Case Name: STATE v. Alcee BENOIT, John Miller, Clobule Arabie
Court: Louisiana Supreme Court
Jurisdiction: Louisiana
Decision Date: 1923-11-12
Citations: 158 La. 242
Docket Number: No. 25166
Parties: STATE v. Alcee BENOIT, John Miller, Clobule Arabie.
Judges: By Division A, composed of O’NIELL, C. J., and ROGERS and BRUNOT, JJ.
Reporter: Louisiana Reports
Volume: 158
Pages: 241–243

Head Matter:
(103 So. 754)
No. 25166.
STATE v. Alcee BENOIT, John Miller, Clobule Arabie.
(Nov. 12, 1923.
On Rehearing, May 14, 1924.)
Appeal from Fifteenth Judicial District Court, Parish of Jefferson Davis; Thos. F. Porter, Jr., Judge.
Rehearing by the WHOLE COURT; O’NIELL, C. J., and ROGERS and BRUNOT, JJ., dissenting.
Thomas Arthur Edwards, of Lake Charles, for appellants.
A. Y. Coco, Atty. Gen., Griffin T. Hawkins, Jr., Dist. Atty., of Lake Charles, and John J. Robira, Asst. Dist. Atty., of Jennings (A. J. Bordelon, of Marksville, and T. S. Walmsley, of New Orleans, of counsel), for the State.
By Division A, composed of O’NIELL, C. J., and ROGERS and BRUNOT, JJ.

Opinion:
O'NIELL, C. J.
Each of the appellants was convicted of manufacturing intoxicating liquor for beverage purposes. Alcee Benoit was sentenced to pay a fine of $500 and costs, and to be imprisoned 60 days, and, in default of payment of the fine, to be imprisoned 9 months longer. Each of the two other defendants was sentenced to pay a fine of $500 and costs, and to be imprisoned 60 days, and, in default of payment of the fine, to be imprisoned 6 months longer.
Every issue in each of the three cases was decided to-day in State v. Doras- Hebert (No. 26165) 103 So. 742.1 Eor the reasons given in that case, the verdict in each of these cases must be affirmed. But the sentence is excessive. When the judge sentenced each defendant to pay a fine of $500 and costs and to be imprisoned 60 days, he imposed the maximum penalty under the statute that was violated. Act 39 of Ex. Sess. 1921, p. 42.
The verdict in each case is affirmed; the sentence of each defendant to pay a fine of $500 and costs and to bo imprisoned 60 days is affirmed; the additional sentence of imprisonment of Alcee Benoit for 9 months and of each of the two other defendants for 6 months is annulled.