Case Name: Nathaniel B. Haskell and another v. Frederick L. Ayres and others
Court: Michigan Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Michigan
Decision Date: 1875-04-30
Citations: 32 Mich. 93
Docket Number: 
Parties: Nathaniel B. Haskell and another v. Frederick L. Ayres and others.
Judges: 
Reporter: Michigan Reports
Volume: 32
Pages: 93–94

Head Matter:
Nathaniel B. Haskell and another v. Frederick L. Ayres and others.
Contract: Timber: Logs. A contract for the sale of all the pine timber-on certain lands specified at a given price per thousand feet, to be removed -within three years from the date of the contract, confers no authority to -cut and remove the same after the expiration of the time-specified, and conveys no title to logs thereafter cut on said lands by third persons.
Submitted on briefs April 29.
Decided April 30.
Brror to Huron Circuit.
Defendants in error sued plaintiffs in error in trover for ■certain logs cut on lands formerly belonging to one Kingsley. 'To prove their title they introduced in evidence a written ■contract, whereby Kingsley sold to them all the merchantable pine timber on said lands at a dollar per thousand feet, board measure, to be removed within three years from the ■date of the contract; and also proved title to the lands in Kingsley at the time the contract was made. It appeared also that Kingsley afterwards deeded the lands, reserving the pine timber and the right of way to take off the same. The logs in question were cut on said premises by third persons after the expiration of the three years, and were purchased of them by defendants below. The judgment below was in favor of the plaintiffs, and the defendants brought error.
.George S. Engle, O. II. Gallup and A. E. Ghadwiclc, for plaintiffs in error.
Richard Winsor and Ashley Pond, for defendants in error.

Opinion:
PeR Gueiah:
This case is clearly governed by Richards v. Tozer, 27 Mich., 451, and Johnson v. Moore, 28 Mich., 3, and it is only necessary to apply the principles there stated.
The judgment must be reversed, -with costs, and a new trial ordered.