Case Name: Krishna NARAYAN; Sherrie Narayan; Virendra Nath; Nancy Makowski; Keith Macdonald as Co-trustee for the DKM Trust Dated October 7, 2011; Simon Yoo; Sumiyo Sakaguchi; Susan Renton, as Trustee for the Renton Family Trust Dated 12/3/09; Stephen Xiang Pang; Faye Wu Liu; Massy Mehdipour as Trustee for Massy Mehdipour Trust Dated June 21, 2006; G. Nicholas Smith; Tristine Smith; Ritz 1303 re, LLC, a Colorado Limited Liability Company; and Bradley Chaffee As Trustee of the Charles V. Chaffee BRC Stock Trust Dated 12/1/99 and The Clifford W. Chaffee BRC Stock Trust Dated 1/4/98, Petitioners/Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. THE RITZ-CARLTON DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, INC.; The Ritz-carlton Management Company, LLC; John Albert; Edgar Gum, Respondents/Defendants-Appellants, and Marriott International Inc.; Maui Land & Pineapple Co., Inc.; Exclusive Resorts, LLC; Kapalua Bay, LLC; Association of Apartment Owners of Kapalua Bay Condominium; Caroline Peters Belsom; Cathy Ross; Robert Parsons; Ryan Churchill; The Ritz-carlton Hotel Company, L.L.C.; Marriott Vacations Worldwide, Corporation; Marriott Ownership Resorts, Inc.; Marriott Two Flags, LP; MH Kapalua Venture, LLC; MLP KB Partner LLC; Kapalua Bay Holdings, LLC; ER Kapalua Investors Fund, LLC; ER Kapalua Investors Fund Holdings, LLC; Exclusive Resorts Development Company, LLC; and Exclusive Resorts Club I Holdings, LLC, Respondents/Defendants
Court: Supreme Court of the State of Hawaii
Jurisdiction: Hawaii
Decision Date: 2017-08-09
Citations: 140 Haw. 380
Docket Number: SCWC-12-0000819
Parties: Krishna NARAYAN; Sherrie Narayan; Virendra Nath; Nancy Makowski; Keith Macdonald as Co-trustee for the DKM Trust Dated October 7, 2011; Simon Yoo; Sumiyo Sakaguchi; Susan Renton, as Trustee for the Renton Family Trust Dated 12/3/09; Stephen Xiang Pang; Faye Wu Liu; Massy Mehdipour as Trustee for Massy Mehdipour Trust Dated June 21, 2006; G. Nicholas Smith; Tristine Smith; Ritz 1303 re, LLC, a Colorado Limited Liability Company; and Bradley Chaffee As Trustee of the Charles V. Chaffee BRC Stock Trust Dated 12/1/99 and The Clifford W. Chaffee BRC Stock Trust Dated 1/4/98, Petitioners/Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. THE RITZ-CARLTON DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, INC.; The Ritz-carlton Management Company, LLC; John Albert; Edgar Gum, Respondents/Defendants-Appellants, and Marriott International Inc.; Maui Land & Pineapple Co., Inc.; Exclusive Resorts, LLC; Kapalua Bay, LLC; Association of Apartment Owners of Kapalua Bay Condominium; Caroline Peters Belsom; Cathy Ross; Robert Parsons; Ryan Churchill; The Ritz-carlton Hotel Company, L.L.C.; Marriott Vacations Worldwide, Corporation; Marriott Ownership Resorts, Inc.; Marriott Two Flags, LP; MH Kapalua Venture, LLC; MLP KB Partner LLC; Kapalua Bay Holdings, LLC; ER Kapalua Investors Fund, LLC; ER Kapalua Investors Fund Holdings, LLC; Exclusive Resorts Development Company, LLC; and Exclusive Resorts Club I Holdings, LLC, Respondents/Defendants.
Judges: (By: Reektenwald, C.J., Nakayama, McKenna, and Pollack, JJ., and Circuit Judge Nakasone, in place of Acoba, J., recused)
Reporter: Hawaii Reports
Volume: 140
Pages: 380–381

Head Matter:
400 P.3d 581
Krishna NARAYAN; Sherrie Narayan; Virendra Nath; Nancy Makowski; Keith Macdonald as Co-trustee for the DKM Trust Dated October 7, 2011; Simon Yoo; Sumiyo Sakaguchi; Susan Renton, as Trustee for the Renton Family Trust Dated 12/3/09; Stephen Xiang Pang; Faye Wu Liu; Massy Mehdipour as Trustee for Massy Mehdipour Trust Dated June 21, 2006; G. Nicholas Smith; Tristine Smith; Ritz 1303 re, LLC, a Colorado Limited Liability Company; and Bradley Chaffee As Trustee of the Charles V. Chaffee BRC Stock Trust Dated 12/1/99 and The Clifford W. Chaffee BRC Stock Trust Dated 1/4/98, Petitioners/Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. THE RITZ-CARLTON DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, INC.; The Ritz-carlton Management Company, LLC; John Albert; Edgar Gum, Respondents/Defendants-Appellants, and Marriott International Inc.; Maui Land & Pineapple Co., Inc.; Exclusive Resorts, LLC; Kapalua Bay, LLC; Association of Apartment Owners of Kapalua Bay Condominium; Caroline Peters Belsom; Cathy Ross; Robert Parsons; Ryan Churchill; The Ritz-carlton Hotel Company, L.L.C.; Marriott Vacations Worldwide, Corporation; Marriott Ownership Resorts, Inc.; Marriott Two Flags, LP; MH Kapalua Venture, LLC; MLP KB Partner LLC; Kapalua Bay Holdings, LLC; ER Kapalua Investors Fund, LLC; ER Kapalua Investors Fund Holdings, LLC; Exclusive Resorts Development Company, LLC; and Exclusive Resorts Club I Holdings, LLC, Respondents/Defendants.
SCWC-12-0000819
Supreme Court of Hawai'i.
DATED: Honolulu, Hawai'i, August 9, 2017.
(By: Reektenwald, C.J., Nakayama, McKenna, and Pollack, JJ., and Circuit Judge Nakasone, in place of Acoba, J., recused)

Opinion:
ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION
Upon consideration of Respondents/Defendants-Appellants the Ritz Carlton Development Company, Inc., et al's motion for reconsideration of the opinion filed on July 14, 2017, Exclusive Resorts, LLC, et al.'s joinder in the motion for reconsideration and the record herein,
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the motion is denied.