Reasons to be pretty Original Broadway production Original Broadway production

| Year_ | Award_Ceremony | Category | Nominee | Result_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2009 | Tony Award | Best Play | Neil LaBute | Nominated |
| 2009 | Tony Award | Best Performance by a Leading Actor in a Play | Thomas Sadoski | Nominated |
| 2009 | Tony Award | Best Performance by a Featured Actress in a Play | Marin Ireland | Nominated |
| 2009 | Drama Desk Award | Outstanding Play | Outstanding Play | Nominated |
| 2009 | Drama Desk Award | Outstanding Actor in a Play | Thomas Sadoski | Nominated |
| 2009 | Drama Desk Award | Outstanding Director of a Play | Terry Kinney | Nominated |
| 2009 | Theatre World Award | Theatre World Award | Marin Ireland | Won |