track listing ; us ep single ; uk cd single ; limited uk ep single personnel tori amos -- acoustic piano , vocals jef scott -- bass ed green -- drums paulinho da costa -- percussion john chamberlin -- mandolin eric williams -- ukulele nancy shanks ( beene ) , tina gullickson -- backgrounds john beverly jones -- sound recording leslie ann jones -- assistance paul mckenna -- mixing davitt sigerson -- producer ian stanley -- producer charts appearances of the song on television live performances tori amos performed '' crucify '' on late night with david letterman in may , 1992 , and on cbs this morning on september 9 , 1992 .