Update:  I've worn these shoes several times over six months, so glad I kept them because they fit much better after a few wears. Still loving the style!   Aug 2015 review:  I really wanted the smart and stylish Rockport Women's Total Motion Melora Captoe Dress Shoe in Nutella/Black. Boo hoo hoo. The shoe has a comfy looking footbed (a cushioned insole) designed by Adidas. Imagine you already have a comfortable pair of shoes. Now put cushioned insoles inside and they begin to feel less comfortable, maybe even too snug. That Adidas insole is a great idea, but the biggest problem with the shoe, in my opinion, is the insole because: (1) It is glued to the inner bottom of the shoe so it isn't removable or replaceable (2) It is an uneven surface which means that my foot rests on both the raised part of the cushion and the flat part, creating an annoying sensation as if I'm standing on a seam or something like that  IF the footbed was replaceable OR simply an even-surfaced soft cushion, the 7.5W would have been the perfect fit because, according to my typical shoe size, the shoe runs larger than most. I bought three sizes to be sure to get the right fit. None fit well. Rockport: I don't mind going up or down a size in a shoe but making the footbed removable and/or comfortable would change my rating to a solid 4.  Detailed info about the fit:  After reading several earlier reviews about the shoe being too large for some and too small for others, first I tried them in my regular size 8W (a finger-sized gap between back of shoe and my foot), then 7.5W (too snug, caused foot cramps but perhaps wearing them in --maybe for a week or so-- will stretch them into a comfort zone??), and finally 8M (too long and too narrow, caused foot cramps). Although both 8M and 8W were too long, I put in heel grips that kept the 8M but not the 8W from slipping off my foot. I wore them for about an hour last night and another 30 minutes this morning walking around in the 7.5W then the 8M, seekingcomfort with various shoe pads and heel grips.  If I didn't really, really like these Melora Captoe pumps, I would have boxed and returned them within 10 minutes. But this pair tugged my heart and my head because it's one of those timeless beauties that double as a workhorse and a class act. I hope Rockport and Adidas will get it right.