2008–09 FA Cup Qualifying Rounds Extra preliminary round Replays

| Tie_no | Home_team | Score | Away_team | Attendance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | Billingham Synthonia | 5–1 | Glasshoughton Welfare | 103 |
| 16 | Brandon United | 1–2 | Billingham Town | 70 |
| 18 | Stokesley SC | 2–0 | Washington | 148 |
| 33 | St Helens Town | 1–0 | Holker Old Boys | 83 |
| 35 | Nostell Miners Welfare | 3–0 | Winsford United | 135 |
| 37 | Flixton | 3–1† | Abbey Hey | 68 |
| 42 | AFC Blackpool | 1–4 | Congleton Town | 54 |
| 49 | Pilkington XXX | 2–1 | AFC Wulfrunians | 68 |
| 67 | Meir KA | 4–4 | Goodrich | 76 |
| Meir KA won 5–4 on penalties | Meir KA won 5–4 on penalties | Meir KA won 5–4 on penalties | Meir KA won 5–4 on penalties | Meir KA won 5–4 on penalties |
| 76 | Lye Town | 5–1 | Brocton | 252 |