List of NCAA Division I men's soccer First-Team All-America teams 1983–present 1983–present

| Year_ | Goalkeeper | Defenders | Midfielders | Forwards_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2003 | Will Hesmer, Wake Forest | Leonard Griffin, UCLA , Trevor McEachron, Old Dominion , Chris Wingert, St. John`s | Scott Buete, Maryland , Sumed Ibrahim, Maryland , C.J. Klaas, Washington | Adom Crew, Brown , Ned Grabavoy, Indiana , Vedad Ibišević, St. Louis University , Joseph Ngwenya, Coastal Carolina |
| 2004 | Christopher Sawyer, Notre Dame | Ugo Ihemelu, SMU , Drew Moor, Indiana , Gonzalo Segares, VCU | Michael Enfield, UCLA , C.J. Klaas, Washington , Sacha Kljestan, Seton Hall , Danny O`Rourke, Indiana | Justin Moose, Wake Forest , Randi Patterson, UNC-G`boro , Ryan Pore, Tulsa , Jeff Rowland, New Mexico |
| 2005 | Chris Dunsheath, Bradley | Greg Dalby, Notre Dame , Tyson Wahl, California , Marvell Wynne, UCLA | Mehdi Ballouchy, Santa Clara , Scott Jones, UNC-G`boro , Yohann Mauger, Akron , Brian Plotkin, Indiana | Jason Garey, Maryland , Ross McKenzie, Akron , Jeff Rowland, New Mexico , Willie Sims, Cal St-N`ridge |