You will be given a context, a subject and a relation. Your task is to generate a question based on the subject and relation. The generated question should include the given subject. Try to use a minimum number of words that are not present in either context, subject or relation while generating question.

Q: Context : Joseph Tarbell (about 1780 -- 24 November 1815) was an officer in the United States Navy during the First Barbary War and the War of 1812. 
Subject : Joseph Tarbell 
Relation : military branch

A: With which military branch did Joseph Tarbell serve with?
****
Q: Context : NGC 5548 is approximately 245 million light years away and appears in the constellation Boötes. 
Subject : NGC 5548 
Relation : constellation

A: The star NGC 5548 is part of what constellation?
****
Q: Context : The fictional Aramis is loosely based on the historical musketeer Henri d'Aramitz. 
Subject : Aramis 
Relation : based on

A:
The Aramis is based upon what?
****