1931 College Football All-America Team NCAA consensus All-American team NCAA consensus All-American team

| Position_ | Name_ | School | Unanimous | College_Hall_of_Fame |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ends | Jerry Dalrymple Vernon “Catfish” Smith | Tulane Georgia | Yes No | Dalrymple HOF Profile Smith HOF Profile |
| Tackles | Dallas “Dal” Marvil Jess Quatse Jack Riley | Northwestern Pittsburgh Northwestern | No No No | No No Riley HOF Profile |
| Guards | Clarence “Biggie” Munn John “Johnny” Baker | Minnesota Southern California | No No | Munn HOF Profile Baker HOF Profile |
| Center | Thomas Yarr | Notre Dame | No | Yarr HOF Profile |
| Quarterback | Barry Wood | Harvard | No | Wood HOF Profile |
| Halfbacks | Marchmont Marchy Schwartz Ernest “Pug” Rentner | Notre Dame Northwestern | No No | Schwartz HOF Profile Rentner HOF Profile |
| Fullback | Gaius Shaver | Southern California | No | No |