Case Name: PITMAN et al. v. The PARAGUAY
Court: United States District Court for the Southern District of New York
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1853
Citations: 19 F. Cas. 744
Docket Number: 
Parties: PITMAN et al. v. The PARAGUAY.
Judges: Before BETTS, District Judge.
Reporter: Federal Cases
Volume: 19
Pages: 744–745

Head Matter:
Case No. 11,187.
PITMAN et al. v. The PARAGUAY.
[N. Y. Times, Nov. 12, 1853.]
District Court, S. D. New York.
1853.
Mauitime Liens — Undek State Laws — Cabin Furniture.
[Labor and supplies to burnish a passenger steamer’s cabin give rise to a lien under the New York statute.]
[This was a libel by George P. Pitman and George S. Humphrey against the steamship Paraguay for labor and materials.]
F. C. Bliss, for libellants.
C. A. May, for defendants.
Before BETTS, District Judge.

Opinion:
The libellants, residing in this city, claim to recover in this action the sum of $236.30, for mattresses, curtains, sofas, table covers, and other upholstery furnished the ship, and for labor done in fitting up her cabin furniture, as being a lien upon the ship, under the lien law of this state. The answer denies all knowledge of the furnishing, and alleges that the charges are extortionate and that the goods furnished were not necessary to the steamer to enable her to perform her intended voyage. The vessel was fitting out for a voyage to South America, with passengers.
writ,t> BY THE COURT, that it is a fair •and. reasonable interpretation of the lien law, to understand it as giving protection to credits for the accommodations and even luxuries usually furnished to steam vessels in the present day, equally with those having relation to merely repairing and rigging a ship so as to render her navigable, and that cabin furniture •supplied to a steamship, intended to be engaged in transporting passengers, comes with-' in the class of privileged claims, without an allegation in the pleadings that they went into the construction of the ship or were attached permanently to her.
Decree for libellants accordingly, with a ref-erence.