Case Name: Kathleen M. WINN, an Arizona taxpayer; Diane Wolfthal, an Arizona taxpayer; Maurice Wolfthal, an Arizona taxpayer Lynn Hoffman, an Arizona taxpayer, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. ARIZONA CHRISTIAN SCHOOL TUITION ORGANIZATION; Arizona School Choice Trust; Luis Moscoso; Gale Garriott, in his official capacity as Director of the Arizona Department of Revenue; Glenn Dennard, Defendants-Appellees
Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 2009-10-21
Citations: 586 F.3d 649
Docket Number: No. 05-15754
Parties: Kathleen M. WINN, an Arizona taxpayer; Diane Wolfthal, an Arizona taxpayer; Maurice Wolfthal, an Arizona taxpayer Lynn Hoffman, an Arizona taxpayer, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. ARIZONA CHRISTIAN SCHOOL TUITION ORGANIZATION; Arizona School Choice Trust; Luis Moscoso; Gale Garriott, in his official capacity as Director of the Arizona Department of Revenue; Glenn Dennard, Defendants-Appellees.
Judges: Before: D.W. NELSON, STEPHEN REINHARDT and RAYMOND C. FISHER, Circuit Judges.
Reporter: Federal Reporter 3d Series
Volume: 586
Pages: 649–671

Head Matter:
Kathleen M. WINN, an Arizona taxpayer; Diane Wolfthal, an Arizona taxpayer; Maurice Wolfthal, an Arizona taxpayer Lynn Hoffman, an Arizona taxpayer, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. ARIZONA CHRISTIAN SCHOOL TUITION ORGANIZATION; Arizona School Choice Trust; Luis Moscoso; Gale Garriott, in his official capacity as Director of the Arizona Department of Revenue; Glenn Dennard, Defendants-Appellees.
No. 05-15754.
United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit.
Oct. 21, 2009.
Isabel M. Humphrey, Esquire, Hunter, Humphrey & Yavitz, PLC, Paul Bender, Phoenix, AZ, Marvin S. Cohen, Esquire, Sacks Tierney PA, Scottsdale, AZ, for Plaintiffs-Appellants.
Benjamin Wyman Bull, Esquire, Jeremy D. Tedesco, Alliance Defense Fund, Scottsdale, AZ, David Andrew Cortman, Esquire, Alliance Defense Fund, Lawrence-ville, GA, Paula S. Bickett, Esquire, Terry Goddard, Esquire, Arizona Attorney General’s Office Frank J. Conti, Jr., Esquire, Pheonix, AZ, Timothy D. Keller, Tempe, AZ, for Defendants-Appellees.
D.C. No. CV-00-00287-EHC, District of Arizona, Phoenix.
Before: D.W. NELSON, STEPHEN REINHARDT and RAYMOND C. FISHER, Circuit Judges.
Order; Concurrence by Judge PREGERSON; Concurrence by Judge D.W. NELSON; Dissent by Judge O’SCANNLAIN.

Opinion:
ORDER
Judges Reinhardt and Fisher voted to reject the petitions for rehearing en banc and Judge Nelson so recommended.
The full court was advised of the petitions for rehearing en banc. A judge requested a vote on whether to rehear the matter en banc, and the matter failed to receive a majority of the votes of the nonrecused active judges in favor of en banc consideration. Fed. RApp. P. 35.
The three petitions for rehearing en banc, filed May 14, 2009, are denied.