After reading all comments, was a little reluctant to order.  But, after receiving the boots so very glad I ordered them.  I wear a 9 1/2 M -10 N/M.  Ordered a size 10.  Liked the because of the height--have a weak ankle, and need some support when doing lots of walking.  These boots were perfect for the extra support.  And although the fit is somewhat lose, it's definitely NOT HUGE, as others described.  I have room for med. wt. socks and did add an extra insole with a little arch support.  The leather was excellent quality and very supple, and the oxblood was a gorgeous color. Great look without being &#34;clunky&#34;.  Upon receiving them, I wore them for a day to test the feel.  They were very comfortable and depending on the sock thickness, probably could get by without the extra insole.  Final evaluation--great boot for the money.