Case Name: Chester Rudnicki vs. Stetson Window Corp.
Court: Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court
Jurisdiction: Massachusetts
Decision Date: 1964-10-28
Citations: 348 Mass. 769
Docket Number: 
Parties: Chester Rudnicki vs. Stetson Window Corp.
Judges: 
Reporter: Massachusetts Reports
Volume: 348
Pages: 769–769

Head Matter:
Chester Rudnicki vs. Stetson Window Corp.
October 28, 1964.
Chester Rudnicki, pro se.
Melvin Norris, for the defendant, submitted a brief.

Opinion:
Plaintiff's appeal dismissed. Defendant's exceptions overruled. In this action of contract the declaration contains five counts. Count 1 was waived and the trial judge directed verdicts for the defendant on counts 3, 4, and 5. There was a verdict for the plaintiff on count 2. The defendant took an exception to the trial judge's charge "wherein the court stated that from the language of the pleadings [count 2] it appeared that the plaintiff had brought an action to recover for work, labor and materials." We note that although count 2 refers to a written contract it also refers to an "account annexed" which contained specifications. The judge instructed the jury that the plaintiff could recover "the fair and reasonable value for the services performed" if he had acted in good faith and "substantially performed the contract." Although count 2 is far from well drafted, we are of opinion that the judge could determine that the plaintiff was declaring on a common count in quantum meruit. "By declaring on an account annexed the plaintiff has by legal intendment stated all the allegations contained in all the common counts." Martha Inc. of New York v. Remis, 330 Mass. 357, 359. Lantz v. Chandler, 340 Mass. 348. There was no error. The plaintiff appealed from the disallowance of his bill of exceptions to the direction of verdicts for the defendant on counts 3, 4, and 5 of the plaintiff's declaration. His appeal is not properly before us. His "exclusive remedy was by petition to establish exceptions." Jones v. Hayden, 314 Mass. 519, 521-522. Commonwealth v. Kossowan, 265 Mass. 436, 437, and cases cited. G. L. c. 231, § 117.