members ; original members donald carpenter -- vocals ( 2003 -- 2008 ) garrett whitlock -- drums ( 2003 -- 2008 ) eric friedman -- lead guitar , backing vocals ( 2003 -- 2006 ) tj davis -- lead guitar ( 2003 -- 2008 ) kelan luker -- bass ( 2003 -- 2008 ) justin finley - lead guitar ( 2006-2008 ) discography in due time ( 2004 ) ( # 16 billboard heatseekers albums ) immortal verses ( 2007 ) ( # 35 billboard heatseekers albums ) singles list of other songs '' complicated '' featured in soundtrack of the punisher .