This edit on TalkRD   I dont want to extend this on TalkRD and I fear that I am misinterpreting your response so I thought Id ask here  When you used the term Bullshit were you referring to my reply  If so I think its unfair and uncivil  The explanation to which you refer is disingenuous its not possible to reply on the IP users talk page because they shift around from IP to IP  Thus their complaint that other users have not taken this to User Talk is misdirected  they dont have a user talk page  Furthermore my reply was not continued carping rather it was a constructive suggestion for that user meant to help them deliver and more convincing apology  Their failure to sign will remain disruptive even if all of the current complainants go away