Case Name: Hatch and others v. Hall
Court: United States Circuit Court for the Southern District of New York
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1884-12-04
Citations: 22 F. 438
Docket Number: 
Parties: Hatch and others v. Hall.
Judges: 
Reporter: Federal Reporter
Volume: 22
Pages: 438–438

Head Matter:
Hatch and others v. Hall.
(Circuit Court, S. D. New York.
December 4, 1884.)
Patents for Inventions — Injunction—Infringement in Another District— Citizenship.
The citizenship of an infringer within the district where the suit is brought, gives the right to proceed in such district against him jiersonally to prevent infringement elsewhere.
In Equity.
Frank P. Prichard and Biddle é Ward, for complainants.
B. F. Watson, for defendant.

Opinion:
WheeleR, J.
The right of the defendant to the orators' patent for the territory comprised within the state of New York would seem to afford him. no right to sell for use, within the territory still owned by the orators, the patented articles made by him in his territory. This is shown in the opinion of McKennan, J., in Hatch v. Adams, ante, 434. But no good reason yet appears why he should not be permitted to advertise the articles and sell them in New York, although the purchasers may take them into the orators' territory. The citizenship of the defendant within this district gives the right to proceed here against him personally to prevent infringement elsewhere. The motion for an injunction is granted so far as to restrain sales by the defendant or his agents within the orators' territory, and denied as to the residue.