List of NCAA Division I men's soccer First-Team All-America teams 1983–present 1983–present

| Year_ | Goalkeeper | Defenders | Midfielders | Forwards_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1985 | Tim Borer, Old Dominion | Paul Caligiuri, UCLA , Shaun Pendleton, Akron , Michael Reynolds, George Mason | John Kerr Jr., Duke , Mark Mettrick, Hartwick , Bruce Murray, Clemson | Michael Brady, American , Eric Eichmann, Clemson , Tom Kain, Duke , Sam Sumo, George Mason |
| 1986 | Jeff Duback, Yale | Paul Caligiuri, UCLA , Benjamin Okaroh, Boston , Steve Trittschuh, SIUE | Mark Francis, SMU , Gary Furlong, Maryland , John Harkes, Virginia | John Catliff, Harvard , Guy Furfaro, Philadelphia , George Gelnovatch, Virginia , John Kerr Jr., Duke |
| 1987 | Bob Willen, Virginia | Seamus Purcell, Providence , Paul Rutenis, Clemson , David Smyth, UNC | John Harkes, Virginia , Mark Mettrick, Hartwick , Tab Ramos, NC State | Doug Allison, South Carolina , Bruce Murray, Clemson , Ken Snow, Indiana , Peter Vermes, Rutgers |