They're cute and fit fine, but they look as though they've been used before which is not okay. The labels on both insoles of the shoes have rubbed off and they look as though they've had pressure from someone's body weight because the leather is wrinkled. The bottoms of the shoes already have black resedue straight out of the box. There are also what seems to be puncture holes from what I would guess are sharp pebbles/rocks getting stuck in them. The packaging was awful as well. You can see all of these things in my attached pictures. I will be demanding a refund because this is not acceptable.