Case Name: Jose Sanchez vs. Massachusetts Property Insurance Underwriting Association
Court: Massachusetts Appellate Division
Jurisdiction: Massachusetts
Decision Date: 1990-12-18
Citations: 1990 Mass. App. Div. 214
Docket Number: 
Parties: Jose Sanchez vs. Massachusetts Property Insurance Underwriting Association
Judges: Present; Pino, Donovan & Kelly, JJ.
Reporter: Reports of Massachusetts Appellate Division (Annual)
Volume: 1990
Pages: 214–215

Head Matter:
Jose Sanchez vs. Massachusetts Property Insurance Underwriting Association
Municipal Court
December 18, 1990.
Present; Pino, Donovan & Kelly, JJ.
Raymond E. Gillespie for the plaintiff.
David J. Buczkowski for the defendant

Opinion:
Pino, J.
This report is based solely on the appellant's assertion that the judge's findings were clearly erroneous and against the weight of the evidence. Each of the Requests for Rulings of Law upon which the appellant relies are, in reality, questions of fact. The trial judge indicated such in his responses to #6, #8 & #9 and, in addition, stated in response to number 6 "I find that the defendant did not breach its contract with the plaintiff by denying plaintiffs claim on the ground of repeated or constant seepage..." Requests #11 & #12 are clearly questions of fact
The appellant's brief does not contain a single case citation.
A recitation of the facts as reported would serve no purpose other than to show with great weight and clarity that the findings of the court were neither clearly erroneous nor against the weight of the evidence. New England Canteen Service, Inc. v. Ashley, 372 Mass. 671 (1977).
Report dismissed.