Its now clear from the evidence presented by ALoan that this page was legitimately moved to River Plate in Nov  after it was nominated on Requested Moves and that the move of this page to Ro de la Plata contravened the normal procedures reversing the previous legitimate move Therefore we should not be accepting the controversial move to Ro de la Plata as a fait accompli and should really be discussing a move from what was the status quo  ie River Plate to Ro de la Plata As a consequence the  majority normally required for a move to River Plate should be ignored and only  of the vote should be required to restore this page to what was the status quo I cannot believe anyone with any sense of fair play could legitimately defend the position of making a controversial move and then having a vote on whether to keep the new name where the balance lies in its favour it is just not the Wiki way