Case Name: JOHN W. MOORE v. ISRAEL SCHWARTZ
Court: Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jurisdiction: North Carolina
Decision Date: 1928-05-02
Citations: 195 N.C. 549
Docket Number: 
Parties: JOHN W. MOORE v. ISRAEL SCHWARTZ.
Judges: 
Reporter: North Carolina Reports
Volume: 195
Pages: 549–550

Head Matter:
JOHN W. MOORE v. ISRAEL SCHWARTZ.
(Filed 2 May, 1928.)
Gambling — Action Will Not Lie Against Maker of Check Given for Gambling Debt.
An action will not lie to recover against the maker upon a note given for a gambling debt.
Civil actioN before Harding, J., at December Term, 1927, of Meck-LENBURG.
The defendant was indebted to the plaintiff for $183.00 and plaintiff brought suit in a magistrate’s court against the defendant to recover that sum. At the trial the defendant admitted the indebtedness to the plaintiff but set up as a counterclaim a check for $170.00, payable to “cash.” The plaintiff denied the legality of the counterclaim and offered evidence tending to show that the check for $170.00 was given by him to one Familant to pay losses incurred in a poker game. Eamilant had endorsed the check to the defendant. There was no evidence contradicting the evidence of the plaintiff that the check sought to be used as a counterclaim by the defendant was given for the purpose of paying a gambling loss. Whereupon the judge instructed the jury to answer in the affirmative the issue relating to whether or not the check was a wagering contract. From judgment for plaintiff for the amount of his account and denying recovery on the counterclaim the defendant appealed.
Thomas W. Alexander for plaintiff.
J. D. McCall for defendant.

Opinion:
Pee Cubiam.
Gaming contracts are covered by C. S., 2142. Such contracts are void and cannot be enforced in a court of justice. Orvis v. Holt, 173 N. C., 231; Bank v. Crafton, 181 N. C., 404.
Under certain circumstances the holder of a check or a note given to pay a gambling debt may recover against the endorser. Bank v. Crafton, supra. This is not such a ease as the endorser is not sued.
No error.