Case Name: E. A. Giraud v. J. T. Robison, Commissioner of the General Land Office, et al.
Court: Supreme Court of Texas
Jurisdiction: Texas
Decision Date: 1909-06-02
Citations: 102 Tex. 488
Docket Number: No. 1955
Parties: E. A. Giraud v. J. T. Robison, Commissioner of the General Land Office, et al.
Judges: 
Reporter: Texas Reports
Volume: 102
Pages: 488–488

Head Matter:
E. A. Giraud v. J. T. Robison, Commissioner of the General Land Office, et al.
No. 1955.
Decided June 2, 1909.
School land—Mustang Island—Application to Purchase.
The law providing for the sale of the public domain situated on Mustang Island (Act of April 24, 1907, Laws 30th Leg., p. 320) having required a separate application for the purchase of each surveyed tract, a bidder whose application complied with the law was entitled to an award of the tract, although a higher price had been offered by one offering to purchase the same with other tracts embraced in one application. (P. 488.)
Original application to the Supreme Court by Giraud for writ of mandamus against the Commissioner of the General Land Office. J. R. Lambert, an adverse claimant of the land, was made corespondent.
The land in question was situated upon Mustang Island and had been surveyed and offered for sale by the Land Commissioner under the Act of April 24, 1907. Giraud had made application to purchase a single tract of one acre at $26. Lambert had offered to purchase this and various other tracts embraced in his applicátion at $32 per acre. The Land Commissioner on account of Lambert’s higher bid had refused to accept relator’s offer.
Charles Rogan and Geo. W. Mendell, Jr., for relator.
R. V. Davidson, Attorney-General, and Wm. E. Hawkins, Assistant, for respondent Robison.
I. C. Baker and Chambers, Hertzberg & Bennett, for respondent, Lambert.

Opinion:
Mr. Justice Williams
delivered the opinion of the court.
The mandamus applied for is granted for the reason that relator was the only bidder for the land whose application complied with the law, the co-respondent having applied, in one application, to pup? chase several separate tracts.
Mandamus granted,