Case Name: Herbert D. Boret et al., Copartners, under the Firm Name of H. D. Boret, Respondents, v. L. Vogelstein & Co., Inc., Appellant
Court: New York Court of Appeals
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1920-12-31
Citations: 230 N.Y. 573
Docket Number: 
Parties: Herbert D. Boret et al., Copartners, under the Firm Name of H. D. Boret, Respondents, v. L. Vogelstein & Co., Inc., Appellant.
Judges: 
Reporter: New York Reports
Volume: 230
Pages: 573–574

Head Matter:
Herbert D. Boret et al., Copartners, under the Firm Name of H. D. Boret, Respondents, v. L. Vogelstein & Co., Inc., Appellant.
Contract — agreement for purchase and shipment of copper for a term of years, price to be based on average market price for seven days preceding and following arrival ■—■ effect of price fixing by government during war.
Boret v. Vogelstein & Co., Inc., 188 App. Div. 605, affirmed.
(Argued December 1, 1920;
decided December 31, 1920.)
Appeal from a judgment of the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court in the first judicial department, entered July 19, 1919, in favor of plaintiffs upon the submission of a controversy under section 1279 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Plaintiff and the firm of L. Yogelstein & Co., whose obligations defendant had assumed in March, 1916, entered into two contracts by the first of which defendant agreed to purchase certain copper from the plaintiff and by the second provision was made for shipment thereof from Sourh America to a port in New Jersey. The first contract contained the following provision: “ Basis of price: Copper by wet assay less 1.3 units to be paid for at the average price of electrolytic wirebars as published in the Engineering & Mining Journal of New York, taking the average of the seven quotations preceding and seven quotations following the date of the arrival of the material in Chrome (15 quotations in all). * * * From the average price contained in the above 15 quotations shall be deducted 1.85 cents per pound as treatment charge both for ore and matte.” The contract was for eight years commencing January 1, 1918. War was declared between the United States and Germany on April 6, 1917, and on September 21, 1917, the president and government of the United States fixed the sum of twenty-three and one-half cents per pound as the price at which refined copper could be bought and sold in the United States, which was less than the current market price at the time, and after that date the Engineering and Mining Journal of New York published daily the ' price thus fixed by the government of the United States. The question was whether, under the circumstances, the contracts were valid and enforcible. The Appellate Division held that in so far as the contract was executed by the plaintiffs the defendant was bound on his part to pay.
Alfred G. Reeves and Ambrose G. Todd for appellant.
Hiram R. Steele and George E. Miner for respondents.

Opinion:
Judgment affirmed, with costs; no opinion.
Concur: Hogan, Cardozo, McLaughlin, Crane and Andrews, JJ. Dissenting: Pound, J. Not voting: His cock, Ch. J.