Theorem: LRAT.DefaultFormula.confirmRupHint_preserves_invariant_helper
Proof state before:
case inl.intro
n : Nat
f : DefaultFormula n
f_assignments_size : f.assignments.size = n
acc : Array Assignment × List (Literal (PosFin n)) × Bool × Bool
hsize : acc.fst.size = n
l : Literal (PosFin n)
ih : f.derivedLits_invariant f_assignments_size acc.fst hsize acc.snd.fst
h : ¬hasAssignment l.snd acc.fst[l.fst.val]! = true
hsize'✝ : (acc.fst.modify l.fst.val (addAssignment l.snd)).size = n :=
  Eq.mpr (id (congrArg (fun _a => _a = n) Array.modify_preserves_size)) hsize
i : Fin n
i_in_bounds : ↑i < acc.fst.size
l_in_bounds : l.fst.val < acc.fst.size
h1 : acc.fst[↑i] = f.assignments[↑i]
h2 : ∀ (l : Literal (PosFin n)), l ∈ acc.snd.fst → l.fst.val ≠ ↑i
⊢ let_fun i_lt_assignments_size := ⋯;
  let_fun i_lt_f_assignments_size := ⋯;
  let assignments_i := (acc.fst.modify l.fst.val (addAssignment l.snd))[↑i];
  let fassignments_i := f.assignments[↑i];
  (assignments_i = fassignments_i ∧ ∀ (l_1 : Literal (PosFin n)), l_1 ∈ l :: acc.snd.fst → l_1.fst.val ≠ ↑i) ∨
    (∃ j,
        ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).fst.val = ↑i ∧
          assignments_i = addAssignment ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).snd fassignments_i ∧
            ¬hasAssignment ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).snd fassignments_i = true ∧
              ∀ (k : Fin (l :: acc.snd.fst).length), k ≠ j → ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get k).fst.val ≠ ↑i) ∨
      ∃ j1 j2,
        ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j1).fst.val = ↑i ∧
          ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j2).fst.val = ↑i ∧
            ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j1).snd = true ∧
              ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j2).snd = false ∧
                assignments_i = both ∧
                  fassignments_i = unassigned ∧
                    ∀ (k : Fin (l :: acc.snd.fst).length), k ≠ j1 → k ≠ j2 → ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get k).fst.val ≠ ↑i

case inr.inl.intro.intro.intro.intro
n : Nat
f : DefaultFormula n
f_assignments_size : f.assignments.size = n
acc : Array Assignment × List (Literal (PosFin n)) × Bool × Bool
hsize : acc.fst.size = n
l : Literal (PosFin n)
ih : f.derivedLits_invariant f_assignments_size acc.fst hsize acc.snd.fst
h : ¬hasAssignment l.snd acc.fst[l.fst.val]! = true
hsize'✝ : (acc.fst.modify l.fst.val (addAssignment l.snd)).size = n :=
  Eq.mpr (id (congrArg (fun _a => _a = n) Array.modify_preserves_size)) hsize
i : Fin n
i_in_bounds : ↑i < acc.fst.size
l_in_bounds : l.fst.val < acc.fst.size
j : Fin acc.snd.fst.length
j_eq_i : (acc.snd.fst.get j).fst.val = ↑i
h1 : acc.fst[↑i] = addAssignment (acc.snd.fst.get j).snd f.assignments[↑i]
h2 : ¬hasAssignment (acc.snd.fst.get j).snd f.assignments[↑i] = true
h3 : ∀ (k : Fin acc.snd.fst.length), k ≠ j → (acc.snd.fst.get k).fst.val ≠ ↑i
⊢ let_fun i_lt_assignments_size := ⋯;
  let_fun i_lt_f_assignments_size := ⋯;
  let assignments_i := (acc.fst.modify l.fst.val (addAssignment l.snd))[↑i];
  let fassignments_i := f.assignments[↑i];
  (assignments_i = fassignments_i ∧ ∀ (l_1 : Literal (PosFin n)), l_1 ∈ l :: acc.snd.fst → l_1.fst.val ≠ ↑i) ∨
    (∃ j,
        ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).fst.val = ↑i ∧
          assignments_i = addAssignment ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).snd fassignments_i ∧
            ¬hasAssignment ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).snd fassignments_i = true ∧
              ∀ (k : Fin (l :: acc.snd.fst).length), k ≠ j → ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get k).fst.val ≠ ↑i) ∨
      ∃ j1 j2,
        ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j1).fst.val = ↑i ∧
          ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j2).fst.val = ↑i ∧
            ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j1).snd = true ∧
              ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j2).snd = false ∧
                assignments_i = both ∧
                  fassignments_i = unassigned ∧
                    ∀ (k : Fin (l :: acc.snd.fst).length), k ≠ j1 → k ≠ j2 → ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get k).fst.val ≠ ↑i

case inr.inr.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro
n : Nat
f : DefaultFormula n
f_assignments_size : f.assignments.size = n
acc : Array Assignment × List (Literal (PosFin n)) × Bool × Bool
hsize : acc.fst.size = n
l : Literal (PosFin n)
ih : f.derivedLits_invariant f_assignments_size acc.fst hsize acc.snd.fst
h : ¬hasAssignment l.snd acc.fst[l.fst.val]! = true
hsize'✝ : (acc.fst.modify l.fst.val (addAssignment l.snd)).size = n :=
  Eq.mpr (id (congrArg (fun _a => _a = n) Array.modify_preserves_size)) hsize
i : Fin n
i_in_bounds : ↑i < acc.fst.size
l_in_bounds : l.fst.val < acc.fst.size
j1 j2 : Fin acc.snd.fst.length
j1_eq_i : (acc.snd.fst.get j1).fst.val = ↑i
j2_eq_i : (acc.snd.fst.get j2).fst.val = ↑i
j1_eq_true : (acc.snd.fst.get j1).snd = true
j2_eq_false : (acc.snd.fst.get j2).snd = false
h1 : acc.fst[↑i] = both
h2 : f.assignments[↑i] = unassigned
h3 : ∀ (k : Fin acc.snd.fst.length), k ≠ j1 → k ≠ j2 → (acc.snd.fst.get k).fst.val ≠ ↑i
⊢ let_fun i_lt_assignments_size := ⋯;
  let_fun i_lt_f_assignments_size := ⋯;
  let assignments_i := (acc.fst.modify l.fst.val (addAssignment l.snd))[↑i];
  let fassignments_i := f.assignments[↑i];
  (assignments_i = fassignments_i ∧ ∀ (l_1 : Literal (PosFin n)), l_1 ∈ l :: acc.snd.fst → l_1.fst.val ≠ ↑i) ∨
    (∃ j,
        ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).fst.val = ↑i ∧
          assignments_i = addAssignment ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).snd fassignments_i ∧
            ¬hasAssignment ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).snd fassignments_i = true ∧
              ∀ (k : Fin (l :: acc.snd.fst).length), k ≠ j → ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get k).fst.val ≠ ↑i) ∨
      ∃ j1 j2,
        ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j1).fst.val = ↑i ∧
          ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j2).fst.val = ↑i ∧
            ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j1).snd = true ∧
              ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j2).snd = false ∧
                assignments_i = both ∧
                  fassignments_i = unassigned ∧
                    ∀ (k : Fin (l :: acc.snd.fst).length), k ≠ j1 → k ≠ j2 → ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get k).fst.val ≠ ↑i
Tactic:
. by_cases l.1.1 = i.1
  . next l_eq_i =>
    have zero_lt_length_list : 0 < (l :: acc.snd.fst).length := by
      simp only [List.length_cons]
      exact Nat.zero_lt_succ (List.length acc.snd.fst)
    apply Or.inr ∘ Or.inl ∘ Exists.intro ⟨0, zero_lt_length_list⟩
    constructor
    . simp only [List.get, l_eq_i]
    . constructor
      . simp only [l_eq_i, Array.get_modify_at_idx i_in_bounds, List.get, h1]
      . constructor
        . simp only [List.get, Bool.not_eq_true]
          simp only [getElem!, l_in_bounds, ↓reduceDite, Array.get_eq_getElem,
            Bool.not_eq_true] at h
          simp only [l_eq_i, h1] at h
          exact h
        . intro k k_ne_zero
          have k_eq_succ : ∃ k' : Nat, ∃ k'_succ_in_bounds : k' + 1 < (l :: acc.2.1).length, k = ⟨k' + 1, k'_succ_in_bounds⟩ := by
            have k_val_ne_zero : k.1 ≠ 0 := by
              intro k_eq_zero
              simp only [List.length_cons, Nat.succ_eq_add_one, Fin.zero_eta, ne_eq] at k_ne_zero
              apply k_ne_zero
              apply Fin.eq_of_val_eq
              simp [k_eq_zero]
            rcases Nat.exists_eq_succ_of_ne_zero k_val_ne_zero with ⟨k', k_eq_k'_succ⟩
            rw [Nat.succ_eq_add_one] at k_eq_k'_succ
            have k'_succ_in_bounds : k' + 1 < (l :: acc.2.1).length := by rw [← k_eq_k'_succ]; exact k.2
            apply Exists.intro k' ∘ Exists.intro k'_succ_in_bounds
            apply Fin.eq_of_val_eq
            exact k_eq_k'_succ
          rcases k_eq_succ with ⟨k', k'_succ_in_bounds, k_eq_succ⟩
          rw [k_eq_succ, List.get_cons_succ]
          have k'_in_bounds : k' < acc.2.1.length := by
            simp only [List.length_cons, Nat.succ_eq_add_one] at k'_succ_in_bounds
            exact Nat.lt_of_succ_lt_succ k'_succ_in_bounds
          exact h2 (acc.2.1.get ⟨k', k'_in_bounds⟩) $ List.get_mem acc.snd.fst k' k'_in_bounds
  . next l_ne_i =>
    apply Or.inl
    constructor
    . rw [Array.get_modify_unchanged l_in_bounds i_in_bounds (addAssignment l.2) l_ne_i]
      exact h1
    . intro l' l'_in_list
      simp only [List.find?, List.mem_cons] at l'_in_list
      rcases l'_in_list with l'_eq_l | l'_in_acc
      . rw [l'_eq_l]
        exact l_ne_i
      . exact h2 l' l'_in_acc
Proof state after:
case inr.inl.intro.intro.intro.intro
n : Nat
f : DefaultFormula n
f_assignments_size : f.assignments.size = n
acc : Array Assignment × List (Literal (PosFin n)) × Bool × Bool
hsize : acc.fst.size = n
l : Literal (PosFin n)
ih : f.derivedLits_invariant f_assignments_size acc.fst hsize acc.snd.fst
h : ¬hasAssignment l.snd acc.fst[l.fst.val]! = true
hsize'✝ : (acc.fst.modify l.fst.val (addAssignment l.snd)).size = n :=
  Eq.mpr (id (congrArg (fun _a => _a = n) Array.modify_preserves_size)) hsize
i : Fin n
i_in_bounds : ↑i < acc.fst.size
l_in_bounds : l.fst.val < acc.fst.size
j : Fin acc.snd.fst.length
j_eq_i : (acc.snd.fst.get j).fst.val = ↑i
h1 : acc.fst[↑i] = addAssignment (acc.snd.fst.get j).snd f.assignments[↑i]
h2 : ¬hasAssignment (acc.snd.fst.get j).snd f.assignments[↑i] = true
h3 : ∀ (k : Fin acc.snd.fst.length), k ≠ j → (acc.snd.fst.get k).fst.val ≠ ↑i
⊢ let_fun i_lt_assignments_size := ⋯;
  let_fun i_lt_f_assignments_size := ⋯;
  let assignments_i := (acc.fst.modify l.fst.val (addAssignment l.snd))[↑i];
  let fassignments_i := f.assignments[↑i];
  (assignments_i = fassignments_i ∧ ∀ (l_1 : Literal (PosFin n)), l_1 ∈ l :: acc.snd.fst → l_1.fst.val ≠ ↑i) ∨
    (∃ j,
        ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).fst.val = ↑i ∧
          assignments_i = addAssignment ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).snd fassignments_i ∧
            ¬hasAssignment ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).snd fassignments_i = true ∧
              ∀ (k : Fin (l :: acc.snd.fst).length), k ≠ j → ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get k).fst.val ≠ ↑i) ∨
      ∃ j1 j2,
        ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j1).fst.val = ↑i ∧
          ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j2).fst.val = ↑i ∧
            ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j1).snd = true ∧
              ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j2).snd = false ∧
                assignments_i = both ∧
                  fassignments_i = unassigned ∧
                    ∀ (k : Fin (l :: acc.snd.fst).length), k ≠ j1 → k ≠ j2 → ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get k).fst.val ≠ ↑i

case inr.inr.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro
n : Nat
f : DefaultFormula n
f_assignments_size : f.assignments.size = n
acc : Array Assignment × List (Literal (PosFin n)) × Bool × Bool
hsize : acc.fst.size = n
l : Literal (PosFin n)
ih : f.derivedLits_invariant f_assignments_size acc.fst hsize acc.snd.fst
h : ¬hasAssignment l.snd acc.fst[l.fst.val]! = true
hsize'✝ : (acc.fst.modify l.fst.val (addAssignment l.snd)).size = n :=
  Eq.mpr (id (congrArg (fun _a => _a = n) Array.modify_preserves_size)) hsize
i : Fin n
i_in_bounds : ↑i < acc.fst.size
l_in_bounds : l.fst.val < acc.fst.size
j1 j2 : Fin acc.snd.fst.length
j1_eq_i : (acc.snd.fst.get j1).fst.val = ↑i
j2_eq_i : (acc.snd.fst.get j2).fst.val = ↑i
j1_eq_true : (acc.snd.fst.get j1).snd = true
j2_eq_false : (acc.snd.fst.get j2).snd = false
h1 : acc.fst[↑i] = both
h2 : f.assignments[↑i] = unassigned
h3 : ∀ (k : Fin acc.snd.fst.length), k ≠ j1 → k ≠ j2 → (acc.snd.fst.get k).fst.val ≠ ↑i
⊢ let_fun i_lt_assignments_size := ⋯;
  let_fun i_lt_f_assignments_size := ⋯;
  let assignments_i := (acc.fst.modify l.fst.val (addAssignment l.snd))[↑i];
  let fassignments_i := f.assignments[↑i];
  (assignments_i = fassignments_i ∧ ∀ (l_1 : Literal (PosFin n)), l_1 ∈ l :: acc.snd.fst → l_1.fst.val ≠ ↑i) ∨
    (∃ j,
        ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).fst.val = ↑i ∧
          assignments_i = addAssignment ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).snd fassignments_i ∧
            ¬hasAssignment ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j).snd fassignments_i = true ∧
              ∀ (k : Fin (l :: acc.snd.fst).length), k ≠ j → ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get k).fst.val ≠ ↑i) ∨
      ∃ j1 j2,
        ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j1).fst.val = ↑i ∧
          ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j2).fst.val = ↑i ∧
            ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j1).snd = true ∧
              ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get j2).snd = false ∧
                assignments_i = both ∧
                  fassignments_i = unassigned ∧
                    ∀ (k : Fin (l :: acc.snd.fst).length), k ≠ j1 → k ≠ j2 → ((l :: acc.snd.fst).get k).fst.val ≠ ↑i