These shoes would be almost perfect if the quality control were there.  Received first pair and tried on and very pleased with the fit.  However, once I starter walking there was a very loud &#34;thwuck&#34; every time I stepped on the right foot because the glue on the insole was faulty.  Amazon replaced the first pair, and when the second pair arrived, both boots had a defective insole.  Will return the second pair as well as I just returned from a trip that I needed steel toed boots for and I had to make do with my Walmart specials that I dislike, but they beat these with respect to quality control (and they have some problems).<br /><br />All in all, seemed to be the perfect boot for my needs but the Wolverine factory & quality control is not up to snuff. Three boots out of four had the problem and you did not need to put the boot on to find it.