I note that the user who raised this no longer has an active account  However I have removed the citation request as it was placed in an inappropriate place in the article  That wax type cylinders were shaved so that they could accept new recordings is not in doubt  Practically all phonographs sold prior to  were equipped with such a shaving device As whether worn out cylinders were accepted back for shaving and rerecording it is probably unlikely that a firm citation will come to light which is often the case with such historical articles  It is something that I had heard of from elswhere but consider the following  A cylinder would cost around  cents at the turn of the th century  To provide context in real terms  cents would have bought you two dinners at reasonable diner  The early cylinders had a very short life of between a dozen to two dozen playings  For all his faults Edison was a very astute businessman   If Edison figured out that he could sell more cylinders by taking back the worn out ones and making an allowance toward the purchase of a new one there can be little doubt that that is exactly what he would have done