FA Women's Premier League National Division
Ayala won the 1995–96 FA Women's Premier League Cup with Wembley Ladies. In the final against Doncaster Belles she scored an injury time penalty to tie the game at 2–2; allowing Wembley to win on penalties. After being an unused substitute in Wembley's 1997 FA Women's Cup final defeat to Millwall Lionesses, Ayala signed for FA Women's Premier League National Division rivals Croydon.