Hi David may I ask did you post this at Jossis request  Are you someone whos ever edited the Rawat articles  I think I recall a David at some point  Was that you In any event while I agree with the general point that editors shouldnt be hunted down etc is that really a fair way to characterize my asking an editor if hes ever been a paid publicist for the articles subject  Do you think thats an irrelevant question especially in light of Jimbo Wales saying just the other day that ideally articles shouldnt be edited by interested parties but that it was hard to know who was who given the ease with which people can be anonymous  Besides Jossis not anonymous is he   Sorry but I find this confusing Wales says Wikipedias a free speech forum Jossi says it isnt  Its all too subtle for me Im afraid