Its hard to say that moving it to the WP space would find a concensus  There are certain topics where its obvious a notability criterion is needed essentially to keep out spamvanity  But even those have some flexible points to allow for the argument Im trying to make  That Science is a rediculously vague topic and because the number of Geneticists is much larger than the number of Cosmologists the number of citations for a Cosmology paper to be as notable whatever the fuck that means as a Genetics paper is lower than the number of citations the Genetics paper has  While the textbook criterion tries to replace that it does so in a way that hacks at one of Wikipedias greatest strengths Being current