Although the water shoes were somewhat large I find it good because my daughter will be able to wear these again next year.  The shoes have an odd smell but they kept her feet protected against the hot cement while we were at Oceans of Fun in Kansas City.  I like the string on the back that keeps the water shoes tight around her ankles.  I would recommend this product to a friend but would recommend that they order a half size smaller if they are looking for a more accurate fit.