Case Name: MAXWELL et al. v. KESSLER
Court: Oklahoma Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Oklahoma
Decision Date: 1924-02-12
Citations: 97 Okla. 201
Docket Number: No. 12821
Parties: MAXWELL et al. v. KESSLER.
Judges: 
Reporter: Oklahoma Reports
Volume: 97
Pages: 201–202

Head Matter:
MAXWELL et al. v. KESSLER.
No. 12821
Opinion Filed Feb. 12, 1924.
1. Appeal and Error — Record—Proceedings on Application to Vacate Judgment.
In order for this, court to review tlie action of the (rial court in denying application to set aside judgment, the proceedings must he brought to this court, by case-made properly attested by the clerk and bearing the evidence of filing in the cause below.
2. Same — Defective Case-Made — Dismissal.
A case-made which does not bear proper attestation by the court clerk and does not show to have been tiled in the cause below, does not present any questions in connection with the court’s action to set aside a judgment for review in this court, and wiil be dismissed on motion of l.ho defendant in error.
■ (Syllabus by Stephenson, C.j
. Commissioners’ Opinion. Division No. 4.
Error from District Court, Nowata ('ounty.
Action by E. Messersmitli to set aside a judgment rendered in a cause wherein Steve" Kessler was plaintiff and the petitioner and B. F. Maxwell et al. were defendants. Application denied. Defendant E. Messer-smith appeals.
Affirmed.
Keith & McGugin, .T. Wood Glass, and F. A. Calvert, for plaintiffs in error.
C. H. Baskin, for defendant in error.

Opinion:
Opinion by
STEPHENSON, C.
Judgment was rendered in this cause in favor of Steve Kessler and against E. Messersmith et. al. Later E. Messersmith filed his application in the cause praying the court to set aside the judgment rendered therein. Fpon due consideration of the application the same was overruled. The petitioner followed this action by filing other applications to set aside the judgment which were denied by the court. The defendant gave notice of appeal and caused to be prepared a case-made purporting to show the proceedings had in relation to the application to set aside the judgment. The purported case-made lodged in this court does not bear proper eertificiajte of the court clerk, !or properly attested, and does not show to have been filed in the cause below. The errors complained of, in order to be reviewed in this court, must be presented by proper case-made. For the errors and irregularities stated the case-made is a nullity and does not present any questions for review in this court. Ft. Smith & W. R. Co. v. McKee, 38 Okla. 194, 132 Pac. 497; St. L. S. F. Ry. Co. v. Bonham, 43 Okla. 637, 143 Pac. 660; Latta et al. v. Way et al., 43 Okla. 638, 143 Pac. 663; Gibbs v. Tanner, 43 Okla. 477, 143 Pac. 189.
Therefore it is recommended that this cause be dismissed.
By the Court: It is so ordered.