instruction:
In this task, you will be presented with a context from an academic paper and a question separated with a 
. You have to answer the question based on the context.
question:
$Coherence@k$ has been shown to have high correlation with human interpretability of topics learned via various topic modeling methods BIBREF7 . Hence, we can expect interpretable embeddings by maximizing it. For evaluating the interpretability, we use $Coherence@k$ (Equation 6 ) , automated and manual word intrusion tests. 
 Question: How do they evaluate interpretability?
answer:
For evaluating the interpretability, we use $Coherence@k$ (Equation 6 ) , automated and manual word intrusion tests.


question:
We present a comparison of the proposed models to existing word embeddings approaches. These are: the Bernoulli embeddings (b-emb) BIBREF1 , continuous bag-of-words (CBOW) BIBREF5 , Distributed Memory version of Paragraph Vector (PV-DM) BIBREF11 and the Global Vectors (GloVe) BIBREF6 model. 
 Question: What word embeddings do they test?
answer:
Bernoulli embeddings (b-emb) BIBREF1 , continuous bag-of-words (CBOW) BIBREF5 , Distributed Memory version of Paragraph Vector (PV-DM) BIBREF11 and the Global Vectors (GloVe) BIBREF6 model


question:
We compared our model with MLE, RL and GAN baselines. Since COCO and EMNLP2017 WMT don't have input while WeiboDial regards posts as input, we chose the following baselines respectively:

MLE: a RNN model trained with MLE objective BIBREF4 . Its extension, Seq2Seq, can work on the dialogue dataset BIBREF2 .

SeqGAN: The first text GAN model that updates the generator with policy gradient based on the rewards from the discriminator BIBREF7 .

LeakGAN: A variant of SeqGAN that provides rewards based on the leaked information of the discriminator for the generator BIBREF11 .

MaliGAN: A variant of SeqGAN that optimizes the generator with a normalized maximum likelihood objective BIBREF8 .

IRL: This inverse reinforcement learning method replaces the discriminator with a reward approximator to provide dense rewards BIBREF12 .

RAML: A RL approach to incorporate MLE objective into RL training framework, which regards BLEU as rewards BIBREF17 .

DialogGAN: An extension of SeqGAN tuned to dialogue generation task with MLE objective added to the adversarial objective BIBREF16 .

DPGAN: A variant of DialogGAN which uses a language model based discriminator and regards cross-entropy as rewards BIBREF13 . 
 Question: What GAN models were used as baselines to compare against?
answer:

MLE SeqGAN LeakGAN MaliGAN IRL RAML DialogGAN DPGAN