From the given sentence, extract the phrase (often noun or verb) that carries the given relationship. The generated phrase should be present in the sentence.
--------
Question: Given Relationship: 'be province of', Sentence: 'B.C. is the third province in Canada -- after Ontario and Quebec -- to offer such a program .'

Answer: province


Question: Given Relationship: 'appoint member of', Sentence: 'Members of the Committee shall be appointed by the Board on the recommendation of the Nominations Committee .'

Answer: appointed


Question: Given Relationship: 'beat', Sentence: 'The perfect storm occurred for Utah to finish on top -- Florida struggling to beat Oklahoma -- but pollsters were still not convinced Utah deserved the top ranking .'

Answer:
beat