# Talk:Manresa Island

In the initial version of this article, Manresa Island is described as a tied island, but a subsequent revision, the text was changed to describe it as a former island.  Is a "tied island" by definition not an island?
The text of the article continues to refer to it as an island.  Calling it a former island seems to be a case of WP:OR.  Aside from this, saying that it's a former island is ambiguous, leaving one to wonder whether it has ceased to be an island or if it has actually ceased to be. Fabrickator (talk) 08:01, 10 October 2023 (UTC)