The problem is this closure now applied to only one category fails NPOV  since according to our current state of consensus we can now tag antisemites in the US but we cant tag them in France or Spain That is exactly why the unified approach was proposed and accepted That a small group of editors attempted to override that in one category is improper because it leads to inconsistency and violation of neutral treatment of subjects Thus I think those who want to change the longstanding consensus should start and frame the RFC and I ask you again to reconsider your close which also fwiw does not deal with biographies of dead people It also doesnt give any hints besides BURDEN on who should be added to the category  how antisemitic must a person be to merit inclusion