Case Name: EDWARD HOLEMAN, vs. THO'S. D. CARNEAL
Court: Kentucky Court of Appeals
Jurisdiction: Kentucky
Decision Date: 1820-10-23
Citations: 2 A.K. Marsh. 602
Docket Number: 
Parties: EDWARD HOLEMAN, vs. THO'S. D. CARNEAL.
Judges: 
Reporter: Kentucky Reports
Volume: 9
Pages: 602–602

Head Matter:
EDWARD HOLEMAN, vs. THO'S. D. CARNEAL.
23 Oct. 1820.
On an appeal from a judgment of the Gallatin circuit court.
The court cannot discharge these curlty in a traverse bond and thereby render him a competent witness.
Talbot for plaintiff, Hardin and Bibb for defendant.

Opinion:
Judge Owsley
delivered the opinion of the court.
Notwithstanding the court, before whom the traverse in this case was tried, made an order discharging the surety in the bond given by Carneal before the justice, for the due prosecution of the traverse, the surety, nevertheless, remained responsible; and, as was held at the present term in the case of Jack against Carneal, the security was incompetent to prove any fact conducing to shew Carneal's right to recover. Because therefore, Rout, who is security in the bond, was admitted as a witness on the part of Carneal, the judgment must be reversed with cost, the cause remanded, and further proceedings had, not inconsistent with his opinion.