Case Name: VILLAGE S. S. Co., Limited, v. STANDARD OIL CO.
Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1910-03-07
Citations: 177 F. 1006
Docket Number: No. 161
Parties: VILLAGE S. S. Co., Limited, v. STANDARD OIL CO.
Judges: Before LÁCOMBE, COXE, and NOYES, Circuit Judges.
Reporter: Federal Reporter
Volume: 177
Pages: 1006–1006

Head Matter:
VILLAGE S. S. Co., Limited, v. STANDARD OIL CO.
(Circuit Court of Appeals, Second Circuit.
March 7, 1910.)
No. 161.
Appeal from the District Court of the United States for the Southern District of New York. This cause comes here' upon appeal from a decree of the District Court dismissing a libel. The action was brought to recover a balance of freight withheld by the-respondent from charter hire of the steamship Drumgeith to compensate for the failure of the ship to deliver certain eases of oil shipped from New York to Whampoa, China. The- opinion of the District Judge is found in 171 Fed. 243.
Charles R. Hickox, for appellant.
Charles O. Burlingham, for appellee.
Before LÁCOMBE, COXE, and NOYES, Circuit Judges.

Opinion:
PER CURIAM.
The District Judge, has stated the facts very clearly and fully and we see no reason to' dissent from his conclusions. If stands admitted that the' Drumgeith received on board 149,160 cases, and the master testified that1 the ship's tally books at Whampoa, where she discharged into lighters sent by the consignee, showed the discharge of only about 148,619 cases. The Chinese stevedores and tallymen were employed and paid by tbe ship, and the circumstance that the agent of the consignee suggested that these particular individuals might be employed, at the same time warning the captain of their untrustworthiness -unless carefully supervised by Europeans, does not relieve the ship of the- biirden of proving delivery of, all cases received. In' view of the-shortage shown by the ship's tally books,, the general testimony of the captain and first officer that, when discharge was completed, no cases were left on board, is not sufficient to establish full delivery; The decree is affirmed; with- interest -and costs.