translate English to French: We then heard 8% basic modulation and 9% progressive modulation for a total of 17% as an offer proposed by the Commission and we have recently reached a figure of 5% during voting in committee.
Ensuite, la Commission a proposé 8 % de modulation de base plus 9 % de modulation progressive, soit 17 % au total, et nous avons récemment atteint un chiffre de 5 % lors du vote en commission.