Case Name: J. O. McCollister, v. W. H. Murray, John M. Young, Frank Frantz, and Chas. H. Filson
Court: Oklahoma Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Oklahoma
Decision Date: 1907-06-25
Citations: 18 Okla. 710
Docket Number: 
Parties: J. O. McCollister, v. W. H. Murray, John M. Young, Frank Frantz, and Chas. H. Filson.
Judges: Irwin, J., and Pancoast, J., dissenting; all the other Justices concurring.
Reporter: Oklahoma Reports
Volume: 18
Pages: 710–710

Head Matter:
J. O. McCollister, v. W. H. Murray, John M. Young, Frank Frantz, and Chas. H. Filson.
(Filed June 25, 1907.)
Original in Supreme Court.
Horace Speed, and Virgil M. Hobbs, for plaintiff.
No appearance for defendant.

Opinion:
Opinion of the court by
Hainer, J.:
This is an original action brought by J. O. McCollister against W. H. Murray, president of the constitutional convention, John M. Young, its secretary, Frank Frantz, governor of Oklahoma Territory, and Chas. H. Filson, secretary of Oklahoma Territory, alleging substantially the same matters as were set forth in the case of G. F. Walck v. W. H. Murray, et al., No. 2145, and asks for the same relief. Upon the authority of Frank Frantz, et al. v. G. E. Autry, the relief prayed for must be denied, and the plaintiff's cause of action is dismissed for want of jurisdiction.
Irwin, J., and Pancoast, J., dissenting; all the other Justices concurring.