"Yes, and" is a rule-of-thumb in improvisational comedy that suggests that a participant in a dialogue should accept what another participant has stated ("Yes") and then expand on that line of thought or context ("and..."). Given a prompt and two responses, identify which response is the type of "yes, and". Indicate your answer by 'Response 1' if the first response is correct, otherwise 'Response 2'.  Note that a "Yes, and" does not require someone explicitly saying 'yes, and...' as part of a dialogue exchange.

Q: Prompt: I like your shoes. 
 Response 1: That didn't work until now, so you probably should have told me sooner that you secretly were this rock star, because I would have loved you a lot longer now. 
 Response 2: They're not for sale.

A: Response 2
****
Q: Prompt: Now that you mention it, I don't either. I thought it was your idea. 
 Response 1: I thought it was your idea. This is like that time we went to Lake Tahoe. 
 Response 2: Right. I can tell you that he's disguised as Mary, my make-up lady, who is also disguised as various things. She's got a gorilla mask on and a Superman costume.

A: Response 1
****
Q: Prompt: Wait, can I say something? You're saying they don't eat wet hay? But you can tell from my story they do. 
 Response 1: Well it sounds like she enjoyed it, it doesn't mean that it's necessarily what she's supposed to be eating. 
 Response 2: Thank goodness. That felt terrible.

A:
Response 1
****