Case Name: J. W. Black, W. A. McLeod and L. A. McDavid, Appellants, v. Skinner Manufacturing Company, a Corporation, Appellee
Court: Florida Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Florida
Decision Date: 1907-01
Citations: 53 Fla. 1088
Docket Number: 
Parties: J. W. Black, W. A. McLeod and L. A. McDavid, Appellants, v. Skinner Manufacturing Company, a Corporation, Appellee.
Judges: Shackleford, C. J., and Cockrell, J., concur;
Reporter: Florida Reports
Volume: 53
Pages: 1088–1089

Head Matter:
J. W. Black, W. A. McLeod and L. A. McDavid, Appellants, v. Skinner Manufacturing Company, a Corporation, Appellee.
The principles controlling the disposition of this cause are stated in the case of J. W. Black,*W. A. McLeod and D. T. Williams y. The Skinner Manufacturing Co., decided this day.
This case was decided by Division A.
Appeal from the Circuit Court for Santa Rosa County.
The facts in the case are stated in the opinion of the court.
Avery & Avery and Darnel Campbell & Son, for Appellants.
T. F. West and Btomvt & Blount, for Appellee.

Opinion:
Whitfield, J.:
This appeal is from a decree of the circuit court for Santa Rosa county adjudging certain deeds of conveyance executed by J. W. Black, one of the appellants, to W. A. McLeod, another appellant, and by W. A. McLeod to the appellant, L. A. McDavid, in so far as they purport to convey all of fractional section one, township three north, range thirty-one west, land situated in Santa Rosa county, Florida, to be invalid as against the appellee and clouds upon its title to said land, and declaring the appellee's title to be valid and subsisting as against the appellants, and ordering said deeds to be canceled of record in so far as they affect said land. The appellee claims title by a deed of conveyance of May 8, 1879, from J. W. Black, one of the appel lants, to D. F. Sullivan, and by mesne conveyances to itself. The appellant, L. A. McDavid, claims title by deed of August 19, 1902, from the appellant, J. W. Black, to the appellant, W. A.'McLeod, and by deed from W. A. McLeod to the appellant, L. A. McDavid.
In the case of J. W. Black, W. A. McLeod and D. T. Williams, appellants, v. Skinner Manufacturing Company, appellee, this day filed, the court held that the deed of May 8, 1879, from J. W. Black to D. F. Sullivan conveyed all the land therein described, and the land in controversy in this cause was included in that deed; therefore J. W. Black had no title to convey to W. A. McLeod in 1902. The deed of May 8, 1879, from J. W. Black to D. F. Sullivan was not. recorded in Santa Rosa county, but it was held in the case above referred to that in the deed of August 19, 1902, from J. W. Black to W. A. McLeod in trust, which also includes the land in question here, the latter was not a purchaser for a valuable consideration, therefore the failure to record the deed of May 8, 1879, from J. W. Black tO' D. F. Sullivan did not make the deed of August 19th, 1902, from J. W- Black to W. A. McLeod, effectual. The deed from W. A. McLeod,, trustee, to L. A. McDavid was a quit claim deed and conveyed no better title than McLeod received from Black. The result is that as against the appellee the appellants have no title and no- error appears in the decree.
Let the decree be affirmed.
Shackleford, C. J., and Cockrell, J., concur;
Taylor, Hocker and Parkhill, JJ., concur in the opinion.