Case Name: THE CITY OF CLEVELAND v. SARAH HYLAND
Court: Ohio Circuit Court
Jurisdiction: Ohio
Decision Date: 1893-01
Citations: 18 Ohio C.C. 868
Docket Number: 
Parties: THE CITY OF CLEVELAND v. SARAH HYLAND.
Judges: Before Caldwell, Hale and Marvin, JJ.
Reporter: Reports of cases argued and determined in the circuit courts of Ohio
Volume: 18
Pages: 868–868

Head Matter:
(Eighth Circuit — Cuyahoga Co., O. Circuit Court
Jan. Term, 1893.)
Before Caldwell, Hale and Marvin, JJ.
THE CITY OF CLEVELAND v. SARAH HYLAND.
. Street improvement — Damages to property — When owner's claim to be filed—
An owner of property whioh he claims will be damaged by a certain improvement proposed by the municipality, must file his claim for the amount of such expected damages with the clerk of the corporation within two weeks after the completion of the publication of the notice given by the corporation of such proposed improvement, or his claim is to be considered waived. Such owner can also recover only damages to the amount claimed in his written notice, as filed within these two weeks with the corporation clerk. Any damages beyond such amount are considered waived.
Meyer, Kelley, Kain & Mooney, for Plaintiff in Error.
Brinsmade, Reynolds & Brinsmade for Defendant in Error.

Opinion:
HALE, J.
As to the amount that might be recovered the court below charged as follows: "I say to you that the claims which are filed here are not conclusive upon the parties as the amount whioh they may recover. They are entitled to recover what the damages actually are.". That presents the question whether the jury in the assessment of damages was limited to claims filed by these the several claimants; and that is about all there is of importance in the case except the case itself. We are cited to no authorities bearing upon the question directly and hardly remotely.
Seotion 2315, of the Revised Statutes provides as follows: "An owner of a lot or of land bounding or abutting upon a proposed improvement, claiming that he will sustain damages by reason of the improvement, shall, within two weeks after the service or the completion of the publication of the notice mentioned in section twenty-three hundred and four, file a claim in writing, with the clerk of the corporation, setting forth the amount of damage claimed, together with a general description of the property with respect to which it is claimed the injury will accrue; an owner who fails to do so shall be deemed to have waived the same, and shall be barred from filing a claim or receiving damages."
As at present advised we are disposed to hold that statute valid in all respects. If no claim for damages has been filed, it is waived and no assessment of damages can be made to the lot owner. If the lot owner-files his claim for damages and fixes the-amount that he claims, we see no reason why he should not be held and deemed to have waived any further claim than that which he makes in the claim filed.