A propos out of subject what do you think this EE guy or EE anonymous is talking about with YBM and Catherine The contain of his Biographie who is on another wiki site and has nothing to do wiht this one So what do you do with that one He suddendly came up with the contain of it big edit several times and each time somebody added or supress something they had to come with the whole text again and again I believe this biographie has now been edited  to  times on the same site So maybe you should have look after that instead he interven first in a discussion about the scientific meaning of part of the Bogdanovs A le big Bang between the Bogdanovs and YBM and like insisted about a point Was answered and since have perverted the debate of this web site into his own website concerning the biographie of the Bogdanov who in fact is somewhere else so you know itBogdanov Affair and talk Bogdanov affair are  distinct thing and the one is not about discussing the other as you might have understood it Maybe we have here the root of the problem a misunderstandig of proportions  sophieXAL