We seem to have a dispute about what should be included in the article on Carbondale IL  Reverting to previous text is not the solution and is counter to Wiki policy  Before submitting a Request for Comment RfC to the Wiki page on Requests for commentHistory and geography I would like to see if we can come to agreement on the nature of our disagreement  Wiki policy says Do not post an RfC before working towards a resolution with other article contributors first   Here is a draft of a description of the disagreement  Is it accurate   In an article about a city Carbondale Illinois we have a disagreement about how much detail on negative historical events is consistent with the Neutral Point of View policy