I would give these shoes 5 stars if they both fit like the right one did.  But the shoes were not the same size regardless of the fact that each said they were 9.5 W on the shoe tongue.  The right one fit perfectly and the left one wouldn't even go on. At first I thought it was because the right one had probably been tried on a great deal while the left one hadn't.  But, put the soles of the shoes against each other and the right one was, in fact, a little larger.  Go figure......  But the look of the shoes were great and the feel was too, if they had matched in fit.  Nice arch support and the color was great and the suede was great.  Really sorry they had to be returned.