Case Name: THE STATE ex rel. HOGAN v. POLICE COMMISSIONERS OF KANSAS CITY, Appellants; THE STATE ex rel. KNIGHT v. POLICE COMMISSIONERS OF KANSAS CITY, Appellants; THE STATE ex rel. WACHS v. POLICE COMMISSIONERS OF KANSAS CITY, Appellants; THE STATE ex rel. SMITH v. POLICE COMMISSIONERS OF KANSAS CITY, Appellants
Court: Supreme Court of Missouri
Jurisdiction: Missouri
Decision Date: 1902-12-24
Citations: 184 Mo. 139
Docket Number: 
Parties: THE STATE ex rel. HOGAN v. POLICE COMMISSIONERS OF KANSAS CITY, Appellants; THE STATE ex rel. KNIGHT v. POLICE COMMISSIONERS OF KANSAS CITY, Appellants; THE STATE ex rel. WACHS v. POLICE COMMISSIONERS OF KANSAS CITY, Appellants; THE STATE ex rel. SMITH v. POLICE COMMISSIONERS OF KANSAS CITY, Appellants.
Judges: All concur, except Valliant, J., who dissents.
Reporter: Missouri Reports
Volume: 184
Pages: 139–139

Head Matter:
THE STATE ex rel. HOGAN v. POLICE COMMISSIONERS OF KANSAS CITY, Appellants; THE STATE ex rel. KNIGHT v. POLICE COMMISSIONERS OF KANSAS CITY, Appellants; THE STATE ex rel. WACHS v. POLICE COMMISSIONERS OF KANSAS CITY, Appellants; THE STATE ex rel. SMITH v. POLICE COMMISSIONERS OF KANSAS CITY, Appellants.
In Banc,
December 24, 1902.
For the reasons set forth in State ex rel. Goodnow v. Police Commissioners of Kansas City, reported at page 109 of this volume, the judgments of the circuit court in the above causes are reversed, and the causes dismissed at relators’ costs.
Appeal from Jackson Circuit Court. — Ho». E. P. Gates, Judge.
Reversed.

Opinion:
MARSHALL, J.
These cases are in all essential respects similar to the case of State ex rel. Goodnow v. Police Commissioners of Kansas City (just decided), 184 Mo. 109; and the reasons given and the conclusion reached in that case apply equally to these cases. The judgment of the circuit court in these cases is therefore reversed, and the causes dismissed at relators' costs.
All concur, except Valliant, J., who dissents.