Case Name: BARNEY v. BANKS
Court: Ohio Court of Appeals
Jurisdiction: Ohio
Decision Date: 1924-10-08
Citations: 3 Ohio Law Abs. 27
Docket Number: No. 1200
Parties: BARNEY v. BANKS
Judges: 
Reporter: The Ohio Law Abstract
Volume: 3
Pages: 27–27

Head Matter:
No. 52
BARNEY v. BANKS
Ohio Appeals, 2nd Dist., Franklin Co.
No. 1200.
Decided Oct. 8, 1924
480. EVIDENCE—Oral evidence is competent to show failure of consideration to justify the setting aside of a deed.
367. DEEDS—Grantor must account ■ to grantee for payments on mortgage and improvements to set aside deed for failure of consideration.
Published only in Ohio Law Abstract
Attorneys—Charles R. Doll, for Barney; B. F. Hughes, for Banks; all of Columbus.

Opinion:
FERNEDING, J.
Epitomized Opinion
Action to set aside a deed for certain real estate upon the ground of failure of consideration. Evidence was submitted that the grantee obligated herself as part of the consideration to live in the property, to take care of the grantor, and to make certain improvements and to pay off the mortgage. Evidence attempting to prove the verbal agreement as to these considerations was objected to as not competent. On appeal the court held:
1. That evidence may be received to prove the actual consideration of a deed and that there was such failure of consideration as would justify the setting aside of the deed.
2. The plaintiff must account to.the defendant for the amount paid by her upon the mortgage, improvements on the property an dother expenses incurred before entitled to having the deed cancelled.