Case Name: KILES et v. BRACKNEY
Court: Ohio Court of Appeals
Jurisdiction: Ohio
Decision Date: 1927-10-31
Citations: 5 Ohio Law Abs. 807
Docket Number: No. 387
Parties: KILES et v. BRACKNEY.
Judges: (Hamilton, PJ., and Mills, J., concur.)
Reporter: The Ohio Law Abstract
Volume: 5
Pages: 807–808

Head Matter:
KILES et v. BRACKNEY.
Ohio Appeals, 1st Dist., Butler Co.
No. 387.
Decided Oct. 31, 1927.
Oscar W. Kuhn, Cincinnati, for Kiles, et.
P. P. Boli, Hamilton, for Brackney.

Opinion:
FULL TEXT.
CUSHING, J.
The plaintiffs prosecute an action against the defendant for specific performance of a cuntí act of lease in the property described in the petition, situate in the Village of Oxford, Butler County, Ohio.
The petition recites that they agreed to sell and convey the property to the defendant by general warranty deed. In consideration whereof, the defendant agreed to pay therefor the sum of fifteen hundred dollars,- payable in cash. The petition recites that the plaintiffs have performed the conditions of the contract on their part to be performed, and duly executed and acknowledged a deed of general warranty: that defendant has refused to pay said purchase money, and has refused to accept the deed thus tendered.
The plaintiffs acquired whatever title they have from Mary Jane Kiles, by her will. They were given the property for life, and after their death, to their heirs forever.
From the facts as admitted, Mary Jane Kiles used the word "heirs" in a technical sense, as meaning heirs generally, and there is nothing in the will to show that it meant children. The necessary parties, namely, the heirs spoken of in the will, aie not before the Court, and, as such, they would not be bound by this action in specific performance, as between the parties hereto.
In the absence of the necessary parties, and as there would be a cloud upon the title, the defendant was not bound to accept the property. A decree similar to that entered in the Court below will be entered here.
(Hamilton, PJ., and Mills, J., concur.)