Someone in the comments had suggested that if you wear a half size, to order the next size up. This didn't work for me. I wear a 9.5 and ordered a 10, and they are FAR too big. I don't blame Joy Fish for this poor information.<br /><br />To boots themselves are good quality, but the return policy stinks. On top of paying for return postage, they require a $12 check to be included in the box. I'm used to Amazon's generous return policy on clothing. I realize that this is not sold directly from Amazon, but it makes no sense to pay shipping twice (once to get to me, once to get back to them), plus $12. It's not worth my time or energy to box up the boots and send them back for what will end up being a dollar or two refunded.<br /><br />LUCKILY this is for a Halloween costume so I don't have to wear them long. If I double up my socks and pad the toes I can hobble around enough to make this work.