Case Name: THATCHER GLASS MANUFACTURING CO. and Continental Ins. Co., Appellants, v. Shirley M. BUYNA, Appellee
Court: Florida District Court of Appeal
Jurisdiction: Florida
Decision Date: 1982-04-01
Citations: 411 So. 2d 1029
Docket Number: No. AB-421
Parties: THATCHER GLASS MANUFACTURING CO. and Continental Ins. Co., Appellants, v. Shirley M. BUYNA, Appellee.
Judges: WENTWORTH, J., concurs.
Reporter: Southern Reporter, Second Series
Volume: 411
Pages: 1029–1030

Head Matter:
THATCHER GLASS MANUFACTURING CO. and Continental Ins. Co., Appellants, v. Shirley M. BUYNA, Appellee.
No. AB-421.
District Court of Appeal of Florida, First District.
April 1, 1982.
John S. Smith of Marlow, Shofi, Ortmayer, Smith, Connell & Valerius, Tampa, for appellants.
H. Guy Smith, Lakeland, for appellee.

Opinion:
THOMPSON, Judge.
The employer/earrier (E/C) challenge a workers' compensation order, contending that the Deputy Commissioner (deputy) erred by awarding compensation to claimant's husband for nursing services. We agree and reverse.
In 1968 claimant sustained a compensable injury. A claim was subsequently filed to compensate claimant's husband for various services he performed for claimant. The deputy concluded that claimant's husband performed nursing care type services which she needed. Accordingly, the deputy awarded the husband compensation for three hours per day at the minimum wage prevailing at the time the services were performed.
There is no competent substantial evidence that claimant's disability, i.e. the nature of her compensable injury and process of recovery, required the services in question as a matter of medical need under the standards of § 440.13, Fla.Stat., for the ten-year period in question and continuing. Accordingly, it was error for the deputy to award compensation for nursing services to claimant's husband.
REVERSED.
WENTWORTH, J., concurs.
MILLS, J., dissents.