I ordered these shoes in Chestnut, size 9. Most of my dress shoes are size 8 1/2, but because I knew I would be wearing socks with these boots, I ordered half a size up and they fit perfectly! The quality and overall look of the shoe is just as I expected. The color does appear slightly (and I mean just very slightly) darker than in the photo, but it's close enough for me to not care. I haven't worn them out yet, only given them a quick test run at home, but they seem very comfortable and easy to walk in. The boots are made of soft faux leather, and the insides are lined with a very thin furry material.<br /><br />I am giving these boots 4 stars because I have only just gotten them in the mail, and have not experienced wearing them for a prolonged period of time; however, as of now, I am pleased with the product!