sighs Forget to log in again Miskatonic Tell you what you explain to me what the difference is between describing someones proposed beliefs as part of a recounting of thought on an issue and asserting that those ideas are the truth and explain to me which you think the article is doing and why  that way Ill know you finally grasp the concept because at the moment it seems to totally escape you  If you cant address this basic cognitive difference Im going to moreorless abandon the debate since you seem incapableunwilling to addresses it rationally  BTW  I fail to see how a film maker and artist according to your profile can style themselves as being a scientific expert or even a philosophical one Not saying you cannot have such interests or inclinations but it fails to make you a professional in either field and you have advanced yourself as an authority as you have been around science Ive been around science too  I work in a technical field professionally but Im not about to run off and proclaim I know the objective truth of the universe and attempt to cram it down other peoples throats Why are you