Jabarkan Daftar Penitensiaria Mayor dari Penitensiaria Apostolik

Tommaso da Capua (1219 — 1239 or 1243)

William of Modena (ca. 1244-1251)

Pierre de Tarentaise (ca. 1273-1276)

Raymond de Chameyrac (not a cardinal) (1326-1328)

Alessandro Vincioli di Perugia (not a cardinal) (1328-1332)

(1367-1370 – data tidak ditemukan, kemungkinan kosong)

Pedro Luis de Borja-Lanzol de Romaní (1503-1511)

Leonardo Grosso della Rovere (1511-1520)

Ranuccio Farnese, O. S. Io. Hieros. (1547-1565)

Antonio Marcello Barberini, O.F.M.Cap. (1633-1646)

Fabrizio Paolucci, pro-penitentiary (1709-1710); penitentiary (1710-1721)

Bernardo Maria Conti, O.S.B.Cas. (1721-1730)

Vincenzo Petra, pro-penitentiary (1730); penitentiary (1730-1747)

Antonio Andrea Galli, C.R.SS.S. (1755-1767)

Castruccio Castracane degli Antelminelli (1839-1852)

Antonio Maria Cagiano de Azevedo (1860-1867)

Antonio Maria Panebianco, O.F.M.Conv. (1867-1877)

Raffaele Monaco La Valletta (1884-1896)

Serafino Cardinal Vannutelli (20 November 1899 - 19 Agustus 1915)

Willem Marinus Cardinal van Rossum, CSSR (1 Oktober 1915 - 12 Maret 1918)

Oreste Cardinal Giorgi (12 Maret 1918 - 30 Desember 1924)

Andreas Franz Cardinal Frühwirth, O.P. (8 Januari 1925 - 31 Juli 1927)

Lorenzo Cardinal Lauri (31 Juli 1927 - 8 Oktober 1941)

Nicola Cardinal Canali (15 Oktober 1941 - 3 Agustus 1961)

Arcadio Maria Cardinal Larraona Saralegui, C.M.F. (13 Agustus 1961 - 2 Februari 1962)

Fernando Cardinal Cento (12 Februari 1962 - 7 April 1967)

Giuseppe Antonio Cardinal Ferretto (7 April 1967 - 1 Maret 1973)

Giuseppe Cardinal Paupini (21 Maret 1973 - 8 April 1984)

Luigi Cardinal Dadaglio (Pro-Major Penitentiary: 8 April 1984 - 27 Mei 1985; Major Penitentiary: 27 Mei 1985 - 6 April 1990)

William Wakefield Cardinal Baum (6 April 1990 - 11 November 2001)