The edits by  are all copyedits and deletions  words excised there is no addition whatever to the substantial content of the page in question he monitors this discussion and made no claim to having contributed to the substantial content  His objection was that the article must have been mistakenly created by UserProf for the G to apply  I have certified that it was  The only other nonProf edits are by  and  which are all wikifications  There are no other edits in existence by other hands  The recommendations you mention belong to the AfD process not to the CSD G rule which must be decided on its own terms  No one here for all the talk above disagreed with those terms so far   Prof