Case Name: Powell et al. v. Porter et al.
Court: Supreme Court of Georgia
Jurisdiction: Georgia
Decision Date: 1939-11-17
Citations: 189 Ga. 440
Docket Number: No. 12829
Parties: Powell et al. v. Porter et al.
Judges: All the Justices concur.
Reporter: Georgia Reports
Volume: 189
Pages: 440–441

Head Matter:
Powell et al. v. Porter et al.
No. 12829.
November 17, 1939.
Rehearing denied December 5, 1939.

Opinion:
Atkinson, Presiding Justice.
1. "Where several plaintiffs jointly sue to recover land, alleging a joint title, there can be no recovery unless the plaintiffs prove a joint title." Shaddix v. Watson, 130 Ga. 764 (61 S. E. 828), and cit.; Powell on Actions for Land, 58, § 27, and notes. All or none must have right to recover. Hunt v. Lavender, 140 Ga. 157 (3) (78 S. E. 805). This was a joint action at law by tenants in common to recover land, and the above principle applies.
2. "Where land has been set apart as a statutory year's support for a widow and minor children, title to the land vests in the widow and minor children, subject to the power of the widow alone to convey in fee simple or mortgage the land for support of herself and minor children. Bridges v. Barbree, 127 Ga. 679 (56 S. E. 1025) ; Cleghorn v. Johnson, 69 Ga. 369; Phillips v. Cook, 158 Ga. 151 (123 S. E. 108); Allen v. Lindsey, 113 Ga. 521 (38 S. E. 975) ; Bank of Cuthbert v. Taylor, 158 Ga. 237 (123 S. E. 262)." Anders v. First National Bank of Barnesville, 165 Ga. 682 (4) (142 S. E. 98).
3. The allegations of the petition showing an absolute deed by the widow, conveying the land to the grantee therein, fails to allege any reason why it was not binding on her. In such circumstances the petition failed to allege a cause of action at least as to the widow, one of the tenants in common, suing jointly to recover the land. Accordingly the action fails as to all the plaintiffs. The judge did not err in sustaining the demurrer and dismissing the action.
Judgment affirmed.
All the Justices concur.
Davis & Friedin, for plaintiffs.
J. W. Dennard, for defendants.