1-1 1/2 sizes too small. Will exchange because they are fabulous. Bed Stu Kitty fits true to size in foot bed. I don't know how the same company can have such discrepancy in sizing. They are top quality and I will be reordering in a 9.5. My regular size is 8 or 8.5. Three stars because I love the boots but hate the hassle.<br /><br />Update....<br /><br />New boots were still narrow but broken now and I love them. I get tons of compliments (if you care what others think). Happy with purchase almost a year later. Looking at the opals now :)<br /><br />Reordered in 9.5. They fit well and the quality is just as good. I'm not sure why, within the same company the sizes vary so much, but figuring out what you can wear is well worth the time. Extremely pleased. If you have to have a wide, I would not recommend. I will be stretching these in the width just slightly. I don't normally wear wide.