Catch Me If You Can
In the summer of 2009, Butler appeared in the world premiere of "Catch Me If You Can" at the 5th Avenue Theatre, the same venue where "Hairspray" had its pre-Broadway tryout. She played Brenda Strong, the Southern ingénue who falls in love with the con artist Frank Abagnale, Jr. (The role was played by Amy Adams in the Steven Spielberg film version of "Catch Me If You Can".)