Case Name: MULLALLY v. IRISH-AMERICAN BENEVOLENT SOCIETY
Court: Supreme Court of California
Jurisdiction: California
Decision Date: 1885-02-17
Citations: 2 Cal. Unrep. 440
Docket Number: No. 8717
Parties: MULLALLY v. IRISH-AMERICAN BENEVOLENT SOCIETY.
Judges: 
Reporter: California Unreported Cases
Volume: 2
Pages: 440–440

Head Matter:
MULLALLY v. IRISH-AMERICAN BENEVOLENT SOCIETY.
No. 8717;
February 17, 1885.
6 Pac. 78.
Benevolent Association—Sick Benefits—Burden of Proof.—In an action against a benevolent association for the recovery of sick benefits, the burden of proof is on the plaintiff to establish a by-law, rule, or custom rendering the society liable for such sick benefits.
. APPEAL from the Superior Court of the City and County of San Francisco.
H. A. Powell and Edgar M. Wilson for appellant; M. C. Hassett for respondent.
See 69 Cal. 559, 11 Pac. 215.

Opinion:
By the COURT.
The court below found: "The widow is not entitled, under the constitution or by-laws of said society (defendant), to recover benefits for sickness due to a member at the time of his death; nor is such widow entitled to recover such benefits under any rule or custom prevailing in said society." It was for the plaintiff to establish the existence of some provision of the constitution, or of some by-law, or (at least) of some rule or custom, which, on the facts proved, made it the duty of defendant to pay to plaintiff the amount of benefits for sickness due to deceased at the time of his death. The court below was justified in finding that plaintiff failed to establish either such provision of the constitution, or such by-law, or such rule or custom.
Judgment and order affirmed.