Carly Smithson Performances/Results Performances/Results

| Week_ | Theme | Song_choice | Original_artist | Order_ | Result_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audition | N/A |  I`m Every Woman  | Chaka Khan | N/A | Advanced |
| Hollywood | N/A |  When I Need You  | Leo Sayer | N/A | Advanced |
| Top 50 | N/A |  Alone  | i-TEN | N/A | Advanced |
| Top 24 (12 Women) | 1960s |  The Shadow of Your Smile  | Tony Bennett | 12 | Safe |
| Top 20 (10 Women) | 1970s |  Crazy on You  | Heart | 1 | Safe |
| Top 16 (8 Women) | 1980s |  I Drove All Night  | Cyndi Lauper | 4 | Safe |
| Top 12 | Lennon–McCartney |  Come Together  | The Beatles | 5 | Safe |
| Top 11 | The Beatles |  Blackbird  | The Beatles | 7 | Bottom 3 |
| Top 10 | Year They Were Born |  Total Eclipse of the Heart  | Bonnie Tyler | 7 | Safe |