Case Name: MOLINE PLOW CO. vs. STATE TREASURER
Court: Michigan Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Michigan
Decision Date: 1895-04-16
Citations: 1 McGrath 1007
Docket Number: No. 14653
Parties: MOLINE PLOW CO. vs. STATE TREASURER,
Judges: 
Reporter: Mandamus cases decided in the Supreme court of Michigan
Volume: 1
Pages: 1007–1007

Head Matter:
MOLINE PLOW CO. vs. STATE TREASURER,
No. 14653,
105 M., 57.

Opinion:
To compel respondent to refund tbe amount wbicb was exacted from relator under Act No. 79, Laws of 1891, and paid by it under protest.
Denied April 16, 1895, witb costs.
Delator insisted that the act bad been declared unconstitutional in Coit vs. Sutton, 102 M., 324; that the payment made was involuntary, and that the act invalidated the contracts made by relators, unless its provisions were complied with. First National Bank vs. Watkins, 21 M., 489; Nickodemus vs. East Saginaw, 25 M., 456.