When I was considering buying these for my daughter I read a bunch of reviews. A lot of people did not understand how the sizing works. The simplest way is to look at a pair of their other shoes and get the EUR / EU size. Go to the size chart and convert it to to the size needed for boots.  Also, I was on the fence about the width. My daughter doesn't like tight shoes, so when I saw wide width was available, I was tempted to get them. I decided to stick with the medium width, and there is plenty of wiggle room. These are nice high quality boots. The price is comparable to what I saw at Payless and Target, but the quality far surpasses what they had.