Peter Pan (1954 musical) Cast of major productions (1954–1999) Cast of major productions (1954–1999)

| Character_ | _1954_Broadway | _1955_broadcast | _1960_broadcast | _1979_Broadway | _1990_Broadway | _1991_Broadway | _1998_Broadway | _1999_Broadway |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Peter Pan | Mary Martin | Mary Martin | Mary Martin | Sandy Duncan | Cathy Rigby | Cathy Rigby | Cathy Rigby | Cathy Rigby |
| Captain Hook / Mr. Darling | Cyril Ritchard | Cyril Ritchard | Cyril Ritchard | George Rose | Stephen Hanan | J.K. Simmons | Paul Schoeffler | Paul Schoeffler |
| Mrs. Darling | Margalo Gillmore | Margalo Gillmore | Margalo Gillmore | Beth Fowler | Lauren Thompson | Lauren Thompson | Barbara McCulloh | Barbara McCulloh |
| Tiger Lily | Sondra Lee | Sondra Lee | Sondra Lee | Maria Pogee | Holly Irwin | Michelle Schumacher | Dana Solimando | Dana Solimando |
| Wendy Darling | Kathleen Nolan | Kathleen Nolan | Maureen Bailey | Marsha Kramer | Cindy Robinson | Cindy Robinson | Elisa Sagardia | Elisa Sagardia |