These shoes were perfect. They came in my size, fit perfectly both in length and width, and were comfortable for all day wear.  So you may be asking, why the 1-star rating?  After 3-4 months of wear, not even daily, the top of the sole began coming loose.  I figured it happens, but thought that a company like Sperry would stand behind their shoes and offer a repair or exchange since I always believed they cared about their customers and high-quality shoes.  I quickly realized they offer no such thing, and will only replace / exchange unworn shoes within 45 days.  I am not typically hard on my shoes - I have several pair of other brands, who shall go nameless in this review, which I've worn for close to a decade and while they appear worn still fit and are not falling apart.  I LOVED these shoes while I owned them, but I can't bring myself to buy another pair at these prices for risk they will fall apart again.