That Grburster case again   Hi Tim Do you remember this checkuser case Ive just been looking over it again while discussing it with someone else and I noticed that you said in that thread at   October  that you called for a check partly because an account that was a selfadmitted alternate account was showing a strong antipathy to ScienceApologist and the first edits this account made were to TalkNonstandard cosmology This raised the immediate suspicion in my mind that this was a sock which I noted in my checkuser request and Iantresman was the user that I suspected most strongly of being the sockmaster The thing that puzzles me here is that you said none of this at the actual request for checkuser See WikipediaRequests for checkuserCaseGrburster You mentioned that Grburster was an alternate account but you didnt mention at the checkuser your concerns about the antipathy to ScienceApologist or the edits to TalkNonstandard cosmology or your suspicion that it might have been a sock of Iantresman You just said these may both be sockpuppets of another account Was there a reason for not stating your suspicions in full The only reason I can think of is that you werent quite sure With hindsight I think detailing your suspicions in full would have been helpful Certainly if you had said at the checkuser what you later said at ANI I wouldnt have objected to the checkuser