Case Name: NNN DURHAM OFFICE PORTFOLIO 1, LLC; James Osmond; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 2, LLC; James Sun Yu Lam; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 3, LLC; Gary F. Turtle; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 4, LLC; Sherry L. Turtle; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 5, LLC; Gregory R. Maloney; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 6, LLC; Sharon I. Maloney; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 7, LLC; Ray Miller, Trustee; Patricia M. Miller, Trustee; NNN Durham Office PortfoLIO 9, LLC; PCL Property, LLC; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 10, LLC; Frances H. Keiffer, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 11, LLC; Frank A. Norman, Jr.; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 12, LLC; St. Kitts Investments, LLC; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 13, LLC; Fannie B. Blackwelder; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 14, LLC; Barbara L. Davidson, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 15, LLC; Frederick J. Hornbacher, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 16, LLC; Roberta Macgregor Masson, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 17, LLC; William B. Wachter II, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 18, LLC; Susan B. Wachter, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 19, LLC; Pell/Cruz Investments, Inc. ; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 20, LLC; Jack R. Brown; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 21, LLC; Patricia A. Brown ; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 22, LLC; Jack D. Laflesch, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 24, LLC; Muriel Sample, Successor Trustee; James K. Merrill, Successor Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 26, LLC; C.G.B.M.T. Enterprises, Inc.; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 27, LLC; Susan E. Wagner; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 28, LLC; Frederic J. Van Dis; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 29, LLC; Lawrence A. Wattson, Trustee; Stephanie T. Wattson, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 30, LLC; Darrin A. Smith; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 32, LLC; Kenneth Deno McLamb; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 33, LLC; Cynthia L. McLamb; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 34, LLC; Mark B. Pista; and Carol E. Pista v. GRUBB & ELLIS COMPANY; Grubb & Ellis Realty Investors, LLC; Grubb & Ellis Securities, Inc. ; NNN Durham Office Portfolio, LLC ; and NNN Realty Advisors, Inc.
Court: Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jurisdiction: North Carolina
Decision Date: 2017-09-28
Citations: 804 S.E.2d 530
Docket Number: No. 218P17
Parties: NNN DURHAM OFFICE PORTFOLIO 1, LLC; James Osmond; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 2, LLC; James Sun Yu Lam; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 3, LLC; Gary F. Turtle; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 4, LLC; Sherry L. Turtle; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 5, LLC; Gregory R. Maloney; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 6, LLC; Sharon I. Maloney; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 7, LLC; Ray Miller, Trustee; Patricia M. Miller, Trustee; NNN Durham Office PortfoLIO 9, LLC; PCL Property, LLC; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 10, LLC; Frances H. Keiffer, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 11, LLC; Frank A. Norman, Jr.; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 12, LLC; St. Kitts Investments, LLC; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 13, LLC; Fannie B. Blackwelder; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 14, LLC; Barbara L. Davidson, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 15, LLC; Frederick J. Hornbacher, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 16, LLC; Roberta Macgregor Masson, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 17, LLC; William B. Wachter II, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 18, LLC; Susan B. Wachter, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 19, LLC; Pell/Cruz Investments, Inc. ; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 20, LLC; Jack R. Brown; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 21, LLC; Patricia A. Brown ; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 22, LLC; Jack D. Laflesch, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 24, LLC; Muriel Sample, Successor Trustee; James K. Merrill, Successor Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 26, LLC; C.G.B.M.T. Enterprises, Inc.; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 27, LLC; Susan E. Wagner; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 28, LLC; Frederic J. Van Dis; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 29, LLC; Lawrence A. Wattson, Trustee; Stephanie T. Wattson, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 30, LLC; Darrin A. Smith; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 32, LLC; Kenneth Deno McLamb; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 33, LLC; Cynthia L. McLamb; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 34, LLC; Mark B. Pista; and Carol E. Pista
v.
GRUBB & ELLIS COMPANY; Grubb & Ellis Realty Investors, LLC; Grubb & Ellis Securities, Inc. ; NNN Durham Office Portfolio, LLC ; and NNN Realty Advisors, Inc.
Judges: 
Reporter: South Eastern Reporter 2d
Volume: 804
Pages: 530–530

Head Matter:
NNN DURHAM OFFICE PORTFOLIO 1, LLC; James Osmond; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 2, LLC; James Sun Yu Lam; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 3, LLC; Gary F. Turtle; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 4, LLC; Sherry L. Turtle; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 5, LLC; Gregory R. Maloney; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 6, LLC; Sharon I. Maloney; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 7, LLC; Ray Miller, Trustee; Patricia M. Miller, Trustee; NNN Durham Office PortfoLIO 9, LLC; PCL Property, LLC; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 10, LLC; Frances H. Keiffer, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 11, LLC; Frank A. Norman, Jr.; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 12, LLC; St. Kitts Investments, LLC; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 13, LLC; Fannie B. Blackwelder; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 14, LLC; Barbara L. Davidson, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 15, LLC; Frederick J. Hornbacher, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 16, LLC; Roberta Macgregor Masson, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 17, LLC; William B. Wachter II, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 18, LLC; Susan B. Wachter, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 19, LLC; Pell/Cruz Investments, Inc. ; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 20, LLC; Jack R. Brown; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 21, LLC; Patricia A. Brown ; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 22, LLC; Jack D. Laflesch, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 24, LLC; Muriel Sample, Successor Trustee; James K. Merrill, Successor Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 26, LLC; C.G.B.M.T. Enterprises, Inc.; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 27, LLC; Susan E. Wagner; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 28, LLC; Frederic J. Van Dis; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 29, LLC; Lawrence A. Wattson, Trustee; Stephanie T. Wattson, Trustee; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 30, LLC; Darrin A. Smith; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 32, LLC; Kenneth Deno McLamb; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 33, LLC; Cynthia L. McLamb; NNN Durham Office Portfolio 34, LLC; Mark B. Pista; and Carol E. Pista
v.
GRUBB & ELLIS COMPANY; Grubb & Ellis Realty Investors, LLC; Grubb & Ellis Securities, Inc. ; NNN Durham Office Portfolio, LLC ; and NNN Realty Advisors, Inc.
No. 218P17
Supreme Court of North Carolina.
September 28, 2017
Charles E. Raynal, IV, Attorney at Law, Jamie S. Schwedler, Attorney at Law, Catherine R.L. Lawson, Attorney at Law, Raleigh, for Grubb & Ellis Company, et al.
John L. Sarratt, Attorney at Law, Raleigh, for Grubb & Ellis Realty Investors, LLC, et al.
Thomas H. Stark, Attorney at Law, Chapel Hill, J. Anthony Penry, Attorney at Law, Seth Allen Neyhart, Attorney at Law, Chapel Hill, for NNN Durham Office Portfolio 1, LLC, et al.
ORDER

Opinion:
Upon consideration of the conditional petition filed by Defendants on the 17th of July 2017 in this matter for discretionary review under G.S. 7A-31 prior to a determination by the North Carolina Court of Appeals, the following order was entered and is hereby certified to the North Carolina Court of Appeals:
"Dismissed as moot by order of the Court in conference, this the 28th of September 2017."