I did like these boots, and they fit comfortably. They were much shorter than I expected, falling several inches below my knee, and I'm only 5'3&#34;.<br /><br />But here's the REAL reason I gave 1 star: They fell apart! The upper is starting to separate from the foot...and there are stress cracks in the rubber where my foot bends. This, after I've only had them for two months. I would expect a lot more from a $65 pair of rubber boots.<br /><br />My Hunter boots lasted 10 years. I guess I'll try Hunter again.<br /><br />Amazon return policy is only for 30 days...the down side of ordering from Amazon. If I had bought these boots locally, the store would take them back They are defective.