The Challenge of Discipleship: A Critical Study of the Sermon on the Mount as Scripture
"...a rich, optimistic, and challenging study in both its discussion of the [Sermon on the Mount] and in its commitment to faith-interpretations." —Warren Carter, St. Paul School of Theology, reviewing for Religious Studies Review, April 2000 (Warren Carter, St. Paul School of TheologyReligious Studies Review)"Daniel Patte shows respect for every interpretation, be it those of ‘ordinary people’ or those of scholars, and clarifies underlying presuppositions of each option. In a fascinating and new way, he relates critical insights to matters of faith, ultimately to help Christians affirm their credo as truly theirs." —Christina Grenholm, Uppsala University (Christina Grenholm, Uppsala University)"Daniel Patte invites the reader to engage a question of ultimate importance in New Testament scholarship, namely, the reciprocal influence of textual meaning and the reader through the meditation of praxis. This question and Patte’s answers are significant now only for engagement with the text of the Sermon of the Mount but with New Testament texts in general." —Sandra M. Schneiders, Jesuit School of Theology (Sandra M. Schneiders, Jesuit School of Theology)"Should be read and discussed in both seminary and church classrooms." —Timothy B. Cargal, Northwood Presbyterian Church, Silver Spring, Maryland (Timothy B. Cargal, Northwood Presbyterian Church)"Readers of any sacred text will be challenged by Patte’s ecumenical call for believers to engage in ethically responsible interpretations of their own scripture." —Fred W. Burnett, Anderson University (Fred W. Burnett, Anderson University)"Breaks new ground in teaching and studying the Bible. Bringing multiple voices (interpretations) into conversation honors the diversity of the people of God and empowers readers to engage directly issues of faith, meaning, and discipleship. I highly recommend this book." —Jack L. Seymour, Garrett-Evangelical Theological Seminary (Jack L. Seymour, Garrett-Evangelical Theo Sem)"Extracts and condenses five representative readings from the morass of modern scholarship, making possible a vigorous dialogue between alternative interpretations. Patte’s new ‘scripture criticism’ will inform the emerging debate about the authority of scripture in the third millenium." —Laurence L. Welborn, United Theological Seminary (Laurence L. Welborn, United Theological Seminary)"The authority of any particular interpretation of a text, Patte says, may be considered only in the open discussion with peers who take into account not only the historic, linguistic, and theological meanings of a text, but also its significance when applied to a life situation. Such an inquiry is no simple matter, but then that is the challenge of discipleship." —David W. Odell-Scott, Kent State University (David W. Odell-Scott, Kent State University)"Ministers or teachers who want to know the basic contours of current scholarship will find various approaches succinctly and fairly summarized by Patte... The value in Patte’s study is found in the way he makes explicit the interpretive choices that lead to different, but plausible, formulations of the Sermon’s teaching. In doing so, he challenges us to be responsible ethically for our readings... I enthusiastically commend this book." — David B. Howell, Ferrum College, reviewing for Interpretation, April 2001 (David B. HowellInterpretation)"...a rich, optimistic, and challenging study in both its discussion of the [Sermon on the Mount] and in its commitment to faith-interpretations." —Warren Carter, St. Paul School of Theology, reviewing for Religious Studies Review, April 2000 (Sanford LakoffReligious Studies Review)"Daniel Patte shows respect for every interpretation, be it those of ‘ordinary people’ or those of scholars, and clarifies underlying presuppositions of each option. In a fascinating and new way, he relates critical insights to matters of faith, ultimately to help Christians affirm their credo as truly theirs." —Christina Grenholm, Uppsala University (Sanford Lakoff)"Daniel Patte invites the reader to engage a question of ultimate importance in New Testament scholarship, namely, the reciprocal influence of textual meaning and the reader through the meditation of praxis. This question and Patte’s answers are significant now only for engagement with the text of the Sermon of the Mount but with New Testament texts in general." —Sandra M. Schneiders, Jesuit School of Theology (Sanford Lakoff)"Should be read and discussed in both seminary and church classrooms." —Timothy B. Cargal, Northwood Presbyterian Church, Silver Spring, Maryland (Sanford Lakoff)"Readers of any sacred text will be challenged by Patte’s ecumenical call for believers to engage in ethically responsible interpretations of their own scripture." —Fred W. Burnett, Anderson University (Sanford Lakoff)"Breaks new ground in teaching and studying the Bible. Bringing multiple voices (interpretations) into conversation honors the diversity of the people of God and empowers readers to engage directly issues of faith, meaning, and discipleship. I highly recommend this book." —Jack L. Seymour, Garrett-Evangelical Theological Seminary (Sanford Lakoff)"Extracts and condenses five representative readings from the morass of modern scholarship, making possible a vigorous dialogue between alternative interpretations. Patte’s new ‘scripture criticism’ will inform the emerging debate about the authority of scripture in the third millenium." —Laurence L. Welborn, United Theological Seminary (Sanford Lakoff)"The authority of any particular interpretation of a text, Patte says, may be considered only in the open discussion with peers who take into account not only the historic, linguistic, and theological meanings of a text, but also its significance when applied to a life situation. Such an inquiry is no simple matter, but then that is the challenge of discipleship." —David W. Odell-Scott, Kent State University (Sanford Lakoff)"Ministers or teachers who want to know the basic contours of current scholarship will find various approaches succinctly and fairly summarized by Patte... The value in Patte’s study is found in the way he makes explicit the interpretive choices that lead to different, but plausible, formulations of the Sermon’s teaching. In doing so, he challenges us to be responsible ethically for our readings... I enthusiastically commend this book." — David B. Howell, Ferrum College, reviewing for Interpretation, April 2001 (Sanford LakoffInterpretation)