I spent hours reviewing wallets before choosing this one for my husband.  He likes the wallet but says it's hard to get out of his back pants pocket.  He says part of the problem is the slickness of the wallet, but that was one of the features that I chose it for having, so that it would slide easily out of his pocket.  Go figure....  I like the organization of the card holders, the fact that the bill department is divided, and the see-through ID part.  I would give the wallet a 4 or 5, but since he's the user, I took his comment into consideration as well.