Case Name: JOHN D. HAGER v. H. B. FOWLKES ET AL.
Court: Tennessee Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Tennessee
Decision Date: 1877-01
Citations: 2 Shan. Cas. 217
Docket Number: 
Parties: JOHN D. HAGER v. H. B. FOWLKES ET AL.
Judges: 
Reporter: Tennessee Cases with Notes and Annotations
Volume: 2
Pages: 217–217

Head Matter:
JOHN D. HAGER v. H. B. FOWLKES ET AL.
Nashville,
January Term, 1877.
HOMESTEAD EXEMPTION. Prevails over debts contracted after act of 1868, though before act of 1870.
In all cases where the debt has been contracted subsequent to the homestead act of 1868, the homestead right is saved, though the contraction of such debts be prior to the act of 1870. [Cited and approved in Nichol v. Davidson County, 3 Tenn. Chy., 550. See notes 48-50 under see. 3803 of the Code.]
Cited with approval: Deatherage v. Walker, 11 Heis., 45; Kennedy v. Stacy, 1 Bax., 330.

Opinion:
Sneed, J.,
delivered the opinion of the court;
The bill was brought to protect a homestead, claimed by the complainant, upon which certain executions had been levied. The chancellor decreed for the complainant. The defenses were that the complainant did not occupy the premises at the time of the levy, and that the debts which had been merged into payments, were contracted prior to the creation by statute of the homestead right. Upon the first proposition, we think the complainant has fully made out his case upon the proof; on the second, it appears that one or more of the several debts sued on was contracted prior to the homestead act of 1870, but subsequent to the homestead act of 1868. It was held in the case of Deatherage v. Walker, decided at Knoxville, in 1873 [since reported in 11 Heis., 45], and in Kennedy v. Stacey, decided at Knoxville, in 1874 [since reported in 1 Bax., 220], that the homestead right was saved in cases where the debts were contracted prior to the homestead act of 1870, if it appears that they were contracted subsequent to the homestead act of 1868'. The principle of these cases must govern the case in hand.
Affirm the decree.