I would rate the features four or five star and the fit a one star, so, I figured three stars was the average. The sandal has great features such as contoured footbed, good sole traction and well constructructed strap/thong. However, Columbia dropped the ball on the sizing of the strap in relation to the footbed. The first pair I ordered was my foot size 9. Could barely squeeze my foot under the straps. Returned that pair and ordered size 10. Was able to get my foot in under the straps with a little wiggling and they seemed to fit okay although a little snug. After wearing around inside the house for less than an hour, I noticed my toes kind of red. I took the sandals off and had some pretty deep indentions in the top of my foot along where the edges of the strap rested - cutting my circulation to my toes.