Case Name: William W. Dewhurst, Appellant, v. The City of St. Augustine, Florida, a Body Politic and Corporate, and C. G. Oldfather, Acting as City Auditor of the City of St. Augustine, Appellees
Court: Florida Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Florida
Decision Date: 1926-02-23
Citations: 91 Fla. 314
Docket Number: 
Parties: William W. Dewhurst, Appellant, v. The City of St. Augustine, Florida, a Body Politic and Corporate, and C. G. Oldfather, Acting as City Auditor of the City of St. Augustine, Appellees.
Judges: Whitfield, P. J. and Terrell and Buford, J. J. Concur.
Reporter: Florida Reports
Volume: 91
Pages: 314–315

Head Matter:
William W. Dewhurst, Appellant, v. The City of St. Augustine, Florida, a Body Politic and Corporate, and C. G. Oldfather, Acting as City Auditor of the City of St. Augustine, Appellees.
Division B.
Opinion Filed February 23, 1926.
Petition for rehearing denied March 25, 1926.
Wm, W. Dewhurst, for Appellant;
E. Noble Calhoun, for Appellees.

Opinion:
Per Curiam.
— In a suit praying for the cancellation of tax sale certificates held by the city for unpaid city taxes, upon grounds of alleged illegality in the assessments upon which the tax certificates are predicated, the court on final hearing dismissed the bill of complaint and an appeal was taken by the complainant.
Even if the allegations of illegality of the tax sale certificates held by the city may be regarded as duly sustained by the law and the evidence, yet it is apaprent that the complainant, appellant here, has not paid the taxes that may be legally due upon the property covered by the alleged invalid certificates, and as the complainant has not offered to do, but should do equity before he can invoke the aid of equity for the relief he seeks, it is considered, ordered and decreed that the decree herein be reversed pro forma and the cause remanded with dirctions to permit the parties by stipulation or other proper procedure to determine the amount of taxes that could legally have been assessed against the property and have not been paid, and that upon proof of the payment of such taxes the proper certificates shall be ordered cancelled; and if the taxes are not paid the bill of complaint shall be dismissed. The costs of this appeal will be taxed equally against the appellant and appellee city.
It is so ordered.
Whitfield, P. J. and Terrell and Buford, J. J. Concur.
Brown, C. J. and Ellis, J. Concur in the opinion.