Case Name: A. W. VAN VALKENBERG vs. WILDER STEAMSHIP COMPANY
Court: Supreme Court of the State of Hawaii
Jurisdiction: Hawaii
Decision Date: 1893-04-17
Citations: 9 Haw. 67
Docket Number: 
Parties: A. W. VAN VALKENBERG vs. WILDER STEAMSHIP COMPANY.
Judges: Bickerton and Erear, JJ., and Cooper, Circuit Judge.
Reporter: Hawaii Reports
Volume: 9
Pages: 67–67

Head Matter:
A. W. VAN VALKENBERG vs. WILDER STEAMSHIP COMPANY.
Question Reserved.
Hearing, March 28, 1893.
Decision, April 17, 1893.
Bickerton and Erear, JJ., and Cooper, Circuit Judge.
(Judd, C.J., being disqualified, he having an interest in the defendant company, Circuit Judge Cooper sat in the case by request.)
A. S. Hartwell, for plaintiff.
F~, M. Hatch, for defendant.

Opinion:
Opinion op the Court, by
Bickerton, J.
Tin's matter comes here on the same reserved questions of law as in the case of M. A. Gonsalves & Company vs. this same defendant. The shipping receipt in this case is in the same form as the one in the Gonsalves & Company case, with the exception of some slight alterations which in our opinion do not in any way effect the construction to be put upon it. We therefore adopt as the opinion of the Court in this case the opinion filed in the case of M. A. Gonsalves & Company vs. Wilder Steamship Company. There is a stipulation made and filed by counsel in this case, that if the exemption is held to be limited to a marine loss, judgment shall be entered for the plaintiff.
Judgment may be entered accordingly for the plaintiff