Case Name: Joomart TOKTOBAEV and Ulukbek Dzhumaliev v. ALPHA CONTRACTING III, LLC, KG Construction, Allegheny Power, West Penn Power Company, Allegheny Energy, First Energy Corporation, Tranzsporter, Tie Down Engineering, Inc., Faith Alliance Church and the Western Pennsylvania District of the Christian and Missionary Alliance. Petition of: First Energy Corporation, Allegheny Energy, Inc and West Penn Power Company. Helen Esbenshade, Esquire, Administratrix and Personal Representative of the Estate of Adylbek Murataliev, Dec. v. Alpha Contracting III, LLC, KG Construction, Allegheny Power, Allegheny Energy, West Penn Power Company, First Energy Corporation, Tranzsporter, Tie Down Engineering, Inc., Faith Alliance Church, and the Western Pennsylvania District of the Christian Missionary Alliance. Petition of: First Energy Corp., Allegheny Energy, Inc and West Penn Power Company
Court: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Jurisdiction: Pennsylvania
Decision Date: 2016-12-06
Citations: 163 A.3d 403
Docket Number: No. 271 EAL 2016; No. 272 EAL 2016
Parties: Joomart TOKTOBAEV and Ulukbek Dzhumaliev v. ALPHA CONTRACTING III, LLC, KG Construction, Allegheny Power, West Penn Power Company, Allegheny Energy, First Energy Corporation, Tranzsporter, Tie Down Engineering, Inc., Faith Alliance Church and the Western Pennsylvania District of the Christian and Missionary Alliance Petition of: First Energy Corporation, Allegheny Energy, Inc and West Penn Power Company Helen Esbenshade, Esquire, Administratrix and Personal Representative of the Estate of Adylbek Murataliev, Dec. v. Alpha Contracting III, LLC, KG Construction, Allegheny Power, Allegheny Energy, West Penn Power Company, First Energy Corporation, Tranzsporter, Tie Down Engineering, Inc., Faith Alliance Church, and the Western Pennsylvania District of the Christian Missionary Alliance Petition of: First Energy Corp., Allegheny Energy, Inc and West Penn Power Company
Judges: Justice Baer and Justice Mundy did not participate in the consideration or decision of this matter.
Reporter: West's Atlantic Reporter, Third Series
Volume: 163
Pages: 403–403

Head Matter:
Joomart TOKTOBAEV and Ulukbek Dzhumaliev v. ALPHA CONTRACTING III, LLC, KG Construction, Allegheny Power, West Penn Power Company, Allegheny Energy, First Energy Corporation, Tranzsporter, Tie Down Engineering, Inc., Faith Alliance Church and the Western Pennsylvania District of the Christian and Missionary Alliance Petition of: First Energy Corporation, Allegheny Energy, Inc and West Penn Power Company Helen Esbenshade, Esquire, Administratrix and Personal Representative of the Estate of Adylbek Murataliev, Dec. v. Alpha Contracting III, LLC, KG Construction, Allegheny Power, Allegheny Energy, West Penn Power Company, First Energy Corporation, Tranzsporter, Tie Down Engineering, Inc., Faith Alliance Church, and the Western Pennsylvania District of the Christian Missionary Alliance Petition of: First Energy Corp., Allegheny Energy, Inc and West Penn Power Company
No. 271 EAL 2016
No. 272 EAL 2016
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania.
December 6, 2016

Opinion:
ORDER
PER CURIAM
AND NOW, this 6th day of December, 2016, the Petition for Allowance of Appeal is DENIED.
Justice Baer and Justice Mundy did not participate in the consideration or decision of this matter.