2012 MLS SuperDraft Round 2 Round 2

| Pick_ | MLS_team | Player | Position_ | Affiliation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20 | Montreal Impact | Calum Mallace | Midfielder | Marquette University Chicago Fire Premier |
| 21 | Vancouver Whitecaps FC | Chris Estridge | Defender | Indiana University Chicago Fire Premier |
| 22 | New England Revolution | * Tyler Polak | Defender | Creighton University Chicago Fire Premier |
| 23 | Chicago Fire | Lucky Mkosana | Forward | Dartmouth College Michigan Bucks |
| 24 | Real Salt Lake | Diogo de Almeida | Defender | Southern Methodist University |
| 25 | San Jose Earthquakes | Jacob Hustedt | Midfielder | University of Washington Ventura County Fusion |
| 26 | Columbus Crew | Aubrey Perry | Defender | University of South Florida |
| 27 | Portland Timbers | Brendan King | Midfielder | University of Notre Dame Chicago Fire Premier |