Haunted by the Archaic Shaman: Himalayan Jhakris and the Discourse on Shamanism
Sidky combines his careful ethnographic study of shamanism as lived in Nepal with a comprehensive and critical review of the broad literature on shamanism. By doing so, he offers much needed order and clarity in this contested field of study. This is a major contribution both to anthropology and the history of religion. (Erika Bourguignon, Ohio State University)Sidky's book is a complete overview of Nepali, Siberian, and Tibetan shamanism as well as an in-depth study of the Nepali jhãkri tradition. It overcomes the confusion created by Eliade's unsupported concepts and puts shamanic studies back on the track of empirical social science. It must be read by anyone seriously interested in shamanic healing. This is the best of ethnographic anthropology, because it is based on an intimate acquaintance with the shamans and their work. It captures the human reality of their profession and doesn't obscure it with mysticism or fanciful nonsense. It is full of real myth and real magical healing that is far more exciting to someone who wants to know the truth about shamanism. Its facts are more exciting than speculative reconstructions of nonsensical archaic modalities. Sidky examines an incredible range of scholarship on shamanism and is able to sift the wheat from the chaff. (James W. Dow, Oakland University)Haunted by the Archaic Shaman[is] an important, significant contribution to anthropology and comparative religions. Combining firsthand ethnography with in-depth scholarly discussion of shamanism. . . . Sidky discusses in depth academic usages of 'shaman,' showing that the term is often used imprecisely and erroneously. The scholarship is impressively sound, with vivid firsthand descriptions of jhãkris, thorough coverage of literature on shamanism; [and] solid analyses of the discourse on shamanism, cutting through fad usage, racist usage, and primitivism. [This book] will be a must-have for any scholars discussing shamanism. (Alice Beck Kehoe, Marquette University)Sidky's commitment to scientific, verifiable conclusions is, likewise, admirable…. And though it does not resolve the knotty questions of how to define and practice ethnography, it offers an instructive example of how one very conscientious scholar has dealt with them. (Journal Of Folklore Research)