I wanted a waterproof boot and I liked these because they weren't too expensive but it made me wonder how waterproof they really are. I live in Alaska and have used them to go out fishing and while the tide comes in, my feet have been fully submerged. Not wet socks yet so I give them 5 stars. I might rub some extra waterproofing stuff just in case but I'm really happy with them so far. I like how they look under some good hiking pants too. It's all about the look -- right girls?? Gotta fish in style!