These fit perfectly fine. My reason for returning them however was that they look cute in the photo (Turquoise) but very geriatric in person. Maybe because I'm a size 7 it looks odd - the straps are very wide and closer together than I expected. I think if the straps were half as thick and this had an ankle strap it would be perfect - and something like that probably exists so I just need to keep shopping. I do love Vionic and have purchased (and kept) 3 pairs that I wear regularly (sneakers, flat sandals, and wedges). If you aren't as worried about the look as I was then this isn't a bad pair to have.