Case Name: The People ex rel. A. C. Tate, Relator, v. William Dalton, Commissioner of Water Supply of City of New York, Respondent
Court: New York Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1898-06
Citations: 24 Misc. 10
Docket Number: 
Parties: The People ex rel. A. C. Tate, Relator, v. William Dalton, Commissioner of Water Supply of City of New York, Respondent.
Judges: 
Reporter: New York Miscellaneous Reports
Volume: 24
Pages: 10–11

Head Matter:
The People ex rel. A. C. Tate, Relator, v. William Dalton, Commissioner of Water Supply of City of New York, Respondent.
(Supreme Court, Kings Special Term,
June, 1898.)
Charter of the Greater Hew York — Bights of the water registrar of Brooklyn to appointment — Mandamus — Veterans’ Acts.
The title of the water registrar of Brooklyn, appointed under its charter passed in 1888 "by the commissioner of city water works to hold “ during pleasure ”, to a similar office under the charter of the Greater New York, cannot be determined upon a peremptory writ of mandamus,' where the title turns on the construction of statutory pro- ■ visions, and this, although the relator is a veteran.
' Semble, that the Veterans’ Acts do not 'apply to the water registrar of Brooklyn, the holder of a public statutory office, and that he holds, a. “ confidential relation to the appointing officer ”, which deprives him of the protection of said acts.
Motion for a peremptory writ of mandamus.
Joseph A. Burr, for relator.
William J. Carr, for respondent.

Opinion:
Van Wyck, J.
The relator Tates's assignment was not " a new appointment or a reappointment." Greater H. Y. Charter, § 1536. The object of the. veterans' act section, 127, was. to continue, so far. as practicable, the privilege of sérving during good behavior or as being nonremovable, except for cause, to those veterans only who, being in the service of either of the separate municipalities prior to consolidation, enjoyed a like privilege under the then existing law. The relator was appointed under the Brooklyn charter.' Laws of 1888, chap. 583, tit. 15, § 1 and 2, subd. 3. His position is designated as that of " water registrar," and he is declared to be the " chief officer " of the " bureau for the collection of the revenue arising from the sale and use of water." His term was " during the pleasure " of the commissioner of the city works and not during good behaviofi
This statute creates a public office and defines the duties thereof, and makes the holder thereof an officer.
To such an officer, it appears the veterans' acts (Laws of 1897, chap. 708; Laws of 1888, chap. 583, tit. 22, § 29; Laws of 1888, chap. 119, amended by Laws of 1892, chap. 577; Laws of 1896, chap. 821) do not apply. In Matter of Hardy, 17 Misc. Rep. 667; People ex rel. Earl v. England, 16 App. Div. 98. A comparison of Brooklyn 'charter, tit. 15, § 1, under which relator was appointed, with tit. 21, § 14, under which Earl was appointed, the relator in that' case discloses that the authority in both cases was couched in the same language. Assuming Tate to have been an officer and that he was displaced by another who holds the office, if not abolished (Greater N. Y. charter), under a color of right, the title of which turns upon the construction of statutory provisions, it has been held that in such a case, such a question should not be determined in a mandamus proceeding. In Matter of Hardy, supra, People ex rel. Wren v. Goetting, 133 N. Y. 569, 571. It would seem that one who collected all the water revenue of the city of Brooklyn ought to be considered as " a person holding a confidential relation to the appointing officer," and, therefore, within this exception of the Veterans' Law. People ex rel. Crummey v. Palmer, 152 N. Y. 220;'People ex rel. Chittenden v. Wurster, id. 360. This is emphasized by the thought that the commissioner of water supply may be personally liable for all moneys collected by such appointee. Greater N. Y. charter, § 468, subd. .3; Tillinghast v. Merrill, 151 N. Y. 135.
For these reasons, the motion for peremptory writ of mandamus must be denied.
Motion "denied.