  	Nymex WTI Contract	  	 	  	 	 	 	Pricing Days	  	Nymex WTI Contract	  	 	 	 	 
	 1-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  	Apr CL Prompt	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	1-Apr	  	May CL	  	May CL Prompt	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 2-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  	May CL “Prompt”	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	4-Apr	  	May CL	  	Jun CL “Prompt”	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 3-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  	Total Days	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	5-Apr	  	May CL	  	Total Days	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 4-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  		  				 	6-Apr	  	May CL	  		 			
	 7-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  	Apr CL %	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	7-Apr	  	May CL	  	May CL %	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 8-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  	May CL %	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	8-Apr	  	May CL	  	Jun CL %	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 9-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  		  				 	11-Apr	  	May CL	  		 			
	 10-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  		  				 	12-Apr	  	May CL	  		 			
	 11-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  		  				 	13-Apr	  	May CL	  		 			
	 14-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  		  				 	14-Apr	  	May CL	  		 			
	 15-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  		  				 	15-Apr	  	May CL	  		 			
	 16-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  		  				 	18-Apr	  	May CL	  		 			
	 17-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  		  				 	19-Apr	  	May CL	  		 			
	 18-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  		  				 	20-Apr	  	June CL	  		 			
	 21-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  		  				 	21-Apr	  	June CL	  		 			
	 22-Mar
	  	Apr CL	  		  				 	25-Apr	  	June CL	  		 			
	 23-Mar
	  	May CL	  		  				 	26-Apr	  	June CL	  		 			
	 24-Mar
	  	May CL	  		  				 	27-Apr	  	June CL	  		 			
	 25-Mar
	  	May CL	  		  				 	28-Apr	  	June CL	  		 			
	 28-Mar
	  	May CL	  		  				 	29-Apr	  	June CL	  		 			
	 29-Mar
	  	May CL	  		  				 		  		  		 			
	 30-Mar
	  	May CL	  		  				 		  		  		 			
	 31-Mar
	  	May CL	  		  				 		  		  		 			

 WTI Price and Spread Profile 
  

																									
	Nymex WTI Pricing as of COB	  	January 20, 2011	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 
							
	 Contract
	  	Feb-11	 	 	Mar-11	 	 	Apr-11	 	 	 	 	 	May-11	 	 	Jun-11	 
	 Price ($/bbl)
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Long Position (MB)
	  	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  
	 Short Position (MB)
	  	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
							
	 Market Structure Differential Calculation
	  				 				 				 				 				 			
							
	 Buy Apr/May
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	MB @ spread of	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	/bbl	  	 				 			
	 Buy Apr/Jun
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	MB @ spread of	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	/bbl	  	 				 			
	 Buy May/Jun
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	MB @ spread of	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	/bbl	  	 				 			
	 Total / Wtd. Avg.
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	MB @ spread of	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	/bbl	  	 				 			
		  	  
	  
	 	 				 				 				 				 			
							
	 Total Market Structure Differential
	  				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 			

  

 SCHEDULE 7 – ESTIMATED TRANSIT TIME AND TVM COST CALCULATION METHODOLOGY

 Crude Oil Transit Time and TVM Cost Calculation 
 Illustrative TVM Cost Calculation 
 (Number of Days) 

 

																																	
	 	  	 	 	 	Receivable Days	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 
	 	  	Total Transit Time	 	 	Transit Time	 	 	Average	 	 	Payment	 	 	Total	 	 	Total	 	 	Interest	 	 	 	 
	 Injection
Point
	  	to Delivery Point	 	 	Post Delivery Point	 	 	Tank Time	 	 	Term	 	 	Receivable Days	 	 	TVM Days	 	 	Rate	 	 	TVM Charge	 
	 Enbridge P/L
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 Edmonton
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Hardisty
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Regina
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Cromer
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Clearbrook
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Lewiston
	  	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Marysville
	  	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Alexander
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Stanley
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Trenton
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
									
	 Mid-Valley P/L
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 Midland
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Colorado City
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Abilene
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Longview
	  	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Clarkson
	  	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Haynesville
	  	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
									
	 Marathon P/L
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 Cushing
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Patoka
	  	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Grade
	  	 	OSA	  	 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 Volume (Bbls)
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 Base Price before TVM ($/Bbl)
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 Capital Usage ($)
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 Injection Point
	  	 	Edmonton	  	 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 TVM Charge
	  	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 TVM Cost ($)
	  	  
 
	 [REDACTED
 
	 ] 
  
	 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 ($/Bbl)
	  	 
 	[REDACTED
 	] 
  	 				 				 				 				 				 				 			

 SCHEDULE 8 – LOGISTICS COSTS 

The below tariffs are intended to be reflective of actual published tariffs. 
 All tariffs are expressed in US Cents/bbls. 
  

					
	 Tariff Schedule
	  	 	 
	 	  	Cents/Bbl	 
	 Mesa / West Texas Gulf
	  			
	 Midland to Midland Pumpover
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Midland to Colorado City
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Colorado City to Longview
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Abilene to Longview
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 
		
	 Millenium
	  			
	 Nederland to Longview
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 
		
	 Ozark
	  			
	 Enterprise to Enbridge Pumpover
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 
		
	 Sunoco Pipeline L.P.
	  			
	 Tulsa to Cushing
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 

 Tariff from Origins along Enbridge System to Marysville by Grade 

 

																													
	 Grade
	  	Cents/Bbl	 
	  	Edmonton	 	 	Hardisty	 	 	Kerrobert	 	 	Regina	 	 	Cromer	 	 	Clearbrook	 	 	Lewiston	 
	 CNS
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 HSB
	  				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 				 				 			
	 MST
	  				 				 				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 			
	 MSW
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 				 			
	 NSA
	  				 				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 			
	 OSA
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 PAS
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 OPTI/PSC
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 SSX
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 Syncrude
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 				 				 				 			
	 UHC
	  				 				 				 				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 			
	 UHL
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 

 SCHEDULE 9 – ENBRIDGE NORTH DAKOTA LINE TERMS 

 

			
	 Term:
	  	Effective for the month of [REDACTED] and continuing as per the terms and conditions of the Crude Oil Supply Agreement between MSCG and PBF.
		
	 Quantity:
	  	Equal to [REDACTED]% of PBF’s owned or controlled allocated space on Enbridge’s Pipeline’s North Dakota’s system from Alexander, Trenton, Stanley and/or any
other location(s) on the Enbridge system to Clearbrook, MN. This volume is currently estimated to be approximately [REDACTED] per day.
		
	 Quality:
	  	 [REDACTED]

	
	 MSCG’s Sale to PBF

		
	 Price:
	  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	For pricing purposes, the oil delivered during any given Calendar month shall be deemed to have been delivered in equal daily quantities during such month.
		
	 Delivery:
	  	Delivery shall be made and title and risk of loss shall pass from MSCG to PBF as the crude oil is transferred within a location upstream of the facilities of Enbridge Pipeline
North Dakota system at Alexander and/or Stanley and/or Trenton, ND.
	
	 MSCG’s Purchase from PBF

		
	 Price:
	  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	For pricing purposes, the oil delivered during any given Calendar month shall be deemed to have been delivered in equal daily quantities during such month.
		
	 Delivery:
	  	Delivery shall be made and title and risk of loss shall pass from PBF to MSCG as the crude oil is transferred within the facilities of Enbridge Pipeline North Dakota system at
Clearbrook, MN.
		
	 Payment:
	  	Shall be made on the 20th of the month following the month of delivery upon presentation of a faxed invoice and appropriate pipeline documentation verifying volumes. Payment will
be made via wire transfer.

 SCHEDULE 10 – HEDGE ADJUSTMENT AMOUNT 

Calculation of June 2011 Hedge Adjustment Amount (for July CL) 

 

																																	
	 	  	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	MSCG’s Hedging for PBF Account	 
	 	  	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	Cumulative	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	Cumulative	 
	 	  	TAS	 	 	Ratable	 	 	Actual	 	 	Daily	 	 	Inventory	 	 	Hedging to Offset	 	 	Contract	 	 	Hedging	 
	 	  	WTI	 	 	Sale	 	 	Consumption	 	 	Imbalance	 	 	Build/(Draw)	 	 	Daily Imbalance	 	 	Roll	 	 	Position	 
	 Date
	  	($/bbl)	 	 	(Bbls)	 	 	(Bbls)	 	 	(Bbls)	 	 	(Bbls)	 	 	(Bbls)	 	 	(Bbls)	 	 	(Bbls)	 
	 5/20/2011 (End of Prior Period)
	  				 				 				 				 	 	—  	  	 				 				 	 	—  	  
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 5/21/2011
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 5/22/2011
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 5/23/2011 (Beginning of Period)
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 	 	—  	  	 				 	 	—  	  
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 5/24/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 5/25/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 5/26/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 5/27/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 5/28/2011
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 5/29/2011
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 5/30/2011
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 5/31/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/1/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/2/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/3/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/4/2011
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/5/2011
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/6/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/7/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/8/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/9/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/10/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/11/2011
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/12/2011
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/13/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/14/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/15/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/16/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/17/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/18/2011
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/19/2011
	  				 				 				 				 				 				 				 			
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/20/2011
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 6/21/2011 (End of Period)
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	—  	  
		  	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 	 	  
	  
	 
	 Total
	  				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 			

  

					
	 Hedge Adjustment Amount Calculation
	  	 	 
	 Sum of Purchase/Sale of July CL
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Roll July to August CL
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  
	  
	 
	 Total Hedge Adjustment Amount
	  	 	[REDACTED	]Form of stock option agreement

 Exhibit 10.1 
 Form Agreement 
 NON-QUALIFIED
STOCK OPTION AGREEMENT 
 This Non-Qualified Stock Option Agreement
(“Agreement”) is entered into as of the Grant Date specified below, by and between [            ] (“Participant”) and ExactTarget, Inc., a Delaware corporation
(“Company”). 
 1. Option Grant. The Company has granted to the Participant a Non-Qualified Stock Option
(“Option”) to purchase shares of the common stock of the Company pursuant to the ExactTarget, Inc. 2008 Equity Incentive Plan (“Plan”), subject to the terms and conditions of the Plan and this Agreement. The Option terms include
the following: 
  

	 	(a)	Grant Date: [            ] 

 

	 	(b)	Number of Shares Subject to Option: [            ] 

 

	 	(c)	Exercise Price per Share: [$            ] 

 

	 	(d)	Expiration Date: [Ten Years after Grant Commencement Date] 

 The Option is subject to the terms of the Plan, which are incorporated by reference as if fully set out herein. By signing this Agreement, the Participant acknowledges that he/she has received a
Prospectus for the Plan and been given the opportunity to receive a copy of the Plan. 
 2. Defined Terms and Rules of
Construction. Except as otherwise defined herein, capitalized terms shall have the meanings specified by the Plan, and the rules of construction specified in the Plan shall apply to this Agreement as well. In addition, the following terms, when
capitalized herein, shall have the meanings set out below: 
 “Exercise Notice” means a written notice on a form
acceptable to the Company that satisfies the requirements of Section 5 of this Agreement. 
 “Expiration Date”
means the date specified in Subsection 1(d). 
 “Option Shares” means the Shares subject to the Option. 

“Securities Act” means the Securities Act of 1933, as amended from time to time. 

“Transferee” means a trust to which the Participant has transferred his rights hereunder, with approval of the Committee,
provided that such trust is a grantor trust and the Participant and his family members (as defined in the following sentence) own more than 50% of the beneficial interests under such trust. For purposes of the preceding sentence, “family
member” means the Participant’s current or former spouse, child, stepchild, and parent, including adoptive relationships. 
 3. Vesting and Exercisability. Unless more rapid vesting is required by the Plan or another provision of this Agreement, the Option shall become vested and exercisable as follows: 

(a) With respect to 25% of the Option Shares, on the first anniversary of the Grant Date, provided that the Participant has not Separated
from Service before such date. 

 (b) With respect to 1/48th of the Option Shares, on the same day of the month as the first
anniversary of the Grant Date in each of the 36 months next following the month in which the first anniversary of the Grant Date occurs, provided, however, no further vesting shall occur after the Participant’s Separation from Service.

 4. Non-Transferability. Neither the Option nor any portion thereof may be transferred, sold, pledged, assigned,
hypothecated, or disposed of in any manner by the Participant other than by will or the laws of descent and distribution to the extent hereinafter set forth or by a donative transfer to a Transferee approved by the Committee. The Option may be
exercised during the Participant’s lifetime only by the Participant or Transferee or, upon the Participant’s legal incapacity to act on his or her own behalf, by the Participant’s conservator or other lawful representative. The Option
shall be null and void and without effect upon any attempted assignment or transfer, except as hereinabove provided, including without limitation, any purported assignment, whether voluntary or by operation of law, pledge, hypothecation, or other
disposition contrary to the provisions hereof, or levy of execution, attachment, trustee process, or similar process, whether legal or equitable, upon the Option. 
 5. Method of Exercise and Payment. 
 (a) The Option may be exercised from
time to time, in whole or part, to the extent then vested and exercisable, only by the person exercising the Option providing an executed Exercise Notice to the Treasurer of the Company at the Company’s principal offices, stating the
holder’s election to exercise the Option and the total number of whole Shares to be purchased. If the person exercising the Option is not the Participant, he/she must submit acceptable proof of his/her right to exercise the Option. 

(b) At the time of exercise, the person exercising the Option shall (i) pay the full Exercise Price for the Shares purchased pursuant
to the Option and (ii) provide for the payment of funds to the Company of applicable tax withholding, by check payable to the order of the Company, or in such other form of consideration permitted by the Plan as the Committee, in its sole
discretion, may deem appropriate. To the extent permitted by the Committee and applicable securities laws, an Option holder may use an approved broker-assisted exercise program for exercise of the Option and the payment of withholding taxes. No such
program may be used during any period in which the holder is prohibited from selling Shares. 
 (c) As soon as practicable after
the Company receives the Exercise Notice and exercise price (including tax withholding), it shall deliver the person exercising the Option, in the name of such person, a certificate or certificates representing the purchased Option Shares (or
provide for direct registration of the Shares by book-entry in the name of the person exercising the Option). In the case of a broker-assisted cashless exercise, shall certificates may be issued to the broker. 

6. Termination of Option. To the extent that any portion of the Option has not been exercised in full before its termination or
Expiration Date, whichever is earlier, it shall terminate and become void and of no effect on such date. In addition, if the Participant Separates from Service, the Option shall terminate as provided below: 

(a) If the Participant incurs a Separation from Service at a time when Cause exists, the Option shall terminate upon the
Participant’s Separation from Service (unless it expires or is terminated pursuant to another provision of the Plan or this Agreement before such time). 

  
 2 

 (b) If the Participant incurs a Separation from Service not described in Subsection
(a) above, the Option shall terminate three months after the Participant’s Separation from Service (unless the Option expires or is terminated pursuant to another provision of the Plan or this Agreement before such time). 

7. Investment Representations. In connection with his exercise of the Option, the option holder shall, to the extent requested to
do so by the Company, make appropriate investment representations and warranties, as determined by the Company. 
 8.
Market Lock-Out. By exercising all or part of the Option, the option holder agrees that, in connection with any underwritten public offering by the Company of its equity securities pursuant to an effective registration statement filed under the
Securities Act of 1933, as amended, the option holder will not sell, make any short sale of, loan, hypothecate, pledge, grant any option for the repurchase of, or otherwise dispose of or transfer for value or otherwise agree to engage in any of the
foregoing transactions with respect to any Option Shares without the prior written consent of the Company or its underwriters, for such period of time from and after the effective date of such registration statement as may be requested by the
Company or such underwriters. 
 9. Securities Law Requirements. If the Committee determines that issuing Shares pursuant
to the Plan or otherwise carrying out any term of this Agreement or the Plan would violate applicable securities laws, the Company shall not be required to issue such Shares or carry out such term. 

10. Indemnification. The Participant agrees to hold the Company and its officers, managers, and controlling persons (as defined in
the Securities Act), and any persons affiliated with any of them or with the issuance of the Option harmless from all expenses, liabilities, and damages (including reasonable attorneys’ fees) (i) deriving from a disposition of the Option
or the Option Shares in a manner that violates the Securities Act or of any applicable state securities law or (ii) that may be suffered by any person by reason of any breach of a representation required of the Participant by this Agreement or
the Plan. 
 11. No Right to Continued Service. This Agreement does not confer on the Participant any right to continued
employment or service with the Company (or its parent or subsidiary) or interfere in any way with the right of the Company (or its parent or subsidiary) to terminate the Participant’s employment or service at any time. 

12. Notices. All notices, requests and other communications hereunder shall be in writing and, if given by telegram, telecopy or
telex, shall be deemed to have been validly served, given or delivered when sent; if given by personal delivery, shall be deemed to have been validly served, given or delivered upon actual delivery; and, if mailed, shall be deemed to have been
validly served, given or delivered three business days after deposit in the United States mail, as required or certified mail, with proper postage prepaid and addressed to the party or parties to be notified, at the following addresses (or such
other address(es) as a party may designate for itself by like notice): 
  

			
	If to the Company:	  	 ExactTarget, Inc.
 20 N.
Meridian St., Suite 200
 Indianapolis, IN 46204
 Attn: Human Resources

  
 3 

			
		
	With a copy to:	  	 Steven K. Humke
 Ice Miller
LLP
 One American Square
 Suite
3100
 Indianapolis, IN 46282-0200

		
	If to the Participant:	  	At the Participant’s most recent home address, as specified in the Company’s record.

 13. Amendment. This Agreement may be amended only by written agreement of the parties hereto and
to the extent permitted by the Plan. 
 14. Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in counterparts, each of which
shall be deemed to be an original and all of which, when taken together, shall constitute one instrument. 
 15. Entire
Agreement. This Agreement contains the entire understanding and agreement between the parties hereto respecting the subject matter hereof, and there are no representations, agreements, arrangements or understandings, oral or written, between the
parties hereto relating to the subject matter of this Agreement that are not fully expressed herein. 
  

			
	PARTICIPANT	  	EXACTTARGET, INC.
		
	 	  	By:                             
                                         
                          
	[Signature]	  	      Traci Dolan, Chief Administrative Officer
	 	  	
	Street Address	  	
	 	  	
	City, State, Zip Code	  	
	 	  	
	Social Security No.	  	

  
 4

Source: [{"source": "alea-institute/alea-institute/kl3m-data-edgar-agreements/train-00204-of-00352.parquet"}, [{"source": "alea-institute/alea-institute/kl3m-data-edgar-agreements/train-00204-of-00352.parquet"}]]