I tried one boot on and didn't even bother to take the other out of the box, I knew right away they were not what I wanted. The size I ordered, 8.5, was correct and technically fit, but it did not line up with my arch and was uncomfortable. Also as some of the other reviews say the material the sole and heel are made of is hard, unforgiving, and seems like it could be unsafe of smooth surfaces due to lack of traction. They just aren't the Ariat quality I'm use to. My experience with Ariat boots being two pairs of Fat Baby's that I've worn almost to death. Those were comfortable from the start. Additionally these were too loose around the ankle. The pattern is cute and the toe box shape is cute. But, I don't recommend these at all, unfortunately. Though I would still recommend Ariat boots of other styles. Another note on the size: I wear an 8.5 or a 9 depending on the brand. My Fat Babies from Ariat are a 9 because I wear them with thick socks. These I ordered in an 8.5 and they went on easily and seemed a good though uncomfortable fit.