Point of view terms used in the Scott article   In the modern reaction it is said   Scotts reputation survived the period after World War II beyond the th anniversary of his death  This is rather obvious Pointofviewterminology Saying something has survived only until a certain point in time basically means its dead Captain Scotts reputation is far from dead so this is not a true representation of reality  A correct encyclopedic term would be  Scotts high reputation remained uncontested until the period after World War II beyond the th anniversary of his death   Another problem is that it is spoken of a timeframe beyond World War II but the first book that is mentioned offering criticism in the next sentence is from  Here we have a difference of more than  years that are claimed to belong to the time that Scotts high reputation had been contested while in reality they belong to the uncontested period Consequently this is another passage that needs further rectifying clarfification