Case Name: Axelrod et al. v. Howell, Appellant
Court: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Jurisdiction: Pennsylvania
Decision Date: 1938-01-03
Citations: 328 Pa. 297
Docket Number: Appeal, No. 257
Parties: Axelrod et al. v. Howell, Appellant.
Judges: Before Schaffer, Drew, Linn, Stern and Barnes, JJ.
Reporter: Pennsylvania State Reports
Volume: 328
Pages: 297–298

Head Matter:
Axelrod et al. v. Howell, Appellant.
Argued December 1, 1937.
Before Schaffer, Drew, Linn, Stern and Barnes, JJ.
Todd Darnel, with him Henry Tenwn, for appellant.
Albert J. Bader, with him Robert M. Bernstein, for appellees.
January 3, 1938:

Opinion:
Per Curiam,
After all the evidence on both sides had been given, and, following his address to the jury, plaintiffs' counsel stated to the trial judge that his clients desired to suffer a voluntary nonsuit. Defendant's attorney objected, giving as Ms reason that argument to the jury had been made by his opponent. The judge refused leave to enter the nonsuit, the trial proceeded, and resulted in a verdict in favor of defendant. Upon subsequent consideration, the judge reached the conclusion, "reluctantly," that under the law in Pennsylvania a plaintiff has the right to suffer a voluntary nonsuit at any time before the jury is ready to render its verdict. This determination was correct: Felts v. Del., Lack. & West. R. R. Co., 170 Pa. 432, 33 A. 97; Crumley v. Lutz, 180 Pa. 476, 36 A. 929; James v. Bream, 263 Pa. 305, 106 A. 722.
Appeal dismissed at appellant's cost.