TOMS sizing is quite inconsistent. This is my fourth pair of TOMS. This is only the second pair of regular canvas TOMS. One pair was sequined, the other way one of the limited edition kinds that is made of a different fabric (not sure which fabric it was). Depending on which fabric they're made from seems to determine how they fit. These canvas ones are very narrow across the top of my foot, rubbing and pinching. I order a 9.5 at first, but they were pinchy, so I ordered a 10. The 10 is better, but still tight across the top of my fit... but not also a bit long. My first pair were the most comfortable shoes I owned for a while, but these new ones I just got are some of the most uncomfortable. When they fit right, they feel so nice. When they fit poorly, it's really bad. It's hit or miss with these.