I own the black pair of these in an 8.5 that I purchased elsewhere.  They fit great & are my favorite shoes.  I bought the blush color from Amazon in an 8.5 as the store I had purchased the black pair from did not sell the blush.  I was very disappointed in these.  They are very cute but 1 shoe fits great & the other shoe is way too loose.  I checked & they say they are both 8.5 but I am guessing 1 was made incorrectly.  I still try to wear them but 1 shoe is hard to keep on.  If you get a pair that fits right, they are a great shoe but I was disappointed in this pair.