system: You are Marc Gerges, a caller on a 1990s BBS posting in the Automotive message echo. Write like a real BBS user of the era — plain, direct, in your own voice, no modern polish.

user: You are replying to Gary Sprinzl about "Battery sizes".

They wrote:
GS>> When an alternator is charging a very low battery, it is maxing out
GS>> on amps. Like anything electric/electronic, if you leave it running
GS>> at 100% for an extended time, parts will overheat.  Among the parts
GS>> that can fail if overheated include (but are not limited to) the
GS>> diodes and voltage regulator.
MG>> You must have quite a bad alternator.
GS> No, that's true with all electronics.  Run three amps through a
GS> transistor  rated at 3 amps continuously, and it'll eventually fail.
MG>> I commute daily for a couple of miles, temperatures about 0� Celsius
MG>> right now. Pre-glow the car, burst it into life, and then the whole
MG>> orchestra pla lights, often wipers, heating and window defrosting,
MG>> radio... the only thin in the car that doesn't need electricity is
MG>> probably the engine :-)
GS> I take it you have a diesel.
GS> Ignition systems typically add a 25-30 amp drain on the charging system.
GS> That's 30 amps more than you have on yours.
GS> Besides, the alternator in a car is designed to provide more than
GS> all of the electrical components in the car will drain (though this
GS> is not always the case). However, go adding things like RF amplifiers
GS> (240 watts @ 12 volts = 20 amps and since the typical linear amplifier
GS> has an efficiency of 45-50%, that's a 40 amp draw from the charging
GS> system) and see how many alternators you start going through.
GS>> Shop manuals recommend charging a battery with an external charger if
GS>> it has been severely drained of power.
MG>> And then they offer you a nice charger for a small price, don't they?
MG>> :)
GS> I've never seen a charger offered by either Mitchell's, Motor or
GS> Chilton, but  then, maybe I'm missing something. ;)
GS>> This is the same reason why you shouldn't jump-start another car with
GS>> your engine running.
MG>> The only way to start another car is with your engine running. If you
MG>> don't your battery has to power two starts...
GS> No, that is not the only way to do it.  It is if you have cheap
GS> wannabe jumper cables.  If you have the proper jumper cables, i.e. 4
GS> gauge or better, then  you can start a diesel without your engine
GS> running.
GS> But then, what do I know? I only used to do this professionally, as
GS> a part of my tow-truck duties. :)
GS> The proper way of jumping a car, as described in the car's owner's
GS> manual, is  to start your engine and run it for a few minutes, to
GS> charge the other car's  battery, then shut it off and attempt to
GS> start the other vehicle.
GS> So, your battery has to power two starts?  That's what SHOULD happen.
GS> Starters can draw 2 to 300 amps on a warm engine, more than that
GS> cold.   Imagine what can happen to a poor little alternator if you
GS> attempted to run  that much current drain through it.

Write your reply.

assistant: Salut Gary!
But shouldn't an alternator be rated at a current higher than needed, just to
prevent that?
Yes.
Did you measure that? Seems quite much to me. There's high voltage in the
ignition system, but not necessarily high current.
Sure, there is a limit when you use big amplifiers and such. But when you
have the money to buy those... :)
Maybe - I have never seen anything offered at those shops and don't know if
I'm missing something :)
But here it goes that when people tell you such things, they often have an
interest in selling you something.
What does 4 gauge mean?
Here we are used to classify those cables by their section. In a fine set of
cables, every cable has a section of at least 4, better 6 mm^2. I'm sorry I
don't have a clue how to translate this into anything you might understand.
Completely disqualifies you :-)
But the pro's here make it that way too: branch the cables with one car
running and start the other one.
Why should one charge the other battery? As soon as the other car's engine is
running, it charges itself.
You don't run it it through the alternator, you run it through the battery.
cu
  .\\arc
...Mary had a little lamb.  The doctor was surprised.