I understand these views but I think that you are mixnmatching logical categories here WPNCs preference for consistency is in reference to the base name of the article  Eg Dont use Elizabeth I of England for one article but Queen Elizabeth II or Elizabeth Mountbatten for another  It has nothing to do with disambiguation  WPDAB covers that for the most part with things like WPNCP covering special cases  DAB makes it clear that disambiguators are only used when required on an articlebyarticle basis and that keeping article names short and predictable is an important goal  Anyway as long as readers can input Chili Township and find what theyre looking for I dont have a big bone to pick