Case Name: Erika Eneman and Amy Nadler, Plaintiffs-Appellants-Petitioners, v. Pat Richter, Susan Riseling, David Williams, Defendants-Respondents, Per Mar Security & Research, Oxford Health Plans (Connecticut), Inc., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2893]; Tara L. Harrison, Gary Harrison and Louise Harrison, Plaintiffs-Appellants-Petitioners, v. Pat Richter, Mike Green and Susan Riseling, Defendants-Respondents, Per Mar Security & Research, Cigna Health Care, Defendants, David Williams, Defendant-Respondent, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., XYZ Insurance Corp., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2895]; Alyson J. Berowitz, and Stephen S. Berowitz, Plaintiffs-Appellants-Petitioners, v. Pat Richter, Mike Green, Susan Riseling, Defendants-Respondents, Per Mar Security & Research, Defendant, David Williams, Defendant-Respondent, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., XYZ Insurance Corporation, Defendants. [Case No. 96-2916]; Rebecca S. Levine, David P. Levine, The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America, Plaintiffs-Appellants-Petitioners, v. Pat Richter, Mike Green, Susan Riseling, Defendants-Respondents, Per Mar Security & Research, Defendant, David Williams, Defendant-Respondent, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., XYZ Insurance Corporation, Defendants. [Case No. 96-2917]; Susan K. Roemer, Plaintiff-Appellant-Petitioner, Blue Cross & Blue Shield United of WI, Involuntary-Plaintiff, v. Susan Riseling, Defendant-Respondent, David Williams, Defendant, Patrick Richter, Defendant-Respondent, Michael Green, Defendant, David Ward, Defendant-Respondent, UW-Madison, Per Mar Security & Research, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2937]; Stephanie M. Kaplan, Plaintiff-Appellant-Petitioner, John Alden Life Insurance Company, a foreign insurance corporation, Involuntary-Plaintiff, v. Susan Riseling, Defendant-Respondent, David Williams, Defendant, Patrick Richter, Defendant-Respondent, Michael Green, Defendant, David Ward, Defendant-Respondent, UW-Madison, Per Mar Security & Research, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2938]; Adam P. Read, Plaintiff-Appellant-Petitioner, v. Susan Riseling, Defendant-Respondent, David Williams, Defendant, Patrick Richter, Defendant-Respondent, Michael Green, Defendant, David Ward, Defendant-Respondent, University of Wisconsin - Madison, Per Mar Security & Research, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2939]
Court: Wisconsin Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Wisconsin
Decision Date: 1999-03-03
Citations: 224 Wis. 2d 258
Docket Number: Nos. 96-2893, 96-2895, 96-2916, 96-2917, 96-2937, 96-2938, 96-2939
Parties: Erika Eneman and Amy Nadler, Plaintiffs-Appellants-Petitioners, v. Pat Richter, Susan Riseling, David Williams, Defendants-Respondents, Per Mar Security & Research, Oxford Health Plans (Connecticut), Inc., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2893] Tara L. Harrison, Gary Harrison and Louise Harrison, Plaintiffs-Appellants-Petitioners, v. Pat Richter, Mike Green and Susan Riseling, Defendants-Respondents, Per Mar Security & Research, Cigna Health Care, Defendants, David Williams, Defendant-Respondent, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., XYZ Insurance Corp., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2895] Alyson J. Berowitz, and Stephen S. Berowitz, Plaintiffs-Appellants-Petitioners, v. Pat Richter, Mike Green, Susan Riseling, Defendants-Respondents, Per Mar Security & Research, Defendant, David Williams, Defendant-Respondent, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., XYZ Insurance Corporation, Defendants. [Case No. 96-2916] Rebecca S. Levine, David P. Levine, The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America, Plaintiffs-Appellants-Petitioners, v. Pat Richter, Mike Green, Susan Riseling, Defendants-Respondents, Per Mar Security & Research, Defendant, David Williams, Defendant-Respondent, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., XYZ Insurance Corporation, Defendants. [Case No. 96-2917] Susan K. Roemer, Plaintiff-Appellant-Petitioner, Blue Cross & Blue Shield United of WI, Involuntary-Plaintiff, v. Susan Riseling, Defendant-Respondent, David Williams, Defendant, Patrick Richter, Defendant-Respondent, Michael Green, Defendant, David Ward, Defendant-Respondent, UW-Madison, Per Mar Security & Research, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2937] Stephanie M. Kaplan, Plaintiff-Appellant-Petitioner, John Alden Life Insurance Company, a foreign insurance corporation, Involuntary-Plaintiff, v. Susan Riseling, Defendant-Respondent, David Williams, Defendant, Patrick Richter, Defendant-Respondent, Michael Green, Defendant, David Ward, Defendant-Respondent, UW-Madison, Per Mar Security & Research, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2938] Adam P. Read, Plaintiff-Appellant-Petitioner, v. Susan Riseling, Defendant-Respondent, David Williams, Defendant, Patrick Richter, Defendant-Respondent, Michael Green, Defendant, David Ward, Defendant-Respondent, University of Wisconsin - Madison, Per Mar Security & Research, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2939]
Judges: 
Reporter: Wisconsin Reports Second
Volume: 224
Pages: 258–262

Head Matter:
Erika Eneman and Amy Nadler, Plaintiffs-Appellants-Petitioners, v. Pat Richter, Susan Riseling, David Williams, Defendants-Respondents, Per Mar Security & Research, Oxford Health Plans (Connecticut), Inc., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2893] Tara L. Harrison, Gary Harrison and Louise Harrison, Plaintiffs-Appellants-Petitioners, v. Pat Richter, Mike Green and Susan Riseling, Defendants-Respondents, Per Mar Security & Research, Cigna Health Care, Defendants, David Williams, Defendant-Respondent, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., XYZ Insurance Corp., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2895] Alyson J. Berowitz, and Stephen S. Berowitz, Plaintiffs-Appellants-Petitioners, v. Pat Richter, Mike Green, Susan Riseling, Defendants-Respondents, Per Mar Security & Research, Defendant, David Williams, Defendant-Respondent, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., XYZ Insurance Corporation, Defendants. [Case No. 96-2916] Rebecca S. Levine, David P. Levine, The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America, Plaintiffs-Appellants-Petitioners, v. Pat Richter, Mike Green, Susan Riseling, Defendants-Respondents, Per Mar Security & Research, Defendant, David Williams, Defendant-Respondent, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., XYZ Insurance Corporation, Defendants. [Case No. 96-2917] Susan K. Roemer, Plaintiff-Appellant-Petitioner, Blue Cross & Blue Shield United of WI, Involuntary-Plaintiff, v. Susan Riseling, Defendant-Respondent, David Williams, Defendant, Patrick Richter, Defendant-Respondent, Michael Green, Defendant, David Ward, Defendant-Respondent, UW-Madison, Per Mar Security & Research, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2937] Stephanie M. Kaplan, Plaintiff-Appellant-Petitioner, John Alden Life Insurance Company, a foreign insurance corporation, Involuntary-Plaintiff, v. Susan Riseling, Defendant-Respondent, David Williams, Defendant, Patrick Richter, Defendant-Respondent, Michael Green, Defendant, David Ward, Defendant-Respondent, UW-Madison, Per Mar Security & Research, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2938] Adam P. Read, Plaintiff-Appellant-Petitioner, v. Susan Riseling, Defendant-Respondent, David Williams, Defendant, Patrick Richter, Defendant-Respondent, Michael Green, Defendant, David Ward, Defendant-Respondent, University of Wisconsin - Madison, Per Mar Security & Research, Struck & Irwin Fence, Inc., Defendants. [Case No. 96-2939]
Supreme Court
Nos. 96-2893, 96-2895, 96-2916, 96-2917, 96-2937, 96-2938, 96-2939.
Oral argument January 6,1999. —
Decided March 3, 1999.
(Also reported in 589 N.W.2d 414.)
For all the plaintiffs-appellants-petitioners there were joint briefs by Lester A. Pines and Cullen, Weston, Pines & Bach, Madison; Richard F. Rice and Fox & Fox, Madison; Mark L. Thomsen and Cannon & Dunphy, S.C., Brookfield and oral argument by Mark Thomsen & Lester A. Pines.
For the defendants-respondents the cause was argued by John J. Glinski, assistant attorney general, with whom on the brief was James E. Doyle, attorney general.
Amicus curiae brief was filed by Edward E. Robinson and Warshafsky, Rotter, Tarnoff, Reinhart & Bloch, S.C., Milwaukee for the Wisconsin Academy of Trial Lawyers.

Opinion:
PER CURIAM.
¶ 1. The court is equally divided on whether to affirm or reverse the decision of the court of appeals. Justice Donald W. Steinmetz, Justice William A. Bablitch, and Justice Jon P. Wilcox would affirm; Justice Ann Walsh Bradley, Justice N. Patrick Crooks, and Justice David T. Prosser would reverse. Chief Justice Shirley S. Abrahamson did not participate.
¶ 2. Accordingly, the decision of the court of appeals is affirmed.