Thank you for this very interesting analysis Heres  negative review of Chodakwiecz book by Michlic  confirming that their fight continues Perhaps the correct neutral way of writing about this situation is to note that Polonsky belongs to one of the two groups of scholars on PolishJewish history each highly critical of another and list the names and publications PS Its sad to see people get at each others throat back in  Polonsky had no problem thanking Chodakiewicz in a note