More on that date and speculation   Over at TalkThe End of the World you referred to the disagreement over your date format note as what I call statements of the truth and what you call liesspeculation  I dont recall anyone ever saying that your Cup theory was a lie just that it was speculative and unencyclopedic  It could be true but we dont really have any evidence to support it and there are other likely explanations  Plus the speculation isnt noteworthy  Season B is an example of noteworthy speculation as it was originated by prominent fans including Paul Cornell published in licensed guide books used in spinoff novels and now appears on the BBCs own Doctor Who website  If the AppleCup theory gets a pedigree like that I wouldnt have any problem including it heck even if there were a mention of it in DWM or another prominent Doctor Who publication  But as far as I know its just a theory discussed on a forum somewhere and one that isnt strongly supported by the evidence at hand  Does that make sense to you