I've had these boots in brown for years and wanted the black ones too. I like a more plain and simple look when it comes to shoes so these boots are the perfect fit for me. After looking for months and months I found what I truly believe was the last black pair of these in 8 1/2 in the world. The brown is my favorite pair of shoes I've ever owned. I love the black as well, but the leather is extremely shiny while the brown is more matte. I would recommend these boots to anyone!