I just signed up for Wikipedia and I can already see why  chose to go As Ive mentioned before ten votes for keep and eight votes for merge is a consensus Why Thats because more people chose to vote keep You mentioning that today it would mean no consensus makes no sense whatsoever because today and yesterday or May in this case are not far apart at all Having cover versions merged with original versions is unintelligent while there is also an ongoing debate about charts where if you ask me is one of the most illogical arguments thats ever been displayed Charts dont add anything to Wikipedia except a POVstyle