My granddaughter says these are squishy and comfy.  The insulation is substantial, and these boots seem very well made, thick soles and the material on the shaft is very nice and strong.  Like the reflective stripes up the sides.  Despite being fairly open at the top, I don't see a problem when she's wearing these with snow getting in because she'll have to tuck in her pants.  we'll see.  But we love these boots and granddaughter can't wait for snow.