Real World/Road Rules Challenge: The Island Cast Cast

| Player | Original_Season | Gender | Eliminated | Placing_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Colie Edison | RW: Denver | Female | Episode 7 | 13th Place |
| Cohutta Grindstaff | RW: Sydney | Male | Episode 6 | 14th Place |
| Tyrie Ballard | RW: Denver | Male | Episode 5 | 15th Place |
| Ashli Robson | RW: Sydney | Female | Episode 4 | 16th Place |
| Rachel Robinson | RR: Campus Crawl | Female | Episode 3 | 17th Place |
| Abram Boise | RR: South Pacific | Male | Episode 2 | 18th Place |
| Dave Malinosky | RW: Hollywood | Male | Episode 2 (quit) | 19th Place |
| Tonya Cooley | RW: Chicago | Female | Episode 1 | 20th Place |