Case Name: The Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Co. v. The Commonwealth of Virginia
Court: Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia
Jurisdiction: Virginia
Decision Date: 1909-09-09
Citations: 110 Va. 215
Docket Number: 
Parties: The Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Co. v. The Commonwealth of Virginia.
Judges: 
Reporter: Virginia Reports
Volume: 110
Pages: 215–216

Head Matter:
Staunton.
The Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Co. v. The Commonwealth of Virginia.
September 9, 1909.
1. State Corporation Commission—Lack of Parties—Railroads—Appeal.—Where a necessary party to the proceedings in a ease before the State Corporation Commission has been ommitted and not served with process, the cause will be remanded to the Commission without deciding any of the questions involved, in pursuance of section 156 (f) of the Constitution, for such further proceedings as may be necessary to a proper and final decision of the matters in controversy.
Appeal from the State Corporation Commission.
Remanded.
This cause conies up upon an appeal from an order of the State Corporation Commission, entered January 28, 1908, and the order of May 20, 1908, imposing a fine of $500 upon the appellant, the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Company, for its failure to carry into effect the 6th paragraph of said order of January 28, 1908.
If. R. Preston and Bumgardner & Bumgardner, for the appellant.
Wm. A. Anderson, Attorney General and Robert Tunstall, for the Commonwealth.

Opinion:
By the Court:
The transcript of the record in this case having been seen and inspected, the court is of opinion, and doth so decide and declare, that the Valley Railroad Company is an independent corporate organization, whose rights and property are materially affected by the orders aforesaid, and was a necessary party, to the proceedings, and as such entitled to reasonable notice and opportunity to make defense by appropriate pleadings, and to introduce evidence in its behalf, and to be heard thereon, before any order affecting its rights could he lawfully entered.
The court, therefore, in pursuance of Article 12, sec. 156 (f) of the Constitution of Virginia (without at this time passing upon any of the questions involved, except to reverse the order of May 20, 1908, imposing a fine of $500 upon the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Company) deems it necessary, in the interest of justice, to remand the case to the State Corporation Commission for such further proceedings to he had therein as may he necessary to a proper and final decision of the matters in controversy.
And it is so ordered.
Remanded.