Case Name: E. A. Thompson v. James Rosenberg et al.
Court: Cuyahoga Circuit Court
Jurisdiction: Ohio
Decision Date: 1909-05-17
Citations: 28 Ohio C.C. Dec. 596
Docket Number: 
Parties: E. A. Thompson v. James Rosenberg et al.
Judges: Henry and Taggart, JJ., concur.
Reporter: Ohio Circuit Court Decisions
Volume: 28
Pages: 596–597

Head Matter:
APPEAL.
[Cuyahoga (8th) Circuit Court,
May 17, 1909.]
Winch, Henry and Taggart, JJ.
Judge Taggart of the fifth circuit sitting in place of Judge Marvin.
E. A. Thompson v. James Rosenberg et al.
Grantee of Owner May Appeal from Foreclosure of Mechanic's Lien.
In an action to foreclose a mechanic’s lien and for personal judgment against the owner at the time the work was done, to which action the grantee of the owner was made-party defendant, the latter may appeal the action to the circuit court.
Appeal.
H. F. Paths and Howland & Niman, for plaintiff.
H. A. Ka,ngesser, John D. F.ackler, Frank Higley, )tlyler & Turney and Max E. Katz, for defendants.

Opinion:
WINCH, J.
Thompson brought his action on an attested account, praying for a personal judgment against the defendant, James Rosen berg, for the value of certain material furnished toward the construction of a house upon premises owned by Eosenberg at the time the materials were furnished, and that the amount of said account be declared a lien upon said premises. He also made A. B. Katz and others defendants, alleging that they claimed liens upon said premises and praying that they be required to set forth their claims or be forever barred.
It appears that the defendant, Katz, purchased said premises of Rosenberg; no personal judgment was asked against him.
The judgment being in favor of Thompson and against Eosenberg and Katz, the latter appealed the case to this court, where he is met by a motion to dismiss his appeal on the ground that the case is not appealable.
Motion overruled on authority of the ease of Fleming v. Kirkendall, 31 Ohio St. 568.
Henry and Taggart, JJ., concur.