Case Name: Commercial Union Insurance Company as Subrogee of Patrick McEvoy and Others, Respondent, v. V. Garofalo Carting Inc., Appellant; State Farm Insurance Company, as Subrogee of Deborah Maini, Respondent, v. V. Garofalo Carting Inc. et al., Appellants
Court: New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 2001-11-29
Citations: 288 A.D.2d 154
Docket Number: 
Parties: Commercial Union Insurance Company as Subrogee of Patrick McEvoy and Others, Respondent, v V. Garofalo Carting Inc., Appellant. State Farm Insurance Company, as Subrogee of Deborah Maini, Respondent, v V. Garofalo Carting Inc. et al., Appellants.
Judges: 
Reporter: Appellate Division Reports
Volume: 288
Pages: 154–155

Head Matter:
Commercial Union Insurance Company as Subrogee of Patrick McEvoy and Others, Respondent, v V. Garofalo Carting Inc., Appellant. State Farm Insurance Company, as Subrogee of Deborah Maini, Respondent, v V. Garofalo Carting Inc. et al., Appellants.
[733 NYS2d 408]

Opinion:
—Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Richard Lowe, III, J.), entered on or about April 13, 2001, which, inter alia, granted the motion of plaintiff in action No. 1 for summary judgment as to liability and denied defendants' motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaints in both actions, unanimously modified, on the law, and upon a search of the record, to grant plaintiff in action No. 2 summary judgment as to liability, and otherwise affirmed, without costs.
The insurer subrogees were entitled to summary judgment on the issue of liability where defendants failed to come forward with competent evidence rebutting the presumption of negligence arising from the circumstance that defendant's employee backed his garbage truck into a house (see, Mitchell v Gonzalez, 269 AD2d 250; Richmond Hill Sav. Bank v Sisters of Order of St. Dominic, 126 AD2d 627). Since defendants posited no medical explanation for defendant driver's conduct or inability to recall the accident, the motion court properly rejected their bare characterization of the accident as an unforeseeable and inexplicable occurrence {see, Chiaia v Bostic, 279 AD2d 495). Concur — Mazzarelli, J. P., Andrias, Ellerin, Buckley and Marlow, JJ.