Essentially this list makes no sense Instead of scouring the net for that one silly article that will drop the emo buzzword in reference to a band that has nothing to do with it thats what is going on in some cases shouldnt this be relying on more of a consensus for whether or not a band is emo You may find one article to call AFI emo but for every one of those you can find hundreds that wouldnt dare throw them into that That doesnt mean the consensus is right  of the time but theres something wrong with the idea of trying to find one person dumb enough to call a band emo so they can be included on some list