2008–09 FA Cup Qualifying Rounds Second qualifying round Replays

| Tie_no | Home_team | Score | Away_team | Attendance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | Blyth Spartans | 5–2 | Whitby Town | 408 |
| 10 | Newcastle Benfield | 2–1† | Winterton Rangers | 84 |
| 13 | Garforth Town | 1–3 | Guiseley | 244 |
| 16 | Harrogate Town | 0–0 | Workington | 305 |
| Harrogate Town won 5–4 on penalties | Harrogate Town won 5–4 on penalties | Harrogate Town won 5–4 on penalties | Harrogate Town won 5–4 on penalties | Harrogate Town won 5–4 on penalties |
| 17 | Witton Albion | 1–3 | Gateshead | 227 |
| 21 | Nuneaton Town | 1–2 | Evesham United | 508 |
| 25 | Rothwell Town | 2–5† | Chasetown | 194 |
| 30 | Brackley Town | 1–0 | Stourbridge | 187 |
| 32 | Atherstone Town | 3–1† | Southam United | 267 |
| 43 | Bognor Regis Town | 0–2 | Burgess Hill Town | 319 |