I came up with the scrollbar idea attack this   guy due to concerns which I will link to below You can see my initial vision for the TOC at  and Monotonehells comments to  and mine  It was deemed to be the best solution to the problem namely the ridiculously varying length of the Main Page TOC I used CSSs overflow feature and the extra scrollbar is far from the rule its the sad exception which Ive tried and failed to get rid of Ill see if I can make a CSS hack though unpretty as they may be