برودواي
She was in the company of "The Newlyweds and Their Baby", a comedy based on the cartoons of George McManus. It premiered at the Majestic Theatre, Broadway (Manhattan) on March 22, 1909. The plot dealt with Mr. and Mrs. Newlywed and Napoleon Newlywed, the baby. Reynolds depicted "Dolly Jolly", a woman who was coveted by the character played by Fletcher Norton.