Case Name: PEOPLE v. ANTOINE
Court: Michigan Court of Appeals
Jurisdiction: Michigan
Decision Date: 1992-05-04
Citations: 194 Mich. App. 189
Docket Number: Docket No. 127364
Parties: PEOPLE v ANTOINE
Judges: Before: Doctoroff, C.J., and Michael J. Kelly and Brennan, JJ.
Reporter: Michigan appeals reports; cases decided in the Michigan Court of Appeals.
Volume: 194
Pages: 189–191

Head Matter:
PEOPLE v ANTOINE
Docket No. 127364.
Submitted February 11, 1992, at Detroit.
Decided May 4, 1992, at 10:05 a.m.
Leave to appeal sought.
Rolando M. Antoine was convicted by a jury in the Detroit Recorder’s Court, Geraldine Bledsoe Ford, J., of armed robbery and was sentenced to eight to sixteen years’ imprisonment. He appealed by leave granted.
The Court of Appeals held:
1. Any error resulting from the court’s failure to instruct the jury with regard to the lesser included offenses of assault with intent to commit unarmed robbery and larceny from a person was harmless because the jury was instructed with regard to the lesser included offense of assault with intent to commit armed robbery and returned a verdict of guilty of the charged greater offense of armed robbery.
2. The trial court’s admonitions and observations at sentencing were not expressions of impermissible sentencing considerations.
Affirmed.
Frank J. Kelley, Attorney General, Gay Secor Hardy, Solicitor General, John D. O’Hair, Prosecuting Attorney, Timothy A. Baughman, Chief of Research, Training and Appeals, and Thomas M. Chambers, Assistant Prosecuting Attorney, for the people.
Gerald M. Lorence, for the defendant on appeal.
Before: Doctoroff, C.J., and Michael J. Kelly and Brennan, JJ.

Opinion:
Brennan, J.
Following a jury trial, defendant was convicted of armed robbery, MCL 750.529; MSA 28.797, and was sentenced to eight to sixteen years' imprisonment. Defendant appeals by leave granted. We affirm.
Defendant argues that the court erred in denying his request to instruct the jury with regard to the following lesser included offenses of armed robbery: assault with intent to commit unarmed robbery, MCL 750.88; MSA 28.283, and larceny from a person, MCL 750.357; MSA 28.589. We find that any error was harmless because the jury was instructed with regard to the lesser included offense of assault with intent to commit armed robbery, MCL 750.89; MSA 28.284, but, nevertheless, returned a verdict of guilty of the greater offense of armed robbery. People v Mosko, 190 Mich App 204, 209-210; 475 NW2d 866 (1991). Defendant's theory at trial was that nothing had happened. He never contended that an unarmed assault occurred. Moreover, there was no evidence that a weapon was not used in the assault. Accordingly, we find that reversal of defendant's conviction is not warranted.
Remand for resentencing is not necessary because we do not find that the trial judge's admonitions and observations at sentencing constituted an expression of impermissible sentencing considerations. Knowing as we do that the trial judge is of the same race as defendant, we can find no offensive or inappropriate consideration underlying her comment regarding her disappointment, which certainly must have reflected all of responsible society's disappointment in the felonious acts of all convicted criminals, in defendant as a black man. Her comments are not racist in any pejorative sense, they are feminist. No claim is made that feminist exhortations are impermissible. Except for the reference to defendant not deserving a lawyer, which we do find puzzling, the other com ments reflect the attitudes of society, and some are personified in the programs recently instituted in this state by its leading citizen.
Defendant also claims that the court made biased and hostile comments at sentencing. Sentencing is the time for comments against felonious, antisocial behavior recounted and unraveled before the eyes of the sentencer. At that critical stage of the proceeding when penalty is levied, the law vindicated, and the grievance of society and the victim redressed, the language of punishment need not be tepid.
Affirmed.