Case Name: Reid v. McIntyre
Court: Supreme Court of Indiana
Jurisdiction: Indiana
Decision Date: 1860-11-27
Citations: 15 Ind. 499
Docket Number: 
Parties: Reid v. McIntyre.
Judges: 
Reporter: Indiana Reports
Volume: 15
Pages: 499–499

Head Matter:
Reid v. McIntyre.
Tuesday, November 27.
APPEAL from the St. Joseph Common Pleas.
M. G. Eewcomb, J. S. Tarhington and Stanfield c& Eddy, for appellant.
Jno. F. Miller and Wm. G. George, for appellee.
(1.) Petition for rehearing filed January 24, and overruled May 10,1861.

Opinion:
Per Gv/riam.
Action hy McIntyre against Beicl for certain carpenter and joiner work.
Trial by jury, verdict and judgment for the plaintiff. The . case is brought here upon the evidence, from an examination of which we think the judgment ought not to be sustained. The evidence fails, as we think, to make out the claim of the plaintiff for so large an amount as he recovered, $340.80, if anything, after deducting the payments and set-off that were admitted on the trial. Substantial justice requires that a new trial should be granted.
The judgment below is reversed, with costs. Cause remanded for a new trial.