To be honost Im really not in the mood to argue with anyone over the ethnic population of Herat or any other city of Afghanistan If you guys want to add that the entire Afghanistans population is Tajiksyou may go ahead and write this everywhere You may also state that Kandahar is  Tajiks like if this gonna change anything I know the fact that UserTajik is Qizibash or whatever you spell itand this group of people are the least in Afghanistan I dont even think they make  of Afghanistans population It is not my duty to come up with the exact number of ethnic people living in each city As an Afghan and a proud PashtunI explain to westerners that since majority of the people  speaking Dari Farsi Herati Persian or whatever you call that languagethis does not mean all of those are ethnic Tajiks The best example is USA againmajority of people in USA speak Enlgish but that does not mean they are ethnic English people You have people from every ethnic of the world living in USA and all speaking English This is the case in Afghanistan   Finally when Emperor Babur stated in his  AD memoires about calling Tajiks SartsPerhaps he meant to call them Rats  November