I say we go ahead and file one Unfortunately an RFC is necessary Whatever the merits of one side or another may be there are disputes that havent been resolved by discussion Here are some of the points of disagreement as I understand them  How relevant are issues such as  hate crimes and air pollution in an encyclopedic article about the university How much space should they be given if any Should the article include the StudentsReviewcom abomination quote or any other mention of StudentsReview Is a selfselected review site a reliable source Im sure theres more As Amerique said the RFC doesnt have to be approved or agreed to by all users Lets make suggestions for wording what the RFC should or shouldnt include etc    e