This is a kind offer indeed and I would urge other editors to take it up if they feel they can do so However Im not sure I want to come back in and try to work the article into something reasonable making sense of the storys historical place in the burgeoning alAqsa intifada of late  while avoiding going overboard on context The latter has only been abused in Paras  and  of the lead and everywhere else throughout the article at the moment  and it would be tricky to do a proper narrative under almost any circumstances  First of all I would have to strip out nearly everything about the quite trivial controversy especially because of the BLP issues along with many of the terrible sources being used Only then might the remainder be useful as the basis of an article that would do justice to the project The article has got to have the firm application of policy first with Haaretz and JPost and the Daily Mirror in Commentary Magazine and OBL out  I suppose we have to have Karsenty and the hoax theory mentioned somewhere  lets confine it to proper encyclopaedic use of the actual French RS translation here Remember hes been convicted of defamation so this is his second bite of the cherry and he gets lucky In French the nearest Karsenty gets to any support is lexamen des rushes ne permet plus dcarter les avis des professionnels entendus au cours de la procdure  that his views cannot be set aside on the basis of the film That is ludicrously different from support for the hoax theory Which in any case is very much a sideshow to this story Have a look  the French report of the court case mentions two points raised by Karsenty right at the end and very nearly brushes them off as quibbles Id be fairly sure that everything from Shahaf can come out he doesnt need mentioning If we have to have anything from him atall I provisionally propose the early theory that was on German television that a Palestinian standing next to the cameraman shot alDurrah dead from the other side of the street I dont know why Shahaf abandoned a semicredible theory for the contradictory he wasnt shot and isnt dead hoax theory which is what he has desperately been trying to persuade us of ever since