List of NCAA Division I men's soccer First-Team All-America teams 1983–present 1983–present

| Year_ | Goalkeeper | Defenders | Midfielders | Forwards_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1991 | Brad Friedel, UCLA | Alexi Lalas, Rutgers , Mike Lapper, UCLA , Cam Rast, Santa Clara | Peter DiMaggio, Columbia , Graham Merryweather, Evansville , Claudio Reyna, Virginia | Gerell Elliott, Fresno State , Henry Gutierrez, NC State , Manny Lagos, Milwaukee , Dante Washington, Radford |
| 1992 | Brad Friedel, UCLA | Joe Addo, George Mason , Scott Schweitzer, NC State , Hector Zamora, Seton Hall | Joe-Max Moore, UCLA , Claudio Reyna, Virginia , Joey Thieman, Princeton | Ben Crawley, Virginia , Robert Martella, Bowling Green , Alan Prampin, SMU , Robert Ukrop, Davidson |
| 1993 | Tim Deck, Wisconsin | Shane Batelle, St. Louis University , Pedro Lopes, Rutgers , Jorge Salcedo, UCLA | Brian Kamler, Creighton , Jason Kreis, Duke , Claudio Reyna, Virginia | Keith DeFini, Creighton , Jimmy Glenn, Clemson , Brian McBride, St. Louis University , Staale Soebye, San Francisco |