These boots are super cute! Though I did have to return them as they were a full size too big. Unfortunately I did not repurchase, as the correct size was much more expensive. I can't speak for all day comfort but I could not get over how cute these were and they seemed to be good quality for the price. I do have rather small calves and these fit slightly on the tight side especially for the shoe being too big so I would not recommend for anyone with larger calves.