Case Name: CLARENCE O. WILCOX vs. LOUISVILLE & NASHVILLE R. R. COMPANY
Court: Louisiana Court of Appeal
Jurisdiction: Louisiana
Decision Date: 1910-04-20
Citations: 7 Teiss. 370
Docket Number: No. 4963
Parties: CLARENCE O. WILCOX vs. LOUISVILLE & NASHVILLE R. R. COMPANY.
Judges: 
Reporter: Decisions, Court of Appeal, parish of Orleans (Teissier)
Volume: 7
Pages: 370–371

Head Matter:
No. 4963.
(Court of Appeal, Parish of Orleans.)
CLARENCE O. WILCOX vs. LOUISVILLE & NASHVILLE R. R. COMPANY.
P. E. Rainold for plaintiff and appellee.
Denegre & Blair and Chaffe for defendant and appellant.
April 20, 1910.
Rehearing refused May 11, 1910.

Opinion:
ST. PAUL, J.
It was a condition of the ticket purchased by plaintiff, and the sole condition, that he would have it "validated" at a given place within twenty-four hours before he offered it for return passage.
For this purpose plaintiff was required to present the ticket at the proper place and at a reasonable time. If defendant's agent was absent at the time, plaintiff was under no obligation to return.
A reasonable time at which to present a ticket for validation is that at which one may reasonably expect to find the agent at his office; this includes not only the time at which the agent is required to be present, but also that at which he is, in fact, usually present.
The evidence shows that the plaintiff did present his ticket at a time at which the agent was usually present at his office. Owing to circumstances unforeseen he happened not to be present that morning.
Plaintiff was, therefore, within his strict legal rights.
Judgment affirmed.