白白的恩典

白白的恩典（英語：Free grace；也称白白恩典）是一种基督教救恩观，主张信心是得救的唯一条件，得救的人拥有永恒的安全，即他们不会失去救恩；这样的安全不依赖信徒的善行和坚忍，只依赖神的应许和保证。白白的恩典的倡导者们认为，善行并不是赚取救恩（如天主教所主张）的条件，也不是维持救恩（如阿米念主义所主张）的条件，也不是证明救恩（如加尔文主义所主张）的条件，而是作为基督门徒的要素和接受永恒奖赏的基础。这种救恩观区分了得救和作门徒 - 得救是相信基督为救主，接受永生的礼物；作门徒是跟随基督并顺服他 。白白的恩典神学家强调救恩的绝对免费性，救恩是白白得来的，因此信徒完全不需要基于自己的表现而确信自己有永生，只需基于神的话语就可确信自己有永生。与此相对的是，其他神学立场往往需要基于信徒的个人表现才能确信他们是否有永生。 Charles Henry Mackintosh 司可福 J. Vernon McGee Charles Ryrie Robert Lightner Everett Harrison Merrill Unger 赞恩·C·霍奇斯 倪柝声 Robert Wilkin Charles Stanley Jerry Vernon Lloyd Tony Evans Chuck Swindoll Robert Thieme William Newell Lance Latham David Anderson Larry Moyer Earl Radmacher Charles Bing Joseph Dillow Fred Chay J. Paul Tanner Ralph Arnold Shawn Lazar Kenneth W. Yates Andy Woods John Niemelä Dennis Rokser Jack Hyles Norman Geisler Miles Stanford R. T. Kendall Anthony B. Badger M.R. DeHaan John R. Rice Grant Hawley Harry Ironside 白白的恩典主要是由以下团体中的个人所宣讲：美南浸信会，独立浸信会， 普利茅斯弟兄会，一些无宗派的教会。 历史上白白的恩典的共同的核心信仰包括： 白白的恩典神学以坚持惟独信心而著称，主张人得救与悔改、受洗或坚忍到底无关。这些行为对于获得永恒的奖赏是必要的，对于得救却不是必要的。白白的恩典的宣讲者们普遍一致认为，善行不能赢得永生，也不能维持永生，也不能证明人有永生。换言之，主耶稣慷慨地将永恒的救恩作为免费的礼物赐予那些相信他的人。白白的恩典神学家普遍坚持信徒的永恒安全，但他们否认每个信徒都必然会坚持信仰。因此，白白的恩典神学家认为，任何相信耶稣基督的人无论未来的行为如何——包括未来的罪行、不信或叛教——都将进入天堂，尽管犯罪或放弃信仰的基督徒将面临上帝的管教。但不是所有坚持白白的恩典神学的人都同意此观点，一些人认为，之后放弃信仰的人不会得救。但他们不是失去了救恩，而是一直就没有真正的救恩。他们的信是肤浅的信，是无根的信(路加福音8:13)，是为了今生利益的信。 与其他宗派的传统不同，白白的恩典神学家对悔改的观点大致可以归为三类： 大部分白白的恩典神学家，包括Harry A. Ironside，Lewis Sperry Chafer， Charles Ryrie， Walvoord， Pentecost， Charlie Bing等人，都认为悔改应被视为改变心意，而不是转离罪恶或对罪恶的悔恨。因此，在这个观点中，悔改被视为相信的同义词。 赞恩·C·霍奇斯、David Anderson、 Robert Wilkin 提出了第二种观点 ，悔改被定义为转离罪恶，但不是获得永生的条件，只有相信基督才是获得永生的条件。赞恩·霍奇斯在他的书《与神和谐》中提出了这个观点，他认为悔改不是得救的条件，而是与神团契和成圣的条件。 约瑟夫·迪洛（Joseph Dillow ）教导说悔改是指对罪恶的悔恨或后悔，在他看来，这是相信的必要前提条件。然而，迪洛拒绝了将悔改视为对基督的委身的观点。 白白的恩典神学家对基督审判台前的永恒奖赏的教义给予了极大的重视。根据该神学，那些看似将称义与善行联系起来的经文，实际上指向永恒的奖赏，而非永恒的救恩。这种观点认为，个人将因着他们的服事程度获得不同的奖赏，这一解读基于哥林多前书，保罗提到有人得救，却“像从火里经过的一样”。恩典神学家将此理解为，那些没有服事基督的人会得救，但会丧失永恒的奖赏。 白白的恩典神学家认为，行为不义的信徒将会经历神严厉的管教。他们通常将希伯来书中的警告，如第10章和第6章的警告，解释为对背道的严厉惩戒的警告。 白白的恩典神学家对于善行作为得救的果子的角色有一些不同的观点，这主要是由于他们对雅各书的解释不同。大多数白白的恩典神学家，如鲍勃·威尔金、赞恩·霍奇斯、约瑟夫·迪洛等人，认为那些拥有雅各书2:17所提到的“死的信心”的人并非假的基督徒，他们认为这里的“死”指的是一种在今生和基督审判台前都无益的信仰，但并不暗示假信。因此，当雅各问“这信心能救他吗”(2:14)，此处的“救”被理解为从罪的暂时惩戒中得救（如赞恩·霍奇斯的观点），或者从奖赏的损失中得救（如查理·宾的观点），或者两者兼有（如约瑟夫·迪洛的观点）。这些神学家争辩说，雅各书在语境上并未谈论永恒的救恩。肯尼思·威尔逊认为，奥古斯丁在雅各书2章的观点上犯了错误，这导致人们认为“鬼魔的假信心”没有善行，而“真信心”必然带来善行。 与之不同的是，虽然查尔斯·赖瑞是白白的恩典神学家，但他认为信心自然会引导人行善，他解释说雅各书是在谈论永恒的得救。赖瑞却反对主权救恩神学(Lordship salvation)，认为信徒并不总是有果子，果子也不一定总是明显的。赖瑞补充说，信徒会在“某种程度上，某个时候，某个地方”有果子，但他同意“属肉体的基督徒”是存在的。 改革宗神学家经常将约翰一书视为一种测试，以便知道人是否被称义。然而，在白白的恩典神学中，这封书信被视为是测试人是否与上帝有团契。因此，白白的恩典神学家将约翰一书中的“知道”等词解释为亲密关系，而不是得救。 白白的恩典神学通常具有时代论的立场。一些白白的恩典神学家试图表明，白白的恩典神学是时代论的自然结果。但仍有一些非时代论神学家持有白白的恩典的救赎论观点。 根据戴夫·安德森的说法，白白的恩典神学与前千禧年主义联系更紧密，而不是与时代论的联系更紧密。 白白的恩典神学在得救的确据上有着独特的立场。所有白白的恩典的倡导者都认同，人能确信自己与上帝共度永恒是基于圣经的承诺，而不是基于个人的行为或在成圣道路上的进展。这一观点强烈区分了永生的礼物（伴随着因信称义）与门徒生活（顺从）。白白的恩典教导人们不需要通过自律行为或善行来换取上帝的永恒救赎；因此，人不能因犯罪或潜在的失败而失去救恩，此种确信是建立在圣经上，而不是对自我行为的反省上。得救的确信是基于基督的义赐予信徒（被归算的义），而不是基于成圣的增长。关于确信的内容，达拉斯神学院在其教义声明的第11条中总结了白白的恩典神学的普遍共识： 我们相信，所有相信基督、通过圣灵重生的人，从他们把耶稣作为救主的那一天起，都有一项特权，就是确信自己得救，这种确信不是基于虚幻地发现了自己有价值，或虚幻地发现了自己配得，而完全建立在圣经上，藉此激发祂的子民产生儿女般的爱、感恩和顺从（路加福音10:20；22:32；哥林多后书5:1, 6–8；提摩太后书1:12；希伯来书10:22；约翰一书5:13）。 在白白的恩典神学家中，对信心的对象有一些争议。赞恩·C·霍奇斯在晚年认为，信心是同意永生的应许；恩典福音社也持此观点。恩典福音社教导说，一个人要得救，不需要知道基督的神性、赎罪和基督的复活；一个人要成圣，需要知道这些 。但不是所有坚持白白的恩典神学的人都同意此观点。查尔斯·赖瑞、查理·宾、乔迪·迪洛等神学家认为，信心的对象是耶稣基督和他的工作 。关于基督的埋葬对于救赎是否是必需的，存在一些小规模的分歧。 白白的恩典神学家通常认为，在救赎中，“信心的质量”并不重要，只有信心的对象重要，正如查理·宾所说：“强调一个人的信心的质量必然意味着信心的对象被淡化”。 白白的恩典神学家坚持无限赎罪(unlimited atonement) 和刑罚性的、替代性的赎罪(penal substitutionary atonement)。白白的恩典神学也区分了两种类型的饶恕，即地位上的饶恕和家庭内的饶恕：地位上的饶恕是通过单单相信而获得的，而家庭内的饶恕则通过认罪获得。家庭内的饶恕并不是为了得救，而是为了恢复与上帝的团契和亲密关系。 在白白的恩典神学中，对于拣选的观点确实存在多样性。以下是一些主要的观点： 温和加尔文主义：查尔斯·赖瑞和刘易斯·斯佩里·查费尔等人接受了加尔文主义关于拣选的温和形式。 有条件的拣选：这是基于上帝的预知，认为上帝根据他预先知道的人的信仰来拣选他们。但持此观点的白白恩典神学家通常拒绝阿米念主义的其他教义。 团体拣选：认为上帝拣选的是一个团体，而不是个人。 服事拣选：肖恩·拉扎尔和恩典福音社等人教导，上帝的拣选总是为了服事的目的。 主权救恩神学 (Lordship Salvation) 白白的恩典（Free Grace）. 马来西亚基督教卫理公会砂拉越华人年议会. 2020-02-26 [2024-06-09]. （原始内容存档于2023-02-01） （中文（简体））.  Catechism of the Catholic Church. [12 April 2021]. （原始内容存档于2014-06-23）. Justification is conferred in Baptism, the sacrament of faith. It conforms us to the righteousness of God, who makes us inwardly just by the power of his mercy. Its purpose is the glory of God and of Christ, and the gift of eternal life . . . . Moved by the Holy Spirit and by charity, we can then merit for ourselves and for others the graces needed for our sanctification, for the increase of grace and charity, and for the attainment of eternal life.  Anderson, David. Free Grace Soteriology 3rd. The Woodlands, TX: Grace Theology Press. 2018.  Dillow, Joseph. Final Destiny: The Future Reign of the Servant Kings. 2012.  Webmaster, G. E. S. The Faith of Demons: James 2:19 – Grace Evangelical Society. September 1995 [2023-01-10]. （原始内容存档于2024-07-15） （美国英语）.  Farley, Andrew. Relaxing with God: The Neglected Spiritual Discipline. Baker Books. 2014-06-24. ISBN 978-1-4412-4608-0 （英语）.  Bing, Charles. Grace, Salvation, and Discipleship: How to Understand Some Difficult Bible Passages. The Woodlands, TX: Grace Theology Press. 2015: 7–30.  Webmaster, G. E. S. A Voice from the Past: Sanctification: What Is It? – Grace Evangelical Society. September 1992 [2023-04-14]. （原始内容存档于2024-05-22） （美国英语）. As a strong advocate of Free Grace in the Brethren assemblies, Mackintosh was harshly censured by southern (U.S.) Presbyterian theologian Robert Dabney  Scofield, Cyrus. In Many Pulpits. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 1922.  YouTube上的"The Power of the Word of God" Bob Nyberg. The Free Grace Fracture (PDF). 4himnet.com. [25 February 2015]. （原始内容存档 (PDF)于2024-09-30）.  Lightner, Robert. Sin, the Savior, and Salvation: The Theology of Everlasting Life. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Kregel. 1996.  Ministries, GraceLife. A History of Free Grace. www.gracelife.org. [2023-04-13]. （原始内容存档于2024-03-13） （美国英语）.  Unger, Merrill. Great Neglected Bible Prophecies. Chicago: Scripture Press. 1955: 120–122.  Unger, Merrill. The New Unger's Bible Handbook, Rev. Ed.. Chicago: Moody. 2005: 537.  Hodges, Zane. The Gospel Under Siege. Dallas, TX: Redencion Viva. 1981.  Hodges, Zane. Absolutely Free: A Biblical Reply to Lordship Salvation. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan. 1989.  Chay, Fred (2017). A Defense of Free Grace Theology: With Respect to Saving Faith, Perseverance, and Assurance. Grace Theology Press. ISBN 978-0-9981385-4-1. Wilkin, Robert. Justification by Faith Alone is an Essential Part of the Gospel. Journal of the Grace Evangelical Society. 2005: 1–13.  Stanley, Charles. Understanding Eternal Security: Secure in God's Unconditional Love. Nashville, TN: Thomas Nelson. 1998.  Evans, Anthony. Theology You Can Count On. Chicago: Moody. 2008.  YouTube上的"Isn't It Risky to Embrace Grace? Pt. 1" William R. Newell. Pilkingtonandsons.com. 1956-04-01 [2015-02-25]. （原始内容存档于2023-06-16）.  Latham, Lance. The Two Gospels. Streamwood, Illinois: Awana Clubs International. 1984.  Moyer, Larry. Free and Clear: Understanding & Communicating God's Offer of Eternal Life. Grand Rapids, MI: Kregel. 1997.  Radmacher, Earl. Salvation. Swindoll Leadership Library Series. Nashville, TN: Thomas Nelson. 2007.  Bing, Charles. Lordship Salvation: A Biblical Evaluation and Response 2. Xulon. 2010. Lordship Salvation. GraceLife Ministries. 2010-01-01 [2020-08-06]. （原始内容存档于2024-01-21）.  Chay, Fred (编). A Defense of Free Grace Theology. The Woodlands, TX: Grace Theology Press. 2017.  Tanner, Paul (编). A Defense of Free Grace Theology. The Woodlands, TX: Grace Theology Press. 2017.  The Gospel Driven Man – Grace Evangelical Society. [2023-04-17]. （原始内容存档于2024-05-24） （美国英语）.  Shawn Lazar – Grace Evangelical Society. [2023-04-13]. （原始内容存档于2024-05-28） （美国英语）.  Kenneth W. Yates – Grace Evangelical Society. [2023-05-12]. （原始内容存档于2024-05-29） （美国英语）.  The Coming Kingdom: What Is the Kingdom and How Is Kingdom Now Theology Changing the Focus of the Church? – Grace Evangelical Society. [2023-05-12]. （原始内容存档于2024-05-20） （美国英语）.  Niemelä, John. Was the Gospel Lost Until the Reformation? – Grace Evangelical Society. July 2015 [2020-09-10]. （原始内容存档于2024-02-22） （美国英语）.  Rokser, Dennis M.; Stegall, Thomas L.; Witzig, Kurt. Should Christians Fear Outer Darkness?. Grace Gospel Press. 2015-09-18. ISBN 978-1-939110-10-7 （英语）.  Hyles, Jack. Enemies of Soul Winning. Exactly what do we mean when we say, "Lordship Salvation"? We are talking about the false doctrine that says that in order for a person to be saved, he must make Jesus the Lord of his life. If that doctrine were true, then no one could be saved, because as long as we are limited by these fleshly bodies, we will be unable to make Jesus totally the Lord of our lives.... There are those who say we have to repent of our sins in order to be saved. No, we have to repent only of the thing that makes us unsaved, and that is unbelief. If a person needs to turn from his sins in order to be saved, what sins does he turn from? Does he turn from pride? Does he turn from selfishness? Does he turn from covetousness? The truth is, nobody can turn from all of his sins until he is raptured and he receives a body like the body of the Saviour.  Repentance Versus the Heresies of Curtis Hutson & Jack Hyles – Grace Evangelical Society. 2023-10-03 [2023-10-04]. （原始内容存档于2024-05-22） （美国英语）.  Lordship Salvation. Ligonier Ministries. [2023-12-03]. （原始内容存档于2024-10-03） （美国英语）. During the final two decades of the twentieth century, certain dispensational theologians began to propagate the idea that one could be in a state of salvation and lack entirely the fruit of repentance from sin and obedience to Christ. Their particular form of soteriology came to be known as free grace–a title coined by Zane Hodges. Some of the other more well-known adherents of the Free Grace movement were Louis Sperry Chafer, Miles Stanford, and Norman Geisler. Hodges became a particularly well-known proponent of the Free Grace theology because of his 1981 book The Gospel under Siege.  Hodges, Zane Clark. A Free Grace Primer: The Hungry Inherit, the Gospel Under Siege, and Grace in Eclipse. Grace Evangelical Society. 2011-11-15. ISBN 978-0-9788773-9-2 （英语）.  Free Grace Theology on Trial: A Refutation of "Historical Protestant" Soteriology – Grace Evangelical Society. 2023-05-16 [2023-05-16]. （原始内容存档于2024-07-19） （美国英语）.  Lazar, Shawn. A Vast Difference: M. R. DeHaan on Salvation and Discipleship – Grace Evangelical Society. 2016-08-26 [2024-01-25]. （原始内容存档于2024-05-26） （美国英语）.  R. Rice, John. Dr. Rice... Here Are More Questions. Sword of the Lord Publishers. 1973. ISBN 0-87398-157-X. There is not any way you can judge whether people are born again except as you take their testimony that they have put their trust in Jesus Christ and depended on Him for salvation. Some of these young people indeed may not have been taught to trust in Christ. If they were looking for "an experience," a certain kind of feeling or emotion, then they may have been misled. Now a Christian should live a consecrated Christian life but that does not automatically follow.  Dispensationalism and Free Grace: Intimately Linked. Dispensational Publishing. [2023-08-20]. （原始内容存档于2024-06-14） （美国英语）.  A. Ironside, Harry. What Is The Gospel?. “ The Gospel is not a call to repentance, or to amendment of our ways, to make restitution for past sins, or to promise to do better in the future.  Wilkin, Bob. What Denominations Hold to Free Grace? – Grace Evangelical Society. 11 February 2022 [2023-01-10]. （原始内容存档于2024-09-28） （美国英语）. [需要較佳来源] Lazar, Shawn. Are There Any Free Grace Denominations? – Grace Evangelical Society. 24 August 2021 [2023-04-18]. （原始内容存档于2024-07-16） （美国英语）. [需要較佳来源] Bing, Charles. Lordship Salvation: A Biblical Evaluation and Response. Xulon. 2010.  Anderson, David. Maximum Joy: First John – Relationship or Fellowship? New Study. The Woodlands, TX: Grace Theology Press. 2013.  Radmacher, Earl. Salvation. Swindoll Leadership Library. Nashville, TN: Thomas Nelson. 2007: 143–186.  Dillow, Joseph. Final Destiny: The Future Reign of the Servant Kings. 2012: 350–390.  Charles, Stanley. Understanding Eternal Security: Secure in God's Unconditional Love. Nashville, TN: Thomas Nelson. 1998.  Dillow, Joseph. Final Destiny: The Future Reign of the Servant Kings. 2012: 719–738.  Moyer, Larry. Free and Clear: Understanding & Communicating God's Offer of Eternal Life. Grand Rapids, MI: Kregel. 1997: 57–79.  Anderson, David (2018). Free Grace Soteriology (3rd. ed.). The Woodlands, TX: Grace Theology Press. Dillow, Joseph. Final Destiny: The Future Reign of the Servant Kings. 2012: 910–989.  Hodges, Zane Clark. Absolutely Free!: A Biblical Reply to Lordship Salvation. Zondervan. 1989. ISBN 978-0-310-51960-7 （英语）.  [1] 互联网档案馆的存檔，存档日期December 9, 2008，. [2] 互联网档案馆的存檔，存档日期November 20, 2008，. E.g., Dick Seymour, All About Repentance (1974)[页码请求]; G. Michael Cocoris, Lordship Salvation, Is it Biblical? (circa 1983)[页码请求] and Repentance: The Most Misunderstood Word in the Bible (1993)[页码请求]; Curtis Hutson, Repentance, What does the Bible Teach[页码请求]; Richard Hill, Why a Turn or Burn Theology is Wrong[页码请求]; and Ronald R. Shea, The Gospel booklet (1988)[页码请求]; and numerous articles by John R. Rice and Curtis Hutson in the Sword of the Lord magazine.[查证请求] Bing, Dr Charlie. Repentance: What's in a Word. www.gracelife.org. [2023-04-17]. （原始内容存档于2024-03-13） （美国英语）.  3. New Testament Repentance: Lexical Considerations | Bible.org. bible.org. [2023-06-08]. （原始内容存档于2024-09-01） （英语）.  Wilkin, Bob. Will There Be Haves and Have-Nots in Jesus' Kingdom? – Grace Evangelical Society. 14 December 2022 [2023-04-18]. （原始内容存档于2024-04-20） （美国英语）.  Ministries, GraceLife. The Free Grace Alliance Within the Free Grace Movement: It is What it is!. www.gracelife.org. [2023-04-18]. （原始内容存档于2024-03-13） （美国英语）.  Wilkin, Bob. Can Faith Without Works Save? – James 2:14 – Grace Evangelical Society. September 1994 [2023-01-10]. （原始内容存档于2024-06-13） （美国英语）.  Dead Faith: What Is It?—A Study on James 2:14–26 – Grace Evangelical Society. [2023-02-21]. （原始内容存档于2024-05-23） （美国英语）.  Bing, Dr Charlie. Faith and Works in James 2:14. www.gracelife.org. [2023-02-21]. （原始内容存档于2023-02-21） （美国英语）.  Wilson, Kenneth. Reading James 2:19–20 Through Anti-Donatist Eyes: Untangling Augustine's Exegetical Legacy. JBL. 2020, 139 (2): 389–410.  Hawley, Grant. Dispensationalism and Free Grace: Intimately Linked. Dispensational Publishing House. October 2017. ISBN 978-1-945774-14-0 （英语）.  Breshears, Gerry. New Directions in Dispensationalism. Evangelical Theological Society 43rd National Conference. Kansas City, MO. November 21–23, 1991 [2024-05-07]. OCLC 58480089. （原始内容存档于2023-04-09）.  Ministries, GraceLife. The Free Grace Alliance Within the Free Grace Movement: It is What it is!. www.gracelife.org. [2023-10-10]. （原始内容存档于2024-03-13） （美国英语）.  Anderson, David R. Free Grace Soteriology. Grace Theology Press. November 2012. ISBN 978-0-9884112-0-3 （英语）.  Dallas Theological Seminary Website. Dts.edu. [2013-12-02]. （原始内容存档于2018-06-28）.  Dillehay, Justin. How 'Free Grace' Theology Diminishes the Gospel. The Gospel Coalition. 15 June 2017 [2023-01-28]. （原始内容存档于2023-06-08） （美国英语）.  Wilson, Ken. Heresy of the Grace Evangelical Society: Become a Christian Without Faith in Jesus As God and Savior. Amazon Digital Services LLC - KDP Print US. 2020-12-31. ISBN 979-8-5859-6339-1 （英语）.  Webmaster, G. E. S. Robert Sandeman (1718-1771) – Grace Evangelical Society. August 2022 [2023-05-12]. （原始内容存档于2024-05-29） （美国英语）.  Patterson, Darrell. IS JESUS' SUBSTITUTIONARY DEATH FOR SIN NECESSARY TO BELIEVE FOR ETERNAL LIFE ACCORDING TO JOHN'S GOSPEL?. Grace Gospel Press. [2023-05-17]. （原始内容存档于2023-05-17） （美国英语）.  Webmaster, G. E. S. Has Grace in Focus Put the Free-Grace Gospel Out of Focus? – Grace Evangelical Society. 2009-11-01 [2023-06-06]. （原始内容存档于2024-05-20） （美国英语）.  A Review of Lewis Sperry Chafer's "Systematic Theology" | Bible.org. bible.org. [2023-10-30]. （原始内容存档于2023-11-29） （英语）.  Chosen to Serve: Why Divine Election Is to Service, Not to Eternal Life – Grace Evangelical Society. [2023-10-30]. （原始内容存档于2024-05-25） （美国英语）.  Wilkin, Bob. election to service – Grace Evangelical Society. 2022-11-15 [2023-10-30]. （原始内容存档于2024-05-18） （美国英语）.  The Doctrine of Absolute Inability. Grace to You. [15 December 2018]. （原始内容存档于2024-02-22）.  Doctrinal Statement. Grace School of Theology. [15 December 2018]. （原始内容存档于2020-10-30）.  Grudem, Wayne. Election Is Not Based on God's Foreknowledge of Our Faith. Monergism. [15 December 2018]. （原始内容存档于2023-12-11）.  Cobb, John. Election Is Based on Foreknowledge. Review and Expositor. 1954, 51 (1): 22–28. S2CID 146858973. doi:10.1177/003463735405100103.  Ryrie, Charles C. Basic Theology: A Popular Systematic Guide to Understanding Biblical Truth. Moody Publishers. 1999-01-11. ISBN 978-1-57567-498-8 （英语）.  Schwertley, Brian. Limited Atonement. Monergism. [15 December 2018]. （原始内容存档于2024-02-22）.  Waite, D.A. Calvin's Error of Limited Atonement. UK Apologetics. [15 December 2018]. （原始内容存档于2024-02-23）.  See also Alcorn, Randy. What Is Your View on Limited Atonement?. Eternal Perspective Ministries. [15 December 2018]. （原始内容存档于2023-06-02）.  Murray, John. Irresistible Grace. Ligonier Ministries. [15 December 2018]. （原始内容存档于2024-06-18）.  Smith, C. Fred. Whosoever Will: A Review Essay. LBTS Faculty Publications and Presentations. 2010: 377 [2024-05-07]. （原始内容存档于2024-02-26）.  Piper, John. Perseverance of the Saints. Desiring God. 15 March 2008 [15 December 2018]. （原始内容存档于2024-05-18）.  Stanley, Charles. Eternal Security: Can You Be Sure?. Nashville, TN: Oliver Nelson. 1990: 80. ISBN 9780840790958.  含有內容需登入查看的頁面 (link)