Sligo Rovers F.C. Most overall appearances Most overall appearances

| Ranking | Nationality | Name_ | Years | Total_Appearancesleague_only |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ireland | Tony Fagan | 1967–87 | 590(431) |
| 2 | England | Tony Stenson | 1968–84 | 387(290) |
| 3 | Ireland | Raffaele Cretaro | 2000–2005 & 2007–2009 & 2011- | 381(311) |
| 4 | Scotland | Johnny Armstrong | 1951-64 | 380(228) |
| 5 | Ireland | Gavin Dykes | 1987-96 | 323(255) |
| 6 | Ireland | Harry McLoughlin | 1977-89 | 315(275) |
| 7 | Ireland | David Pugh | 1963–67 & 1969-78 | 308(236) |
| 8 | Ireland | Martin McDonnell | 1979–1984 & 1990-97 | 284(214) |
| 9 | England | Chris Rutherford | 1975–1985 | 281(222) |
| 10 | Ireland | Conor O`Grady | 1998–2001 & 2005-10 | 281(239) |