The shoe is made of a very nice leather. The fit is pretty well. I don't think that someone with a narrow foot would be happy with this shoe. It seems to fit a more of a medium width. I would have rated this shoe a 5 star; however, the straps along the sides tend to bow out and I don't like that about the shoe. They are comfortable and they aren't horrible, but I wouldn't buy them again, just because the straps bowing out bother me.