The Secret Garden (musical) Characters, casts, and recordings Characters, casts, and recordings

| Character_ | Original_Broadway_performer | Original_Australian_performer | Original_West_End_performer | _2005_World_AIDS_Day_Benefit_Dream_Cast |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mary Lennox | Daisy Eagan | Samantha Fiddes / Sarah Ogden | Natalie Morgan | Jaclyn Neidenthal |
| Archibald Craven | Mandy Patinkin | Anthony Warlow | Philip Quast | Steven Pasquale |
| Lily Craven | Rebecca Luker | Marina Prior | Meredith Braun | Laura Benanti |
| Neville Craven | Robert Westenberg | Philip Quast | Peter Polycarpou * | Will Chase |
| Martha | Alison Fraser | Susan-Ann Walker | Linzi Hateley | Celia Keenan-Bolger |
| Dickon | John Cameron Mitchell | Tom Blair | Jordan Dunne | Michael Arden |
| Colin Craven | John Babcock | Bart Ritchie / Ross Hannaford | Luke Newberry | Struan Erlenborn |
| Ben Weatherstaff | Tom Toner | Raymond Duprac | N/A | David Canary |