Case Name: Talbott & Sons v. E. J. Sandifer
Court: Supreme Court of South Carolina
Jurisdiction: South Carolina
Decision Date: 1887-07-20
Citations: 27 S.C. 623
Docket Number: No. 2103
Parties: Talbott & Sons v. E. J. Sandifer.
Judges: 
Reporter: South Carolina Reports
Volume: 27
Pages: 623–624

Head Matter:
No. 2103.
Talbott & Sons v. E. J. Sandifer.
April Term, 1887.
July 20, 1887.
Skinner Williams, for appellant.
James H. Davis, contra.

Opinion:
OPINION by
Mr. Justice McIver,
This was an action to foreclose a mortgage on a steam engine. The defence was, breach of warranty and offer to rescind. Under issues submitted to the jury, they found that plaintiffs had not complied with their agreement, and that defendant's damages by reason thereof were $100. The Circuit Judge (Witherspoon) declined to rescind, but ordered a credit of $100 to be entered on plaintiffs' note, and a foreclosure for the balance. Defendant appealed upon the single ground that he should have been allowed to enter up judgment on the verdict. Held, that the Circuit Judge was not bound by the verdict, but had the right and it was his duty, to render his own decision.