Case Name: The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Whitehead, Appellant; The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Waters, Appellant; The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Wade, Appellant; The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Headley, Appellant; The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. United Mine Workers of America, District 6, Appellant; The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. United Mine Workers of America, Appellant; The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Pacifico, Appellant; The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Kovaleski, Appellant; The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Smith, Appellant
Court: Supreme Court of Ohio
Jurisdiction: Ohio
Decision Date: 1953-11-25
Citations: 160 Ohio St. 320
Docket Number: Nos. 33707, 33708, 33709, 33710, 33711, 33712, 33713, 33714 and 33715
Parties: The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Whitehead, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Waters, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Wade, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Headley, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. United Mine Workers of America, District 6, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. United Mine Workers of America, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Pacifico, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Kovaleski, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Smith, Appellant.
Judges: . Weygandt, C. J., Middleton, Taft, Hart Zimmerman, Stewart and Lamneck, JJ., concur,
Reporter: Ohio State Reports, New Service
Volume: 160
Pages: 320–321

Head Matter:
The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Whitehead, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Waters, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Wade, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Headley, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. United Mine Workers of America, District 6, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. United Mine Workers of America, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Pacifico, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Kovaleski, Appellant. The State, ex rel. Bruns Coal Co., Appellee, v. Smith, Appellant.
(Nos. 33707, 33708, 33709, 33710, 33711, 33712, 33713, 33714 and 33715
Decided November 25, 1953.)
Messrs. Graham, Graham, Hollingsworth, Gottlieb é Johnston, for appellee.
Messrs. Jenkins, Williams, Wendt, Murray <& Deeg and Mr. George T. Tarbutton, for appellants.

Opinion:
It is ordered and adjudged that these appeals as of right be, and the same hereby are, dismissed for the reason that no debatable constitutional question is involved.
Appeals dismissed.
. Weygandt, C. J., Middleton, Taft, Hart Zimmerman, Stewart and Lamneck, JJ., concur,
Both counsel comment at length on the decision of this court in the case of Athens Home Telephone Co. v. Peck, Tax Commr., 158 Ohio St., 557, 110 N. E. (2d), 571. This case is not mentioned in the opinion of the Board of Tax Appeals. The obvious reason for this is that the board announced its decision on January not enter into the act of transportation itself."