I have been a size 12 all my adult life, so I ordered a size 12--but they were huge!  Boot seemed a bit flimsy on construction and light.  So I am disappointed-- although they looked nice out of the box--just not on my feet!  A 3 on quality and a 1 on size--so a 2 - 2 1/2 overall.  Got a New Balance boot from Amazon, also a size 12, about which I am very happy and would recommend!