Ayako Hamada
At "Volume 33" in September 2010, McKay defeated Nicole Matthews, after losing to Matthews earlier that year in April at "Volume 30". She followed up with an upset victory over Ayako Hamada and Sara Del Rey in a three-way match by pinning former Shimmer Champion Del Rey at "Volume 34". As a result, later in September 2010, McKay was granted a title match against her trainer and former tag partner, Shimmer Champion Madison Eagles at "Volume 35", but failed to win.