These are perfect shoe trees for my leather loafers and dress shoes. The Petite fits in my women's US sized 5-5.5 shoes very well thanks to the split toe design. I find the advantages of these are the wooden pull handles which makes adding/removing the shoe trees much simpler as opposed to pull strings. The cedar is an inoffensive scent that isn't too heavy. As advertised, great for keeping shape of shoes and letting leather breath. I have two Everlane Modern Loafers bought around the same time, wore equally as much, and in the same size 5. I can tell the difference between both with one using shoe trees and another without: the one with the shoe trees has a more supple leather feel to the interior, has better structure, and didn't need to be broken in. Excellent product, will definitely buy more!