Casey James Performances Performances

| Episode | Theme | Song_choice | Original_artist | Order_ | Result_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Top 11 | Billboard Number 1 Hits |  The Power of Love  | Huey Lewis and the News | 9 | Safe |
| Top 10 | R&B / Soul |  Hold On, I`m Comin`  | Sam & Dave | 2 | Safe |
| Top 9 | Lennon–McCartney |  Jealous Guy  | John Lennon | 7 | Safe |
| Top 9 | Elvis Presley |  Lawdy Miss Clawdy  | Lloyd Price | 9 | Safe |
| Top 7 | Inspirational |  Don`t Stop  | Fleetwood Mac | 1 | Bottom 3 |
| Top 6 | Shania Twain |  Don`t!  | Shania Twain | 3 | Bottom 3 |
| Top 5 | Frank Sinatra |  Blue Skies  | Belle Baker | 2 | Safe |
| Top 4 | Songs of the Cinema | Solo  Mrs. Robinson  — The Graduate | Simon & Garfunkel | 4 | Safe |
| Top 3 | Contestant`s Choice |  OK, It`s Alright with Me  | Eric Hutchinson | 1 | Eliminated |