1894–95 FA Cup First Round Proper First Round Proper

| Tie_no | Home_team | Score | Away_team | Date_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 | Small Heath | 1–2 | West Bromwich Albion | 2 February 1895 |
| 13 | Sheffield United | 3–1 | Millwall Athletic | 2 February 1895 |
| 14 | Southampton St Mary`s | 1–4 | Nottingham Forest | 2 February 1895 |
| 15 | Newcastle United | 2–1 | Burnley | 2 February 1895 |
| 16 | Barnsley St Peter`s | 2 -v- 1 (Match void) | Liverpool | 2 February 1895 |
| Replay | Liverpool | 4–0 | Barnsley St Peter`s | 11 February 1895 |