Case Name: The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. Morris Bogin, Benjamin Goldberg, Sol Taub, Alex. Boreh, Louis Broad, Lena Gantman, Rebecca Gercht, Lena Stanashefsky, Alex Seaman, Sam Nelson, Julius Ginsberg, Sam Klempner, Louis Nelson, Menia Rosman, Anna Shapiro and Bertha Copeland, Appellants; The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. Jessie Silver, Fannie Sopolsky, Anna Wingar, Jennie Levine, Fanny Fubenberg, Fanny Shor, Jacob Levinson, Pauline Gutterman, Cecelia Richman, Dora Azusky, Tillie Glantz, Minnie Schiferin, Ida Rosen, Bessie Pearl and Sarah Mackler, Appellants; The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. Becky Lande, Yetta Salzman, Esther Steinberg, Anna Bendilovich, Fanny Kivintner, Sophie Stutzin, Fanny Steinberg, Vera Krieger, Clara Gabin, Ruth Gluskin, Rosie Green, Rachel Lavine, Jennie Drunkin, Esther Sivitz, Beckie Arowsky, Elenor Urban, Marian Gross, Abe Koneak, Isidore Mark, Morris Sternberg, Issie Greenspan, Herman Richman, William Friedman, Harry Gittleman, Benjamin Forsythe and Hyman Gunsman, Appellants; The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. Harry Jacobs, Morris Beskin, Isidor Solmowitz, Paul Strumasser, Israel Brown, Jos. Greenberg, Sam Schaffer, Paul Spolnik, Max Palson, Phillip Keller, Louis Grabelsky, Sol Kaininsky, Philip Denenberg, Harry Gordon, Jos. Brifus, Isidor Kirmeier, Abe Helfenbaum, Morris Rothman, Philip Herman, Morris Smith, Sam Bean, Harry Cohen, John Sigorick, Herbert Feldman, Bernard Olenberg, Isidor Brown, Mike Knezew, Sarah Terutzky, Ethel Shaw, Sarah Dubow, Malvina Bavman, Bertha Herman, Pearl Halpern, Sarah Bramnick, Annie Boses, Celia Samarodin, Appellants
Court: New York Court of Appeals
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1928-05-01
Citations: 248 N.Y. 530
Docket Number: 
Parties: The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. Morris Bogin, Benjamin Goldberg, Sol Taub, Alex. Boreh, Louis Broad, Lena Gantman, Rebecca Gercht, Lena Stanashefsky, Alex Seaman, Sam Nelson, Julius Ginsberg, Sam Klempner, Louis Nelson, Menia Rosman, Anna Shapiro and Bertha Copeland, Appellants. The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. Jessie Silver, Fannie Sopolsky, Anna Wingar, Jennie Levine, Fanny Fubenberg, Fanny Shor, Jacob Levinson, Pauline Gutterman, Cecelia Richman, Dora Azusky, Tillie Glantz, Minnie Schiferin, Ida Rosen, Bessie Pearl and Sarah Mackler, Appellants. The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. Becky Lande, Yetta Salzman, Esther Steinberg, Anna Bendilovich, Fanny Kivintner, Sophie Stutzin, Fanny Steinberg, Vera Krieger, Clara Gabin, Ruth Gluskin, Rosie Green, Rachel Lavine, Jennie Drunkin, Esther Sivitz, Beckie Arowsky, Elenor Urban, Marian Gross, Abe Koneak, Isidore Mark, Morris Sternberg, Issie Greenspan, Herman Richman, William Friedman, Harry Gittleman, Benjamin Forsythe and Hyman Gunsman, Appellants. The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. Harry Jacobs, Morris Beskin, Isidor Solmowitz, Paul Strumasser, Israel Brown, Jos. Greenberg, Sam Schaffer, Paul Spolnik, Max Palson, Phillip Keller, Louis Grabelsky, Sol Kaininsky, Philip Denenberg, Harry Gordon, Jos. Brifus, Isidor Kirmeier, Abe Helfenbaum, Morris Rothman, Philip Herman, Morris Smith, Sam Bean, Harry Cohen, John Sigorick, Herbert Feldman, Bernard Olenberg, Isidor Brown, Mike Knezew, Sarah Terutzky, Ethel Shaw, Sarah Dubow, Malvina Bavman, Bertha Herman, Pearl Halpern, Sarah Bramnick, Annie Boses, Celia Samarodin, Appellants.
Judges: 
Reporter: New York Reports
Volume: 248
Pages: 530–531

Head Matter:
The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. Morris Bogin, Benjamin Goldberg, Sol Taub, Alex. Boreh, Louis Broad, Lena Gantman, Rebecca Gercht, Lena Stanashefsky, Alex Seaman, Sam Nelson, Julius Ginsberg, Sam Klempner, Louis Nelson, Menia Rosman, Anna Shapiro and Bertha Copeland, Appellants. The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. Jessie Silver, Fannie Sopolsky, Anna Wingar, Jennie Levine, Fanny Fubenberg, Fanny Shor, Jacob Levinson, Pauline Gutterman, Cecelia Richman, Dora Azusky, Tillie Glantz, Minnie Schiferin, Ida Rosen, Bessie Pearl and Sarah Mackler, Appellants. The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. Becky Lande, Yetta Salzman, Esther Steinberg, Anna Bendilovich, Fanny Kivintner, Sophie Stutzin, Fanny Steinberg, Vera Krieger, Clara Gabin, Ruth Gluskin, Rosie Green, Rachel Lavine, Jennie Drunkin, Esther Sivitz, Beckie Arowsky, Elenor Urban, Marian Gross, Abe Koneak, Isidore Mark, Morris Sternberg, Issie Greenspan, Herman Richman, William Friedman, Harry Gittleman, Benjamin Forsythe and Hyman Gunsman, Appellants. The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. Harry Jacobs, Morris Beskin, Isidor Solmowitz, Paul Strumasser, Israel Brown, Jos. Greenberg, Sam Schaffer, Paul Spolnik, Max Palson, Phillip Keller, Louis Grabelsky, Sol Kaininsky, Philip Denenberg, Harry Gordon, Jos. Brifus, Isidor Kirmeier, Abe Helfenbaum, Morris Rothman, Philip Herman, Morris Smith, Sam Bean, Harry Cohen, John Sigorick, Herbert Feldman, Bernard Olenberg, Isidor Brown, Mike Knezew, Sarah Terutzky, Ethel Shaw, Sarah Dubow, Malvina Bavman, Bertha Herman, Pearl Halpern, Sarah Bramnick, Annie Boses, Celia Samarodin, Appellants.
(Argued April 9, 1928;
decided May 1, 1928.)
Aiken A. Pope and Jacob M. Mandelbaum for appellants.
Joab H. Banton, District Attorney (Felix C. Benvenga and John C. McDermott of counsel), for respondent.

Opinion:
Judgment in each case affirmed; no opinion.
Concur: Carduzo, Ch. J., Pound, Crane, Andrews, Lehman, Kellogg and O'Brien, JJ.