This shoes are extremely comfortable. They are cushioned and seems durable. The brown color is beautiful and the shine is just about right - not too shiny and not matte - You can get a decent shine.  These also have a good grip especially on wet pavement. I am hoping that the coloe won't fade when it gets wet - i do not think it would tho.  i usually wear 8 1/2 on most shie brands, including clarks but I find these shoes to be 1/2 inch bigger. I ordered an 8EE and it fits perfectly.  I prefer Clarks over Rockfort because of it's much comfortable  plus it's cheaper, and you get the same quality. My only complain? These shoes have a squeeky sound when walking in smooth surface but the sound is not too annoying - I can live with it  This is a bargain for a quality shoes!  P.S.  This is my 4th clark shoes. I have two rockport shoes which are collecting dust. Don't get me wrong, Rockport shoes have good quality but my feet just aren't fit witn rockports.  UPDATE: 8/28 I initially gave these shoes a 5 star rating.  When these arrived last night, I tried it on and walked around the garage for several minutes and it felt very comfortable - I was happy, hence the 5 start rating. When I used this today to work, my feet so much discomfort plus the leather gets easily scuffed, which cannot be buffed. It's too bad because these are really good looking shoes at a bargain price, and I love all my four Clarks shoes for their comfort, style, and quality leather materials. Unfortunately, this particular style didn't leave up to par with Clarks' reputation of workmanship. I will still purchase Clarks shoes but will stay away from this particular style