Case Name: Manmy COHEN and Dorothy Cohen, doing business as Manny Cohen Company, Libellants, v. M/V The CIUDAD DE IBAQUE, her engine, boilers, etc., the Transportadora Grancolombiana, Ltda., and Flota Mercante, Grancolombiana, S. A., Respondents
Court: United States District Court for the Southern District of New York
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1956-09-27
Citations: 145 F. Supp. 190
Docket Number: 
Parties: Manmy COHEN and Dorothy Cohen, doing business as Manny Cohen Company, Libellants, v. M/V The CIUDAD DE IBAQUE, her engine, boilers, etc., the Transportadora Grancolombiana, Ltda., and Flota Mercante, Grancolombiana, S. A., Respondents.
Judges: 
Reporter: Federal Supplement
Volume: 145
Pages: 190–190

Head Matter:
Manmy COHEN and Dorothy Cohen, doing business as Manny Cohen Company, Libellants, v. M/V The CIUDAD DE IBAQUE, her engine, boilers, etc., the Transportadora Grancolombiana, Ltda., and Flota Mercante, Grancolombiana, S. A., Respondents.
United States District Court S. D. New York.
Sept. 27, 1956.
Cooper, Ostrin & De Vareo, New York City, Richard Gyory, New York City,' of counsel, for libellants.
Nelson, Healy, Baillie & Burke, New York City, Alan Baillie, New York City, of counsel, for respondents.

Opinion:
SUGARMAN, District Judge.
In a suit for cargo damage, the respondents move for an order (1) vacating the interlocutory decree entered on movants' failure to appear or answer and (2) granting leave to file an answer to the libel.
After extended negotiations between the parties both before and after commencement of the suit, counsel for libel-lants concededly advised movants' representative to send the case to counsel for defense.
This was not done because the underwriter did not believe that libellants' proctor meant what he said.
Considering the uncontradicted assertion that libellants' "chief witness" is now dead and no good cause being shown to justify granting the complete relief sought, the motion is granted to the limited extent of directing that the commissioner hear respondents on the sole question of damages.
It is so ordered.