Case Name: ROBERT INCHES, Appellant, v. HENRY VAN VALKENBURGH, Respondent
Court: Supreme Court of California
Jurisdiction: California
Decision Date: 1859-11-29
Citations: 1 Cal. Unrep. 81
Docket Number: No. 2251
Parties: ROBERT INCHES, Appellant, v. HENRY VAN VALKENBURGH, Respondent.
Judges: I concur: Cope, J.
Reporter: California Unreported Cases
Volume: 1
Pages: 81–81

Head Matter:
ROBERT INCHES, Appellant, v. HENRY VAN VALKENBURGH, Respondent.
No. 2251;
November 29, 1859.
Appeal — Report of Referee — When not Disturbed. — A judgment upon a report of a referee, where no motion has been made to set it aside or for a new trial, will not be reviewed on appeal.
APPEAL from Fourth Judicial District. San Francisco County.
A. T. Wilson for appellant; H. S. Love for respondent.

Opinion:
BALDWIN, J.
— In this ease judgment was entered for the defendant on the report of a referee. No motion was made for a new trial, or to set aside the report of the referee. An appeal is taken from the judgment so entered on the report of the referee; but it has been expressly held that this court will not review such a judgment under the circumstances: Porter v. Barling, 2 Cal. 72.
Judgment affirmed.
I concur: Cope, J.