Case Name: Ex Parte Solares
Court: Supreme Court of Puerto Rico
Jurisdiction: Puerto Rico
Decision Date: 1903-08-28
Citations: 4 P.R. 155
Docket Number: No. 16
Parties: Ex Parte Solares.
Judges: 
Reporter: Puerto Rico Reports
Volume: 4
Pages: 155–159

Head Matter:
Ex Parte Solares.
Application for a writ of Habeas Corpus.
No. 16.
Decided August 28, 1903.
Wakrant op Arrest — Requisites—A warrant of arrest must be issued in the name and by the authority of the People of Porto Rico, without which requisite the warrant is null and void.
Security to Keep the Peace — Proceedings—In proceedings instituted for the purpose of obtaining security to lreep the peace, the accused is entitled to be heard and introduce evidence in his behalf in accordance with the provisions of section 67 of the Penal Code.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE.
The writ issued for the production of the prisoner Eloy Solares Vanga, before the court, having been duly returned, the hearing of the case was had, when counsel for petitioner requested that the record of proceedings instituted by the justice of the peace of Manatí, in the matter of the complaint made before him against Solares and " which led to his imprisonment, be submitted, and the representative of the Attorney General having assented to said request, the aforesaid record was called for and brought before the court. From the said record it appears that immediately upon the ratification of the charge by the complainant and confirmation thereof by three witnesses whose testimony was given in writing over their signatures, the justice of the peace of Manatí issued an order directing that the accused Eloy Solares, be required to give bond in the sum of five hundred dollars to keep the peace toward the People of Porto Pico, and particularly toward the complainant, which bond would be valid and binding for six months; and that upon being served with notice of said complaint and required to furnish the said bond, according to return of said service entered at the end of the order and signed by the justice of the peace and clerk of the court, Solares stated that he denied the charge and had no property wherewith to furnish such bond, said return appearing without the signature of the accused, although he was able to write, no reason being given for such omission; and that Solares having failed to furnish the bond required of him, the justice of the peace had issued the warrant for his arrest, solely in his name and by his own authority.
The hearing having been resumed yesterday, counsel for petitioner filed an application for the discharge of his client, alleging among other reasons, that he had not been heard in the manner prescribed by section 67 of the Penal Code in force; that the warrant was void because it had not been issued in the name of the People of Porto Rico, all of which he would prove, and incidentally asked that the amount of the bond be reduced. The representative of the Attorney General indorsed the allegations of counsel for petitioner with reference to the nullity of the warrant.
Mr. Emigdio 8. Ginorio, for petitioner.
Mr. Feuille, Assistant Attorney General, for the People.

Opinion:
Mr. Chief Justice Quiñones,
after making the above statement of facts, delivered the following opinion :
The warrant for the arrest of Eloy Solares not having been issued in the name and by the authority of the People of Porto Rico, as generally provided by the Code of Criminal Procedure for this class of documents, in compliance with the provisions of section 16 of the Organic Act for the government and civil administration of this Island, approved April 12, 1900, said warrant is void and cannot have the effect of depriving the petitioner Eloy Solares of his liberty.
Moreover, inasmuch as the latter has not been heard in the manner prescribed by section 67 of the Penal Code, the justice of the peace of Manatí could not convict him without exceeding his jurisdiction which did not authorize him to convict the accused before hearing him and receiving his evidence, should he have presented any, and thus violating one of the most essential requirements of the special procedure provided for such cases under Title VI of the Penal Code in force.
, Wherefore, the case must be considered as coming under paragraphs 1 and 3 of section 483 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, for which reason the petitioner should be discharged. The prisoner Eloy Solares Vanga is ordered to be immediately discharged from custody, and the warden of the jail notified of this decision for compliance therewith and the proper order issued to give further effect thereto. The record of proceedings forwarded to the Chief Justice relating to the imprisonment of said Eloy Solares is directed to be returned to the justice of the peace of Manatí with a copy of this decision for his information and guidance.