In this task, you're given an ambiguous question (which can be answered in more than one way). Your task is to write a question that clarifies the given question in such a way that the generated question has one unique answer.

Q: What is the marginal rate of tax in ireland?

A: What is the marginal rate of tax in ireland for a person age 65+ earning under €18,000 per year?
****
Q: When did the earth and solar system form?

A: When did the Solar System form?
****
Q: When does attack on titan season 2 take place?

A:
When does attack on titan season 2 release originally take place?
****