Case Name: In the Matter of the Voluntary Dissolution of The Gies Lithographic Company. Homer E. Dudley, as Temporary Receiver of The Gies Lithographic Company, Appellant; George Bleistein, as President of The Courier Company, Judgment Creditor, Respondent
Court: New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1896
Citations: 7 A.D. 550
Docket Number: 
Parties: In the Matter of the Voluntary Dissolution of The Gies Lithographic Company. Homer E. Dudley, as Temporary Receiver of The Gies Lithographic Company, Appellant; George Bleistein, as President of The Courier Company, Judgment Creditor, Respondent.
Judges: 
Reporter: Appellate Division Reports
Volume: 7
Pages: 550–553

Head Matter:
In the Matter of the Voluntary Dissolution of The Gies Lithographic Company. Homer E. Dudley, as Temporary Receiver of The Gies Lithographic Company, Appellant; George Bleistein, as President of The Courier Company, Judgment Creditor, Respondent.
Liens — an execution delivered to a sheriff has priority over an order appointing a temporaA'y receiver of the judgment debtor, fled later on the same day.
Where an execution, issued upon a valid judgment against a corporation, is delivered to the sheriff of the proper county upon the same day as, but prior to, the filing of an order appointing a temporary receiver of the property of the corporation, the execution, being prior in time, is entitled to priority over the title acquired by the receiver.
. Appeal by Homer E. Dudley, as temporary receiver of The Gies Lithographic Company, from an order made at a Special Term of the Superior Court of Buffalo, and entered in the office of the clerk of said court on the 31st day of December, 1895, which orders and adjudges that an execution issued out of the County Court in favor of the plaintiff in an action- wherein George Bleistein, as president of the Courier Company is plaintiff,' and • The Gies Lithographic Company is defendant, is a lien upon the real and personal property of .The Gies Lithographic Company, judgment debtor,- superior to the right, title and possession of the receiver herein, and ordering the receiver in this proceeding to pay the amount of said judgment and execution to said judgment creditor out of the first moneys in his hands as such receiver, and prior to all other claims.
Norris Morey, for the appellant.
W. C. Miner, for the respondent.

Opinion:
Per Curiam:
The Gies Lithographic Company was incorporated pursuant to thé Business Corporations Law of this State, and had its principal business office at Buffalo, New York. November 22, 1895,' George Bleistein, as president of the Courier Company, began an action in the Municipal Court of Buffalo against said corporation, by the personal service of a summons, to recover a sum due for goods sold by the plaintiff to the defendant. November 29, 1895, judgment was recovered in the action for $351.88 damages and costs, and was entered and docketed in the office of the clerk of the county of Erie before ten minutes past ten o'clock in the forenoon of that day, at which time an execution on the judgment was issued and delivered to the sheriff of that county. November 29, 1895, the directors of the corporation filed a petition praying for its voluntary dissolution on the ground of its insolvency and for the appointment of a receiver thereof. At fifteen minutes past twelve o'clock in the afternoon of that day an order was filed with the clerk of said county appointing Homer E. Dudley temporary receiver of the corporation and restraining its creditors from bringing actions against it and also from taking further proceedings in actions theretofore brought. The fourth subdivision of the order provided:
"4. That before entering upon the duties of his trust said receiver execute and file with the clerk of this court a bond with sufficient surety to the people of the State of New York in the sum of twenty thousand ($20,000) dollars, conditioned for the faithful discharge by said receiver of the duties of his trust, such bond to be approved as to its sufficiency, form and manner of its execution by a judge of this court, and upon the filing of such bond so approved, the said receiver is authorized to take possession and sequester the property of the said corporation, The Gies Lithographic Company, and to take and hold all property held by and in the possession of said corporation; all funds of the said corporation not needed for immediate disbursements to be deposited in the Marine Bank of Buffalo, N. Y."
At about thirty minutes past two o'clock in the afternoon of that day the receiver filed his bond with the clerk of said county, and immediately thereafter entered upon the discharge of his duties. At forty-five minutes past four o'clock in the afternoon of that day a copy of the order appointing the receiver was served on the attorneys who had appeared in the action, and recovered the judgment in favor of George Bleistein as president. It is not disputed that the judgment debtor had sufficient chattels, in Erie county, subject to levy and sale upon an execution* out of which the judgment could have been satisfied. The only question involved in this appeal is, which acquired the first- lien on the chattels, the judgment creditor under his execution, or the receiver under bis order.
It is suggested that this judgment is void under section 48 of the Stock Corporation Law (Laws of 1890, chap. 564, as amended by Laws of 1892, chap. 688), which provides: " Ho conveyance, assignment or transfer of any property of any such corporation by it or by any officer, director or stockholder thereof, nor any payment made, judgment suffered, lien created or security given by it or by any officer, director or stockholder when the corporation is insolvent or its insolvency is imminent, with the intent of giving a preference to any particular creditor over other creditors of the corporation shall be valid."
There is no evidence that the corporation or any of its officers suffered this judgment to be recovered.with intent to give a preference to this judgment creditor. It is not asserted that the debt for which the judgment was recovered was not justly due and owing by the corporation to the judgment creditor, and the inference from the facts stated in the record is, that the corporation not only did not intend to give this creditor a preference, but intended to defeat the attempt to collect this debt by means of a judgment. The judgment was not recovered in violation of the statutory provision quoted.
When the execution was delivered to the sheriff of the county of Erie it became a lien on all of the judgment debtor's goods and chattels' within that county (Code Civ. Proc. § 1405), which was not divested by the order appointing a receiver subsequently granted and entered. (Walling v. Miller, 108 N. Y. 173; Matter of Lewis & Fowler Mfg. Co., 89 Hun, 208.) In The Matter of Christian Jensen Co. (128 N. Y. 550) the receiver was appointed two days before the writs of replevin, and attachment were issued, and he filed his bond and qualified the day before they were issued, and he took possession of the property the day the writs were issued, and, therefore, that case does not sustain the appellant's position.
We have before us two processes of duly constituted courts, both of which became liens on the goods and chattels of the judgment debtor, and as one is as much entitled to the protection and favor of the court as the other, the equities of the parties are equal, and the lien which is prior in time must prevail.
The order is affirmed, with costs and printing disbursements against the. receiver, payable out of the estate in his hands. '
All concurred.
Order affirmed, with ten dollars costs and disbursements payable out of the fund.