Regarding criticism of his Astrology research   Hello all  For your information the German language WP article offers a rather nuanced view of the academic discussion about the methodological issues of his work on Astrology It does not just mention one publication critical of his book as does your article at present but two critical ones and several in his defence apparently all by experts    I am far from making any claims myself as I do not know much of mathematics just I point out that matters seem to be not as simple as your piece suggests to readers  Regards