I have another pair of Sperry's that fit comfortably and ordered the same size. Out of the box, these were comfortable. I wore them for the first time on a day I was sitting a lot in meetings. My feet were killing me after a couple of hours. I have a high arch and rather wide feet but not wide enough to wear a size W. These were pinching through the arch and rubbing my heels. Unfortunately, I can't return since I wore them already.<br />I'm not such a fan of Sperry's after this.