I wear between an 8.5 or 9 in Keen shoes.  I found these too large to keep.  They look nice but feel larger than the Size 8.5 Keens I am now wearing.  I may try the Size 8 but am concerned that they will be too small.  I am giving the shoes 3 stars but I can't really evaluate them other than the overall fit. UPDATE:  I ordered the smaller size 8.  They fit well.  The problem with this pair, as reported in other reviews, is that the dye rubs off.  With this pair, it is even on the paper that the shoes are wrapped with inside the Keen box.  I rubbed the strap and the dye came off on my hand.  It did wash off, but I don't know if it would wash out of socks or tights.  It comes off other parts of the shoe but much more from the strap.  This is a problem I have not had with Keen shoes before.  How could quality control miss this??  Do better, Keen.  I really want to wear your shoes.