Case Name: The Richmond. Haskins and others v. The Richmond
Court: United States Circuit Court for the Eastern District of New York
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1886-06-23
Citations: 30 F. 201
Docket Number: 
Parties: The Richmond. Haskins and others v. The Richmond.
Judges: 
Reporter: Federal Reporter
Volume: 30
Pages: 201–202

Head Matter:
The Richmond. Haskins and others v. The Richmond.
(Circuit Court, E. D. New York.
June 23, 1886.)
Coimsion — Steamer and Schooner in Tow — -Sudden SnijnR.
The decision of the district court in the same case (28 Fed. Rep. 332) affirmed.
Admiralty Appeal.
JET. D. Hotchkiss, for libelants, Haskins and others.
Owen & Gray, (F. D. Sturges,) for the Richmond, appellant.
Reported by R. I). & Wyllys Benedict, Esqs., of the New York bar.

Opinion:
Blatchfokd, Justice.
The reasons assigned by the district judge for condemning the Richmond, and exonerating the tug, were these, the Richmond improperly sheered to the west, and struck the schooner. Even if the tug began to sheer to the west before the Richmond did, such act did not cause the collision, because the tug was, from the outset, to the west of the Richmond, and a swing of the tug to the west would be in a direction away from the Richmond, while the swing of the Richmond to the west was towards the tug, and such swing necessarily brought the steamer and the schooner into collision. The tug and the Richmond were not upon courses crossing, so as to involve risk of collision, and impose on the tug the duty of avoiding the Richmond. I concur in these views, and in the conclusion to which they lead. Let there be a decree for the libelants against the Richmond for $818.41, with interest from September 17,1888, and for the costs of the libelants in the district court, taxed at $192.20, and for their costs in this court, to be taxed.