List of NCAA Division I men's soccer First-Team All-America teams 1983–present 1983–present

| Year_ | Goalkeeper | Defenders | Midfielders | Forwards_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1988 | Tony Meola, Virginia | Jeff Agoos, Virginia , Marcelo Balboa, San Diego State , Kevin Grimes, SMU | Henry Gutierrez, NC State , Pat O`Kelly, Seton Hall , Mark Santel, St. Louis University | Scott Benedetti, Portland , Brian Benedict, Duke , Ken Snow, Indiana , Joey Valenti, Duke |
| 1989 | Tony Meola, Virginia | Kevin Grimes, SMU , Cam Rast, Santa Clara , Kevin Wylie, Vermont | David Banks, Philadelphia , Tim Martin, Fresno State , Pat O`Kelly, Seton Hall | Clark Brisson, South Carolina , Peter Isaacs, Howard , Robert Paterson, Evansville , Ken Snow, Indiana |
| 1990 | Kasey Keller, Portland | Jeff Agoos, Virginia , Scott Cannon, Evansville , Tom Loeber, South Carolina | Dario Brose, NC State , Chad Deering, Indiana , Mark Santel, St. Louis University | Steve Rammel, Rutgers , Ken Snow, Indiana , Billy Thompson, UCLA , David Weir, Evansville |