I bought a black pair to replace my old black pair that got lost at a festival. The shoes fit properly and are as comfortable as my old pair I bought from zumies. I don't know if these are fakes or not. If they are they're extremely good fakes. I've owned two pairs of Tom's and in general they only last about a year before they start fraying and coming apart so if you're looking for a long life shoe these aren't it. But they are very comfortable and cute. ☺