So far, these boots are very comfortable and fit my foot well.  Very good quality boot.  I actually tend to have issues with ladies boots and dress shoes being too tight around the toes and by the end of the day, my small toes feel crammed and sore.  Not the case with these.  I would give these a 5, but it is too soon to tell since it is still summertime and I have only been wearing them around the house for a few hours.