I am giving these boots a 4 even though I am sending  them back. The quality is great and it really is a beautiful boot which is why I am rating it as I am. However,  I have short (5'2&#34;) and muscular legs (14&#34;) but these boots are too wide for my legs. They look like rain galoshes which is not at all cute. I am between a 7.5 and 7 shoe size and ordered the 7 and felt the boots were too long on my foot as well. Sending these back...perhaps I'll try the non-wide calf version in a 6.5? The boot hunt continues.