Quite enough said on this issue here already I would strike the insulting comment if I were you but you of course are free to do as you wish As for your initial larger scholarly point I am sure it will be duly refuted and clarified by sheer scholarship in due course as I suggested to Nina above Just that certainty I hope would be good enough for her to bypass your personal insults above and let the issue rest for now In the future I also hope you will refrain from coming and confronting and insulting her in her own talk page I would hope you never come to mine either Sincerely