The leather on the shoe was really nice. Ideal heel for walking without looking matronly, especially for those of us who can no longer wear 4 inch heels,but still want that sex appeal. Unfortunately I have a high instep and the leather across the top of foot seemed tight. Only wore the shoes on carpet in my home - didn't want to wear out if I was uncertain about keeping. I still give the shoe a high rating even though I did return them the next day. The shoe was purchased for some upcoming trips and school;therefore I wanted comfort and attractiveness. I still give the shoe a rating of 4 stars although I only wore them in the house off and on for a few hours.The band across the foot bed is actually slanted and may expose an unattractive small toe.