These shoes fit great (got a 8W), feel very comfy for all day wear, and don't look too clunky. I was worried that the light leather color might scuff easily, but no problems so far. The only only only thing preventing me from giving 5 starts is the irritation from the back of the shoes. As other customers have noted, it really chaffs the back of your foot, and after a month's wear it hasn't softened yet, though here's hoping it will. I've already ordered another pair in black.