Case Name: Boyer, appellant, v. Brown
Court: New York Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1874-06
Citations: 4 Thomp. & Cook 698
Docket Number: 
Parties: Boyer, appellant, v. Brown.
Judges: 
Reporter: Thompson & Cook's Supreme Court Reports
Volume: 4
Pages: 698–698

Head Matter:
Boyer, appellant, v. Brown.
Practice—appeal from order setting aside verdict— O'ase not containing all the evidence— Oosts.
Where a verdict was set aside in the county court on the ground that it was against the evidence, and the case on appeal did not profess to contain the whole evidence; held, that the court could not say that it was not properly granted.
The costs on granting a new trial in such case were in the discretion of the county judge.
Appeal from an order at the Herkimer county court setting aside a verdict as against the evidence. The action was brought in a justice’s court by Hiram Boyer against Boswell D. Brown, to recover for work, labor and services of plaintiff’s team and workmen.
Link & Dennison, for appellant.
Burrows & Palmer, for respondent.

Opinion:
E. Darwin Smith, J.
Order affirmed.