There's nothing WRONG with them. Not really. I'm 190lbs, a size 16-18, and they are big on my calves. They fall slightly down my legs. I have the laces tied as tight as possible. The sole and heel are plastic-y. Whoever said they are sized small must be lying about their actual size. I'm a big 10 (ordered a 10) and can easily wear thick socks. They are cute and seem good for a high heel winter boot. Price was OK. I'm happy?