I give these shoes a 3 star because they look great, but even though I ordered them to be larger than my son normally wears they were still a little smaller than expected.  I would have sent them back for a different size, but my son did love them and threw a fit about sending them back.  They look good on him.  The only issue that I has was the size, but to me that is a pretty big issue!  I suggest that if you order these get them at least a whole size larger than what your child usually wears.