Case Name: HELLRIGLE v. DULANY
Court: United States Circuit Court of the District of Columbia
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1834-10
Citations: 11 F. Cas. 1059
Docket Number: 
Parties: HELLRIGLE v. DULANY.
Judges: 
Reporter: Federal Cases
Volume: 11
Pages: 1059–1060

Head Matter:
Case No. 6,343.
HELLRIGLE v. DULANY.
[4 Cranch, C. C. 473.]
Circuit Court, District of Columbia.
Oct Term, 1834.
Jurisdiction — Amount op Verdict — Offsets.
If, in a suit in Alexandria, D. C., the debt be reduced below $50, by offsets, the plaintiff may have judgment for the sum found by the verdict
Assumpsit for $466.25, for work and labor as overseer, gardener, carpenter, &c. Plea, non assumpsit and set-off, and account in bar, consisting of cash payments, and cash received for vegetables sold, &c. Verdict for plaintiff, for $23.12.
Mr. Neale, for defendant,
moved for a non-suit, because the damages found are below the jurisdiction of this court and cited Maitland v. McDearman, 1 Va. Cas. 131; Minor v. Goodall, 3 Call, 393; Pitts v. Carpenter, 1 Wils. 19; Gross v. Eisher, 3 Wils. 48; Ferguson v. Highley, 2 Va. Cas. 255; Parker v. Elding, 1 East, 353; Neff v. Talbot. 1 Va. Cas. 140; Hepburn v. Lewis. 2 Call, 497; Newell v. Wood, 1 Munf. 555; U. S. v. McDowell, 4 Cranch [8 U. S.] 316; and the act of 1823 (enlarging the jurisdiction of justices of the peace), § 6 (3 Stat. 743).
Mr. 'Mason and Mr. Taylor, for plaintiff.
[Reported by Hon. William Cranch, Chief Judge.]

Opinion:
THE COURT
rendered judgment for the plaintiff, after considering the following cases and authorities, viz.: Goddard v. Davis [Case No. 5,491], in this court at Alexandria, July term, 1801; Rutter v. Merchant [Id. 12,179], at the same term; McKnight v. Ramsay [Id. 8,868), at Alexandria, Oct., 1801; Ridgway v. Pancost [Id. 11,818], at Alexandria, April, 1802; Curry v. Fletcher [Id. 3,490], at Washington, Dec., 1802; Beale v. Voss [Id. 1,160], at Washington, July term, 1804; Acts Md. 1729, c. 20, § 5; the British statute of 2 Geo. II., c. 22, § 13; Acts Md. 1785, c. 4, § 7; Id. c. 87, § 2; Acts Md. 1791, c. 68, § 9; Hays v. Bell [Case No. 6,270], at Alexandria, July, 1807; McLaughlin v. Stelle [Id. 8,873], at Washington, June, 1808; Smith v. Queen [Id. 13,096], at Washington, June, 1808: Bryan v. Davis [Id. 2,065], at Washington, June, 1810; Skinner v. Caffrey [Id. 12,924], at Washington, Dec., 1819; Cazenove v. Darrell [Id. 2,539], at Alexandria, Nov., 1823; Hooe v. Rees [Id. 6,668], at Alexandria, May, 1824; Burton v. Varnum [Id. 2,220], at Washington, Dec., 1824; Davidson v. Burr [Id. 3,602], at Washington, Dec., 1824; Pitts v. Carpenter, 2 Strange, 1191.