Case Name: Henry McRoberts et al v. Henry H. Barnard et al.
Court: Lorain Circuit Court
Jurisdiction: Ohio
Decision Date: 1908-04-29
Citations: 32 Ohio C.C. Dec. 697
Docket Number: 
Parties: Henry McRoberts et al v. Henry H. Barnard et al.
Judges: Winch, Henry and Marvin, JJ.
Reporter: Ohio Circuit Court Decisions
Volume: 32
Pages: 697–698

Head Matter:
WILLS
[Lorain (8th) Circuit Court,
April 29, 1908.]
Winch, Henry and Marvin, JJ.
Henry McRoberts et al v. Henry H. Barnard et al.
Widow May Will Property Devised “to Her and to Her Disposal.”
A widow who has received real estate under her husband’s will “to be to her and to her disposal during her life," may dispose of the same by her will.
Error.
Affirmed no opinion, McRoberts v. Barnard, 81 Ohio St 560.

Opinion:
HENRY, J.
The only feature of this case which we deem it necessary to discuss here is the true interpretation of the second item of Pitt McRoberts will, as follows:
"I give and devise all the residue of my estate to Abby my beloved wife, to be to her and to her disposal during her life. ' '
The testator's widow, Abby, undertook to dispose, by will, of the real estate thus devised to her. The validity of this disposition by her obviously can be rested either upon the view that she was invested with the fee therein by the term of her husband's will, or upon the view that her husband's will invested her with the power to make testamentary disposition of the same. The first of these views seems to us to be supported by the case of Davis v. Corwine, 25 Ohio St. 668, and Lesley v. Smith, 7 Circ. Dec. 264 (13 R. 189).
The second view is supported by the Massachusetts ease of Burbank v. Sweeney, 161 Mass. 490 [37 N. E. 669], a well considered ease which we approve.
Judgment "below affirmed.
Winch and Marvin, JJ., concur.