@[simp]
theorem quot_left_distrib (x y z : PGame) : (⟦x * (y + z)⟧ : Game) = ⟦x * y⟧ + ⟦x * z⟧ :=
  match x, y, z with
  | mk xl xr xL xR, mk yl yr yL yR, mk zl zr zL zR => by
    let x := mk xl xr xL xR
    let y := mk yl yr yL yR
    let z := mk zl zr zL zR
    refine' quot_eq_of_mk'_quot_eq _ _ _ _
    · fconstructor
      · rintro (⟨_, _ | _⟩ | ⟨_, _ | _⟩) <;>
          -- Porting note: we've increased `maxDepth` here from `5` to `6`.
          -- Likely this sort of off-by-one error is just a change in the implementation
          -- of `solve_by_elim`.
          solve_by_elim (config := { maxDepth := 6 }) [Sum.inl, Sum.inr, Prod.mk]
      · rintro (⟨⟨_, _⟩ | ⟨_, _⟩⟩ | ⟨_, _⟩ | ⟨_, _⟩) <;>
          solve_by_elim (config := { maxDepth := 6 }) [Sum.inl, Sum.inr, Prod.mk]
      · rintro (⟨_, _ | _⟩ | ⟨_, _ | _⟩) <;> rfl
      · rintro (⟨⟨_, _⟩ | ⟨_, _⟩⟩ | ⟨_, _⟩ | ⟨_, _⟩) <;> rfl
    · fconstructor
      · rintro (⟨_, _ | _⟩ | ⟨_, _ | _⟩) <;>
          solve_by_elim (config := { maxDepth := 6 }) [Sum.inl, Sum.inr, Prod.mk]
      · rintro (⟨⟨_, _⟩ | ⟨_, _⟩⟩ | ⟨_, _⟩ | ⟨_, _⟩) <;>
          solve_by_elim (config := { maxDepth := 6 }) [Sum.inl, Sum.inr, Prod.mk]
      · rintro (⟨_, _ | _⟩ | ⟨_, _ | _⟩) <;> rfl
      · rintro (⟨⟨_, _⟩ | ⟨_, _⟩⟩ | ⟨_, _⟩ | ⟨_, _⟩) <;> rfl
    -- Porting note: explicitly wrote out arguments to each recursive
    -- quot_left_distrib reference below, because otherwise the decreasing_by block
    -- failed. Previously, each branch ended with: `simp [quot_left_distrib]; abel`
    -- See https://github.com/leanprover/lean4/issues/2288
    · rintro (⟨i, j | k⟩ | ⟨i, j | k⟩)
      · change
          ⟦xL i * (y + z) + x * (yL j + z) - xL i * (yL j + z)⟧ =
            ⟦xL i * y + x * yL j - xL i * yL j + x * z⟧
        simp only [quot_sub, quot_add]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xL i) (mk yl yr yL yR) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (mk xl xr xL xR) (yL j) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xL i) (yL j) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        abel
      · change
          ⟦xL i * (y + z) + x * (y + zL k) - xL i * (y + zL k)⟧ =
            ⟦x * y + (xL i * z + x * zL k - xL i * zL k)⟧
        simp only [quot_sub, quot_add]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xL i) (mk yl yr yL yR) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (mk xl xr xL xR) (mk yl yr yL yR) (zL k)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xL i) (mk yl yr yL yR) (zL k)]
        abel
      · change
          ⟦xR i * (y + z) + x * (yR j + z) - xR i * (yR j + z)⟧ =
            ⟦xR i * y + x * yR j - xR i * yR j + x * z⟧
        simp only [quot_sub, quot_add]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xR i) (mk yl yr yL yR) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (mk xl xr xL xR) (yR j) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xR i) (yR j) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        abel
      · change
          ⟦xR i * (y + z) + x * (y + zR k) - xR i * (y + zR k)⟧ =
            ⟦x * y + (xR i * z + x * zR k - xR i * zR k)⟧
        simp only [quot_sub, quot_add]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xR i) (mk yl yr yL yR) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (mk xl xr xL xR) (mk yl yr yL yR) (zR k)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xR i) (mk yl yr yL yR) (zR k)]
        abel
    · rintro (⟨i, j | k⟩ | ⟨i, j | k⟩)
      · change
          ⟦xL i * (y + z) + x * (yR j + z) - xL i * (yR j + z)⟧ =
            ⟦xL i * y + x * yR j - xL i * yR j + x * z⟧
        simp only [quot_sub, quot_add]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xL i) (mk yl yr yL yR) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (mk xl xr xL xR) (yR j) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xL i) (yR j) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        abel
      · change
          ⟦xL i * (y + z) + x * (y + zR k) - xL i * (y + zR k)⟧ =
            ⟦x * y + (xL i * z + x * zR k - xL i * zR k)⟧
        simp only [quot_sub, quot_add]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xL i) (mk yl yr yL yR) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (mk xl xr xL xR) (mk yl yr yL yR) (zR k)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xL i) (mk yl yr yL yR) (zR k)]
        abel
      · change
          ⟦xR i * (y + z) + x * (yL j + z) - xR i * (yL j + z)⟧ =
            ⟦xR i * y + x * yL j - xR i * yL j + x * z⟧
        simp only [quot_sub, quot_add]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xR i) (mk yl yr yL yR) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (mk xl xr xL xR) (yL j) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xR i) (yL j) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        abel
      · change
          ⟦xR i * (y + z) + x * (y + zL k) - xR i * (y + zL k)⟧ =
            ⟦x * y + (xR i * z + x * zL k - xR i * zL k)⟧
        simp only [quot_sub, quot_add]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xR i) (mk yl yr yL yR) (mk zl zr zL zR)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (mk xl xr xL xR) (mk yl yr yL yR) (zL k)]
        rw [quot_left_distrib (xR i) (mk yl yr yL yR) (zL k)]
        abel
  termination_by _ => (x, y, z)
  decreasing_by 

Proof state:
xl xr : Type u_1
xL : xl → PGame
xR : xr → PGame
yl yr : Type u_1
yL : yl → PGame
yR : yr → PGame
zl zr : Type u_1
zL : zl → PGame
zR : zr → PGame
x✝ :
  ∀ (y : (_ : PGame) ×' (_ : PGame) ×' PGame),
    (invImage (fun a => PSigma.casesOn a fun x snd => PSigma.casesOn snd fun y snd => (x, y, snd))
            Prod.instWellFoundedRelationProd).1
        y { fst := mk xl xr xL xR, snd := { fst := mk yl yr yL yR, snd := mk zl zr zL zR } } →
      ⟦y.1 * (y.2.1 + y.2.2)⟧ = ⟦y.1 * y.2.1⟧ + ⟦y.1 * y.2.2⟧
k : zr
⊢ (invImage (fun a => PSigma.casesOn a fun x snd => PSigma.casesOn snd fun y snd => (x, y, snd))
        Prod.instWellFoundedRelationProd).1
    { fst := mk xl xr xL xR, snd := { fst := mk yl yr yL yR, snd := zR k } }
    { fst := mk xl xr xL xR, snd := { fst := mk yl yr yL yR, snd := mk zl zr zL zR } }

Next tactic:
pgame_wf_tac