Lake Michigan Conference (defunct) Members before dissolution Members before dissolution

| Institution | Location_ | Nickname | Founded | Type_ | Enrollment | Joined | Current_Conference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alverno College | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | Inferno | 1887 | Private/Catholic | 1932 | 2004 | Northern (NAC) |
| Concordia University | Mequon, Wisconsin | Falcons | 1880 | Private/Lutheran Missouri Synod | 1600 | 1982 | Northern (NAC) |
| Dominican University | River Forest, Illinois | Stars | 1901 | Private/Catholic | 3250 | 2005 | Northern (NAC) |
| Edgewood College | Madison, Wisconsin | Eagles | 1927 | Private/Catholic | 2000 | 1974 | Northern (NAC) |
| Lakeland College | Plymouth, Wisconsin | Muskies | 1862 | Private/United Church of Christ | 950 | 1982 | Northern (NAC) |
| Maranatha Baptist Bible College | Watertown, Wisconsin | Crusaders | 1968 | Private/Baptist | 850 | 1974 | Northern (NAC) |
| Marian University | Fond du Lac, Wisconsin | Sabres | 1936 | Private/Catholic | 2918 | 1974 | Northern (NAC) |
| Milwaukee School of Engineering | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | Raiders | 1903 | Private/Non-sectarian | 1395 | 1977 | Northern (NAC) |