I haven't reviewed many, if any, products on Amazon, but felt compelled to review this one.  These boots are comfortable, but not waterproof.  I bought them because they were represented as waterproof.  After about 15 months, they weren't.  Year two, much worse, even the dew on the grass soaks my feet.  I didn't expect the waterproofing to last forever, but after just 15 months?  Weak.  If you want comfortable, leaky boots, get them.  Note that most of these reviews are from folks who had them less than a year.