Jabarkan Sambutan dari She's Dating the Gangster

She's Dating the Gangster mendapatkan sambutan positif dari para penonton dan kritikus. Menurut situs pengumpul ulasan Rotten Tomatoes, film ini masih memegang 70% rating dari penonton. Philbert Ortiz-Dy dari Click the City juga memberikan ulasan positif terhadap film ini, dengan pernyataan She's Dating the Gangster is at its best when it allows kids to be kids. Its portrayal of young, intensely romantic love is really charming, especially placed as it is in this wacky conception of its period setting.