I love them I read others reviews. I normally wear a size 9 and i have a wide foot but i wanted to wear thick socks (up in wy) so i ordered a size 10. I have very athletic calves the circumference of my calf is 20 so i was very skeptical they would even fit but... they do i had to stretch them a little in the shaft but I manage. Alot better than what you ca find for &#34;wide calf boots&#34;<br />Im also 5'8 and they fall just below my knee. SO cute they pictures are pretty close to what you get in the mail.<br />I do wear them to class (college and they stay up pretty good) i wouldn't recommend them in the saddle thou. been there done that, they are &#34;riding&#34; boots not riding boots. I would say make sure you wear tall socks they might rub your heel.