Case Name: The State against Caleb Jones; and The State against Thomas M'Cartan
Court: South Carolina Court of Appeals
Jurisdiction: South Carolina
Decision Date: 1804
Citations: 2 Bay 519
Docket Number: 
Parties: The State against Caleb Jones, and The State against Thomas M'Cartan.
Judges: Present, Grimice, Waties, Bay, Brevard and Lee, Judges.
Reporter: South Carolina Law Reports
Volume: 2
Pages: 520–520

Head Matter:
The State against Caleb Jones, and The State against Thomas M'Cartan.
Columbia,
1804.
Where a jury iq a criminal ease -prill find a verdict contrary to, or •without evidence, as well opinion6t -l of Tud»ereSíthíf court-win, up-of the Judge cause, order a oat argument"
THESE were two criminal cases, tried in Spartanhurgh ... Á ° district, in which the defendants were convicted of larceny,
_ _ . r . , Motions for new trials.

Opinion:
Judge Waties,
before whom the defendants were tried aDd convicted, in his place on the bench, reported to the other Judges, that in his opinion, there was no evidence offered in these cases, sufficient in law to convict either oi the defendants, and so he charged the jury. Hut that such were their prejudices against the defendants, that they con* victed them both, against his opinion and directipn.
Whereupon thg court, upon his report, ordered a new trial, without hearing argument.
Present, Grimice, Waties, Bay, Brevard and Lee, Judges.