Case Name: Margaret A. McDonald, Respondent, v. People's Gas and Electric Company of Oswego, Appellant; Helen Quigley, Respondent, v. People's Gas and Electric Company of Oswego, Appellant; Elizabeth McDonald, Respondent, v. People's Gas and Electric Company of Oswego, Appellant; Grace McDonald, Respondent, v. People's Gas and Electric Company of Oswego, Appellant
Court: New York Court of Appeals
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1928-11-20
Citations: 249 N.Y. 584
Docket Number: 
Parties: Margaret A. McDonald, Respondent, v. People’s Gas and Electric Company of Oswego, Appellant. Helen Quigley, Respondent, v. People’s Gas and Electric Company of Oswego, Appellant. Elizabeth McDonald, Respondent, v. People’s Gas and Electric Company of Oswego, Appellant. Grace McDonald, Respondent, v. People’s Gas and Electric Company of Oswego, Appellant.
Judges: 
Reporter: New York Reports
Volume: 249
Pages: 584–584

Head Matter:
Margaret A. McDonald, Respondent, v. People’s Gas and Electric Company of Oswego, Appellant. Helen Quigley, Respondent, v. People’s Gas and Electric Company of Oswego, Appellant. Elizabeth McDonald, Respondent, v. People’s Gas and Electric Company of Oswego, Appellant. Grace McDonald, Respondent, v. People’s Gas and Electric Company of Oswego, Appellant.
(Argued October 19, 1928;
decided November 20, 1928.)
Edwin J. Misen and Francis E. Cullen for appellant.
Francis’ D. Culkin, Avery S. Wright and Leonard H. Amdursky for respondents.

Opinion:
no opinion.
Concur: Pound, Crane, Kellogg and O'Brien, JJ. Dissent: Cardozo, Ch. J., Andrews and Lehman, JJ.