@pitr-ch Yeah, what I did here was that for the Roles that only had one service, I moved the puppetclass to the Service from the Role so we get the params automatically like we get for the HA services. This means we're now only hard-coding param lists for the non-HA controllers and the Neutron Networker. LVM, Swift, and the compute nodes are now auto-generating their param lists, so we have a smaller set of params we have to keep in sync.