Case Name: James I. Allen vs. American Building & Loan Ass'n
Court: Minnesota Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Minnesota
Decision Date: 1893-10-20
Citations: 55 Minn. 86
Docket Number: No. 8305
Parties: James I. Allen vs. American Building & Loan Ass’n.
Judges: 
Reporter: Minnesota Reports
Volume: 55
Pages: 86–86

Head Matter:
James I. Allen vs. American Building & Loan Ass’n.
Submitted on briefs Oct. 6, 1893.
Affirmed Oct. 20, 1893.
No. 8305.
Former decisions followed.
The decisions of this court in Allen v. Same Defendant, 49 Minn. 544. and üarpenter v. Same Defendant, 54 Minn. 403, followed.
(Opinion published 56 N. W. Rep. 577.)
Appeal by defendant, American Building and Loan Association, from a judgment of the District Court of Hennepin County, William Lochren, J., entered December 28, 1892, against it for $12,634.69.
Hart & Brewer, Rea & Hubacheck, G. M. Cooley and M. B. Koon, for appellant.
Lusk, Bunn & Hadley, for respondent.

Opinion:
Buce, J.
This court has recently decided two cases involving substantially the same questions as are now presented for our consideration. We refer to the cases of Allen v. Same Defendant, 49 Minn. 544, (52 N. W. Rep. 144), and Carpenter v. Same, 54 Minn. 403, (56 N. W. Rep. 95.) Ordinarily, we would not again review these questions, but, in view of the large interests involved, and numerous parties affected, and that the writer hereof was not a member of this court at the time such decisions were made, we have deemed it advisable to consider fully the questions again submitted for our consideration, and, having done so, the former decisions are followed, adhered to, and the judgment of the lower court affirmed,