I want to love these shoes.  They just arrived today, and I couldn't wait to try them on.  I have worn nothing but Skechers (including Bobs) for several years.  I am a perfect 7.5 in all of my Skechers shoes.  These are WAY to narrow and WAY to short.  I could not even get my right foot in them (and that's my small foot).  They are going back, and I'm not going to reorder.  An 8 or 8.5 might be OK lengthwise, but they will still be too narrow.  I gave them 2 stars because I love the style.