College Road, Hong Kong : Rationale is a very simple case of failing WP:INHERITED .  The specific application of this policy is also noted at WP:NROAD BrigadierG ( talk ) 21:14, 5 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] Note:  This discussion has been included in the deletion sorting lists for the following topics: Geography , Transportation ,  and Hong Kong .  Skynxnex ( talk ) 21:25, 5 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] Delete , short road failing WP:MILL .  Geschichte ( talk ) 08:31, 6 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] Delete A road that does not satisfy any notability.  ✠ SunDawn ✠ (contact) 05:19, 10 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] Keep per the significant coverage in multiple independent reliable sources .  The subject passes Wikipedia:Notability (geographic features)#Roadways , which says: Road networks: International road networks (such as the International E-road network ), Interstate , national, state and provincial highways are typically notable.  Topic notability for county roads, regional roads (such as Ireland's regional roads ), local roads, streets and motorway service areas may vary, and are presumed to be notable if they have been the subject of multiple published secondary sources which contain significant coverage and are reliable and independent of the subject.  Sources Selection of two sources: "書院道精英地段" [Elite area of College Road].  The Sun (in Chinese).  2012-05-19.  Archived from the original on 2024-05-12 .  Retrieved 2024-05-12 .  The article notes: "九龍塘區的豪宅內街以寧靜見稱，書院道同樣具備此項特色，其中坐落街道頭段的勝豐園，乃沿街老牌豪宅屋苑之一，樓齡約三十八年，兩座物業合共提供約48個單位，" From Google Translate: "The inner streets of luxury houses in Kowloon Tong District are famous for their tranquility. College Road also has this feature. Situated at the beginning of the street, Sheng Feng Yuan is one of the old luxury housing estates along the street. It is about 38 years old and has two properties. A total of about 48 units are provided," The article notes: "其中步行已可達多家名校的書院道（College Road），盡佔名校網優勢，而書院道豪宅的入場費則由千萬餘以至逾半億元俱備。書院道鄰近喇沙利道，兩條豪宅街道的命名均源自區內名校之一的喇沙書院。" From Google Translate: "Among them, College Road is within walking distance of many famous schools, taking advantage of the network of famous schools. The admission fee for luxury houses on College Road ranges from more than 10 million to more than 500 million yuan. College Road is adjacent to La Salle Road. The two luxury streets are named after La Salle College, one of the famous schools in the area."  The article notes: "書院道除了四周環境清幽恬靜外，最吸引買家之處，是優質學府選擇眾多，對於有意讓子女入讀名校的家長，吸引力自然特別高。至於在該街道一帶的名校除喇沙書院外，尚有瑪利諾修院學校、拔萃小學及黃笏南中學等。" From Google Translate: "In addition to the quiet and peaceful surroundings, College Road is most attractive to buyers because of its wide selection of high-quality schools. It is particularly attractive to parents who intend to enroll their children in prestigious schools. As for the famous schools in this street area, in addition to La Salle College, there are also Maryknoll Convent School, Diocesan Primary School and Wong Wat South Secondary School." "書院道匯聚黃金屋" [Collection of Golden Houses on College Road].  Oriental Daily (in Chinese).  2012-09-30.  Archived from the original on 2024-05-03 .  Retrieved 2024-05-03 .  The article notes: "九龍塘不但具備傳統豪宅區的魅力，更吸引之處是坐擁九龍名校網，其中步行已可達多家名校的書院道（College Road），尤其凸顯名校網優勢，老牌豪宅及豪宅新貴散落於寧靜的街道上，為講求實用的用家與愛好新廈的豪客提供不同選擇。" From Google Translate: " Kowloon Tong not only has the charm of a traditional luxury area, but what is even more attractive is that it is located in the prestigious Kowloon School Network. College Road (College Road), which is within walking distance of many famous schools, particularly highlights the advantages of the prestigious school network. Old luxury homes and upstart luxury homes are scattered here. The quiet street provides different options for practical users and high-end buyers who like new buildings."  The article notes: "其中坐落街道頭段的勝豐園，乃沿街老牌豪宅屋苑之一，樓齡約三十八年，..."  From Google Translate: "Among them, Sheng Feng Yuan, located at the end of the street, is one of the old luxury housing estates along the street. It is about 38 years old. ..."  The article notes: "書院道另一個老牌屋苑為博文閣，坐落街道的中段，由於位於內街之中，加上面向喇沙書院的大球場，環境清幽，視野亦較開揚。" From Google Translate: "Another well-established housing estate on College Road is Bowen Court, located in the middle of the street. Because it is located in an inner street and faces the stadium of La Salle College, it has a quiet environment and a relatively open view."  The article notes: "除了老牌豪宅外，書院道近年有一個矚目的新一代豪宅落成，乃由興勝創建發展的EI8HT COLLEGE。" From Google Translate: "In addition to the old luxury houses, a new generation of luxury houses has been completed on College Road in recent years, which is EI8HT COLLEGE founded and developed by Xingsheng."  Additional sources: "九龍塘樂苑 雅緻裝潢闊露台" [Kowloon Tong Lok Garden Elegantly decorated wide terrace].  Hong Kong Economic Times (in Chinese).  2013-08-30.  p.  D5.  The article notes: "位於九龍塘的書院道，屬於內街，靜處一隅，由於街道比較短，因此供應的豪宅僅約10個左右。中原豪宅Stately Home九龍豪宅副區域聯席董事何維進稱，書院道的豪宅樓齡十分參差，其中最新的書院道8號於2011年入夥，而最舊的一批，樓齡逾50年。" From Google Translate: "Located on College Road in Kowloon Tong, it is an inner street and is located in a quiet corner. Since the street is relatively short, there are only about 10 luxury homes available. Ho Wei-jin, deputy regional co-director of Stately Home Kowloon luxury homes, said that the age of the luxury homes on College Road is very different. The newest one, No. 8 College Road, was occupied in 2011, while the oldest ones are more than 50 years old."  The article notes: "由於鄰近九龍城，位處名校網，故書院道除家長客、低調廠家外，均屬用家，放盤有限交投不多。 最新一宗成交於4月份錄得，為書院道8號中層，實用面積1,758平方呎，建築面積2,446平方呎，為屋苑最後一間餘貨，以5,190萬元成交。" From Google Translate: "As it is close to Kowloon City and is located in a prestigious school network, College Road is owned by users except for parents and low-key manufacturers. The listings are limited and there is not much transaction. The latest transaction was recorded in April. It is a middle-floor building at No. 8 College Road, with a salable area of ​​1,758 square feet and a built-up area of ​​2,446 square feet. It is the last remaining unit in the housing estate and was sold for HK$51.9 million." "香港8號" [Hong Kong No. 8].  Sing Pao Daily News (in Chinese).  2011-11-14.  p.  B3.  The article notes: "書院道因鄰近的喇沙書院而得名，現時書院道8號為新盤Eight College，由興勝創建（896）發展，屬於香港六大建築集團之一，估計發展商命名時取8號的 諧音「發」，著重其「意頭」。 該樓盤毗鄰九龍塘火車站，交通便捷，並鄰近校網，包括香港城巿大學、香港浸會大學、喇沙書院、拔萃小學，以及耀中國際小學∕幼兒園。" From Google Translate: "College Road is named after the nearby La Salle College. Currently, No. 8 College Road is the new Eight College, developed by Xingsheng Construction (896), which is one of the six major construction groups in Hong Kong. It is estimated that the developer took No. 8 when naming it. It is homophonic to "fa", emphasizing its "meaning". The property is adjacent to the Kowloon Tong Railway Station, with convenient transportation, and is close to school networks, including City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong Baptist University, La Salle College, Diocesan Primary School, and Yew Chung International Primary School/Kindergarten." "九龍塘明麗園中層 環境清幽" [Ming Lai Garden, Kowloon Tong, middle floor, quiet environment].  Hong Kong Economic Times (in Chinese).  2019-11-01.  p.  D19.  The article notes: "九龍塘書院道，是傳統豪宅物業集中地，該地段以路闊車流量少，環境清幽見稱，放盤向來罕有 ，其中明麗園中層單位，連車位叫價2,500萬元。" From Google Translate: "College Road, Kowloon Tong, is where traditional luxury properties are concentrated. The area is famous for its wide road, low traffic volume, and quiet environment. It has always been rare to find a listing. Among them, the mid-rise unit in Ming Lai Garden, including a parking space, is priced at NT$25 million."  Ng, Chi-fai 伍志輝 (2015-06-20).  "靚盤巡禮：九龍塘明麗園　 裝修新淨　環境清幽" [Tour of beautiful properties: Kowloon Tong Ming Lai Garden, newly renovated and clean, with a quiet environment].  Apple Daily (in Chinese).  p.  B4.  The article notes: "九龍塘書院道附近名校多，行車路面寬闊，車流量不高，環境清幽，同時享有鄰近九龍城的方便購物地利，沿路新舊物業都有一定捧場客。 明麗園座落書院道近衙前圍道方向，屬區內老牌大宅之一，盤源向來不多，" From Google Translate: "There are many famous schools near College Road in Kowloon Tong. The road surface is wide, the traffic volume is not high, and the environment is quiet. It also enjoys the convenient shopping location near Kowloon City. New and old properties along the road have a certain number of fans. Ming Lai Garden is located on College Road near Nga Tsing Wai Road. It is one of the old-style mansions in the area. There are not many houses in the area." "書院道8號連平台 裝潢雅緻" [No. 8, College Road, with terrace, elegant decoration].  Hong Kong Economic Times (in Chinese).  2015-04-17.  p.  D5.  The article notes: "九龍塘書院道街道比較短，故此提供的豪宅物業不多，樓齡一般由37至54年不等。 ... 而書院道8號，屬目前該處樓齡最新的物業，僅4年樓" From Google Translate: "The street of College Road in Kowloon Tong is relatively short, so there are not many luxury properties available. The age of the buildings generally ranges from 37 to 54 years. ... No. 8 College Road is currently the newest property there, being only 4 years old." "書院道樂苑低層 特高樓底" [Low floor, extra high floor, Dao Lok Court, College].  Hong Kong Economic Times (in Chinese).  2013-12-20.  p.  D7.  The article notes: "九龍塘書院道可供二手轉售的屋苑，除勝豐園外，大部分均在10層以下；至於樓齡方面，除書院道8號於11年入夥外，餘下多已超過40年。" From Google Translate: "Most of the housing estates available for second-hand resale in College Road, Kowloon Tong, with the exception of Sing Fung Garden, are below 10 storeys. As for the age of the buildings, except for No. 8 College Road, which was occupied in 11 years, most of the remaining housing estates are over 40 years old."  There is sufficient coverage in reliable sources to allow College Road, Hong Kong ( traditional Chinese : 書院道 ; simplified Chinese : 书院道 ) to pass Wikipedia:Notability#General notability guideline , which requires "significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject".  Cunard ( talk ) 08:10, 12 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] Relisted to generate a more thorough discussion and clearer consensus.  Relisting comment: Can we get an assessment of newly found sources?  Please add new comments below this notice.  Thanks, L iz Read!  Talk!  21:53, 12 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] Comment .  I don't see what's significant in the sources provided.  It's a road with buildings in it.  Geschichte ( talk ) 14:56, 13 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] The sources allow College Road, Hong Kong, to meet Wikipedia:Notability (geographic features)#Roadways , which says roads "are presumed to be notable if they have been the subject of multiple published secondary sources which contain significant coverage and are reliable and independent of the subject".  The sources discuss the road's namesake, the luxury housing estates on the road, how the prestigious schools in the area affect the prices of houses on the road, how parents and manufacturers are the primary owners of the road's units or property, and the road's attributes (wide, short, quiet, and low traffic volume).  A non-notable road would not receive this depth of discussion in reliable sources.  Cunard ( talk ) 06:19, 14 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] Delete My problem with the sources presented is that they're all articles on property, not articles on the road itself, which is a short residential street.  A proper article on a road - looking at London as an example - will have details on history, naming, events which occurred there, which the sources don't specifically cover.  I don't think any of the additional sources count, and I'd like to see an additional source specifically written on the road before I think this would meet WP:GNG .  SportingFlyer T · C 04:15, 15 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] The Sun article is titled "Elite area of College Road" and extensively discusses the road's background and attributes.  It is not an article focused on the properties on the road.  The Oriental Daily article is titled "Collection of Golden Houses on College Road".  The article's thesis is that "the road has old luxury homes and upstart luxury homes scattered throughout", and the article backs up this statement by describing the various properties that dot the road.  Significant coverage of what is on the road is significant coverage of the road.  The article provides further context by noting that the road is close to prestigious schools and that it is a quiet, inner street.  The sources do discuss why College Road is named College Road (its name was inspired by the nearby La Salle College ).  There is no requirement in Wikipedia:Notability (geographic features)#Roadways for the sources to discuss "events that occurred there".  College Road's notability is not derived from events that occurred there.  College Road's notability is derived from being dotted with luxury properties from its proximity to prestigious schools.  Cunard ( talk ) 06:08, 15 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] Comment: College Road has received significant coverage in reliable sources so meets Wikipedia:Notability (geographic features)#Roadways .  If the consensus is that the road is not notable, the article still should not be deleted.  Per Wikipedia:Deletion policy#Alternatives to deletion , the article should be merged to Kowloon Tsai , the area the road is in.  A redirect with the history preserved under the redirect will allow editors to selectively merge any content that can be reliably sourced to the target article.  A redirect with the history preserved under the redirect will allow the redirect to be undone if significant coverage in reliable sources is found in the future.  Cunard ( talk ) 06:08, 15 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] Merge with Kowloon Tsai : where this content would be relevant and verifiable, while not requiring independent notability.  Owen× ☎ 15:33, 20 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] I'm fine with a merge.  SportingFlyer T · C 20:01, 22 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] Merge as suggested by OwenX .  While I'm a fan of WP:50k , I also understand that not everyone ascribes .  A merge is a more reasonable outcome and compromise than outright deletion.  Bearian ( talk ) 23:31, 20 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] Relisted to generate a more thorough discussion and clearer consensus.  Relisting comment: There's a rough consensus against keep, but not yet a consensus between merging and deletion.  Further arguments in favor of keep that may shift this emerging consensus are of course also still welcome.  Please add new comments below this notice.  Thanks, signed, Rosguill talk 18:17, 21 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] Oppose , per Cunard.  203.145.95.251 ( talk ) 12:47, 22 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] Merge to Kowloon Tsai .  I appreciate the sources located by @ Cunard and the text is much better than it was.   However the road itself isn't claimed to be that notable or of historical import, just a desirable place to live near a famous school.  As an example Sassoon Road doesn't get its own page but rather sits within Victor Sassoon .  Nor does Mount Davis Road, whereas Rednaxela Terrace does because there's something interesting about its naming.  Oblivy ( talk ) 05:22, 23 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] Regarding Sassoon Road , I supported a redirect at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sassoon Road because I could not find significant coverage in reliable sources about it.  Neither Wikipedia:Notability (geographic features)#Roadways nor Wikipedia:Notability#General notability guideline require a road to "claimed to be that notable or of historical import".  The guidelines only require the subject to have received significant coverage in reliable sources, which this road has.  Cunard ( talk ) 08:57, 24 May 2024 (UTC) [ reply ] The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate.  Please do not modify it.  Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's talk page or in a deletion review ).  No further edits should be made to this page.

Discussion outcome: merge