I've owned another pair of Doc Marten lace up boots for nearly 6 years and I love them dearly–so much so that they are nearly worn out. When buying this pair (the cherry red leather Arcadia, size 9), I ordered the same size as my old trusty pair, but something about them is just not right.<br /><br />In terms of comfort, the ankle section near the strap (as many other reviews have pointed out) is rather tight. The rest of the boot, however, is quite roomy, which doesn't feel great. The construction of the boot is very sturdy, almost too much so. I've worn these boots a number of times, and it feels like the leather will never soften, which is rather uncomfortable. Also, the strap at the top of the boot has a tendency not to stay in place, and I often find myself pushing it back down.<br /><br />In terms of looks, the color and finish of the cherry red leather is gorgeous. However, the design of the boot is not quite as nice as I had anticipated. My shoe size is generally a US women's size 9.5, which is not small. But the length of this boot makes it look as if I'm wearing clown shoes. It doesn't help that the rubber sole of the shoe sticks out pretty far from the shoe itself, making my foot look much bigger than it really is. Also, the toe of the shoe is fairly rounded, making this look more like a work boot than a fashion boot.<br /><br />All in all, it's a well-constructed, good looking boot, but it is not very comfortable to wear and not a good choice for women with larger feet. I regret buying it.