'MBTI - INTJ  Enneagram (with wing) - Either 8w7 or counterphobic 6w5  Alignment - Neutral Good  Instinctual variant (so/sx/sp) - sx/sp or sp/sx  Hogwarts house - Gryffindor|||That's what matters. J/P is fucked up for introverts. I honestly believe that in many cases people who score IxxP or IxxJ on traditional tests are at least as likely to be the opposite J/P type in...|||Also, I think it's kind of funny that you mentioned the possible slight correlation between the N/S and P/J scales as though it's somehow relevant. Even if they are broadly correlated, that says...|||If the dichotomies are all independent scales that isn't necessary. The idea that introverts as a rule are softer than extroverts is obviously not true. As we've been over before, it's also very...|||Reviving an old thread here but I don't agree with this at all. I think E/I could be equally hard or soft depending on the person. For example a bubbly, fluffy, chatty ENFJ is going to be way,...|||You made multiple typos in the same post in a manner that was too consistent to seem coincidental, asshole. First you say that INTJs don't do well with extroverted thinking despite it being the...|||It's all right, I just don't care for people presuming to know me better than I do (again--Fi), certainly not random people on the internet. I was probably a bit too harsh in response myself...|||TL;DR: I like Belle and will type her whatever type I think I am.  The idea that Belle is anything but an INF is pretty ridiculous on its face. INFJ I could maybe see an argument for, but not...|||Uh... no.    I'm not looking only at the inferior to judge, I am looking at the whole picture, the dynamics of the functions in the stack (including the repression of the inferior) is the entire...|||Is it really any different from the animated version?  In that it was:  Belle - INFP Beast - INTJ Gaston - ESTP Candle - ESFP Clock - ISTJ|||I don't think even Socionics does that. Though honestly I don't even know what the fuck to make of Socionics, I decided I wasn't going to take it seriously as soon as I heard about visual...|||Uh... what the fuck are you talking about? INTJ second function is extroverted thinking, INFJ is extroverted feeling.|||Either INFJ who spent much of his early years in the grip of inferior Se or ISTP who integrated Ni-Fe functions really well later in his life. I have no doubt what his function axes (Ni-Se and Ti-Fe)...|||As I've explained elsewhere, the inferior function is the least conscious, the least accessible, the most alien to a person, the blind spot that is repressed. So having the most distant connection...|||I get it, xNTJs are often pretty damn arrogant. But ExTPs can also be extremely arrogant. Though I suppose in the former case it comes across more as true arrogance that gets under people's skins,...|||Well yes, it's a product of inferior Ni. The desire to present everything as the best, the biggest, the boldest, the flashiest -- that kind of ridiculous hyperbole (Trump himself called it...|||It absolutely boggles my mind that there are people who cannot see that Trump is the living embodiment of Se, specifically ESTP.  Like, how is there still any debate about this? Trump is not Te....|||Guten tag! Sehr gut logic, mein freund.  https://media1.britannica.com/eb-media/58/129958-004-C9B8B89D.jpg  Also he, you know, didn't actually win the popular vote and was only elected...|||You stole my line.|||Even if that is the case (and I'm not sure why you say it is), is the fact that Snape--the Half-Blood Prince--clearly disregarded the by-the-book instructions, came up with his own innovative and...|||Not really, as the lower functions (at least or especially the inferior--there is debate about the role of the tertiary that I won't get into here as it's not relevant) are suppressed. They are the...|||Mike is clearly an INTP. Jay is probably more INFP. Both are snarky pretentious geeks who love to over-think films, but Jay is usually a lot softer. God only knows what the fuck Rich Evans is. ...|||I've changed my mind, decided I'm an INTJ after all. The Te-Fi axis seems to be undeniably present in me despite my attempts to rationalize it as a product of dominant Ti, and I think I have inferior...|||I don't agree with any of this. It's completely inconsistent with his characterization in the series. Yoda, a 900-year-old sage we are meant to accept as a source of ultimate wisdom, and who has...|||I start writing and figure it out as I go. This has never failed me.|||Personality is not nearly as stable across the lifespan as some believe.  Children and adolescents, in general, are more extroverted, more open, and less conscientious. (i.e. Are pulled more in the...|||I'll put explanations next to typings that go against the consensus or are otherwise unconventional.  Qui-Gon: INFJ  Obi-Wan: INFJ (He acts more like an ISTJ in the prequels - Stern, irritable,...|||To return to the OP: The reason some say he has been typed as ISFP is that for some inexplicable reason he was listed as one on some early internet type pages. I can't find any of them still standing...|||I'm going to be serious myself for a second. You can argue that Trump is smart in the same kind of way a lot of sociopaths (and ESTPs) are smart: Good at manipulating and conning gullible idiots. ...|||https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ztVMib1T4T4|||The point is he's accusing people of being retarded self-typed sensors simply for not agreeing with him (which in his mind means you're dumber than him), implying S is inherently retarded unlike...|||Again, I do not see what there is to interpret. It is clear. YOU are the one who evidently does not understand what you read. Let's break it down again.    He's not entirely wrong, but...|||No. No it was definitely sweeping generalization.    ...What? What he said and what he meant was ABUNDANTLY, OBVIOUSLY clear in context. Like there is no doubt about it. He's saying the reason...|||No, only I am. He only thinks he is.    What is a critical hit if not calling others retarded and variations thereof, directly and indirectly?  If you mean only that my insults had more wit...|||Because it did. And notice I was still attacking only the statement, which he still had not clarified at all, not the person making the statement. He was most definitely the first to get personal....|||Uh... It's true that he thinks that, clearly.  But what he thinks sure as fuck is not actually true.|||I understand that, but he's still wrong. If he wants to start a whole new interpretation of Jung of his own, fine. But to claim that somehow the MBTI test indicates the opposite preferences for E/I...|||Jamaia So apparently you are illiterate as well then?  Let's consider the facts, slowly, since that is apparently necessary with you people.   1. It started when he said the following:   ...|||There's nothing to assume. It is an objective, verifiable fact what Myers and Briggs were intending to measure with the P/J scale (which they invented and you are now trying incoherently to...|||Oh the irony.|||By the way, this?    Yeah, that wasn't a mere relational example. The only serious validity MBTI has is its correlation to the Big Five. When that goes out the window, it all goes out the...|||Okay, you're not that bright. You've made that clear, because WE JUST FUCKING ESTABLISHED THAT HE STARTED THE WHOLE FUCKING CONFLICT AND ESCALATED IT DESPITE MY ATTEMPTS TO DE-ESCALATE IT. THIS IS...|||I treat others as they treat me, and I give their ideas only the respect they deserve. No more and no less.    How about this: Instead of being a condescending prick, why don't you actually read...|||This is objectively false and is in fact the complete opposite of reality. You are clearly woefully misinformed on this matter. Yet you have the nerve to state blatant falsehoods definitively as...|||This is not accurate. I am highly aware of the actual correlations between MBTI and Big Five. MBTI N correlates with Openness. Not P. Neither correlate to Extroversion (which is of course another,...|||Just to remind everyone how all this began:    So this is him literally saying that Everyone who is not the same type I think I am is a retarded idiot.  In the exact same post where he is...|||The point was that they are inseparably linked. i.e. The ideas are proof of your insanity.  I stand by this claim.|||I absolutely did not. I suggest making use of your browser's back button.    I would have if he would have defined his claim in a coherent fashion (and also presented it in a less hostile...|||I don't have a point other than that your point is bullshit. And it is so obviously bullshit on its face to literally everybody except you that attempting to seriously deconstruct it would be a...|||You know what's really funny?  You talking about proving things.  That's funny.  You know what else is funny?  Implying it's somehow less mentally healthy to not spend five years and...'