List of NCAA Division I men's soccer First-Team All-America teams 1983–present 1983–present

| Year_ | Goalkeeper | Defenders | Midfielders | Forwards_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2011 | Brian Holt, Creighton | Chris Estridge, Indiana , Matt Hedges, North Carolina , Charles Rodriguez, UNC Charlotte | Miguel Ibarra, UC Irvine , Enzo Martinez, North Carolina , Luis Silva, UCSB | Ashton Bennett, Coastal Carolina , Ethan Finlay, Creighton , Billy Schuler, North Carolina , Andrew Wenger, Duke |
| 2012 | Andre Blake, Connecticut | Chad Barson, Akron , Andrew Farrell, Louisville , Andrew Ribeiro, Creighton | Scott Caldwell, Akron , Jose Gomez, Creighton , Dillon Powers, Notre Dame | Ashton Bennett, Coastal Carolina , Ryan Finley, Notre Dame , Daniel Haber, Cornell University , Patrick Mullins, Maryland |
| 2013 | Andre Blake, Connecticut | Steve Birnbaum, California , AJ Cochran, Wisconsin , Taylor Peay, Washington | Laurie Bell, Milwaukee , Aodhan Quinn, Akron , Leo Stolz, UCLA | Pete Caringi III, UMBC , Sagi Lev-Ari, Cal St-N`ridge , Patrick Mullins, Maryland , Harrison Shipp, Notre Dame |