I have been a fan of keen shoes for several years. I wear a size 12 2E shoe in other brands, but Keen 12 D has always fit great. These keens are shorter and have a much narrower toe box than my older keen shoes. Keen's website recommends ordering a half size up (On many of the new models, seems like a common theme). They have a wide version, but not in 12.5. At this point I'm going to start looking at other brands in the keen price range. I'm seriously super bummed that the shoe brand that used to fit like a glove now fits like a Walmart special. I'm wearing my old keens and loving the the old school keen fit.  These also had a bump/wrinkle sewn into the inside of the toe. It rubbed on my toe and was really uncomfortable. It's possibly a sign of lower quality keens being produced.