gzone0111/musique_hotpotqa_graph_retriever huggingface dataset:
Question: Do non-Christians agree that the cause of death of the person who said man cannot live by bread alone happened?
Context: Document 1: Jesus: Christian doctrines include the beliefs that Jesus was conceived by the Holy Spirit, was born of a virgin named Mary, performed miracles, founded the Christian Church, died by crucifixion as a sacrifice to achieve atonement for sin, rose from the dead, and ascended into Heaven, from where he will return. Most Christians believe Jesus enables people to be reconciled to God. The Nicene Creed asserts that Jesus will judge the living and the dead either before or after their bodily resurrection, an event tied to the Second Coming of Jesus in Christian eschatology. The great majority of Christians worship Jesus as the incarnation of God the Son, the second of three persons of the Trinity. A minority of Christian denominations reject Trinitarianism, wholly or partly, as non-scriptural. The birth of Jesus is celebrated annually on December 25 (or various dates in January by some eastern churches) as Christmas. His crucifixion is honored on Good Friday and his resurrection on Easter. The widely used calendar era "AD", from the Latin "anno Domini" ("in the year of the Lord"), and the equivalent alternative "CE", are based on the approximate birthdate of Jesus.
Document 2: Crucifixion of Jesus: The baptism of Jesus and his crucifixion are considered to be two historically certain facts about Jesus. James Dunn states that these "two facts in the life of Jesus command almost universal assent" and "rank so high on the 'almost impossible to doubt or deny' scale of historical facts" that they are often the starting points for the study of the historical Jesus. Bart Ehrman states that the crucifixion of Jesus on the orders of Pontius Pilate is the most certain element about him. John Dominic Crossan states that the crucifixion of Jesus is as certain as any historical fact can be. Eddy and Boyd state that it is now "firmly established" that there is non-Christian confirmation of the crucifixion of Jesus. Craig Blomberg states that most scholars in the third quest for the historical Jesus consider the crucifixion indisputable. Christopher M. Tuckett states that, although the exact reasons for the death of Jesus are hard to determine, one of the indisputable facts about him is that he was crucified.
Document 3: Matthew 4:4: Matthew 4: 4 is the fourth verse of the fourth chapter of the Gospel of Matthew in the New Testament. Jesus, who has been fasting in the desert, has just been encouraged by Satan to make bread from stones to relieve his hunger, in this verse he rejects this idea.
Answer: the crucifixion of Jesus is as certain as any historical fact can be
Reasoning steps: who said man cannot live by bread alone Answer: Jesus
What is the cause of death of Jesus ? Answer: crucifixion
Do non-Christians agree that the crucifixion happened? Answer: the crucifixion of Jesus is as certain as any historical fact can be
Question: What county shares a border with another county, where the birthplace of Cyrus David Foss is found?
Context: Document 1: Kingston (town), New York: Kingston is a town in Ulster County, New York, United States. The Town of Kingston is in the northeast part of Ulster County, north of the City of Kingston. Kingston is inside the Catskill Park. The population was 889 at the 2010 census.
Document 2: Chichester, New York: The hamlet of Chichester, New York, formerly referred to as Chichesterville, is one of the northernmost communities in the town of Shandaken, New York, being right next to the borderline between Ulster County and Greene County.
Document 3: Cyrus David Foss: Foss was born in Kingston, New York on January 17, 1834. He attended Wesleyan University, graduating in 1854. He began his career teaching, and then entered the ministry. Foss was "pastor of the most prominent Methodist churches in this city [New York] and Brooklyn."
Answer: Greene County
Reasoning steps: Cyrus David Foss >> place of birth Answer: Kingston
Kingston >> located in the administrative territorial entity Answer: Ulster County
Ulster County >> shares border with Answer: Greene County
Question: In the administrative territorial entity where the place of birth of Elisha R. Potter is located, what county is a border shared with?
Context: Document 1: Elisha R. Potter: Elisha Reynolds Potter (June 20, 1811 – April 10, 1882) was a politician and jurist from Kingston, Rhode Island. He was a justice of the Rhode Island Supreme Court, and served one term in the United States House of Representatives.
Document 2: Kingston (town), New York: Kingston is a town in Ulster County, New York, United States. The Town of Kingston is in the northeast part of Ulster County, north of the City of Kingston. Kingston is inside the Catskill Park. The population was 889 at the 2010 census.
Document 3: Chichester, New York: The hamlet of Chichester, New York, formerly referred to as Chichesterville, is one of the northernmost communities in the town of Shandaken, New York, being right next to the borderline between Ulster County and Greene County.
Answer: Greene County
Reasoning steps: Elisha R. Potter >> place of birth Answer: Kingston
Kingston >> located in the administrative territorial entity Answer: Ulster County
Ulster County >> shares border with Answer: Greene County
Question: Which county shares a border with the county Elisha Reynolds Potter was born in?
Context: Document 1: Chichester, New York: The hamlet of Chichester, New York, formerly referred to as Chichesterville, is one of the northernmost communities in the town of Shandaken, New York, being right next to the borderline between Ulster County and Greene County.
Document 2: Kingston (town), New York: Kingston is a town in Ulster County, New York, United States. The Town of Kingston is in the northeast part of Ulster County, north of the City of Kingston. Kingston is inside the Catskill Park. The population was 889 at the 2010 census.
Document 3: Elisha R. Potter: Elisha Reynolds Potter (June 20, 1811 – April 10, 1882) was a politician and jurist from Kingston, Rhode Island. He was a justice of the Rhode Island Supreme Court, and served one term in the United States House of Representatives.
Answer: Greene County
Reasoning steps: Elisha Reynolds Potter >> place of birth Answer: Kingston
Kingston >> located in the administrative territorial entity Answer: Ulster County
Ulster County >> shares border with Answer: Greene County
Question: Which county is the birth place of A Walk in the Woods's author located?
Context: Document 1: Michael Bryson: Michael G. Bryson (August 22, 1942 – May 22, 2012) was a news and sports reporter and editor from Des Moines, Iowa and the elder brother of travel writer Bill Bryson. He co-authored a book "The Babe Didn't Point: And Other Stories About Iowans and Sports" with his son Michael G. Bryson Jr in 1989. He also wrote a book called "The Twenty-Four-Inch Home Run" in 1990. Bryson was an editor and associate publisher of the Sun Press Newspapers in Hawaii from 1979 to 1986. He covered the New York Mets in 1969 while a sports reporter for the Associated Press. He was a news reporter for the "Des Moines Register and Tribune" from 1970 to 1979. He attended Drake University.
Document 2: A Walk in the Woods (book): A Walk in the Woods Front cover of the American paperback edition. Author Bill Bryson Illustrator David Cook Country United States Language English Subject Appalachian Trail Publisher Broadway Books Publication date 4 May 1998 Media type Hardcover Pages 274 pp (first edition) ISBN 0 - 7679 - 0251 - 3 OCLC 37903447 Dewey Decimal 917.404 / 43 21 LC Class F106. B92 1998
Document 3: Indianola, Iowa: Indianola is a city in Warren County, Iowa, United States, 18 miles south of Des Moines, Iowa. The population was 14,782 at the 2010 census. It is the county seat of Warren County.
Answer: Warren County
Reasoning steps: who wrote the book a walk in the woods Answer: Bill Bryson
Bill Bryson >> place of birth Answer: Des Moines
Des Moines >> located in the administrative territorial entity Answer: Warren County
Question: In which county is the city where the author of Shakespeare: The World as Stage was born?
Context: Document 1: Shakespeare: The World as Stage: Shakespeare: The World as Stage is a biography of William Shakespeare by author Bill Bryson. The 199-page book is part of Harper Collins' series of biographies, "Eminent Lives". The focus of the book is to state what little is known conclusively about Shakespeare, and how this information is known, with some discussion of disproved theories, myths, and that which is believed by the public but not provable. It also explores the political, social, cultural and economic background to Shakespeare's work.
Document 2: Michael Bryson: Michael G. Bryson (August 22, 1942 – May 22, 2012) was a news and sports reporter and editor from Des Moines, Iowa and the elder brother of travel writer Bill Bryson. He co-authored a book "The Babe Didn't Point: And Other Stories About Iowans and Sports" with his son Michael G. Bryson Jr in 1989. He also wrote a book called "The Twenty-Four-Inch Home Run" in 1990. Bryson was an editor and associate publisher of the Sun Press Newspapers in Hawaii from 1979 to 1986. He covered the New York Mets in 1969 while a sports reporter for the Associated Press. He was a news reporter for the "Des Moines Register and Tribune" from 1970 to 1979. He attended Drake University.
Document 3: Indianola, Iowa: Indianola is a city in Warren County, Iowa, United States, 18 miles south of Des Moines, Iowa. The population was 14,782 at the 2010 census. It is the county seat of Warren County.
Answer: Warren County
Reasoning steps: Shakespeare: The World as Stage >> author Answer: Bill Bryson
Bill Bryson >> place of birth Answer: Des Moines
Des Moines >> located in the administrative territorial entity Answer: Warren County
Question: In which county is the birthplace of the author of A Short History of Nearly Everything?
Context: Document 1: Michael Bryson: Michael G. Bryson (August 22, 1942 – May 22, 2012) was a news and sports reporter and editor from Des Moines, Iowa and the elder brother of travel writer Bill Bryson. He co-authored a book "The Babe Didn't Point: And Other Stories About Iowans and Sports" with his son Michael G. Bryson Jr in 1989. He also wrote a book called "The Twenty-Four-Inch Home Run" in 1990. Bryson was an editor and associate publisher of the Sun Press Newspapers in Hawaii from 1979 to 1986. He covered the New York Mets in 1969 while a sports reporter for the Associated Press. He was a news reporter for the "Des Moines Register and Tribune" from 1970 to 1979. He attended Drake University.
Document 2: A Short History of Nearly Everything: A Short History of Nearly Everything by American-British author Bill Bryson is a popular science book that explains some areas of science, using easily accessible language that appeals more so to the general public than many other books dedicated to the subject. It was one of the bestselling popular science books of 2005 in the United Kingdom, selling over 300,000 copies.
Document 3: Indianola, Iowa: Indianola is a city in Warren County, Iowa, United States, 18 miles south of Des Moines, Iowa. The population was 14,782 at the 2010 census. It is the county seat of Warren County.
Answer: Warren County
Reasoning steps: A Short History of Nearly Everything >> author Answer: Bill Bryson
Bill Bryson >> place of birth Answer: Des Moines
Des Moines >> located in the administrative territorial entity Answer: Warren County
Question: What is the country for the birthplace of the author of At Home: A Short History of Private Life?
Context: Document 1: Indianola, Iowa: Indianola is a city in Warren County, Iowa, United States, 18 miles south of Des Moines, Iowa. The population was 14,782 at the 2010 census. It is the county seat of Warren County.
Document 2: At Home: A Short History of Private Life: At Home: A Short History of Private Life is a history of domestic life written by Bill Bryson. It was published in May 2010. The book covers topics of the commerce, architecture, technology and geography that have shaped homes into what they are today, told through a series of "tours" through Bryson's Norfolk rectory that quickly digress into the history of each particular room.
Document 3: Michael Bryson: Michael G. Bryson (August 22, 1942 – May 22, 2012) was a news and sports reporter and editor from Des Moines, Iowa and the elder brother of travel writer Bill Bryson. He co-authored a book "The Babe Didn't Point: And Other Stories About Iowans and Sports" with his son Michael G. Bryson Jr in 1989. He also wrote a book called "The Twenty-Four-Inch Home Run" in 1990. Bryson was an editor and associate publisher of the Sun Press Newspapers in Hawaii from 1979 to 1986. He covered the New York Mets in 1969 while a sports reporter for the Associated Press. He was a news reporter for the "Des Moines Register and Tribune" from 1970 to 1979. He attended Drake University.
Answer: Warren County
Reasoning steps: At Home: A Short History of Private Life >> author Answer: Bill Bryson
Bill Bryson >> place of birth Answer: Des Moines
Des Moines >> located in the administrative territorial entity Answer: Warren County
Question: What kind of university did the author of Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day attend?
Context: Document 1: New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station: The New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station (or NJAES) is an entity currently operated by Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey in conjunction with the State of New Jersey in the university's role as the state's sole land-grant university. Today, it conducts research in agriculture, horticulture and turf grass science, and through the Rutgers Cooperative Extension aids New Jersey farmers, landscapers, and residents in each of the state's twenty-one counties.
Document 2: Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day: Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day, published in 1972, is an ALA Notable Children's Book written by Judith Viorst and illustrated by Ray Cruz. It has also won a George G. Stone Center Recognition of Merit, a Georgia Children's Book Award, and is a Reading Rainbow book. Viorst followed this book up with three sequels, "Alexander, Who Used to be Rich Last Sunday" , "Alexander, Who's Not (Do You Hear Me? I Mean It!) Going to Move" , and "Alexander Who's Trying His Best to Be the Best Boy Ever" .
Document 3: Judith Viorst: Viorst is a 1952 graduate of the Newark College of Arts and Sciences at Rutgers University in Newark, New Jersey. In 1968, Viorst signed the "Writers and Editors War Tax Protest" pledge, vowing to refuse tax payments in protest against the Vietnam War. In the latter part of the 1970s, after two decades of writing for children and adults, she turned to the study of Freudian psychology. In 1981, she became a research graduate at Washington Psychoanalytic Institute after six years of study.
Answer: land-grant university
Reasoning steps: Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day >> author Answer: Judith Viorst
Judith Viorst >> educated at Answer: Rutgers University
Rutgers University >> instance of Answer: land-grant university
Question: What historic figure inspired the name of the county that shares a border with another county, where the village of Bethel is located?
Context: Document 1: Clermont County Public Library: The Clermont County Public Library is a public library in Clermont County, Ohio, located east of Hamilton County and within the greater Cincinnati area. There are ten library branches in the system: Amelia, Batavia, Bethel, Felicity, Goshen, Milford, New Richmond, Owensville, Union Township, and Williamsburg.
Document 2: Bethel, Ohio: Bethel is a village in Clermont County, Ohio, United States. The population was 2,711 at the 2010 census. Bethel was founded in 1798 by Obed Denham as Denham Town, in what was then the Northwest Territory. Bethel is the home of the first movie theater in Ohio which was founded in 1908 by Aaron Little. It is home to the Starlite Drive-In, one of the few remaining drive-in theaters in the United States.
Document 3: Hamilton County: Hamilton County is the name of ten counties in the United States of America, eight of them named for Alexander Hamilton, first United States Secretary of the Treasury:
Answer: Alexander Hamilton
Reasoning steps: Bethel >> located in the administrative territorial entity Answer: Clermont County
Clermont County >> shares border with Answer: Hamilton County
Hamilton County >> named after Answer: Alexander Hamilton
Question: After whom is the county sharing a border with the county in which Jackson Township can be found named?
Context: Document 1: Jackson Township, Clermont County, Ohio: Jackson Township is one of the fourteen townships of Clermont County, Ohio, United States. As of the 2010 census the population was 2,980.
Document 2: Clermont County Public Library: The Clermont County Public Library is a public library in Clermont County, Ohio, located east of Hamilton County and within the greater Cincinnati area. There are ten library branches in the system: Amelia, Batavia, Bethel, Felicity, Goshen, Milford, New Richmond, Owensville, Union Township, and Williamsburg.
Document 3: Hamilton County: Hamilton County is the name of ten counties in the United States of America, eight of them named for Alexander Hamilton, first United States Secretary of the Treasury:
Answer: Alexander Hamilton
Reasoning steps: Jackson Township >> located in the administrative territorial entity Answer: Clermont County
Clermont County >> shares border with Answer: Hamilton County
Hamilton County >> named after Answer: Alexander Hamilton
Question: Who was the county sharing a border with Franklin Township's county named after?
Context: Document 1: Hamilton County: Hamilton County is the name of ten counties in the United States of America, eight of them named for Alexander Hamilton, first United States Secretary of the Treasury:
Document 2: Clermont County Public Library: The Clermont County Public Library is a public library in Clermont County, Ohio, located east of Hamilton County and within the greater Cincinnati area. There are ten library branches in the system: Amelia, Batavia, Bethel, Felicity, Goshen, Milford, New Richmond, Owensville, Union Township, and Williamsburg.
Document 3: Franklin Township, Clermont County, Ohio: Franklin Township is one of the fourteen townships of Clermont County, Ohio, United States. The 2010 census reported 4,188 people living in the township, 3,307 of whom lived in the unincorporated portions of the township.
Answer: Alexander Hamilton
Reasoning steps: Franklin Township >> located in the administrative territorial entity Answer: Clermont County
Clermont County >> shares border with Answer: Hamilton County
Hamilton County >> named after Answer: Alexander Hamilton
Question: Who was the county that shares a border with Ohio Township's county named after?
Context: Document 1: Hamilton County: Hamilton County is the name of ten counties in the United States of America, eight of them named for Alexander Hamilton, first United States Secretary of the Treasury:
Document 2: Ohio Township, Clermont County, Ohio: Ohio Township is one of the fourteen townships of Clermont County, Ohio, United States. The 2010 census reported 5,192 people living in the township, 2,610 of whom were in the unincorporated portions of the township.
Document 3: Clermont County Public Library: The Clermont County Public Library is a public library in Clermont County, Ohio, located east of Hamilton County and within the greater Cincinnati area. There are ten library branches in the system: Amelia, Batavia, Bethel, Felicity, Goshen, Milford, New Richmond, Owensville, Union Township, and Williamsburg.
Answer: Alexander Hamilton
Reasoning steps: Ohio Township >> located in the administrative territorial entity Answer: Clermont County
Clermont County >> shares border with Answer: Hamilton County
Hamilton County >> named after Answer: Alexander Hamilton
Question: Who was the country that neighbors Goshen Township's county named after?
Context: Document 1: Goshen Township, Clermont County, Ohio: Goshen Township is one of the fourteen townships of Clermont County, Ohio, United States. As of the 2010 census the population was 15,505.
Document 2: Clermont County Public Library: The Clermont County Public Library is a public library in Clermont County, Ohio, located east of Hamilton County and within the greater Cincinnati area. There are ten library branches in the system: Amelia, Batavia, Bethel, Felicity, Goshen, Milford, New Richmond, Owensville, Union Township, and Williamsburg.
Document 3: Hamilton County: Hamilton County is the name of ten counties in the United States of America, eight of them named for Alexander Hamilton, first United States Secretary of the Treasury:
Answer: Alexander Hamilton
Reasoning steps: Goshen Township >> located in the administrative territorial entity Answer: Clermont County
Clermont County >> shares border with Answer: Hamilton County
Hamilton County >> named after Answer: Alexander Hamilton
Question: Who is the county that shares a border with the county Miami Township is located in named after?
Context: Document 1: Clermont County Public Library: The Clermont County Public Library is a public library in Clermont County, Ohio, located east of Hamilton County and within the greater Cincinnati area. There are ten library branches in the system: Amelia, Batavia, Bethel, Felicity, Goshen, Milford, New Richmond, Owensville, Union Township, and Williamsburg.
Document 2: Miami Township, Clermont County, Ohio: Miami Township is one of the fourteen townships of Clermont County, Ohio, United States. The population at the 2010 census was 40,848, up from 36,632 in 2000. The township's students are served mostly by Milford Exempted Village Schools.
Document 3: Hamilton County: Hamilton County is the name of ten counties in the United States of America, eight of them named for Alexander Hamilton, first United States Secretary of the Treasury:
Answer: Alexander Hamilton
Reasoning steps: Miami Township >> located in the administrative territorial entity Answer: Clermont County
Clermont County >> shares border with Answer: Hamilton County
Hamilton County >> named after Answer: Alexander Hamilton
Question: Who is the county that shares a border with the county Wayne Township is located named after?
Context: Document 1: Hamilton County: Hamilton County is the name of ten counties in the United States of America, eight of them named for Alexander Hamilton, first United States Secretary of the Treasury:
Document 2: Clermont County Public Library: The Clermont County Public Library is a public library in Clermont County, Ohio, located east of Hamilton County and within the greater Cincinnati area. There are ten library branches in the system: Amelia, Batavia, Bethel, Felicity, Goshen, Milford, New Richmond, Owensville, Union Township, and Williamsburg.
Document 3: Wayne Township, Clermont County, Ohio: Wayne Township is one of the fourteen townships of Clermont County, Ohio, United States. The 2010 census reported 4,885 people living in the township, 4,493 of whom were in the unincorporated portions of the township.
Answer: Alexander Hamilton
Reasoning steps: Wayne Township >> located in the administrative territorial entity Answer: Clermont County
Clermont County >> shares border with Answer: Hamilton County
Hamilton County >> named after Answer: Alexander Hamilton