There was an editor who went round posting CATs of ethnicity on numerous pages related to people of Jewish descent whether those people recognized themselves as Jews or not I think he was banned As Oncenawhile says what determines these things is not a priori abstract inferences but RS Begins quip doesnt override the fact that he was not born there and dismissed famously Palestinians as the Arabs of Eretz Israel denying them a right to be called Palestinians and defining the land as Eretz Israel In this his position was identical to Golda Meir who lived in Mandatory Palestinian with that citizenship but asserted that it was not as if there was a Palestinian people in Palestinevar After all there are no Palestinian people We invented them but they dont existNur Masalha Imperial Israel and the Palestinians The Politics of Expansion Pluto Press   pThese quotes from selfdefined Israelis explain most of the driveby votes here and the logic of wishing to deny the preMandate list which follows and no one is willing to face the evidence absolutely normative for wiki peoples articles