Case Name: THE YUMURI. BEEBE v. THE YUMURI
Court: United States District Court for the Southern District of New York
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1895-03-06
Citations: 68 F. 930
Docket Number: 
Parties: THE YUMURI. BEEBE v. THE YUMURI.
Judges: 
Reporter: Federal Reporter
Volume: 68
Pages: 930–930

Head Matter:
THE YUMURI. BEEBE v. THE YUMURI.
(District Court, S. D. New York.
March 6, 1895.)
Pilotage — Tender at Sea — Ship Liable.
The display of the customary pilot signals on the usual cruising ground of pilot boats at sea, and the visible approach of the boat towards an incoming vessel, are a sufficient tender of oif-shore pilotage, with the cus‘tomary waiver of extra charge; and if the vessel does not heed the tender, but comes in without a pilot, she is liable under the statute for the usual pilotage fees.
This was a libel by G-eorge W. Beebe against the steamship Yumuri to recover pilotage.
Carpenter & Park, for libelant.
Carter & Ledyard, for claimant.

Opinion:
BROWN, District Judge.
1. I find that the pilot boat approached the Yumuri within the customary cruising ground for incoming vessels, and displayed her blue flag as a signal, which was recognized, or ought to have been recognized, by the master and mate of the Yumuri, when the pilot boat was within a reasonable distance; and that this was, in legal effect, a tender and offer of her services as pilot to the Yumuri.
2. That under the fixed and well-known practice and custom not to make any claim to off-shore pilotage for pilots taken on board in that region, the above tender was also virtually an offer of pilot-age with a.waiver of any claim to such extra pilotage charge.
3. That the failure of the Yumuri to slow down or turn towards the pilot boat and accept the offered services, was a refusal of such service; and having taken no pilot subsequently, she became answerable to the libelant, under the statute, for the amount of ordinary pilotage, viz. $47.32, for which, with interest, a decree may be entered, with costs.