Case Name: UNITED STATES SUGAR CORPORATION, Petitioner v. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, Respondent. American Chemistry Council, et al., Intervenors; American Chemistry Council, Petitioner v. Environmental Protection Agency, Respondent. American Forest & Paper Association, et al., Intervenors
Court: United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 2016-12-23
Citations: 671 F. App'x 824
Docket Number: No. 11-1108; Consolidated with 11-1124, 11-1134, 11-1142, 11-1145, 11-1159, 11-1165, 11-1172, 11-1174, 11-1181, 13-1086, 13-1087, 13-1091, 13-1092, 13-1096, 13-1097, 13-1098, 13-1099, 13-1100, 13-1103; No. 11-1141; Consolidated with 11-1182, 11-1207, 11-1208, 13-1105, 13-1107
Parties: UNITED STATES SUGAR CORPORATION, Petitioner v. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, Respondent American Chemistry Council, et al., Intervenors American Chemistry Council, Petitioner v. Environmental Protection Agency, Respondent American Forest & Paper Association, et al., Intervenors
Judges: BEFORE: Henderson, Brown, and Griffith, Circuit. Judges
Reporter: West's Federal Appendix
Volume: 671
Pages: 824–825

Head Matter:
UNITED STATES SUGAR CORPORATION, Petitioner v. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, Respondent American Chemistry Council, et al., Intervenors American Chemistry Council, Petitioner v. Environmental Protection Agency, Respondent American Forest & Paper Association, et al., Intervenors
No. 11-1108
Consolidated with 11-1124, 11-1134, 11-1142, 11-1145, 11-1159, 11-1165, 11-1172, 11-1174, 11-1181, 13-1086, 13-1087, 13-1091, 13-1092, 13-1096, 13-1097, 13-1098, 13-1099, 13-1100, 13-1103
No. 11-1141
Consolidated with 11-1182, 11-1207, 11-1208, 13-1105, 13-1107
September Term, 2016
United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit.
Filed On: December 23, 2016
EPA-76FR15608, EPA-78FR7138, EPA-76FR15554, EPA-78FR7488
Timothy S. Bishop,. Chad Matthew damage, Mayer Brown LLP, Chicago, IL, for Petitioner (Case No. 11-1108).
Norman Louis Rave, Jr., Perry M. Ro-sen, John Charles Cruden, Assistant Attorney General, Sam Hirsch, U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), Environment and Natural Resources Division, Madeline Paradise Fleisher, Hogan Lovells US LLP, Washington, DC, for Respondent (Case No. 11-1108).
David M. Friedland, Beveridge & Diamond, P.C., Claudia M. O’Brien, Stacey Lynn VanBelleghem, Latham & Watkins LLP, William L, Wehrum, Jr., Charles Howland Knauss, Esquire, Lauren Elizabeth Freeman, Makram B. Jaber, Hunton & Williams LLP, Jeffrey A. Knight, Peter H. Wyckoff, Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP, Harry Moy Ng, John P. Wagner, Senior Attorney, American Petroleum Institute, Lisa Marie Jaeger, Bracewell LLP, James Samuel Pew, Neil Gormley, Attorney, Earthjustice, Quentin Riegel, Deputy General Counsel, National Association of Manufacturers, Washington, DC, William F. Lane, Esquire, Alan Holmes McConnell, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Raleigh, NC, Allen A. Kacenjar, Jr., Esquire, Douglas A. McWilliams, Esquire, Squire Patton Boggs (US) LLP, Cleveland, OH, Shannon S. Broome, Esquire, Attorney, Hunton <& Williams LLP, Hunton & Williams LLP, San Francisco, CA, Ronald A. Shipley Law Office of Ronald A. Shipley, Damascus, MD, Larry Benton Alexander, Esquire, Jones, Foster, Johnston, & Stubbs, P.A., West Plam Beach, FL, Carol F. McCabe, Esquire, Michael Dillon, Attorney, Suzanne llene Schiller, Esquire, Manko, Gold, Katcher & Fox, LLP, Bala Cynwyd, PA, for Interve-nors for Respondent (Case No. 11-1108).
David M. Friedland, Beveridge & Diamond, P.C., Leslie A. Hulse, American Chemistry Council, Washington, DC, for Petitioner (Case No. 11-1141).
Madeline Paradise Fleisher, Hogan Lo-vells US LLP, Norman Louis Rave, Jr., Perry M. Rosen, U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), Environment and Natural Resources Division, Washington, DC, for Respondent (Case No. 11-1141).
William L. Wehrum, Jr., Hunton & Williams LLP, Neil Gormley, Attorney, James Samuel Pew, Earthjustice, Pamela A. Lacey, American Gas Association, William Pedersen, Nidhi J. Thakar, Esquire, Perkins Coie LLP, Jeffrey A. Knight, Peter H. Wyckoff,- Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP, Harry Moy Ng, John P, Wagner, Senior Attorney, American Petroleum Institute, Robin S. Conrad, Esquire, Partner, Dentons US LLP, Quentin Rie-gel, Deputy General Counsel, National Association of Manufacturers, Lisa Marie Jaeger, Bracewell LLP, James Watson Conrad, Jr., Conrad Law & Policy Counsel, Washington, DC, William F. Lane, Esquire, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Raleigh, NC, for Intervenors for Respondent, Movant-Intervenor (Case No. 11-1141).
BEFORE: Henderson, Brown, and Griffith, Circuit. Judges

Opinion:
ORDER
Per Curiam
Upon consideration of the petitions for panel rehearing filed on September 12, 2016 by Louisiana Environmental Action Network, Sierra Club, Clean Air Council, Partnership for Policy Integrity, and Environmental Integrity Project in Nos. 11-1108, et al. and 11-1141, et ah; by American Municipal Power, Inc. in No. 11-1108, et al.; and by EPA in No. 11-1108, et al. as to remedy, and the responses to EPA's petition, it is
ORDERED that the petition filed by EPA be granted to the extent that the numeric MACT standards set in the Major Boilers Rule for new and existing sources in each of the eighteen subcategories be remanded without vacatur for the agency to conduct further proceedings consistent with the court's prior opinion, in accordance with the opinion issued herein this date. It is
FURTHER ORDERED that the remaining petitions be denied.
The Clerk is directed to enter a new judgment. The Clerk is further directed to issue the mandate'forthwith.