instruction:
You will be given a context, a subject and a relation. Your task is to generate a question based on the subject and relation. The generated question should include the given subject. Try to use a minimum number of words that are not present in either context, subject or relation while generating question.
question:
Context : Ralph H. Spanjer (September 20, 1920 -- February 8, 1999) was a Major General in the United States Marine Corps. 
Subject : Ralph H. Spanjer 
Relation : military branch
answer:
In what military branch did Ralph H. Spanjer serve?


question:
Context : The Muppet Christmas Carol is a 1992 American musical fantasy-comedy film and an adaptation of Charles Dickens's 1843 novel A Christmas Carol. 
Subject : The Muppet Christmas Carol 
Relation : based on
answer:
Which is the basis of The Muppet Christmas Carol?


question:
Context : Alexandre Dumoulin (born 24 August 1989) is a French rugby union player. 
Subject : Alexandre Dumoulin 
Relation : occupation
answer:

What was Alexandre Dumoulin's occupation?