Case Name: SHAW v. SHAW
Court: Buffalo Superior Court
Jurisdiction: New York
Decision Date: 1893-11
Citations: 26 N.Y.S. 715
Docket Number: 
Parties: SHAW v. SHAW.
Judges: 
Reporter: West's New York Supplement
Volume: 26
Pages: 715–716

Head Matter:
(5 Misc. Rep. 497.)
SHAW v. SHAW.
(Superior Court of Buffalo, Special Term.
November, 1893.)
Divorce—Allowance for Expenses.
Where the answer, in an action for divorce on the ground of adultery, contains a general denial and countercharges of adultery, investigation of which will necessarily involve a long and expensive litigation, plaintiff will be granted an allowance to meet such expenses, though she is not entitled to alimony.
Action for divorce on the ground of adultery. Plaintiff asks for an allowance for counsel fees.
Granted in part.
Whitcher & Sawyer, for plaintiff.
Sprague, Morey, Sprague & Brownell, for defendant.

Opinion:
TITUS, C. J.
This action is brought for a divorce. The plaintiff alleges, on defendant with various persons named in the complaint. The answer of the defendant is a general denial of these charges, and contains countercharges of adultery of the plaintiff with various persons. The plaintiff's reply to these charges is a general denial. All of the pleadings are verified, and the investigation of these charges against both plaintiff and defendant will necessarily involve a long and expensive litigation, requiring the expenditure of considerable money in procuring witnesses and in employing counsel. When the case was before me in an action for a separation between these same parties, I denied the relief then asked for, for what seemed to me good and sufficient reasons found in the evidence, and which it is not necessary to state here. It then appeared that the plaintiff had the house where the parties lived, and for which the defendant had in some measure contributed towards the payment. It does not seem to me now that the plaintiff should have alimony, as she then" was, and, as appears, now is, able to support herself; -but in view of the fact that the plaintiff, in addition to making proof of the charges contained in her complaint, will be obliged to meet and defend herself against countercharges made by her husband, I think she should be allowed a reasonable sum for expenses. An order may be entered requiring the defendant, within 10 days, to pay to the plaintiff or her attorney the' sum of $50 for that purpose. Ordered accordingly.