List of NCAA Division I men's soccer First-Team All-America teams 1983–present 1983–present

| Year_ | Goalkeeper | Defenders | Midfielders | Forwards_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1994 | David Kramer, Fresno State | Brandon Pollard, Virginia , Eddie Pope, UNC | Jason Kreis, Duke , Brian Maisonneuve, Indiana , Matt McKeon, St. Louis University , Todd Yeagley, Indiana | Brent Bennett, James Madison , Mac Cozier, Charlotte , Darren Eales, Brown , Staale Soebye, San Francisco |
| 1995 | Chris Snitko, UCLA | Scott Lamphear, Wisconsin , Ian McIntyre, Hartwick , Brandon Pollard, Virginia | Ben Hickey, St. John`s , Jesse Marsch, Princeton , Clint Mathis, South Carolina | Mike Fisher, Virginia , Matt McKeon, St. Louis University , Toni Siikala, Campbell , Andy Williams, Rhode Island |
| 1996 | Jon Busch, Charlotte | Tahj Jakins, UCLA , Pete Santora, Furman , John Stratton, Air Force | Mike Fisher, Virginia , Steve Klein, Bowling Green , Mike Mekelburg, USF | Tony Kuhn, Vanderbilt , Ignace Moleka, FIU , Johnny Torres, Creighton , Andy Williams, Rhode Island |