The Mirror of Narcissus - Secular Songs by Guillaume de Machaut
The second Gothic Voices recording was something of a milestone: the first recording of  14-century music performed by voices alone. The absence of instruments permits very precise  tuning (no small matter in this repertory) and doesn't obscure Machaut's poetry (which was admired  by no less than Geoffrey Chaucer). Belying its scholarly-but-dull reputation, Gothic Voices sings  with plenty of energy and rhythmic snap; the monophonic songs, performed by a single  unaccompanied voice, come off particularly well. The best example of this disc's achievement is  the famous "Douce dame jolie," which has been done as everything from a catchy little  ditty to a fife-and-drum march: Margaret Philpot performs it as what it is--the forlorn plea of a  spurned lover.--Matthew Westphal