Case Name: KATHERINE BROWN AND ANOTHER v. ALMA L. GALLINGER
Court: Minnesota Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Minnesota
Decision Date: 1933-01-20
Citations: 188 Minn. 22
Docket Number: No. 29,113
Parties: KATHERINE BROWN AND ANOTHER v. ALMA L. GALLINGER.
Judges: OLSEN, Justice, took no part in-the consideration or decision of this case.
Reporter: Minnesota Reports
Volume: 188
Pages: 22–23

Head Matter:
KATHERINE BROWN AND ANOTHER v. ALMA L. GALLINGER.
January 20, 1933.
No. 29,113.
Alma L. Gallinger, pro se.
John L. Brown, for respondents.
Reported in 246 N. W. 473.

Opinion:
STONE, Justice.
Plaintiffs had judgment on the pleadings, and defendant appeals. The action is for injunction to prevent trespass upon land in possession of plaintiffs. Plaintiffs' title depends upon the foreclosure by action of a mortgage admittedly given by defendant and which she insists by answer is still a mortgage notwithstanding its foreclosure. That foreclosure is pleaded at length in the complaint, together with the resulting sale, plaintiffs claiming under conveyance from the purchaser at the sale. Defendant's failure to redeem is also alleged by the complaint and admitted by the answer, the latter, however, setting up certain facts which, if true, would have been at best matter of defense in the foreclosure action. Judgment was properly ordered for plaintiffs on the pleadings. The judgment in the foreclosure action, from which there was no appeal (the time for appeal has expired), is res judicata. 3 Dunnell, Minn. Dig. (2 ed. & Supp.) § 5163. It is not open to collateral attack (§ 5137, id.) as was attempted by the answer in this case.
Judgment affirmed.
OLSEN, Justice, took no part in-the consideration or decision of this case.