Presidents' Athletic Conference Current members Current members

| Institution | Location_ | Nickname | Founded | Enrollment | Joined |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bethany College | Bethany, West Virginia | Bison | 1840 | 1030 | 1958 |
| Chatham University † | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania | Cougars | 1869 | 2300 | 2007 |
| Geneva College | Beaver Falls, Pennsylvania | Golden Tornadoes | 1848 | 1791 | 2007 |
| Grove City College | Grove City, Pennsylvania | Wolverines | 1876 | 2500 | 1984 |
| Saint Vincent College | Latrobe, Pennsylvania | Bearcats | 1846 | 1652 | 2006 |
| Thiel College | Greenville, Pennsylvania | Tomcats | 1866 | 1066 | 1958 |
| Thomas More College | Crestview Hills, Kentucky | Saints | 1921 | 1900 | 2005 |
| Washington & Jefferson College | Washington, Pennsylvania | Presidents | 1781 | 1519 | 1958 |
| Waynesburg University | Waynesburg, Pennsylvania | Yellow Jackets | 1849 | 1500 | 1990 |