Case Name: TRUMBULL STELL CO. v. ROUTZAHN
Court: United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1923-09-22
Citations: 2 Ohio Law Abs. 162
Docket Number: No. 11950
Parties: TRUMBULL STELL CO. v. ROUTZAHN
Judges: 
Reporter: The Ohio Law Abstract
Volume: 2
Pages: 162–162

Head Matter:
No. 158
TRUMBULL STELL CO. v. ROUTZAHN
U. S. District Court, N. D. Ohio, E. D.
No. 11950.
Decided Sept. 22, 1923
476. INTERNAL REVENUE — New issue of shares of stock of par value of $25 for each share of old stock of par value of $100 not subject to stamp tax.
1030. STATUTES — Re-enactment of statute, adoption of previous construction.
Attorneys — Harrington, De Ford, Huxley & Smith, Youngstown, for Trumbull Steel Co.; A. E. Bernsteen and Fred S. Day, Cleveland, for Routzahn.

Opinion:
WESTENHAVER, D. J.
Epitomized Opinion
This was an action by the Trumbull Steel Company against C. F. Routzahn, Collector of Internal Revenue, to recover back a stamp tax paid to the U. S. government. Prior to Aug. 16, 1820, the Trumbull Steel Co. had issued an outstanding 131,681 shares of stock evidenced by certificates of par value of $100 each. On that date pursuant to Secs. GC. 8719-8722 of Ohio the Company amended its articles of incorporation, chánging the par value of each share of $1,00 to $25. The outstanding certificates were thereafter called in and four new for each of the old were issued. No other change in stock ownership or stock privileges or corporate organizaton was made. A tax of 5c on each $100 par value of the new certificates was levied and assessed, paid under protest, and application for a refund made to the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, and by him refused. This action was then brought against the Collector. A demurrer was filed thereto. In overruling the demurred the court held:
1. This readjustment of. the stock of the corporation was not an original issue either on organization or re-organization and that the new certificates were not subject to the war revenue tax of Nov. 23, 1921 (Secs. 1100 and 1107, Schedule A, pa. 2, Comp. Stat. Supp. 1923, par. 6318i, 6318p).
2. The re-enactment by Congress, without change, of a statute which has previously received a certain construction, whether judicial or departmental, is an adoption of such construction.