These are a bit snug, but I'm getting used to them as I break them in. Not sure on the water proofing yet. I bought them for my trip upcoming trip to Ireland where we plan on lots of walking. I would prefer a deeper shoe, however. It feels like my heel is going to come out of the shoe when I take a step. That'll take some getting used to. They seem to have good support, so I'm hoping that'll help with all the walking we shall be doing.