Case Name: PEOPLE ex rel. AMATO v. ROMAN CATHOLIC HOUSE OF GOOD SHEPHERD
Court: New York Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1899-11
Citations: 14 N.Y. Crim. 304
Docket Number: 
Parties: PEOPLE ex rel. AMATO v. ROMAN CATHOLIC HOUSE OF GOOD SHEPHERD.
Judges: 
Reporter: New York Criminal Reports
Volume: 14
Pages: 304–305

Head Matter:
Supreme Court—Special Term—New York County.
November, 1899.
PEOPLE ex rel. AMATO v. ROMAN CATHOLIC HOUSE OF GOOD SHEPHERD.
Criminal law—Commitment.
Where the commitment is made under chapter 353 of 1886, no notice to parents is required.
Writ of habeas corpus.
Charles A. Watson, for relator.
De Lancey Nicoll (Cornelius J. Sullivan, of counsel), for respondent.

Opinion:
GIEGERICH, J.
The contention that the commitment was-invalid, because not made on notice to the father of the relator, is found to be without force. The commitment was made-under chapter 353 of the Laws of 1886, and, under that statute, no notice to parents was required. The provisions of section 291 of the Penal Code relating to the commitment of children, on notice to either parent, guardian or custodian, cannot be read into the statute in question, since the two enactments are not found to be in pari materia. Under the law of 1886-the commitment of females over a definite age only is provided for, not the commitment of children generally, as under the Penal Code, and the places of detention, within the discretion of the magistrate, are of a different nature under these different statutes. It is well to be inferred that the legislature consid ered. notice to the parents expedient in the cases covered generally by this section of the Penal Code, while deeming such notice unnecessary to a proper commitment under the special law, and I conclude, therefore, that the commitment as made was valid. There is nothing in the papers to disclose the fact that the relator is a married woman, if such is the fact, and I must determine the matter upon the record before me.
Writ dismissed and relator remanded.