I will revisit this review if I can resolve the one squeaking shoe- Unfortunately, it was too late to return them; when I wore them for the first time one shoe squeaked all day long- So annoying- They fit great, look great, and are very comfortable, but you all know it only takes the one squeaking  shoe to ruin a great pair of shoes and I am now concerned to buy another color in fear they may squeak... they get 3 stars because if one shoe did not squeak they would be the perfect shoe