Muslim Zion: Pakistan as a Political Idea
Muslim Zionexposes the reader to ideals and realities that competed in the formation of Pakistan. It is a cerebral insight into how there was never a clear notion of 'what Pakistan should be' and, therefore, it is not surprising 'what it has become.'(Gayatri ChandrasekaranMint2013-08-22)Faisal Devji'sMuslim Zion...is a refreshing addition to the study of politics of Muslim League and Jinnah's personality as it traces the creation of Pakistan...Muslim Zionbrings forth the collaborative and competitive politics of Ambedkar and Jinnah, a much ignored aspect. The book thus effectively traces the creation of Pakistan by mapping Islam, Muslim, and minorityism packed with some fresh and original perspectives on Sir Syed Ahmed, Allama Iqbal, and Syed Ameer Ali among others.Muslim Zionwill also be of interest to those seeking to have some understanding of the Shia sub-sects. Devji suggests that the interest of prominent Shias in the politics of Muslim League had got to do with the fact that they wanted to protect themselves from both the Hindu as well as the Sunni majority... Even as the book explores on the idea of Pakistan, the amazing parallels between a Muslim homeland and Jewish settlement seamlessly runs through the narrative making it eminently readable.Muslim Zionis a provocative and fascinating piece of scholarship with some very complex and tight observations and arguments. (Danish KhanTwo Circles2013-09-12)A trenchant analysis...the book presents a wholly different and more nuanced view of Islamic politics than most recent titles. (Publishers Weekly2013-07-01)No one butFaisal Devjicould have given usMuslim Zion, which offers a brilliant, counterintuitive meditation on the analogy between ideologies of Zionism and Pakistani/Muslim nationalism, and at the same time a nuanced historical exploration of the idea of Pakistan. Intellectual history as a page-turner. (Noah Feldman, author ofCool War: The Future of Global Competition)Despite their vast differences, Pakistan and Israel share this strange coincidence of birth: they were both created to resolve the problematic status of minorities defined partly by religion. Scholars in a number of fields have begun to explore facets of this strange parallelism.Faisal Devjihas brought the historian's traditional skills to the task, focusing on the Muslim League's demand from the 1930s for a separate homeland for the Muslims of India.Muslim Ziontells a gripping story and will make an important contribution to this ongoing scholarly discussion. (Aamir R. Mufti, author ofEnlightenment in the Colony: The Jewish Question and the Crisis of Postcolonial Culture)Devjiis arguably the most brilliant scholar of his generation writing today on South Asian history and global Islam. His explorations of the tensions inherent in the idea of Pakistan as a Muslim homeland, and the fascinating parallels he draws with Zionist and settler-colonial pasts, provide a new point of departure for the study of both Muslim and Dalit politics in British India. His reflections on the failure of the category 'minority' in decolonizing times will help us rethink the very idea of the political in the twentieth century. A thoughtful and courageous book. (Dipesh Chakrabarty, University of Chicago)A fascinating, thoughtful, and provocative work,Muslim Zionexplores the paradoxical dimensions of Pakistan by focusing on the period when this country was imagined, but yet unrealized. (Christophe Jaffrelot, CERI-Sciences Po/CNRS)Faisal Devji's brilliantly written, deeply felt book is an important contribution to the study of the tortured relationship between different ideas of Pakistan and of Islam. (Anatol Lieven, author ofPakistan: A Hard Country)A remarkable book…Devjihas persuasively interpreted Jinnah’s view of Pakistan as an anti-territorial, universalistic conception of the nation. Summoning Pakistan into existence was an act of pure will that required the rejection of history, soil, and culture--all the usual grounds on which to claim nationhood, and which for Jinnah subverted the unity he claimed for India’s Muslims. (Sunil KhilnaniNew Republic2013-11-09)Devjiprovides a unique insight into the underpinnings of the idea of Pakistan. [He] sees a parallel between the Zionist movement for Israel and the Muslim nationalist movement for Pakistan…Devji provides an excellent narrative of the course of Muslim politics, its interactions with other Indian movements, and the commitment to a separate political entity--Pakistan. This is familiar territory, but it is presented with an entirely new perspective--the author refers to contemporary literature, poetry, and political speeches and writings…Devji’s erudite, balanced and lucid work, embellished with pithy insights and interesting sources, is a stern warning about the hazards of basing nationhood on religious identity. (Talmiz AhmadBusiness Standard2013-11-12)Devjioffers a detailed analysis of the various political and ideological forces that were at play in the buildup to Pakistan’s creation. Devji’s larger project seems to be to mitigate the tendency to look at historical phenomena from the 20th and 21st centuries isolated from their global context…He notes that Jinnah ‘seems to have possessed more books on the problems of European Jewry than on any Muslim people or country.’ Devji also believes that the formation of Pakistan set a precedent that made Israel possible. (Hannah Harris GreenLos Angeles Review of Books2013-12-02)