In this task, you are given a second sentence. Your task is to generate the first sentence on the same topic but incoherent and inconsistent with the second sentence.

[Q]: However , the son himself has stated that there is no truth in this story .
[A]: There is a myth that the railway was closed after a kidnap attempt on the owner 's son and that the operating capital for the following season was employed in effecting his return .


[Q]: However , Borglum realized that the eroded Needles were too thin to support sculpting .
[A]: The original plan was to make the carvings in granite pillars known as the Needles .


[Q]: However , after Bury signed James Vaughan from Birmingham City , Clark was deemed surplus to requirement and allowed to leave Gigg Lane , having made only 4 competitive appearances .
[A]:
Clark made his debut for Bury in a 2 -- 0 victory over Charlton on 6 August 2016 .