Case Name: The Cripple Creek Mining Company v. Esteb
Court: Colorado Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Colorado
Decision Date: 1906-04
Citations: 37 Colo. 431
Docket Number: No. 4768
Parties: The Cripple Creek Mining Company v. Esteb.
Judges: 
Reporter: Colorado Reports
Volume: 37
Pages: 431–431

Head Matter:
[No. 4768.]
The Cripple Creek Mining Company v. Esteb.
Former Opinion Followed.
The judgment in this case is affirmed in accordance with the opinion in Cripple Cseek Mining Co. v. Brahant, ante, p. 4&3.
Appeal from the District Court of Teller County.
Hon. Louis W. Cunningham, Judge.
Action by Paul Esteb against Tbe Cripple Creek Mining Company. From a judgment for plaintiff-, defendant appeals.
Affirmed.
JVCessrs. Wolcott, Vaile & Waterman and Mr. H. H. Dunham (Mr. Wm. W. Field, of counsel), for appellant.
Messrs. Stimson & Smith and Mr. James J. Mc-Feely, for appellee.

Opinion:
Mr. Justice Campbell
delivered tbe opinion of tbe court:
Tbis action for tbe recovery of damages for personal injuries caused by defendant's negligence was submitted to tbe same jury that tried tbe case of Cripple Creek M. Co. v. Brabant, ante, page 423. Tbe plaintiff's injury was inflicted at tbe same time, tbe issues in tbe two actions were substantially tbe same, and tbe evidence identical. Tbe same questions of fact and law are involved in tbe two cases. Tbe ruling there is controlling here, and accordingly tbe judgment in tbis case is affirmed. Affirmed.
Chief Justice Gabbert and Mr. Justice Steele concur.