Case Name: MIRA HAYS, et al. v. JOHN HAYS, Adm'r, &c.
Court: Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jurisdiction: North Carolina
Decision Date: 1870-01
Citations: 64 N.C. 59
Docket Number: 
Parties: MIRA HAYS, et al. v. JOHN HAYS, Adm’r, &c.
Judges: 
Reporter: North Carolina Reports
Volume: 64
Pages: 59–60

Head Matter:
MIRA HAYS, et al. v. JOHN HAYS, Adm’r, &c.
A cause in equity being before a court upon exceptions to a report, made-under an order for an account therein :
Held, that it. was erroneous for the Judge, upon sustaining the exceptions, to proceed to dismiss the bill.
Bill in equity, before Mitchell, J., upon exceptions to a reportmade in the course of the cause, at Fall Term 1869, of Caldwell Court.
An order for an account having been made, upon the report coming in the defendant filed exceptions, which on consideration, were sustained by the court, the report set aside, and the bill dismissed. Thereupon the plaintiff appealed.
Folk for the appellant.
Malorie, contra.

Opinion:
Reade, J.
When the defendant's exceptions to the report were sustained, it was the privilege of the plaintiff to appeal from the ruling of his Honor, and present the whole case to this court: but the plaintiff was deprived of that privilege by the order dismissing the bill. We consider the case before us not upon the merits, but upon the appeal from the order dismissing it. That was clearly erroneous.
This will be certified, &c.
Per. Curiam. Order reversed.