I bought these boots for Alpine hunting, mushroom picking, and firewood getting in Southeast, Alaska. So far these boots have kept my feet dry. They need to be broken in more in order to wear them comfortably ALL DAY. The reason these are getting one star less is; the gluing of the fabric on the heels was done very messy! I almost sent them back for fear they would not be waterproof but I gave them a chance. There was also a small gouge in the fabric.. but that's just visual. They're working for me; lightweight, waterproof, and comfy. They look nice too :)