Case Name: James AFFLECK, Clara B. Archibald, Agnes Austin, Ruth W. Blackburn, Holbrook G. Botset, Meldrew Boyle, Elsie Breen, Sara S. Brown, Elizabeth S. Brush, Erwin Campbell, Iva Campbell, Thomas Campbell, Lois M. Chamberlain, John Cleland, E. Clifford Ebert, Edna N. Ebert, Betty R. Elliott, Robert Erwin, John Grabe, Grace Grabe, Beatrice Grater, Elizabeth B. Gregg, Ruth N. Hardy, Josephine T. Haught, Naomi V. Henry, Albert Henry, Fern L. High, Grace Holmes, Ruth Howarth, Dorothy Jackson, Wayne R. Jamison, Pauline Jamison, John Latimer, Helen Lutton, Olive McClelland, Martha McGrew, William Moorhead, Dorothy Moorhead, Evelyn O. Nicholas, Agnes R. Peacock, Carl A. Reshenberg, Christine Rhodes, Charles F. Robinson, Ernest Ruder, Martha Ruder, John G. Samuels, E.P. Schaelchlin, Nelly F. Schaelchlin, Adele C. Schoenberger, Catherine Sherman, Elizabeth M. Silvis, Gladys Spencer, Elizabeth A. Weixel, Grace Weixel, Nora C. Welte, Leslie C. Whitney and Mabel Williamson, Appellants, v. ST. BARNABAS, INC.
Court: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Jurisdiction: Pennsylvania
Decision Date: 1989-11-28
Citations: 523 Pa. 288
Docket Number: Appeal No. 1 W.D. Appeal Dkt. 1989
Parties: James AFFLECK, Clara B. Archibald, Agnes Austin, Ruth W. Blackburn, Holbrook G. Botset, Meldrew Boyle, Elsie Breen, Sara S. Brown, Elizabeth S. Brush, Erwin Campbell, Iva Campbell, Thomas Campbell, Lois M. Chamberlain, John Cleland, E. Clifford Ebert, Edna N. Ebert, Betty R. Elliott, Robert Erwin, John Grabe, Grace Grabe, Beatrice Grater, Elizabeth B. Gregg, Ruth N. Hardy, Josephine T. Haught, Naomi V. Henry, Albert Henry, Fern L. High, Grace Holmes, Ruth Howarth, Dorothy Jackson, Wayne R. Jamison, Pauline Jamison, John Latimer, Helen Lutton, Olive McClelland, Martha McGrew, William Moorhead, Dorothy Moorhead, Evelyn O. Nicholas, Agnes R. Peacock, Carl A. Reshenberg, Christine Rhodes, Charles F. Robinson, Ernest Ruder, Martha Ruder, John G. Samuels, E.P. Schaelchlin, Nelly F. Schaelchlin, Adele C. Schoenberger, Catherine Sherman, Elizabeth M. Silvis, Gladys Spencer, Elizabeth A. Weixel, Grace Weixel, Nora C. Welte, Leslie C. Whitney and Mabel Williamson, Appellants, v. ST. BARNABAS, INC.
Judges: Before NIX, C.J., and LARSEN, FLAHERTY, McDermott, zappala and papadakos, jj.
Reporter: Pennsylvania State Reports
Volume: 523
Pages: 288–293

Head Matter:
566 A.2d 852
James AFFLECK, Clara B. Archibald, Agnes Austin, Ruth W. Blackburn, Holbrook G. Botset, Meldrew Boyle, Elsie Breen, Sara S. Brown, Elizabeth S. Brush, Erwin Campbell, Iva Campbell, Thomas Campbell, Lois M. Chamberlain, John Cleland, E. Clifford Ebert, Edna N. Ebert, Betty R. Elliott, Robert Erwin, John Grabe, Grace Grabe, Beatrice Grater, Elizabeth B. Gregg, Ruth N. Hardy, Josephine T. Haught, Naomi V. Henry, Albert Henry, Fern L. High, Grace Holmes, Ruth Howarth, Dorothy Jackson, Wayne R. Jamison, Pauline Jamison, John Latimer, Helen Lutton, Olive McClelland, Martha McGrew, William Moorhead, Dorothy Moorhead, Evelyn O. Nicholas, Agnes R. Peacock, Carl A. Reshenberg, Christine Rhodes, Charles F. Robinson, Ernest Ruder, Martha Ruder, John G. Samuels, E.P. Schaelchlin, Nelly F. Schaelchlin, Adele C. Schoenberger, Catherine Sherman, Elizabeth M. Silvis, Gladys Spencer, Elizabeth A. Weixel, Grace Weixel, Nora C. Welte, Leslie C. Whitney and Mabel Williamson, Appellants, v. ST. BARNABAS, INC.
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania.
Argued Sept. 29, 1989.
Decided Nov. 28, 1989.
Kenneth P. Simon, Phillip S. Simon, Simon & Simon, Pittsburgh, for appellants.
Thomas E. Birsic, James A. Buddie, Kirkpatrick & Lock-hart, Pittsburgh, for appellee.
Before NIX, C.J., and LARSEN, FLAHERTY, McDermott, zappala and papadakos, jj.

Opinion:
PER CURIAM:
Appeal dismissed as having been improvidently granted.
PAPADAKOS, J., files a dissenting opinion.
LARSEN, J., dissents.
PAPADAKOS, Justice,