Case Name: John T. HENNESSY; Michael B. High; William A. Bracken; Larry Gibson; Martha C. Hitchcock; Laurence A. Liss; Ken Mancini; George S. Rapp; Roberta Griffin Torian; Frank J. Soriero v. FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION, as Receiver for Meritor Savings Bank (D.C. Civil No. 93-cv-05589); Thomas CALLAHAN v. FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION, as Receiver for Meritor Savings Bank (D.C. Civil No. 94-cv-01949) Appeal of John T. HENNESSY, Roberta Griffin Torian, Michael B. High, William Bracken, Laurence Liss, Marty Hitchcock, George S. Rapp, Kenneth R. Mancini, Lawrence J. Gibson, Frank J. Soriero and Thomas Callahan, Appellants David A. CAMPBELL, Jr.; Robert F. Hanna; Leslie Voth; Helen T. DeMarco, individually, and Robert F. Hanna; Helen T. Demarco, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, (Separation Plan Class), and David A. Campbell, Jr., on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, (Retiree Health Class), and David A. Campbell, Jr.; Robert F. Hanna, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, (Life Insurance Class) v. FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION as Receiver for Meritor Savings Bank Appeal of David A. CAMPBELL, Jr., Robert F. Hanna, Helen T. DeMarco and Leslie Voth, Appellants Joseph A. ADOLF, Laurence J. Arnold, Christian F. Aurig, George W. Barber, Linda C. Barch, Richard F. Bate, Owen J. Behen, Lauren Bethea, Elizabeth L. Blankenhorn, Anne Marie Boback, Susan M. Brown, John J. Buczek, George S. Bunting, Mary Ann C. Burch, Edith Burkeitt, Thomas P. Callahan, David A. Campbell, Jr., Karla J. Carney, John M. Casamento, Jr., William J. Cathcart, Lisa Cavalli, Nancy L. Ceffaratti, Joseph D. Cellucci, Esther Cerbo, Carole A. Circucci, Anthony R. Coogan, Larry A. Cook, Samuel J. Cook, Wallace P. Cooney, Paul L. Coppola, Lorene C. Coquillette, Betty R. Corley, Harriet S. Corley, Joan T. Corson, David E. Coverdale, Mary C. Craige, Louis T. Cullen, John F. Culp, Edward D. Custer, Michael Czincila, Joan E. Debes, Irene V. Delizzio, Gail L. Delviscio, Harold L. Dempsey, Harold C. Dengel, Debra Anne Denight, Beatrice L. Desher, Joseph H. Devore, Jr., Anna S. Difelice, Mario Difelice, Mary Ann Digregorio, Leonid A. Dobrinin, Sarah S. Doody, Joseph M. Duffy, Leonard T. Ebert, John A. Fatula, Charles J. Ferrie, George W. Fetters, Jr., Lore L. Fisher, John P. Fogarty, Cynthia M. Ford, Doris Gagliardi, Barbara A. Gibson, Frances J. Gillen, William R. Goettle, Charles W. Gray, III, Eugene A. Heiwig, William H. Hilliard, William H.H. Hsu, Stanley E. Hunt, Charles C. Jones, Thomas C. Keiser, Kathleen F. Kelly, Lynn M. Kelly, Ethel S. Keowen, John Andrew Kinnerman, Philip W. Klinger, C. Andrew Krepps, Jr., John David Lambert, Michael G. Lewis, Patricia Leuthy, Salvatore Lizzio, Aldo S. Lombardi, Elisabeth W. Lord, Kathleen Lynch, E. David MacNally, William C. MacNeill, Jr., Frank Joseph Marullo, Edward M. Mason, Jr., Thomas G. Marvel, Ruth A. McAllister, Joseph F. McCole, Christine D. McCormick, Philip J. McCormick, Janet B. McCourt, David C. Melnicoff, Freda I. Millar, Anthony M. Mingarino, Joseph J. Moffa, Linda Lee Montana, Barbara L. Morgan, Marion D. Morgan, Leonard V. Morris, David D. Morrison, Mary T. Murphy, Anthony J. Nocella, William A. Norris, III, Martha K. Ny-lund, Mary E. Orr, John T. Osmian, Charles E. Padgett, Patricia Pawling, Howard F. Pearce, Catherine P. Piccone, Peter P. Pryzbylkowski, Darlene E. Purugganan, Elizabeth L. Rafetto, Edward W. Rapp, Luba K. Reilly, Louise M. Reitano, Antoinette D. Rendino, Ms. Jamie Rindock, Jean Davis Robinson, Richard Rogers, Diane S. Rohr, Herbert A. Roth, Anthony J. Santilli, Jr., Kathleen M. Sawchynsky, Ruth C. Schmidt, Michael F. Scutti, Martin Selgrath, John W. Semple, Joseph F. Slane, Robert A. Smalley, Elizabeth K. Sonneborn, Fred B. Staas, Walter R. Staples, Robert C. Steinman, Arthur W. Stettler, Jean J. Stubbs, Anthony Tabasco, Robert B. Taylor, Annita L. Tedesco, Kenneth C. Thomas, Patricia E. Thompson, Dianne T. Tindall, James M. Toolan, Morris Varano, Stanley J. Verbeek, Donna Volz, Leslie C. Voth, Theresa M. Webb, Cynthia West, Robert B. Whitelaw, Alton T. Winner, Jr., Anne M. Wise, Verdella Wright, Anthony J. Zongaro and Lina G. Zanoni, Appellants, v. FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION, as Receiver for Meritor Savings Bank
Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1995-09-26
Citations: 66 F.3d 659
Docket Number: Nos. 94-1857, 94-1933 and 94-1934
Parties: John T. HENNESSY; Michael B. High; William A. Bracken; Larry Gibson; Martha C. Hitchcock; Laurence A. Liss; Ken Mancini; George S. Rapp; Roberta Griffin Torian; Frank J. Soriero v. FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION, as Receiver for Meritor Savings Bank (D.C. Civil No. 93-cv-05589). Thomas CALLAHAN v. FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION, as Receiver for Meritor Savings Bank (D.C. Civil No. 94-cv-01949). Appeal of John T. HENNESSY, Roberta Griffin Torian, Michael B. High, William Bracken, Laurence Liss, Marty Hitchcock, George S. Rapp, Kenneth R. Mancini, Lawrence J. Gibson, Frank J. Soriero and Thomas Callahan, Appellants David A. CAMPBELL, Jr.; Robert F. Hanna; Leslie Voth; Helen T. DeMarco, individually, and Robert F. Hanna; Helen T. Demarco, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, (Separation Plan Class), and David A. Campbell, Jr., on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, (Retiree Health Class), and David A. Campbell, Jr.; Robert F. Hanna, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, (Life Insurance Class) v. FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION as Receiver for Meritor Savings Bank. Appeal of David A. CAMPBELL, Jr., Robert F. Hanna, Helen T. DeMarco and Leslie Voth, Appellants Joseph A. ADOLF, Laurence J. Arnold, Christian F. Aurig, George W. Barber, Linda C. Barch, Richard F. Bate, Owen J. Behen, Lauren Bethea, Elizabeth L. Blankenhorn, Anne Marie Boback, Susan M. Brown, John J. Buczek, George S. Bunting, Mary Ann C. Burch, Edith Burkeitt, Thomas P. Callahan, David A. Campbell, Jr., Karla J. Carney, John M. Casamento, Jr., William J. Cathcart, Lisa Cavalli, Nancy L. Ceffaratti, Joseph D. Cellucci, Esther Cerbo, Carole A. Circucci, Anthony R. Coogan, Larry A. Cook, Samuel J. Cook, Wallace P. Cooney, Paul L. Coppola, Lorene C. Coquillette, Betty R. Corley, Harriet S. Corley, Joan T. Corson, David E. Coverdale, Mary C. Craige, Louis T. Cullen, John F. Culp, Edward D. Custer, Michael Czincila, Joan E. Debes, Irene V. Delizzio, Gail L. Delviscio, Harold L. Dempsey, Harold C. Dengel, Debra Anne Denight, Beatrice L. Desher, Joseph H. Devore, Jr., Anna S. Difelice, Mario Difelice, Mary Ann Digregorio, Leonid A. Dobrinin, Sarah S. Doody, Joseph M. Duffy, Leonard T. Ebert, John A. Fatula, Charles J. Ferrie, George W. Fetters, Jr., Lore L. Fisher, John P. Fogarty, Cynthia M. Ford, Doris Gagliardi, Barbara A. Gibson, Frances J. Gillen, William R. Goettle, Charles W. Gray, III, Eugene A. Heiwig, William H. Hilliard, William H.H. Hsu, Stanley E. Hunt, Charles C. Jones, Thomas C. Keiser, Kathleen F. Kelly, Lynn M. Kelly, Ethel S. Keowen, John Andrew Kinnerman, Philip W. Klinger, C. Andrew Krepps, Jr., John David Lambert, Michael G. Lewis, Patricia Leuthy, Salvatore Lizzio, Aldo S. Lombardi, Elisabeth W. Lord, Kathleen Lynch, E. David MacNally, William C. MacNeill, Jr., Frank Joseph Marullo, Edward M. Mason, Jr., Thomas G. Marvel, Ruth A. McAllister, Joseph F. McCole, Christine D. McCormick, Philip J. McCormick, Janet B. McCourt, David C. Melnicoff, Freda I. Millar, Anthony M. Mingarino, Joseph J. Moffa, Linda Lee Montana, Barbara L. Morgan, Marion D. Morgan, Leonard V. Morris, David D. Morrison, Mary T. Murphy, Anthony J. Nocella, William A. Norris, III, Martha K. Ny-lund, Mary E. Orr, John T. Osmian, Charles E. Padgett, Patricia Pawling, Howard F. Pearce, Catherine P. Piccone, Peter P. Pryzbylkowski, Darlene E. Purugganan, Elizabeth L. Rafetto, Edward W. Rapp, Luba K. Reilly, Louise M. Reitano, Antoinette D. Rendino, Ms. Jamie Rindock, Jean Davis Robinson, Richard Rogers, Diane S. Rohr, Herbert A. Roth, Anthony J. Santilli, Jr., Kathleen M. Sawchynsky, Ruth C. Schmidt, Michael F. Scutti, Martin Selgrath, John W. Semple, Joseph F. Slane, Robert A. Smalley, Elizabeth K. Sonneborn, Fred B. Staas, Walter R. Staples, Robert C. Steinman, Arthur W. Stettler, Jean J. Stubbs, Anthony Tabasco, Robert B. Taylor, Annita L. Tedesco, Kenneth C. Thomas, Patricia E. Thompson, Dianne T. Tindall, James M. Toolan, Morris Varano, Stanley J. Verbeek, Donna Volz, Leslie C. Voth, Theresa M. Webb, Cynthia West, Robert B. Whitelaw, Alton T. Winner, Jr., Anne M. Wise, Verdella Wright, Anthony J. Zongaro and Lina G. Zanoni, Appellants, v. FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION, as Receiver for Meritor Savings Bank.
Judges: Before: SLOVITER, Chief Judge, BECKER, STAPLETON, MANSMANN, GREENBERG, HUTCHINSON, SCIRICA, COWEN, NYGAARD, ALITO, ROTH, LEWIS, McKEE, SAROKIN and GARTH , Circuit Judges.
Reporter: Federal Reporter 3d Series
Volume: 66
Pages: 659–661

Head Matter:
John T. HENNESSY; Michael B. High; William A. Bracken; Larry Gibson; Martha C. Hitchcock; Laurence A. Liss; Ken Mancini; George S. Rapp; Roberta Griffin Torian; Frank J. Soriero v. FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION, as Receiver for Meritor Savings Bank (D.C. Civil No. 93-cv-05589). Thomas CALLAHAN v. FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION, as Receiver for Meritor Savings Bank (D.C. Civil No. 94-cv-01949). Appeal of John T. HENNESSY, Roberta Griffin Torian, Michael B. High, William Bracken, Laurence Liss, Marty Hitchcock, George S. Rapp, Kenneth R. Mancini, Lawrence J. Gibson, Frank J. Soriero and Thomas Callahan, Appellants David A. CAMPBELL, Jr.; Robert F. Hanna; Leslie Voth; Helen T. DeMarco, individually, and Robert F. Hanna; Helen T. Demarco, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, (Separation Plan Class), and David A. Campbell, Jr., on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, (Retiree Health Class), and David A. Campbell, Jr.; Robert F. Hanna, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, (Life Insurance Class) v. FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION as Receiver for Meritor Savings Bank. Appeal of David A. CAMPBELL, Jr., Robert F. Hanna, Helen T. DeMarco and Leslie Voth, Appellants Joseph A. ADOLF, Laurence J. Arnold, Christian F. Aurig, George W. Barber, Linda C. Barch, Richard F. Bate, Owen J. Behen, Lauren Bethea, Elizabeth L. Blankenhorn, Anne Marie Boback, Susan M. Brown, John J. Buczek, George S. Bunting, Mary Ann C. Burch, Edith Burkeitt, Thomas P. Callahan, David A. Campbell, Jr., Karla J. Carney, John M. Casamento, Jr., William J. Cathcart, Lisa Cavalli, Nancy L. Ceffaratti, Joseph D. Cellucci, Esther Cerbo, Carole A. Circucci, Anthony R. Coogan, Larry A. Cook, Samuel J. Cook, Wallace P. Cooney, Paul L. Coppola, Lorene C. Coquillette, Betty R. Corley, Harriet S. Corley, Joan T. Corson, David E. Coverdale, Mary C. Craige, Louis T. Cullen, John F. Culp, Edward D. Custer, Michael Czincila, Joan E. Debes, Irene V. Delizzio, Gail L. Delviscio, Harold L. Dempsey, Harold C. Dengel, Debra Anne Denight, Beatrice L. Desher, Joseph H. Devore, Jr., Anna S. Difelice, Mario Difelice, Mary Ann Digregorio, Leonid A. Dobrinin, Sarah S. Doody, Joseph M. Duffy, Leonard T. Ebert, John A. Fatula, Charles J. Ferrie, George W. Fetters, Jr., Lore L. Fisher, John P. Fogarty, Cynthia M. Ford, Doris Gagliardi, Barbara A. Gibson, Frances J. Gillen, William R. Goettle, Charles W. Gray, III, Eugene A. Heiwig, William H. Hilliard, William H.H. Hsu, Stanley E. Hunt, Charles C. Jones, Thomas C. Keiser, Kathleen F. Kelly, Lynn M. Kelly, Ethel S. Keowen, John Andrew Kinnerman, Philip W. Klinger, C. Andrew Krepps, Jr., John David Lambert, Michael G. Lewis, Patricia Leuthy, Salvatore Lizzio, Aldo S. Lombardi, Elisabeth W. Lord, Kathleen Lynch, E. David MacNally, William C. MacNeill, Jr., Frank Joseph Marullo, Edward M. Mason, Jr., Thomas G. Marvel, Ruth A. McAllister, Joseph F. McCole, Christine D. McCormick, Philip J. McCormick, Janet B. McCourt, David C. Melnicoff, Freda I. Millar, Anthony M. Mingarino, Joseph J. Moffa, Linda Lee Montana, Barbara L. Morgan, Marion D. Morgan, Leonard V. Morris, David D. Morrison, Mary T. Murphy, Anthony J. Nocella, William A. Norris, III, Martha K. Ny-lund, Mary E. Orr, John T. Osmian, Charles E. Padgett, Patricia Pawling, Howard F. Pearce, Catherine P. Piccone, Peter P. Pryzbylkowski, Darlene E. Purugganan, Elizabeth L. Rafetto, Edward W. Rapp, Luba K. Reilly, Louise M. Reitano, Antoinette D. Rendino, Ms. Jamie Rindock, Jean Davis Robinson, Richard Rogers, Diane S. Rohr, Herbert A. Roth, Anthony J. Santilli, Jr., Kathleen M. Sawchynsky, Ruth C. Schmidt, Michael F. Scutti, Martin Selgrath, John W. Semple, Joseph F. Slane, Robert A. Smalley, Elizabeth K. Sonneborn, Fred B. Staas, Walter R. Staples, Robert C. Steinman, Arthur W. Stettler, Jean J. Stubbs, Anthony Tabasco, Robert B. Taylor, Annita L. Tedesco, Kenneth C. Thomas, Patricia E. Thompson, Dianne T. Tindall, James M. Toolan, Morris Varano, Stanley J. Verbeek, Donna Volz, Leslie C. Voth, Theresa M. Webb, Cynthia West, Robert B. Whitelaw, Alton T. Winner, Jr., Anne M. Wise, Verdella Wright, Anthony J. Zongaro and Lina G. Zanoni, Appellants, v. FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION, as Receiver for Meritor Savings Bank.
Nos. 94-1857, 94-1933 and 94-1934.
United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit.
Sept. 26, 1995.
Before: SLOVITER, Chief Judge, BECKER, STAPLETON, MANSMANN, GREENBERG, HUTCHINSON, SCIRICA, COWEN, NYGAARD, ALITO, ROTH, LEWIS, McKEE, SAROKIN and GARTH , Circuit Judges.
As to panel rehearing.

Opinion:
SUR PETITION FOR REHEARING
COWEN, Circuit Judge.
The petitions for rehearing filed by appellants in Nos. 94AL857; 94-1933 and 94-1934 having been submitted to the judges who participated in the decision of this court and to all the other available circuit judges of the circuit in regular active service, and no judge who concurred in the decision having asked for rehearing, and a majority of the circuit judges of the circuit in regular active service not having voted for rehearing by the court in banc, the petitions for rehearing are denied.