I have this pair of flats in black and it fits like a glove. I only rate it a 2 star because I think I got a defected brown pair. The left foot is loose fit/wider and it often falls off my foot, but the right side fits perfectly. I bought 2 pairs of flats to save on shipping. If I had to return this defective pair then pay for a replacement replacement pair, it be more worth it to be at the mall. This is why I gave it a 2-star, otherwise, I would rate it a 5-star!