Case Name: GOLDEN v. McCABE
Court: Michigan Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Michigan
Decision Date: 1899-11-07
Citations: 121 Mich. 666
Docket Number: 
Parties: GOLDEN v. McCABE.1
Judges: 
Reporter: Michigan Reports
Volume: 121
Pages: 666–667

Head Matter:
GOLDEN v. McCABE.1
Lou Liens — Statement oe Amount Due — Excessive Claim.
Log liens are subject to be defeated by an intentional overstatement, in the statement of lien filed, of the amount claimed to be due.
Error to Baraga; Haire, J., presiding.
Submitted October 25, 1899.
Decided November 7, 1899.
Proceedings under the log-lien law , by John Golden against Michael J. McCabe. Joseph W. Fordney and Aaron T. Bliss intervened as owners of the logs. From a judgment for plaintiff, on verdict directed by the court, against defendant McCabe, but denying a lien upon the logs, plaintiff brings error.
Affirmed.
Button & Culver, for appellant.
Chadboúrne & Bees, for appellees Fordney and Bliss.

Opinion:
Per Curiam.
We are of the opinion that this case is ruled by Gibbs v. Hanchette, 90 Mich. 657. See, also, Estlow v. Hanna, 75 Mich. 219; Auditor General v. Prescott, 94 Mich. 190; Auditor General v. Chandler, 108 Mich. 571; Auditor General v. Hutchinson, 113 Mich. 249; Pioneer Iron Co. v. City of Negaunee, 116 Mich. 435.
The judgment is affirmed.