Case Name: Smith vs. Smith
Court: New York Court of Chancery
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1832-01-23
Citations: 1 Edw. Ch. 255
Docket Number: 
Parties: Smith vs. Smith.
Judges: 
Reporter: Edwards' Chancery Reports
Volume: 1
Pages: 255–256

Head Matter:
Smith vs. Smith.
Temporary alimony and money to carry on the suit will be allowed, notwithstanding the opposite party puts in a plea denying the marriage.
January 23, 1832.
The bill in this cause was filed by the wife against the husband for a divorce a mensa et thora, on the ground of cruelty. It distinctly set forth the time and place of marriage and the name of the minister who officiated at the ceremony. The pleading was sworn to.
An application was now made for temporary alimony and money to carry on the suit.
The defendant, by way of meeting it, read his plea, sworn to, which unequivocally denied his ever having been married to the complainant. It was unaccompanied by any answer,
Mr. Thomas W. Clerke, for the applicant.
Mr, Charles W, Sandford, for the defendant.

Opinion:
The ' Vice-Chancellor,
A novel question is presented here. Although the defendant denies á marriage de facto, he . , , has not denied cohabitation, or living together, nor the great cruelty set forth in the bill. .At this stage of the suit, I do not think the plea sufficient to prevent the granting of the application. In Smyth v. Smyth, 2 Adams, 254, the!' court, in effect, granted temporary alimony, when in point of form it could not allot it to the wife until the fact of marriage was either proved or confessed by the.husband.
I shall direct a reference to -a master to 'ascertain the amount-which ought to be. allowed, according as the circumstances of the defendant may appear before him.
Ordered accordingly.