This boots are great, but I'm giving it three stars because within just the first few wears one of the kleats that hold the laces in place broke off.  I'm confident Baffin would repair this for me, but it is the top kleat so I can get by without it and it's just not worth me paying shipping to send them back for something like that.  Otherwise they are great, they fit good, and keep you really warm.  I like how there is an open space above the top of your foot which allows your feet to stay warmer.  You can wear them pretty loose to stay warmer and they'll still stay on your feet pretty well, or you can crank them down pretty good with the laces.  Definitely bulky boots, but they are a pac style boot, so that is absolutely expected.