2008–09 FA Cup Qualifying Rounds First qualifying round Replays

| Tie_no | Home_team | Score | Away_team | Attendance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 74 | Arlesey Town | 1–0 | Brentwood Town | 110 |
| 76 | Bedford Town | 1–1 | Wealdstone | 349 |
| Bedford Town won 4–2 on penalties | Bedford Town won 4–2 on penalties | Bedford Town won 4–2 on penalties | Bedford Town won 4–2 on penalties | Bedford Town won 4–2 on penalties |
| 81 | Whyteleafe | 2–0 | Horsham YMCA | 82 |
| 85 | Arundel | 1–2 | Godalming Town | 123 |
| 90 | VCD Athletic | 3–0 | Hythe Town | 153 |
| 109 | Bideford | 1–3† | Frome Town | 193 |