Case Name: Lawrence Gillette vs. Plante Properties, Inc.
Court: Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court
Jurisdiction: Massachusetts
Decision Date: 1965-05-03
Citations: 349 Mass. 760
Docket Number: 
Parties: Lawrence Gillette vs. Plante Properties, Inc.
Judges: 
Reporter: Massachusetts Reports
Volume: 349
Pages: 760–760

Head Matter:
Lawrence Gillette vs. Plante Properties, Inc.
Edward N. Hurley & Gerald 3. Parish, for the plaintiff, submitted a brief.
Philip 3. Ryan for the defendant.
May 3, 1965,

Opinion:
Exceptions overruled. The plaintiff, a tenant of the defendant, alleges error in the allowance of the defendant's motion for a directed verdict. Approximately six weeks prior to the accident on which this action is based the defendant's janitor commenced putting ashes in holes in the yard to the rear of the defendant's premises. In the ashes were some clinkers of undetermined size. In order for the plaintiff to reach the rubbish and garbage cans located in the back yard it was necessary to cross the yard. While taking some garbage to the trash cans at about dusk the plaintiff fell over a clinker the size of a grapefruit and was injured. The record contains no evidence that the defendant, directly or indirectly, was responsible for the presence of the clinker on the spot where the plaintiff fell. Without such evidence any finding for the plaintiff would of necessity be based upon conjecture. Prushensky v. Pucilowski, 269 Mass. 477, 479. Vaillancourt v. Rex Realty Corp. 326 Mass. 534. The defendant's motion was properly allowed.