instruction:
Given a sentence and two mentions from the text (arguments), indicate a phrase (a verb or noun phrase) that describes the relationship between the provided arguments.
question:
Sentence: 'Oklahoma City -- Governor Brad Henry announced today that Oklahoma Department of Emergency Management Director Albert Ashwood has been appointed to a new U.S. Homeland Security oversight team .', Argument/Subject 1: 'director', Argument/Subject 2: 'governor'
answer:
be appoint by


question:
Sentence: 'Clarence was recently elected Chair of the Vancouver School Board in December 2007 .', Argument/Subject 1: 'board', Argument/Subject 2: 'chair'
answer:
elect


question:
Sentence: 'Lincoln is named MVP after gaining 121 yards in 14 carries as West defeats East 27-14 in front of 20,016 persons in AFL All-Star game in Balboa Stadium .', Argument/Subject 1: 'east', Argument/Subject 2: 'west'
answer:

defeat