Haley Scarnato American Idol performances American Idol performances

| Week_ | Theme | Song_Choice | Original_Artist | Order_ | Result_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Top 24 (12 Women) | Free Choice |  It`s All Coming Back to Me Now  | Pandora`s Box | 8 | Safe |
| Top 20 (10 Women) | Free Choice |  Queen of the Night  | Whitney Houston | 9 | Safe |
| Top 16 (8 Women) | Free Choice |  If My Heart Had Wings  | Faith Hill | 4 | Safe |
| Top 12 | Diana Ross |  Missing You  | Diana Ross | 6 | Safe |
| Top 11 | British Invasion |  Tell Him  | Billie Davis | 1 | Safe |
| Top 10 | No Doubt /Artists who inspire Gwen Stefani |  True Colors  | Cyndi Lauper | 5 | Bottom 2 |
| Top 9 | American Classics |  Ain`t Misbehavin`  | Fats Waller | 8 | Bottom 2 |