Case Name: LETHERER v. PHŒNIX ACCIDENT & SICK BENEFIT ASS'N
Court: Michigan Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Michigan
Decision Date: 1906-07-23
Citations: 145 Mich. 313
Docket Number: Docket No. 107
Parties: LETHERER v. PHŒNIX ACCIDENT & SICK BENEFIT ASS’N
Judges: McAlvay, Blair, Montgomery, and Hooker, JJ., ^concurred.
Reporter: Michigan Reports
Volume: 145
Pages: 313–313

Head Matter:
LETHERER v. PHŒNIX ACCIDENT & SICK BENEFIT ASS’N
Insurance — Accident Insurance — Immediate Disability — What Constitutes.
This case, involving the liability of an accident insurance company for an injury not immediately disabling assured, is ruled by Letherer v. Insurance Co., ante, 310, involving the same facts.
Error to Lenawee; Chester, J.
Submitted May 4,1906.
(Docket No. 107.)
Decided July 23, 1906.
Assumpsit by John F. Letherer against the Phoenix Accident & Sick Benefit Association on a policy of insurance. There was judgment for plaintiff, and defendant brings error.
Reversed, and no new trial ordered.
Theodore M. Joslin (Abbott & Abbott and E. J. Adams, of counsel), for appellant.
Smith, Baldwin & Alexander, for appellee.

Opinion:
Ostrander, J.
The plaintiff in this case is the plain-tiff in Letherer v. Insurance Co., ante, 310. The injury . to plaintiff, the foundation of this action, is the identical injury described in the opinion in that case. The provisions • of the policy set out in the opinion in that case are identical with those, in the policy sued upon in this case. The court was requested to direct a verdict for defendant. This request, for reasons set out in the opinion referred to, should have been granted.
Judgment is reversed, and no new trial will be granted.
McAlvay, Blair, Montgomery, and Hooker, JJ., ^concurred.