During an immune response, type I interferon (IFN-I) signaling induces a wide range of changes, including those which are required to overcome viral infection and those which suppress cytotoxic T cells to avoid immunopathology. During certain bacterial infections, IFN-I signaling exerts largely detrimental effects. Although the IFN-I family of proteins all share one common receptor, biologic responses to signaling vary depending on IFN-I subtype. Here, we asked if one IFN-I subtype dominates the pro-bacterial effect of IFN-I signaling and found that control of Listeria monocytogenes (L.m.) infection is more strongly suppressed by IFN-β than IFN-α.