First, the positives: I love the color and the heel is just the right height. However, these boots are are way too big around the calf. They were too big for me to begin with, but then the stretchy panels quickly stretched out and started drooping. After only a few weeks of wear, these boots started looking really ridiculous. They fit around my calves like rain boots: very wide and frumpy. The only way I can maybe pull them off now is with leg warmers or thick socks so that they don't droop around. Also, the boots get scuffed really easily, so if you ever walk around in them, the &#34;leather&#34; gets torn up pretty quickly. When I first got the boots, I was walking up some outdoor stairs and I barely grazed one of the steps...it made a noticeable, white scratch in the toe. I was pretty sad.