Case Name: Four Aces Jewelry Corp., Respondent, v. Jeffrey D. Smith et al., Appellants. (And a Third-Party Action.)
Court: New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1998-12-03
Citations: 256 A.D.2d 42
Docket Number: 
Parties: Four Aces Jewelry Corp., Respondent, v Jeffrey D. Smith et al., Appellants. (And a Third-Party Action.)
Judges: 
Reporter: Appellate Division Reports
Volume: 256
Pages: 42–45

Head Matter:
Four Aces Jewelry Corp., Respondent, v Jeffrey D. Smith et al., Appellants. (And a Third-Party Action.)
[680 NYS2d 539]

Opinion:
—Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Lorraine Miller, J.), entered January 8, 1998, which, insofar as appealed from, denied defendants' motion to renew their prior motion to compel production of plaintiffs 1993 and 1994 corporate income tax returns, reversed, on the law, without costs, the motion granted and plaintiffs directed to produce their 1993 and 1994 corporate income tax returns.
While tax returns are not discoverable absent a showing of overriding necessity (Matthews Indus. Piping Co. v Mobil Oil Corp., 114 AD2d 772), here, defendants have made the requisite showing. That there was a substantial variance be tween plaintiffs valuations of its inventory as of December 31, 1992, in a report to its insurer's accountant, and as of March 31, 1993, in its application for insurance, creates a proper basis for compelling production of plaintiffs 1993 and 1994 tax returns. This variance between the two valuations raises at least an inference of possible fraud, overcoming our normal reluctance to order production of tax returns (see, e.g., David Leinoff, Inc. v 208 W. 29th St. Assocs., 243 AD2d 418, 419-420; Leon Sylvester, Inc. v Aetna Cas. & Sur. Co., 189 AD2d 730). Moreover, the denials by plaintiff's principal and manager of any personal knowledge of the pre-incident inventory value, or personal involvement in either of the two valuations, leave a void as to the underlying financial position of the corporation for the periods in question. Concur — Sullivan, J. P., Mazzarelli and Saxe, JJ.
Rubin and Tom, JJ.,