From the given sentence, extract the phrase (often noun or verb) that carries the given relationship. The generated phrase should be present in the sentence.

[Q]: Given Relationship: 'appear in', Sentence: 'The Bible is clear that Balaam was priest of God having a place within the sons of Abraham and to whom the Angel of Yahovah appeared .'
[A]: appeared


[Q]: Given Relationship: 'lose to', Sentence: 'John McCain agreed to carry on the FRP-Republican Party agreement , but lost to Barack Obama .'
[A]: lost


[Q]: Given Relationship: 'be member of', Sentence: 'Rutgers University is a leader among public research institutions , a member of the Association of American Universities with 48,000 students on campuses in three cities .'
[A]:
member