II 115th CONGRESS 1st Session S. 1930 IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES October 5, 2017 Mr. Bennet (for himself, Mrs. Feinstein , Ms. Harris , Mr. Wyden , Mr. Whitehouse , Ms. Hassan , Mr. Cardin , Mr. Merkley , Mrs. Murray , Mr. Van Hollen , Ms. Warren , Mr. Heinrich , Ms. Hirono , and Mr. Udall ) introduced the following bill; which was read twice and referred to the Committee on Environment and Public Works A BILL To establish a cost of greenhouse gases for carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide to be used by Federal agencies, and for other purposes.

1. Short title This Act may be cited as the Pollution Transparency Act . 2. Findings Congress finds that— (1) sound economic and policy analyses require that the economic benefits of reducing climate change be considered together with the costs of policies and measures to reduce greenhouse gas emissions; (2) climate change, if not addressed, is projected to inflict substantial damage on the economy and people of the United States; (3) according to the Congressional Budget Office, the Government Accountability Office, and the Office of Management and Budget, the impacts of climate change are— (A) costing United States taxpayers billions of dollars annually; and (B) putting pressure on the Federal budget; (4) the expenditures by the Federal Government resulting from the effects of climate change are projected to increase, and reducing greenhouse gas emissions presents an opportunity to minimize those expenditures; (5) between calendar years 2008 and 2015, the United States reduced carbon pollution from the energy sector by nearly 10 percent, while the economy grew more than 10 percent; (6) more than 1,200 companies are taking the cost of climate change into consideration in business decisions; (7) estimates of the costs of greenhouse gases provide a method and measure, grounded in scientific and economic research, for monetizing— (A) the costs of greenhouse gas emissions; and (B) the benefits of reducing greenhouse gas emissions; (8) the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine has provided detailed recommendations for improving the estimate of the costs of greenhouse gases for the purpose of regulatory analysis; (9) the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions by other countries benefits the United States by reducing climate risks to the United States, and the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions by the United States benefits other countries; (10) in light of the global nature of the problem of greenhouse gas emissions, the interests of the United States would be maximized if the United States were to use a calculation method of the cost of climate pollution that reflects global damages; (11) due to the nature of climate change risks, the returns on mitigation may pay off in periods that would otherwise involve substantial losses; (12) economic theory and evidence suggests that, for actions with intergenerational consequences such as the consequences of climate change, a discount rate approximately equal to or less than the long-term yield on the debt of the Treasury of the United States may be appropriate; and (13) it is imperative that the academic community continue research on the cost of greenhouse gases. 3. Definitions In this Act: (1) Calculation method The term calculation method means the method by which the costs of greenhouse gases are calculated in accordance with subsections (a), (b), and (c) of section 4, respectively. (2) Committee The term Committee means the Costs of Greenhouse Gases Scientific Review Committee established under section 7(a). (3) Costs of greenhouse gases (A) In general The term costs of greenhouse gases means the monetized present discounted values, in dollars, of the current and future net costs to society that result from— (i) 1 ton of emissions of a specific greenhouse gas in a specific year, including damage relating to— (I) a change in net agricultural productivity; (II) energy use; (III) human health; (IV) property damage from increased flood risk and sea level rise; and (V) to the maximum extent practicable, the value of the effect on ecosystem services due to climate change; and (ii) the monetized present discounted values of the current and future net benefits to society from a 1-ton reduction of emissions of a specific greenhouse gas in a specific year, including a reduction in any damage described in clause (i). (B) Inclusions The term costs of greenhouse gases includes— (i) the cost of carbon dioxide; (ii) the cost of methane; (iii) the cost of nitrous oxide; and (iv) the cost of any other greenhouse gas estimated by the Working Group. (4) Working Group The term Working Group means the Interagency Working Group on the Costs of Greenhouse Gases established under section 5(a). 4. Cost of carbon dioxide, cost of methane, and cost of nitrous oxide (a) Cost of carbon dioxide In developing any rulemaking that requires a regulatory impact analysis, making any substantial procurement decision for which the cost of carbon dioxide is not applied before the date on which a revised version of the costs of greenhouse gases is finalized, the head of any Federal agency shall consider and document the cost of carbon dioxide in accordance with the amounts specified in the following table: Cost of Carbon Dioxide, 2010 Through 2050 (in 2007 Dollars per Metric Ton of Carbon Dioxide), Discount Rate and Statistic Year 5 Percent Average 3 Percent Average 2.5 Percent Average High Impact (95th Percentile at 3 Percent Discount Rate) 2010 $10 $31 $50 $86 2011 $11 $32 $51 $90 2012 $11 $33 $53 $93 2013 $11 $34 $54 $97 2014 $11 $35 $55 $101 2015 $11 $36 $56 $105 2016 $11 $38 $57 $108 2017 $11 $39 $59 $112 2018 $12 $40 $60 $116 2019 $12 $41 $61 $120 2020 $12 $42 $62 $123 2021 $12 $42 $63 $126 2022 $13 $43 $64 $129 2023 $13 $44 $65 $132 2024 $13 $45 $66 $135 2025 $14 $46 $68 $138 2026 $14 $47 $69 $141 2027 $15 $48 $70 $143 2028 $15 $49 $71 $146 2029 $15 $49 $72 $149 2030 $16 $50 $73 $152 2031 $16 $51 $74 $155 2032 $17 $52 $75 $158 2033 $17 $53 $76 $161 2034 $18 $54 $77 $164 2035 $18 $55 $78 $168 2036 $19 $56 $79 $171 2037 $19 $57 $81 $174 2038 $20 $58 $82 $177 2039 $20 $59 $83 $180 2040 $21 $60 $84 $183 2041 $21 $61 $85 $186 2042 $22 $61 $86 $189 2043 $22 $62 $87 $192 2044 $23 $63 $88 $194 2045 $23 $64 $89 $197 2046 $24 $65 $90 $200 2047 $24 $66 $92 $203 2048 $25 $67 $93 $206 2049 $25 $68 $94 $209 2050 $26 $69 $95 $212. (b) Cost of methane In developing any rulemaking that requires a regulatory impact analysis, making any substantial procurement decision for which the cost of methane is not applied before the date on which a revised version of the costs of greenhouse gases is finalized, the head of any Federal agency shall consider and document the cost of methane in accordance with the amounts specified in the following table: Cost of Methane, 2010 Through 2050 (in 2007 Dollars per Metric Ton of Methane), Discount Rate and Statistic Year 5 Percent Average 3 Percent Average 2.5 Percent Average High Impact (95th Percentile at 3 Percent Discount Rate) 2010 $370 $870 $1,200 $2,400 2011 $380 $910 $1,200 $2,500 2012 $400 $940 $1,300 $2,600 2013 $420 $970 $1,300 $2,700 2014 $440 $1,000 $1,300 $2,700 2015 $450 $1,000 $1,400 $2,800 2016 $470 $1,100 $1,400 $2,900 2017 $490 $1,100 $1,500 $3,000 2018 $510 $1,100 $1,500 $3,000 2019 $520 $1,200 $1,500 $3,100 2020 $540 $1,200 $1,600 $3,200 2021 $560 $1,200 $1,600 $3,300 2022 $590 $1,300 $1,700 $3,400 2023 $610 $1,300 $1,700 $3,500 2024 $630 $1,400 $1,800 $3,600 2025 $650 $1,400 $1,800 $3,700 2026 $670 $1,400 $1,900 $3,800 2027 $700 $1,500 $1,900 $3,900 2028 $720 $1,500 $2,000 $4,000 2029 $740 $1,600 $2,000 $4,100 2030 $760 $1,600 $2,000 $4,200 2031 $790 $1,600 $2,100 $4,300 2032 $820 $1,700 $2,100 $4,500 2033 $850 $1,700 $2,200 $4,600 2034 $880 $1,800 $2,200 $4,700 2035 $900 $1,800 $2,300 $4,900 2036 $930 $1,900 $2,400 $5,000 2037 $960 $1,900 $2,400 $5,100 2038 $990 $2,000 $2,500 $5,200 2039 $1,000 $2,000 $2,500 $5,400 2040 $1,000 $2,000 $2,600 $5,500 2041 $1,100 $2,100 $2,600 $5,600 2042 $1,100 $2,100 $2,700 $5,700 2043 $1,100 $2,200 $2,700 $5,800 2044 $1,200 $2,200 $2,800 $5,900 2045 $1,200 $2,300 $2,800 $6,100 2046 $1,200 $2,300 $2,900 $6,200 2047 $1,300 $2,400 $2,900 $6,300 2048 $1,300 $2,400 $3,000 $6,400 2049 $1,300 $2,500 $3,000 $6,500 2050 $1,300 $2,500 $3,100 $6,700. (c) Cost of nitrous oxide In developing any rulemaking that requires a regulatory impact analysis, making any substantial procurement decision for which the cost of nitrous oxide is not applied before the date on which a revised version of the costs of greenhouse gases is finalized, the head of any Federal agency shall consider and document the cost of nitrous oxide in accordance with the amounts specified in the following table: Cost of Nitrous Oxide, 2010 Through 2050 (in 2007 Dollars per Metric Ton of Nitrous Oxide), Discount Rate and Statistic Year 5 Percent Average 3 Percent Average 2.5 Percent Average High Impact (95th Percentile at 3 Percent Discount Rate) 2010 $3,400 $12,000 $18,000 $31,000 2011 $3,500 $12,000 $18,000 $32,000 2012 $3,700 $12,000 $19,000 $33,000 2013 $3,800 $13,000 $19,000 $34,000 2014 $3,900 $13,000 $20,000 $34,000 2015 $4,000 $13,000 $20,000 $35,000 2016 $4,200 $14,000 $20,000 $36,000 2017 $4,300 $14,000 $21,000 $37,000 2018 $4,400 $14,000 $21,000 $38,000 2019 $4,600 $15,000 $22,000 $38,000 2020 $4,700 $15,000 $22,000 $39,000 2021 $4,900 $15,000 $23,000 $40,000 2022 $5,000 $16,000 $23,000 $41,000 2023 $5,200 $16,000 $23,000 $42,000 2024 $5,400 $16,000 $24,000 $43,000 2025 $5,500 $17,000 $24,000 $44,000 2026 $5,700 $17,000 $25,000 $45,000 2027 $5,900 $17,000 $25,000 $46,000 2028 $6,000 $18,000 $26,000 $47,000 2029 $6,200 $18,000 $26,000 $48,000 2030 $6,300 $19,000 $27,000 $49,000 2031 $6,500 $19,000 $27,000 $50,000 2032 $6,800 $19,000 $28,000 $51,000 2033 $7,000 $20,000 $28,000 $52,000 2034 $7,200 $20,000 $29,000 $54,000 2035 $7,400 $21,000 $29,000 $55,000 2036 $7,600 $21,000 $30,000 $56,000 2037 $7,800 $21,000 $30,000 $57,000 2038 $8,000 $22,000 $31,000 $58,000 2039 $8,200 $22,000 $31,000 $59,000 2040 $8,400 $23,000 $32,000 $60,000 2041 $8,600 $23,000 $32,000 $61,000 2042 $8,800 $23,000 $33,000 $62,000 2043 $9,100 $24,000 $33,000 $64,000 2044 $9,300 $24,000 $34,000 $65,000 2045 $9,500 $25,000 $34,000 $66,000 2046 $9,800 $25,000 $35,000 $67,000 2047 $10,000 $26,000 $35,000 $68,000 2048 $10,000 $26,000 $36,000 $69,000 2049 $10,000 $26,000 $36,000 $71,000 2050 $11,000 $27,000 $37,000 $72,000. 5. Interagency Working Group on the Costs of Greenhouse Gases (a) Establishment The Director of the Office of Management and Budget, the Director of the Office of Science and Technology Policy, and the Chair of the Council of Economic Advisers shall establish an interagency working group, to be known as the Interagency Working Group on the Costs of Greenhouse Gases to carry out the calculation method revision evaluation described in section 6. (b) Membership The Working Group shall consist of members from— (1) the Council of Economic Advisers; (2) the Office of Science and Technology Policy; (3) the National Security Council; (4) the National Economic Council; (5) the Council on Environmental Quality; (6) the Department of Agriculture; (7) the Department of Commerce; (8) the Department of Energy; (9) the Department of the Interior; (10) the Department of Transportation; (11) the Department of the Treasury; (12) the Department of Health and Human Services; and (13) the Environmental Protection Agency. 6. Calculation method revision (a) Revision evaluation (1) In general Not later than 5 years after the date of enactment of this Act, and not less frequently than once every 5 years thereafter, the Working Group shall carry out a revision evaluation for the cost of carbon dioxide, cost of methane, and cost of nitrous oxide to determine whether a revision of the calculation method of the cost of carbon dioxide, cost of methane, or cost of nitrous oxide is necessary. (2) Considerations In carrying out a revision evaluation under paragraph (1) or a revision under subsection (b), the Working Group shall— (A) consider— (i) the findings of the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine relating to approaches to estimating the costs of greenhouse gases; (ii) the findings of the Committee under section 7(a)(3); (iii) advancements in scientific and economic research relating to the impacts of climate change and the estimation of the costs of greenhouse gases; (iv) new domestic and international findings; and (v) all harm caused by greenhouse gas emissions; (B) assess any proposed revision of the calculation method with respect to— (i) consistency with the state of scientific knowledge, as reflected by current, peer-reviewed literature; and (ii) the adequacy with which the proposed calculation method identifies and represents key uncertainties and sensitivities; (C) evaluate the harm caused by greenhouse gas emissions for the period beginning on the date on which the applicable revision evaluation commences and ending on a date in the future that would allow estimation of the vast majority of discounted climate damages; (D) apply one or more discount rates, which shall— (i) account for the intergenerational nature of the harm caused by climate change; and (ii) be consistent with the interest rate of consumption used by Federal agencies to reflect climate risk; (E) include values that account for global damages from greenhouse gas emissions; (F) document the calculation method and present results in a manner adequate for the scientific community to understand and assess the calculation method; and (G) make available to researchers the model code for review, use, and modification. (b) Revision (1) Calculation method If the Working Group makes a determination under subsection (a)(1) that revision of the calculation method is necessary, the Working Group shall draft a proposed revision of the calculation method. (2) Public notification and comment period Any proposed revision of the calculation method shall be published in the Federal Register for a period of public comment of not fewer than 90 days and include consultation with industry groups. (3) Effect of revisions by Working Group Any revised calculation method of the cost of carbon dioxide, the cost of methane, or the cost of nitrous oxide developed by the Working Group under paragraph (1) and published under paragraph (2) shall supersede the applicable discount rate value of the cost of carbon dioxide, the cost of methane, or the cost of nitrous oxide under section 4. 7. Costs of Greenhouse Gases Scientific Review Committee (a) Establishment (1) In general Not later than January 1, 2019, and not less frequently than once every 5 years thereafter, the Director of the Office of Management and Budget, in consultation with the Director of the Office of Science and Technology Policy and the Chair of the Council of Economic Advisers, shall establish a committee, to be known as the Costs of Greenhouse Gases Scientific Review Committee . (2) Membership The membership of the Committee shall consist of not fewer than 10 members, selected by the presidents of the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, who shall represent scientific fields relevant to the estimation of the costs of greenhouse gases, including— (A) climate science; (B) climate economics; and (C) decision analysis. (3) Duties The Committee shall publish a report in which the Committee shall— (A) make a recommendation to the Working Group regarding whether a revision of the calculation method is necessary; (B) if the Committee determines that a revision is necessary, recommend scientific data and models to be used by the Working Group in the revision of the calculation method; (C) provide scientific advice to the Working Group on the revision; and (D) provide guidance to the U.S. Global Change Research Program with respect to the research necessary to advance the estimation of the costs of greenhouse gases. (b) Termination On the completion of the revision evaluation for which the Committee is established, the Committee shall terminate. (c) Authorization of appropriations There are authorized to be appropriated to the Secretary of Commerce such sums as are necessary to administer the Committee.