Case Name: Donald R. KURZ; William Anderson; James E.W. Beck; William T. Bergen; Charles W. Bowden; William H. Brown; Richard Cahill; Armando L. Capoferri; Robert C. DeMarco; James J. DiLolle, Sr.; Vincent J. DiMaggio; John J. DiValentino, Jr.; William E. Drumel; Victor J. Gibialante; Francis T. Golden; James J. Granger; Elmer D. Greim, Jr.; James H. Hair; John M. Hoopes; Benjamin J. Kilian; George C. Linthicum; Hubert A. McKown, Jr.; Henry P. McNamee; Oliver K. Messner; Robert E. Miller; John A. Morse; Samuel J. Mullen; John A. Munley; Stanley B. Myers; John J. Nusspickel; James W. Patterson; Alfred B. Schumann; Joseph C. Sharkey; William H. Smoyer; Woodrow E. Snyder; James D. Sutliff; Edward J. Vetner; Dominic C. Viglianese; G. Earle Watt; Frederick W. Winterling; John R. Young v. PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC COMPANY; Service Annuity Plan of Philadelphia Electric Company; Charles L. Fritz; J.L. Everett, III; John H. Austin, Jr. John J. Divalento, Jr., William E. Drumel; John A. Morse; Samuel J. Mullen; Stanley B. Myers; Dominic C. Viglianese; James J. DiLolle; Benjamin J. Kilian; Charles W. Bowden; Elmer D. Greim, Jr.; Frederick W. Winterling; James W. Beck; James H. Hair; Robert C. DeMarco; Alfred G. Schumann; Richard Cahill; James W. Patterson; John M. Hoopes; Hubert A. McKown, Jr.; Robert E. Miller; James D. Sutliff; Henry P. McNamee; Francis T. Golden; William T. Bergen; George C. Linthicum; William W. Anderson; John R. Young; Vincent J. Dimaggio; Shields L. Daltroff; Richard O. Folkman; Alfred E. Stavola; Robert H.C. Less; Samuel E. Bell; Donald F. Washington; Frank J. Gallagher; Maurice M. Peitzman; Harry G. Turner, Jr.; Robert I. Friend; Donald C. Robinson; William J. Leaman, Jr.; Augustus W. O'Malley; Dallas S. Scott, Jr.; John S. Stillwagon; Robert C. Heckesser; William R. Travetti; William B. Horlock; James States; Thomas W. Rayer; John H. Vonrhine; Walter Allwoerden; George C. Wiedersum, Jr.; James R. McCarron; Salvator J. Destefano; John C. Garvin; A. William Lancaster; Joseph A. Focht; Robert Mitchell; Joseph P. Subranni; John F. Crawford; William G. Taylor; Kenneth R. Sedgley, Jr.; Irwin G. Blackburn; Charles R. Carey; John R. Young; Jessee E. Gray, Jr.; James D. Derstine; Allen H. Braid; Paul L. Thomas; Stephen Micklosh, Jr.; William L. Gibbons; Russell B. Murray; Roland J. Markun; Ernest W. Beam; Raymond W. Scholl, Jr.; John F. Parker; Joseph F. McBride; Vincent S. Boyer; Martin M. Morgan and David Monzo, Appellants in 95-1795; Donald R. KURZ; William Anderson; James E.W. Beck; William T. Bergen; Charles W. Bowden; William H. Brown; Richard Cahill; Armando L. Capoferri; Robert C. DeMarco; James J. DiLolle, Sr.; Vincent J. DiMaggio; John J. DiValentino, Jr.; William E. Drumel; Victor J. Gibialante; Francis T. Golden; James J. Granger; Elmer D. Greim, Jr.; James H. Hair; John M. Hoopes; Benjamin J. Kilian; George C. Linthicum; Hubert A. McKown, Jr.; Henry P. McNamee; Oliver K. Messner; Robert E. Miller; John A. Morse; Samuel J. Mullen; John A. Munley; Stanley B. Myers; John J. Nusspickel; James W. Patterson; Alfred B. Schumann; Joseph C. Sharkey; William H. Smoyer; Woodrow E. Snyder; James D. Sutliff; Edward J. Vetner; Dominic C. Viglianese; G. Earle Watt; Frederick W. Winterling; John R. Young v. PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC COMPANY; Service Annuity Plan of Philadelphia Electric Company; Charles L. Fritz; J.L. Everett, III; John H. Austin, Jr. Peco Energy Company, formerly known as Philadelphia Electric Company, Service Annuity Plan of Philadelphia Electric Company, Charles L. Fritz, J.L. Everett, III and John H. Austin, Jr., Appellants in 95-1796
Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1997-05-07
Citations: 113 F.3d 432
Docket Number: Nos. 95-1795, 95-1796
Parties: Donald R. KURZ; William Anderson; James E.W. Beck; William T. Bergen; Charles W. Bowden; William H. Brown; Richard Cahill; Armando L. Capoferri; Robert C. DeMarco; James J. DiLolle, Sr.; Vincent J. DiMaggio; John J. DiValentino, Jr.; William E. Drumel; Victor J. Gibialante; Francis T. Golden; James J. Granger; Elmer D. Greim, Jr.; James H. Hair; John M. Hoopes; Benjamin J. Kilian; George C. Linthicum; Hubert A. McKown, Jr.; Henry P. McNamee; Oliver K. Messner; Robert E. Miller; John A. Morse; Samuel J. Mullen; John A. Munley; Stanley B. Myers; John J. Nusspickel; James W. Patterson; Alfred B. Schumann; Joseph C. Sharkey; William H. Smoyer; Woodrow E. Snyder; James D. Sutliff; Edward J. Vetner; Dominic C. Viglianese; G. Earle Watt; Frederick W. Winterling; John R. Young v. PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC COMPANY; Service Annuity Plan of Philadelphia Electric Company; Charles L. Fritz; J.L. Everett, III; John H. Austin, Jr. John J. Divalento, Jr., William E. Drumel; John A. Morse; Samuel J. Mullen; Stanley B. Myers; Dominic C. Viglianese; James J. DiLolle; Benjamin J. Kilian; Charles W. Bowden; Elmer D. Greim, Jr.; Frederick W. Winterling; James W. Beck; James H. Hair; Robert C. DeMarco; Alfred G. Schumann; Richard Cahill; James W. Patterson; John M. Hoopes; Hubert A. McKown, Jr.; Robert E. Miller; James D. Sutliff; Henry P. McNamee; Francis T. Golden; William T. Bergen; George C. Linthicum; William W. Anderson; John R. Young; Vincent J. Dimaggio; Shields L. Daltroff; Richard O. Folkman; Alfred E. Stavola; Robert H.C. Less; Samuel E. Bell; Donald F. Washington; Frank J. Gallagher; Maurice M. Peitzman; Harry G. Turner, Jr.; Robert I. Friend; Donald C. Robinson; William J. Leaman, Jr.; Augustus W. O’Malley; Dallas S. Scott, Jr.; John S. Stillwagon; Robert C. Heckesser; William R. Travetti; William B. Horlock; James States; Thomas W. Rayer; John H. Vonrhine; Walter Allwoerden; George C. Wiedersum, Jr.; James R. McCarron; Salvator J. Destefano; John C. Garvin; A. William Lancaster; Joseph A. Focht; Robert Mitchell; Joseph P. Subranni; John F. Crawford; William G. Taylor; Kenneth R. Sedgley, Jr.; Irwin G. Blackburn; Charles R. Carey; John R. Young; Jessee E. Gray, Jr.; James D. Derstine; Allen H. Braid; Paul L. Thomas; Stephen Micklosh, Jr.; William L. Gibbons; Russell B. Murray; Roland J. Markun; Ernest W. Beam; Raymond W. Scholl, Jr.; John F. Parker; Joseph F. McBride; Vincent S. Boyer; Martin M. Morgan and David Monzo, Appellants in 95-1795. Donald R. KURZ; William Anderson; James E.W. Beck; William T. Bergen; Charles W. Bowden; William H. Brown; Richard Cahill; Armando L. Capoferri; Robert C. DeMarco; James J. DiLolle, Sr.; Vincent J. DiMaggio; John J. DiValentino, Jr.; William E. Drumel; Victor J. Gibialante; Francis T. Golden; James J. Granger; Elmer D. Greim, Jr.; James H. Hair; John M. Hoopes; Benjamin J. Kilian; George C. Linthicum; Hubert A. McKown, Jr.; Henry P. McNamee; Oliver K. Messner; Robert E. Miller; John A. Morse; Samuel J. Mullen; John A. Munley; Stanley B. Myers; John J. Nus spickel; James W. Patterson; Alfred B. Schumann; Joseph C. Sharkey; William H. Smoyer; Woodrow E. Snyder; James D. Sutliff; Edward J. Vetner; Dominic C. Viglianese; G. Earle Watt; Frederick W. Winterling; John R. Young v. PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC COMPANY; Service Annuity Plan of Philadelphia Electric Company; Charles L. Fritz; J.L. Everett, III; John H. Austin, Jr. Peco Energy Company, formerly known as Philadelphia Electric Company, Service Annuity Plan of Philadelphia Electric Company, Charles L. Fritz, J.L. Everett, III and John H. Austin, Jr., Appellants in 95-1796.
Judges: Before: COWEN and ROTH, Circuit Judges and CINDRICH , District Judge.
Reporter: Federal Reporter 3d Series
Volume: 113
Pages: 432–433

Head Matter:
Donald R. KURZ; William Anderson; James E.W. Beck; William T. Bergen; Charles W. Bowden; William H. Brown; Richard Cahill; Armando L. Capoferri; Robert C. DeMarco; James J. DiLolle, Sr.; Vincent J. DiMaggio; John J. DiValentino, Jr.; William E. Drumel; Victor J. Gibialante; Francis T. Golden; James J. Granger; Elmer D. Greim, Jr.; James H. Hair; John M. Hoopes; Benjamin J. Kilian; George C. Linthicum; Hubert A. McKown, Jr.; Henry P. McNamee; Oliver K. Messner; Robert E. Miller; John A. Morse; Samuel J. Mullen; John A. Munley; Stanley B. Myers; John J. Nusspickel; James W. Patterson; Alfred B. Schumann; Joseph C. Sharkey; William H. Smoyer; Woodrow E. Snyder; James D. Sutliff; Edward J. Vetner; Dominic C. Viglianese; G. Earle Watt; Frederick W. Winterling; John R. Young v. PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC COMPANY; Service Annuity Plan of Philadelphia Electric Company; Charles L. Fritz; J.L. Everett, III; John H. Austin, Jr. John J. Divalento, Jr., William E. Drumel; John A. Morse; Samuel J. Mullen; Stanley B. Myers; Dominic C. Viglianese; James J. DiLolle; Benjamin J. Kilian; Charles W. Bowden; Elmer D. Greim, Jr.; Frederick W. Winterling; James W. Beck; James H. Hair; Robert C. DeMarco; Alfred G. Schumann; Richard Cahill; James W. Patterson; John M. Hoopes; Hubert A. McKown, Jr.; Robert E. Miller; James D. Sutliff; Henry P. McNamee; Francis T. Golden; William T. Bergen; George C. Linthicum; William W. Anderson; John R. Young; Vincent J. Dimaggio; Shields L. Daltroff; Richard O. Folkman; Alfred E. Stavola; Robert H.C. Less; Samuel E. Bell; Donald F. Washington; Frank J. Gallagher; Maurice M. Peitzman; Harry G. Turner, Jr.; Robert I. Friend; Donald C. Robinson; William J. Leaman, Jr.; Augustus W. O’Malley; Dallas S. Scott, Jr.; John S. Stillwagon; Robert C. Heckesser; William R. Travetti; William B. Horlock; James States; Thomas W. Rayer; John H. Vonrhine; Walter Allwoerden; George C. Wiedersum, Jr.; James R. McCarron; Salvator J. Destefano; John C. Garvin; A. William Lancaster; Joseph A. Focht; Robert Mitchell; Joseph P. Subranni; John F. Crawford; William G. Taylor; Kenneth R. Sedgley, Jr.; Irwin G. Blackburn; Charles R. Carey; John R. Young; Jessee E. Gray, Jr.; James D. Derstine; Allen H. Braid; Paul L. Thomas; Stephen Micklosh, Jr.; William L. Gibbons; Russell B. Murray; Roland J. Markun; Ernest W. Beam; Raymond W. Scholl, Jr.; John F. Parker; Joseph F. McBride; Vincent S. Boyer; Martin M. Morgan and David Monzo, Appellants in 95-1795. Donald R. KURZ; William Anderson; James E.W. Beck; William T. Bergen; Charles W. Bowden; William H. Brown; Richard Cahill; Armando L. Capoferri; Robert C. DeMarco; James J. DiLolle, Sr.; Vincent J. DiMaggio; John J. DiValentino, Jr.; William E. Drumel; Victor J. Gibialante; Francis T. Golden; James J. Granger; Elmer D. Greim, Jr.; James H. Hair; John M. Hoopes; Benjamin J. Kilian; George C. Linthicum; Hubert A. McKown, Jr.; Henry P. McNamee; Oliver K. Messner; Robert E. Miller; John A. Morse; Samuel J. Mullen; John A. Munley; Stanley B. Myers; John J. Nus spickel; James W. Patterson; Alfred B. Schumann; Joseph C. Sharkey; William H. Smoyer; Woodrow E. Snyder; James D. Sutliff; Edward J. Vetner; Dominic C. Viglianese; G. Earle Watt; Frederick W. Winterling; John R. Young v. PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC COMPANY; Service Annuity Plan of Philadelphia Electric Company; Charles L. Fritz; J.L. Everett, III; John H. Austin, Jr. Peco Energy Company, formerly known as Philadelphia Electric Company, Service Annuity Plan of Philadelphia Electric Company, Charles L. Fritz, J.L. Everett, III and John H. Austin, Jr., Appellants in 95-1796.
Nos. 95-1795, 95-1796.
United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit.
May 7, 1997.
Before: COWEN and ROTH, Circuit Judges and CINDRICH , District Judge.
. Honorable Robert J. Cindrich, United States District Court Judge for the Western District of Pennsylvania, sitting by designation.

Opinion:
SUR PETITION FOR PANEL REHEARING
The petition for panel rehearing filed by appellants Monzo, Morgan and McEntee in the above-entitled case having been submitted to the judges who participated in the decision of this court and no judge who concurred in the decision having asked for rehearing, the petition for rehearing is denied.