Case Name: PEOPLE ex rel. FORWARD ASS'N v. PURDY et al., Commissioners of Taxes and Assessments
Court: New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1916-04-14
Citations: 158 N.Y.S. 551
Docket Number: 
Parties: PEOPLE ex rel. FORWARD ASS’N v. PURDY et al., Commissioners of Taxes and Assessments.
Judges: 
Reporter: West's New York Supplement
Volume: 158
Pages: 551–553

Head Matter:
PEOPLE ex rel. FORWARD ASS’N v. PURDY et al., Commissioners of Taxes and Assessments.
(Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department.
April 14, 1916.)
Taxation @=3241(1)—Exemptions—Benevolent Institutions.
A certificate of incorporation, which shows that the purpose of the organization is, among other things, to own, manage, and operate a building for the purpose of the corporation, and to sublet portions of such building to other persons, clearly shows that the corporation is not entitled to an exemption from taxation under Tax Law (Consol. Laws, c. 60) § 4, subd. 7, which provides exemption only when the property of sucli a corporation is used entirely for corporation purposes, and not when it is rented, or when profit is derived thereon from other persons.
[Ed. Note.—For other cases, see Taxation, Cent. Dig. §§ 389, 391, 393; Dec. Dig. @=5241(1).]
Appeal from Special Term, New York County.
Certiorari by the People, on the relation of the Forward Association, against Lawson Purdy and others, as Commissioners of Taxes and Assessments. From an order denying a motion to quash the writ and dismiss the proceeding, defendants appeal. Reversed, writ quashed, and proceeding dismissed.
The following is the certificate of incorporation of the Forward Association:
State of New York, City and County of New York—ss;
We, the undersigned, of full age, being desirous of associating ourselves together for the purpose of mutual enjoyment,- social intercourse among members, also for the purpose of distributing literature, social and economic science as hereinafter is more particularly fully described, pursuant to and in conformity with acts of the Legislature of the state of New York relating to membership corporations, do hereby certify and declare that we are all of full age, two-thirds of us are citizens of the United State, and all of us are residents of the state of New York. We do further certify and declare as follows:
(1) That the particular objects for which said corporation is formed are as follows: To promote social intercourse and enjoyment among its members, diffuse knowledge in literature, economic and social science by means of meetings, lectures and more particularly by the means of useful publications.
(2) That the corporate name by which the said corporation hereby to be formed shall be known and distinguished is and shall be the Forward Association.
(3) That the territory in which the operation of said corporation is to be principally conducted is city of New York and state of New York.
(4) That the principal office of said corporation shall he located in the city of New York, county of New York and state of New York.
(5) That the number of directors shall be seven.
(6) [Names and place of residence of directors until first annual meeting.]
(7) That the annual meeting of said corporation shall be held on the first Monday of January in each year.
The amended certificate of incorporation reads as follows:
We, the undersigned, being all of the directors of the Forward Association, a membership corporation organized under the laws of the state of New York, desiring to alter the certificate of incorporation of the Forward Association so as to extend its corporate purposes pursuant to the provisions of the Membership Corporations Law of the state of New York, do hereby make and file the annexed certificate for such purpose and do certify as follows:
That the name of the corporation, whose certificate of incorporation is hereby altered is the Forward Association.
That the alteration proposed and intended to be affected by the execution and filing of this amended certificate consists ofi an extension of corporate purposes so as to include the following, to wit: “To promote social intercourse among its members, and to promote and diffuse, especially among the Jews in the United States, a general knowledge of literature, economics, social, political and historical science, and other useful information by means of publication, circulation, and sale of books, periodicals, newspapers, and other species of literature as well as by lectures and other methods; to own, "manage, and operate a building or buildings in the city of New York and elsewhere for the said purposes of the said corporation, and to sub-let portions of such building or buildings to other persons; to assist other progressive, political, civic, economic, and philanthropic movements and organizations financially, to co-operate with such organizations and movements, and to initiate such movements. The association shall at all times adhere to and propagate the principles of international Socialism and shall support only such political parties and organizations in the United States whose programs, platforms, and activities are in close conformity to such principles. The corporate purposes of the Forward Association shall not be changed, amended, or extended without the concurring vote of at least two-thirds of all members of the corporation present at the meeting at which any resolution for such proposed changes, amendments, or extensions shall be voted upon.”
Argued before CLARKE, P. J., and EAUGHLIN, DOWLING, PAGE, and DAVIS, JJ.
William H. King, of New York City, for appellants.
Alexander Kahn, of New York Cky, for respondent.

Opinion:
PER CURIAM.
It clearly appears from the certificate of incorporation of the relator that it is not within the class of corporations or associations entitled to exemption from taxation by subdivision 7, § 4, of the Tax Law.
The order is reversed, with $10 costs and disbursements, the writ of certiorari quashed, and the proceeding dismissed, with $10 costs.