2005 New York Yankees season Game log May

| Date_ | Opponent | Score | Loss | Attendance | Record | Boxscore |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 11 | Mariners | 13–9 | Thornton (0–3) | 47844 | 16–19 | W4 |
| May 13 | @ Athletics | 9–4 | Harden (2–3) | 38636 | 17–19 | W5 |
| May 14 | @ Athletics | 15–6 | Blanton (0–4) | 41180 | 18–19 | W6 |
| May 15 | @ Athletics | 6–4 | Rincón (1–1) | 37237 | 19–19 | W7 |
| May 16 | @ Mariners | 6–3 | Hasegawa (0–1) | 37814 | 20–19 | W8 |
| May 17 | @ Mariners | 6–0 | Mateo (1–1) | 35549 | 21–19 | W9 |
| May 18 | @ Mariners | 6–7 | Gordon (0–3) | 37419 | 21–20 | L1 |
| May 20 | @ Mets | 5–2 | Zambrano (2–4) | 55740 | 22–20 | W1 |
| May 21 | @ Mets | 1–7 | Johnson (4–3) | 55800 | 22–21 | L1 |
| May 22 | @ Mets | 5–3 | Hernández (2–2) | 55953 | 23–21 | W1 |
| May 24 | Tigers | 12–3 | Ledezma (2–4) | 37099 | 24–21 | W2 |