Central Indiana Athletic Conference Former Members Former Members

| School | Location_ | Mascot | County | Year_Joined | Previous_Conference | Year_Left |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Huntington North * | Huntington | Vikings | 35 Huntington | 1932 | Independents | 1974 |
| Noblesville | Noblesville | Millers | 29 Hamilton | 1932 | Hamilton County | 1938 |
| Peru | Peru | Tigers | 52 Miami | 1932 | Independents | 1998 |
| Rochester | Rochester | Zebras | 25 Fulton | 1932 | North Central | 1964 |
| Tipton | Tipton | Blue Devils | 80 Tipton | 1932 | Independents | 1998 |
| Wabash | Wabash | Apaches | 85 Wabash | 1932 | Independents | 2006 |
| Windfall | Windfall | Dragons | 80 Tipton | 1932 | Independents | 1936 |
| Warsaw | Warsaw | Tigers | 43 Kosciusko | 1933 1953 | Independents Northeastern IN | 1946 1964 |
| Plymouth | Plymouth | Pilgrims | 50 Marshall | 1935 | Independents | 1964 |
| Muncie Burris | Muncie | Owls | 18 Delaware | 1938 | Independents | 1976 |
| Hartford City | Hartford City | Airedales | 05 Blackford | 1945 | Independents | 1968 |