2008–09 FA Cup Qualifying Rounds Extra preliminary round Replays

| Tie_no | Home_team | Score | Away_team | Attendance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Marlow United won 4–2 on penalties | Marlow United won 4–2 on penalties | Marlow United won 4–2 on penalties | Marlow United won 4–2 on penalties | Marlow United won 4–2 on penalties |
| 172 | Calne Town | 3–0 | Devizes Town | 76 |
| 176 | Bitton | 3–0 | Thame United | 82 |
| 184 | Wootton Bassett Town | 1–6 | Flackwell Heath | 97 |
| 187 | Street | 5–1 | Chard Town | 123 |
| 195 | Falmouth Town | 4–2 | Shaftesbury | 66 |
| 197 | Saltash United | 2–4 | Gillingham Town | 116 |
| 200 | Wimborne Town | 3–2 | Dawlish Town | 273 |