Case Name: Catherynne Whtyefawn KENDRICK, Appellant, v. Martin POPE, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Pratt, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Julie Redd, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Shawna Reid, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Richardson-Beshears, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Patricia A. Roberts, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Mickey Robertson, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Santa Clause Runyun, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; L.K. Sluder, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Jim Smith, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Judith Steed, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Lori Tacker, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Janet Tiner, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Christy Townsend, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Julia Webber, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Pam Wilson, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Leslie H. Zomant, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Kathleen M. Dechant, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Roy Agee, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Bobbie Allison, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Candice Ashby, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Roger L. Ayers, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Ronald Bailey, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Henry Boyce, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Maggie Capel, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; William Caraway, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Phillip W. Cargill, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Bernstein Coleman, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; C. Corrington, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Judy Taylor, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; June Daniels, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Wayland, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Jeff Deen, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Linda Dixon, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Amanda C. Dutton-Jackson, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Linda Dykes-Cullum, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Stephanie England, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Nurzuhal Faust, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Cherry Garrett, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; James Gibson, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; William Jones, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Wendy Kelley, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Crystal Lavender, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; John Maples, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Deborah Masters, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Larry May, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; P. McCoy, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; S.E. McCrory, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Sonya Whitefield McGinnis-Douglas, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Larry Norris, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Dexter Payne, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Petit, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Kathy Pirano, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Defendants, Lavonda K. Donavion, Sgt., McPherson Unit, ADC; Sara E. Martin, Corporal, McPherson Unit, ADC, Appellees. Bobby Coleman, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; C. Compton, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction, Defendants
Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 2012-03-01
Citations: 671 F.3d 686
Docket Number: No. 11-1564
Parties: Catherynne Whtyefawn KENDRICK, Appellant, v. Martin POPE, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Pratt, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Julie Redd, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Shawna Reid, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Richardson-Beshears, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Patricia A. Roberts, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Mickey Robertson, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Santa Clause Runyun, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; L.K. Sluder, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Jim Smith, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Judith Steed, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Lori Tacker, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Janet Tiner, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Christy Townsend, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Julia Webber, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Pam Wilson, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Leslie H. Zomant, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Kathleen M. Dechant, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Roy Agee, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Bobbie Allison, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Candice Ashby, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Roger L. Ayers, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Ronald Bailey, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Henry Boyce, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Maggie Capel, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; William Caraway, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Phillip W. Cargill, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Bernstein Coleman, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; C. Corrington, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Judy Taylor, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; June Daniels, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Wayland, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Jeff Deen, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Linda Dixon, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Amanda C. Dutton-Jackson, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Linda Dykes-Cullum, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Stephanie England, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Nurzuhal Faust, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Cherry Garrett, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; James Gibson, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; William Jones, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Wendy Kelley, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Crystal Lavender, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; John Maples, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Deborah Masters, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Larry May, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; P. McCoy, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; S.E. McCrory, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Sonya Whitefield McGinnis-Douglas, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Larry Norris, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Dexter Payne, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Petit, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Kathy Pirano, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Defendants, Lavonda K. Donavion, Sgt., McPherson Unit, ADC; Sara E. Martin, Corporal, McPherson Unit, ADC, Appellees. Bobby Coleman, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; C. Compton, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction, Defendants.
Judges: Before LOKEN, BYE, and COLLOTON, Circuit Judges.
Reporter: Federal Reporter 3d Series
Volume: 671
Pages: 686–690

Head Matter:
Catherynne Whtyefawn KENDRICK, Appellant, v. Martin POPE, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Pratt, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Julie Redd, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Shawna Reid, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Richardson-Beshears, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Patricia A. Roberts, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Mickey Robertson, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Santa Clause Runyun, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; L.K. Sluder, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Jim Smith, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Judith Steed, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Lori Tacker, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Janet Tiner, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Christy Townsend, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Julia Webber, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Pam Wilson, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Leslie H. Zomant, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Kathleen M. Dechant, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Roy Agee, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Bobbie Allison, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Candice Ashby, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Roger L. Ayers, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Ronald Bailey, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Henry Boyce, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Maggie Capel, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; William Caraway, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Phillip W. Cargill, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Bernstein Coleman, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; C. Corrington, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Judy Taylor, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; June Daniels, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Wayland, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Jeff Deen, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Linda Dixon, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Amanda C. Dutton-Jackson, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Linda Dykes-Cullum, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Stephanie England, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Nurzuhal Faust, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Cherry Garrett, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; James Gibson, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; William Jones, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Wendy Kelley, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Crystal Lavender, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; John Maples, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Deborah Masters, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Larry May, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; P. McCoy, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; S.E. McCrory, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Sonya Whitefield McGinnis-Douglas, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Larry Norris, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Dexter Payne, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Petit, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Kathy Pirano, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; Defendants, Lavonda K. Donavion, Sgt., McPherson Unit, ADC; Sara E. Martin, Corporal, McPherson Unit, ADC, Appellees. Bobby Coleman, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction; C. Compton, Classification Administrator, Arkansas Department of Correction, Defendants.
No. 11-1564.
United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit.
Submitted: Aug. 15, 2011.
Filed: March 1, 2012.
Rehearing and Rehearing En Banc Denied April 12, 2012.
Brenna J. Ryan, Baldwinsville, NY, for appellant.
Sherri L. Robinson, AAG, Little Rock, AR, for appellee.
Before LOKEN, BYE, and COLLOTON, Circuit Judges.
Judges Riley, Wollman, Colloton, Gruender and Benton would grant the petition for rehearing en banc.

Opinion:
PER CURIAM.
Arkansas inmate Catherynne Whtyefawn Kendrick appeals following the district court's disposition of her claims against Sergeant Lavonda K. Donavion, the sole remaining defendant in this 42 U.S.C. § 1983 action. Upon careful review, we conclude that Kendrick administratively exhausted her constitutional claims arising from the confiscation of her Catholic Bible, rosary beads, and other religious materials during a November 2007 cell shakedown, and the subsequent failure to return these items. We also conclude that—-on the present record—trialworthy issues exist on these claims. See Montin v. Estate of Johnson, 636 F.3d 409, 412 (8th Cir.2011) (summary judgment standard of review); King v. Iowa Dep't of Corr., 598 F.3d 1051, 1052 (8th Cir.), cert. denied, — U.S.—, 131 S.Ct. 499, 178 L.Ed.2d 296 (2010) (de novo review of administrative exhaustion).
Accordingly, we reverse as to the claims against Donavion, and we remand for further proceedings consistent with this opinion. We also grant appellee Corporal Sarah E. Martin's motion to dismiss; we deny Kendrick's motion to "reinstate" Martin; and we deny Kendrick's remaining motions for relief, which in part raise claims and allegations that can be addressed on remand.