Case Name: THE NATIONAL THREAD CO., Resp't, v. THE MANSFIELD SILK AND THREAD CO. and FANNIE JACOBS, App'lts
Court: New York Supreme Court, General Term
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1889-01-28
Citations: 21 N.Y. St. Rep. 977
Docket Number: 
Parties: THE NATIONAL THREAD CO., Resp’t, v. THE MANSFIELD SILK AND THREAD CO. and FANNIE JACOBS, App’lts.
Judges: 
Reporter: New York State Reporter
Volume: 21
Pages: 977–977

Head Matter:
THE NATIONAL THREAD CO., Resp’t, v. THE MANSFIELD SILK AND THREAD CO. and FANNIE JACOBS, App’lts.
Complaint—Dismissal—When doctrine op stare decisis applicable.
Appeal from judgment entered on the verdict of a jury at circuit and from order denying motion for new trial.
John II. V. Arnold., for app’lts; 8. B. Fairfield, for resp’t.
See same case on former appeal, 4 N. Y. State Rep., 886.

Opinion:
Bartlett, J.
It is impossible to reverse this judgment without taking a different view of the case from that adopted by the general term on the previous appeal. It was then held that the plaintiff was entitled to recover, inasmuch as the defendant, Fannie Jacobs, had received and retained in her possession a considerable amount of money belonging to the plaintiff on demand; and proof of this fact seems to have been deemed sufficient to warrant a recovery against her under the pleadings, which were then in the same form as at present. Upon the second trial, now under review, she herself admitted the collection and possession of some of the plaintiff's moneys.
The question whether any demand had 'been made upon her for payment was left to the jury, and they found against her.
grave doubt as to the sufficiency of the proof to establish any liability on the part of the Mansfield Silk and Thread Co., but as the general term then held that the complaint :against this defendant was erroneously dismissed on the first trial, I think the doctrine of stone decisis requires us to sustain the learned judge who presided on the second trial, in denying a similar motion to dismiss.
Van Brunt, Ch. J., and Daniels, J., concur.