Case Name: In the Matter of Joseph P. McLaughlin, Appellant, against William Wilson, as Commissioner of the Department of Housing and Buildings of the City of New York, et al., Respondents; In the Matter of John H. Newman, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents; In the Matter of Henry C. Wist, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents; In the Matter of Alexander Newman, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents; In the Matter of Edmund F. Konrady, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents; In the Matter of George J. Northrup, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents; In the Matter of August Nebgen, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents; In the Matter of Charles J. Falk, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents; In the Matter of Anthony A. McNally, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents; In the Matter of John E. Manion, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents; In the Matter of Louis Sweet, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents; In the Matter of Charles Zoufaly, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents; In the Matter of William Bartow, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents; In the Matter of John J. Lundon, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents; In the Matter of Harry P. Wasserman, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents; In the Matter of Harold U. Lockwood, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents
Court: New York Court of Appeals
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1943-03-04
Citations: 290 N.Y. 660
Docket Number: 
Parties: In the Matter of Joseph P. McLaughlin, Appellant, against William Wilson, as Commissioner of the Department of Housing and Buildings of the City of New York, et al., Respondents. In the Matter of John H. Newman, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Henry C. Wist, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Alexander Newman, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Edmund F. Konrady, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of George J. Northrup, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of August Nebgen, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Charles J. Falk, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Anthony A. McNally, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of John E. Manion, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Louis Sweet, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Charles Zoufaly, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of William Bartow, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of John J. Lundon, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Harry P. Wasserman, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Harold U. Lockwood, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents.
Judges: 
Reporter: New York Reports
Volume: 290
Pages: 660–661

Head Matter:
In the Matter of Joseph P. McLaughlin, Appellant, against William Wilson, as Commissioner of the Department of Housing and Buildings of the City of New York, et al., Respondents. In the Matter of John H. Newman, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Henry C. Wist, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Alexander Newman, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Edmund F. Konrady, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of George J. Northrup, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of August Nebgen, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Charles J. Falk, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Anthony A. McNally, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of John E. Manion, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Louis Sweet, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Charles Zoufaly, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of William Bartow, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of John J. Lundon, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Harry P. Wasserman, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents. In the Matter of Harold U. Lockwood, Appellant, against The Same, Respondents.
Submitted February 23, 1943;
decided March 4, 1943.
Thomas D. Thacher, Corporation Counsel (Paxton Blair and Henry J. Shields of counsel), for motion.
George Gordon Battle opposed.

Opinion:
Motion granted and appeals dismissed with costs and ten dollars costs of motion.