Im 10.5 and the shoe fits JUST right.  I would've liked a tiny bit more room to grow into but that isn't the main concern.  For $30-50 ish dollarsv you really kind of her what you paid for.  The shoe is not hard at all it feels smooth and cheap.  The sole is the real issue if You walk a lot, or are a heel striker like me.  The sole will wear out quickly due to the material not to mention it looks like that cheap tan from the bottom.  In other words if they could've just jacked up the proce 10-25 dollars I wouldn't have cared as long as they fixed this.  They didn't even come in a box,  just styrofoam wrapped in plastic. In order words just buy this if you absolutely must have some dress shoes you'll probably wear seldomly.