Case Name: JOHN H. DILLARD and T. J. HILL v. HIAWASSEE RIVER POWER COMPANY
Court: Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jurisdiction: North Carolina
Decision Date: 1919-01-03
Citations: 177 N.C. 109
Docket Number: 
Parties: JOHN H. DILLARD and T. J. HILL v. HIAWASSEE RIVER POWER COMPANY.
Judges: 
Reporter: North Carolina Reports
Volume: 177
Pages: 109–109

Head Matter:
JOHN H. DILLARD and T. J. HILL v. HIAWASSEE RIVER POWER COMPANY.
(Filed 3 January, 1919.)
Attorney and Client — Attorneys’ Fees — Reference.
Appeal by defendant from Lane, J., at the April Term, 1918, off CHEROKEE.
Witherspoon & Witherspoon and M. W. Bell for plaintiffs.
J. N. Moody for defendant.

Opinion:
Pee Oubiam.
This is an action brought by the plaintiffs to recover-of the defendant for legal services rendered the defendant. The defendant, answering the complaint, averred it had paid the plaintiffs the sum of $1,800 for said services, -and that this was all their services were-reasonably worth.
The case was referred to J. D. Mallonee, referee, to state the account-between the. parties. The referee heard the matter and reported his findings of fact and conclusions of law to April Term, 1918, of the Superior • Court, and it was heard upon exceptions to the referee's report, before - Judge Lane. His Honor sustained all the findings and rulings of the referee and overruled all exceptions to the referee's report, as well as all objections taken by the defendant to the evidence as it was taken before • the referee and rendered judgment for plaintiffs. The defendant excepted and appealed to the Supreme Court.
The first thirty-nine exceptions were taken to the referee's report, to-both his findings of fact and conclusions of law, and whether these exceptions, or any of them, should be sustained, it is admitted, depends-, largely upon the consideration of the exceptions to the testimony of the plaintiff Hill and that of Norvell, a witness for the plaintiff, the latter-having testified as an expert.
"We have examined the numerous exceptions and think they cannot be-, sustained, and that it is needless to discuss them.
Affirmed.