Presidents' Athletic Conference Former members Former members

| Institution | Location_ | Nickname | Founded | Enrollment | Joined | Left_ | Current_Conference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Allegheny College | Meadville, Pennsylvania | Gators | 1815 | 2100 | 1958 | 1984 | NCAC |
| Alfred University | Alfred, New York | Saxons | 1836 | 2300 | 1996 | 1998 | Empire 8 |
| Carnegie Mellon University | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania | Tartans | 1900 | 6170 | 1968 | 1989 | UAA |
| Case Institute of Technology | Cleveland, Ohio | Rough Riders | 1880 | n/a | 1955 | 1970 | n/a 1 |
| Case Western Reserve University | Cleveland, Ohio | Spartans | 1967 | 4227 | 1970 | 1984 | UAA |
| Eastern Michigan University | Ypsilanti, Michigan | Eagles | 1849 | 22974 | 1962 | 1967 | MAC (NCAA Division I) |
| Hiram College | Hiram, Ohio | Terriers | 1850 | 1271 | 1972 | 1989 | NCAC |
| John Carroll University | University Heights, Ohio | Blue Streaks | 1886 | 3726 | 1955 | 1988 | OAC |
| Wayne State University | Detroit, Michigan | Warriors | 1868 | 32564 | 1955 | 1967 | GLIAC (NCAA Division II) |