First it disturbs me that I cant answer the good issues youre raising about number of copies sold etc without the sources at hand I think that info might be in the Reynolds compilation of essays that Id have to order again via interlibrary loan and that takes weeks Beyond that to your questions Ill retire or take a long break or do whatever one does when fed up with this place No I wouldnt renominate  Id let it go I wrote it for WP to run in  as an example of WWI literature WP doesnt want it Its been quite a lot of work and doing a good review is a lot of work and my feeling is its not worth it if I cant speak to the issues adequately without the sources The list of stories in this section but I prosified it