Deportivo Anzoátegui
Fuenmayor started his playing career with Unión Atlético Maracaibo where he was part of the squad that won Primera División Venezolana in 2005. After financial troubles hit, he joined Maracaibo based Zulia FC before a brief spell in Europe with Vålerenga. He returned to Venezuela, signing for Deportivo Anzoátegui in 2010.