I've been looking for a pair of stylish but comfortable pumps forever and really hoped that these shoes would be it. But while they were incredibly supportive and comfortable in the arch area, they narrowed a bit too much up front, pinching my toes together and rubbing uncomfortably around the edges when I tried them out at home. There was some extra room in the back, so I don't think it would have helped to size up. They also didn't look great on, at least in black--the wide ankle band made the shoe look bulky and a little severe, and the shape of the toe area made it look like I'd slipped my feet into witch hats, for lack of a better description. That said, my feet are on the larger side (9.5), so lots of shoes that look great on smaller feet just don't work for me.