Case Name: Reliable Loan and Investment Company, Appellant, v. The Delgus Company, Inc., and Another, Respondents, Impleaded with Michael Skidelsky, Defendant
Court: New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1928-03-02
Citations: 223 A.D. 94
Docket Number: 
Parties: Reliable Loan and Investment Company, Appellant, v. The Delgus Company, Inc., and Another, Respondents, Impleaded with Michael Skidelsky, Defendant.
Judges: 
Reporter: Appellate Division Reports
Volume: 223
Pages: 94–96

Head Matter:
Reliable Loan and Investment Company, Appellant, v. The Delgus Company, Inc., and Another, Respondents, Impleaded with Michael Skidelsky, Defendant.
First Department,
March 2, 1928.
J. George Silberstein of counsel ¡Charles Tolleris and Leonard Acker with him on the brief; Charles Tolleris, attorney], for the appellant. ...
Milton Paulson of counsel [ Pomerantz & Paulson, attorneys], for the respondents.

Opinion:
Proskauer, J.
By several written agreements The Delgus Company, Inc., bought stock of the Larvex Corporation from the Rosses. The agreements provided for an abatement by $5,000 of the purchase price in the event that these sellers entered into competition with the Larvex Corporation. It also provided that " this agreement and the payments to be made thereunder may be assigned by the [sellers] upon condition, however, that [they] give notice in writing by registered mail " to the buyer, The Delgus Company, Inc. The defendants Rosenberg and Skidelsky guaranteed the payments to be made by The Delgus Company, Inc. The agreements were assigned by the Rosses to the defendant Skidelsky, who in turn assigned to one Siegfried and Siegfried assigned to the plaintiff as collateral security for a loan. After the assignment to Siegfried, - The Delgus Company, Inc., continued to. make payments to Siegfried under the contracts. These facts are undisputed.
The action is to recover the payments required under the agreements to be made by The Delgus Company, Inc.
Summary judgment is resisted on the ground that the assignment to the plaintiff is made invalid by the clause in the agreement requiring the giving of notice in writing by registered mail. There are two answers to this contention. The covenant requiring notice in writing does not make the assignment void, but only makes the assignor liable for damages, if any. (Manchester v. Kendall, 51 N. Y. Super. Ct. [19 J. & S.] 460; affd., 103 N. Y. 638; Bank of United States v. Public Bank of New York City, 88 Misc. 568; affd., 168 App. Div. 915.) It was obviously intended to protect the buyer from making payments to the wrong party. Moreover, by the payments made to Siegfried, The Delgus Company, Inc., waived this clause. The covenant regarding assignments, moreover, relates only to assignments " by the party of the first part," ' the Rosses, and not to assignments by any assignee of the party of the first part. The Delgus Company, Inc., having acquiesced in the assignments to Skidelsky and Siegfried, is in no position to question the validity of the subsequent assignment.
A defense is asserted for the abatement, of $5,000 on the ground that the Rosses did compete with the Larvex Corporation. While the proof supporting the alleged counterclaim is meagre, we deem it in the interest of justice to give defendants their day in court on this claim.
The order appealed from should be reversed, with ten dollars costs and disbursements, and the motion granted so far as to sever the action and direct judgment under rule 114 of the Rules Civil Practice for the plaintiff's claim, less the $5,000 for which defendant The Delgus Company, Inc., claims credit under the first separate and distinct defense.
Dowling, P. J., Merrell, McAvoy and Martin, JJ., concur.
Order reversed, with ten dollars costs and disbursements, and motion granted so far as to sever the action and direct judgment under rule 114 for the plaintiff's claim, less the $5,000 for which defendant The Delgus Company, Inc., claims credit under the first separate and distinct defense. Settle order on notice.