Case Name: SHEEHEE v. RESLER
Court: United States Circuit Court of the District of Columbia
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1801-10
Citations: 21 F. Cas. 1224
Docket Number: 
Parties: SHEEHEE v. RESLER.
Judges: MARSHALL. Circuit Judge, of the same opinion.
Reporter: Federal Cases
Volume: 21
Pages: 1224–1224

Head Matter:
Case No. 12,739,
SHEEHEE v. RESLER.
[1 Cranch, C. C. 42.]
Circuit Court, District of Columbia.
Oct. Term. 1801.
Malicious Prosecution — General Issue — Probable Cause.
In an action on the case for a malicious prosecution. the defendant may, upon the general issue, show probable cause for the prosecution.
A bill of exceptions was taken. Pee this case in the supremo court of the United States (1 Cranch [5 U. S.] 110), where the judgment was affirmed.
Case, for a malicious prosecution. To set aside an office judgment at the third term after it was rendered, the defendant pleaded a special justification which went to show probable cause for the prosecution.
The counsel for the plaintiff objected to the receiving the plea, and cited Bull. N. P. 14; Sutton v. Johnstone, 1 Term R. 493; Cox v. Wirrall. Cro. Jac. 193; Downman v. Downman, 1 Wash. [Va.] 29; Farmer v. Darling, 4 Burrows, 1971.
|Affirmed in 1 Cranch (5 U. S.) 110.]

Opinion:
CRANCH. Circuit Judge.
As the gist of the action is malice and the want of probable cause, the plaintiff must show the want of such cause; which will admit the defendant to give in evidence on the general issue the same facts which he has pleaded specially. Consequently, it is not necessary to the merits of the case that they should be specially pleaded. And the defendant having suffered an office judgment to go against him. and this not being a plea to issue, he cannot claim it as a matter of right.
MARSHALL. Circuit Judge, of the same opinion.
KILTY, Chief Judge.
Although it is necessary for the plaintiff to give evidence of a want of probable cause, yet that would perhaps only admit the defendant to give evidence as to the same facts which were disclosed by the plaintiff, and might not authorize him to give evidence of other facts within his own knowledge, and which might not be known to the plaintiff. This is a plea tending to an issue, and I think the defendant is in time to plead it.