Case Name: Hodgdon v. Darling
Court: New Hampshire Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: New Hampshire
Decision Date: 1881-12
Citations: 61 N.H. 582
Docket Number: 
Parties: Hodgdon v. Darling.
Judges: Allen, J., did not sit: the others concurred.
Reporter: New Hampshire Reports
Volume: 61
Pages: 582–582

Head Matter:
Hodgdon v. Darling.
An agreed case, in which the defendant has no interest, does not authorize a decision of a controversy between the plaintiff and other persons who are not parties to the suit.
Assumpsit. Facts agreed. The defendant owes the plaintiff the amount claimed for labor performed by the plaintiff in erecting a house for the defendant. The plaintiff’s lien on the house, under G. L., e. 139, ss. 11, 12, is secured by an attachment made in this suit within the prescribed ninety days. Similar liens of other workmen on the same house are secured by attachments made in other suits at different times within the ninety days. The attached property not being sufficient to satisfy all the claims, the question was submitted whether the first attaching creditor should be paid in full, or whether the attached property should be applied in proportional satisfaction of all the claims.
A. R. Evans, for the plaintiff.
Ray, Drew £ Jordan, for the defendant.

Opinion:
Clark, J.
The defendant, having no interest in the case, declines to argue it. Whether his house is applied in full payment of some of the claims, or in part payment of all, is a matter of indifference to him. Between him and the plaintiff there is no contention. If there is a controversy between this plaintiff and the plaintiffs in the other suits as to the precedence or equality of lien, it cannot be determined in a proceeding in which only one of the contestants is a party. Advising them, in either of the suits at law, how to levy the executions to which they will be entitled when they recover judgments, would not be an exercise of judicial power. Stone v. Hobart, 8 Pick. 464; Smith v. Cudworth, 24 Pick. 196; State v. Sias, 17 N. H. 558; State v. Stevens, 36 N. H. 59.
Case discharged.
Allen, J., did not sit: the others concurred.