Case Name: GWALTNEY v. INSURANCE CO.
Court: Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jurisdiction: North Carolina
Decision Date: 1904-04-05
Citations: 134 N.C. 552
Docket Number: 
Parties: GWALTNEY v. INSURANCE CO.
Judges: WaleeR, J., concurs in the dissenting opinion.
Reporter: North Carolina Reports
Volume: 134
Pages: 552–567

Head Matter:
GWALTNEY v. INSURANCE CO.
(Filed April 5, 1904).
For former opinion in this ease and headnotes thereto, see Gwaltney v. Assurance Society, 132 N. C., 925.
Petition to rehear this ease dismissed.
Montgomery and Walker, JJ., dissenting
Maxwell & Kearns, for the petitioner.
T. B. Hufham and E. B. Qline, in opposition

Opinion:
Clark, C. J.
This is a petition to rehear the former decision in this case, 132 N. C., 925. The same propositions of law, as now, were presented and argued on the former hearing. No material point of law or fact has been shown to have been overlooked, and our opinion would be simply a reiteration, substantially, of what was written on the former hearing. Whatever difference of view there may be as to the facts, the jury, in their province, have determined the truth or falsity of the averments on both sides, and we cannot disturb their finding. The case had been previously before this Court, 130 N. C., 629, and has been heretofore fully considered. It is now ordered
Petition dismissed.