Alright, got it. I was just under the impression that the code made the return value unclear so a comment was needed to clear it up. I those cases (because I do that often) I try (as best I can) to make the code good enough to remove the comment. I think my proposal is a bit clearer, but then again I wrote it so of course I would think that :) 

Fix if you want to, if not - never mind ;)