Case Name: Douglas-Guardian Warehouse Corp. v. Todd et al.
Court: Supreme Court of Georgia
Jurisdiction: Georgia
Decision Date: 1957-01-14
Citations: 212 Ga. 791
Docket Number: 19512
Parties: Douglas-Guardian Warehouse Corp. v. Todd et al.
Judges: All the Justices concur.
Reporter: Georgia Reports
Volume: 212
Pages: 791–793

Head Matter:
19512.
Douglas-Guardian Warehouse Corp. v. Todd et al.
Argued November 13, 1956
Decided January 14, 1957.

Opinion:
Duckworth, Chief Justice.
The test of a case as made by writ of error to the Supreme Court as to whether it is one in equity, and hence reviewable by the Supreme Court (Code, Ann., § 2-3704), is not what it might have been at any given time during its pendency in the trial court, but what remained in it and is brought here for review. Matters eliminated either by the parties or by order of the trial court constitute no part of the case in the Supreme Court. Cochran v. Stephens, 155 Ga. 134 (116 S. E. 303); Coats v. Casey, 162 Ga. 236 (133 S. E. 237); Benton v. Benton, 164 Ga. 541, 543 (139 S. E. 68); Jones v. Pierce, 192 Ga. 217, 219 (14 S. E. 2d 739); Gilbert Hotel No. v. Black, 192 Ga. 641 (16 S. E. 2d 435); Overstreet v. Schulman, 203 Ga. 284 (46 S. E. 2d 344); Anagnostis v. Alexandrou, 203 Ga. 752 (48 S. E. 2d 521).
The only equity the case ever had was prayers for injunctive relief. These were effectively and completely eliminated in the modification order and, in so far as plaintiff's prayers were concerned, by the consent order entered January 12, 1949, expressly dissolving the only injunctive order issued in its favor, to which no exception was taken. There is no basis for an equitable accounting under Code § 37-301, and none was sought. And the final order denying an injunction does not make the case one in equity, since this was surplusage under the earlier consent degree. See Gormley v. Slicer, 178 Ga. 85 (172 S. E. 21). Thus the case is now one purely of law, and consequently the Court of Appeals and not this court has jurisdiction. See Rabun v. Wynn, 211 Ga. 446 (86 S. E. 2d 305); Simonton Construction Co. v. Pope, 212 Ga. 456 (93 S. E. 2d 712).
Transferred to the Court of Appeals.
All the Justices concur.
G. H. Mingledorff, Gibson & Maddox, Larry B. Pedrick, Bennett, Pedrick & Bennett, for plaintiff in error.
Lippitt & Lippitt, R. A. Moore, contra.