Case Name: BIRDIE HOUSE v. PENN. R. CO. et al
Court: United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1923-03-17
Citations: 1 Ohio Law Abs. 483
Docket Number: No. 11496
Parties: BIRDIE HOUSE v. PENN. R. CO. et al
Judges: 
Reporter: The Ohio Law Abstract
Volume: 1
Pages: 483–483

Head Matter:
No. 494
BIRDIE HOUSE v. PENN. R. CO. et al
U. S. District, N. D. Ohio. E. D
No. 11496.
Decided March 17, 1923
REMAND OF CAUSE to state court — Motion to de-ned — Would be in conflict with authority.
Motion to Remand to State Court;
Overruled
Attorneys — Payer, Winch, Minshall & Karsch, for

Opinion:
WESTENHAVER, D. J.
Epitomized Opinion
The motion of plaintiff House to remand this cause to the state court is denied on authority of Robbins v. -. 245 Fed. (D. C.) 435 and Vearial v. -, 197 Fed. (D. C.) 577 and Gatehouse, 274 Fed. (D. C.) 370. The instant case is in no wise distinguished from the above cited cases. The motion to remand is in effect a request that this court, overrule the decision of the Circuit Court of Appeals, in the Robbins case, and the Supreme Court in French v. Construction Co., 76 OS. 509.