2005 MLS SuperDraft Round three Round three

| Pick_ | MLS_Team | Player | Position_ | Affiliation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 | MetroStars | Chris Corcoran | M | St. Johns University |
| 26 | C.D. Chivas USA | Aaron Lopez | D | UCLA |
| 27 | F.C. Dallas | Winston Marshall | D | Wright State University |
| 28 | F.C. Dallas | Chris Gomez | GK | Brown University |
| 29 | Chicago Fire | Chris Rolfe | F | University of Dayton |
| 30 | San Jose Earthquakes | Victor Arbelaez | M | UNLV |
| 31 | San Jose Earthquakes | Orlando Ramirez | F | Fresno Pacific University |
| 32 | San Jose Earthquakes | C.J. Klaas | D | University of Washington |
| 33 | New England Revolution | Tony Lochhead | D | UC Santa Barbara |
| 34 | Los Angeles Galaxy | * Quavas Kirk | F | Generation adidas |
| 35 | Chicago Fire | Gonzalo Segares | D | Virginia Commonwealth University |
| 36 | Chicago Fire | Thabiso Khumalo | M | Coastal Carolina University |