I 113th CONGRESS 2d Session H. R. 3959 IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES January 29, 2014 Ms. Bonamici (for herself and Mr. Kildee ) introduced the following bill; which was referred to the Committee on Education and the Workforce A BILL To establish a Pay It Forward model for funding postsecondary education.

1. Short title This Act may be cited as the Pay It Forward College Affordability Act of 2014 . 2. Findings; Purpose (a) Findings Congress finds the following: (1) Postsecondary education has expanded opportunities for people in the United States to qualify for high-quality jobs and entry into the middle class, providing clear benefits to the Nation’s economy. (2) Public investment by the States in higher education has decreased significantly, especially in the past 5 years before the date of enactment of this Act, as a result of the 2008 fiscal collapse. (3) With college costs rising beyond the reach of many people in the United States, financial aid programs are inadequate to reach all students with financial need. (4) The increasing unaffordability of a college education has forced students to borrow more money to pay for higher education, causing two-thirds of college seniors to graduate with an average student debt of $26,600. (5) High levels of student debt are damaging not only to the individual student’s ability to succeed financially but also will have grave consequences for the future economy of the United States. (6) Congress must halt the decrease in State support for education and, over time, must catalyze increases in State funding for higher education. (7) There is a need to encourage a new approach to financing the students’ share of the cost of higher education that will not result in graduates who are overburdened with student debt. (8) The Pay It Forward model presents a new opportunity for financing and expanding higher education, through the replacement of tuition and mandatory fees with a post-graduation contribution program that establishes the funding for access to higher education for the next generational cohort of students. (b) Purpose The purpose of this Act is to test and encourage the development of Pay It Forward model financing programs. 3. Definitions In this Act: (1) Annual Income The term annual income means an amount equal to the sum of— (A) annual adjusted gross income, as defined in section 62 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986; and (B) any amount described under section 103 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986. (2) Cost of attendance The term cost of attendance has the meaning given the term in section 472 of the Higher Education Act of 1965 ( 20 U.S.C. 1087ll ). (3) Institution of Higher Education (A) Institution of higher education The term institution of higher education has the meaning given the term in section 102 of the Higher Education Act of 1965 ( 20 U.S.C. 1002 ), except that for purposes of this Act, an institution of higher education does not include any program of postsecondary education or training, including a degree or certificate program, that is designed to prepare students for entry into a recognized occupation or profession that requires licensing or other established requirements as a pre-condition for entry into such occupation or profession, unless— (i) the successful completion of the program fully qualifies a student, in the State in which the institution offering the program is located (and in any State in which the institution indicates, through advertising or marketing activities or direct contact with potential students, that a student will be prepared to work in the occupation or profession after successfully completing the program), to— (I) take any examination required for entry into the recognized occupation or profession in the State, including satisfying all State or professionally mandated programmatic and specialized accreditation requirements, if any; and (II) be certified or licensed or meet any other academically related pre-conditions that are required for entry into the recognized occupation or profession in the State; (ii) the institution offering the program provides timely placement for all of the academically related pre-licensure requirements for entry into the recognized occupation or profession in the State, such as clinical placements, internships, or apprenticeships; (iii) in the case of State licensing or professionally mandated requirements for entry into the recognized occupation or profession in the State in which the institution offering the program is located (and in any State in which the institution indicates, through advertising or marketing activities or direct contact with potential students, that a student will be prepared to work in the occupation or profession after successfully completing the program) that require specialized accreditation— (I) the program meets that requirement for specialized accreditation through its accreditation or pre-accreditation by an accrediting agency or association recognized by the Secretary of Education as a reliable authority as to the quality or training offered by the institution in that program; and (II) if the program is in a pre-accredited, probation, or show cause status by an accrediting agency or association described in subclause (I), and the requirement for specialized accreditation is for full accreditation, the institution— (aa) establishes, to the satisfaction of the Secretary of Education, that each student who enrolls before the program is fully accredited attests of being advised that the program is in a pre-accredited, probation, or show cause status and of being informed of the effect on the student's eligibility for assistance under this Act and on the student's ability to satisfy State or professionally mandated requirements for entry into the recognized occupation or profession if full accreditation is delayed, denied, terminated, or withdrawn; and (bb) publicly and prominently discloses in any advertising, marketing, or recruitment materials and activities for the institution, the institution's pre-accredited, probation, or show cause status and the implications of such status for prospective students; and (iv) the institution— (I) discloses on the application to enroll in the institution that its program does not necessarily satisfy out-of-State requirements, if applicable; and (II) upon receipt of an application to enroll in the institution, notifies the student, prior to enrollment, if the program in which the student intends to enroll does not satisfy the requirements of the State in which the student is a resident, if applicable. (B) School, department, or program The term institution of higher education may include a particular school, department, or program within an institution of higher education described in subparagraph (A). (4) Pay It Forward model The term Pay It Forward model means a system in which— (A) the Secretary, a State, or an institution of higher education pays all or part of a participating student's cost of attendance, but not less than an amount equal to the cost of tuition and mandatory fees, for each such student during some or all of the time that the student is enrolled at an institution of higher education in order to replace the student's need to borrow under the Federal Direct Stafford Loan and Federal Direct Unsubsidized Stafford Loan Programs under part D of title IV of the Higher Education Act of 1965 ( 20 U.S.C. 1087a et seq. ); and (B) such student signs a contract agreeing to contribute to the Secretary, a State, or an institution of higher education, as the case may be, a certain percentage (not to exceed 5 percent) of the student’s annual income, for a specified number of years upon graduation or when the student ceases to be enrolled at such institution of higher education, except that the specified number of years for which the student agrees to contribute according to such contract shall not exceed 25 years, which shall be known as the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan . (5) Secretary The term Secretary means the Secretary of Education. (6) Tuition and mandatory fees The term tuition and mandatory fees means tuition and fees normally assessed a student carrying the same academic workload as determined by the institution of higher education. 4. Initial Studies (a) In General Not later than 180 days after the date of enactment of this Act, the Secretary, in consultation with the Secretary of the Treasury— (1) and the Director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, shall conduct a study on the feasibility of, and options for, implementing the Pay It Forward model, in a manner that is in the best interests of students; and (2) shall conduct a study— (A) on whether the student loan servicer payment program or the Internal Revenue Service income tax withholding mechanism (such as preauthorized automatic electronic funds transfers) of collection for the Pay It Forward model would work best; (B) on how best to establish a participant’s agreement described under section 5(g)(3), or a similar agreement made under another Pay It Forward model, including what percentage of a participant's income the participant should be required to contribute and what is an appropriate time period for contribution; (C) on how the rates of contribution under the Pay It Forward model may differ— (i) according to different income levels; and (ii) based on whether the student pursues a graduate or professional education program immediately after completing their undergraduate education or at a future time; (D) on how best to streamline the collection process and ensure compliance; and (E) on ways to prevent increases in tuition and other education costs. (b) Report Not later than 30 days after the completion of the studies described in subsection (a), the Secretary shall prepare and submit a report containing the results of the initial studies described in subsection (a), to the Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions of the Senate, the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs of the Senate, the Committee on Finance of the Senate, the Committee on Education and the Workforce of the House of Representatives, the Committee on Financial Services of the House of Representatives, and the Committee on Ways and Means of the House of Representatives. 5. Grants for State Pay It Forward Pilot Program (a) In General Unless the Secretary determines, as a result of the initial studies described in section 4, that the Pay It Forward model is not feasible or otherwise not in the public interest or in the best interest of students, the Secretary shall, not later than 1 year after the completion of such initial study, award grants, on a competitive basis, to not more than 3 States in the first 2 years and not more than 7 additional States in subsequent years (while limiting the number of students participating to 15,000 annually in the first 2 years and 50,000 annually in subsequent years in all States) to enable such States to establish and carry out a Pay It Forward model State pilot program as described in subsection (e). (b) Application; Duration (1) Application Each State that desires to receive a grant under this section shall submit an application to the Secretary at such time, in such manner, and containing such information as the Secretary may reasonably require. (2) Duration Grants awarded under this section shall be for a period of not less than 10 years and not more than 25 years and the Secretary shall make grant funds available to each State on an annual basis. (c) State contribution requirement A State receiving a grant under this section shall provide, either directly or through private contributions, non-Federal funds for each award year in an amount that is not less than the greater of— (1) the difference between— (A) the amount for an award year that the State has agreed to pay for all students participating in the State Pay It Forward Contribution Plan described in subsection (e); and (B) the amount of the Federal funds described in subsection (e)(2); or (2) the amount that is 10 percent of the amount of the Federal funds described in subsection (e)(2). (d) Maintenance of Effort Each State receiving a grant under this section for a fiscal year shall provide the Secretary with an assurance that the aggregate expenditures by the State, from funds derived from non-Federal sources, for the contribution to higher education costs, including student loans and grants for higher education for each fiscal year for which a grant is awarded under this section (excluding funds for a State Pay It Forward model) are not less than the aggregate expenditures by the State for the contribution to higher education costs, including student loans and grants for higher education, for the fiscal year preceding the first fiscal year for which a grant was awarded to the State under this section, as adjusted for inflation using the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers published by the Department of Labor (CPI–U). (e) State Pilot Program (1) State Activities In accordance with subsection (a), each State receiving a grant under this section shall establish and carry out a State Pay It Forward model pilot program, through which the State shall— (A) select eligible institutions, in accordance with subsection (f), for participation in the program; (B) in coordination with the Secretary, establish an application and enrollment process through which a student who is enrolled at a participating eligible institution who wishes to participate in the program, and fulfills the requirements of the enrollment process, as determined by the State, shall be enrolled in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan, subject to paragraph (3); (C) provide each student at each participating eligible institution with a written notice— (i) that such student has the option to participate, or to decline to participate, in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan on an annual renewable basis, subject to paragraph (3); (ii) of the application and enrollment process described in subparagraph (B); and (iii) of the terms and conditions of the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan, as described in subsection (g); (D) ensure that, subject to subsection (g)(5)(A) and in accordance with paragraphs (4) and (5) of subsection (g), an eligible student’s cost of attendance will be reduced by the amount of any assistance considered estimated financial assistance, as defined in section 428(a)(2)(C) of the Higher Education Act of 1965 ( 20 U.S.C. 1078(a)(2)(C) ) prior to the awarding of aid under the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan toward the student’s cost of attendance; (E) award funds, from amounts made available under subsection (c), any other State funds, and amounts made available under paragraph (2)(B) to pay— (i) each participating institution an amount equal to the tuition and mandatory fees for each student at that institution who is enrolled in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan, as described in subsection (g), except that such amount shall, for each student, not exceed the lesser of— (I) the amount of the tuition and mandatory fees for each such student at the most expensive public institution of higher education in the State for the type of institution the participating student attends (including a 4-year institution, 2-year institution, or 1-year institution) for that award year; or (II) the cost of attendance for each such student to attend the institution at which the student is enrolled; and (ii) each participating student any additional costs of attendance that have been agreed to in the student’s contract described in subsection (g), except that such additional costs shall be in an amount such that the sum of such additional costs and the amount of tuition and fees described in clause (i) shall, for each such student, not exceed the lesser of— (I) the amount of the tuition and mandatory fees for a student at the most expensive public institution of higher education in the State for the type of institution the participating student attends (including a 4-year institution, 2-year institution, or 1-year institution) for that award year; or (II) the cost of attendance for the student to attend the institution at which the student is enrolled. (2) Federal Funds The Secretary shall pay each State receiving a grant under this section, for each award year for the purpose of carrying out paragraph (1)(E), an amount equal to the product of— (A) the number of students in the State that are enrolled in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan for that award year; multiplied by (B) an amount equal to the sum of— (i) the maximum amount that a student is eligible to receive through a Federal Direct Stafford loan under part D of title IV of the Higher Education Act of 1965 ( 20 U.S.C. 1087a et seq. ) for that award year; plus (ii) the maximum amount that a student is eligible to receive through a Federal Direct Unsubsidized Stafford loan under part D of title IV of the Higher Education Act of 1965 ( 20 U.S.C. 1087a et seq. ) for that award year. (f) Eligible institutions (1) In general An eligible institution, for purposes of this section, means an institution of higher education, that— (A) submits an application to the State at such time, in such manner, and containing such information as the State may reasonably require; (B) agrees to participate in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan and commits to participation in research that may be related to the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan; and (C) agrees to maintain— (i) in the case of an institution of higher education in which the entire institution is participating, the level of institutional financial aid, including the level of institutional funding for student grants and loans, as adjusted for inflation by the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers published by the Department of Labor (CPI–U), that the institution provides at the time of the application to participate in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan throughout the duration of the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan; or (ii) in the case of a department, school, or program within an institution of higher education, maintain the level of aid described in clause (i) on a department, school, or program-wide basis. (2) Selection of participating institutions (A) In General If a sufficient number of eligible institutions in a State receiving a grant under this section wish to participate in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan, such State shall establish methods for selecting eligible institutions to participate, or otherwise set standards for participation, in such a way that meets the requirements of this paragraph and maximizes the utility of the research that results from the evaluation of the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan. (B) Criteria In selecting eligible institutions under subparagraph (A), the State shall consider the extent to which selected institutions will represent varied geographic locations and types of institutions (such as community colleges, institutions that offer 4-year programs, or other variations in the types of institutions that are selected). (C) Preference In selecting eligible institutions under subparagraph (A), the State shall give preference to eligible institutions that have a history of making an effort to reduce or hold constant tuition and mandatory fees and cost of attendance or have a plan to reduce or hold constant tuition and mandatory fees and cost of attendance, as determined by the State. (3) Announcement of participants Each State receiving a grant under this section shall announce each eligible institution that is selected for participation in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan at a time that provides students at participating eligible institutions with adequate notice in advance of the commencement of the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan at that institution. (4) State as grant recipient The Secretary may award grants to States that have developed, or are in the process of developing, pilot Pay It Forward grant programs at the State level to enable the State to carry out the activities described in this Act as if such State were an eligible institution selected for participation in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan. (g) Terms of the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan If a student who attends a participating eligible institution has applied for and enrolled in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan as described in subsection (e)(1)(B)— (1) the State shall pay— (A) to the participating institution that such student attends not less than an amount equal to the cost of tuition and mandatory fees during the time that the student is enrolled as an undergraduate at the participating eligible institution and is participating in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan, and for a period of not more than— (i) 4 years; or (ii) another period of time (such as a certain number of college credits or academic years completed) that the State, the institution, and the student shall determine and specify in the agreement described under paragraph (3); and (B) a student who attends a participating eligible institution and has applied for and enrolled in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan any additional costs of attendance that are agreed to by the State, the institution, and the student and are established in the contract described in paragraph (3), except that such additional costs shall be in an amount such that the sum of such additional costs and the amount of tuition and fees described in subparagraph (A) shall, for each such student and for each award year, not exceed the amount of the tuition and mandatory fees for a student at the most expensive public institution of higher education in the State for the type of institution the participating student attends (including a 4-year institution, 2-year institution, or 1-year institution) for that award year; (2) the State shall ensure that variations in the time that a student's tuition and mandatory fees is paid by the State shall be reflected in— (A) the length of the contribution period established in the student's Pay It Forward Contribution Plan agreement described under paragraph (3), except that the length of such contribution period shall not exceed 25 years; and (B) the percentage of annual income that such student shall contribute, as established in the student's Pay It Forward Contribution Plan agreement described under paragraph (3); (3) the student shall sign a contract agreement, which shall include— (A) the period of time (such as a certain number of college credits or academic years completed) during which the State will pay the institution that the student attends not less than an amount equal to the cost of tuition and mandatory fees that the student requests to have provided through the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan while the student is enrolled at such participating eligible institution; and (B) any additional costs of attendance that the State agrees to pay for such student through the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan while the student is enrolled at such participating eligible institution; and (C) a statement that the student will contribute to the State a certain percentage (not to exceed 5 percent) of the student’s annual income for a specified number of years upon graduation from such institution of higher education, successful completion of the student's course of study, or when such student ceases to be enrolled at such institution of higher education, as determined by the State, and the student shall be required to begin making such contributions on the date that is the later of— (i) 1 calendar year after graduation from such institution of higher education, successful completion of the student's course of study, or when such student ceases to be enrolled at such institution of higher education, as determined by the State; or (ii) 1 calendar year after the completion of a year that the student is enrolled in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan; (4) the student shall continue to be eligible to obtain any grants, scholarships, or funds that do not have to be repaid (including Federal Pell Grants or any other Federal, State, or institutional grant money) that the student would otherwise be eligible to receive if the student was not a participant in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan and that are applied toward the student's tuition and mandatory fees at the eligible institution, and the amount of such grants, scholarships, or funds shall be deducted from the amount that the State would otherwise pay toward the student's tuition and mandatory fees under the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan, thereby proportionately reducing the percentage of a participating student's annual income that the student will be required to contribute or the duration of the student's contribution period, as described under paragraph (3); (5) the student shall continue to be eligible to obtain any other student loans, including Federal student loans (except for Federal Direct Stafford Loans under part D of title IV of the Higher Education Act of 1965 ( 20 U.S.C. 1087a et seq. )), that the student would otherwise be eligible to receive if the student was not a participant in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan except that— (A) any funds received by a student under the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan shall be considered estimated financial assistance for purposes of calculations under section 428(a)(2)(C) of the Higher Education Act of 1965 ( 20 U.S.C. 1078(a)(2)(C) ); and (B) the amount of such loans shall be deducted from the amount that the State would otherwise pay toward the student’s tuition and mandatory fees under the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan, thereby proportionately reducing the percentage of a participating student's annual income that the student will be required to contribute or the duration of the student's contribution period, as described under paragraph (3); and (6) if the student obtains Federal student loans, such student shall remain eligible for applicable Federal loan repayment, forgiveness, or similar programs regarding such Federal student loans to the same extent that the student would be eligible for such repayment, forgiveness, or similar programs if the student were not also participating in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan. (h) Method of contribution collection The Secretary, in consultation with the Secretary of the Treasury or a designee of the Secretary of the Treasury, shall work with appropriate State agencies to develop an efficient mechanism for students who enroll in the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan, including using existing student loan repayment structures, wage withholding (such as preauthorized automatic electronic funds transfers), or other suitable methods as the respective State agencies may determine and as approved by the Secretary. (i) State Report Each State receiving a grant under this section shall annually prepare and submit a report to the Secretary containing such information about the grant program as the Secretary may require. 6. Advisory Council (a) In General The Secretary shall establish, and appoint members to, a technical advisory council to make recommendations to the Secretary about— (1) how to design an evaluation of the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan described under section 5; (2) how to maximize the utility of the research results that may be used to evaluate such program; and (3) implementation issues and solutions for State-based Pay It Forward model pilot programs, which may include applying a State-based Pay It Forward model pilot program for nontraditional students, including students who are older, already working, or attending school at night, and in cases in which graduates voluntarily leave the workforce. (b) Members of the Council The technical advisory council established under this section shall include not more than 11 members, of whom— (1) not less than 3 members shall be academic researchers with expertise in higher education; (2) not less than 2 members shall have expertise in quantitative program evaluation; (3) not less than 2 members shall be student advocates; and (4) not less than 2 members shall be experts in budgetary and financial matters. (c) Report The technical advisory council established under this section shall prepare and submit a report to the Secretary containing the recommendations described in subsection (a). 7. Implementation study (a) Initial Evaluation Not later than 5 years after the establishment of the State Pay It Forward models under section 5, the Secretary shall, after consideration of the advisory council recommendations regarding how to evaluate the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan described under section 6(a), conduct an initial evaluation of the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan, which may include an evaluation of— (1) how the rates of contribution under the Pay It Forward model may differ according to different income levels; (2) the rates of students who fail to contribute funds as agreed to under the Pay It Forward model; (3) how best to establish a student's agreement described under section 5(g)(3), or a similar agreement made under another Pay It Forward model, including what percentage of a student's income the student should be required to contribute and what is an appropriate time period for contribution; (4) ways to prevent increases in tuition and other education costs; and (5) ways to integrate existing Federal student loan repayment and forgiveness programs into the Pay It Forward model. (b) Evaluation Not later than 10 years after the establishment of the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan described under section 5, the Secretary shall, after consideration of the advisory council recommendations regarding how to evaluate the Pay It Forward Contribution Plan— (1) evaluate whether existing student loan debt could be converted into a Pay It Forward model; (2) evaluate the impact of the Pay It Forward model on a student's career choices and employment, including how such model may impact a student's employment in public service jobs and level of employment (such as whether a student participating in the Pay It Forward model will go on to part time or full time employment); (3) evaluate mechanisms through which employers could provide funds toward the contributions that an employee is required to make under a Pay It Forward model contribution agreement; (4) examine the long-term solvency and feasibility of an expanded Pay It Forward program; and (5) examine the distributional implications of allowing students to opt out of participation in a Pay It Forward model program as compared to requiring all students who are enrolled at a participating institution to participate in a Pay It Forward model program. (c) Report Upon completion of the evaluation described under subsection (a), the Secretary shall prepare and submit a report containing the results of such evaluation to the Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions of the Senate, the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs of the Senate, the Committee on Finance of the Senate, the Committee on Education and the Workforce of the House of Representatives, the Committee on Financial Services of the House of Representatives, and the Committee on Ways and Means of the House of Representatives. 8. Expanded Implementation The Secretary may expand the Pay It Forward model, including by developing Pay It Forward model pilot programs for students pursuing post-baccalaureate degrees that relate to the medical profession in order to meet the need for more primary medical care providers, increasing the number or duration of grants to States for carrying out a Pay It Forward State pilot program, or establishing a Federal program based on the Pay It Forward model, if the Secretary determines that doing so— (1) will not increase the cost to the Federal Government for carrying out Federal loan programs under title IV of the Higher Education Act of 1965 ( 20 U.S.C. 1070 et seq. ); (2) may be carried out using amounts available for the programs under title IV of the Higher Education Act of 1965 ( 20 U.S.C. 1070 et seq. ); and (3) is in the best interests of students and the Nation in advancing national priorities for education, health, and economic development. 9. Waiver (a) State application for waiver A State awarded a grant under this Act may apply to the Secretary to waive a requirement of the grant. (b) Secretary authority The Secretary may waive any provision in this Act if the Secretary determines that doing so would be in the best interest of students and achieve the goals of the Pay It Forward model. 10. Pay It Forward Fund (a) Establishment of a fund There is established in the Treasury a fund, to be known as the Pay It Forward Fund (referred to in this section as the Fund ), to be administered by the Secretary of Education, in which all funds received in Pay It Forward contributions under this Act shall be deposited. (b) Use The amounts in the Fund shall be made available to the Secretary of Education in order to carry out this Act. 11. Amounts available for Pay It Forward from Stafford Loan Program Amounts made available under any Act to carry out the Federal Direct Stafford Loan Program under part D of title IV of the Higher Education Act of 1965 ( 20 U.S.C. 1087a et seq. ) shall be available to the Secretary of Education to carry out the Pay It Forward program under this Act.