Given a sentence and two mentions from the text (arguments), indicate a phrase (a verb or noun phrase) that describes the relationship between the provided arguments.
--------
Question: Sentence: 'Lord of the Rings star Dominic Monaghan will play an 18th century gravedigger and Hellboy star Ron Perlman is attached to play his priest for the Indie?horror flick I Sell the Dead .', Argument/Subject 1: 'ron perlman', Argument/Subject 2: 'hellboy'

Answer: star as


Question: Sentence: '1860 - Lincoln is elected the 16th President of the United States , the first Republican , receiving 180 of 303 possible electoral votes and 40 percent of the popular vote , with the South voting almost solidly against him .', Argument/Subject 1: 'lincoln', Argument/Subject 2: 'unite state'

Answer: be elect president of


Question: Sentence: 'Microsoft Windows Vista is a registered trademark of Microsoft Corporation and screen shots are reprinted by their permission .', Argument/Subject 1: 'window', Argument/Subject 2: 'microsoft'

Answer:
be trademark of