Theorem: LRAT.DefaultFormula.insertRupUnits_preserves_assignments_invariant
Proof state before:
case inr.inl.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro
n : Nat
f : DefaultFormula n
f_readyForRupAdd : f.readyForRupAdd
units : List (Literal (PosFin n))
h :
  let assignments := (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.assignments;
  let_fun hsize := ⋯;
  let rupUnits := (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits;
  insertUnit_invariant f.assignments ⋯ rupUnits assignments hsize
hsize : (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.assignments.size = n
i : PosFin n
b : Bool
hb : hasAssignment b (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.assignments[i.val] = true
p : PosFin n → Bool
hp :
  ∀ (x : DefaultClause n),
    (some x ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.clauses.data ∨
        (∃ a,
            (a, false) ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits.data ∧ unit (a, false) = x ∨
              (a, true) ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits.data ∧ unit (a, true) = x) ∨
          ∃ a,
            (a, false) ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.ratUnits.data ∧ unit (a, false) = x ∨
              (a, true) ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.ratUnits.data ∧ unit (a, true) = x) →
      ∃ a, (a, false) ∈ Clause.toList x ∧ decide (p a = false) = true ∨ (a, true) ∈ Clause.toList x ∧ p a = true
pf : p ⊨ f
j : Fin (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits.size
b' : Bool
i_gt_zero : ↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩ > 0
h1 : (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits[j] = (⟨↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩, ⋯⟩, b')
h2 : (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.assignments[↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩] = addAssignment b' f.assignments[↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩]
h3 : ¬hasAssignment b' f.assignments[↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩] = true
h4 :
  ∀ (k : Fin (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits.size),
    k ≠ j → (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits[k].fst.val ≠ ↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩
⊢ p ⊨ (i, b)

case inr.inr.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro
n : Nat
f : DefaultFormula n
f_readyForRupAdd : f.readyForRupAdd
units : List (Literal (PosFin n))
h :
  let assignments := (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.assignments;
  let_fun hsize := ⋯;
  let rupUnits := (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits;
  insertUnit_invariant f.assignments ⋯ rupUnits assignments hsize
hsize : (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.assignments.size = n
i : PosFin n
b : Bool
hb : hasAssignment b (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.assignments[i.val] = true
p : PosFin n → Bool
hp :
  ∀ (x : DefaultClause n),
    (some x ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.clauses.data ∨
        (∃ a,
            (a, false) ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits.data ∧ unit (a, false) = x ∨
              (a, true) ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits.data ∧ unit (a, true) = x) ∨
          ∃ a,
            (a, false) ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.ratUnits.data ∧ unit (a, false) = x ∨
              (a, true) ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.ratUnits.data ∧ unit (a, true) = x) →
      ∃ a, (a, false) ∈ Clause.toList x ∧ decide (p a = false) = true ∨ (a, true) ∈ Clause.toList x ∧ p a = true
pf : p ⊨ f
j1 j2 : Fin (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits.size
i_gt_zero : ↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩ > 0
h1 : (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits[j1] = (⟨↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩, ⋯⟩, true)
h2 : (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits[j2] = (⟨↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩, ⋯⟩, false)
left✝¹ : (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.assignments[↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩] = both
left✝ : f.assignments[↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩] = unassigned
right✝ :
  ∀ (k : Fin (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits.size),
    k ≠ j1 → k ≠ j2 → (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits[k].fst.val ≠ ↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩
⊢ p ⊨ (i, b)
Tactic:
. rw [h2] at hb
  by_cases b = b'
  . next b_eq_b' =>
    let j_unit := unit (insertRupUnits f units).1.rupUnits[j]
    have j_unit_def : j_unit = unit (insertRupUnits f units).1.rupUnits[j] := rfl
    have j_unit_in_insertRupUnits_res :
      ∃ i : PosFin n,
        (i, false) ∈ (insertRupUnits f units).1.rupUnits.data ∧ unit (i, false) = j_unit ∨
        (i, true) ∈ (insertRupUnits f units).1.rupUnits.data ∧ unit (i, true) = j_unit := by
      apply Exists.intro i
      rw [j_unit_def, h1]
      by_cases hb' : b'
      . rw [hb']
        apply Or.inr
        constructor
        . have h1 : (insertRupUnits f units).fst.rupUnits[j] = (i, true) := by
            rw [hb'] at h1
            rw [h1]
            simp only [Prod.mk.injEq, and_true]
            apply Subtype.ext
            rfl
          rw [← h1]
          apply Array.getElem_mem_data
        . rfl
      . simp only [Bool.not_eq_true] at hb'
        rw [hb']
        apply Or.inl
        constructor
        . have h1 : (insertRupUnits f units).fst.rupUnits[j] = (i, false) := by
            rw [hb'] at h1
            rw [h1]
            simp only [Prod.mk.injEq, and_true]
            apply Subtype.ext
            rfl
          rw [← h1]
          apply Array.getElem_mem_data
        . rfl
    specialize hp j_unit ((Or.inr ∘ Or.inl) j_unit_in_insertRupUnits_res)
    simp only [List.any_eq_true, Prod.exists, Bool.exists_bool, Bool.decide_coe, Fin.getElem_fin, List.find?, j_unit] at hp
    simp only [Fin.getElem_fin] at h1
    rcases hp with ⟨i', hp⟩
    simp only [h1, Clause.toList, unit_eq, List.mem_singleton,
      Prod.mk.injEq] at hp
    rcases hp with ⟨hp1, hp2⟩ | ⟨hp1, hp2⟩
    . simp only [b_eq_b', ← hp1.2, HSat.eval]
      rw [hp1.1] at hp2
      exact of_decide_eq_true hp2
    . simp only [b_eq_b', ← hp1.2, HSat.eval]
      rw [hp1.1] at hp2
      exact hp2
  . next b_ne_b' =>
    apply (assignments_invariant_of_strong_assignments_invariant f f_readyForRupAdd.2).2 i b _ p pf
    have b'_def : b' = (decide ¬b = true) := by
      cases b <;> cases b' <;> simp at *
    rw [has_iff_has_of_add_complement, ← b'_def, hb]
Proof state after:
case inr.inr.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro.intro
n : Nat
f : DefaultFormula n
f_readyForRupAdd : f.readyForRupAdd
units : List (Literal (PosFin n))
h :
  let assignments := (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.assignments;
  let_fun hsize := ⋯;
  let rupUnits := (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits;
  insertUnit_invariant f.assignments ⋯ rupUnits assignments hsize
hsize : (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.assignments.size = n
i : PosFin n
b : Bool
hb : hasAssignment b (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.assignments[i.val] = true
p : PosFin n → Bool
hp :
  ∀ (x : DefaultClause n),
    (some x ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.clauses.data ∨
        (∃ a,
            (a, false) ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits.data ∧ unit (a, false) = x ∨
              (a, true) ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits.data ∧ unit (a, true) = x) ∨
          ∃ a,
            (a, false) ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.ratUnits.data ∧ unit (a, false) = x ∨
              (a, true) ∈ (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.ratUnits.data ∧ unit (a, true) = x) →
      ∃ a, (a, false) ∈ Clause.toList x ∧ decide (p a = false) = true ∨ (a, true) ∈ Clause.toList x ∧ p a = true
pf : p ⊨ f
j1 j2 : Fin (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits.size
i_gt_zero : ↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩ > 0
h1 : (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits[j1] = (⟨↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩, ⋯⟩, true)
h2 : (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits[j2] = (⟨↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩, ⋯⟩, false)
left✝¹ : (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.assignments[↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩] = both
left✝ : f.assignments[↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩] = unassigned
right✝ :
  ∀ (k : Fin (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits.size),
    k ≠ j1 → k ≠ j2 → (f.insertRupUnits units).fst.rupUnits[k].fst.val ≠ ↑⟨i.val, ⋯⟩
⊢ p ⊨ (i, b)