black dog running along a beach in the water
is it a big dog
yes
what kind of dog is it
black dog
is he wearing a collar
no
is anyone with the dog
no
can you see the water
yes, it's in the water
any boats
no
is the dog in the water
yes
do he have a ball
no
any waves
no, just ripples in the water
is the beach nice
i can't see the beach