These boots would be good if you have slim calves I'm assuming. This boot would dig into my calves and would suffocate my calves so much that I would have to take them partially off even during class! I could barely walk approximately half a mile to my car after class -- ~3 hours of wearing these boots.I wore them twice and I'm probably never wearing them again. The things I like about them is the finish and the quality of the boot, but the comfort and the sizing of the boot is awful. I disliked these so much that I went out to buy a different pair of rain boots that were 1) WAY more comfortable 2) cheaper - $20! Another thing to note is that I ordered the matte and they sent me the shiny black boots. I did however receive the difference from Amazon customer support.