I would give 5 stars anytime, because the shoes is excellent.  It's very comfortable, soft leather, glamorous looking and affordable.  The one thing that concerned me is that the top of the shoes is way too small compared to the my size of the shoes and not quite as proportional as the picture. If only the designer thought of the ratio of of the top of the shoes (the mouse head) for long sizes and the shorter sizes it will be perfect.  My size is 9.5, you can see more than half my toes, and the mouse mouth is unable to be seen it is too small.  I have to give this expensive shoes away.