These boots hold up fairly well and the clean and polish up great.  The fit seems decent but I have noticed they rub slightly odd on the tops of my foot.  On my drive home I find I loosen the boots up because of this.  The other complaint I have is there is a little metal piece in the arch underneath the insole.  The insole is the only thing keeping this in place and the insole does not hold up at all.  So on both pairs (brown and black) that I have of these I've had to replace the insoles and have lost the metal arch support.