Case Name: Matter of the Application of Arthur Werther for an Order Directing the Custodians of Primary Records of the County of Kings, City of New York, to Certify and Canvass His Name as Being the Elected Member of the Republican County Committee from the Twenty-eighth Election District of the Twenty-third Assembly District
Court: New York Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1916-04
Citations: 94 Misc. 681
Docket Number: 
Parties: Matter of the Application of Arthur Werther for an Order Directing the Custodians of Primary Records of the County of Kings, City of New York, to Certify and Canvass His Name as Being the Elected Member of the Republican County Committee from the Twenty-eighth Election District of the Twenty-third Assembly District.
Judges: 
Reporter: New York Miscellaneous Reports
Volume: 94
Pages: 681–683

Head Matter:
Matter of the Application of Arthur Werther for an Order Directing the Custodians of Primary Records of the County of Kings, City of New York, to Certify and Canvass His Name as Being the Elected Member of the Republican County Committee from the Twenty-eighth Election District of the Twenty-third Assembly District.
(Supreme Court, Kings Special Term,
April, 1916.)
Election Law — when question of eligibility of candidate may be raised.
Only an enrolled voter is eligible as a candidate for election as a member of a county committee, and the question of eligibility may be raised after the election.
Application under sections 41 and 56 of the Election Law to require custodians of primary records of Kings county to certify and canvass petitioner’s name as member of the Republican county committee.
Samuel Y. Gitlin, for petitioner.
Baruch Miller, for respondent Joseph Allen.
Lamar Hardy, corporation counsel (John B. Shanahan, assistant corporation counsel), for custodians of primary records.

Opinion:
Benedict, J.
This is a proceeding under sections 41 and 56 of the Election Law to require the custodians of primary records of the county of Bangs to certify and canvass the petitioner's name as member of the Republican county committee from the twenty-eighth election district of the twenty-third assembly district of Kings county. The application is opposed by Joseph Allen, who has been recognized and placed on the roll as the elected member of the county committee for said dis trict, despite the fact that both he and the petitioner, who were the only candidates, received the same number of votes, nine each, at the primary election on April 4, 1916, so that the election resulted in a tie.
The contention of the petitioner is that said Joseph Allen was ineligible for the office of member of the county committee because he was not at the time of the election an enrolled voter of the Republican party. It appears from the answering affidavit that said Allen became of age after the last general election, but on what precise date is not disclosed, and that on April 10, 1916, he caused himself to be specially enrolled by filing a declaration as permitted by section 14b of the Election Law. It is also alleged that the committee chosen at the said primary election was convened and organized on April eleventh.
Section 37 of the Election Law, as amended by chapter 820 of the Laws of 1913, provides among other things that 1 ' Each member of a county committee shall be an enrolled voter of the party residing in the assembly district containing the election district in which he is elected. ' ' Mr. Allen was not an enrolled voter at the time of the election, and the question is whether his subsequent enrollment qualifies him to serve. The solution of this question depends upon when the term of the member of a county committee commences. If it commences immediately upon his election, then, in my opinion, the candidate must be eligible for the office at the time of the election. If,, on the other hand, it commences at some later time, I shall assume for the purposes of this proceeding, that a person, although not eligible at the time of the election, may serve if he becomes eligible before his term of office commences. Turning to section 38 of the Election Law, as amended by chapter 820 of the Laws of 1913, which applies to both stale and county committees, we find a provision that " The members of either committee shall hold office until the election of their successors. ' ' From this it would seem necessarily to follow that the term of office of any person elected to a county committee commences at once upon his election, and therefore that, as Allen was ineligible for the office when elected, the votes cast for him were void, and the petitioner is entitled to be declared elected.
I do not find in sections 55a and 125 of the Election Law any provision preventing this objection from being raised now, because not raised prior to the election by the proceedings permitted by said sections.
These conclusions require the granting of the application. It may be observed in passing that, even if Allen had been eligible, he would not have been entitled to be seated as a member of the committee, because there was a tie vote and therefore no election. In such case there is a vacancy to be filled by the remaining members of the committee as provided in sections 37 and 43 of the Election Law.
Motion granted.