Case Name: The State, ex rel. Lee, v. Ferguson, Auditor of State, et al.
Court: Supreme Court of Ohio
Jurisdiction: Ohio
Decision Date: 1975-12-17
Citations: 44 Ohio St. 2d 159
Docket Number: No. 74-932
Parties: The State, ex rel. Lee, v. Ferguson, Auditor of State, et al.
Judges: O’Neill, C. J., Herbert, Corrigan, Stern, Celebeezze, W. Brown and P. Brown, JJ., concur.
Reporter: Ohio State Reports, Second Series
Volume: 44
Pages: 159–162

Head Matter:
The State, ex rel. Lee, v. Ferguson, Auditor of State, et al.
(No. 74-932
Decided December 17, 1975.)
Messrs. Lucas, Prendergast, Albright, Gibson, Brown é Newman, and Mr. John A. Brown, for relator.
Mr. William J. Brown, attorney general, and Mr. Thomas V. Martin, for respondents.

Opinion:
Per Curiam.
In State, ex rel. Fry, v. Ferguson (1973), 34 Ohio St. 2d 252, 298 N. E. 2d 129, the court allowed writs of mandamus compelling respondents therein, including t'he Auditor and Treasurer of State, to pay classified state employees at the rates of pay provided in S. B. No. 147. It was the court's view, at page 256, in that ease "that the federal law regulating the pay of state employees does not supersede the state statute."
After the decision in Fry, supra, the United States, in October 1973, obtained in the Temporary Emergency Oonrt of Appeals an injunction restraining the state of Ohio from violating the Economic Stablization Act of 1970, as amended, and from paying the salary increases provided for in the pay bill. United States v. Ohio (1973), 487 F. 2d 936. The judgment of the Temporary Emergency Court of Appeals was affirmed in May 1975, Fry v. United States (1975), U. S. , 44 L. Ed. 2d 363, which was after the Economic Stabilization Act had expired on April 30, 1974.
Eelator cites United States v. California (1974), 504 F. 2d 750. In that case the United States sought to enjoin the state of California from implementing a state employee pay increase which the Supreme Court of California had directed state officials to pay on April 19, 1974, the decision becoming final on May 19, 1974. The action was filed by the United States on May 8, 1974, which was after expiration of the Economic Stabilization Act.
Section 218 of the Economic Stabilization Act (Section 1904 note, Title 12, U. S. Code) provided that the authority to enforce orders and regulations under the act expired on April 30, 1974, but that such expiration should not ' ' affect any action or pending proceedings not finally determined on such date, nor any action or proceeding based upon any act committed prior to May 1, 1974." Finding "neither of the exceptions to Section 218 applicable," (504 F. 2d, at page 757) the Temporary Emergency Court of Appeals dismissed the government's complaint for lack of jurisdiction.
It is relator's position that the injunction issued by the Temporary Emergency Court of Appeals relative to Ohio's pay increases is no longer effective for the reasons stated in the California case. There is, however, a crucial distinction between the California case and the instant case. The decision of the California court authorizing payment came after expiration of the Economic Stabilization Act, whereas here the government's injunction was obtained while the act was in force. This order was affirmed by the Supreme Court of the United States.
"In order for relator to be entitled to a writ of man-damns he mnst show two things: (1) A clear legal right to the relief prayed for (State, ex rel. Board of Edn., v. Griffin, 161 Ohio St. 537), and (2) a clear legal duty on the respondent to perform the act (State, ex rel. Clink, v. Smith, 16 Ohio St. 2d 1)." State, ex rel. Long, v. Bettman (1970), 24 Ohio St. 2d 16, 17, 262 N. E. 2d 859. See State, ex rel. Pressley, v. Indus. Comm. (1967), 11 Ohio St. 2d 141, 228 N. E. 2d 631. .
Relator here has established neither a clear legal right to the relief prayed for, nor a clear legal dnty on the part of respondent to perform the act.
Therefore, the writ is denied.
Writ denied.
O'Neill, C. J., Herbert, Corrigan, Stern, Celebeezze, W. Brown and P. Brown, JJ., concur.