4 out of 5, based on the color.  The only disappointment is the actual color, which I describe as milk chocolate brown.  I expected the color to be more natural and not so dark brown.  About the clog, I am use to Dansko clogs but when I had to return 3 different pair due to size issues of too big or too small, I decided to try a different brand.  I am glad I did.  The Troentorp clog fits perfect and is very comfortable.  I did have to break in the clog especially in the ridge that crosses over the top of your foot.  I won't give my Dansko yet, but I am glad to have another style of clog that I enjoy wearing just as much.