You will be given three sentences. Read them, then identify a noun phrase (person, place, or thing) or event that is shared between all three sentences. As the output, write the span of the text corresponding to that phrase in each sentence. Keep the order of the sentences, that is, your answer should look like: 1: *a phras from sentence 1e* 2: *a phras from sentence 2* 3: *a phrase from sentence 3*

Q: 1: The prosecutor repeatedly thanked the public for the information that led to the arrest . 2: He also said that , because of the public 's assistance in the case , police were able to serve a search warrant on Williams ' residence where they seized a.40 - caliber handgun ,  which has been tied to the shell casings that were recovered  at the scene of the shooting . 3: Prosecutor thanks public for leading police to .40 - caliber allegedly used in shooting .

A: 1: The prosecutor 2: He 3: Prosecutor
****
Q: 1:  And then when the opportunity arose , he attacked the officer ,  Bukowski said , noting that Taylor  attacked from the side  around 3 a.m .  Beat him , choked him .  2: That officer is now in an intensive care unit at St . Mary 's Hospital in Kankakee , Bukowski said . 3: Sheriff : The correctional officer is in intensive care after being beaten , choked .

A: 1: the officer 2: That officer 3: The correctional officer
****
Q: 1: Engraved with the words ,  Darling Joe , Happy 70th Birthday 2009 . 2: Love Jenny ,  the antique ring lodged in the rocks clearly meant something to both Joe and Jenny . 3: Words engraved on the antique ring give clues to its owner 's identity .

A:
1: Darling Joe 2: Joe 3: its owner 's
****