Case Name: Johnathan Daniel KING, David Allen, Donald Edward Arnold, Christopher Paul Barker, Tracy T. Beams, Alejandro Castaneda, Carl Cravens, William J. Dunlap, Allen H. Foraker, Anthony Graham, Mark A. Garrison, Ronald J. Guidry, Jeremy D. Hearn, Carlos M. Hernandez, Jessica L. Hernandez, Robert C. Hudgins, Kenneth Johnson, Jerry S. Jones, Ray T. Jones, Scott Lynch, Thomas C. Madrid, Eric A. Magana, Steven Adkison, Arthur S. Aguero, Jose M. Aleman, Andrew Andrade, Andrew Arguello, Luis C. Ayala, Ricardo Barreda, Daryl Bartlett, Kelly Jo Benjamin, Harold J. Bennett, Robert Breyer, Andrew Butts, Jodi R. Butts, Jess Cabe, Erik J. Cansino, Joseph Caporale, Sean Carrigan, Jack Carson, Rigoberto Cepeda, Edwin Cestero, Anthony E. Chambers, David Cloer, Michael P. Cluff, Shayne Collins, David Colon-Escobar, James R. Comings, Brian T. Cornell, David R. Daiss, Ian P. Daugherty, James R. Davis, Timothy B. Davis, Ruben De La Torre, Darryll Dennis, Jorge L. Dominquez, Sal Dorado, Brian S. Dvorak, Jonas K. Edwards, Scott Edwards, Saul Enriquez, Roberto Espinoza, Jr., Cesar E. Falcon, Bryan K. Fenley, Terrance S. Ferguson, George H. Ferland, Cody L. Fox, Todd J. Fraser, Greg Furnia, Joe A. Gallegos, Elde Garcia, Joel Garcia, Manuel Garcia, Jr., Hugo Garza, Jon Gelber, Jose Luis Gonzalez, Jose A. Gonzalez, Jr., Christopher Gorneau, Eliezer Guajardo, Jr., Gary R. Gualducci, Guadalupe I. Gutierrez, Eric T. Haley, Riley W. Hanback, Gerald Hancock, John E. Harvey, Fausto Hernandez, James R. Herrick, Phillip D. Hise, Steven W. Imrie, Travis W. Inman, Juan Isarraraz, Jr., Dennis Jenkins, Jr., Damon W. Jones, Francisco Juarez, Donald Kenefick, John Kessler, Cully E. Knowlton, William M. Kocan, Kurt W. Kraus, Pyotr Kukharsky, Alfredo Lara, David Ledezma, III, Zenaida Levrie, Stephen C. Lewis, Brandon Longaker, Alex J. Lopez, Cristobal B. Lopez, Felix A. Lopez, Jose C. Lopez, Martin N. Lopez, Haydee Lozano, Claudia Lukason, Trevor MacKenzie, Troy Manske, Samuel Martinez, Lisa Martinez Crouse, Ernesto Martinez, Jr., Kenneth J. Maurer, Chad McBroom, Brian G. McClellan, Guillermo Medrano, III, Hektor G. Mesta, Mark Middleton, Adam Miller, Rodolfo Montelongo, Corey S. Moore, Veronica Morales, Jose A. Morales, Jr., Paul Jerome Murphy, Joe F. Navaro, Leroy L. Notterman, Robert J. Noziska, Eric Pahler, Jude W. Patterson, Samuel D. Peak, John J. Pineiro, Mike B. Pio, Mark W. Potter, Mark Qualter, Amanda Ramirez, Eduardo Rangel, Patricia Reyes, Ruben Ricci, Stacy Guy Rider, Mark Anthony Rios, Jim Rivera, Robin J. Roberts, Benjamin Rodriguez, Alonzo Rodriguez, Mario A. Rodriguez, Ciro Roman, Carlos Romo, Mauro A. Rueda, Joshua E. Sanchez, Raymundo Sanchez, Donald K. Scee, Jeremy Schappell, James Vincent Scordato, Robert J. Senior, Joseph Shailor, Laren M. Shaw, Franciso J. Silva, Paul Silva, Roma J. Solidum, Richard Soria, Andrew K. Sproul, John L. Sturgeon, Jr., Michael Szubinski, Christopher Talbert, Michael Wayne Taylor, Andres Tellez-Giron, Kevin W. Thatcher, Pamela M. Thomas, Jason R. Thompson, David J. Trevino, Manuel Trevino, Millard H. Tucker, Jr., Jamie M. Turley, Darrell S. Turner, Rodolfo Valdez, Jr., Brad Valencia, Marco A. Vargas, Roy Vargas, Jr., Alexander Vazquez, Gary Velasquez, Fernando Venegas, Jason Violette, Edward P. Wagner, Jr., William Whitehead, Cody S. Winn, William Wolf, Kevin S. Worrell, Robert S. Wotring, III, Plaintiffs-Appellants v. UNITED STATES, Defendant-Appellee
Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 2016-01-07
Citations: 627 F. App'x 926
Docket Number: No. 2015-5066
Parties: Johnathan Daniel KING, David Allen, Donald Edward Arnold, Christopher Paul Barker, Tracy T. Beams, Alejandro Castaneda, Carl Cravens, William J. Dunlap, Allen H. Foraker, Anthony Graham, Mark A. Garrison, Ronald J. Guidry, Jeremy D. Hearn, Carlos M. Hernandez, Jessica L. Hernandez, Robert C. Hudgins, Kenneth Johnson, Jerry S. Jones, Ray T. Jones, Scott Lynch, Thomas C. Madrid, Eric A. Magana, Steven Adkison, Arthur S. Aguero, Jose M. Aleman, Andrew Andrade, Andrew Arguello, Luis C. Ayala, Ricardo Barreda, Daryl Bartlett, Kelly Jo Benjamin, Harold J. Bennett, Robert Breyer, Andrew Butts, Jodi R. Butts, Jess Cabe, Erik J. Cansino, Joseph Caporale, Sean Carrigan, Jack Carson, Rigoberto Cepeda, Edwin Cestero, Anthony E. Chambers, David Cloer, Michael P. Cluff, Shayne Collins, David Colon-Escobar, James R. Comings, Brian T. Cornell, David R. Daiss, Ian P. Daugherty, James R. Davis, Timothy B. Davis, Ruben De La Torre, Darryll Dennis, Jorge L. Dominquez, Sal Dorado, Brian S. Dvorak, Jonas K. Edwards, Scott Edwards, Saul Enriquez, Roberto Espinoza, Jr., Cesar E. Falcon, Bryan K. Fenley, Terrance S. Ferguson, George H. Ferland, Cody L. Fox, Todd J. Fraser, Greg Furnia, Joe A. Gallegos, Elde Garcia, Joel Garcia, Manuel Garcia, Jr., Hugo Garza, Jon Gelber, Jose Luis Gonzalez, Jose A. Gonzalez, Jr., Christopher Gorneau, Eliezer Guajardo, Jr., Gary R. Gualducci, Guadalupe I. Gutierrez, Eric T. Haley, Riley W. Hanback, Gerald Hancock, John E. Harvey, Fausto Hernandez, James R. Herrick, Phillip D. Hise, Steven W. Imrie, Travis W. Inman, Juan Isarraraz, Jr., Dennis Jenkins, Jr., Damon W. Jones, Francisco Juarez, Donald Kenefick, John Kessler, Cully E. Knowlton, William M. Kocan, Kurt W. Kraus, Pyotr Kukharsky, Alfredo Lara, David Ledezma, III, Zenaida Levrie, Stephen C. Lewis, Brandon Longaker, Alex J. Lopez, Cristobal B. Lopez, Felix A. Lopez, Jose C. Lopez, Martin N. Lopez, Haydee Lozano, Claudia Lukason, Trevor MacKenzie, Troy Manske, Samuel Martinez, Lisa Martinez Crouse, Ernesto Martinez, Jr., Kenneth J. Maurer, Chad McBroom, Brian G. McClellan, Guillermo Medrano, III, Hektor G. Mesta, Mark Middleton, Adam Miller, Rodolfo Montelongo, Corey S. Moore, Veronica Morales, Jose A. Morales, Jr., Paul Jerome Murphy, Joe F. Navaro, Leroy L. Notterman, Robert J. Noziska, Eric Pahler, Jude W. Patterson, Samuel D. Peak, John J. Pineiro, Mike B. Pio, Mark W. Potter, Mark Qualter, Amanda Ramirez, Eduardo Rangel, Patricia Reyes, Ruben Ricci, Stacy Guy Rider, Mark Anthony Rios, Jim Rivera, Robin J. Roberts, Benjamin Rodriguez, Alonzo Rodriguez, Mario A. Rodriguez, Ciro Roman, Carlos Romo, Mauro A. Rueda, Joshua E. Sanchez, Raymundo Sanchez, Donald K. Scee, Jeremy Schappell, James Vincent Scordato, Robert J. Senior, Joseph Shailor, Laren M. Shaw, Franciso J. Silva, Paul Silva, Roma J. Solidum, Richard Soria, Andrew K. Sproul, John L. Sturgeon, Jr., Michael Szubinski, Christopher Talbert, Michael Wayne Taylor, Andres Tellez-Giron, Kevin W. Thatcher, Pamela M. Thomas, Jason R. Thompson, David J. Trevino, Manuel Trevino, Millard H. Tucker, Jr., Jamie M. Turley, Darrell S. Turner, Rodolfo Valdez, Jr., Brad Valencia, Marco A. Vargas, Roy Vargas, Jr., Alexander Vazquez, Gary Velasquez, Fernando Venegas, Jason Violette, Edward P. Wagner, Jr., William Whitehead, Cody S. Winn, William Wolf, Kevin S. Worrell, Robert S. Wotring, III, Plaintiffs-Appellants v. UNITED STATES, Defendant-Appellee.
Judges: MOORE, BRYSON, and WALLACH, Circuit Judges.
Reporter: Federal Claims Reporter
Volume: 125
Pages: 926–928

Head Matter:
Johnathan Daniel KING, David Allen, Donald Edward Arnold, Christopher Paul Barker, Tracy T. Beams, Alejandro Castaneda, Carl Cravens, William J. Dunlap, Allen H. Foraker, Anthony Graham, Mark A. Garrison, Ronald J. Guidry, Jeremy D. Hearn, Carlos M. Hernandez, Jessica L. Hernandez, Robert C. Hudgins, Kenneth Johnson, Jerry S. Jones, Ray T. Jones, Scott Lynch, Thomas C. Madrid, Eric A. Magana, Steven Adkison, Arthur S. Aguero, Jose M. Aleman, Andrew Andrade, Andrew Arguello, Luis C. Ayala, Ricardo Barreda, Daryl Bartlett, Kelly Jo Benjamin, Harold J. Bennett, Robert Breyer, Andrew Butts, Jodi R. Butts, Jess Cabe, Erik J. Cansino, Joseph Caporale, Sean Carrigan, Jack Carson, Rigoberto Cepeda, Edwin Cestero, Anthony E. Chambers, David Cloer, Michael P. Cluff, Shayne Collins, David Colon-Escobar, James R. Comings, Brian T. Cornell, David R. Daiss, Ian P. Daugherty, James R. Davis, Timothy B. Davis, Ruben De La Torre, Darryll Dennis, Jorge L. Dominquez, Sal Dorado, Brian S. Dvorak, Jonas K. Edwards, Scott Edwards, Saul Enriquez, Roberto Espinoza, Jr., Cesar E. Falcon, Bryan K. Fenley, Terrance S. Ferguson, George H. Ferland, Cody L. Fox, Todd J. Fraser, Greg Furnia, Joe A. Gallegos, Elde Garcia, Joel Garcia, Manuel Garcia, Jr., Hugo Garza, Jon Gelber, Jose Luis Gonzalez, Jose A. Gonzalez, Jr., Christopher Gorneau, Eliezer Guajardo, Jr., Gary R. Gualducci, Guadalupe I. Gutierrez, Eric T. Haley, Riley W. Hanback, Gerald Hancock, John E. Harvey, Fausto Hernandez, James R. Herrick, Phillip D. Hise, Steven W. Imrie, Travis W. Inman, Juan Isarraraz, Jr., Dennis Jenkins, Jr., Damon W. Jones, Francisco Juarez, Donald Kenefick, John Kessler, Cully E. Knowlton, William M. Kocan, Kurt W. Kraus, Pyotr Kukharsky, Alfredo Lara, David Ledezma, III, Zenaida Levrie, Stephen C. Lewis, Brandon Longaker, Alex J. Lopez, Cristobal B. Lopez, Felix A. Lopez, Jose C. Lopez, Martin N. Lopez, Haydee Lozano, Claudia Lukason, Trevor MacKenzie, Troy Manske, Samuel Martinez, Lisa Martinez Crouse, Ernesto Martinez, Jr., Kenneth J. Maurer, Chad McBroom, Brian G. McClellan, Guillermo Medrano, III, Hektor G. Mesta, Mark Middleton, Adam Miller, Rodolfo Montelongo, Corey S. Moore, Veronica Morales, Jose A. Morales, Jr., Paul Jerome Murphy, Joe F. Navaro, Leroy L. Notterman, Robert J. Noziska, Eric Pahler, Jude W. Patterson, Samuel D. Peak, John J. Pineiro, Mike B. Pio, Mark W. Potter, Mark Qualter, Amanda Ramirez, Eduardo Rangel, Patricia Reyes, Ruben Ricci, Stacy Guy Rider, Mark Anthony Rios, Jim Rivera, Robin J. Roberts, Benjamin Rodriguez, Alonzo Rodriguez, Mario A. Rodriguez, Ciro Roman, Carlos Romo, Mauro A. Rueda, Joshua E. Sanchez, Raymundo Sanchez, Donald K. Scee, Jeremy Schappell, James Vincent Scordato, Robert J. Senior, Joseph Shailor, Laren M. Shaw, Franciso J. Silva, Paul Silva, Roma J. Solidum, Richard Soria, Andrew K. Sproul, John L. Sturgeon, Jr., Michael Szubinski, Christopher Talbert, Michael Wayne Taylor, Andres Tellez-Giron, Kevin W. Thatcher, Pamela M. Thomas, Jason R. Thompson, David J. Trevino, Manuel Trevino, Millard H. Tucker, Jr., Jamie M. Turley, Darrell S. Turner, Rodolfo Valdez, Jr., Brad Valencia, Marco A. Vargas, Roy Vargas, Jr., Alexander Vazquez, Gary Velasquez, Fernando Venegas, Jason Violette, Edward P. Wagner, Jr., William Whitehead, Cody S. Winn, William Wolf, Kevin S. Worrell, Robert S. Wotring, III, Plaintiffs-Appellants v. UNITED STATES, Defendant-Appellee.
No. 2015-5066.
United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit.
Jan. 7, 2016.
Raymond Charles Fay, Fay Law Group PLLC, Washington, DC, argued for plaintiffs-appellants.
Daniel B. Volk, Commercial Litigation Branch, Civil Division, United States Department of Justice, Washington, DC, argued for defendant-appellee. Also represented by Benjamin C. Mizer, Robert E. Kirschman, Jr., Steven J. Gillingham; Lindsay K. Solensky, Bureau of Customs and Border Protection, United States Department of Homeland Security, Washington, DC.
MOORE, BRYSON, and WALLACH, Circuit Judges.

Opinion:
JUDGMENT
PER CURIAM.
This Cause having been heard and considered, it is
OrdbRed and Adjudged:
AFFIRMED. See Fed. Cir. R. 36.