Case Name: Paul H. STRINGER and Timothy D. Schubert, Petitioners on Review/Petitioners on Reconsideration, v. CAR DATA SYSTEMS, INC., an Oregon corporation; Consumer Data Systems, Inc., an Oregon corporation; James L. Adkisson; David W. Agnor; Sharon Agnor; James L. Agnor; Arlene L. Belanger; Peter G. Bock; Susan D. Ebner; Mark S. Boyd; Jeffrey Scott Carlson; Lawrence R. Custer; Stephen J. Ebner; William A. Henry; John H. Hodges, Sr.; Bernal Hug, Jr.; Virginia Hug; Celas A. Hug; Kent Hug; Cheryl Hug; Paul E. Johnson; Corleen Johnson; Mark Anthony Royal Kallenberger; David E. Lamb; Jacqueline C. Lamb; Steven D. Lee; Claudia J. Lee; Leslie R. Lock; Terry R. Lock; Steve P. Nagel; Henry B. Shafer; Bob Sievers, Jr.; Judy A. Sievers; Donald Smith; Richard M. Botteri and Weiss, Descamp & Botteri, a professional corporation, an Oregon professional corporation, Respondents on Review/Respondents on Reconsideration, and Elizabeth A. PERRY and James B. Kargman, Nominal Defendants
Court: Oregon Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Oregon
Decision Date: 1993-01-28
Citations: 315 Or. 308
Docket Number: CC A8907-04022; CA A65113; SC S38792
Parties: Paul H. STRINGER and Timothy D. Schubert, Petitioners on Review/Petitioners on Reconsideration, v. CAR DATA SYSTEMS, INC., an Oregon corporation; Consumer Data Systems, Inc., an Oregon corporation; James L. Adkisson; David W. Agnor; Sharon Agnor; James L. Agnor; Arlene L. Belanger; Peter G. Bock; Susan D. Ebner; Mark S. Boyd; Jeffrey Scott Carlson; Lawrence R. Custer; Stephen J. Ebner; William A. Henry; John H. Hodges, Sr.; Bernal Hug, Jr.; Virginia Hug; Celas A. Hug; Kent Hug; Cheryl Hug; Paul E. Johnson; Corleen Johnson; Mark Anthony Royal Kallenberger; David E. Lamb; Jacqueline C. Lamb; Steven D. Lee; Claudia J. Lee; Leslie R. Lock; Terry R. Lock; Steve P. Nagel; Henry B. Shafer; Bob Sievers, Jr.; Judy A. Sievers; Donald Smith; Richard M. Botteri and Weiss, Descamp & Botteri, a professional corporation, an Oregon professional corporation, Respondents on Review/Respondents on Reconsideration, and Elizabeth A. PERRY and James B. Kargman, Nominal Defendants.
Judges: UNIS, J., dissented and filed an opinion in which Fadeley, J., joined.
Reporter: Oregon Reports
Volume: 315
Pages: 308–310

Head Matter:
On petition for reconsideration filed December 10, 1992,
petition for reconsideration denied January 28, 1993
Paul H. STRINGER and Timothy D. Schubert, Petitioners on Review/Petitioners on Reconsideration, v. CAR DATA SYSTEMS, INC., an Oregon corporation; Consumer Data Systems, Inc., an Oregon corporation; James L. Adkisson; David W. Agnor; Sharon Agnor; James L. Agnor; Arlene L. Belanger; Peter G. Bock; Susan D. Ebner; Mark S. Boyd; Jeffrey Scott Carlson; Lawrence R. Custer; Stephen J. Ebner; William A. Henry; John H. Hodges, Sr.; Bernal Hug, Jr.; Virginia Hug; Celas A. Hug; Kent Hug; Cheryl Hug; Paul E. Johnson; Corleen Johnson; Mark Anthony Royal Kallenberger; David E. Lamb; Jacqueline C. Lamb; Steven D. Lee; Claudia J. Lee; Leslie R. Lock; Terry R. Lock; Steve P. Nagel; Henry B. Shafer; Bob Sievers, Jr.; Judy A. Sievers; Donald Smith; Richard M. Botteri and Weiss, Descamp & Botteri, a professional corporation, an Oregon professional corporation, Respondents on Review/Respondents on Reconsideration, and Elizabeth A. PERRY and James B. Kargman, Nominal Defendants.
(CC [ AXXXX-XXXXX ]; CA A65113; SC S38792)
844 P2d 905
Robert J. McGaughey, of McGaughey & Georgeoff, Portland, filed the petition for petitioners on reconsideration.
No appearance contra.
UNIS, J., dissented and filed an opinion in which Fadeley, J., joined.
Appeal from Multnomah County Circuit Court, Lee Johnson, Judge. 108 Or App 523, 816 P2d 677 (1992), modified on reconsideration, 110 Or App 14, 821 P2d 418 (1991); affd, 314 Or 576, 841 P2d 1183 (1992).

Opinion:
UNIS, J.,
dissenting.
I would allow the petition for reconsideration. I wish to call attention to Note, Exclusivity of Appraisal — The Possibility of Extinguishing Shareholder Claims, 42 Case W Res L Rev 955 (1992), which was not published when my separate opinion in Stringer v. Car Data Systems, Inc., 314 Or 576, 591, 841 P2d 1183 (1992) (Unis, J., concurring in part, dissenting in part, with Fadeley, J., joining), was issued.
Fadeley, J., joins in this dissent.