Change:
# See the License for the specific language governing permissions and # limitations under the License. <ins> # This script builds protoc-gen-gogo binary in runtime and genertates # `*/api.pb.go` from the protobuf file `*/api.proto`. # Usage: #     hack/update-generated-runtime.sh </ins> set -o errexit set -o nounset set -o pipefail

Discussion:
What would you like to be : There are many useful scripts in "". For example, I often use and for creating simple k8s cluster quickly. However, there are only few explanation or nothing how to use it. I think it becomes more useful and helpful if some instruction or guidance is explained in each script. Why is this needed: It aims and expects to increase new k8s developers by describing how to use each script. My proposal Add the following description under the copyright for each script file. Overview of the script Simple usage Supplementary explanation(This is option) Other concern I would like to know the purpose of use about hack directory. (e.g. Where to put tools for developers(therefore there is no guidance?).)
I don't know who is in charge of each scripts of hack, but if he agrees the idea of this feature request , I am going to do this task myself!!
/sig testing
I believe there is a script generating swagger/openapi specfilters under hack, but I am still struggling with it. It could be of great help if there is some how-to doc for each scripts.
this basis, why not create a file under the hack folder, because a lot of kk CIs are derived from multiple script commands under the hack. There are already 268+ files under the hack file. For contributors unfamiliar with these, these comments and instructions are helpful to them, and it is also helpful for new contributors to handle pr ci error reports.
/cc What do you think
I think it's good idea to create (It may be easy to understand if the script's explanation is described by category or use in ) Apart from that, it is helpful that the script file itself has a brief description.
When we create , it may tough work if creating it including all scripts explanation at one time. (There are many scripts and I understand only some scripts now.) Regarding , current my idea is to add a description to each script little by little and update the at the same time. This means that will be completed little by little in conjunction with adding the description of each script. In the future, if someone create new script in hack, he also may have to add description of his script into
Self-documenting commands sound useful. A high level overview also sounds useful.

/cc /cc Regarding adding help information, I suggest that we can submit pr in one or several files as a unit, so that we can track and statistics. For the documentation, I think it should be concise and not too long. How about this advice? We can claim tasks through , the pr title yes , i agree with you. [x] kubernetes/hack/benchmark- [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] kubernetes/hack/boilerplate/BUILD [ ] kubernetes/hack/boilerplate/test/BUILD [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] kubernetes/hack/BUILD [x] kubernetes/hack/build- [x] kubernetes/hack/build- [x] [ ] kubernetes/hack/conformance/BUILD [ ] [x] kubernetes/hack/dev-build-and- [x] kubernetes/hack/dev-build-and- [x] kubernetes/hack/dev-push- [ ] kubernetes/hack/e2e-internal/BUILD [ ] kubernetes/hack/e2e-internal/e2e-cluster- [ ] kubernetes/hack/e2e-internal/e2e- [ ] kubernetes/hack/e2e-internal/e2e-grow- [ ] kubernetes/hack/e2e-internal/e2e-shrink- [ ] kubernetes/hack/e2e-internal/e2e- [ ] kubernetes/hack/e2e-internal/e2e- [x] kubernetes/hack/e2e-node- [ ] kubernetes/hack/generate- [x] kubernetes/hack/generate- [ ] kubernetes/hack/gen-swagger-doc/gen-swagger- [x] kubernetes/hack/get- [x] kubernetes/hack/ginkgo- [x] kubernetes/hack/grab- [x] kubernetes/hack/install- [ ] kubernetes/hack/jenkins/benchmark- [ ] kubernetes/hack/jenkins/OWNERS [ ] [ ] kubernetes/hack/jenkins/test- [ ] kubernetes/hack/jenkins/verify- [ ] kubernetes/hack/lib/BUILD [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [x] kubernetes/hack/lint- [x] kubernetes/hack/list-feature- [x] kubernetes/hack/local-up- [ ]

kubernetes/hack/make-rules/BUILD [ ] kubernetes/hack/make- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/BUILD [ ] kubernetes/hack/make- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/skipme/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/skipme/subsubdir/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/skipme/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/subdir/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/testdata/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/testdata/subsubdir/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/testdata/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/underscore/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/underscore/subsubdir/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/underscore/README [ ]

kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-with-gofiles/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/helpers/go2make/testdata/dir-without-gofiles/README [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/Makefile.manifest [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/make- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/test- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/test-e2e- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/test-e2e- [x] kubernetes/hack/make-rules/test- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make- [ ] kubernetes/hack/make- [ ] kubernetes/hack/OWNERS [x] kubernetes/hack/pin- [x] kubernetes/hack/print-workspace- [x] kubernetes/hack/run-in- [ ] kubernetes/hack/testdata/auth- [x] [x] [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/CRD/foo-- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/CRD/foo-deleted- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/CRD/foo-updated- [x] [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/CRD/multi-crd-list-- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/CRD/multi-crd-list-deleted- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/CRD/multi-crd-list-updated- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/CRD/multi-crd- [x] [x] [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/deployment-label- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/deployment-label- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/deployment-label- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/deployment-multicontainer- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/deployment- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/deployment- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/deployment- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/deployment-with- [x] [x] [x] [x] [x] [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/filter/pod-apply- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/filter/pod-dont- [x]

kubernetes/hack/testdata/frontend- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/frontend- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/invalid-rc-with-empty- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/kubernetes- [x] [x] [x] [x] [x] [ ] kubernetes/hack/testdata/multi-resource- [ ] kubernetes/hack/testdata/multi-resource-json- [ ] kubernetes/hack/testdata/multi-resource- [ ] kubernetes/hack/testdata/multi-resource-list- [ ] kubernetes/hack/testdata/multi-resource- [ ] kubernetes/hack/testdata/multi-resource-rclist- [ ] kubernetes/hack/testdata/multi-resource- [ ] kubernetes/hack/testdata/multi-resource-svclist- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/multi-resource-yaml- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/multi-resource- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/null-propagation/deployment- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/null-propagation/deployment- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/OWNERS [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/pod- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/pod- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/pod-with-api- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/pod-with-large- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/pod-with- [x] [x] [x] [x] [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/prune- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/prune- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/recursive/deployment/deployment/nginx- [x] [x] [x] [x] [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/recursive/pod/pod/busybox- [x] [x] [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/recursive/pod- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/recursive/pod-modify/pod/busybox- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/recursive/pod- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/recursive/pod- [x] [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/recursive/rc/rc/busybox- [x] [x] [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/redis-slave- [x]

kubernetes/hack/testdata/retainKeys/deployment/deployment- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/retainKeys/deployment/deployment- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/rollingupdate-daemonset- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/rollingupdate- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/rollingupdate-statefulset- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/rollingupdate- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/scale-deploy-1.yaml [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/scale-deploy-2.yaml [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/scale-deploy-3.yaml [x] [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/service- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/service- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/sorted-pods/sorted- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/sorted-pods/sorted- [x] kubernetes/hack/testdata/sorted-pods/sorted- [ ] [ ] [x] kubernetes/hack/test- [ ] kubernetes/hack/test- [x] kubernetes/hack/update- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update- [x] kubernetes/hack/update- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-generated-api-compatibility- [x] kubernetes/hack/update-generated-device-plugin- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-generated-device- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-generated- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-generated-kms- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-generated- [x] kubernetes/hack/update-generated-kubelet-plugin-registration- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-generated-kubelet-plugin- [x] kubernetes/hack/update-generated-pod-resources- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-generated-pod- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-generated-protobuf- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-generated- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-generated-runtime- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-generated- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-generated-swagger- [x] kubernetes/hack/update- [x] kubernetes/hack/update-import- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-openapi- [x] kubernetes/hack/update- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-vendor- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update- [ ] kubernetes/hack/update-workspace- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-

[x] kubernetes/hack/verify-api- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-cli- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-conformance- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-external-dependencies- [ ] kubernetes/hack/verify-flags/excluded- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-flags/OWNERS [x] kubernetes/hack/OWNERS [ ] kubernetes/hack/verify-flags- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-generated-device- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-generated- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-generated-files- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-generated- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-generated- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-generated-kubelet-plugin- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-generated-pod- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-generated- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-generated- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-generated-swagger- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-import- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-import- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-no-vendor- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-openapi- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-pkg- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-publishing- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-readonly- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-staging-meta- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-test- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-test- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-test- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-typecheck- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify- [x] kubernetes/hack/verify-vendor- [x]

kubernetes/hack/verify- [x]
i will pick up , i will do it step by step.
I agree with your idea, and thanks the checkbox to check progress. there are many scripts, so let's work together!
/assign /assign
I will pick up hack/verify-
I will pick up hack/verify-
I will pick up hack/verify- (all of verify scripts). But there are large number of scripts(over 40), I want to split it into two or three PRs.
I will pick up hack/update-
I will pick up these scripts. kubernetes/hack/benchmark- kubernetes/hack/build- kubernetes/hack/build- kubernetes/hack/dev-build-and- kubernetes/hack/dev-build-and- kubernetes/hack/dev-push- kubernetes/hack/e2e-node- kubernetes/hack/generate-
I will pick up these scripts get- ginkgo- grab- install- lint- list-feature- local-up- pin- print-workspace- run-in- test- test-
How about this now? /help Marking this tag so that others can easily access it.
This request has been marked as needing help from a contributor. Please ensure the request meets the requirements listed . If this request no longer meets these requirements, the label can be removed by commenting with the command. <detailsIn response to : How about this now? /help Marking this tag so that others can easily access it. Instructions for interacting with me using PR comments are available . If you have questions or suggestions related to my behavior, please file an issue against the repository. </details
I think we've finished adding simple explanations to the almost scripts. It seems that several scripts of update- does not complete yet. I think we may able to close after that work.
I will pick up these scripts:
/assign