Another attempt to reframe what I said and set up a straw man a favourite Hogbin tactic  As I have repeatedly made clear I am not a nationalist and am very happy having been an active campaign worker for Better Together with the outcome of the referendum  However the point is that the Edinburgh Agreement makes it very clear that Scotland could have become independent and that is totally at variance with your untruthful claim that Texas at least has a legal case for secession sic Scotland has none  I cite it because it is very important to underline the fact that you continue to show dishonesty and a disregard for the sources which do not suit you in the claims that you are making  If you do not respect the truth then I suggest you should not be contributing here