Case Name: Edward J. O'Dell vs. Commissioner of Banks
Court: Massachusetts Appeals Court
Jurisdiction: Massachusetts
Decision Date: 1975-02-24
Citations: 3 Mass. App. Ct. 709
Docket Number: 
Parties: Edward J. O’Dell vs. Commissioner of Banks.
Judges: 
Reporter: Massachusetts Appeals Court Reports
Volume: 3
Pages: 709–709

Head Matter:
Edward J. O’Dell vs. Commissioner of Banks.
February 24, 1975.
Anthony J. DiPerna for the petitioner.
Terence P. O’Malley, Assistant Attorney General, for the Commis- • sioner of Banks.

Opinion:
If we were to assume that the (undescribed) office or position of "Permanent Director of the Division of Credit Union Examinations" (see the fourth sentence of G. L. c. 26, § 3, as most recently amended by St. 1964, c. 269) which the petitioner held from June 8, 1970, until May 11, 1973, is (or was) one falling within the protection afforded by G. L. c. 30, § 9A (as appearing in St. 1947, c. 242), we would be unable to conclude that the petitioner "held such office or position" (Chairman of State Housing Bd. v. Civil Serv. Commn. 332 Mass. 241, 244 [1955]; emphasis original) for the three-year period required by § 9A. He did not do so as matter of fact, nor do we think he did so as matter of law during the earlier period (from June 15, 1969, until June 7, 1970) when he served as "Acting Director of the Division of Credit Union Examinations" and "assumed the responsibilities and discharged the duties of the Director of Bank Examinations in said Division." During that period he had no right to continue to serve as "Acting Director" (compare Fantini v. School Comm. of Cambridge, 362 Mass. 320, 324 [1972]), was subject to removal by the Commissioner (compare Cieri v. Commissioner of Ins. 343 Mass. 181, 184 [1961]), and had no right to be appointed to the position of "Permanent Director" (compare Murphy v. Cambridge, 342 Mass. 339, 340-341 [1961]).
Order for judgment affirmed.