1995 Major League Baseball Draft First round selections First round selections

| Pick | Player | Team | Position_ | Hometown_School |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 | Matt Morris | St. Louis Cardinals | RHP | Seton Hall University |
| 13 | Mark Redman | Minnesota Twins | LHP | University of Oklahoma |
| 14 | Reggie Taylor | Philadelphia Phillies | OF | Newberry, SC |
| 15 | Andy Yount | Boston Red Sox | RHP | Kingwood, TX |
| 16 | Joe Fontenot | San Francisco Giants | RHP | Lafayette, LA |
| 17 | Roy Halladay | Toronto Blue Jays | RHP | Golden, CO |
| 18 | Ryan Jaroncyk | New York Mets | SS | Escondido, CA |
| 19 | Juan Lebron | Kansas City Royals | OF | Arroyo, Puerto Rico |
| 20 | David Yocum | Los Angeles Dodgers | LHP | Florida State University |
| 21 | Alvie Shepherd | Baltimore Orioles | RHP | University of Nebraska |
| 22 | Tony McKnight | Houston Astros | RHP | Texarkana, AR |
| 23 | David Miller | Cleveland Indians | 1B | Clemson University |