Real World/Road Rules Challenge: The Island Cast Cast

| Player | Original_Season | Gender | Eliminated | Placing_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Derrick Kosinski | RR: X-Treme | Male | Winner | Winner |
| Evelyn Smith | Fresh Meat | Female | Winner | Winner |
| Johnny Devenanzio | RW: Key West | Male | Winner | Winner |
| Kenny Santucci | Fresh Meat | Male | Winner | Winner |
| Jenn Grijalva | RW: Denver | Female | Episode 8 | Runner-Up |
| Paula Meronek | RW: Key West | Female | Episode 8 | Runner-Up |
| Robin Hibbard | RW: San Diego | Female | Episode 8 | Runner-Up |
| Ryan Kehoe | Fresh Meat | Male | Episode 8 | Runner-Up |
| Dunbar Merrill | RW: Sydney | Male | Episode 8 | 9th Place |
| Johanna Botta | RW: Austin | Female | Episode 8 | 10th Place |
| KellyAnne Judd | RW: Sydney | Female | Episode 8 | 11th Place |
| Dan Walsh | RR: Viewers` Revenge | Male | Episode 8 | 12th Place |