Case Name: THE STATE ex rel. FIDELITY-PHOENIX FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY OF NEW YORK et al. v. JAMES D. BARNETT, Judge
Court: Supreme Court of Missouri
Jurisdiction: Missouri
Decision Date: 1912-01-27
Citations: 239 Mo. 193
Docket Number: 
Parties: THE STATE ex rel. FIDELITY-PHOENIX FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY OF NEW YORK et al. v. JAMES D. BARNETT, Judge.
Judges: All concur except Valliant, C. J., and Graves, J., who dissent in a separate opinion by the latter.
Reporter: Missouri Reports
Volume: 239
Pages: 193–193

Head Matter:
THE STATE ex rel. FIDELITY-PHOENIX FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY OF NEW YORK et al. v. JAMES D. BARNETT, Judge.
In Banc,
January 27, 1912.
Prohibition.
Writ denied.

Opinion:
WOODSON, J.
— The esséntial facts of this case and the legal principles underlying them, are substantially the same as those involved in the case of State ex rel. Pacific Mutual Life Insurance Company v. Grimm, decided by this court, In Banc, at the present term, and reported at page 135 of this report. By consent of parties, it was submitted on briefs, in connection with that case. We have carefully considered this case, and have found no fact or principle of law governing the same which leads to a different conclusion from what was reached in that case. We, therefore, deny the peremptory writ of prohibition, and quash the preliminary rule heretofore issued.
All concur except Valliant, C. J., and Graves, J., who dissent in a separate opinion by the latter.