Man Ain't Supposed to Cry
Perhaps a man ain't supposed to cry. But when that man boasts the soulful individualism of the incomparable singer Joe Williams, he ain't supposed to sound like other people, either. That fact alone explains the problem with this legendary, long unavailable ballads-and-strings album. Recorded in late 1957,Crysought to present Williams in a different light from the one he occupied in front of theCount Basieband, transforming him from a sophisticatedly bluesy jazzman into a pop crooner.  Surrounded by treacly strings on "I'm Through with Love," he sings the verse with the prim correctitude ofElla Fitzgerald's "songbook" albums; when he navigates the plunging melody of "What Will I Tell My Heart?," he begins to sound likeNat "King" Cole; holding the long notes on "Say It Isn't So," he channels a bit ofFrank Sinatra; and when he swoops up to a melody's zenith, on "What's New?" or "I'll Never Smile Again," you catch a whiff ofSarah Vaughan.Much of this has to do with repertoire. Williams could always sing the standard ballads better than most jazzmen, but a whole program of them--even one as short as this (under 36 minutes)--plays against such strengths as his gritty soul and enormous swing. But you also have to blame the big-orchestra treatment. Only when the arrangements feature the horns over the strings, imparting something bluesy to the mix, does Williams really sound at home. Label M toutsA Man Ain't Supposed to Cryas "the best album Joe Williams ever made," but even though he sings splendidly, it's not the Joe Williams most of us want to know. And if it's a great standards set from Williams you're after, check outThe Greatest ... Count Basie Plays, Joe Williams Sings Standards.--Neil Tesser