I should have sent them back.  My daughter and I wear the same size.  She has very average width feet and her toes are average length.  The strap closest to the toes fits past the little toe on both of our feet.  I cant imagine it fitting right on any foot.  Her little toe always sticks out under the strap and she has just been a good sport about wearing them, but I wouldn't recommend them if you can't try them on.  They would have been cute otherwise, but I would never wear them like that.