Case Name: VOLLMER v. NEZ PERCES COUNTY
Court: Idaho Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Idaho
Decision Date: 1900-11-15
Citations: 7 Idaho 302
Docket Number: 
Parties: VOLLMER v. NEZ PERCES COUNTY.
Judges: Huston, C. J., and Sullivan, J., concur.
Reporter: Idaho Reports
Volume: 7
Pages: 302–303

Head Matter:
(November 15, 1900.)
VOLLMER v. NEZ PERCES COUNTY.
[62 Pac. 925.]
Premature Appeal — Dismissal op Appeal. — Motion to dismiss appeal sustained upon the ground that the appeal was taken and perfected prior to entry of judgment.
(Syllabus by the court.)
APPEAL from District Court Nez Perces County.
Miles S. Johnson and F. Danford, for Appellant,
cite no authorities upon the question passed upon by the court.
James E. Babb, for Respondent.
No brief can be found on file.

Opinion:
QUARLES, J.
Respondent moves to dismiss this appeal upon several different grounds. One of the grounds upon which the motion is based is that the appeal was perfected before the judgment was entered in the lower court. This ground is con fessed by the appellant, for which reason this appeal must be dismissed. The appellant suggests, however, that "this appeal was taken for the purpose of having the present statutes in regard to taxation — as to the right of appeal from boards of equalization — judicially determined as a precedent governing the official action of such officers in raising public revenues; and, as this question is raised by respondent's motion we respectfully ask and pray that your honorable court pass on this question in deciding this motion." Inasmuch as the appeal was prematurely taken, and therefore dismissed, this court has not jurisdiction over the subject matter of the action, and does not believe that any good would result from an expression of our views obiter, for which reason we refrain from expressing an opinion as to the subject matter of the appeal. Costs awarded to respondent.
Huston, C. J., and Sullivan, J., concur.