The Osmond Brothers. (Trivia! This is the song that Alanis sang on Star Search..and lost). I can tell you've been hurt. By that look on your face boy. Some girl brought sad into your happy world. You need love but you're afraid that if you give in. Someone else will come along. And sock it to ya again. Chorus:. One bad apple don't spoil the whole bunch boy. Give it one more try before you give up on love. One bad apple don't spoil the whole bunch boy. I don't care what they say. I don't care what you heard. I could make you happy baby. Satisfy you too. But how can I if you won't give me a chance. To prove my love to you?. Won't you give me just one chance?. I'll give you my guarantee that you won't be hurt again. Repeat chorus. I've been noticing you baby. For a long long time. And I'm not ashamed to tell the world. That you really messed up my mind. Boy to me you're like a dream come true. I'd rather hurt myself than to ever hurt you. Repeat chorus.