Jabarkan Canadian Comedy Awards dari Michael Cera

2008 Menang Best Performance by a Male - Film (Canadian Comedy Award) lewat film Superbad

Chicago Film Critics Association Awards

2007 Menang Most Promising Performer (CFCA Award) lewat film Juno dan Superbad

2008 Nominasi Best Kiss (MTV Movie Award) lewat film Juno berbagi dengan Ellen Page

2008 Nominasi Best Male Performance (MTV Movie Award) lewat film Juno

2008 Nominasi Breakthrough Performance (MTV Movie Award) lewat film Superbad

2010 Menang Best Actor in a Motion Picture, Comedy or Musical (Satellite Award) lewat film Scott Pilgrim vs. the World

2008 Nominasi Best Actor in a Motion Picture, Comedy or Musical (Satellite Award) lewat film Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist