Mr Anonymous  First of allthe three we are discussing are at least  years oldwould you like to tell them to their face  Secondyou are wrongthe Treaty of Versailles was not signed until   There was instability and the war continued in Russia and Germanys government was in turmoil  US soldiers were needed to keep the peace  I suppose the US war in Iraq ended May   with Mission Accomplished  NOT  You simply dont understand that a war EFFORT is exactly that  Many of the socalled veterans were working typewriters driving delivery trucks etc  These three could have seen more action than thatsuch as Julio Ereneta picking up mines  Since the peace treaty wasnt signed until  it is arguable that the war ended in   At the very least these men were recruited to replace those sent to warif there had been no WWI they would likely have never joined  Moreoever we see veterans like Moses Hardy recruited in  returned to the US in  In fact most WWI veterans did NOT return in  they returned in   Finally this list is intended to include possible WWI veterans did we really verify the Polish claims  We can throw out a case like Merlyn Kreuger because one he is  not  and two he never served at Fort Dix as he claimed  These three however DID serve and were called on to serve by the US govt due to WWI  Thus at least SOME people would include them as WWI veterans  Its not for you alone to decide  I think a disclaimer is already balancing it out