Case Name: Emily Allen Elfreth, executrix, &c., complainant-appellant, v. Charles J. Allen, executor, et al., defendants; Elizabeth R. Allen and Susan J. Allen, executrices, &c., defendants-appellants
Court: New Jersey Court of Errors and Appeals
Jurisdiction: New Jersey
Decision Date: 1930-05-19
Citations: 106 N.J. Eq. 263
Docket Number: 
Parties: Emily Allen Elfreth, executrix, &c., complainant-appellant, v. Charles J. Allen, executor, et al., defendants; Elizabeth R. Allen and Susan J. Allen, executrices, &c., defendants-appellants.
Judges: 
Reporter: New Jersey Equity Reports
Volume: 106
Pages: 263–265

Head Matter:
Emily Allen Elfreth, executrix, &c., complainant-appellant, v. Charles J. Allen, executor, et al., defendants; Elizabeth R. Allen and Susan J. Allen, executrices, &c., defendants-appellants.
[Argued October 23d, 1929.
Decided May 19th, 1930.]
Mr. Scott Scammell, for the appellants.
Mr. Peter Backes, for the respondents.

Opinion:
Per Curiam.
Onr examination of the case and briefs, and consideration of the arguments by counsel, leads to an affirmance of such parts of the decree below as are brought before us on this appeal, viz.: (1) the amount of the award to the trustee, and (3) the amount of the award to its counsel.
Inasmuch as the court is unanimous on one phase of the appeal but not on the other, at the request of the judges, the following questions are ordered to be voted upon separately:
1. Shall the award to the trustee of four per cent, commission on the two-fifths share of the corpus distributable to the executrix of the estate of Sarah H. Allen, deceased, and of four per cent, commission on the income of $333,383.37 received by said trustee, be affirmed?
3. Shall the award of a counsel fee to Peter Backes as counsel be affirmed for the amount fixed by the court of chancery in the decree under review?
As to first question—
For affirmance — The Chief-Justice, Trenchard, Parkee, Black, Campbell, Lloyd, Case, Bodine, Van Buskiek, McGlennon, Kays, Hetfield, Dear, Wells, JJ. 14.
For reversal — None.
As to second question—
For affirmance — Trenchard, Parkee, Campbell, Lloyd, Case, McGlennon, Kays, Hetfield, Dear, JJ. 9.
For reversal — The Chief-Justice, Black, Bodine, Van Buskirk, Dear, JJ. 5.