Sheffield F.C.
After spending just one season with Sheffield F.C, Modest joined other local North Nottinghamshire side Worksop Town, after making 22 league appearances for Sheffield F.C. and scoring 6 goals. Modest made his debut for Worksop Town later that same day as Worksop faced Hednesford Town in a mid-week league match. The game finished in a 0–4 victory to Worksop Town, with Modest making his debut as a substitute nine-minutes before the final whistle.