The section at GothsEtymology would only be appropriate for the very first part of this article and is naturally dealt with in more detail there so there would probably be no additions Since a disambiguation page is meant to be a list of links that would mean that that part of the article would also cease to exist If the contention is that it is better for a reader wanting to understand the term Gothic to go to Goth disambiguation Gothic disambiguation and  Gothic also a disambiguation page and then find the relevant articles find the information about them visit the various articles and find the relevant sections and work out how they relate to each other then I suppose that is a point a view However I would contend that it would be easier for them to go to this page and then if they are interested in a particular use of the term to go on to that page through the main article links In short this page in its current form has a useful function within an encyclopedia If it is actually believed that it does not do this then it should be taken to AfD and fully debated    Synthesis The synthesis tag that has been placed on this article is relatively easy to deal with Scholars often point to the evolution of this term from Germanic tribes to other uses See for example David Punter and  Glennis Byrons Gothic Blackwell  pp  at  There is no new synbthesis being advancing here and the tag should be removed if it cannot be justified