Case Name: UNITED STATES v. FISHER
Court: United States Circuit Court for the District of Ohio
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1849-10
Citations: 25 F. Cas. 1086
Docket Number: 
Parties: UNITED STATES v. FISHER.
Judges: 
Reporter: Federal Cases
Volume: 25
Pages: 1086–1087

Head Matter:
Case No. 16,102.
UNITED STATES v. FISHER.
[5 McLean, 23.]
Circuit Court, D. Ohio.
Oct. Term, 1849.
Embezzlement from Mail—Indictment—Article: of Value.
1. Where an indictment charges the carrier-of the mail with stealing a letter out of it, it is-sufficient.
2. If the letter contain an article of value, it must be so averred in the indictment, to subject the defendant to the incurred penalty.
3. But as it is an offence to steal a letter which, contains no article of value, it is not necessary to aver that it contained no such article.
The District Attorney, for the Government.
Mr. Lawrence, for defendant.
[Reported by Hon John McLean, Circuit Justice.]

Opinion:
OPINION OF THE COURT. This is an. indictment against the defendant [John Fisher], charging him as carrier of the mail, with stealing letters, &c. A motion is made to-quash certain counts in the indictment which charge the defendant with stealing a letter, without alleging that it contained no article of value. This is not necessary. A carrier-of the mail is subject to a higher penalty where he steals a letter out of the mail,, which contains an article of value. And. when this offense is committed, the indictment must allege the letter contained an article of value, which aggravates the offense- and incurs a higher penalty. But where the offense consists in stealing a letter, it may be so laid in the indictment, and the proof cannot go beyond the indictment. The motion is overruled.
The evidence being heard by the jury, he was convicted, and sentenced by the court