I ordered the Melissa Button in cognac soft vintage. The boots don't match one another. In fact, they look like the irregulars you would find at a boot barn outlet store, as they don't meet the quality standards Frye is known to have. Not only do they not match as a pair, the leather on the front shaft of the right boot is much lighter than the piece on the back. The front piece has wrinkles in the leather, and the pull straps aren't lined up so they look crooked when looking at them from the front. I will be sending them back and ordering directly from Frye.