These boots are by far the best boots I have ever owned. They ARE Water proof to a certain extent. Not sure what Some people are talking about. I am a meter reader I walk 10 to 15 miles a day 5 days a week! Yes 10 to 15 miles! For the first few months they hold up great and keep the water out on wet rainy days, mornings with dew, I've even warn them through the snow. Once the gortex  wears out and the color fades they do start to let water in but not as much as any other hiking light weight work boot. If you're looking for a weekend warrior boot that's water proof these are it  or a boot to work in they are great. I have spent 1000's of dollars on boots over the years and these are my favorite I have had atleast 6 pairs. Best buy for sure! Not to mention I wear  a size 13 wide so it's hard to find any boot that are comfy... Timberland is known for narrower boots but the wide is perfect!