The left boot fit as expected, but the right boot was painfully tight at the forefoot.  The boots were kept, out of desperation, because they were purchased immediately prior to a seven-week motorcycle trip.  Eventually the right boot &#34;broke in&#34; enough to be okay, but I originally thought that I would have to throw them away and replace them on the road.  The initial pain was that great.  Such a fit problem has never occurred previously with any other pair of boots or shoes, so I cannot attribute it to a difference in my feet.  I believe it is a quality control issue.  If both boots had fit as well as the left boot always has, then I would have happily given them five stars.  The price is very reasonable, the boots are waterproof (I did wax them for additional protection), they eventually became comfortable to hike in, and they have worn very well.  If Justin can address this problem, then they well have one of the best work boots on the market, and at bargain prices.