Online magazine
"Faiths and Pantheons" received generally positive reviews. Online magazine "Fictional Reality" considered the interior artwork to stand out, and found both the mechanics and setting information useful, although concluded that it was "not a required book" for play. Reviewing a 2007 German edition, "Anduin" also praised the book's layout and setting information; the translated edition was considered especially beneficial to German players, because 2nd edition books with similar content (such as "Faiths &amp; Avatars" and "Demihuman Deities") were only released in English. However, the detailed mechanical stat blocks for major deities were viewed as largely unsuccessful.