Hi Awadewit As a new Wikipedian it is reassuring for me to see a more veteran member of Wikipedia echo a few of the thoughts that I have been having regarding a how undefinitive of a bibliography I posted and b how to go from there to actually do the work towards getting an actual definitive account of Tolkien scholarship and improving the Wikipedia articles I think your approach sounds great Based on what youve said though would it be correct for me to extrapolate that it sounds like you wont be actually joining us in the collaboration given your time being occupied with other projects We would greatly appreciate your help if you have the time andor any Tolkien resources handy So please feel free to pitch in if that is the case However I completely understand if youre busy with other things and am already very grateful with the help that you have already provided Many thanks