Case Name: Butcher & Singer v. Hinchliffe & Keener Inc., etc. Appeal of Thomas A. Keener. Appeal of Charles K. Keener and Robert G. MacAlister
Court: Superior Court of Pennsylvania
Jurisdiction: Pennsylvania
Decision Date: 1980-05-23
Citations: 287 Pa. Super. 539
Docket Number: Nos. 1515 & 1516
Parties: Butcher & Singer v. Hinchliffe & Keener Inc., etc. Appeal of Thomas A. Keener. Appeal of Charles K. Keener and Robert G. MacAlister.
Judges: Before CERCONE, P. J., and MONTGOMERY and LI-PEZ, JJ.
Reporter: Pennsylvania Superior Court Reports
Volume: 287
Pages: 539–540

Head Matter:
May 23, 1980.
427 A.2d 255
Butcher & Singer v. Hinchliffe & Keener Inc., etc. Appeal of Thomas A. Keener. Appeal of Charles K. Keener and Robert G. MacAlister.
Reargument Denied Aug. 29, 1980.
Argued November 15, 1979.
Frank E. Coho, for appellant;
Fredrick N. Egler, Jr., for appellee.
Before CERCONE, P. J., and MONTGOMERY and LI-PEZ, JJ.

Opinion:
Order denying the motions of Charles K. Keener and Robert G. MacAlister, trustees of the Hinchliffe & Keener, Inc. Employee Pension Plan for judgment N.O.V. in their favor or a new trial is affirmed; but as to Thomas A. Keener, individually, that order is reversed and a new trial granted.