Well, I loved the idea of this shoe, I actually wanted the red Puffy's but they no longer come in red.  I ordered these in red, and they stretched out so bad my toes were hanging over pretty much right away. Had I not worn them outside, I would have sent them back.  I ended up stitching a pleat in the leather toe part and the upper part.  What a disappointment.  Bring back the Puffy in red, please.  These are not the same and stretch terribly.