You are given a review of Amazon's food products. Your task is to divide them into two classes: negative or positive, depending on the content of the review.

Q: Don't know much to say except they smelled funny upon opening the bag and neither of our 2 dogs would go anywhere near them.

A: Negative
****
Q: Complete, protein-based nutrition.  My dogs love this...although I'm not sure the pibble actually tastes it, she inhales it so fast.  ;)  Regarding the other users who have had diarrhea issues:  My gastro-picky GSD (is that a word? I think other GSD owners will understand!) has had this as well.  Initially, I overfed this food, thinking that he needed to be eating the same amount as he had been eating the other stuff. You feed MUCH less of this product.  It is nutrient-dense, and not all filler like other foods.  If you over-feed, you increase the risk of unpleasant side effects.  It's a bit pricey, and I haven't broken down the cost per day, but since you feed less it might be competitive with other brands if someone was inclined to "run the numbers".

A: Positive
****
Q: Consumers Beware of Greenie products for dogs or cats. It contains a very toxic ingriedant called, Menadione Sodium Bisulfite {MSB},which is a synthetic {man made} form of Vitamin K3 and causes cancer, organ damage {kidneys,lungs,liver,and mucous membranes}. It is also in almost All dry and canned pet foods. Chech your ingredients on All of your pet treats and foods. This will kill your pets. Check to see if BHA,BHT,and propylne glycol are listed in your treats and foods, both dry and canned. These Will Kill pets.

A:
Negative
****