Case Name: FRANKLIN D. GREEN, Plaintiff v. DR. JOHN MOOREHEAD and JOHN DOE, Defendants
Court: District Court of the Virgin Islands
Jurisdiction: Virgin Islands
Decision Date: 1984-02-22
Citations: 20 V.I. 534
Docket Number: Civil No. 83-221
Parties: FRANKLIN D. GREEN, Plaintiff v. DR. JOHN MOOREHEAD and JOHN DOE, Defendants
Judges: 
Reporter: Virgin Islands Reports
Volume: 20
Pages: 534–535

Head Matter:
FRANKLIN D. GREEN, Plaintiff v. DR. JOHN MOOREHEAD and JOHN DOE, Defendants
Civil No. 83-221
District Court of the Virgin Islands Div. of St. Thomas and St. John
February 22, 1984
John J. Mahon, Esq., St. Thomas, V.Ifor plaintiff
Patricia D. Steele, Esq., Christiansted, St. Croix, V.I.,/or defendant Dr. John Moorehead

Opinion:
CHRISTIAN, Chief Judge
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER
This medical malpractice action is before the Court on motion of defendant John Moorehead for dismissal on the ground that plaintiff failed to file his proposed complaint with the Medical Malpractice Action Review Committee prior to initiating this lawsuit. 27 V.I.C. § 166i(b) (Supp. 1982). In support of his motion, defendant presents the affidavit of Roy L. Schneider, Commissioner of Health. Dr. Schneider avers that he is "the keeper of the records" of the Medical Malpractice Action Review Committee and that "no Proposed Complaint was received by this Committee for the case of Green vs. Dr. Moorehead and John Doe, Civil No. 221-1983."
Plaintiff counters with the affidavit of John J. Mahon, counsel for plaintiff. Attorney Mahon asserts that he prepared a medical mal practice complaint for plaintiff and mailed same to Dr. Schneider via certified mail on April 14, 1983. Appended to the affidavit as Exhibits A, B, and C, respectively, are copies of the Complaint, a Receipt for Certified Mail dated April 14, 1983, and, a Return Receipt addressed to Attorney Mahon indicating that article P340 559 461, addressed to Dr. Roy L. Schneider, St. Thomas Hospital, St. Thomas, Virgin Islands, was received by the addressee on April 15, 1983. (The signature on the receipt does not appear to be that of Dr. Schneider.)
Title 27, § 166i(c) of the Virgin Islands Code provides, in pertinent part, that "[t]he proposed complaint shall be deemed filed [with the Committee] when a copy of the proposed complaint is delivered or mailed by registered or certified mail to the Commissioner of Health . . . ." 27 V.I.C. § 166i(c) (Supp. 1982). As the uncontested affidavit of Attorney Mahon establishes, for present purposes, that a copy of the complaint was sent to the Commissioner of Health via certified mail, the Commissioner's failure to receive the complaint is immaterial. Under the statute, filing occurred when the complaint was posted even if the intended recipient never received the complaint.
ORDER
The premises considered and the Court being fully advised,
IT IS ORDERED that the motion of defendant John Moorehead for dismissal of this action be, and the same is, hereby DENIED.