My wife buys these flip flops by Yellow Box every year - once at DSW, Yellow Box.com, Zappos and 6PM and she said they all fit just right.  She has wide feet and these were still to wide for her. The left foot wide but the Right foot was soooooo big that she could not wear them at all. WHAT A WASTE OF MONEY.  She said she will go back to ordering and buying them where she knows they will fit perfectly.