# Talk:Batal Hajji Belkhoroev

I believe that N. Hanif never existed and Sarup & Sons is a notorious copyright-violation mill. Any works attributed to N. Hanif were written by others. For example, in this work:

Hanif, N. (1997). Islam and Modernity. Sarup & Sons. ISBN 978-81-7625-002-3.
"Hanif" refers to the following as his own work:

'Ishrat Hasan Enver (October 1964). "Reconstruction of Iqbal's Reconstruction of religious thought in Islam" (PDF). The Islamic Review. 52 (10): 13–16.
Other portions of the book are copied from the following:

Lokhandwalla, S. T., ed. (1971). India and Contemporary Islam: Proceedings of a Seminar. Transactions of the Indian Institute of Advanced Study. Vol. 6. Simla: R. Nivas. p. 223. OCLC 3495303.
Daask (talk) 21:30, 19 September 2024 (UTC)