Colts–Patriots rivalry 2000s (Patriots 8-6) 2000s (Patriots 8-6)

| Year_ | Date_ | Winner | Result_ | Loser | Location_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2006 | November 5 | Indianapolis Colts | 27-20 | New England Patriots | Gillette Stadium |
| 2007 | January 21 | Indianapolis Colts | 38-34 | New England Patriots | RCA Dome |
| 2007 | November 4 | New England Patriots | 24-20 | Indianapolis Colts | RCA Dome |
| 2008 | November 2 | Indianapolis Colts | 18-15 | New England Patriots | Lucas Oil Stadium |
| 2009 | November 15 | Indianapolis Colts | 35-34 | New England Patriots | Lucas Oil Stadium |