The shoes are too small. I could not get my foot in it. So as to a rating I cannot give one. I would like to return them but was not given a return ticket. The shoe would be alright if it did not have the material sewn on it. Elastic should be on the opening so it could give when putting it on. I would have been able to at least try it on. It looks like it would have fitted if I was able to put my foot in the opening.