I have ordered the 9.5 in the leather shoes, and when I received these really cute shoes, the sizing was so off, I felt like they were 2 sizes too small. I wore them only once to the store and when I got back from only 40 minutes of wear, my left foot was numb, and I had indents in the back of each heel. I wish the sizing was appropriate on ALL of these shoes and not just on the leather ones. I ended up giving them to my sister who has much smaller feet than me.