I am giving only a three star because I have 7 other pairs of this shoe and they are size 9 and fit me perfectly. For some reason this color in this style runs large. The first pair of this color I received I returned because they fell off my feet. This pair is still too large but I kept them. I love this style keen. It is comfortable and very supportive. I wear one of my 8 pair everyday. Before I found this style I wore Birkenstocks but these keens are much more comfortable and cooler on my feet and have a great arch support. I hope they have more colors next season, I will purchase more.