Case Name: The J. W. Dennis
Court: United States District Court for the Northern District of New York
Jurisdiction: United States
Decision Date: 1884-03-28
Citations: 19 F. 799
Docket Number: 
Parties: The J. W. Dennis.
Judges: 
Reporter: Federal Reporter
Volume: 19
Pages: 799–800

Head Matter:
The J. W. Dennis.
(District Court, N. D. New York.
March 28, 1884.)
Retaining oe Vessel by a Ship-Keeper.
A vessel which has been detained by a ship-keeper, pending a controversy, must ho delivered up to her owner immediately upon the settlement, of the suit. The marshal will not be justified in employing a ship-keeper after the suit has been settled, merely because a formal order of discontinuance has not Loen entered.
In Admiralty.
This is a motion in the nature of an appeal from the taxation of the marshal’s bill of costs, by the clerk. The marshal employed a ship-keeper at $2.50 per day to take charge of the libeled vessel. The clerk allowed the bill at $1.75 per day. Various affidavits were submitted by the parties. Some to the effect that the amount was too high; others that it was a very reasonable charge for the work done. It appears from the affidavits that the controversy between the parties has been settled, though no formal order to that effect has been entered. It also appears that since the settlement and the taxation by the clerk as aforesaid the ship-keeper has retained possession of the vessel and has demanded pay for his services.
George N. Loveridge, for motion.
James A. Murray, opposed.

Opinion:
Coxe, J.
I have read with care all of the affidavits and papers submitted in this case and have reached the conclusion that the bill of costs and disbursements as taxed by the clerk, February 28,1884, cannot with propriety be reduced. As the stipulation limits the inquiry to the items of that bill, I express no opinion up.on the question as to the right of the ship-keeper to compensation since that day. There should be no delay, however, if the controversy is settled, in -discontinuing the action and restoring the vessel to her proper owner.