In this task, you are given two natural language statements with similar wording. You must choose the statement that makes less sense based on common sense knowledge. A '
' separates the statements. Use "first" or "second" to indicate which sentence makes less sense.

[EX Q]: The cat ate a treat
The cat ate a horse
[EX A]: second

[EX Q]: Four people can play simultaneously on the xbox 360 with four controllers
one spider can play on the xbox 360 with four controllers
[EX A]: second

[EX Q]: She turned the volume on the TV up, and it got quieter
She turned the volume on the TV up, and it got louder
[EX A]:
first