I'm with Lucy
After being unexpectedly dumped by her dream boyfriend, Lucy (Monica  Potter,Along Came a Spider) wants to hide away in her apartment--but her  friends set her up with a series of blind dates: a shy entomologist (John  Hannah,Sliding Doors), a sensual playwright (Gael Garcia Bernal,Y Tu  Mamá También), a hunky doctor (David Boreanaz,Angel), a  self-centered baseball player (Anthony LaPaglia,Lantana), and a bickering  businessman (Henry Thomas,All the Pretty Horses). We know she ends up  marrying one of these five guys; trying to figure out which one, as the dates  unfold in flashbacks, makes the movie engaging--up to a point. The script loses  focus and Potter, though pretty, is too bland to sustain interest (though it  should be said that she shows more flair inI'm with Lucythan in her  previous romantic comedy efforts, such as the laughably badHead Over  Heels).--Bret Fetzer