These do what I needed: Keep my feet dry when it rains like crazy. However, they don't seem very durable. The fourth time I tried to put them on using the loop, it ripped off. Now, they fit snug, so you really need the loop (or a shoe horn) to get them on (think rubber socks). They're much more snug than rubber boots would be.<br /><br />Other than that, they seem fine. Just not sure how I'm going to get the one without the loop on now.