Appalachian Athletic Conference Member schools Current members

| Institution | Location_ | Founded | Type_ | Enrollment | Joined | Nickname_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bryan College | Dayton, Tennessee | 1930 | Private (non-denominational) | 1044 | 2001 | Lions |
| Columbia College† | Columbia, South Carolina | 1854 | Private (Methodist) | 1200 | 2011 | Fighting Koalas |
| Milligan College | Elizabethton, Tennessee | 1866 | Private (Disciples of Christ) | 1006 | 2001 | Buffaloes |
| Montreat College | Montreat, North Carolina | 1916 | Private (Presbyterian) | 1145 | 2001 | Cavaliers |
| Point University | West Point, Georgia | 1937 | Private (Christian churches and churches of Christ) | 1000 | 2011 | Skyhawks |
| Reinhardt University | Waleska, Georgia | 1883 | Private (Methodist) | 1057 | 2009 | Eagles |
| St. Andrews University | Laurinburg, North Carolina | 1958 | Private | 800 | 2012 | Knights |
| Savannah College of Art and Design at Atlanta | Atlanta, Georgia | 2005 | Private | 2000 | 2012 | Bees |