I give the Timberline Pro Women's Renova shoe five stars.  They fit great and are very comfortable.  I bought 2 pair in different sizes on the lightening deal on July 18th because I didn't know which size to buy.  The total for both pairs of the &#34;lightening deal&#34; came to $81.16 including tax.  When I returned the pair that didn't fit, they will only give me a refund of $21.30!  They called it an &#34;item promotion deduction&#34; of $25.49.  The &#34;lightening deal&#34; wasn't very dazzling!  Very disappointed in you Amazon.  Will not ever do your lightening deals again!