Case Name: GRAND LODGE, GENERAL GRAND INDEPENDENT ORDER OF BROTHERS AND SISTERS OF LOVE & CHARITY, etc., Inc., v. James RANDALL and Isaiah Sumner
Court: Louisiana Court of Appeal
Jurisdiction: Louisiana
Decision Date: 1933-04-17
Citations: 147 So. 748
Docket Number: No. 1183
Parties: GRAND LODGE, GENERAL GRAND INDEPENDENT ORDER OF BROTHERS AND SISTERS OF LOVE & CHARITY, etc., Inc., v. James RANDALL and Isaiah Sumner.
Judges: 
Reporter: Southern Reporter
Volume: 147
Pages: 748–749

Head Matter:
GRAND LODGE, GENERAL GRAND INDEPENDENT ORDER OF BROTHERS AND SISTERS OF LOVE & CHARITY, etc., Inc., v. James RANDALL and Isaiah Sumner.
No. 1183.
Court of Appeal of Louisiana. First Circuit.
April 17, 1933.
Chas. J. Mundy, of New Orleans, for appellant.
Rene H. Ilimel, of Franklin, for appellees.

Opinion:
LE BLANC, Judge.
This is one of the two suits referred to in the opinion in the case of Isaiah Sumner v. Grand Lodge, Knights of Pythias of State of Louisiana (La. App.) 147 So. 747, this day handed down, in which the issue as between Isaiah Sumner and James Bandall, intervener in that proceeding, is the same. As stated in the opinion in that case, the suits were consolidated for the purpose of trial and also for argument before this court. In this suit, judgment was rendered in favor of James Bandall recognizing him as beneficiary under the policy issued by the plaintiff in this case in favor of Allen Sumner, deceased, and as such, entitled to the proceeds thereof which had been deposited by plaintiff in the registry of the court.
For the same reasons as are assigned in the ease of Isaiah Sumner v. Grand Lodge, Knights of Pythias, it is ordered that the judgment appealed from herein be, and the same is hereby, affirmed.