Case Name: Granville & Newark Motor Service, Inc., v. Public Utilities Commission of Ohio
Court: Supreme Court of Ohio
Jurisdiction: Ohio
Decision Date: 1928-06-13
Citations: 119 Ohio St. 148
Docket Number: Nos. 21068 and 21069
Parties: Granville & Newark Motor Service, Inc., v. Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
Judges: Marshall, C. J., Day, Allen, Kinkade and Robinson, JJ., concur.
Reporter: Ohio State Reports, New Service
Volume: 119
Pages: 148–150

Head Matter:
Granville & Newark Motor Service, Inc., v. Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
(Nos. 21068 and 21069
Decided June 13, 1928.)
Mr. John F. Carlisle and Mr. Wayne C. Overturf, for plaintiff in error.
Mr. E. C. Turner, attorney general, Mr. A. M. Cal-land, Mr. E. B. Meyer, qnd Mr. D. E. Armstrong, for defendant in error.

Opinion:
By the Court.
This order of the Public Utilities Commission simply puts the two companies back in the original status quo, with the exception of the fact that the plaintiff in error is now protected better than before; for the restriction as to the carriage of passengers whose whole ride is between Gran-ville and Newark did not exist prior to the issuance of the present order. The commission had before it the situation where there were two applicants for certificates of convenience and necessity to operate over the same particular route between fixed termini. The commission, upon hearing, issued a certificate to the applicant which it found to be the best fitted to perform the service required by the public convenience and necessity, and denied the certificate to the other applicant. This court will not disturb such order, unless it affirmatively appears from the record that the order is unreasonable and unlawful. Royal Green Coach Co. v. Public Utilities Commission, 110 Ohio St., 41, 143 N. E., 547.
Upon consideration of the entire record, no such affirmative showing is made, and hence we affirm the orders of the Public Utilities Commission.
Orders affirmed.
Marshall, C. J., Day, Allen, Kinkade and Robinson, JJ., concur.
J ones, J., not participating.