Case Name: Petition 6478-R of C. J. Tower & Sons (Buffalo)
Court: United States Customs Court
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1946-01-31
Citations: 16 Cust. Ct. 219
Docket Number: No. 50867
Parties: Petition 6478-R of C. J. Tower & Sons (Buffalo).
Judges: 
Reporter: United States Customs Court Reports
Volume: 16
Pages: 219–219

Head Matter:
Before the Second Division,
January 31, 1946
No. 50867.
Petition 6478-R of C. J. Tower & Sons (Buffalo).

Opinion:
Opinion by
Lawrence, J.
The testimony of the two witnesses for the petitioner showed that the trees in question were entered at 32 cents each, which, on entry, was believed to be the correct dutiable value thereof; that subsequent to making entry petitioner learned that the prices actually paid for the trees were higher than those stated on entry; and that on being apprised of that fact, petitioner expected that an opportunity would be afforded to amend the entries, as was customary in such cases, but that before steps could be taken in that direction the merchandise had been appraised. The acting appraiser at Niagara Falls and the customs agent, who investigated the purchase price of the trees in question, testified for the Government that the petitioner had always been truthful and cooperative in their customs transactions, and that, in their opinion, no attempt had been made to defraud the revenue. The court was satisfied concerning the good faith of the petitioner and was loath to believe that a reputable importer would intentionally try to save $23 in regular duties, deliberately running the risk of incurring additional duties in excess of $700, which were imposed in this case. It was held that while the authorities relied upon by the Government may be factually similar in some respects, nevertheless they are different in important particulars and therefore do not control in this case. The court held that satisfactory evidence had been supplied by the petitioner and that the evidence established that the entry of the merchandise was without any intent to defraud the revenue of the United States or to conceal or to misrepresent the facts of the case or to deceive the appraiser as to the value of the merchandise. The petition was therefore granted.