1925 College Football All-America Team NCAA consensus All-American team NCAA consensus All-American team

| Position_ | Name_ | School | Unanimous | College_Hall_of_Fame |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ends | Bennie Oosterbaan Mike Tully | Michigan Dartmouth | No No | Oosterbaan HOF Profile No |
| Tackles | Ed Weir Ralph Chase | Nebraska Pittsburgh | Yes No | Weir HOF Profile No |
| Guards | Carl Diehl Ed Hess | Dartmouth Ohio State | No No | No No |
| Center | Edward L. McMillan | Princeton | No | No |
| Quarterback | Benny Friedman | Michigan | No | Friedman HOF Profile |
| Halfbacks | Andy Swede Oberlander Red Grange | Dartmouth Illinois | Yes No | Oberlander HOF Profile Grange HOF Profile |
| Fullback | Ernie Big Dog Nevers | Stanford | No | Nevers HOF Profile |