Well maybe well judge when weve read all the reviews and see what they say about her scholarship It will also be interesting to see whether they change over time ie whether her latest books have been received differently from her earlier ones I certainly didnt mean to present an incomplete selection of reviews these are all those turned up by a systematic search of the journals under the keywords Bat Yeor and dhimmi in one of the main scholarly databases Please add any more you can find Of course there are also the literary magazines and others that are not listed as scholarly journals but are good sources As for a judgement from on high Im musing really but it would be good to have a ruling following thorough discussion by people not directly involved in this particular case Without the possibility of getting further opinions in these arguments drag on so long I always tend to the view that WP disputes are best resolved by looking to the sources is it reliable is it quoted fairly is there no undue weight Problem should be solved  would it were so simple in reality though